Limitations of Co Training for Natural Language Learning from Large Datasets

(1)

"!# $% &' $ ()(* %

% % (,+)

%(-.0/2143658793;:<>=2:?/@-58AB6/%36<C:DA/%<>5-36:

EFG%HJILKNMOFPNKRQJS*TUQJMOG%VWKNFXIZY%[X\]FP%[XF

TUQJIP%F^_^4`P%\bacFXId\eKgf

hiKj%HJ[HOklnmpoJqWrJs

t

G%\]FXI[Fuv[HWIw%\_FNxzy9[d{_[QJIP%F^_^]{]FXw%V

|'}*~ <>/%=

>>c2#C)g2%CCgc2

cC289c¡ L¢g2gCX2c2c £9¤W¢g2Cg2

2¢g¥ 2¢g2gCO¦W'¢gX>c2¢§? ¡gX¨2g

22©c¢g% ¤ª¢2«X>¬2¢>#c

c¦c¦WC¢gg¢g2c2®¤bg¯«9C¡°¢±¤Z¡

¦CCR¢>c2²2¢X¬%³9±³g>Ug¢¤2c¡¦CC

2¢Ccg¢cX´%>R2¢2µCc29¦cJ

>U¤¶ £C·¢g>c2>0c¢g2X>4¡2>c>2g% £g

20¢XgJ¢c¢¢£Jc¡ >³0gC¸cg?¡g>µWc¦

¤*¢g>c22g¢c £µ¢g¹C LcC2¦c¤eCg

9c £º>CX8»°20¦cg2>2®22g¦2> 6W

¢2ºµ' 9g¢gcXC¼9¨2c«¢c¢µ £>·¢>c2

gCXc £U¦J?½>¾>¿À¢g2µ2Ác £OggC ¦¢§

£>·¢gX>2CÂ ¡g¨2gµcÂ¤bc¡'g2%C© ¡g

¨2Ã¢gC2C±>¹O³¦CC>gC«¤¶C¡Äz>¡

¦c¥2¢> Å*X>X¼XC>2¢>?O¢2µ¸c>¡¢§

¤Ä¢g29¦WC¢gg¢g2CÂ2¢gµ¥0>¦2¢>

¢g¤e2¢g2?¡¬2g>CUW¢)Æ>2Xgg¢c¼ª

2g>>g¥¬%XX¢gCµg2%CRz¡W¢ ¤4 £>

¢gCc2ÇÃ c³ L²¶Jc9µ £CggC £¢g4¢g2È9g¢>

9>X«X22Â2¢g9¢X¡ ¡¦C³2É¶2²c>J

g2>Cg¢gU¢gc¢R £CggC £¢gC' £>·¢gX>c2?c±³9¡¡

¬X¢gCg2g%gC"U¢g2%Xº92CÊ £>

¢gCc2 >¢gÇ¡gC¶c¢g2>J¡2>c> Cgc2

¢W

Ë Ì

@ <CÍ45*Î*= 3;Ív@

CêCc2Æëgìcícïî'¢ 62C¡¡¼Zð>ñ>ñ>ò>óÂ

Cg2ggCÃcC2À¤b>¬Cgc2¥ ¡g

¨c ¢>¢gº¤egô9>¡g¢U¤-¡¦CC'2¢

c©'¡>9g¢¤*2c¡¦CC©2¢>¼Ä22«c

¢C¼¦22¢ÃCX2c2W¢X¼ U¤Ä¢g22¢>õ®c¡

2g>2öggCX L¥ëigc99÷CÃµøXC £¢Cµù>óc

J>g¢¢gC¢g2 ¢g2>g¢X¡ >X¦c*¤% £>·¢gX>c2¼

¢gcRg¢gcXÆU>¢z¢gCO¦W©2C £¢¡ > £>c £g2X

õ0g?¢g2cÂ¢g2' £C·¢g>c2«c>2,¢g

2g>¦cC¬Æ,c¢2>¡2Cc>Cgc2¼Z¢g

¢g2®>C¬¤ÇCXc 28¢g2>¬>2J¢Â¤WcR2

¡2>c> 2% £gX2² £¬C2W¢gX Ïc¢¡ £c¡X¼

9Wc¢g2>4³2>c>«Cgc2¢XgJR £>W¢g¢

gcgcO¢gO¢2 ¡gX¨c ¢CO¢WU2g>2X

g¢c2CO £>2ú]2c £¢C«¢gÂ £C·¢g>c2'¢gc¢

¢g2UC¸pc¶J2cXgCX4¤X¢2>2cX¼XX¢g2ö¢gc

J2cXgCX¼v¤Ä¢g>c2±´>¬cX>2gC¸2W¢XC¼

>2?¤b £2O>®c¢g2X>U¡2>c>Cgc2©X>g

¢g2?¸2g¢>D¤°2û £>·¢gCc2' >R 2Æ

¡g> Wc¦ ¤¢g>c2´%>UcgUgC¸cgC

¢g²> 6c>U2X¦cUX¤e>X9c £R>C

c gg¢gcX¤ £>·¢g>c2¤b>4c¢2>J¡2

>c>Cgc2ÆC2Xggg¢g20 >³¦c¡¡¢§¸p2

¢>D2X20¢g2¢gD¤¦cg2>2©22gº¡X2

¢¨c ¢>c üNC ¢gc ¢g¼v £>·¢>c2RgCXc £U¦W

½>¾C¿#¢2Â2Á%gc £º©gg>R¦¢§ ¡¨2g

¢gX>2CÇCÂý>þ>þµ¡¦CC±´%C¬cRc' ¡¨2g

¢gX>2C>#ù>ð>ð>¼³þ>þ>þ©¡¦CCÿ´>¬cnõ®c¡

¢gc4ggc¢¬*¢¤b%2¼W¤b2g¢g2¬J>g¢¢>Zg

>CC*¢gc¢ X¢g>¢>µ¢g2Ç¸pc>³¢§¤z¢g2Ç¡

¦CC02¢C £cc³¢gC¥¦JÂ £>·¢>c2ccXg

¤b2g¢g2º¡¬2g>C¬J¢õ0¹C2Xgg'¢gc2g>¦2

CÊ¢g¹'âÒÕ>ÔÑ§ä>Û·ÔåOÙèpãzÔÑÖ]ÙÔÕOJX¡J¢¼¶ÓÒ>Ñ

Ñ§ÔÓÛ·ÔÕÓÒ;Û·Ñ£äCÖ_×Ö_×Ø¼N¢c¢C¬cWÈJc9 22>

¢¢g>¢g £>ggC £¢µ¢g2g>g9CXÂX22?¦J>¢g

g¢2c2®CggC £¢gCÂ £>·¢gCc2'2g>9¢g'¦

¸c¢gZgc £g¤bc¡¼¦2¡X2±¢2C9>c2µº

> £2X> £Cc>W¤ £>gC £¢gC© £>·¢gX>c2¡

cRc¢gÇJ¢ggg¢2±¢g2X>'Z¢gcOC

g2ggCOCgc2¼¦¢§O¢2Ã2C±¢gµ¦J>¢g

g¢> £2¢©³¦CCÆ2¢>¼Zcº¢g202C¢g

£>¢g2ÿXgCº¢XgÊõ00JCc¢g0C2¹2

2g> Lc¼X2X2R £>ggC £¢C £C·¢g>c2¼p¢Ugg2

¢gc¢g2X> öc'R2>¢g2Ç22g> Lc¼g2>

>¢ £¦cc2UCg2ggCRCgc2ZZ¢g

> £¢X>ÇCgc2²ëg4>2¢Z>¡³¼ðCñ>ñóg

22´J¢UgC £¢CO¤¢gccµJ¢ggXc £Çg

g2c £Cc £g2*g2g>2c22R £>·¢>c24øXC £

¢>2?½cX £¦Â¢g20¦cg?2>2"22Xg

(2)

