PSP BUYER‘S GUIDE 2011
INSIGHTS IN THE WORLDWIDE ONLINE PSP MARKET
Authors
The Paypers
Ionela Barbuta, Monica Gaza, Mihaela Mihaila, Adriana Screpnic, Cosmin Turcu
Release
Version 1.0
October 2011
Copyright © The Paypers BV
All rights reserved
INTRODUCTION
You are reading the PSP Buyer‗s Guide 2011, the most complete and up-to-date reference source for online
PSP (Payment Services Provider) related information at global level. This guide is published once a year by
The Paypers, the leading independent source of news and analyses for professionals in the payment industry.
The market is constantly moving with numerous new developments in the online payments space and so are
we. The PSP Buyer‘s Guide has rapidly captured the attention of service providers, payment professionals
and web merchants who have the necessary technical and/or operational expertise to bring the industry to a
new competitive level. This independent guide has been designed to function as a solid reference point for all.
E-commerce has long been heralded as having the potential to act as an engine for new revenue growth. But
at present, cross-border e-commerce is far from being utilized to a full extent, or at least this is what statistics
so far suggest. It is universally acknowledged that online fraud is the main inhibiting factor and much of the
recent discussion in online retail is indeed around fraud prevention. Solutions are constantly being proposed
and these range from the development of fraud protection services to strong calls to action towards the
industry to come up with more efficient e-payment services which are less sensitive to fraud, have more cross
border reach and lead to more sales conversion.
Web merchants have started to articulate their demands, while online consumers hold privacy dear and the
lack of confidence in both the merchants and the online payment options they use are still hurdles to be
overcome. In this context, where banks struggle with innovation delivery, payment service providers need to
constantly re-examine the basis on which they deliver customer propositions. They do offer as many payment
options as possible, but do merchants/buyers actually need all of them? After all, the merchant`s online
business depends on the service and reliability they provide.
Building on last year‘s successful first edition, this year‘s edition with a global focus has been expanded
substantially.
The first part of our overview presents some general developments in e-commerce, online payments and the
persistent problem of fraud, voiced by key industry stakeholders. This section includes key facts and trends on
the industry on behalf of the Merchant Risk Council, the merchant-led trade association focused on electronic
commerce risk and payments globally and also insights into the European online payments space, by Wijnand
Jongen, CEO of Thuiswinkel.org, advocating the European E-Payments Merchant Initiative on behalf of major
cross-border European web retailers and their representative e-commerce member organizations.
In the second part, various global PSPs express their thought leadership, with a particular focus on
developments regarding fraudsters, risk management, maximizing conversion strategies for merchants and
how the opening of the BRIC markets influence their strategy.
In the third part, driven by popular demand from players who have helped shape the industry‘s development,
the PSP Buyer‘s Guide 2011 now provides state-of-the-art information on over 300 online PSPs all over the
world.
With this guide we hope to provide all parties involved in online payments processes with a clear insight into
the dynamic and competitive PSP market.
Finally, this document has been written with the utmost care. If you discover that, despite our efforts, it
contains information that is unclear or erroneous, we would appreciate it if you would let us know.
Chiel Liezenberg,
Partner, Innopay
Adriana Screpnic,
Nicolas Vedrenne, Managing Director, Merchant Risk Council Europe
Near the turn of the millennium, as the internet was opening new markets and e-commerce was beginning
its rapid growth, a group of merchants joined together to form the Merchant Risk Council (MRC) as a way
to increase networking and education among merchants to better enable them to successfully fight online
fraud (3.6% of total online revenues in 2000). Today, with members representing over 300 member
companies across the globe, the MRC not only continues to provide a platform for education and
discussion, but acts as an advocate for e-commerce merchants, providing a unified voice for improving the
industry as a whole. The MRC delivers year-round programming that empowers its members with the
knowledge and tools to succeed in the online payment, security, and risk industries of today, as well as
tomorrow.
Nicolas Vedrenne developed his career in France, UK, Latin America and Spain with Société Générale,
Sema Group and Monext, specializing in payment systems, fraud prevention, risk management and credit
bureaux. In 1999, he took the responsibility of several Experian businesses as President Hispano America
and CEO Spain. A passionate advocate of cross cultural understanding, and after a 2 years round the
world trip, Nicolas Vedrenne was involved in the selection process of Madrid as a candidate city for the
2016 Olympic Games. He wrote a book on “change and business transformation” and he is a
co-founder of 1x1microcredit.org, an NGO project specializing in microcredit.
The MRC is …
the world‘s foremost global, non-profit, merchant-led trade association focused on managing
payments, preventing online fraud and promoting secure e-commerce.
The current state of online retailing is…
booming. Retailers are entering new countries where growth in online
retailing is a bright spot in sluggish national economies. Cross Atlantic e-commerce as well as roll-out into the BRIC
countries are now key components of our members‘ e-payment strategies. Large players are jumping into
cross-border operations but often meet new challenges that require a full re-thinking of their payment operations. It is not
unusual to see a multinational with a British website, a Dutch logistics center, an American PSP, a Romanian fraud
prevention team and a call center in the Philippines selling to… a Russian customer. As a result, although fraud is
down in percentage to 0.9% of online revenues, 54% of our members report an increase in fraud pressure and
21% are observing more complex fraud schemes this year.
PSPs can help merchants reduce costs and generate more revenue by …
listening more to the merchant
community, a positive trend observed in recent years. The sector has moved from a rigid product offering to
customizable solutions, mainly because of a better understanding of the payment landscape by merchants.
Traditional card brands are also improving their willingness to talk directly with merchants and a better collaboration
with PSPs has been critical for new product development. In particular, the MRC takes note and encourages
acquirers to enhance the amount of data and analysis available when it comes to chargeback management. New
niche players are also emerging with highly efficient technologies. Device fingerprint analysis is a good example,
“Traditional card brands are also improving their willingness to talk directly with merchants and
a better collaboration with PSPs has been critical for new product development.”
As a conclusion, with 34% of players expecting to
increase their budget for fraud management and
65% focusing on improving automated detection
and sorting capabilities in 2011, the merchant
sector clearly deserves full attention from PSPs.
