Current
Status
of the Identification
and
Management
of Tinea
Capitis
Daniel
P. Krowchuk,
MD, Anne
W. Lucky,
MD, Susan
I. Primmer,
MD,
and Joseph
McGuire,
MD
From the Departments of Dermatology and Pediatrics, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut
ABSTRACT. Tinea capitis due to Trichophyton tonsurans
has become a significant health problem affecting
chil-dren and adolescents. This infection has several different
distinctive clinical patterns which, if not recognized, may
result in delayed diagnosis and therapy. This review is
designed to emphasize the differences between tinea
cap-itis caused by T tonsurans and that caused by other organisms. Current diagnostic and therapeutic measures are discussed. Pediatrics 1983;72:625-631; Trichophyton tonsurans, tinea capitis, scalp, Microsporum.
Tinea capitis, a common disorder in the pediatric
age group, may affect up to 10% to 20% of the
population during epidemics.13 The emergence of
Trichophyton tonsurans as the organism predomi-nantly responsible for this infection has resulted in a clinical pattern not previously described with
Microsporum sp infection.4’5 Our experience in the
Pediatric and Dermatology Clinics at the Yale-New
Haven
Medical
Center
seemed
to indicate
an
in-crease
in the
number
of children
affected
by this
disease. If this is true for other areas of the country,
one may expect that those who provide primary
care for children will observe a similar trend. This discussion is limited to tinea capitis caused by T
tonsurans and how the expression of this infection
differs from tinea capitis caused by Microsporum sp.
DEFINITIONS
Tinea is the general term used to describe an
infection by any of the keratinophilic fungi known
Received for publication Oct 14, 1982; accepted Feb 2, 1983. Reprint requests to (A.W.L.) Division of Pediatric Dermatology, The Children’s Hospital Medical Center, Elland and Bethesda Ayes, Cincinnati, OH 45229.
PEDIATRICS (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright © 1983 by the
American Academy of Pediatrics.
as dermatophytes and is synonymous with
ring-worm. Dermatophytes exist in two forms: growing,
elongated hyphae and resting, compact spores. Ti-nea capitis refers to infection involving the scalp and hair shafts. Although a number of different
dermatophytes may cause tinea capitis, three
or-ganisms appear to be responsible for the majority
of disease in the United States: T tonsurans, M
audouini, and M canis. Tinea capitis is almost
exclusively a disease of children and adolescents with only 5% of cases occurring in adults. T ton-surans
appears
to be the
most
common
organism
responsible for adult infection.6
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Transmission of dermatophytic infection usually occurs between humans (anthropophilic) during ep-idemics (ie, T tonsurans and M audouini), or trans-mission is from animals to man (zoophilic) and is
sporadic in nature (ie, M canis).7 In the past 30 years, there has been a gradual shift in the role
played by various organisms responsible for
epi-demic tinea capitis in the United States. Studies
performed in South Carolina in the 1950s revealed
that more than 94% of infections were caused by
members of the genus Microsporum (Table 1). In
contrast, by the 1970s only 9.4% of infections were
caused by Microsporum sp while T tonsurans had
become
the
dominant
organism,
causing
90.6% of all cases.8 T tonsurans has been endemic in Puerto Rico and Mexico in the past, and it is postulated that its increasing incidence in the United States reflects population shifts and subsequentinfec-tion.”9 The shift from Microsporum to T tonsurans is more than an epidemiologic curiosity; the char-acteristics of infection by T tonsurans differ
consid-erably from those of disease caused by Microsporum sp (Table 2).
ton-TABLE 1. Changing Epidemiology of Tinea Capitis In-fection*
1950-1954
Terreni (N = 278)
1954
Adams and
Riley
(N = 100)
1973-1978
Prevost
(N = 265)
Microsporum audouini canis pseum Trichopkvton tonsurans 96.7% 2.9% . .. 0.4% 50% 39% 5% 5% 9.4% ...
...
90.6%* From Prevost.5
TABLE 2. Differences Between Trichophyton tonsur-ans and Microsporum Species Infection
T tonsurans Microsporum
-.