¡XJ¢¨c ¢X>c

:Ív<>: 36=2/%B /%@*5879<C/= 3;=2/B

AÍv@ ~ 365-:<>/ 36Íc@ ~ Ív<'AÍ <>/%3;@*36@

2¹ £C·¢g>c2©c>2n2c³O 2Ê> £2

¢µ ¡¨c ¢>OJW>¢g2gR¤b>Ç¢g? «¦

C2C9¤eÿC¢g24¤W¢§¢g4¤%¤eC¢g2g4¤>¢g2

2¢C¼°C> 6 C¡CÖ]Ôö8üNC9´%C¬cC¼Uìc

cî'¢ 62C¡%ëgð>ñCñ>ò>ó*XX £¦¥¬¦c>R ¡g

¨c ¢>O¢g%¼c' c¡ 6O¢g2>Cv ¢gX¢gR2

2¢g2µ>92C¢²>©¦©c>º¥2cCg

¢§¥¤_> £c¢£¥¬C¦*2¬c>CüN>4¢c*¢g%¼

¢g2©g2C>g¢9¢g2?¤b¡X2O¢§0 0ëð>ó¢g2

>XÈ £>J¢>2C±¢g2U¢´W¢ ¤z¢g2Uc>c¤e>´J

>¬cC¼zÑ§ÔÙÔä>Ñ§ÓÜ Ö_×Û·ÔÑ§ÔÙÛ·Ùv>ÄãèåÖ]Óä>Û·Ö]Ò>×Ù Wëù>óW¢g2

>X¥ £>W¢X>2C0¡2JÃJ¢2¢g¢g2µc>

¤b> ´>¬cC¼vâ!±äCÕÖ]ÙÒCÑg

2ÇJ¢gc¢CÃ¦cc±ìc8cRî«¢ L2C³"ª £>

¢gCc2ÂC>>¢gcô $#Çëü4>2gðCóÃ¢gc¢Z¢§¶

¤z¢g2Ç2¢ µ¦U2C¢g¢g>R¢£¥ ¡g

¨2¢gc¢ 2C'C> 6«C¢g2&%-> 6Â ¡¨2

9¢>2C«220>2O,¤¢g2Â³¦CC©2¢>

2¢42gC2¡ £¢g¡¦C¤b>2g¢Xc £4¤N¢2¶2c³

¦CC2¢>-ìcRgCC £¢2²¢ ¬>¢ £>2¨cXJ¢2g

2¡ £¢>2cÃ>222 ¢g2¬ £>ggg>c22R2¢c £

Z¢O¢g2C2gC2¡ £¢gC'¡¦C ¢g±¢2µ¡¦CCO2¢>¼

C> 6® ³g¨2¥ >2²¢«¢2±>¢2µz>¡¡¦c

¢gCc2Â2¢>0CW¢Wc2¢g2 ¦>µ´%C¬cC¼

¦0c>ZW¢gCO¢g¦J®â!Oä>ÕÖ]ÙÒ>Ñ ¡2JR

¦µ2gC«¢g¢g>0¢g2µc> ¡g¨2¼ c³9¦

c>Ç¦>2¢Ñ§ÔÙÔäCÑ£ÓÜ±Ö]×Û·ÔÑ§ÔÙÛ·ÙÃcRãèåÖ]Óä>Û·Ö]Ò>×Ù

¦Ã2gC9¢g9¢gC±¢2R¡2 ¡g¨2

Ïc¢¡>¢gc2µ¤U £>·¢gCc2¹¤b% £2C >¹¢g2

2c¡³ ¦c¡¡¢§ ¤X¢g2 £>·¢>c2c>29¼>c

cg¢X¡ £c¡¼>µ ¡¡¤b%2¢g2¬ggcU2¢>2v2CXC

¢g)2g2g¢g28Á%C £¢C2g®¤±¢g2# >>C

¢c9ìc c©î«¢ L2C³*ëgð>ñCñ>ò>óª2gW¢C

' Z·g¢§Âc>J¤Z £>·¢g>c2¼UJ¢ggXc 2

¢g2º £>c £2¢¤U £¬c¢¦c¡¡¢£'¦¢£®¢g2¢g

>¢ ¤e2c £¢X>c ¢g2'2c¡¦CC2¢«¢gc¢«¼

¢g2 ¢Xg>¢ª¤e2c £¢X>g2>c¡RgC¢2 >¬È¡¦C

¢g Â2g¢c £g2g ¤ c¡ 6« ¢ g

2 9>X©¢§>22¢Cc>¡¬Cg¢J¢OJ¢g

¨2gg¢X¼C¢c¢*C> 6µ%®¤2¢g22¢g2>c¡µ¢ggC³¤C¦

g)( W¢ª¤eC-Cgc2 ¢g2 ³g¨c ¢> ¢g*Jc

+-,&.&/0.21.2/43057698;:<>=@[email protected]"30/O=@D;?D;?P=@8;P5M

/0D;30H<Q=RLTSVUW*305XADFL030D;?PN:D;L0HYD;3Z1/05<[=R8F30.2/0?=@30D;\.=@8;P5M

/0D;30H<][email protected]^`_8F5NDF330H.aG25M"30/O=RDF?DF?P]_=@/O=RAD;P<bWcDed.cdf`g4:L0M

D;?P48K=@f .28;.2A!=@?Ah:[email protected]=R3O=a_=@/030D;30D;5?.2AZDF?`305EAD;L030DF?G23

\`D;.2jLOdkSV5l695`5NL03OW9<].2?`30D;5?.2A&f .28;5mjEWlD;La5?.$L0:G@HT=R8F30.2/0?=@M