In the online world, online transaction fraud is
one of the greatest challenges for web
merchants. What connections, if any, do you
see between the use of different payment
methods and the amount of fraud?
Employing different payment methods does not
necessarily produce a higher risk in itself but rather
a higher complexity in payment and fraud
prevention management. Simple convergence is
not a likely solution as consumers will always want
to have the choice when it comes to paying over
the web. Offering different payment methods is a
very critical aspect of a successful checkout process for our merchants. Amongst new trends, large players adapt
their checkout screen depending on the country the consumer is located in or charge the consumer a premium if
the operation is flagged as risky with a specific payment method.
Merchants also monitor carefully the balance between risk and sales transaction completion rate. An example is
the adoption of 3D secure authentication by consumers: some cultures adopted it very quickly; others are
struggling and find it invasive. The MRC recommendation is to have merchants customize their own strategies as
every business is different. So far, complex mandatory regulations have proven unsuccessful in countries where
they were tested.
In your opinion, what are the most common types of fraud in the financial ecosystem and the best ways to
mitigate them?
The shape of fraud is changing. From the friendly fraud observed at the beginning of 2000, we are moving to a
more organized type of fraud. Massive data and security breaches have been observed recently. This
organizedcrime is more complex to tackle as stolen payment and identity data are then sold over the internet,
ending up being used by non-frequent / first time fraudsters. So nowadays, a typical fraud case would involve a
large criminal organization taking over a large amount of data and a soft fraudster/customer using this data for his
personal benefit. For solutions, the MRC observes that specific tactics and tools typically lose their effectiveness
after about 18 months as fraudsters adapt their operations. This is why merchants understand the importance of
having multiple tools supported by excellent analytic skills. Our benchmarking surveys show that, on average, large
merchants use a combination of over 8 detection tools/ techniques.
“The MRC observes that specific tactics and tools typically lose their effectiveness after about
18 months as fraudsters adapt their operations. This is why merchants understand the
importance of having multiple tools supported by excellent analytic skills.”
Are certain sectors that have online revenue streams particularly susceptible to fraud, as compared to
others?
We divide the e-commerce ecosystem into 4 categories: travel and ticketing, online gaming and gambling, physical
goods and digital content. But unfortunately fraudsters operate across these sectors. Services for immediate
consumption are heavily targeted but physical goods, with a higher value, are also attractive to fraudsters.
Therefore the real need is to understand the impact of fraud on the merchant‘s business. For physical goods or
travel, there is a big loss in goods/services. For digital goods, the focus is more on the loss of potential revenue.
The true cost of fraud is the combination of the loss of goods or revenue + the cost of the fraud prevention tools
and teams + the amount of good business transactions not accepted as a result of a false positive analysis. MRC
merchants reject an average of 2.6% of orders due to suspicion of fraud. That latest aspect attracts a lot of
attention lately as rejected transactions can be the source of legitimate business and can be turned into a revenue
generator.
Chargebacks represent a big hurdle for e-commerce merchants and online business owners. In your
opinion, how can they be prevented?
In 2011, 45% of the typical MRC merchant‘s fraud losses
came from chargebacks. But the recovery rate increased
from 25% in 2009 to 41% in 2011 due to better analytics
and to a higher rate of representation. Large players
have better automation of their chargeback operations
but manual review staff still represents the largest part of
fraud prevention costs (44% of suspicious transactions
are reviewed manually) which causes some concerns
from top management when it comes to budgets.
Therefore, a careful analysis of the balance between
manual review supported by powerful data and
automated tools is the best way to prevent chargebacks.
As mobile commerce becomes more popular, are there unique security concerns associated strictly with
the mobile channel? Or is it affected by the same security issues as e-commerce?
There are no clear trends when it comes to mobile payment. Apart from micro-payments such as Premium SMS for
very specific sectors, the mobile device is mainly used as a web browser and payment solutions are ―as if‖ on a pc.
But yes, there is an additional layer of security concerns: apart from the possibility of the device being stolen,
mobile devices are more vulnerable to infection and consumers are still on a learning curve: for example, most
mobile users have Bluetooth activation without password protection. It is therefore possible to infect many devices
with spyware in a small amount of time. Therefore the concern is more on how to protect the data that could
potentially reside in the mobile device. Last but not least, the traditional fraud prevention systems using
geo-“Payments and fraud prevention are areas in which merchants have a common interest and
they should learn from their counterparts (as fraudsters do!).”
Is interoperability between online authentication solutions possible?
Although this is a trendy topic, we do not think that this is a panacea. Past experiences have shown that there is no
ideal solution. In addition, recent developments in security breach, cyber-mafias, and account take-overs mean that
interoperability could lead to more risk by concentrating on a single set of data in a unique system/environment.
Interoperability may be an improvement for consumer convenience, providing it is user friendly, but not necessarily
good for fraud prevention. Tokenization is also a potential improvement along those lines. Finally, some
government initiatives are being reviewed but the MRC would suggest a close cooperation with the merchant
community to ensure proper implementation as well as more interaction with consumers to encourage adoption.
Directions of development for online fraud
prevention systems: what does the industry lack
and where should improvements be made?
There are tools such as data sharing that could be
very effective for crime prevention. As proven over the
past decade in national banking systems with Credit
Reference Agencies, exchanging data on fraudsters is
key for crime prevention and the technology exists.
However, the cross-border nature of e-commerce is
not compatible with most of the national Data
Protection Laws in place and international regulations
are
still limited on the matter. Therefore, the merchant community should encourage governments to unlock the power
of technology by carrying out a proper review of the sector and e-crime associated with it. Law enforcement,
currently under-resourced, could also benefit from this next step in its prosecution duties as shown in the US.
Finally, all stakeholders of the ecosystem should increase their level of collaboration and experience sharing.
Payments and fraud prevention are areas in which merchants have a common interest and they should learn from
their counterparts (as fraudsters do!). Is it the most efficient approach? MRC members who collaborate on a
regular basis on fraud prevention with other industry members have reported an average of 33% lower revenue
loss due to online payment fraud over the past three years, with chargeback rates 24% lower and manual reviews
three times lower than similar merchants.