Sex predisposition M = F M > F
Racial predisposi- B > W B < W
tion
Natural history Chronic
infec-tion
Spontaneous
resolution at puberty
Age Children and
adults
Prepubertal
children
Alopecia Insidious,
dif-fuse
Well-defined
Fluorescence Absent Characteristic
(Wood’s lamp)
surans affects blacks far more commonly than
whites and is equally distributed between males and
females.H Many reports1”#{176}’5 have documented that infection by members of the genus Microsporum
resolve spontaneously and, in the case of M
au-douini, this often occurs at puberty. The natural
history of Trichophyton sp infection has not been as extensively studied. Although spontaneous cures
have been reported, infection may persist for
months, years, or decades in untreated individu-als.t’17
PATHOGENESIS/PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
The exact manner in which dermatophytic infec-tion of the scalp becomes established is not known. Fallen hairs, scale, and shared fomites (combs, brushes, hats) have been implicated in the trans-mission of fungal elements.7 Human inoculation
studies performed in the 1950s using Microsporum
sp have elucidated some features of tinea capitis. From the site of initial infection, hyphae spread in
a radial fashion and penetrate surrounding hair
follicles. The hyphae may then infect the
keratin-ized portions ofthe hair. During this process, spores are formed within the hair shaft (endothrix infec-tion) or on the surface of the hair shaft (ectothrix
infection))#{176}” Spore formation within the hair in
endothrix infection results in significant weakening
of the hair shaft with subsequent fracture of the
hair at the scalp line. The remnant of hair within the follicle is the so-called “black-dot,” the hallmark of infection by T tonsurans. Dermatophytes prefer actively growing (anagen) hairs; hence, resting (tel-ogen) hairs are relatively immune from infection.
The hair bulb is usually spared after eradication of infection, and hair regrowth usually occurs.
CLINICAL PRESENTATIONS
The clinical presentation of tinea capitis caused by T tonsurans varies substantially from that due
to Microsporum infection. Children with
Micros-porum tinea capitis often exhibit well-defined areas
of alopecia and the diagnosis is aided by hair shaft
fluorescence on exposure to ultraviolet light
(Wood’s lamp). T tonsurans tinea capitis does not fluoresce. In addition, T tonsurans tinea capitis is often more subtle in its appearance. Several pat-terns of infection may be observed.
Seborrheic
Patients with T. tonsurans tinea capitis may
complain of dandruff. The diffuse scaling and as-sociated pruritus may mimic atopic or seborrheic dermatitis of the scalp.18 Diffuse and progressive hair loss may occur after long-standing infection.
In Microsporum infections, well-circumscribed
pat-terns of hair loss are more typical. Fine, white scale
throughout the scalp of a 9-year-old girl with T
tonsurans infection is shown in Fig 1. There had
been slow, progressive, generalized hair loss over a
period
of months.
A more
subtle
presentation
with
only limited involvement of the scalp is shown in
Fig 2.
Black Dot
The black dot is the hallmark of infection by T
tonsurans (Fig 3). These hair remnants within the
follicular orifice may be the only manifestation of
fungal disease and may be hidden beneath scale.
The black dots may be few in number and difficult to find, but they are the most reliable source of material for diagnosis.
Kerion
Any patient with tinea capitis may develop a
kerion. Kerions are erythematous, boggy, tender
masses with perifollicular pustules which develop
rapidly on the scalp (Fig 4). They may be
accom-panied
by systemic
manifestations
including
fever,
neutrophils and that bacterial cultures are sterile.19
Our experience is that secondary infection with
bacteria, especially Staphylococcus aureus is com-mon. Antibiotic treatment alone, however, does not result in resolution of the kerion.
Kerions represent an immune response to the
dermatophyte and often herald the resolution of
the infection. Rasmussen and Ahmed2#{176} found that
36 patients with noninflammatory tinea capitis had intradermal tests negative to trichoptiytin antigen
at 48 hours in contrast to 15/16 patients with
kerions who manifested delayed hypersensitivity reactions. This finding suggests that, in those pa-tients with kerions, cellular immunity was involved in kerion formation.
Patients with any of the forms of T tonsurans tinea capitis may concurrently exhibit tinea cor-poris, lesions of fungal infection elsewhere on the skin. Such lesions are circular or oval scaling
plaques with erythematous papular-pustular
bor-ders (Fig 5).