npomq9oOrsutvispwx)yzvo

s@nprwv!{mxr|p|@w}omn~)zvh woO)z

s@nprwv!{mxr|p|@w}omn~i4zvh woOi4z

rxxz`~ s@zZqz|@wsxromx|a"znaom rZqxom|awv

rxxz`~$s@zZqz|@wsxromx|a"znaom rZqxom|awv

ryyX~ m|aZz|psa{mzv}yomv s@xhxr9oOxoOyoOirZqxom|as@z

ryyX~i |aZz|psa{mzv}yomv s@xhxr9oOxoOyoOirZqxom|as@z

ü4C2g®ð#¦2g¢g> £¢? L2CRº¤µì¶c c

î'¢ 62C¡"' ôC>>¢gcn¤b>º £>·¢g>c2D2X2

±9C¡Äg¢¤³¦CC©2¢'ëm*óg¼0¡gC±g¢¤

2c¡¦CC'2¢µëmZóg¼ÄcR¢§µ%¤v¢g2²2¢

ëm

# Xóg

gC £Cc2¼¢gc¢U¢29% Ug2>c¡¦ £>c2¢Cc>¡

cXcXW¢µ¤*C> 6©>¢g2Â>XR¢g0¦2

¤bc¡*4292g>C¢gc¢42cX¢g2gggc¬2¢X>2¼

¬¢Xgµ¢gc¢ÇZCc¦cÃ¢gcX ¡g¨c

¢>O2gRCgc¦cZ¢© £C·¢g>c2 ÏD´J

¡¬J¢gZ¢g¢2R ®>>>X¢gc9¼>¢g2±2C¢¡ £C

¢gc¢¢ È¡U>g¢XW¢4¢Ã2gg>¢2Z2g¢gX¦22¢>

¤ ¡¡¦C©¢g2>gZ2'¦%X©¤ ¡¦CC

2¢X>Ãü4cC¡C¼¢g2?XC¬>2g¢¢gC±¢g2ZÁC £¢X>

2g ¤4 £>·¢>c2µ>º¶¦c>¥ ¡g¨c ¢>

¢g9¡R¡¡-¢g9¢gc¢ÈX £X¦C'¦XCC

¡¡2°cUø22CëgðCñ>ñ>ñ>ó>¶ £>c £g2C¢gc¢

¢g2Ç ®>C>¢gc8XJ 2>¢-g¢ggC2c¤eC £U¢g2

gC¸cgCUW¢%¢gc¢cWJ>¢2-¤b2c £¢>2cg2>c¡¶¦

£Uc¢¦cZ¢g0¢g292c³¦CCÂ2¢C«42¹2

¢g%Xc £C0®>>>¢c9¼Ä4ìÄW>¢¼¢gc¢µ2gC £¢X

9c¡9÷¥99¢ L?¦¢§©%¤¢g2µ22

¡¦CCµ2¢>¼>22² £¦cc¢>¤v¡XCÈ¤bg

£>·¢>c2cÇ2>ìÄW>¢ëgü>g2c9cøXccgC¼

ð>ñCñ>óg

>8c cc2ëgù>þ>þCþ>ó¤b>UC¬¢g2Ç¬>g¢

¢g2Cg>2>9CUc¡ >J>g¢¢>¤W¢g2RXX¡Xg

¢c¤4 £Cc2¢>cCÄcXcXc £±¤ 22

X%2 £>·¢gCc2 2C«´JX¡¬J¢g'g2>

>¢gC±¢gc¢U cXcXc £?XW¥cXC0>¤b

¤bC £¢¢g2Â¤b>9c £0¤Ã £C·¢g>c2¡È¦22¢¢gc¢

¼ 2 £¬cgC0¢gDC¢g2'C>>¢gc¬¢gc¢

2g¡¦CCc2c³¦CC2¢C¼¬gc 6)%*î

ëm¢¶CU2g¢gv¢ª>¡¡¼Jð>ñ Cº¢C¡¡¼>ù>þCþ>þ>óg¼J9

g¢X¡¡ 2XC4ÁC £¢X>4>Z 2µZ´Wc³¡ ¢°¤eC¢g2g

gc³¢ 22J2 c¼W2g%¡XC¢c¢*¢g2R2>2>

¡Uc¡¡ ¢-gCX2c2c £Â¢g2R2¢>

Ï Æ £>W¢g¢U¢g'2g>2²J>g¢X¢>2¤¢g2

(3)

22>2c £C£¨`ý>þ9¡¡³>)¥ö©£2O¥¢C£¢g2U¨2cc ¡>³±¢g2Cõ¹g®>>gcUW¢m¥£

ëi¦có

Ï

ª«£c2cO¬2 O¬"¥4¼ª«£øX>2¢g®¬a¦¶>C`¬-¥-¼¯ª«ªRg¢X¦c¡gc2°ª£2cR¢¡ 2¬¢O¬¥vZ¢gª£

'

¡c ¬;¥

£>g¢g2V±¥ ¼ª 22>2c £C ª £¨ ¬ ý>þ ¬ 9³¡¡> ¬¥' ª £2 ¬¥±¢g ª £¢g2 ¬ ¨2cc ¡>³ ¬ g¢g2C ¬

õÿg ¬ >>gc¬J¢ ¬¥-ª

ëg ó

² C¤e¢Ç>J¢g´J¢ üN £2õ?> ³ >J¢Z>J¢g´J¢ ² ¦C

´µ´

Ï

µ

Ï

c2c µ¶¶ ³ 2 µ

·

¼µ ¼

Ï

¼

µ

¼

µ

Ï g¢¦c³gc2 µ`¸

ì] 2c9¢¡ µ¶¶

¢

µ

k ø É

¢g

µ

Ï '

¡c

µ

·k'

>g¢gX2

µ

k

¼

µ

¼ 22C2c £C

µ¸

ì]¢ ì

ü4>2'ù2µ¦cg k' ²Æëg>óZg c2¡ ¢C²¦JDX¸pc±¦2C L>¢¼c©ëi¦có¦W Ï ÉUì"¢C©2

¢gCc22¢c £ÇÂëg ó £>2g¢¤¢g2µ¤b% £2U>XÇZ¢cg¢g·¤b·gC L'¢¼Ä¢Z £>J¢g´W¢ >X Z¢g

cg¢·¤e·C 60¢>X¼*c0¢g Ï ÉUì ¡¦C³29cg¢·¤e·C 6D¢>Rg²¤bgÊ¢g2 ' 2g¦c2'¢

g¢ag¢gJÈc2¡ ¢gRRg2²¤bC¢g2g¢¢g2U¦2c2±C¶c9¤¢g2UgJ¢gc £C

¢CO¤Cg2g%gC0Cc2±¢±2gC¦cC¬

9c¢g2>¡2>cCUCgc2¥ë ·² ² ógî'J ·² ²

¢W¥ £>W¢g¢¥D¢§OÈJÃZ¢D¢g2µ¦©c>

¡¨c ¢>'¢g'g¢gc2CDÂ2g>2>g'>

£>·¢gX>c2#ü4gg¢¼ ¢g2'¦ïc>'¢¤]> £¢g>g

c¢g2X>¡ J¢g9c>¥c'¡2µ% ¼ c¡Z>¢g2

k²² ¢gW?R©2C¢cC«c Lïc¢g2>*%

øXC £>c2¼9J k²² 2g>¦cC¬UC¸pc9W2cXCX

¤¬¢2>2cX'¤¬¢>c2¹´%C¬c¼Ã c¡?¢g2

¦cC¢g ©¦Cg2C«22ÂW2cXCX

¤´%C¬c

>2C¸p2J¢C¼>2Ç¤b% £2U>'c¢2>v¡2>c>

Cc2)W¢g%Xc £©2 ¸p2¢>2Æ¦>2¢Â¢g2

>³¦c¡¡¢§'¤*¢g2? £>·¢gX>c2'cC29¹ü4gg¢¼

Óä>× ÓÒ6Û·Ñ§ä>Ö]×Ö]×Ø¹Ô äã>ãåÖ]ÔÕ#Û·ÒåÔä>Ñ×Ö_×ØÿãÑ§Ò

åÔâÙ&4Ö]Û·Ü>Ò>èJÛU×äCÛ·èWÑ§ä>åCÚä>ÓÛ·ÒCÑÖKºäCÛ·Ö_Ò>×ÙÖ_×Û·Ò»Ö]Ô4Ùl¼

> c cc"g¢gcXÂg2>Cg¢g²0¸c>¡¨2C

(9X9¢C2g9¢g'¢gc¸2g¢>c¼¤b>²¥¢g´J¢

¡¨c ¢>ï¢8XX>2Cÿ¢g £>W¢X>gCX22

2J¢c¤eC9¢> Ç2>¼µ¢¹X¦cÂ¢g

£>J¢J2 J>g¢X¢> ¤X¢g2¬gg2¬¤eC¡g>· >

k²²

¢gWX9øXC £>c2¼ Ü>ÒïÕCÒÔÙÓÒ6Û·Ñ§ä>Ö]×Ö]×ØµÙÓä>åÔ

4Ü>Ô×ÿäÂåä>Ñ§ØÔ×èJâÔÑµÒ;Ú«Û·Ñ§ä>Ö]×Ö]×ØÔ½äCâãåÔÙä>Ñ§Ô

Ñ§ÔN¾èWÖ]Ñ§ÔÕ©Û·Ò©äCÓÜ>Ö]ÔÔDèJÙäåÔ¥ãJÔÑÚÒ>Ñâä>×ÓÔ0åÔÔåÙ ¼

Ï ¢Ç c³2¦cU¢9´WC £¢¢c¢ ¢g2¥ ï>C>¢gc

Z¡³°2>¢ >'C¡¡¼ZX20¢gÆ9g¢>?R>X0¦J

¢g2 ¡g¨2g*ÃC³¦>X¢gC¼X¢g2 ¡g

¨29µ% >c>³'C2Oc £>gC £¢ ¡¦CC

2g¢Xc £Ä¢¢g2¬¡¦CC2¢> Ï ¤29JR¢gX¢>2

¤vÿgC¸pcC¤e>ÈCgc2¢g2 ¢g¼%X>

2¢>®©¢g2Â¸c>¡¢§'¤*¢g2?¡¦CC2¢'9

¦C £¬R2g>¦cC9¼%µ¢g2g Á%C £¢2Z¢g2R¸c>¡¢§

¤¶g2¦2C¸p2J¢% ¡g¨2gXÀüNC'¡g>· >

99¦µXc¡CXC ¢¡¬C

ü4cC¡C¼O2C¢g¢gc¢9¢2Â> £2C £©¤2¢g>

9¢¡ >¡Â> £cc¡¢C²¢gX>c2º2¢'²¡¬

>g¢J¢Rg2'¤b>µRW?¦J>¢gg¢gX2c2ÂCgc2

¬¢2%X-ë·CN¿g gJÇëgð>ñ>ñ>ýCóg¼ ³ ¡>Á¥c

¶

>2

ëgðCñ>ñ>ñ>ógó¼êg2C>g¢2¢gc¢U¢g2µgÈXU¤c2cX

g¢Xc22Çc9XC>¡2UZ¢g¢gcªg2Z9U¦ >

c¨c W¢

À Á / ~ :ÂÂÍvÎ*@87 <>/ ~ : Ì 5*:@ 3pÃ*=2/ 36Ív@

ìgÂ2>222gëi¦cg k' Xó«g0¢gC2¢>2

>³X¨22C92C2gC £2gC±2>2©22Xg¼ ¡C

k'

¢c¢ZX92>¢ £>W¢X>

k'

ëü4>2gRù>R¡¡2g

¢gX¢g¦cg k' 9¢g¥g2>g¢R´%>UcC¡ó)ìg

2>2)22g¡XW¢X¨c ¢C Â¢g2®¢g8¤>

¢X2®¢g2©¦cg ·' ¹#ºgJ¢gc £ ¤eg ¢g2

>XU¤c¢2±gJ¢gc £ cO¢g2CÃcg¢g·¤b·gC 6

¢>µì¶g2>2022¡XJ¢¨c ¢>ÂR £g2

¡C9 £¬>2W¢Â¤gJg¢gCU0¢gc¢ÂC¬ccg

¢³>gJW¢X> £¢¡ -c>J¼Jc c22Rc¤eC9¢>Ug

¢gXJ>-ëiC4î'¢Ç¢²>¡?ëgð>ñ>ñCógóUcÂ¸p2g¢X>

2¶X2ÂëiC* 29¢²>¡©ëù>þ>þ>þ>óó¶gW¢gC¬

î'J £>g22·¦cgCOU¢g2%XcCU¦Â2c¡C

¢g¢2±¢g%¼-c c22g¢¢Xg¢¡ CÄ¬¢2%X¥ëiC

J2 6¹ëgð>ñCò>ò>ógóg¼¢2¤b>9¢>2·¦cC«Cgc2

ëiC&³ C¬gcíc8î' £2ÿëgð>ñ>ñ>òCógóg¼¬gC¢g©g

¸2c £ZCc2RëiCJ X2Èc ' £ÈëgðCñ>ñ>ò>ógó¼

¬CU>gJ·¦cgCgC¸2c £ZCgc2RëiC>¬>

¢¬>¡ëgð>ñ>ñCñ>ógóg¼2cµ¬C¬CgW·¦cgC±Cgc2¥ëiC

ø22«c ¸ 2g¢gRëgð>ñ>ñ>ñCógóg¼C¬>2>¢g2gX

É¶2¬ gg¢gcXC¬cJ¶C¡·W2 ¦2> 6>¢

g2gW¢X¢>c¼?W¢g%Xc £CÀ¦J[³ >¬c c

(4)

2Â¢g2O>X©±¢gc ¥¦2> 6>¢ ëÖ_×ÙÖ]Õ>ÔCóm!Å9¼

¬Cc29¢g2Ã>X±2>¢ Z¢c?¬¦2> 6>¢ZëÒ>èWÛ0

ÙÖ_Õ>ÔCómD>Æµ¼OUCc2À¢2ï>)¢gcû

¦2> 6>¢¼Ä¦22¢92C¢¢2>¬µ¦2> 6>¢µ9¢g2µ2g

£C22Z¶C2¼¡CX¢g2 >ÇÔØÖ_×Ù ¶2®¦2> 6>¢

J2¼z¢g2U¦2X> LC¢2Ã¢Xg¢g2¤b>UC±J¢g²

>¢C2 ¢gü4>2gÈù¦9C¢g-¢g2 ´>¬

cµgJ¢gc £C¼g2Z2¢g2 Ï ÉUì"¢g2ggJ¢

¢Cc«>c2O´>¬c¥¤eC

Ï ÉUì"¢>2c> ¢g2R¤b> ÈFÉÊËÌÍ`ÊË ÎÎÎm É$ÏÌÍpÏ ÎÎÎO É·ËlÌÍ2Ë EÐ0Ñ 2g É Ï

*¢g2Z¤b £2¶>X9ëg¡CX¢2>U 2>g

¢«¢g9¦¥Cg2C2ó c Í Ï

Z¢ggWJ¢> £¢X¡ U ¢g

>>ëg¡Ccg¢g·¤e·gC Lcó¢X õ0CX¢gÂ¢g2

C¤b¢ cÃCW¢-¤z¢g2Ç¤e £2>9c cXC±¤b>

£>J¢g´J¢0ü4c>³C¼uÐ Ã¢g2

Ï

ÉUì"¢¤ É Ï 0ü4>

2gZùC ¡¡2¢g¢gªU¤b2g¢Xc £*¢>²¤egÿ¢g2

´>¬cUgJ¢gc £C

õ0Ç L2Cg c>C¶¦c>¬ ¡gX¨2g¤b>4¢g2 g¢gcXC¼

¨2gg¢X¼°¦C 2g'¢g2Æg? £CW>cW¢µ¢g02gºc2¼

cXC2¼Äc>¦Â2gCÂ'2g%>2µ £>·¢>c2

g¢gc2 c¥C £>c2¼¦C 2g±¢2¹g9cg¢¡ £2

¡X9C¡·gc¢gC¢g £>·¢>c2¦J%g¢g2U¤ö >

£c¡¢X2'2g>¦c¦c¡³¢¥¤e>C> 6©2gC2¡ £¢X>cü>>

¥2g¢c £]Ò¼p¢g2È ¡g¨2ªX¢g92Ä¢g2È9´W

¡c,Cg¢gC%¡¦CcZ¤b¡

ÐeÓÔeÕ Ö g 9´

×NØaÙ ¬IÚª*Ú± ÛVÜ

ëmÐOÝÒó Ö g¬9´ Ü ëOÐ·ó Ü ëeÒÝÞÐ·ó Ö g¬9´ Ü ëOÐ·ó Ë ßà ÊË Ü ë É ß ÌÍ ß ÝÐ·ó Ï R´W¡¬J¢g4Z¢Ã¢g2gc>>*¦c> Ï ÉUì© ¡g

¨2¼°?¤b>2c«¢gc¢R>g¹¡¢g¢ > £2> £ÂÈ

> £X¨c £C« 2¢2¶CDc¤e>X9¢C¹ëg¡C

É ß ó È-C2>gCª¦JU¢g2¬ ¡g¨2 õ0-¢g2gC¤b>g-g2¦2 g¢¢g2¢g9¢g2R¡¬cZ¢g Ü ë Í ß ÝÐ·óZ¤eC Ü ë É ß ÌÍ ß ÝÐ·ó ¦XCC

22gC¦c¦c¡¡¢X

Ü

ë

Í

ß

ÝÞÐ·óUgµg¢¡9¢gC0¤bg

¢g2¢g>c2¹2¢O¦WÆX¢9c2Â¢g2¤b> £¢C

¤ ¢g22g¢c £ ¡¦CCáÐ¢gc¢µcCOgJW¢X> £¢¡

â¯UHDFLG25N?`30/O=@L030Lj D;30H4530H.2//0.IL0:8;30LOWL0:GpH!=@L]ã =R<]L0H=0j

=@?ACBZ=@/0GI:LOJaä0åNææçNè0WD;?AD;Gc=@30D;?P!30HV=R3kjé5N/0AXD;?15/0<b=R30DF5N?

D;L]DF<E_ 5/03O=R?`3]15/EfV=RL0.ZêëTDFA.2?`30D;ìG`=@30D;5?dÇ,&.ZL0_ .2G2:8K=@30.

[email protected]?=@D;\.af=0gN.2LGI8e=RL0L0DFì.2/0L:L0.IAZH.2/0.k=@/0.aL0D;<]_8Fg4?53 L05_HDFL030D;[email protected]].2?5:PH43053O=Rí.=@A\=@?`3O=@PN.5N1 jé5/0AEDF?15/0<Z=@M ¢>>g ß ë·>> ß

ó¼zZ¢g ¬·g¢X¡9¢>c

Ü ëÍ ß ÝÐ·óaÖïî ë Í ß Ð·óéð©ð î ëmÐ·óñðòý Å*g î

ëeÒöó X2C¢gU¢g2²¤eC¸p2c £¤>J¢kÒ¹

¢g2¢gX>c2 2¢>µcU¢¡9¢X¬WC¢g2U¢g2

¢gX>c2©2gC¦c¦c¡¡¢§¹¦Wc c22g¢gc>Zëi22

gcó±C¬cÂ¤b>C> Lcg¢·¤e·C 68¢ë·¤

c³ L¢g2RgZý>ó

ó AÍ <>/%3;@*36@

Ív< ÌôYÁ AB;/ ~X~

3pÃ*:<

~

µ2c £>·¢gCc2¼X¢g2U¦cg k' ¡g¨c ¢>

¢g?2g¢¨2g¢U¦¤]> £¢gCgCOJ¢gµ% 9ü>>U¢g2

Ï ÉUìD2¢c £-ëiCC £¢g>gö¤cg¢g·¤b·gC L¢C-2

X´JC©¤eöõZ÷«¢gø÷2ó9±%û £>ggCcX9¢g

g2¦2¢±¤*¢g2'g¢9¤Uc2¡ £úùõZ÷

ÎÎÎm

÷)ûX 2

¬Cg¢vc¢g2X>p g*gc2$ùõZ÷

ÎÎÎO þû c

ùþ

ÎÎÎO

÷)û¼c2¡ ¢2D¢gc¢>2 ¡g¨2?WCW

¢U¢2¤e £2¢?cO¢g29¢X>U¢gº¢gRC¤b¢¼c¡

¢g2C¢g2J>J¢9¢g2?¤b £2±¢¹c«¢g2¢>

¢g²¢ >J¢

>¢gU¢c¢ ¢g2gZ% Z £g¢Cc9

³¢g¢g2X¡XX¢gc ¤U £>c2¢>c> cX2

Xc £Z¦¢§%Ê¤eC¢2g c £U¦>¢gºc cX

¢g2 ¤b% £29¢X©É¶¢g2 ¼c LÆ²C¤b¢

µ

X>J¢

9¢g¢2¢g2R¤b% £2 ¢¼¤b> ´>¬cC¼v9

¦¬>gR¢g2>g¢³ >¡?¢¢g> £¢>C¼¦22¢Ã¤b>2c

¢gc¢*¢g2RC¤b¢ µ X>J¢4%Uc c22²¤e £22g>C

¬Cg¢ÁC £¢c>%2> £¢³ £C

2 Ï ÉUìÊ¢>20¢g©C¸pc±g¬92>

¬2¨c ¢X>2 ¢g±¢2 8>C>¢gcRü4gg¢¼ö¢Ç

¡U2> £¢¡ CW¤b>*¢2Z £>·¢gCc2R ¡¨2g4¢gZ2g

2¡ £¢È¡¦CÈ¤b>*C> 6?2g¢Xc £¤bg"¢g2 2>U>2

g¢Z¤Ä2c¡¦CCD2¢>

Ï

2g¢gC>2¼ÇX9>¡¥2¢

WöZR>J¢>2C2¼v¤bC±Z¢gXcX9CC £¢gC

2¢c £ ¤bgï¢g2Ç¡g>4¢Þü'øXC £>c2¼W¢g2 Ï ÉUì

¢>2¢?ZÃ¢ggcgC¼¢2¢gcÂÃ¦ccgC¼

¡g¨c ¢X>c9ü>2g¢g2¬CgC¼¢g22¢g¦22¢>O¤

¡¦CR?¢g29¢gCc2?2¢µ¬>92W¦cC¡c £C

¢gc©¢g2Â2¢g¦22¢>D¤°>¢>?c 2¢>

´>¬cÇ¢g2¶¦'cCÃ¢é¶c>UCC¼ÄýC½>¡ñ>¿

¤v´%C¬c²g³¦CCýÄ¼*³þ>¿[ÅÇ¼-cÂù>¡ð>¿

Æµ4ø2c £¢Rµ¡U2> £¢¡ Cê¢g?C22¼C¼*ùÇÄ¼*ù>ù

Å9¼%cð&Æµ¼W¢g¢g2R¡¦CC2¢¢ CC Lg¢±¤

£>·¢>c2¼U2g¢gC>2¼U2g¢c £?«CC £¢gCD¦W

¨2g¢ 62WC2 ¡¦CaÐ-¢UcX> £C22¢g

¢g2Ç¡¦C%2g¢g¦22¢>c¼>¢g2?>2229¢22¢c £

þUHDFL)L03O=R?A=@/0A·<]5`AD;ìGc=@30D;5?4jÿ=RL¡D;?`30/05`A:G2.2A4f`gb68F:<

=@?A[email protected]¡ä0åNææçNèñD;?=R?Z. 5/03305]G25m\.I/30H.:?A.2/08;g`DF?P

AD;L030/0D;f:30DF5N?451:?8K=@f .28;.2A4D;?L03O=R?G2.ILH5Oj°.2\.2/OWêDFP =@<=@?A

(5)

n@oOq9omrsutv spwx)yzvo

spn@rwvh{mxr|@|pw}omn$~)zv! wom)z

spn@rwvh{mxr|@|pw}omn$~i]zv! womi]z

spn@rv|@"omnanprvyzZxZ|@omxom{Os@omyXom rZqxom|

"npz s@z)tv s@wx

"zn~~ ~i

rxxz`ø~s@zZqz|pwsaxr9oOx|a¯znrxx)om rZqxom|awv

n@oOq9omrs!s@wZom|

|pomxom{msuxr9omx Vrsn@rvyz r{m{Ozn@ywv!Zs@z"$#

spn@rv|@"omnZz|ps{mzv}yoOvispxxr9omxomy

Vom rZqxou"npz

s@z

ü4>2Â½©2º¬2¨2C® £>·¢g>c2¹>C>¢gc

9>W¢C2 2¢Wé&%ê¤zX÷('¼vcµ¡¦C$)

2g¢Xc £* ¢gX¢>ZgCC £¢gCR> £>22U¢U¢g2

2g¢¦22¢C±¤ö¡¦C+*+,caZ¢g2Ã>Xc>>

>>X¢gc9¼¡©*¢g2Ç¡¦CCµ2¢>¼éÿ¢g2 2c¡¦CC

2¢C¼c»

#O

ª¢g2Ã X

¬>¢R £>2¨cXW¢X¡¦CC ÐÄ¢gO¢g2«¡¦CC«2¢>

c2g% £CX2Ã2gg> ¢g2R2¢g¦22¢>9¤ö¡

¦CU9¢g2Ç¡¦CC±2¢XÃ¬2g¢c £ÈZ¡¦CC

c>2XC2Ã2¥¬2¨2CO >C>¢gc)2g

gJ¢gC?ü4C2gR½>

- .

1%/%B6Î-/ 3;Ív@

õ0 J>c¢g £>·¢g>c2¯¤b>

Ï

ÉUì ¡¨c

¢Cï22 ¢c22¢0g¢ggC¦cC¦J

³ >Ugc c î'X £2 ¤bg C £¢>2 ð>ý0/ð>ò

ëi¢gX>c2º2¢>¼ ùCð>ð>ù2g¢c £ócDùCþ«ë·¢gg¢

2¢C¼$°>½©2¢c £ó9¤ª¢g2

'

2 g¦c2

õ¹>³0øX¢gg¢

¶

>2gcCD £>22)ëgî'X £2"¢ >¡¡¼

ð>ñ>ñC½>óg >c2 2g¢c £¹ £>2¢«¤¬cg¢g·¤e

gC L¢c Ï ÉUìD¡¦CJ¤e>¶¤b% £2ö>2¼>C>2

Z¢Â £>J¢g´J¢g ¤¢§9cg¢·¤e·C 6«¢X> ¢gR¢g2

C¤b¢µc>J¢Ã¤Ä¢g2«¤e £20É¶2>C4> £2> £

¤Zñ>ý>¡ðC¿ µ¢g2'¤b>9c £0¤U«g2g%gC

Ï

ÉUì# ¡g¨2¢>2C«>©¢2? £>ggC £¢¹¡¦CC

>gX>9¤W¢g2Ç¤bc¡N¢gX>c2R2¢X>ë

Ï

µ>2*´JX

¬J¢g4¢g2>CW ¡g¨242g-¢g2ÈC¤b¢4%Â¤>¢g2

2¢C¼Cc¡ L > £¢gcC¡>2¢g¤eC¬¢g2Ç £¦c2C

C¤b¢

µ

>W¢Z¡ó ü>>'c¢¡>¡¦CC2¢C¼¶¢g2

¨2gg¢Æ2g¢c £Z¤¢2¢>c2 2¢g>

¢g2C¶ £>ggC £¢-³¦CXõ0X¢gX92Cª¢24¦g¢ög¢g

¢2²¤b>¢g2 c>¬¢g¤z¢g2R ®>>>¢c¦J

¢gg¢X2µc¢cz>2]©ëgc¢¡>>¬>2J¢*¤v¡

¦CC92¢>ó2JC¤bgð>þ¶¢gÇý>þ>þCþ>¼p¢2'«ëiJ

÷Cóc¤egïù>þ>þ¢Zý>þ>þ>þC¼¢g21)Çëi>X¢gX÷Cóv¤bg

ð¬¢g ý>þ>2Ã¦g¢¢g¢2¼cO¢gX¬ ¤Á%C £¢>

2OJC2'gO2gC0¢g2g>2C2>2¢±¢2OJCc

¢>±2cg 2>¢gC9>¢g2ggC

24365798;:=<>?<> @BA õ?>¦2g> ¢g2 2g>Cgg*¤z¢g2

£>·¢>c2µ2g £gÃ¦JX¢g9c2¼*¢UC> L¢g

¢>c¼v¢g2?> £2> £?¤¢g2 £>·¢gCc2Â ³g

¨2g>O¢g2Â¢gg¢º2¢>õ0>©gC £>¢g2

> £2X> £'¤¢g2µ>gZ2¦%XÂ¤¡¦CCÂ2¢>

2?¬Cg2gCUW¢g ¹¦Oc>¢g¢gC«¢gÿXc¡ £¢

µCgc2' £2gCC¼*c2¡ ¢2µ¢g22g>>g¤- £>

¢gX>c2R¢g2R ³g¨2¬> £2> £« Lc2C ü4>

2gY¹2ggJ¢g¢§¶©2ggJ¢¢C© £2>¼>2

¤b>¢g2¹C¤e¢? £>J¢g´J¢? ¡gX¨2?c>2¹¤b>¢g2

¡¦CCÂ2¢>©ë2±X>J¢ £CW¢g´J¢µ ³g¨2¦

c> ¡9³¡R¢g±¢2C¤e¢¼¦22¢R¢g X¤e>X9c £

-¡CW¢Ã>ggC³ó$ g2 c¼% £>·¢gCc2Ãgc¢g

Æ³¬2g>C¬J¢¹¢gg¢> £2X> £©>9¢g2ºc

¢³>Ä ³g¨2Ç>¤b¢gR¦>2¢µð>¾Cþ±¢¢C2¼êCXc £

2µ¦JÂ½>¾>¿Ê¢22Ác £«g> ¦¢§0¢g2

£>·¢>c2¥ ¡gX¨2Zc¢g2Z>>% ¡g¨2

»*c¤eCg¢g2c¢gCC¼N¢g2Ç¡¬2g>CUW¢R¢gg¢ C £2

C £XJÄ2C¢ £>J¢J2- £C·¢g>c2 2g>>gg

¢g2¼W¤b>Rc £ÃCWX¼z¢g2ÂXC ³2¬

c¢9¦C¤b>gg¢¦c¡³÷C2¢>2cñ>ùC¡ý>¿9õ0

JW>¢g2÷O¢gc¢R¢gc XC ¡2Â'X2'¢g¹XC

2¢X>ÂO¢g2²¸c>¡¢§¤¢g2²¡¦CC'2¢C4c

JW>¢g2-vg22>g¢gC¦JRü4>2gaC¦c¼Wc2³ ¢2

¢gc¢?¡¦CC"2¢X> £2C £8XC £Cg'g¢gC>2³

¦C¤e> g¢¦c³¡÷C2Ç¢gC2c9ñ¿9 >¢g ¢c¢4¢g2

> £2X> £©¤¶¢g2 ¡¨2µg¢¦c¡³÷¢ ²J¢

¦c¢¥¢gc0¢g29g¢X¦c> £2X> £'¤¢g2«¡

¦CC2¢>¼24>c³ª¦´WC £¢gC±³¤2¡¦CC92¢

¸c>¡¢§ÂccXg?¤b2g¢g2?¡U2g>C¬J¢'¤bg¯ £>

¢gX>c2

ü>2g¢g2¬CgC¼Ä £C·¢g>c2¤eC¦c

k'

¡XJ¢

¨c ¢X>0gCU9¢gO¦?¸pc¢g±2¢C9¢g'¢g2

cX>¬¢gg¢g¢X2>üNC¶´>¬cC¼zZ¢gúÖïù>þ>þ

¢g2« £>·¢g>c2? ¡gX¨2gµ2CZ2>¢Ã¢g¦ > £

£2¢g*2>2C9¢g g2g¢> £C·¢g>c2¼pc¡Z¢g

Ö ð>þ>þ>þC¼c¢2¹gµ¢gJÂ> £2¢gC¼D¢2±g2

¢gc¢ £>·¢g>c2R £>J¢g¦22¢g->g²¡¢¢È> £2> £

¦C¤e>U¢g2R¡¦CCO2¢XX¢>¢gÈëgü4>2gÇý>óg

Ï ±¢g22´W¢-gC £¢>2X¼X¶>2Xgg-¢g2 2g>¦cC¬

¤2¢0X>X>2¢C®c«c>¬¢gRg2¢%¢§

¤b>È £>·¢gCc2

24368;8DCFEHGICFJK24365798;:=<>?<> @BA 'g2 ¦>C¼

¢g2ÈX>X>2¢CU¤N¢g2È¡¦CC2¢ J¢ggXc £

C¡¦c¡¡¢£Z2g>¦cC#¤e> £>·¢g>c2Ã¦C 2gÃc £

£gX>O ¡gX¨2g92g'gc £>C©WCg

(6)

ë>ó

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.92

0.925

0.93

0.935

0.94

0.945

0.95

0.955

0.96 Accuracy of Left Classifier

Accuracy

Iterations of Co−Training

ëi¦có

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.94

0.95

0.96

0.97

0.98

0.99

1 Accuracy of Labeled Data

Accuracy

Iterations of Co−Training

ü4>2Z¡

²

Cc2 £2g>Ç¤b>Z £>·¢gX>c22Ug¡³ £2g>µ?ëg>ó c2³ ¢g ¢g2RC £2> £¤¢g2µC¤e¢

£>J¢g´J¢R ¡g¨2¼ c¡¢g2«X>¢g¢gC'¡2g2 U¢29>>X¤e>X9c £9¤v¢g2>¬« ¡g¨2¢gX>2C

>º±¡¦CC±>gX>¤¢g2¥ £¬c¢Ã¢gCc22¢X>& 2Âë·¦có ¢g2²> £2> £¤¢2µ¡¦CC'2¢

>¢g2µ £C2ggU¤ö £>·¢gCc2-ìcC¢g? £2g>ÇgÇ>>> ¨2CUg22

ëg>ó

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.86

0.87

0.88

0.89

0.9

0.91

0.92

0.93

0.94

0.95

0.96 Accuracy of Left Classifier (L = 200)

Accuracy

Iterations of Co−Training

ëi¦có

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.86

0.87

0.88

0.89

0.9

0.91

0.92

0.93

0.94

0.95

0.96 Accuracy of Left Classifier (L = 1000)

Accuracy

Iterations of Co−Training

ü4>2Uý ² Cc2µ £2gC ¤b> £>·¢gCc2 Z¢g9zg2R>¬C2W¢g4¤c¢X¡>J¡¦CC92¢-ëg>óa ÖÆù>þ>þ>¼

ëi¦có4CÖïð>þ>þ>þC

2>¢¢g>²J¢gg>2¦WÂgZ2¹c £>gC £¢2

gg¢2µ¢g2²X¢gC¢CO¤v¢g2²¡¦CC«2¢>¼

2>µ¢g2g>J¢U¢g29c¢¡9¢µXC ¡2«> £

£2> £ ¤b>Z £>·¢gX>c2

ÃJCc¢g¢gc->¦c¡¡¢£C¼¡c¡¢gÈ¶J2

9¥22>¢¢g>%¦WÇ2¢g9¢¡ C¡Z £>gC £¢2C> 6

2Z?³¦CC'2¢c £µ¢C2XCR¢±¢g2¥¡

¦CCÿ2¢>Àü4>2gÂ¾C²2gW¢gµ¢g2'ggc¢g±¤

¢gcµ´J¡UW¢ ±JJ>¢g2X÷C2¼¢g2Â ¡g

NUH.H`:<b=@?·G25:8;A=@8;L05uL0DF<]_8;g]AD;L0Gc=R/0AkD;?G25N/0/0.2G2308;g]8K=@M

f .28;.2A·DF?L03O=@?G2.2L305/0.2A:G2.30H.a. 5N/03f:3jé.A54?53.2\=@8;M

g¢C>'c £gC2g¢gC>2¡O¢gZ¢gc¦C2¢Rþ>¡ý>¿

¤¢g2Z>>vC £2> £?>¤b¢gZò>þCþ9¢g¢>2 üNCZ

gCCNJc9 22>¢¢>¼X¢g2 Á%>g¢*¢µ> 6c> ¢gc

¡U2g>C¬J¢*>c¡Ãc>c cXCgZ2²ð>þ

2¢c £¢g¢>c¼>²ò>þCþ>þ'2g¢c £X¼¦22¢

>c £>ggC £¢X2²¦>2¢]ýCþ¢c¢¶Rc £>ggC £¢X

¡¦CC2ZW2Ç £>gC £¢gC' £>·¢g>c2¼vPO¬Xg

¢C g2g%gC=QU¢g2%2¼J9>W¢C2%¢g2¸pcC¡¢§

¤W¢g2Ç¡¦CC92¢X>¼N>¢¢g2ÁCg¢*>µ¢g2 cg¢*¤

¢g2ZWcR22>¢¢>C9>2 9>³v'2g>>g

¢>0¢g'¢g2?>U>2W¢¤2¢±c¢¡R¢gC¡¦CC

(7)