Wijnand Jongen, CEO of Thuiswinkel.org
Thuiswinkel.org is the branch association for businesses that sell products and services to consumers (b-to-c) via
the internet, catalogues and/or the post. The association promotes the interests of its members both nationally and
internationally.
In addition, Thuiswinkel.org also strongly attaches considerable importance to the interests of the consumers that
purchase from its members. Wijnand Jongen has been for 10 years the CEO of Thuiswinkel.org, the association for
the online e-commerce industry in the Netherlands, serving 1300 plus web merchants. Thuiswinkel.org took the
lead in the E-Payments Merchant Initiative, uniting European merchant interests via major cross border web
merchants and 7 other e-commerce organizations from Belgium (Becommerce), France (Fevad), Germany (BvH),
Denmark (FDIH), UK (IMRG), Finland (Verkkateollissuus), Sweden (Distancehandel).
E-commerce development
In the past 15 years e-commerce has become a mature market and is still growing. This trend is expected to
continue in the coming years due to the further proliferation of mobile devices (smartphones, tablets) and the trend
of consumers being ‗always online‘. Following this market success, e-commerce payments have seen a
tremendous development in the past decade. Cards have become today‘s most important online payment methods
in most countries and will continue to be so for the foreseeable future. However, cards have important product
flaws when used for web transactions since ‗cards were never designed for the web‘. The customer is not
physically present with his card, therefore e-commerce payments are known as Card Not Present (CNP)
transactions. Without the card present, the main flaw for (credit) cards as a means of payment is their vulnerability
to fraud. There are alternatives for cards, but these have their own flaws, mainly fragmentation and a lack of user
friendliness. These imperfections affect merchants and consumers strongly and threaten trust online.
For the payment world these imperfections bring opportunities to create new more efficient methods to consumers
and merchants. Many positive developments have taken place to optimize payments for the web. Innovation has
seen traditional payment methods come under pressure as consumers and merchants migrate to more convenient
and efficient and secure payment methods. However the journey is far from complete and does create operational
issues for merchants who have to operate within this complex market. The online industry (both merchants and
providers of financial services) should listen more carefully to consumer needs if we want to maintain growth as we
did the past decade. In the next paragraph, I will highlight some of the most pressing customer needs. The last part
is dedicated to four trends that, in my belief, will shape the next phase in e-commerce payments.
Consumer needs
Issues like the lack of confidence in online payment methods, privacy concerns and the lack of trust in the web
merchants form barriers for the growth of e-commerce. On a more practical level, they hinder conversion. It is in the
interest of the e-commerce sector to eliminate these barriers. Today‘s payment issues are numerous and it is not
obvious to categorize them in a practical and meaningful way. When we take the key barriers for e-commerce from
the EU‘s Digital Agenda we see the following issues:
“Each type of payment puts bespoke requirements on merchants in terms of usability, security
and functionality. Regarding payments this means consumers want more trust in online
payment methods.”
●
Lack of confidence in the online payment methods
●
Privacy concerns. For a consumer it is comprehensible that he should identify himself in order to enable the
delivery of goods or services online. However this should be able with providing the right set of personal data,
affecting the consumer‘s privacy as little as possible
●
Lack of trust in the web merchant. Consumers expect fair agreements, conditions and delivery, whether or not
supported by (international) trust marks.
We can safely conclude that trust is the critical factor. On top of this we see that future developments will impact
the need for new services. i.e. the rise of mobile devices. Each type of payment puts bespoke requirements on
merchants in terms of usability, security and functionality.
Regarding payments this means consumers want more trust in online payment methods. Consumer needs and
autonomous developments form three trends that will have an impact on e-commerce:
New banking payment services will be developed
A trend we will certainly see in the future is the development of new services that use the existing banking payment
schemes for online use. It might be a way for the banks to address the most urgent issue in payments that I
mentioned before. Bank payment schemes such as credit transfers and direct debits are core banking services
since payments became digital more than fifty years ago. Over time, every country around the world has developed
its own national standards and mechanisms. For a few years we now have SEPA within the European Union,
which aims to standardize these core banking payment services, including cards. The SEPA project (since 2002,
banking self-regulation) led to the introduction of the SEPA Credit Transfer (SCT) in 2008 and the introduction of
the SEPA Direct Debit (SDD) in 2009. The uptake of these new services by market and public sector has been
limited so far.
Therefore an end-date will be mandated by the European Commission, which will probably be 1st January 2013. It
is with these core banking products (credit transfer, direct debit) where merchants see the opportunity for new
payment developments when they would be made suitable for use on the web. One example is the SEPA Credit
Transfer which has no chargeback risk for merchants because the buyer initiates the payment through his own
bank. Since SCT is not designed for the web either, a new breed of payment method has come to market in
various countries across the globe, which is called Online Banking ePayments (OBeP). With OBeP in the checkout
process, the buyer is redirected from the merchant site to the site of his bank, where he authorizes the transaction
with his online banking credentials. The merchants receive a real-time payment guarantee as a result of this
authorization. Today OBeP services are not based on SEPA payments yet, but they can be made suitable for the
SEPA payments requirements.
A strong point for the OBeP category is that users are directed to their online banking environment. This
guarantees a high level of security, but is also familiar to the user and thereby enhances trust and ease of use. The
OBeP has a 90% market penetration in the Netherlands with similar systems in e.g. Germany (giropay), Austria
(eps), USA (Secure Vault Payments), Canada, Colombia and Poland, but very limited cross border reach. This
fragmented and non-interoperable landscape is not beneficial for the proliferation of this type of payments. The
“The development of new services that can enhance trust in the e-commerce market is a key
responsibility for the industry. If we succeed, I’m confident that e-commerce can sustain growth
and keep on serving consumers in the best possible way.”
initiative from a technical point of view. However, proper pricing models are still a decisive factor as well for
successful European proliferation of this category of payment services. OBeP systems based on SCT are a viable
alternative to cards because of the absence of chargeback risks. Therefore merchants want more cross-border
OBeP payment options, including an international solution while reducing fragmentation and optimizing the buyer
experience. Buyers should be able to pay internationally with their online bank credentials.