DIAGNOSIS
The Wood’s lamp (an ultraviolet or “black light” with a spectrum of 320 to 400 nm) has been a useful tool in the diagnosis of tinea capitis because mem-bers of the genus Microsporum produce substances that accumulate in infected hairs and fluoresce when exposed to ultraviolet light. Patients with
tinea capitis caused by Microsporum sp can be
rapidly and accurately examined for the presence of infection using this procedure. Unfortunately fluorescence is not a characteristic of T tonsurans,
and a Wood’s lamp examination is of no value in
the diagnosis of T tonsurans infection.
Specimens obtained from the scalp are useful for the diagnosis of tinea capitis. The black dot offers the highest yield for both potassium hydroxide
(KOH) preparation and fungal culture. Using a
magnifying glass, one may identify black dot hairs and remove them easily and painlessly using forceps or a needle. The small hair fragment is then trans-ferred to a glass slide for a KOH preparation or to appropriate media for fungal culture. Scale from the scalp may also be useful for diagnosis. This may
be obtained by gently scraping the scalp with a
glass slide or scalpel blade or by brushing vigorously with a sterile toothbrush. The material is collected on a glass slide or sterile Petri dish for subsequent
KOH preparation or transfer to culture medium.
Direct inoculation of toothbrush bristles onto agar may be useful.45’15 Although hairs long enough to
be pulled are not infected in T tonsurans tinea
capitis, spores or hyphae may be present at their base. Thus, several hairs pulled from the scalp in an area of scaling (using a small Kelly clamp that has the teeth covered with rubber tubing for greater
traction) may be useful for diagnostic purposes.
The KOH preparation is useful for the rapid
diagnosis of tinea capitis. The specimen is placed on a glass slide, one or two drops of a 10% to 209 solution of KOH is added and a coverslip applied.
The slide may be briefly heated over a flame or
allowed to remain at room temperature for 15 to 20 minutes. Either process allows the KOH to dissolve cellular material, leaving the hyphae and spores
more easily identifiable. Heating too vigorously will
result in crystallization of the KOH, thus making
interpretation more difficult. A black dot hair with intrapiliary hyphae and spores is shown in Fig 6. The endothrix hyphae of T tonsurans characteris-tically line up in parallel arrays within the hair shaft. The transverse septae produce compact, rec-tangular arthrospores. When densely infected, the hair shaft may be replaced by such spores.
Individ-ual spores, often in short chains, can be seen on
keratin debris obtained by scraping the scalp (Fig
7). Altering the focal plane of the microscope will
cause the fungal elements to appear alternately
refractile or blue-green.
Fungal culture provides a definitive diagnosis and
should be performed in all patients suspected of
having tinea capitis. Specimens employed in
cul-tures are identical with those used for the KOH
preparation: black dots, scale, and pulled hairs.
Specimens may be inoculated directly onto the me-dium or may be transported to the laboratory in a sterile Petri dish or between glass slides. Sabour-aud’s agar, containing chloramphenicol and
cyclo-heximide (Mycosel or Mycobiotic agar) which
re-duce the growth of bacteria and saprophytic fungi, is the medium of choice. Specimens are inoculated
onto the surface of the medium and the caps of
slant tubes are left loose to permit air entry. Growth generally occurs within 1 to 2 weeks at room
tern-perature and the fungus may be identified by
mi-croscopic examination of a fungal colony. A typical culture of T tonsurans on Mycobiotic agar is shown
in Fig 8. This demonstrates the buff-tan, folded,
suede surface and the deep brown pigmented
un-derside. Dermatophyte Test Medium (DTM)
con-tains antibiotics (gentamicin sulfate and chlortet-racycline HC1), an agent to control saprophytic fungi (cyclohexamide), and a phenol red indicator.
Growing dermatophytes produce alkaline
byprod-ucts which cause the medium to change from its
original yellow color to red.2’ This facilitates the identification of dermatophytes by nonmycologists but makes species identification more difficult. Be-cause some saprophytic fungi or bacteria may con-taminate the culture and produce a color change, false-positive reactions may occur. Such reactions are seen in approximately 3% ofall cultures.22
pr
I .
Fig 2.
. .
.
..
-.
.,.,‘- -. . ,.. .
.. . : ..
