• No results found

An approach to the examination of land management considerations in a development planning process: Some aspects of the changing role of the Native Land Trust Board of Fiji, 1940-1985.

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "An approach to the examination of land management considerations in a development planning process: Some aspects of the changing role of the Native Land Trust Board of Fiji, 1940-1985."

Copied!
297
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

AN APPfiOACH TO THE EXAMINATION OF LAND MANAGEMENT CONSIDERATIONS IN A DEVELOPMENT PLANNING PROCESS:

SOME ASPECTS OF THE CHANGING ROLE OF THE NATIVE LAND TRUST BOARD OF F U I, 1940-1985

Thesis subm itted i n p a r ti a l f u lf illm e n t of th e req u irem en ts f o r th e degree of Doctor of Philosophy

Paul W illion Munro-Faure

School of O riental and A frican S tu d ies U niversity of London

Malet St London W. C, 1

(2)

ProQuest Number: 10672614

All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS

The qu ality of this repro d u ctio n is d e p e n d e n t upon the q u ality of the copy subm itted. In the unlikely e v e n t that the a u th o r did not send a c o m p le te m anuscript and there are missing pages, these will be note d . Also, if m aterial had to be rem oved,

a n o te will in d ica te the deletion.

uest

ProQuest 10672614

Published by ProQuest LLC(2017). C op yrig ht of the Dissertation is held by the Author.

All rights reserved.

This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States C o d e M icroform Edition © ProQuest LLC.

ProQuest LLC.

789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346

(3)

ABSTRACT

The th e s is aims t o id e n tif y a p h ilo so p h ical approach to th e q u e stio n of how we can a tte m p t t o r e s o l v e p ro b lem s i n th e s o c ia l s c ie n c e s . Two p a r t i c u l a r problem a re a s th a t have geographical relevance in t h i s a re a are development planning and th e management of th e land resource. Follow ing t h i s defined approach re le v a n t area s of theory a rs discussed and assessed i n th e l i g h t of th e p hilo sop hical c r i t e r i a A conceptual framework w ith in which a development planning process might o p erate i s proposed, and lin k ag es w ith land id e n tifie d . This m a te ria l i s viewed i n th e context of re le v a n t in fo rm a tio n drawn from th e experience of F iji .

I t i s arg u ed t h a t a l l ’d e v e lo p m e n t1 r e s u l t s from in d i v i d u a l and j o i n t d ecisio n s i n any given system (or im pingeing thereon) being converted in to a c tio n U ntil such tim e as s u b s ta n tia l advances a re made i n in d iv id u a l and group behavioural theory, understanding of processes o p e ra tin g and the a b i l i t y to p red ic t outcomes (which i t i s argued i s e s s e n tia l fo r e f f e c tiv e development planning) w ill be very r e s tr ic te d . Understanding and th e accum ulation of knowledge i n such circum stances may depend not so much upon th e c o n s tru c tio n and te s tin g of hypotheses but upon the c a re fu l observatio n, reco rd in g and a n a ly sis of changes. In th e p resen t case, p ressu res and p ro cesses r e s u ltin g i n changes i n th e management of N ative Land are considered using d e ta ile d m a te ria ls from f i e l d research.

C o n c lu sio n s a r e draw n r e g a r d in g t h e p h ilo s o p h ic a l ap p ro ac h ad op ted, development planning and the developed conceptual framework, and the processes of change and im pacts a r is in g from the p o lic ie s and o p e ra tio n s of th e Native Land T rust Board i n the context of F i j i ’s development fo r th e period 1940- 1985.'

(4)

PREFACE

The main co n ce rn and c o n te n t o f th e t h e s i s i s th e dev elop m ent o f th e N ative Land T r u s t Board o f F i j i betw een 1940 and 1985.

The Board was c r e a t e d i n 1940 by th e N a tiv e Land T r u s t O rd in an ce o f th a t y e a r . I t was a s s ig n e d r e s p o n s i b i l i t y f o r th e a d m in is tr a t io n and management o f N a tiv e Land, w hich h i t h e r t o had been s u b je c t to an ad hoc p r o c e s s .

Land and i t s a v a i l a b i l i t y f o r u se p la y a c e n t r a l r o l e i n e n a b lin g developm ent to p ro c e e d . I t i s , a s a r e s u l t , a f a c t o r to be c o n s id e re d i n p la n n in g f o r developm ent a t th e n a t i o n a l l e v e l .

T h is i s o f p a r t i c u l a r im p o rta n c e i n th e c o n te x t o f F i j i , w here la n d ow nership i s d iv id e d i n t o f r e e h o l d (8% ), Crown (9 .5 % ), and N ativ e (82.5% ) - c r e a t i n g w hat am ounts to a v i r t u a l monopoly i n th e su p p ly o f la n d f o r new developm ent on th e p a r t o f th e B oard. The t h e s i s v iew s ch an g es i n th e Board a g a i n s t t h i s background and a g a i n s t t h a t o f n a t i o n a l d ev elo p m en t.

The t h e s i s pays p a r t i c u l a r a t t e n t i o n to th e l e g a l and a d m in is tr a t iv e e s ta b lis h m e n t o f th e N a tiv e Land T r u s t B oard , and t o how t h i s h a s changed o v e r tim e . I t re v ie w s th e d ev elop m en t o f i t s p o l i c i e s i n r e l a t i o n to th e a d m i n i s t r a t i o n and l e a s i n g o f th e la n d r e s o u r c e , and exam ines th e p r e s s u r e s and c o n s t r a i n t s upon th e Board in th e b r o a d e r c o n te x t o f F i j i and i t s n a t i o n a l d evelopm ent p la n n in g .

(5)

TABLE OF CONTENTS Page A bstract 2 Acknowledgements 5 L is t of Tables 6 L is t of F ig ures 9 Glossary of Terms 11

Chapter 1 In tro d u cto ry 14

Chapter 2 P h ilo so p h ical Approach 20

Why a re we p rim arily concerned w ith philosophy? a) The aim of research

b) The disadvantages of not d efin in g an a p p ro p ria te p h iloso ph ical approach

What a r e th e op tio n s a s reg ard s d if f e r e n t p h ilo so p h ies? a) Do we have ary option?

b) What op tio n s do we have?

What i s re q u ire d of our philosophy in praxis? Epistem ological P ro p o sitio n s

Epistemology I E p ist emology I I

O ntological P ro p o sitio n s Ontology I

Ontology I I

P hiloso ph ical P ro p o sitio n s P h ilo so p h ical P o sitio n

31

48

60 69 Chapter 3 T h eo retical Framework

S o c io -c u ltu ra l theory and context S o c io -c u ltu ra l theory

S o c io -c u ltu ra l context P o lit ic a l theory and context

P o lit ic a l theory P o lit ic a l context

Economic theory and context Economic theory

Economic context

B ehavioural theory and context Behavioural theory Behavioural context In te g ra tio n T h eo re tic al p o s itio n Contextual p o s itio n 71 72 82 93 105 114

Chapter 4 The N ative Land T rust Board 1940-1973 Background

N ative Land T rust Ordinance, 1940 Development p ressu res 19 40-1973

a) P o pu lation growth b) Population d r i f t c) Economic growth d) L e g is la tiv e growth P ercep tio n s of re s p o n s ib ility

A dm inistration p o lic ie s and im p lan en tatio n a) S ta ffin g po licy and tr a in in g

b) Management s tr u c tu re and decision-m aking c) Accounting p r a c tic e s 121 122 125 128 136 141 3

(6)

Page F ie ld p o lic ie s and im plam entation 151

a) Work load b) Finances

c) A g ric u ltu ra l land: g en erally : re se rv e s d) Urban land

e) Tourism f) F orestry

g) M inerals and e x tra c tiv e in d u s tr ie s

P ercep tion s of e ffe c tiv e n e ss 169

Chapter 5 The N ative Land T rust Board 1974—1985 173

Development p ressu res 1974-1985 174

a) P op ulation grcwth b) Population d r i f t c) Economic grcwth d) L e g is la tiv e growth

P ercep tio n s of r e s p o n s ib ility 182 A dm inistration p o lic ie s and im plem entation 186

a) S ta ffin g policy and tr a in in g

b) Management s tr u c tu re and decision-m aking c) Accounting p r a c tic e s

F ie ld p o lic ie s and im plem entation 200 a) Work load

b) Finances

c) A g ric u ltu ra l lan d: g en era lly : re s e rv e s d) Urban land

e) Tourian f) F o restry

g) M inerals and e x tra c tiv e in d u s tr ie s

P erceptions of e ffe c tiv e n e ss 214

Chapter 6 F u tu re C o nsiderations 220

N ative Land T rust Board 221

F i j i 226

In te rn a tio n a l 228

Developments w ith in th e e x is tin g framework 230 Developments of the e x is tin g framework 233 P o s s i b i l i t i e s fo r d ire c tin g change 236

Chapter 7 Conclusions 239 On change 241 On processes of change 245 The fu tu re 247 A Note on Fieldwork 250 Notes 253 B ibliography 280

(7)

Ackncwledgement s

I t i s a pleasu re to acknowledge th e a s s is ta n c e of those who have been good enough to help i n some way in th e research and p re p a ra tio n o f t h i s t h e s i s I should lik e t o thank those members of the s t a f f and of th e stu d en t body of th e School of O rien tal and A frican S tu d ies who have le n t an e a r during my period of study. Harvey Demaine and Keith McLachlan as su p e rv is o rs have been kind and generous i n t h e i r in te re s t* encouragement, and advice.