M-commerce develops rapidly
Only recently the mobile device (phone, tablet) has become a serious alternative to the PC when it comes to
e-commerce. However, because of the different user settings and screen sizes as well as the uncertainty of security
risks, not every online payment method is applicable for a mobile device. Payment methods and apps which are
optimized for mobile devices are developed which can be offered in a competitive fashion. This goes beyond the
native payment options of the app stores offered by the major platforms (Apple, Android, Blackberry etc.) and the
keying in of credit card details on a mobile device. E-commerce via mobile devices will also benefit from generic
e-authentication solutions: consumers can then re-use profile data stored elsewhere to reduce input on the device
itself. This will improve the shopping experience, hence increase conversion.
Online identity and authentication development
The last trend I would like to highlight is that of ‗online identity‘. Consumers have more and more online identities of
various natures. They vary from verified credentials (e.g. bank passes) to unverified credentials with stored
preferences (e.g. social media credentials; the expectations of ‗social sign in‘ are high amongst many marketers
and web merchants). Initiatives are developed to re-use these identities in the online commerce context, with
security levels that can be adapted to the risk or the value of the transaction (basic security for low value, high level
of security for higher values). There are many benefits, including the improvement of the security of cards, credit
transfers and direct debits. By using a similar international online identity solution for all payment types, the buyer
experience will be harmonized. This leads to a better experience, more trust and therefore more sales if
implemented in a way that the consumer‘s privacy is warranted.
Buyers can store profile information (address, name etc.) and disclose them to merchants of their choice. This
gives a merchant more certainty and leads to a better buyer experience (more conversion). All channels will benefit
as an online identity improves all shopping experiences. I.e. mobile screens are small and have small keyboards.
Using already stored online identity profiles will reduce the need for input by buyers and will therefore make the
mobile channel easier to use.
Exciting times for e-commerce payments
Overall we can conclude these are exciting times for e-commerce payments. We‘ve come a long way, but there are
still a lot of challenges. The development of new services that can enhance trust in the e-commerce market is a key
responsibility for the industry. If we succeed, I‘m confident that e-commerce can sustain growth and keep on
Adyen
Adyen: A next generation global Internet
Payment Service Provider
Adyen is a highly specialised International Payment
Service Provider working for large international
e-commerce companies. Adyen works with companies
that are based all over the world that are active in a
wide variety of industries. This gives a fascinating
insight into the major trends in the field of global
e-commerce.
Looking at what drives the larger, international
e-commerce companies, we have identified key trends
across the markets. In this article we would like to
outline these trends, and at the same time layout
Adyen's approach to helping merchants successfully
deal with these trends.
PCI Compliance
The pressure on merchants to be PCI Compliant
continues to grow year-on-year. Over the past year
we have again seen a number of data breaches
which further drives regulation in this field. It is
estimated that for medium sized merchants, being
compliant costs between USD 300.000 and USD
400.000. This explains why we see that the largest
e-commerce businesses are changing their payment
infrastructure to a completely outsourced solution.
As an illustration Adyen has gone live with a number
of airlines that have fully adopted the Adyen hosted
payment page model which relieves them fully from
PCI compliant responsibility.
True globalisation of e-commerce
Emerging markets are now mature and serious
markets. Some facts:
●
Average GDP growth in Latam is 4.4% vs 1.7%
in Europe
●
Internet penetration growth in Brazil and
Argentina is the fastest in the world
Where a few years ago everybody spoke about
doing business in emerging markets, today many
e-commerce companies are processing serious
volumes in these countries. Countries in Latin
America, most notably Brazil, are experiencing the
most growth. It's not only the global, experienced
e-commerce companies that are paving the way.
There is a highly dynamic market with many
successful domestic e-commerce businesses in
Brazil. For Adyen this has been the reason to open
offices in Sao Paolo during the past year.
Furthermore we have invested heavily in
―tropicalising‖ our payment platform for the local
Latin American markets. This means that we have
developed connections directly into the local
acquiring banks and have developed support for
processing credit card payments in installments – a
very common way of paying online in Latin America.
Local payment methods are also key, especially the
cash based ―boletos‖ are a requirement for this
region. Cash is still king...
Fraudsters never give-up
Here at Aden we are convinced that fraud will never
go away. This is what we are seeing throughout the
last few years. New authentication tools like 3D
Secure are by now quite well penetrated – especially
across the northern European countries. Fraud
continues to be at the top of the agenda for the large
players in e-commerce. Patterns continue to evolve,
fraud prevention tools need to follow...
Adyen runs a next generation Fraud Prevention Tool
which is highly customisable. We have helped
merchants reduce their fraud losses for up to 90%.
Last year Adyen has taken its own Device
Recognition Software live which in combination with
our self-learning fraud pattern recognition
technology provides the latest standard for Fraud
Control.
Conversion, Conversion, Conversion
A/B testing is now everyday business for any serious
e-commerce business. Ensuring that a consumer
has the most seamless and enjoyable checkout
process is the highest priority. For Adyen, making
sure our payment platform contributes to this goal is
one of our core priorities. This means that we
continuously measure and optimize the
effectiveness of our payment page solutions. This
gives very interesting insight along the way.
Did you know that:
●
Supporting 3D Secure in southern European
countries can still reduce conversion with
20%...
●
Processing credit cards in Spain with a local
Spanish acquirer can increase conversion with
25%...
●
Offering consumers a single-screen payment
page over a 3-page payment screen has shown
a 90% higher conversion rate....
Adyen's conversion analytics tool was designed to
provide merchants with ongoing insight into
conversion % across their markets.
The rise of the mobile sales channel
It was ten years ago when we saw the first WAP
payment solutions. Back then this was very much a
marketing gimmick. Today Adyen sees many
millions of transactions running through its payment
solution for iPhone and Android. These transactions
come from ticketing companies, online retailers and
group-buying business that all have very quickly
adopted the mobile sales channel. One of the
fascinating observations is that anytime an
established web retailer launches a mobile sales
channel, it almost instantly generates volume. It is
clear that the global consumer is ready and eager to
buy any product on a mobile.
Roelant Prins, CCO, Adyen
Adyen is the leading provider of global internet payment and e-commerce solutions for e-commerce merchants. Adyen‘s internet payment solution enables merchants to increase online conversion by optimizing the online payment process. This ―one-stop‖ solution can be implemented within days and connects companies to global customers through a growing offering of payment methods. For more information please visit
Chase Paymentech
Are You Getting The Best From Your Payments
Solution?