..
.
... . .
, . 1’ ,
. .
.
-.“,..‘ .
.. ‘
.
‘-‘ v
\:
-1
Fig 3.
Fig 1. Seborrheic form of T tonsurans tinea capitis in 9-year-old black girl. Widespread areas of fine, white
adherent scale and diffuse hair loss are present.
Fig 2. More limited form of T tonsurans tinea capitis in 6-year-old male sibling of patient in Fig 1.
Fig 3. Characteristic “black dots” (arrows) of T tonsur-ans infection within areas of hair loss in this 3-year-old black girl. Each black dot represents an infected hair
,r
.
., ,..,.r
. .
.
‘..
ii F
h
shaft that has broken off at level of scalp surface.
Fig 4. Kerion, acute inflammatory reaction to scalp in-fection with T tonsurans, over occiput of 2-year-old black
boy. Lesion is tender, boggy, erythematous, oozing, and
crusted with numerous pustules. Regional
Fig5. Fig 6.
1
Fig 7.
4’, - ,.
C- . . ,
Fig 8.
Fig 5. Girl with T tonsurans tinea capitis with irregular annular plaque with papular border and scaly surface characteristic of body ringworm (tinea corporis).
Fig 6. Photomicrograph of KOH preparation of black
dot showing elongated hyphae within shaft of infected hair (endothrix infection). Hair is beginning to dissolve because of 10% KOH. Each hypha is breaking up into characteristic arthrospores (x620).
Fig 7. Photomicrograph of KOH preparation of scalp
rapidly than saprophytic fungi, interpretation of
DTM cultures at 1 or 2 weeks may eliminate some
false-positive results.1#{176}
When the diagnosis of tinea capitis is made,
family members and close contacts should be
ex-amined. These individuals, although asymptomatic, may exhibit signs of early infection such as mild scaling of the scalp. Early recognition and therapy may reduce morbidity and decrease spread of infec-tion.
scale from patient with tinea capitis showing arthrospores of T tonsurans in chains, clumps, and as single elements (x620).
Fig 8. Fungal cultures of T torisurans grown at room temperature showing characteristic morphology. Top of colony (left) is tan to buff-colored with suede, folded surface whereas underside (right) exhibits brown pig-ment. Cultures are on slants of Sabouraud’s agar with cyclohexamide and chioramphenicol (Mycobiotic agar).
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Scaling and pruritus of the scalp may be seen in disorders such as psoriasis and atopic or seborrheic dermatitis. Bacterial folliculitis with pustules and
inflammation may be confused with a kerion. In
Morphea may also be seen with an isolated patch of alopecia. Finally, trichotillornania (compulsive hair pulling) also results in areas of alopecia a!-though the scalp itself is not affected.
THERAPY
Systemic griseofulvin is the drug of choice for the treatment of tinea capitis. Topical therapy alone is not curative. Griseofu!vin is active against all
spe-cies of Trichophvton and Microsporum and inhibits
funga! mitosis by disrupting the mitotic spindle. Because it does not affect the resting spores, the
drug is primarily fungistatic, although in actively
metabolizing hyphae it may prove fungicidal.
Gris-eofulvin is also reported to have a direct
anti-inflammatory activity although the mechanism of
this effect is not known.2t
Griseofu!vin is available in microsize and ultra-microsize forms. Use of the ultramicrosize prepa-ration allows the dose to be reduced by 50%, but there is no evidence of increased efficacy or fewer side effects. The dose is determined by the prepa-ration’s particle size and the patient’s body weight
(Table 3). A suspension containing 125 mg of the
microsize particle form in each 5 mL (Grifulvin V, Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp) is available for
pedi-atric use. Absorption of the drug is reported to
increase when the drug is given with a meal, partic-ularly one high in fat content.24’25 Although the optimal dosing schedule has not yet been
deter-mined, most manufacturers recommend daily
ad-ministration in single or divided doses. Some
stud-ies suggest that resolution of infection may be
achieved with less frequent administration.