I should li k e t o reco rd nry g r a titu d e to B rian Robson, my e rs tw h ile D irecto r of S tudies, fo r suggesting th a t I co nsider r e g is t r a tio n a t th e School; and to Dick Hodder f o r h is e a rly thoughts and enthusiasm which have done much to s u s ta in me as my id e a s have developed.

I owe a g r e a t and c o n tin u in g d e b t t o th e N a tiv e Land T r u s t B oard f o r i t s frie n d sh ip , i t s h o s p ita lity , and i t s gen erosity i n honouring me w ith access to i t s records, and i n allow ing me to d iscu ss m a tte rs fr e e ly w ith i t s management and s t a f f . I hope th a t they w ill f in d th i s work to be of sane i n t e r e s t .

There are, of course, rnary o ther people to whom thanks a re due w ith in F i j i : a t th e A g r i c u l t u r a l T r ib u n a l’s o f f i c e ; a t th e U n iv e r s ity o f th e South P a cific; i n th e Government Archives, in th e C entral Planning O ffice L ibrary and i n v a r io u s o th e r G overnm ent and l o c a l governm ent o f f i c e s ; i n th e I n s t i t u t e of V aluatio n and E sta te Management of F i j i ; i n th e F i j i I n s t i t u t e of A g ric u ltu ra l Science; and elsew here. To a l l of them thanks are given. I t i s in a p p ro p ria te to l i s t a l l of those who have been of a s s is ta n c e , but i t i s a p leasu rab le duty to mention two, guiding s p i r i t s from w ith in the Board, J o s e fa ta Kamikamica and Waisake Savou, and to thank them fo r t h e i r indulgence, Vinaka.

The typing of th e th e s is has been a long and drawn out a f f a i r since e a rly 1986 when Mary T u ll and C a ro le Moody f i r s t s t a r t e d t o f e e d i t i n t o a r a t h e r g e r i a t r i c R acal word p r o c e s s o r . T h e ir f o r t i t u d e i n s t r u g g l i n g w ith my handw riting and w ith such a tr y in g machine deserve a h e a r t f e l t thankyou.

I t i s cu riou s t o observe how one’s fam ily in v a ria b ly f a l l s t o be considered la s t . I thank my p a re n ts fo r t h e i r gen erosity both of funds and of s p i r i t which has continued beyond a l l th e bounds of reasonable p a re n ta l duty.

My e f f o r ts a s they fo llow , and such a s they are, a re however b est p u t in to c o n te x t by th o s e o f my w ife J u d i t h ; who h a s been d e l i v e r e d o f our th r e e ch ild ren , Napier, Hannah and Sophie; who has su ffe re d the death of our f i r s t daughter, Hannah, in New Zealand; who has organised s ix changes of address; who h a s p u t up w ith h e r husband ch an g in g em ploym ent t h r e e tim e s w h i l s t research in g and w r itin g up h is th e s is ; and who has even found tim e to work in te r m itte n tly over the p ast f iv e years.

H ig h c liffe Min chi nh ampton Glouce s t e rs h ire .

(8)

L i s t o f t a b l e s

Page

Chapter 2: P h ilosophical Approach

2.1 Three kinds of s c i e n t i f i c theory (A fter Bunge) 39

Chapter 3: T heoretical Framework

3.1 D is tr ib u tio n of freeh o ld or eq u iv alen t ten u re 77

3 .2 C u ltural r e la tio n s h ip s w ith land 78

3.3 Changes i n e l e c t e d r e p r e s e n t a t i o n a t th e n a t io n a l l e v e l i n 87 F i j i

3.5 The d ev elo pm ent p la n n in g p r o c e s s and l i n k a g e s w ith la n d i n 119 F i j i

Chapter 4 : The N ative Land Trust Board 1940-1973

4.1 P o p u la tio n g ro w th , 1936-1976: t o t a l s and g ro w th r a t e s based 128 upon decennial censL

4.2 P o p u la tio n d r i f t , 1966-1976: by D iv is io n b ased upon d e c e n n ia l 130 censi

4.3 P opulation d r i f t , 1936-1976: grcwth of urban pop ulation 131 4.4 P o p u la tio n d r i f t , 1966-1976: d i f f e r e n t i a l g ro w th o f u rb a n 131

populations

4.5 Economic grow th, 1960-1974: e x p a n s io n of th e to u ris m i n d u s tr y 132 by v i s i t o r a r r iv a ls stay in g 24 hours or mere

4.6 Economic gro w th , 1950-1974: s t r u c t u r e o f G ro ss D o m estic 133 Product by percentage share, t o t a l G.D.P. and average annual

growth r a te s

4.7 L e g i s l a t i v e g row th, 1940-1974: m ajo r le g i s l a t i o n enacted, date 134 of enactment, and im pact on n a tiv e lan d management.

4.8 L e g i s l a t i v e g ro w th , 1968-1974: im p a c t of p r o v is io n s o f 136 le g is la tio n ; the A g ric u ltu ra l Landlord and Tenant Act, 1966,

refe re n c e s to th e A g ric u ltu ra l Tribunal i n i t i a t e d and disposed of 1/1/68 - 19/7/74

4.9 S t a f f , 1 9 4 5 -1 97 4 : s u m m a r y o f e x t e r n a l t r a i n i n g 147 3.4 S ectors o f a c tiv ity and impact on n atio n al development 118

(9)

Page

4.10 S ta f f , 1368: summary of examination passes 148

4.11 W orkload, 1951-1968: summary of casew o rk d e a l t w ith by th e 153 Board

4.12 Workload, 1945-1974: growth i n number of le a s e s and te n a n c ie s 154 granted by th e Board

4.13 Income and exp end iture, 1940-1974 1 56

4.14 Annual r e n t a l s and r o y a l t i e s , 19 46-197 4: am ounts c o l l e c t e d 158 and d i s t r i b u t e d , r e n t a l v a lu e o f th e n a t iv e e s t a t e , and

a rre a rs

4.15 W orkload, 1968-1971: th e A g r ic u lt u r a l L an d lo rd and T en an t 162 Ordinance up to 25th February 1971.

Chapter 5: The N ative Land Trust Board 1974-1985

5.1 P o p u la tio n g ro w th , 1974-1985: t o t a l s and g ro w th r a t e s based 175 upon decennial censi

5.2 Population d r i f t , 1977: average household weekly r e a l income 175 5 .3 P o p u la tio n d r i f t , 1 9 7 6 -1 9 8 6 : p r o j e c t e d p o p u l a t i o n s by 177

P ro v in ce OOOOs)

5.4 Economic growth, 1974-1984: expansion of th e t o u r i s t in d u stry 178 by v i s i t e r a r r iv a ls

5.6 Economic g ro w th , 1974-1985: s t r u c t u r e o f G ro ss D o m estic 179 Product, by percentage share, t o t a l G.D.P. and average annual

growth r a te s

5.7 L e g i s l a t i v e g r o w th , 1 978-1 9 8 4 : im p a c t o f p r o v is io n s o f 181 le g is la tio n ; th e A g ric u ltu ra l Landlord and Ttenant Act, 1966,

refe re n c e s to th e A g ric u ltu ra l Tribunal pending and disposed of

5.8 S ta f f , 1978-1985: sunmary of te c h n ic ia n le v e l tr a in in g 192 5.9 S ta ff, 1978-1985: sunmary of a d d itio n a l in house tr a in in g 192 5.10 S ta f f , 1978-198 5: l o c a lis a t io n of p ro fessio n al le v e l p o s itio n s 194 5.11 W o rk lo a d , 1 9 7 4 -1 9 8 5 : g r o w th i n n u m b e rs o f l e a s e s and 202

ten an cies granted by the Board

5.12 Income and expenditure, 1974-1985 203

5.13 Annual r e n t a l s and r o y a l t i e s , 1974-1985; am ounts c o l l e c t e d 204 and d i s t r i b u t e d , r e n t a l v a lu e o f th e n a t iv e e s t a t e , and

a rre a rs

(10)