Merchants cannot afford to ignore the impact of
fraud and hidden costs associated with
e-commerce.
No matter what your industry, fraud is a part of it and
is clearly not going to diminish. In fact, in research
recently conducted by Chase Paymentech, 62% of
British mid-sized and large companies that handle
customer-not-present (CNP) payments lost money
through fraudulent transactions in the twelve months
up to March 2011
1.
With a long and successful history of working with
some of the world‘s largest e-commerce merchants,
we at Chase Paymentech believe that we have a
good understanding of merchants‘ fraud concerns.
We understand that in order to compete successfully
and maximize sales, e-commerce merchants need
solutions that filter fraud and encourage legitimate
shoppers to transact in a secure environment
without materially increasing headcount or costs.
In response to this need, Chase Paymentech has
developed an innovative suite of solutions designed
specifically to combat fraud utilizing continuous
transaction monitoring, a customizable rules engine
and advanced fraud detection technologies.
According to some merchants, Safetech
SMFraud
Tools have helped them to notably reduce their
chargebacks. In fact, one top internet retailer using
Safetech Fraud Tools has consolidated its fraud
review to a single full-time employee managing fraud
on more than 25,000 orders per day. Before a
transaction is completed, Safetech Fraud Tools are
at work determining the location and device
identification of your customer through custom
scripts run on your payment page. Once the
consumer completes the purchase, data is sent to
Chase Paymentech with the authorization request.
Chase Paymentech then sends this request to the
payment brands and receives an authorization
response that includes approval or decline, as well
as Address Verification Service (AVS) response
data. This data is routed through our Risk Inquiry
System, analyzed and checked against custom rules
that you may have implemented. A fraud score is
calculated and returned with the authorization
response. You may then choose to approve or
decline the transaction (or auto-decision based on
your custom rules).
The Chase Paymentech approach combines
multi-layer device fingerprinting, proxy piercing, dynamic
order linking, dynamic risk scoring, custom rules
management and auto-decisioning that together
provide a unique solution that can dramatically
enhance your current risk management activities.
Best of all, Safetech Fraud Tools can be used
effectively regardless of currency and payment
method, simplifying the cost and complexity of your
fraud management initiatives.
Looking ahead to the future, UK online sales are
predicted to rise 18% this year to a total value of GBP
69 billion
2. And yet, cart abandonment rates are said
to have risen to 88%, up from 75% in 2010
3.
Merchants are therefore behoved to ensure that they
have taken a strategic approach to payment
processing. Issues such as preventing a customer
from paying in their chosen currency or payment
method, a cumbersome payment process and not
offering the level of security and protection demanded
by consumers, all have the potential to lead to cart
abandonment.
Similarly, when implementing a multi-channel
approach, merchants should take time to review their
checkout process. For example, inputting a 16 digit
card number on a mobile phone may not be the most
convenient for your customer and forcing 3D Secure
may cause issues with some smartphones. There are
many ways that Chase Paymentech can help
merchants maximize conversation strategies and
sales opportunities through implementing a smart,
strategic payment process.
Currently, Chase Paymentech provides solutions to
merchants looking to trade in over 130 currencies
worldwide. Our strategic focus is influenced by a
number of variables including our merchants‘ strategy
and other opportunities for growth. As e-commerce
continues to grow globally, markets change. The
opening-up of the BRIC market represents a growing
e-commerce opportunity and one that we continue to
evaluate and assess.
Chase Paymentech‘s consultative approach provides
each client with a dedicated relationship manager who
works closely with that merchant to understand their
business, challenges, constraints and future growth
plans. This familiarity allows us to focus our expertise
on the issues of real concern to the individual
merchant.
As more and more merchants strive to reduce
operating costs and increase revenue in order to
compete profitably in today‘s price-sensitive market,
our focus remains on providing our clients with the
business intelligence and solutions needed to meet
their specific requirements. Client success has always
been our primary goal – and will remain so in the
coming year.
Notes:
(1) ―CNP Payments at Risk‖, independent market research conducted by Dynamic Markets on behalf of Chase Paymentech
(2) IMRG Capgemini: e-Retail Sales Index: January 2011 (3) Digital Trends: Shopping Cart Abandonment Rate: March 2011
Chase Paymentech Europe Limited, trading as Chase Paymentech, is a subsidiary of JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. (JPMC) and is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland. The information herein does not take into account individual client circumstances, objectives or needs and is not intended as a recommendation of a particular product or strategy to particular clients and any recipient of this document shall make its own independent decision. Information in this document has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but neither Chase
Paymentech Europe Limited nor any of its affiliates warrant the completeness or accuracy of the information contained herein. This document and the information provided herein may not be copied, published, or used, in whole or in part, for any purpose other than expressly authorised by Chase Paymentech Europe Limited. © 2011, Chase Paymentech Europe Limited. All rights reserved.
GlobalCollect
Fraud is not a local issue
One of the key challenges for web merchants and
e-commerce growth in general is mitigating online
fraud. Fraudsters have become more sophisticated
and built organized fraud networks across the world.
Guided by a knowledgeable Payment Service
Provider such as GlobalCollect, online merchants
can reduce fraud by offering alternative payment
options which inherently have a lower fraud risk, for
example real-time bank transfers.
The future of fraud prevention will largely depend on
further cooperation across Payment Service
Providers, merchants, financial institutions, security
experts, trade associations such as MRC, and local
law enforcement to accelerate the detection of fraud
and develop the appropriate counter measures. The
advent of mobile payments brings further challenges
related to this payment channel and related devices.
To help combat online crime, GlobalCollect‘s
scalable Fraud Screening Service features a range
of integrated fraud reduction tools from renowned
partners to maximize transaction safety prior to
payment authorization. These include customized
business rules, online account validation, neural
networks to detect suspicious patterns, IP
geolocation data to determine the real-world location
of a web visitor, pre-check for fraudulent use of
credit cards, and more.
