Philosophy
The Journal of the
Royal Institute of Philosophy
edited by
RENFORD BAMBROUGH
Volume 55
1980
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
CAMBRIDGEPublished by the Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge
The Pitt Building, Trumpington Street, Cambridge CB2 IRP
32 East 57th Street, New York, NY 10022, USA
© The Royal Institute of Philosophy 1980
\\\
CONTENTS
ARTICLES
A L D R I C H , V I R G I L c. Mirrors, Pictures, Words, Perceptions page 39 C A N D L I S H , STEWART T h e Real Private Language Argument 85 CARRIER, L. s. Perception and Animal Belief 193
D E V I N E , P H I L I P E. Homicide Revisited 329
DUFF, A N T O N Y Desire, Duty and Moral Absolutes 223 G O L D S T E I N , I R W I N Why People Prefer Pleasure to Pain 349
H E L M , P A U L God and Spacelessness 211
HORNSBY, J E N N I F E R Arm Raising and Arm Rising 73
HUNTER, j . F. M. Wittgenstein on Language Games 293 JACKSON, FRANK Ontological Commitment and Paraphrase 303 KELLENBERGER, j . Religious Faith and Prometheus 497 K O L N A I , AUREL T h e Ghost of the Naturalistic Fallacy 5 LYON, A R D O N On Remaining the Same Person 167 MCCLOSKEY, H. j . Privacy and the Right to Privacy 17 MONRO, D. H. T h e Sonneteer's History of Philosophy 363 MORRIS, w. E. Actuality and Possibility 57 MOUNCE, H. o. Art and Real Life 183 SHARPE, R. A. Freud and the Freedom of the Sane 485 S K I L L E N , A N T H O N Y How to Say Things with Walls 509 STROUD, BARRY Berkeley v. Locke on Primary Qualities 149 VALBERG, EUGENE A Theory of Secondary Qualities 437
W E L B O U R N E , M I C H A E L Knowing and Believing 317
W I L K E S , K A T H L E E N v. More Brain Lesions 455
W R I G L E Y , M I C H A E L Wittgenstein on Inconsistency 471
DISCUSSION
B A N N O N , M I C H A E L j . Neural Adaptation to Unnecessary Pain 408
BELSEY, A N D R E W and C A T H E R I N E Sex, Equality and M r Lucas 386
B O R O W S K I , E. j . Moral Autonomy Fights Back 95 BROWN, K E I T H Thomas Hobbes and the Title Page of Leviathan 410 C O T T I N G H A M , JOHN Race and Individual Merit 525
DAVIES, B R I A N Wittgenstein on God 105
G O L D S T E I N , L A U R E N C E T h e Reasons of a Materialist 249
H O L L I S , M A R T I N Meaning and Method: Some Recent Work in the Philosophy of the Social Sciences 239 HURKA, T H O M A S Geach on Deriving Categorical 'Oughts' 101
J O H N S T O N , P A T R I C I A and T. M. REED Children's Liberation 263
LESSER, HARRY Suicide and Self-Murder 255 L E W I S , HARRY Quine on Wiggins 125
LOWE, E. j . Active and Passive Euthanasia: An Objection 550 M O N T A G U E , P H I L L I P Re-examining Huck Finn's Conscience 542
MORA, FREYA Metaphysical Purdah 377
O'NEIL, R I C H A R D A. Abrams on Active and Passive Euthanasia 547 ORR, ROBERT Kant and Gallie on Politics 113 P U C C E T T I , R O L A N D On Saving our Concept of a Person 403 PYBUS, E L I Z A B E T H M. Utilitarianism: A Basic Flaw? 554
ROWAN, MICHAEL
and
ALAN SMITHSONStove on Popper's Scientific
Statements 358
ROWE, DOROTHY
Philosophy and Psychiatry 109
SCARRE,
GEOFFREYChildren and Paternalism 117
SMITH,
MICHAELDid Socrates Kill Himself Intentionally? 353
SMITHSON, ALAN
and
MICHEAL ROWANStove on Popper's Scientific
Statements 358
THALBERG, IRVING Avoiding the Emotion-Thought Conundrum 396
YUDKIN, MARCIA
Difference be Damned 392
REVIEWS
ATTFIELD, ROBIN
God and the Secular (M. A. Stewart) 267
BELL, DAVID Frege's Theory of Judgement (Leslie Stevenson) 277
BRANDT, RICHARD B.
A Theory of the Good and the Right (Dorothy Emmet) 412
CARGILE, JAMES
Paradoxes: A Study in Form and Predication (I. G.
McFetridge) 421
CHURCHLAND,
PAUL
M.Scientific Realism and the Plasticity of Mind
(R. G. Swinburne) 273
COHEN, G. A. Karl Marx's Theory of History: A Defence (R. F. Atkinson) 416
CURTIS, BERNARD
and
WOLFE MAYS(Eds). Phenomenology and Education:
Self-consciousness and its Development (Martin Warner) 132
EBERSOLE, FRANK B.
Meaning and Saying (Norman Malcolm) 555
EBERSOLE, FRANK B. Language and Perception (Norman Malcolm) 555
FOGELIN,
R. j . Understanding Arguments: An Introduction to Informal Logic
(Vera Peetz) 126
GASKIN, j . c. A. Hume's Philosophy of Religion (M. A. Stewart) 267
GOLDMAN, ALVIN
and
JAEGWON KIM(Eds). Values and Morals: Essays in
Honor of William Frankena, Charles Stevenson and Richard Brandt (J. J. C.
Smart) 557
HARRISON, ANDREW
Making and Thinking: A Study of Intelligent Activities
(Bernard Mayo) 128
HARRISON, BERNARD
An Introduction to the Philosophy of Language (Jane
Heal) 561
HARRISON, ROSS
(Ed.) Rational Action: Studies in Philosophy and Social
Science (Roger Trigg) 559
HODGES, WILFRID
Logic (Vera Peetz) 126
KENNY, ANTHONY
The God of the Philosophers (Paul Helm) 418
KIM JAEGWON
and
ALVIN1.
GOLDMAN(Eds). Values and Morals: Essays in
Honor of William Frankena, Charles Stevenson and Richard Brandt (J. J. C.
Smart) 557
KIRWAN, CHRISTOPHER
Logic and Argument (Vera Peetz) 126
LESLIE, JOHNValue and Existence (Colin Lyas) 275
LEVIN, MICHAEL
j . Metaphysics and the Mind-Body Problem (Kathleen V.
Wilkes) 565
MAYS, WOLFE
and
BERNARD CURTIS(Eds). Phenomenology and Education:
Self-consciousness and its Development (Martin Warner) 132
MIDGLEY, MARY
Beast and Man: The Roots of Human Nature (Christine
Battersby) 270
MORAWETZ, THOMAS
Wittgenstein and Knowledge: The Importance of On
Certainty (R. W. Beardsmore) 130
OKIN, SUSAN MOLLER
Women in Western Political Thought (Julia Annas) 564
PRATT, VERNONThe Philosophy of the Social Sciences (D. A. Lloyd Thomas) 135
SCRUTON, ROGER The Aesthetics of Architecture (R. A. Sharpe) 567 STERN, j . p. A Study of Nietzsche (H. P. Rickman) 423 S W I N B U R N E , RICHARD The Existence of God (Paul Helm) 562 T E I C H M A N , j . The Meaning of Illegitimacy (H. J. McCloskey) 278 W E I L , SiMONE Lectures on Philosophy (Benjamin Gibbs) 133 WILSON, EDGAR The Mental as Physical (J. M. Hinton) 414