Page

5 . 1 4 A g r i c u l t u r a l la n d . 1 9 7 4 - 1 9 8 5 : num bers o f l e a s e s , and a r e a 205

leased by th e Board

5 . 1 5 A g r ic u lt u r a l la n d , 1 9 8 1 - 1 9 8 5 : D evelopm ent P la n 8 , p r o je c te d 206

r e le a s e o f lan d fo r a g ric u ltu re

5 . 1 6 A g r i c u l t u r a l la n d , 197 4 - 1 9 8 5 : num bers o f l e a s e s , and a r e a 2 0 7

leased (reserv e land) by the Board

5 . 1 7 Urban la n d , 1 9 7 4 - 1 9 8 5 : num bers o f n o n - a g r i c u l t u r a l l e a s e s 2 0 9

(11)

L i s t o f F ig u r e s

Page

Chapter 2: P h ilosop h ical Approach

2.1 Approaches to planning: black box and w hite box 33

2 .2 Conceptual grcwth of hunan knowledge 36

2.3 The process of method refinem ent (A fter Rescher) 44 2.4 The m e ta p h y s ic a l and f a c t u a l e le m e n ts and t h e i r l i n k i n g 46

to g eth er i n s ta g e s i n an in q u iry procedure (A fter Rescher)

2.5 Modes of becoming and r e la te d o n to lo g ies (A fter Bunge) 58 2.6 E f f ic a c y of a number o f dev elo p m en t p la n s a t a g iv e n tim e 66

according t o th e method of planning

2.7 P e r c e p tio n s o f r e a l i t y o f a number o f i n d i v i d u a l s a t a g iv e n 66 tim e according t o th e ir perceptual a b i l i t y

2.8 Efficacy o f a nunber of development planning p ro cesses over time 67 2.9 E f fic a c y o f d ev elo p m en t p la n n in g p ro c e s s a g a i n s t a c c u ra c y o f 67

percep tion o f r e a l i t y over tim e

Chapter 3: T h eoretical Framework

3.1 Society in loco 74

3 .2 C ultural groups i n loco 75

3.3 Changes w ith in a c u ltu r a l group 76

3.4 Map f o r th e a n a l y s i s of p e r s o n a l i t y and p o l i t i c s ( A f te r 83 B rew ster-an ith )

3.5 Feedback i n a p o l i t i c a l system 85

3 .6 C ircu lar flow of income i n a s im p lis tic economy 95 3.7 Leakages i n th e c ir c u la r flow of income 95

3.8 Context and sources of change i n an economy 96

3.9 P rin cip al n e t f in a n c ia l flow s in F i j i (A fter Development Plan 7) 100 3.10 P e r c e p tio n o f th e p e r c e p tu a l m echanism o f th e i n d i v i d u a l 108

(A fter Lloyd and Dicken)

3.11 Behavioural m atrix (A fter Pred) 109

(12)

3.12 Conceptual sequence of n atio n al development 3.13 Generic sequence of n atio n al development

Page

115 116

Chapter 4: The N ative Land Trust Board 1940-1973

4.1 Population grcwth, 1936-1976 1 29

4.2 Economic growth, 1960-1974: expansion of the tou rism in d u stry 132 by v i s i t o r a r r i v a l s stay in g 24 hours or more

4.3 Growth of s t a f f and com position, 1946-1973 143

4.4 O rganisation c h a rt, 1962 1 44

4.5 P roposed o r g a n i s a t i o n c h a r t and s t a f f i n g o f th e B oard from 148 1968, showing a c tu a l 1968 s t a f f le v e ls b ra c k stte d where not a t

establishm ent

4.6 O rganisation c h a rt, 1973 1 50

4.7 W orkload, 1945-1974: in d e x of g ro w th i n t o t a l number o f 155 le a se s and te n a n c ie s managed by th e Board (1955 = 100)

4.8 .Tourism, 1946-1974: h o te l le a s e s granted by y ear 166

Chapter 5: The N ative Land Trust Board 1974-1985

5.1 Growth of s t a f f and com position, 1973-1985 189

5.2 S ta ff, 1973-1985: p ro p o rtio n follow ing tr a in in g co u rses 193 5.3 O r g a n is a tio n c h a r t , 1979-1985: D iv is io n a l E s t a t e O f f ic e 197

o rg a n isa tio n

5.4 O rganisation c h a rt, 1979-1985: Head O ffice o rg a n is a tio n 198 5.5 Workload, 1974-1985: co n tro l of work o v e ra ll and by D ivision . 201

(13)

G lossary of Terms

A note on F iji a n s p e llin g and p ro n u n ciatio n

Throughout t h i s th e s is th e accepted standard s p e llin g of F iji a n words i s used. For p ro nu nciatio n th e eq u iv a le n ts a r e as fo llc w s

:-b i s pronounced mb a s i n tim ber c i s pronounced t h as i n t h i s d i s pronounced nd a s in band g i s pronounced ng a s i n king q i s pronounced ng as i n fin g e r G alala M ataqali Tokatoka Turaga Yakavanua Tavusa 1 1

independent F iji a n farm er who paid a commutation r a te to be re le a s e d from communal se rv ic e s under the old F ijia n R egulations

a sub-clan; su b d iv isio n of a y a v u sa ; th e prim ary landowning u n it

fam ily group; su b d iv isio n of m ataq ali

c h i e f ; th u s , f o r in s ta n c e , t u r a g a - n i - q a l l i s c h i e f o f th e m ataq ali

i n th e manner of th e land; customary

w id e s t p a t r i l i n e a l k in s h ip group ; d escen d ed from a common an c e sto r.

(14)
(15)

"... I reg ard ev erything th a t i s sa id h ere as c o r r ig ib le p re c is e ly because I wish philosophy were alw ays done in a s c i e n t i f i c mood".

M. Bunge

•’The Hyth of S im p lic ity 11

(16)

CHAPTER 1 Introductory

' I t was a dark and stormy n ig ht;

The lig h tn in g flashed* th e thunder crashed.

And th e r a in came down in bucket a . . The Robber C aptain said ; "Antonio t e l l us a story.", And th i s i s the sto ry Antonio to ld :

'" I t was a dark and stormy night;

The lig h tn in g flashed, the thunder crashed, And th e r a in came down i n buckets.

Ihe Robber Captain said; "Antonio t e l l us a story.", And t h i s i s th e sto ry Antonio to ld :

'" " I t was a d a rk ... "«*••'

"A ntonio's T ale". T ra d itio n a l.

(17)

CHAPTER 1

Introductory

The sig n ific a n c e of th e re la tio n s h ip between receiv ed or ta u g h t 'knowledge1 and f i r s t hand p r a c tic a l experience i s remarkable. I t i s arguably one of th e f i r s t pieces of knowledge th a t an in d iv id u a l acquires, and i s p o ssib ly one of th e most im portant.

Take, fo r in stan ce, a c h ild standing a t a bus sto p w a itin g f o r the 8.30 am. bus t o ta k e him t o s c h o o l; he does n o t g iv e up h i s v i g i l a t 8.30 am . j u s t becau se th e bus h as n o t p u lle d i n t o s i g h t , s in c e i n h i s e x p e rie n c e th e tim e ta b le i s very o fte n in a c c u ra te , and the bus fre q u e n tly l a t a

"Why do I say th i s ? " , and "How can t h i s be n arrow ed down i n t o a more meaningful statem ent?" w i l l be two very im p o rtan t q u e s tio n s running through th ese pages.

For the moment, however, a general c l a r i f i c a t i o n of the general statem en t w ill s u ffic e to in d ic a te th e intended d ire c tio n of tra v e l.

What i s "received or tau gh t 'knowledge'"? I t mey be taken a s being rep o rted exp lan atio n s of events or e n t i t i e s , of th e ir ex isten ce and behaviour both as reg ard s them selves a s in d iv id u a ls, and as reg ards them selves i n th e context i n which they have th e ir bein& The le v e l of in v e s tig a tio n and ex p lan atio n i s im po rtan t and i s , of course, defined i n th e f i r s t in sta n c e by fundamental q u e stio n s of s c a le and i n the second perhaps by conceptual capacity.

But what s ta tu s do th ese ex p lan atio n s have?

" F i r s t hand e x p e r ie n c e " , i n s o f a r a s i t r e l a t e s t o r e c e iv e d or ta u g h t 'k n o w led g e', may be in s ta n c e d i n two ways. On th e one hand, f i r s t hand experience re p re s e n ts the opp ortu nity to t e s t ex p lan atio n s a g a in s t the r e a l

(18)

world. On the o th er. I t g iv es the o pportunity to examine how ex p lan atio n s have been r e la te d i n th e p ast to d e sire d changes in th e even ts or e n t i t i e s and th e ir ex isten ce or behaviour.

E xplanations a re th e re fo re stro n g ly re la te d to exp ectatio n s, and i n th e l a t t e r sense, to p red ic tio n s.

I t i s im p ortant to be aware th a t none of the above makes any g r e a t dep artu re from anything th a t has been o ften s ta te d before, and indeed i t may be drawn from common sense. I t does, however, presen t a u sefu l o r ie n ta tio n e x e rc ise to f a c i l i t a t e th e i n t r o d u c t i o n of some o f th e m ost f u n d a m e n ta lly d i f f i c u l t problems not only facin g th e developing world, but also , i t may be added, u n d erw ritin g many of the d i f f i c u l t i e s of the developed world.

I t i s re le v a n t to ask to what ex ten t ex p lan atio n i s a v a lid procedure fo r th e a c c u r a te i d e n t i f i c a t i o n o f e x p e c ta t io n s and p r e d i c t i o n s . Any q u e s ti o n providing in fo rm a tio n d efin in g th e s ta tu s of ex p lan atio n s i n th e above context i s valuable.

Such q u e stio n s a r e of c ru c ia l sig n ific a n c e In th e developing w orld because explanatory statem en ts are n e c e ssa rily p recu rso rs of d e c isio n s governing the u t i l i s a t i o n of reso u rces and t h e i r allo c a tio n . From a r a tio n a l p o in t of view i t i s im portant to secure the b e st a v a ila b le r e tu r n from sca rc e resou rces. How much more so fo r those p a r ts of th e w orld c h a ra c te rise d by la c k of reso u rces of a l l kinds!

T rav e llin g through a number of c o u n trie s a s u p e r f ic ia l aw areness o f th e im pact of th i s p o te n tia l problem was generated i n a wide v a r ie ty of f i e l d a The eco lo g ica l consequences of th e Aswan Dam; th e long term f in a n c ia l p ro sp ects of major i r r i g a t i o n development schem es; th e J o n g le i Canal and prop osed d r a in i n g o f th e Sudd; a n e x p e r im e n ta l sheep schem e i n K apoeta, S o u th e rn Sudan; th e long term consequences of land r e g i s t r a t i o n and c o n so lid a tio n

schemes in Kenya; and so on

This wide range of, a l b e i t s u p e r f ic ia l, f i r s t hand experience provided an im po rtan t f i r s t in d ic a tio n th a t exp lanation, i n term s of th e o r if ic a tio n , i s not an autom atic s o lu tio n to th e fu lfilm e n t of expect a tio n sa n d p re d ic tio n s. (Although a t th a t stage, th e q u e s tio n was not form ulated In such a gen eral

(19)

manner; ifc was found i n a su ccessio n of "why?" and "how?" questio ns.) Why c o u ld n o t th e e c o l o g ic a l p ro b le m s o f d is p l a c i n g th e s i l t i n g p r o c e s s be fcreseen?^ How could a country l i k e Sudan undertake m ajor development schemes which o f f i c i a l s f e l t would never be fin a n c ia lly independent?2 How could th e f u t u r e im p a c t o f th e J o n g l e i Canal and th e d ra in a g e o f th e Sudd e v e r be assessed to th e s a ti s f a c tio n of th e whole reg io n affe c te d ? ^ How could th e p la n n e r s o f th e K apoeta sheep schem e not be aw are o f th e p o t e n t i a l d i f f i c u l t i e s c re a te d by ta k in g lan d w ithout n e g o tia tio n or com pensation fo r th e cu sto m ary ow ners?^ Why had n ot Kenya e n a c te d minimum and maximum la n d h o ld in g l e g i s l a t i o n t o t r y t o p re v e n t f u t u r e p ro b le m s o f e x c e s s iv e su b d iv isio n of land and the emergence of absentee landlordism?-^

And so on.

This unease found p a r a l le l ex pression i n w ritin g s on th e su bject. The keynote a d d r e s s of th e PTRC S em inar on " P la n n in g and D evelopm ent i n D ev elo ping Countries" i n 1981:

"Thus, a s u b s ta n tia l p ro p o rtio n of aid to developing c o u n trie s i n th e post war period was of the wrong kind and i t i s only i n th e p ast 10 y ears th a t a g re a te r understanding of th e is s u e s has begun to emerge w h i eh w ill r e s u l t in . m.cre re le v a n t and p o te n tia lly more h e lp fu l and

successful ap pro ach es.. . "

"In th e p la n n in g f i e l d , th e wrong, te rm s o f r e f e r e n c e i n e v i t a b l y re s u lte d i n th e wrong kind of p la n a No wonder th a t so many . plans

prepared la b o rio u s ly a t co nsiderable co st were never im plem en ted..." "In in te r n a tio n a l funding agencies o v e r-s o p h is tic a te d academ ics w rote term s of referen c e fo r equally over^-sophisticated p r a c t iti o n e r s to provide o v e r-s o p h is tic a te d se rv ic e s fo r Third World c o u n trie s which did not have th e m a te ria l or s k ille d manpower reso u rces to implement the r e s u ltin g la rg e ly ir r e le v a n t p ro p o sala . Other m istaken approaches w ere aca d em ic f i n a l s t a t e m a s te r p la n s , w hich w ere i n v a r i a b l y overtaken by event a

C r itic a l awareness of t h i s problem from a p r a c tic a l p o in t of view was fo s te re d and perhaps matured by f u r th e r experience i n England, Planning, which may be taken fo r the p resen t as any in te rv e n tio n in an e x is tin g s e t of circum stan ces or procedures i n an a tte m p t to secure c e r ta in d esired ends on the b a s is of an a n a ly s is of the e x is tin g circum stances, seems to be i n an alm o st id e n tic a lly s im ila r and d i f f i c u l t s i t u a t i o n

(20)

The context of the problem thus widely observed, i n t u iti v e ly ta k e s on a more general aspect, and w ith th is , slow dawning of the r e a l i s a t i o n th a t perhaps th ese d i f f i c u l t i e s a re not the r e s u l t of shortcom ings i n the theory th a t i s being app lied ; t h a t po ssib ly they r e s u lt from th e n atu re of th e p re th e c r e tic a l environment i n which the theory i t s e l f i s a t p resen t stru c tu re d .

Such a w idely experienced problem seems to argue fo r a fundam ental e rro r in approach. There i s a su sp icio n th a t the s o c ia l scien c es a3 a whole, a t l e a s t in s o fa r as they a re ap p lied i n th e r e a l world, tend to o p erate on a s im ila r le v e l to "Antonio's Tale": t e l l i n g much the same sto ry , a l b e i t i n in c re a s in g d e ta il, w ith r e la tiv e ly l i t t l e v a r ia tio n over the years.

There i s no th e o re tic a l b a s is fo r o b je c tin g to th is , i n the same way th a t t h e r e i s no o b j e c t i o n t o th e t e l l i n g o f A n to n io 's T a le i n th e n u rs e ry , p a r t i c u l a r l y when th e l i g h t s a r e o u t and th e th u n d e r i s c r a s h in g and th e lig h tn in g i s fla sh in g . I t c re a te s a splendid environment which g iv es o f f an atmosphere of c r e d ib ility .

But what happens when we r e c i t e "Antonio's Tale" i n th e o u tsid e w orld and gather to g e th e r under a tr e e to s h e lte r from the stormy b la s t? I t t e l l s us nothing o f any p r a c tic a l use; although we may d eriv e some com fort from th e f a m ilia r words, th i s i s s w iftly d is p e lle d when lig h tn in g s trik e s ....

The p r e th e c re tic a l environm ent w ith which we must i n i t i a l l y be concerned, and which w ill have f i r s t claim on our tim e, w ill involve a clo se look a t th e theory of knowledge; the ph ilosop hical realm p e rc e p tiv e ly summed up by Hume i n th e mid eig h teen th century:

"Our problem belongs to th e theory of knowledge, or to epistem ology, rep uted to be the most a b s tr a c t and rem ote and a lto g e th e r ir r e le v a n t reg io n of pure philosophy."^

But t h i s i t s e l f re q u ire s a problem, a defined context i n which to be discussed and ap plied; i n a p h ilo so p h ical sense, i n a th e o re tic a l sense and u ltim a te ly i n a p ra c tic a l sense. How e lse may i t otherw ise be judged?

(21)

The p h ilo s o p h ic a l and t h e o r e t i c a l them es a re th u s p u rsu e d , and t e n t a t i v e suggestions made i n such a form as to f a c i l i t a t e exam ination i n th e context of th e r e a l world.

As to the choice of problem?

I t has already been in d ic a te d th a t a very s u b s ta n tia l problem area i s to be found i n a sse ssin g the consequences of v ario u s planned a c t i v i t i e s i n any given en v iro n m en t. W hether acknow ledged o r n o t i t i s a problem t h a t i s o f sig n ific a n c e to a l l people; but, i n term s of im pact i t i s arguable th a t the g r e a t e s t s i g n i f i c a n c e i s on th e p e o p le s o f th e d e v e lo p in g w o rld . Who i s u ltim a te ly most a ffe c te d by th ese consequences i s not, however, of p a r tic u la r r e le v a n c e (e x c e p t, o f c o u rs e , to th e in d iv id u a ls and s o c ie t ie s concerned) because th e p a r t i c u l a r "How?" and ’’Why?” q u e s ti o n s t h a t a r e exam ined a re probably capable of f a i r l y general ap p licatio n .

N o n e - th e - le s s , a s i s p e rh a p s I n e v i t a b l e , c irc u m s ta n c e s h av e i n d i c a t e d a c e r ta in d ire c tio n .

In th e present in sta n c e , background, tr a in in g and p r a c tic a l experience a l l com bine to s u g g e s t t h a t la n d , i t s p la c e i n th e schem e o f th in g s , and th e im pact of changes i n th e f a c to r s c o n tro llin g i t s use, a re most lik e ly to be reasonably e f f e c tiv e ly d e a lt w ith. Likewise op portu nity has d ic ta te d th a t the s p e c if ic context i n which th e r e s u ltin g pro po sals a r e d iscussed w i l l be drawn from the South P a c ific Region.

I t i s f o r th e s e , l a r g e l y chance r e a s o n s t h a t th e c e n t r a l t o p i c o f "Land Management c o n s i d e r a t i o n s i n th e D evelopm ent P la n n in g p ro c e s s " h a s been se le c te d ; and indeed th a t th e s p e c ific case study u t i l i s e d should be th a t of F i j i 's Native Land T rust Board and the n atu re and e f f e c ts of i t s changing r o le i n th e development planning process.

I t i s f o r t u n a t e t h a t such an exam ple i s t o hand i n s o f a r a s i t h a s had s u b s t a n t i a l im p a c ts n o t o n ly i n F i j i , b u t a ls o s p r e a d in g th ro u g h o u t th e Region.

(22)

CHAPTER 2

P h ilosophical Approach

n 'I w i l l read th e inven to ry 1, began Craven gravely, pick ing up one of the papers,, .'the inventory of what we found lo o se and unexplained i n th e c a s t l e . . .

' f i r s t item . ..A very co n sid erab le hoard o f precious sto nes, nearly a l l diam onds....

’Second item . Heaps and heaps o f lo ose snuff....

'T hird item . Here and .th ere about th e house cu rio u s l i t t l e heaps of minute p ieces of metal,..some lik e s te e l sprin gs and some in th e form of m icroscopic w heel a . . .

'F o u rth ite m . The wax c a n d le s ... By no s t r e t c h of fan cy c a n th e human mind connect to g e th e r sn u ff and diamonds and wax and lo ose

clockw ork.'

' I th in k I see th e connexion,' said , th e p rie s t. 'T his Glengyle was mad a g a i n s t th e F ren ch R ev o lu tio n . He was an e n t h u s i a s t f o r th e a n c ie n re g im e , and was tr y in g to re -e n a c t l i t e r a l l y th e fam ily l i f e of the l a s t Bourbons. He had snu ff because i t was the e ig h teen th - century luxury; wax candles because they were th e e ig h teen th -cen tu ry lig h tin g ; th e mechanical b i t s of ir o n re p re s e n t th e lo ck sm ith hobby o f L o u is XVI; t h e diam onds a r e f o r th e Diamond N ecklace o f M arie A n toinette.

Both th e o th e r men w ere s t a r i n g a t him w ith round ey es. ’ What a p e r f e c t l y e x t r a o r d in a r y n o tio n ! ' c r i e d Flam beau. 'Do you r e a l l y th in k th a t i s th e tru th ? '

' I am p e rfe c tly su re i t i s n 't , ’ answered F ather Brow a ...

Then he said : 'The l a t e Earl of Glengyle was a th ie f. He liv e d a second and d arker l i f e a s a desp erate house-breaker. He did not have any can d le stic k s because he only used these candles cut sh o rt in the la n te rn he carried . The sn u ff he employed as th e f i e r c e s t French c rim in a ls have used pepper: to f li n g i t suddenly i n dense masses i n th e face of a captor or pursuer. But th e f in a l proof i s th e curious coincidence of the diamonds and the sm all s te e l wheels. S urely th a t makes every th in g p la in to you? Diamonds and sm all s te e l w heels a re the only two in stru m e n ts w ith which you can cut out a pane of g la ss.' 'Diamonds and sm all w heels,' rep eated Craven, rum inating. 'I s th a t a l l th a t makes you th in k i t the tru e explanation?'

' I don't th in k i t th e tru e e x p la n a tio n ' re p lie d th e p r ie s t p la c id ly ; '... The t r u e t a l e , of c o u rs e , i s s o m e th in g much m ore humdrum. Glengyle had found, or thought he had found, precious sto n e s on h is e s ta te . Somebody had bamboozled him w ith those lo ose b r i l l i a n t s , saying they were found i n th e c a s tle caverns. The l i t t l e w heels a re some diam ond-cutting a f f a ir . He had to do the th in g very roughly and i n a sm all.w ay, w ith th e h elp of a few shepherds or rude fe llo w s on th ese h i l l a Snuff i s the one g re a t luxury of such Scotch shepherds;

(23)

i t s the one th in g w ith which you can bribe them They d id n 't have can d le stic k s because they d id n 't want them; they held th e candles in th e ir hands when they explored the caves.*

'I s th a t a l l ? ' asked Flambeau a f t e r a long pause. 'Have we got to the d u ll tr u th a t la s t ? '

'Oh no,' sa id F ather Brown

' I o n ly s u g g e s te d t h a t b ecau se you s a id one co u ld n o t p l a u s i b l y connect sn u ff w ith clockwork or candles w ith b rig h t stones. Ten f a ls e p h iloso ph ies .w i ll f i t th e universe; te n f a ls e th e o rie s w i l l f i t Glengyle Castle. But we want the r e a l ex p lan atio n of the c a s tle and th e un iv erse.' "

frcm 'The Honour of I s r a e l Gcw* '3he Innocence of F ath er Brown'

G. K. C hesterton.

(24)

CHAPTER 2

P h ilosop h ical Approach

Why are we prim arily concerned w ith philosophy?

Philosophy, philo so ph ers and works of philosophy cover a wide spectrum of i n t e r e s t and of a p p ro a c h e s. I n view of th e fu n d a m e n ta l n a tu r e of th e d i s c i p l i n e t h i s i s p e rh a p s s u r p r i s i n g , a s th e ty r o m ig h t be f o r g iv e n f o r presuming th a t a l l c o rre c tly analysed problems should p roperly reduce to some common b a s is of explanation, even though not n e c e ssa rily some common method of explanation.

A cursory e x p lo ra tio n o f l i b r a r i e s of philosophy w ill produce th e r e a l i s a t i o n th a t th is presum ption i s em phatically not the case. More d e ta ile d exam ination of th e s u b je c t m a t e r i a l p ro d u c e s an im p r e s s io n o f a f a s c i n a t i n g ran g e of competing ex p lan atio n s of exp lanation, and of the context u a lis a tio n , mode, method and approach th e re to . The fo rce w ith which such co m p etitio n i s argued, p a r tic u la r ly in c e r ta in key areas, i s in d ic a tiv e of the s tre n g th of the view s held and of the degree of commitment th e re to by th e p e r s o n a litie s involved.^

These are s ig n if ic a n t observatio ns, fo r a l l th e ir s u p e r f ic i a li ty , a s they serve to emphasise th a t v ir t u a ll y any pronouncements i n philosophy must be se e n on an, a s i t w ere, sub ju d i c e b a s is . There do n o t a p p e a r t o be any id e n tif ie d a b so lu te s i n th e study of th e abso lute, fo r th e p resen t a t le a s t.

Philosophy subdiv ides in to a number of id e n tif ia b le problem areas, commencing w ith lo g ic and sem antics, and ranging through to th e more m etaphysical area s of epistemology and ontology. Disagreem ents e x is t i n a l l a rea s; over, fo r in stan ce, many valued lo g ic s , and d e f in itio n s of tru th , but th e more vehement co n ten tio n s from the p resent p o in t of view appear i n th e a re a s of epistem ology and ontology. These may be defined re s p e c tiv e ly as fo llo w s; "the theory of th e m ethod or g ro u n d s of know ledge", and "th e th e o ry o f p u re b ein g o r r e a lity ." In essence th e "how?" and "what?" q u e stio n s of th e universe w r it

■p

la rg e .

I t I s w ith th ese q u e stio n s th a t th i s chap ter w ill be concerned, because the prime i n t e r e s t of a s o c ia l, a s of any, scien c e must be i n th ese "how?" and "what?" form s of question. Geography i s no excep tion i n t h i s resp ect.

(25)

The s c ie n c e s are* o f c o u rs e , a ls o d epen dent upon th e o th e r a r e a s o f p hilo sop hical concern id e n tif ie d . Q uestions o f lo g ic and of sem antics are viewed as being r e la tiv e ly uncontentious i n the present co ntext and are thus not exam ined s p e c i f i c a l l y . B ro ad er q u e s ti o n s o f m e ta p h y s ic s , however* p a r tic u la r ly i n a geographical context, re q u ire b r ie f c o n sid e ra tio n a s they may be a s ig n if ic a n t determ inant of th e p h ilo so p h ical approach adopted tow ards an id e n tif ie d problem.

Such in te r r e la tio n s h ip s as th e re may be between th e m etaphysical stand po in t and the w ider p h ilo so p h ical view p e r ta in to th e in d iv id u a l p ro b lem -so lv er's a ttitu d e s . In d iv id u al stan d p o in ts a re n e c e ssa rily unique and have an impact upon the i d e n tif i c a ti o n and s e le c tio n of, and the approaches to problem a I t i s re a s o n a b le to a rg u e t h a t th e a g g r e g a tio n o f such a p p ro a c h e s may be in stru m e n ta l i n the d e f in itio n of a problem and of i t s proposed so lu tio n . This may be p o te n tia lly of co n sid erab le relev ance to geographical problems, since d iv ergent re g io n s and c u ltu r a l groupings may favour c e r ta in m etaphysical and a c c o r d a n t p h il o s o p h i c a l a p p ro a c h e s t o stud y. Some form o f m e ta p h y s ic a l co n sid era tio n may th e re fo re be of s ig n ific a n c e p a r tic u la r ly where the problem i s o f such a n a tu re , and e s p e c i a l l y w here a p r o b le m - s o lv e r t r e a t s w ith problems o u ts id e h is own c u ltu r a l and re g io n a l fram es of referen ce.^

For the moment, however, concern i s w ith the approach to problems and t h e i r s e le c tio n :

"...and i t i s a p rim e co n cern , f o r j u s t a s g e o g r a p h ic a l stu d y in s o c i a l s c ie n c e can n o t p ro cee d w ith o u t a t l e a s t a p h il o s o p h i c a l v ie w p o in t (w h e th e r e x p l i c i t l y o r by im p l i c a t i o n ) , so p h ilo so p h y becomes b arren w ithout problema"^

I t has been s ta te d by Popper th a t th e le g itim a te a re a s of concern a re th e s e lf-e v id e n t "concrete e v i l s '1 of s o c ie ty :

"Work f o r th e e l i m i n a t i o n o f c o n c r e te e v i l s r a t h e r th a n f o r th e r e a l i s a t i o n of a b s tr a c t gooda Do not aim a t e s ta b lis h in g happiness by p o l i t i c a l , means. R ath er aim a t th e e l i m i n a t i o n o f c o n c r e te m iseries. Or, i n more p r a c tic a l term s: f ig h t fo r th e e lim in a tio n of poverty by d ir e c t means - fo r example, by making su re th a t everyone has a minimum incoma

" I t i s a fa c t, and not a very stran g e fa c t, th a t i t i s not so very d i f f i c u l t t o re a c h ag ree m en t by d i s c u s s i o n on w hat a r e th e m ost in to le r a b le e v i ls of our so ciety , and on what a re th e most urgent s o c ia l reform s. Such an agreement can be reached much mere e a s ily than an agreement concerning some id e a l form of s o c ia l l i f e . For th e

(26)

e v ils are w ith us h ere and now. T hey can be experienced, and are being experienced every day, by many people who have been and a re being made m iserab le by poverty, unemployment, n a tio n a l oppression, war and disease. Those of us who do not s u ffe r from these m ise rie s m eet ev ery day o t h e r s who can d e s c r ib e them to us. T h is i s w hat makes th e e v i l s c o n c re te . T h is i s why we can g e t som ew here by a rg u in g a b o u t them, why we can p r o f i t h e r e from th e a t t i t u d e o f reasonableness. We can le a rn by lis te n in g to concrete claim s, ty p a t i e n t l y t r y i n g t o a s s e s s them a s i m p a r t i a l l y a s we can,, and by considering ways o f meeting them w ithout c re a tin g worse e v il a

With id e a l goods i t i s d iff e r e n t. These we know only from our dreams and from th e d ream s o f our p o e ts and p r o p h e ta They can n o t be discussed, only proclaim ed from th e housetops, they do not c a l l fo r th e ra tio n a l a t tit u d e of th e im p a rtia l judge, but fo r th e em otional a t tit u d e of the im passioned preacher."^

The concrete analogy i s in s tr u c tiv e . Concrete comes i n a wide v a rie ty of d if f e r e n t types and mixes determ ined by the t e n s i le and o th e r requ irem ents of th e product. I t may re q u ire rein fo rc in g . I t may be an in a p p ro p ria te m a te ria l f o r some fo rm s o f c o n s tr u c t io n , m o reover, i f im p r o p e r ly u sed i t may be resp o n sib le fo r severe d e fe c ts in a s tru c tu re .

Concrete, th e re fo re , re q u ir e s to be ap p ro p ria te t o the ta s k i n hand, and to be ap p ro p ria tely used. I t can be no l e s s th e case w ith th e i d e n t i f i c a t i o n of th e "concrete e v ils " in so ciety . The d e f in itio n i s not an easy, nor an ab so lu te t a s k a s i s s u g g e s te d ; s t i l l l e s s so i s ag ree m en t on p r o p o s a ls f o r t h e i r re s o lu tio n .

W h ils t s y m p a th e tic t o th e g e n e r a l p o in t b e in g made by Popper, i t i s n o t f e a s ib le i n r e a l i t y to r e s t r i c t e f f o r ts to those designed to e lim in a te such au to d efin in g e v i l s a s may ex ist. L i t t l e credence would be given to such a s im p lis tic view in p ra c tic e i n any case.

I t i s p referred w ith in reaso n to follow th e s p i r i t of Harvey:

own o b je c tiv e has been to give the geographer f r e e r e ig n i n h is choice of o b je ctiv e , in th e b e lie f th a t g e o g r a p h y always has been and always w ill be what those who c a ll them selves geographers choose to do. »5

a) The aims o f research

The aim s o f r e s e a r c h a r e m a n ifo ld and a r e a t base th e r e s u l t of p e rs o n a l i n c l i n a t i o n s o f th e in d i v i d u a l r e s e a r c h e r . I t i s t h i s p e r s o n a l i t y o f p ercep tio n th a t th e p resent approach attem pts, i f not to e ra d ic a te , a t le a s t

(27)

to d e fu s e by m aking i t e x p l i c i t . Such p e rs o n a l i n c l i n a t i o n s a r e bound, w ittin g ly or not, in to a s e t of common bundles of philosophy. These bundles can g en erally be gathered in to a meta-aim, independent of philosophy, which i s t o attem pt to solve problems.

Im portant research i s norm ally to be found by s o rtin g out from th e mass of co m p etin g p ro b lem s th o s e p ro b lem s w h ich m a tte r . The r e s o l v i n g of su ch p ro b le m s o c c u rs a t th e p o in t w here s u b je c t iv e o p in io n i s c o n v e rte d i n t o o b je c tiv e knowledge. This i s , i n i t s e l f , the su b ject of co n sid erab le heated debate both as reg ard s th e a re a s of le g itim a te in t e r e s t i n r e a l i t y and a s reg ard s how o b je c tiv e knowledge i s procured and defined.

For th e p resen t purposes i t i s p o ssib le to put forw ard a general view th a t the bare minimum requirem ent to be aimed f o r i n a piece of r e s e a rc h i s th a t the proposed s o lu tio n must be in te r n a lly and e x te rn a lly c o n s is te n t and th a t i t must be dem onstrably sex I t must be in te r n a lly c o n s is te n t in s o fa r a s the lo g ic o f th e reasoning i n th e s o lu tio n must conform to a r a ti o n a l norm. I t must be e x te rn a lly o o n siste n t because the devised conceptual scheme must be capable of f i t t i n g and, by v ir tu e of the form er q u a lity , of ex p lain in g th e s itu a tio n in some way.

Research th e re fo re a tte m p ts to provide n o n - tr iv ia l and r a tio n a l ex p lan atio n s o f observed events, independent of personal, and id e a lly of tem poral and lo c a tio n a l co n sid era tio n s.

T h is c h a p te r w i l l a tte m p t t o i d e n t i f y th e ap p ro ach to be a d o p te d i n th e p resen t th e s is a s re g a rd s both in te r n a l and ex te rn a l consistency.

b) The disadvantages o f not d efin in g an appropriate p h ilosop h ical approach

Whether or not an in d iv id u a l i s aware of i t , he must, of n e c e ssity , adopt some ph ilo so p h ical stance i n h is a tte m p ts to reso lv e problems i n r e a l i t y .

Returning to the previously id e n tif ie d schodboy a t the bus stop ; he stay s w a itin g th e re because:

i ) He knows th a t th e 8.30 am. bus has not gone past th e stop,

i i ) He knows th a t a bus norm ally le a v e s and i s tim e ta b le d t o leav e the bus depot to reach th e stop ty 8.30 am.

i i i ) He knows from p ast experience th a t t r a f f i c and passenger boarding in buses can le ad t o delays.

(28)

iv) He reasons th a t under normal conditions, and th e re was n e ith e r snow nor f r o s t th a t morning, he can a n tic ip a te th e b is to a r r iv e a t some tim e in the near fu tu re , and w ait a

v) He c o n s id e r s t h e p o s s i b i l i t y , as tim e g o es on, o f w a lk in g , or of b icy clin g sin ce h is school i s not f a r away,

v i) He may n o t, how ever, c o n s id e r th e p o s s i b i l i t y o f a t a x i , o r o f c h a rte rin g a h e lic o p te r, or of r e tu rn in g home to take a l i f t from h is parents, since they may not have the necessary resources.

Now, the schoolboy w i l l not consider the philo so ph ical im p lic a tio n s of these reasoning p ro cessea There are, however, im plied sta te m e n ts reg arding th e nature of lo g ic, the ep istem o lo g ical c o n sid era tio n s of how the problem should be app ro ached , and a n o n to l o g ic a l s ta te m e n t r e g a r d in g t h e n a t u r e of th e r e a l i t y in which the problem of g e ttin g to school ta k es place.

A ch ild i n th e same s itu a tio n from a more a f f lu e n t background could see th e problem d if f e r e n tly , a s he may w ell be able to affo rd a ta x i, or to take a l i f t from horna

Likewise, th e c h ild who reaso ns th a t i f the 8.30 am. bus does not a rr iv e by t h a t tim e th e n i t i s th e a c t o f a b e n e v o le n t God w hich h e i n t e r p r e t s a s in d ic a tin g th e n ece ssity fo r takin g th e day o ff as a tru an t.

And so on, ad in fin itu m .^

The p h ilo s o p h ic a l o u tlo o k i s th u s i n e v i t a b l y p r e s e n t. Under e x i s t i n g con ditio ns in th e United Kingdom i t i s thought th a t th e most l i k e ly schoolboy o p tio n scen ario s would be contained w ith in th e f i r s t two p o s s i b ili ti e s . Such a l i k e l i h o o d i s , how ever, d e te rm in e d a t t h a t l e v e l o f problem s o lv in g by c u r r e n t s o c i a l and econom ic c r i t e r i a , and i s p ro b a b ly n o t a te m p o ra l and lo c a tio n independent observation.

The v i t a l point i s th a t th e philosop hical outlook d e fin e s th e way in which the problem i s seen, and th e way i n w hich a s o l u t i o n i s so u g h t. In s h o r t, philoso ph ical outlook has a d efin in g im pact upon th e way in which a problem so lv e r tr e a t s w ith h is m a te ria l.

In order to f u l f i l l th e b asic aim of research, which i s o b je c tiv ity , and since i t i s im p o s s ib le t o ap p ro ach a problem w ith o u t some p h ilo s o p h ic a l

(29)

p re c o n c e p tio n s , i t s h o u ld th e r e f o r e be a fu n d a m e n ta l du ty of th e problem so lv er to s ta te what stance he proposes taking, This i s im p o rtan t for two reasons.

F ir s tly , an a p r io r i attem pt to re so lv e such approach problems should have a b e n e fic ia l im pact upon the q u a lity of the s o lu tio n s being proposed I t w ill norm ally impose a s trin g e n t mode of s e l f c r itic is m p a r tic u la r ly in th e f ie l d of the in te r n a l consistency but also i n term s of the e x te rn a l consistency of th e approach to a problem. Moreover, as i t extends th e re s p o n s ib ility of the problem so lv er back to the borders of m etaphysics, I t e x p l ic it ly opens up th e maximum spectrum of th e su b ject m a tter of th e problem and of th e adopted approach to close scru tin y .

Hence th e second a rea of im portance; not only does t h i s approach open th e m a te ria l to s e l f c r itic is m , but by making i t e x p lic it, i t also opens i t to the re fin in g or r e f u tin g c r itic is m of other problem -solver a

This i s of p a r tic u la r im portance, not simply because i t I s seen a s a m a tter o f in t e ll e c tu a l honesty, but because the philo sop hical v a ria b le should u ltim a te ly be a s trin g e n tly d e fin a b le v a ria b le i n the approach to problem a As such the attem p t should be made to Id e n tify i t c le a rly , as even lim ite d a l te r a t io n s in t h i s v a ria b le may have a profound impact upon r e s u l t s and thus upon proposed s o lu tio n s to problems.

The un stated presum ptions of th e f l a t e a r t h e r s may henceforth be avoided

What are th e o p tio n s a s reg ard s d if f e r e n t ph iloso ph ies?

I t h a s been o b s e rv e d t h a t t h e r e e x i s t s a w ide ran g e and v a r i e t y of philosophies, and i t has been argued th a t i t i s im p o rtan t when undertaking research to make the p a r tic u la r philosophy adopted e x p l ic it in s o fa r as th a t i s p o ssible. There must e x is t, th e re fo re , an apparent choice fo r the in d iv id u a l r e s e a r c h e r . The c h o ic e i t s e l f and th e r a t i o n a l e f o r th e d e c i s i o n making process of choosing w i l l vary from person to person fo r a number of reasons w hich r e v o lv e aro un d p e r s o n a l i t y , and around e x p e rie n c e . T here i s an in te r r e la tio n s h ip between these two which seems to compound the divergence of c o n flic tin g p h ilo so p h ies: an a l b e i t lim ite d reading of philosophy does not in d ic a te any tendancy tow ards the c la s s ic d ia le c t ic approach to problems.

P e r s o n a li ty , In a n o n - s p e c if i c and g e n e r a l se n se , i s th u s o f c r i t i c a l

(30)

im portance i n the d e c isio n as to the ap p ro p ria te p h ilo so p h ical approach to a problem . T his i n d i c a t e s two im p o r ta n t p o in t s ; f i r s t l y , q u e s ti o n s o f p e r s o n a l i t y demand f u r t h e r d e t a i l e d i n v e s t i g a t i o n i n t h i s c h a p te r , and secondly, from here on th e su b ject m a tte r i s o v e rtly personal, a l b e i t tre a te d i n an o b je c tiv e fashion.

a) Do we have any option?

I t i s u n r e a l i s t i c , to suppose t h a t i n d i v i d u a l s , g ro u p s o f i n d i v i d u a l s , s o c ie tie s , and groups of s o c ie tie s , w ill ever agree upon a b a sic philosophy of l i f e . This makes i t unproductive i n view of the s ta te d aim s of research, to attem p t to s e le c t a p a r tic u la r view point favoured by p a r tic u la r p a r tie s a t a p a r t i c u l a r tim e w ith a view to e s t a b l i s h i n g i t i n p e r p e t u ity . The m ost a p p r o p r ia te a p p ro ac h , even i f o n ly from a p ra g m a tic p o in t o f v ie w , i s to u t i l i s e the o n to lo g ical and ep istem o lo g ical schemes th a t appear to present th e n e a re st to ab so lu te given the re s e a rc h e r’s p ercep tio n of the c u rre n t s ta te of knowledge. I t i s in trig u in g to propose th a t those of d if f e r e n t philo sop hical p e r s u a s io n s may u l t i m a t e l y be a b le t o i d e n t i f y and e x t r a c t v a lu a b le i n f o r m a tio n from such an a n a l y s i s i n th e a b s o lu t e by s e l e c t i n g from and i n t e r p r e t i n g th e v ie w s p re s e n te d a c c o r d in g t o t h e i r l e v e l and mode of understanding.

In order to achieve such an id e a l s itu a tio n th e u ltim a te requirem ent would be to be able to p resen t the p h ilo so p h ical approach i n axdcm atised fash ion , a s a s e r i e s o f axiom s none o f w hich i s e i t h e r s u b je c t d e p e n d e n t o r problem d ep en d en t w hich w ould prod uce a p h il o s o p h i c a l re g im e t o w h ich a l l o th e r lo g ic a lly v a lid regim es would reduce.®

In answ er to th e q u e s t i o n a s t o w h e th e r t h e r e e x i s t s any r e a l c h o ic e i n philosophy the answer must th e re fo re be a ffirm a tiv e . I t i s w orthw hile b r ie f ly i l l u s t r a t i n g t h i s by looking a t p a r tic u la r areas of philosophy in o rd er to try to id e n tify the d if f e r e n t im pact of d if f e r e n t ph iloso ph ies upon a b i l i t y to achieve the aims of research,

b) What op tion s do we have?

Lau Tsu w ritin g i n th e six th century B. C. :

"In the p u rs u it of le arn in g , every day something i s aoquired. In th e p u rs u it of Tao, every day something i s dropped.

(31)

U ntil no n-actio n i s achieved.

When nothing i s done, nothing i s l e f t undone.

The world i s ru led by l e t t i n g th in g s take th e ir course. I t cannot be ru led by in te r f e r in g . " ^

Dhirendra M D atta w ritin g i n 1961:

"P h ilo so p h y , o f even th e m ost c a t h o l i c k in d , i f c o n fin e d t o mere i n t e ll e c tu a l d iscu ssio n , w ill rem ain a h e lp le s s s p e c ta to r o f war, in trig u e and d e v a s ta tio n rep ea ted ly c a rrie d on by persons w ith narrow outlooks and u n co n tro lled passions."

Karl Marx w ritin g i n 1845:

"Thephilosophers have only in te rp re te d th e w orld i n v a rio u s ways; the point i s to change i t ." ^

J . S. M ill in h is essay "On L ib erty " w rote i n 1859:

"The o b j e c t o f t h i s E s s a y i s t o a s s e r t o n e v e r y s im p l e p r i n c i p l e . . . t h a t th e s o le end f o r w hich mankind a r e w a rra n te d , in d iv id u a lly or c o lle c tiv e ly , i n i n t e r f e r i n g w ith th e l i b e r t y o f a c tio n o f . any of t h e i r number i s s e lf - p r o te c tio n ., to prevent harm to o th e r s ... The o n ly freed o m w hich d e s e r v e s th e name i s t h a t of pursuing our own good in„our own way, so long as we do not a tte m p t to deprive o th e rs of t h e i r a "

K. R. Popper w ritin g i n 1969:

"...the main t a s k o f th e s o c i a l s c ie n c e s . I t i s t o t r a c e th e 1 ? unintended s o c ia l repercussions o f in ten tio n a l human actions."

Five d if f e r e n t philosophers, f iv e d if f e r e n t p hilosop hies and f i v e d if f e r e n t approaches to problems.

There i s no n ece ssity fo r th e p resen t purposes to attem p t to o u tlin e the range of o ptio ns in philosophy, fo r th a t would border upon an i n f i n i t e ta sk ; nor i s th e re a n ece ssity to review th e general areas of agreement and disagreem ent, fo r th i s i s not a p h ilo so p h ical tr e a tis e .

\

The principle^ p resen t concern I s to id e n tif y those approaches which most clo sely r e l a t e to the o p tio n s itu a tio n p referred abova The approach to be adopted fo r th e p resen t purposes may then be id e n tif ie d . W hilst t h i s im p lie s a general knowledge le v e l of background in fo rm atio n on a range of philoso ph ies i n o rd e r to p ro v id e c o n te x tu a l in d e x in g , i t d oes n o t demand d e t a i l e d c o n s id e r a tio n of o th e r th a n th o s e id e a s t h a t a r e to be s p e c i f i c a l l y in co rp orated.

V a rio u s e le m e n ts and id e a s put fo rw a rd by w o rk e rs i n r e l e v a n t a r e a s o f

&

(32)

philosophy th e re fo re re q u ire to be examined and pieced to g e th e r to form an i n t e g r a t e d s t r u c t u r e . Such a s t r u c t u r e m ust n o t o n ly s a t i s f y th o s e requirem ents s p e c ifie d above which r e la te predominantly to th e academic and th e o re tic a l sph eres; i t must a lso r e l a t e stro n g ly to the sphere of praxis.

The so cial sciences, geography, and t h e i r a p p lic a tio n in th e development, or any, p la n n in g p ro c e s s m ust n e c e s s a r i l y be f i r m l y f i x e d i n th e p r a c t i c a l world. Unless m a te ria l r e s u l t s th a t can be m eaningfully ap p lied i n such an area of o p eratio n , a tte m p ts to solve ou tstan ding problems a re i n v a in

I t i s t h e r e f o r e im p o r ta n t, b e f o re d e t a i l i n g t h e o r i e s o f know ledge and o f r e a l i t y , to look more c lo se ly a t the p r a c tic a l req u irem en ts th a t r e q u ire to be f u l f i l l e d by ary proposed s o lu tio n s to problems i n th e development planning

process. At th i s p r e th e o r e tic a l stag e a general overview may be adopted in t h e know ledge t h a t m ore d e t a i l e d r e q u ir e m e n ts w i l l be f u l f i l l e d i n th e th e o re tic a l d isc u ssio n below.

What i s required o f our philosophy in praxis?

In th i s f i r s t in sta n c e , i t may be s ta te d th a t what i s re q u ire d i n r e l a t i o n to any given problem i s i t s so lu tio n .

The development planning process may be taken as being a process imposed upon a fu n ctio n in g qystem covering a defined geographical a re a w ith a view to achieving c e rta in , norm ally s ta te d a irn s .^

The prim e o b j e c t i v e of t h i s p r o c e s s m ust be t o e n a b le th e p r o v is io n of a s o l u t i o n o r s e t of s o l u t i o n s t h a t w i l l r e s u l t i n t h e f u l f i l l m e n t of th e req u ire d aims, w ithout sid e e f f e c t a I t must, in o th e r words, enable the im plem entation of a unique d ire c te d s e t of events and a c t i v i t i e s to produce a unique p red ic ted s e t of r e s u l t a

In sh o rt, i t must work.

This requirem ent pioses a l l s o r ts of problems fo r th e philosophy to be adopted, and w ill p erforce demand f u r th e r a t t e n t i o a

References

Related documents

Ingenierías, Telecomunicaciones Electronic Engineering, Telecommunications Informática Informatics, Computer Science CAFYDE Physical Education, Sport Science

While firms with high leverage and more fixed rate debt retain more liquidity, those with lower leverage and more floating rate debt tend to have higher operating cash flows..

Effective teacher induction programs can support and assist beginning teachers in.. becoming successful practitioners, thus impacting the performance and

An estimate of the relative contribution of the CCER strategy versus the SBA strategy for reducing maternal deaths can be established, although available data do not provide the

In addition, as part of the data collection, a standardized form was used for all deliveries on which the following would be recorded immediately after

• Designed and implemented a special orientation program by working together with International and National Exchange Students.. • Initiated UH Hilo participation in the UH

Several Member States (Belgium, Denmark, France and the United Kingdom) experienced a certain recovery of industrial production in June ; in the Federal Republic of Germany