GlobalCollect is also fully Payment Card Industry
Data Security Standards (PCI DSS) certified and an
active member of the PCI Security Standards
Council‘s Participating Organization program. Using
our Hosted Merchant Link solution allows you as a
merchant to design your checkout section in line
with your branding while letting GlobalCollect take
care of meeting compliance rules - such as PCI DSS
- regarding processing and storing sensitive data.
Safety in numbers: how to turn browsers into
buyers
Next to successful fraud mitigation, there is a
demonstrated correlation between the number of
localized payment methods offered and increased
customer conversion rates. Meaning, the more
locally preferred payment options you present, the
higher the chance your customers will not abandon
the checkout procedure. Two examples are
Germany, where credit card purchases accounted
for only 20% in 2010 and Russia, where cash
payments are still very popular. Good to know:
GlobalCollect offers an unrivalled portfolio of
international, local, and alternative payment
methods in almost 200 countries and 170
currencies. As part of its service portfolio,
GlobalCollect also offers currency conversion of
sales volumes collected in up to 150 local currencies
into a desired remittance currency. This enables you
as a merchant to conduct business online with fixed,
negotiated foreign exchange currency conversion
fees, leading to a reduced FX risk for globally
collected revenues. In turn, you can offer your
customers the convenience to pay in their domestic
currency – another conversion driver.
Implementing a winning payments strategy in
alliance with our clients
Depending on the analyst, you will see the forecast
for online payments grow from USD 700B to more
than USD 1T by the end of 2012. Mature markets
such as the US and EMEA will continue to show
very attractive growth rates but the prime growth will
clearly come from new and emerging markets in the
years to come. GlobalCollect‘s strategy for the next
12 months will be developed in close cooperation
with its online merchants to help grow their
e-commerce business across the world, including a
strong focus on:
Mobile payments - further development of
both enabling payments via mobile devices
(mobile interface) as well as using Premium
SMS/carrier billing
Vertical-specific fraud prevention
enhancements
Expanded product offering in emerging
markets
The rising star: BRIC markets
The so-called BRIC countries all show up to 50%
YoY growth figures in e-commerce and online
payment adoption so they offer tremendous
potential. That said, each BRIC country has its own
intricacies and is rapidly developing a local payment
culture combining best-of-breed and hybrid payment
methods – so one strategy will not ―fit all‖.
To seize opportunities in these markets and
maximize checkout conversion rates, merchants
need to offer local acquiring and alternative
payments - the latter alone can increase conversion
rates by up to 40%. Most of these alternative
payments require a local legal entity and local bank
account, adding a tremendous work load to your
operations, accounting, and legal departments.
Unless you as a merchant have the above capacity
and knowledge to set up your e-commerce business
in these markets, outsourcing is by far the best
solution. GlobalCollect has profound BRIC
experience plus extensive knowledge of the various
local market requirements, customer payment
preferences, and repatriation issues, as well as the
legal entities in place to help you tap into these
markets. Accordingly, GlobalCollect will continue to
grow its portfolio of alternative and local payment
methods alongside the relevant fraud screening
tools. Headquartered in the Netherlands to serve the
EMEA region, GlobalCollect also has offices in North
and Latin America and the Asia Pacific region to
consult clients interested in targeting BRIC markets
locally.
GlobalCollect is the world's premier Payment Service Provider of local e-payment solutions for international Customer Not-Present (CNP) channels such as internet, mail, and telephone orders, and specializes in a wide range of industries such as travel, retail, online gaming, financial services, telecommunications, publishing, portals, and digital content. Through a single-interface online payment platform, we offer access to an unrivalled portfolio of local and international payment methods in almost 200 countries, including all major credit and debit cards, direct debits, bank transfers, real-time bank transfers, eWallets, cash at outlets, prepaid methods, checks, and invoices. For more information please visit
Wirecard
How merchants maximize revenues and
simultaneously combat fraud
Merchants with cross-border operations are faced
with an ongoing challenge to manage fraud, no
matter whether they sell goods, travel services or
digital services. In the card-not-present area in
particular they have to realize that these fraud trials
often correlate with their chargeback rate. They
should not underestimate how this measurement
relates directly to their fraud rates.
That is why professional case management is the
most important goal. A stand-alone payment service
provider has to work very closely with one or more
acquiring banks with whom the merchant has a
contract. This is mostly lacking in terms of getting all
necessary information together properly.
New business intelligence tools which the Wirecard
Group provides enable shop operators to estimate
the effectiveness of the risk management strategy
that they employ. In addition, they also benefit from
the maximum amount of transparency on how
central fraud parameters develop over time. In
concrete terms, the new business intelligence tools
portray information to online retailers using
transparent graphs. This allows, for example,
changes in fraud parameters such as the
chargeback or fraud rate to be tracked over time.
If retailers use the Verified by Visa and MasterCard
SecureCode security methods, the card-issuing
bank is liable in the event of fraud. This reversal of
liability means that the retailer is only informed of
cases of fraud the in the event of a return debit.
Additional information, which can be provided as a
result of the close links between acquiring and
technical services within the Wirecard Group, gives
retailers a top-level view of the overall picture. This
end-to-end data allows the company to constantly
adjust its risk management. At the same time,
retailers ensure that they meet the card companies'
formal requirements with regard to permissible fraud
rates. The advantages are obvious: shop operators
have greater control of fraud as it occurs, thus
allowing them to optimize their revenues.
A risk management strategy should start by
analyzing each market-proofed payment solution
that merchants should offer in order to successfully
develop their business in each single country. Once
this has been done, a top-level view of how fraud
can be managed is required.
It goes without saying that preventing fraud before it
happens is the best option.
Wirecard`s solutions cover consumer identification
and credit rating, strategy management in
combination with fraud prevention methods and the
company‘s Fraud Prevention Suite provides
maximum protection against payment default. This
comprises fraud pattern analytics, rule and decision
management, fraud screening and pattern
(behaviour) detection, performance monitoring and
case management.
Despite the fact that we offer the world‘s leading
payment methods, we have already positioned our
company already in the BRIC area. What is more,
Wirecard not only meets customer-specific
requirements with its highly flexible and
customizable range of products and services. In
order to deploy and maintain tailored solutions and
features, we offer a set of professional services
spanning consulting, project management, business
and system analysis, implementation and quality
assurance, operations as well as customer support.
The sophisticated analysis features show the extent
to which rule-based fraud recognition impacts the
success of the business. We believe that this type of
overview will also be of interest to shop operators
who were previously skeptical about automated
tests.
Heiner Kallweit, Head of Product Line
Risk & Fraud Prevention
Wirecard AG is one of the leading international providers of electronic payment and risk management solutions. Worldwide, the Wirecard Group supports over 12,000 companies from a wide range of industry segments in automating their payment processes and minimizing cases of default. Wirecard Bank AG is a Principal Member of Visa, MasterCard and JCB and operates as a credit card acquirer in 69 countries around the world, involving over 100 transaction currencies and 18 payout currencies. Part of the Wirecard Group, Wirecard Bank provides innovative solutions in the fields of corporate banking, prepaid and co-branded cards, along with account products for both business and private customers. For more information please visit www.wirecard.com
WorldPay
Building a global strategy, brick by BRIC
It‘s with good reason that many retailers are eyeing
the BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India and China) countries
with such eager interest.
A report launched at the end of August by
PriceWaterhouse Cooper suggests that while these
fast growing countries delivered just 17% of global
GDP in 2010, their contribution is set to rapidly soar
and that they will provide an astonishing 40% of
GDP growth during 2011 and 2012 (1) .
Indeed, in AT Kearney‘s 2011 Global Retail
Development Index (2), Brazil, India and China all
maintained positions in the top ten, with only Russia
slipping out of the upper echelons. Brazil in
particular excelled, awarded a 100% ‗attractiveness‘
rating as an investment location, in part due to the
upcoming Olympics and World Cup.
For online retailers, this creates an immense
opportunity. In our experience of working with
numerous online retailers, we have found that with
much of their mission-critical infrastructure in place,
the process of expansion can be much simpler than
for a bricks-and-mortar competitor.
Capitalising on the BRIC opportunity
Although emerging markets present online
merchants with near-limitless opportunity, naturally
they also create a number of serious considerations
that need to be taken into account.
At WorldPay, we‘re doing all we can to help retailers
and merchants expand their reach into the BRIC
countries and other developing territories. We‘re
focusing on three key areas: we‘re making it as easy
as possible for merchants to take payments across
borders, helping them maximise conversion rates
and also fight fraud head-on.
Payments without borders
The popularity of payment methods between
countries can vary hugely. Failing to provide
payment methods that suit the local audience can be
one of the quickest ways of limiting business
expansion.
For a retailer without experience of those local
markets, that can create some unexpected
requirements. In China, for instance, where many
consumers want to inspect an item before parting
with their money, Cash-on-Delivery (COD) is the
most popular method of payment for goods
purchased online. As a result, AliPay - an escrow
service that manages the transfer of funds between
retailers and buyers – now provides access to more
than 550 million users. A similar situation exists in
Russia, where only a small percentage of the 130
million credit cards in circulation are usable online.
Issued primarily for the collection of salaries, and
missing essential CVC information, these credit
cards are increasingly shunned by many retailers in
favour of e-wallet solutions, such as WebMoney.
As a result, the most successful online retailers are
now adopting multiple payment strategies. Taking
the simple step of moving from a single payment
method to two or three can boost conversion rates
by as much as 10%. WorldPay, thanks to its recent
acquisition of Envoy Services, is now the world‘s
leading provider of alternative payment solutions
and offers a range of options for any business
looking to expand its payment offering to customers.
Maximising conversion rates
Making it as easy as possible for the customer to
purchase and pay is absolutely key to improving
conversion rates for any retailer. Something as
simple as presenting webpages or an online store
can have a major impact on sales patterns.
Research conducted recently shows that shoppers
are four times as likely to buy from a shop that
communicates to them in their native language.
At WorldPay, we provide a service that allows
merchants to present payment pages in multiple
languages with the minimum of effort, greatly
simplifying the situation for anyone expanding into
foreign territories.
Linguistics aren‘t the only consideration however, as
currency conversion also needs to be taken into
account. A website presented in the local language
is a great first step, but offering the choice to pay in
local currency can also be a major driver for sales.
As a result, retailers need to find a payments partner
that can offer Foreign Exchange services enabling
shoppers to pay in their own currency.
Tackling fraud
When it comes to global retail fraud, we‘ve seen a
growing trend of what is termed ‗clean fraud‘.
Increasingly sophisticated fraudsters have found
ways of placing orders with highly consistent
attributes, including IP geolocations, card issuing
countries, phone numbers and more. As a result,
fraudulent transactions look almost exactly like good
transactions, causing frustration for merchants.
Sophistication is also breeding coordination. We‘ve
witnessed a number of fraud rings ‗teaming up‘ to
make coordinated attacks, which require equally
high-level fraud strategies to counter.
There is no single solution to fraud. Instead, we
believe that it‘s vital that merchants adopt a number
of complementary risk strategies that work together
to both optimize the number of ‗good‘ transactions
that they accept whilst minimizing the fraudulent
ones. Services such as WorldPay‘s RiskGuardian,
which provides a high specification fraud screening
service can be the perfect addition to an overseas
risk management strategy.
Notes:
(1) www.investmentinternational.com/news/latest/bric- economies-set-to-soar-as-g7-recovery-slows-economists-predict-4860.html (2)www.atkearney.com/images/global/pdf/Retail_Global_E xpansion-GRDI_2011.pdfWorldPay is a leading global provider of payment and risk services, processing millions of transactions every day. WorldPay is a unification of seven leading retail payment solutions and offers a range of services including acquiring, gateway, alternative payments, risk
management, and mobile payments. WorldPay became an independent company in December 2010. For more information, visit www.worldpay.com
Company 2Checkout.com
Website www.2checkout.com/community/
Geographical presence Europe, North/Latin America Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
≈
Company 3V Transaction Services
Website www.3v.ie
Geographical presence Europe, North/Latin America Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
Company 99Bill
Website www.99bill.com
Geographical presence Asia/Pacific Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking≈
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
≈
Company ABN Amro
Website www.abnamro.com/en/index.html
Geographical presence North/Latin America, Europe, Middle East/Africa, Asia/Pacific Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
Company Accelya
Website w3.accelya.com
Geographical presence North/Latin America, Europe, Middle East/Africa Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
Company Acculynk
Website www.acculynk.com
Geographical presence North/Latin America Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Company Acceptance
Website www.acceptance.de
Geographical presence Europe Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards≈
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
Company ACI Worldwide
Website www.aciworldwide.com/
Geographical presence Asia/Pacific, Europe, Middle East/Africa, North/Latin America Payment methods Credit cards
≈
Debit cards≈
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet≈
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
Offline
Company ACM (United Tranz*actions)
Website www.acmeft.net
Geographical presence North/Latin America Payment methods Credit cards
Debit cards
Pre-paid cards
Online banking
E-wallet
Mobile/SMS/IVR
Alternative payment methods
AcceptEmail provides a comprehensive e-billing & payment service based on e-mail, SMS and
social media via a wide variety of local payment methods that we categorize in credit cards, debit cards and online banking.
Company AcceptEmail
Website www.acceptemail.com
Keywords E-billing, e-invoicing, e-bill, e-invoice, e-mail, payment, credit management, invoice-to-cash Contact Mr P.J. Kwakernaak, CEO, [email protected], +31 20 7470123
Geographical presence Europe, Middle East/Africa
Market segment(s) Retail, insurance , telecom, utilities, ticketing, charity, education, internet, publishers Active since (year) 2006
Payment methods
Credit cards Amex, MC, VISA, CB, JCB
Debit cards Dankort, Bancontact/Mister Cash, Maestro, Giropay, BCMC
Pre-paid cards N/A
Online banking All local online banking systems
E-wallet N/A
Mobile/SMS/IVR AcceptSMS is available in The Netherlands Alternative payment methods Sofort
Offline N/A
Connected companies (#) #3 Acquirers
Companies PSP is connected to WorldPay, Ogone, ICEPAY, iDEAL, PBS, PayDutchGroup Settlement currencies (acquirers) EUR
Services
Unique Selling Points Lower costs for invoicing and collection; debtors pay quicker, increase of customer satisfaction and environmentally friendly replacement of paper for digital; no duplication of data and no errors in creating the payment
Core services E-Billing Presentment and Payment by email, SMS and social media Pricing Monthly license fee + transaction per AcceptEmail
Collecting payments Via partners Distributing payments Via partners Fraud prevention (measures)
Fraud prevention partners
Credit management (services) Credit management is applicable in all stadia in the invoice-to-cash process Other services Integration with Credit Management System, AcceptSMS and voicecast
Third Parties Microsoft, Exact, RICOH, Mastercard, Triloq Payments, Fundtech, Litas Prie Lito and various resellers
Technology
Direct connections
Batch processing
Per order processing
Merchant pages (direct model)
PSP pages (indirect model)
Adyen is the most innovative and experienced PSP currently on the market. Adyen combines highly
sophisticated, fully customizable hosted payment pages, unprecedented reporting capabilities with transparant and no-frills pricing. Adyen is specialised in least-cost transaction routing. In
combination with Adyen's conversion management software merchants are capable to vastly improve conversion rates at lowest cost per conversion. Adyen provides fully integrated state-of the art fraud control.
Company Adyen
Website www.adyen.com
Keywords Innovation, conversion, fraud control, multi-channel, global, experience, independent, flexible Contact Sander Maertens, VP, [email protected]; +31202401240
Geographical presence Global, specifically strong in Americas and Europe
Market segment(s) Retail, travel, digital content, gaming, gambling, ticketing, social networks, social buying Active since (year) In payments business since 1997, current platform operational since 2006
Payment methods
Credit cards Visa, MasterCard, Amex, JCB, Diners, Discover, UATP, AirPlus, co-branded
Debit cards (e)Maestro, Visa electron, MrCash, Dankort, Laser, Delta, Carte Bleue, CartaSi, Postepay Pre-paid cards Wallie-card, PaySafeCard, PostePay, Cash ticket, Ukash, local (national) brands
Online banking iDEAL, sofortüberweisung, DIRECT ebanking, Nordea, suomen verkkomaksut and the whole range of local Scandinavian and Polish banking methods
E-wallet Paypal, MoneyBookers, Netteller, Click&Buy, Hyves Afrekenen Mobile/SMS/IVR Global coverage
Alternative payment methods Mobile payment pages, open invoice (post-payment), electronic invoicing / pay by e-mail Offline Bank transfers in over 30 countries, a selection of local voucher payment methods Connected companies (#) #25+ Acquirers and capable of working with 3rd party providers of (risk & loyalty) solutions Companies PSP is connected to Acquirers, fraud services, logistic partners, credit management services, e-commerce platforms Settlement currencies (acquirers) ARS, AUD, BRL, CAD, CHF, CLP, COP, CZK, DKK, EUR, GBP, HKD, HUF, ILS, IND, JPY, LTL,
LVL, MXN, NOK, NZD PLN RUB SEK SGD THB TRY USD ZAR Services
Unique Selling Points Increased conversion by simplifying the payment experience for shoppers; strong, configurable and real-time fraud screening, including device fingerprinting, artificial learning., more insight and control by providing statistical insight into payments; transparent, real-time interchange-plus pricing; short time-to-market of new features with bi-weekly releases; strong in new technologies, such as mobile payments, connected TV, in-app payments
Core services Multi-channel payment platform, fraud management, payment advise, reconciliation, reporting Pricing All-in pricing matrix, maximum transaction price of EUR 0,10. No set up or maintenance costs. Get a
price quote now!
Collecting payments Yes, Adyen is operating a full service model, being capable to reconcile all payment methods Distributing payments
Fraud prevention (measures) Flexible & state-of-the-art risk module, incl. consistency & velocity checks, referral lists, persistent cookies, device fingerprinting, proxy piercing. All checks are fully configurable & extendable. Due to operating a collecting model, Adyen can enrich risk module with payment behavior
Credit management (services) Yes, via third party, but fully integrated
Other services Fully customisable payment pages; Recurring and one click payments; Global electronic invoicing; Native mobile payment pages; A fully mobile accessible back-environment; MOTO (call center environment); Pay out; Point-of-Sale
Third Parties Everything is developed and managed in-house Technology
Direct connections Yes, when merchant is PCI compliant
Batch processing