How-ever, efficacy of a less frequent dose remains to be
confirmed in children with T tonsurans tinea
capi-tis. Most infections can be controlled with a dosage
of 10 mg/kg of body weight per day of the microsize
TABLE 3. Griseofulvin Preparations (1982)
Particle Size and Dose Products Available
Microsize Grifulvin V*_suspension
Child: 10 mg/kg/d 125 mg/5 mL, tablets
Adult: 500- 1,000 mg/d 250, 500 mg
Fulvicin-U/Ft-tablets
250, 500 mg
Grisactin-capsules 125,
250 mg; tablets 500 mg
Ultramicrosize Fulvicin P/Gt-tablets
Child: 5 mg/kg/d 165, 330 mg
Adult: 250-500 mg/d Grisactin Ultra-tablets 125, 250 mg
Gris-PEG-tablets 125,
250 mg
* Ortho Pharmaceutical Corp. 1 Schering Corp.
1:
Ayerst Laboratories.§
Dorsey Laboratories.preparation taken for a 6- to 8-week period. In
resistant cases, both the dose and the duration of therapy may be increased. Following initiation of therapy, patients should be seen at 3-week intervals to evaluate clinical progress. At each visit, a repeat fungal culture is performed; treatment is continued until a negative culture is obtained.
There are potential adverse effects associated with griseofulvin therapy. As many as 15% of adult
patients may experience headache, which is often reversible despite continued therapy. Rare hema-tologic alterations such as neutropenia and
leuko-penia have been observed although these have
sometimes resolved during the treatment course.
Hepatotoxic reactions have been recognized and
griseofulvin is contraindicated in patients with
hep-atocellular damage or porphyria. Other reported
adverse reactions include proteinuria,
photosensi-tivity, urticaria, as well as disturbances of the CNS and gastrointestinal tract. Despite these potential adverse effects, the incidence of serious reactions is low.24’25 Manufacturers suggest that hematologic, hepatic, and renal function be monitored periodi-cally during treatment. The standard of practice by many dermatologists suggests that in otherwise
healthy individuals such monitoring may not be
necessary.26 Clinical studies are needed to assess the nature and frequency of adverse effects, if any,
during griseofulvin therapy in children.
Ketocona-zole is a relatively new antifungal agent currently being used for systemic mycoses. It has not yet been
approved for use in dermatophyte infections such as tinea capitis. Recent reports of severe hepato-toxic reactions during therapy may limit its poten-tial use to the rare griseofulvin-resistant cases.27
A variety of adjunctive agents are available for use in tinea capitis and although not curative alone may prove valuable when combined with oral gris-eofulvin. Topical antifungal agents such as clotri-mazole, haloprogin, and miconazole nitrate are of-ten employed in an attempt to control surface fun-gal elements and reduce infectivity. These products are applied twice daily; consequently, their use may
prove expensive during prolonged therapy.
Re-cently, Allen et a!28 compared the efficacy of
ad-junctive agents and found that shampooing twice
weekly with selenium sulfide lotion 2.5% (Selsun Brown, Exsel) was more effective in decreasing the duration of positive fungal cultures in children with
T tonsurans tinea capitis than either clotrimazole or shampooing with a bland preparation.
Although generally not required, oral or
intrale-sional steroid therapy may hasten the resolution of
severe kerions and possibly prevent scarring.19 In patients with persistent alopecia following kerion
resolution, hair transplantation may be considered.
epilate, thus removing the substrate for infection.
Recent studies have demonstrated that patients
treated with roentgenography have an increased
incidence of benign and malignant tumors of the
head and neck.2Bf This therapeutic measure has
now been abandoned.
SUMMARY
In recent years, T tonsurans has become the
leading cause of tinea capitis in the United States.
Accompanying the increased importance of this
organism have come changes in the clinical pres-entation of the disease. The subtle signs and symp-toms and insidious course of this disease require that clinicians be aware of the multiple clinical presentations if a correct diagnosis is to be made. Early therapy with griseofulvin and topical agents will reduce morbidity and infectivity.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank Ortho Pharmaceutical Corporation, Raritan, NJ, for supporting the cost of the color repro-ductions.