ëgCó

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.92

0.925

0.93

0.935

0.94

0.945

0.95

0.955

0.96 Accuracy of Left Classifier

Iterations of Co−Training

Accuracy

ëi¦có

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900 1000

0.92

0.925

0.93

0.935

0.94

0.945

0.95

0.955

0.96 Iterations of Co−Training

Accuracy

Accuracy of Left Classifier

ü4>2 ¾4CggC £¢gCZ £>·¢g>c2ë>ózC¡¡Rc¢g-XC>2¢>Ã¤X¢2 ¡¦CC2¢*¦WR £CggC £¢2Ç¡¦C¡2

ggCgÃõ8¢gR'0g¢Ã¢?ð>þ>þµëi¦cóg¼* £CggC £¢gC' £>·¢gX>c2 > 6c>ÃgW¢X¡>¡¢2C £2> £'¤¢2¤ec³

g2g%gCO ¡g¨2

üN2¢g2¬>C¼ £>gC £¢gC £C·¢g>c2 >³%

c>¬C®¢2¢¢§'¢g'¢g2?>¬C2W¢¤ c¢¡>

¡¦CC2¢>õÿ2¹¢gJ®¡¢g¢ ¡¦CC2¢X0

2g¡XC2¼¢g2¹c¢X¡> ¡g¨2g? 22>¢g2¢>

£>·¢gX>c2²¡¬2XCC¬W¢Xcõ¢g2ggC £>g

gC £¢>c¼Ä2X>X¼¢g2µg0¤g¢¢2Z¢D¢gJ

¡¢¢²¡¦CC02¢µ £¬c¢gC'C¡³9c¢gC2¼vg

¢gc¢¶ £>·¢g>c2Z Z¦Èc¢³¢gC*Z¢g¥g¦c¢gX¡

9C¡%>¬>2J¢g¤ö¡¦CC2¢>MS

>¢gÃ¢c¢ £CggC £¢gC £>·¢g>c2 g2¦2¢?2³¤e

¤bgW¢¶¤egÿ £C·¢gg¢2ëgî±2CÄ¢->¡³¼>ù>þ>þ>þCóg4É¶2

9CW¢'ï¢gc¢¹ £>·¢gg¢X2¹#> £¢X>Cg2

22g% £Ã¢gc¢U2 £C·¢g>c2¼ 2gC¥ £>g

gC £¢gC? £>·¢g>c2?RO £C·¢g>c2±2g £gZ¢gc¢

2g > £¢CÂCc280¦¬>O2gC C¼U £>

¢gg¢X22c¡¢g2 £¬c¢X¦c¡¡¢§º £>c £2¢¤bg

£>·¢gX>c2 ¢Z¡XJ¢¡¤b´>¬cª¤b>-Jc9¥2

2>¢¢g>4¢g²¡¦C"Ä´%C¬c*2>gÇ ¡g¨c ¢>2

¦J¢2¶Æ ¡g¨2g2Áë·¢g2È £>W¢W¢>g¢ó

g £C2¡XgC 2¡¬ c2³2¢g-¤b>°> £¢CCg2

2¥¸p2 >gC £¢gC9 £>·¢>c2¼N>µ¢g2 >¢g2

cc2¼2gU¢2 ¡gX¨2g ¢g±CC £¢Rc'¡

¦C2´%>Uc ¦C¤b>gU2gW¢X2¢g2C ¢g¢g2UJ2

9?g%¶XOìÄ>¢g¹U¢g2%Xc>9¢29>>¤

>¡%¡¢2WcR22>¢¢X>Á%>g¢ £>·¢g¢2

¦J0gCXc 20¢2±¢gC¢>Jc¦9¤2g¢Xc £²2

2>¢¢gC)% £>ggC £¢gCµ £>·¢gX>c2Z¦W2¢g9¢X¡ >¡

¡¦C¡2²9Jµ¤ê¢2U2c¡¦CCO2g¢Xc £

T

UH.2/0.4DFLk=@?ý=RAADF30D;5?=@8G25N?GI.2/0?Ç30HV=R3jD;30H!305`5h8;D;30308F.

D;?D;30De=R8AV=R3O=WGI5M"30/O=@D;?D;?P]<b=eg4?5N3 [email protected]=RGpHD;.2\.$=RA.2M

:=@30.éG25m\N.2/O=@PN.é5130H.°3O=@L0íd9UHDFL9DFL0L0:.¡D;L*=RAA/0.2L0L0.2AEf .28;5Ojd

7$:=VWX2Y3=Z[CF8;:=@\C]A

Ï

J¢gg¢2C¼2¢g2gÃC9>2

³>J¢ '¦¢§0¢g2«> £2> £¤* £>gC £¢gC

¢gc¼Ä¶µJW>¢g2÷¢c¢µ £>·¢>c2XJ2>¢

2C £gX¡ ¨2cª¢2 ¬>¢Ä2gC¤bc2c¡¦CCª´>¬

cXîRCg2gC gCC¼vc £92c³¦CC´%>Uc

ÃgCC £¢C0c'¡¦CC±¦cgC¥>'¢g2²Cg2g

£>2¨cXc £ '¢g2CZ2gC2¡ £¢>2¼¢g2gR´%>Uc

¬Cg¢ ¡>C9g2gW¢X¢>¤z¢g2Uc¢¶¤z¢g2

¢gc> £È¤_>R¡¡¡c¢g¢2U ³g¨2¼pX¢g2ö¢gc

2Cc¤bcv¤b>ZCgc292 gC £¢g¤ê¢g2Z¢g

Ï

>¢2¶CX¼ª¢g¢WÆ¡¢g¢º¡¦CCï2¢>¼Z £>

¢gX>c2¥ ¡g¨2g >c«Cgc¢ ¤¢g2U¢g

ìÄc2JÂ £c ¡Xc £C¼¢g2²2¢¬WêcX>¬

¢g^'¤*¢g2Â,>>C¢gc>¡ 29¢gÿc2

gC £¢X0´Jc>g¢gcgg2CÆø2c £O¢g2 ³g

¨2g'2g¢RgCC £¢ 2g¢c £¢¹¡¦C¤bg ¢g2

2¢X°W_%·¼X c2gC £¢R¤b> £-¢g2Cÿ¢g g

C £¢gÇ £g¢>c¼ö>¦C¢ >¢gJ¢¡>¡'¬CgU2gC¤bc¡¼

2¢c £U¢gº¡¦Cv¦W'g¢¢2?ÇX9>¡JX÷C

ìÄ¡¡9¢X2'¢g2OJc¦µ¤¶´%C¬cJC¡¡¦c

¢gR³¦C¡¼> 2g>J¢*¢g2 ¡g¨2g¤bgïg

C £¢X2±´ 2>CÂ¤bgô¤]>9³¡¡gW>2´>¬

cX©ë

¢g2>Xc>C¤e>Xc³¢>Z¤ £C·¢g>c2¼p¦22¢-Z¢g

£>gC £¢gC0 £>·¢>c2¢g2 ¡¦CCD2¢XRC9>2

`cZ>¡¤v¢g2%) ¡g¨2gX¼ê2>¦2¦cC¥¦W

¢g2 9C¡X÷ ¤z¢g2 JW¤vz>¡¡¦c ´%C¬c¼

9>RW 9¢>³ó

ü4C2gµ¾¦?2ggJ¢gU¢g2ggc¢U¤* £>gC £¢gC

£>·¢>c2´J³¬W¢Ç c¡ 6a' g¢ ¢g ð>þ>þ