REFERENCES
1. Rudolph AH, Rosen T, Friedman L, et al: Tinea capitis, in
Demis DJ, Dobson RL, McGuire J (eds): Clinical
Dermatol-ogy. Philadelphia, Harper and Row, 1982, Chap 17-6, pp
1-23
2. Terreni AA: Tinea capitis survey in Charleston, SC. Arch Dermatol 1961;83:88-91
3. Grin El: A controlled field trial in Yugoslavia of the efficacy of griseofulvin in the mass treatment of tinea capitis. Bull
WHO 1962;26:797-821
4. Gaisin A, Holzwanger JM, Leyden JJ: Endothrix tinea cap-itis in Philadelphia.
mt
J Dermatol 1977;16:188-1905. Rudolph AH: The clinical recognition of tinea capitis from
Trichophyton tonsurans, editorial. JAMA 1979;242:1770 6. Pipkin JL: Tinea capitis in the adult and adolescent. Arch
Dermatol 1952;66:9-40
7. Rippon JW: Medical Mycology. Philadelphia, WB Saunders and Co, 1974, pp 96-1 16
8. Prevost E: Nonfluorescent tinea capitis in Charleston, SC.
JAMA 1979;242:1765-1767
9. Joseph HL, Halde C: Tinea capitis due to Trichophyton tonsurans. Arch Dermatol 1955;83:371-375
10. Kligman AM: The pathogenesis of tinea capitis due to
Microsporum audouini and Microsporum conic: I. Gross observations following the inoculation of humans. J Invest
Dermatol 1952;18:231-246
1 1. Kligman AM: Tinea capitis due to M audouini and M canis:
II. Dynamics of the host-parasite relationship. Arch I)er-matol 1955;71:313-337
12. Livingood CS, Pillsbury DM: Ringworm of the scalp: Pro-longed observation, family investigation, cultural and
im-munologic studies in 130 cases. J Invest Dermatol
19414:43-57
13. Laur WE: Spotaneous cure of tinea capitis due to Micros-porum audouini. Arch Dermatol 195 1;64:364-366
14. Whittle CH: Is scalp ringworm in children a self-limiting disease? Lancet 1953;2:10-12
15. Friedman L, Derbes VJ, Hodges EP: The course of untreated tinea capitis in negro children. J Invest I)ermatol 1964;
42:237-242
16. Seale ER, Richardson JB: Trichophvton tonsurans: A follow-up of treated and untreated cases. Arch I)ermatol
1960;81:87-94
17. Warm RP: Persistent Trichophvton tonsurans infection. Br
,JDermatol 1977;97(suppl 15):48-49
18. Honig PJ, Smith LR: Tinea capitis masquerading as atopic or seborrheic dermatitis. J Pediatr 1979;94:604-605
19. Esterly NB: Fungal infections in children. Pediatr Ret’
1981;3:41-49
20. Rasmussen JE, Ahmed AR: Trichophyton reactions in chil-dren with tinea capitis. Arch Dermatol 1978;114:371-372
21. Taplin D, Zaias N, Rebell G, et al: Isolation and recognition ofdermatophytes on a new medium (DTM). Arch I)ermatol
1969;99:203-209
22. RockoffAS: Fungus cultures in a pediatric outpatient clinic.
Pediatrics 1979;63:276-278
23. D’Arcy PF, Howard EM, Muggleton PW, et al: The anti-inflammatory action of griseofulvin in experimental ani-mals. ,J Pharm Pharmacol 1960;12:659-665
24. Sande ME, Mandell GL: Antimicrobial agents, in Gilman AG, Goodman LS, Gilman A (eds): The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics. New York, Macmillan, 1980, pp
1237-1238
25. AMA Department of Drugs: AMA Drug Evaluations.
Chi-cago, AMA, 1980, pp 1360-1362
26. Friedman L, Derbes VJ, Tromovitch TA: Single dose ther-apy of tinea capitis. Arch Dermatol 1960;82:415-418
27. Jones HE: Ketoconazole, editorial. Arch Dermatol 1982; 118:217-219
28. Allen HB, Honig PJ, Leyden JJ, et a!: Selenium sulfide: Adjunctive therapy for tinea capitis. Pediatrics 1982;69:81-83
29. Shore RE, Albert RE, Pasternack BS: Follow-up study of patients treated by x-ray epilation for tinea capitis. Arch Environ Health 1976;31:21-28
30. Ron E, Modan B: Benign and malignant thyroid neoplasms after childhood irradiation for tinea capitis. JNCI 1980;65: