Margin Requirements & Margin Calls

(1)

Margin Requirements & Margin Calls

Dr. Patrick Toche

References :

† Zvi Bodie, Alex Kane, Alan J. Marcus. Essentials of Investment. McGraw-Hill Irwin.

(2)

In this chapter you will learn...

I buying on margin

I margin accounts

I initial margin

(3)

In this chapter you will learn...

I buying on margin I margin accounts

I initial margin

I maintenance margin

(4)

In this chapter you will learn...

I buying on margin I margin accounts I initial margin

(5)

In this chapter you will learn...

(6)

In this chapter you will learn...

(7)

Buying On Margin

I The practice of purchasing securities with cash borrowed from a broker is referred to as “buying on margin”.

I The percentage margin is defined as the equity value

con-tributed by an investor as a percentage of the current market value of the securities held in the margin account.

I Margin trading is risky because both gains and losses are

am-plified.

I Cash and securities held in the margin account are used as collateral for the margin loan.

(8)

Buying On Margin

I The percentage margin is defined as the equity value con-tributed by an investor as a percentage of the current market value of the securities held in the margin account.

I Margin trading is risky because both gains and losses are

am-plified.

I Cash and securities held in the margin account are used as

collateral for the margin loan.

(9)

Buying On Margin

I Margin trading is risky because both gains and losses are am-plified.

I Cash and securities held in the margin account are used as

collateral for the margin loan.

I Minimum margin requirements are used to protect brokers from

(10)

Buying On Margin

I Minimum margin requirements are used to protect brokers from

(11)

Buying On Margin

(12)

Regulation T

I Regulation T sets rules on the extension of credit by securities brokers and dealers in the U.S.

I Regulation T sets minimum margin requirements for stocks

bought on margin.

I Since 1974, the initial margin requirement for margin stock

purchases has been50%.

I In other countries, brokerage firms are free to set their own margin requirements.

(13)

Regulation T

I Regulation T sets minimum margin requirements for stocks bought on margin.

I Since 1974, the initial margin requirement for margin stock

purchases has been50%.

I In other countries, brokerage firms are free to set their own

margin requirements.

(14)

Regulation T

I Since 1974, the initial margin requirement for margin stock purchases has been50%.

I In other countries, brokerage firms are free to set their own

margin requirements.

I The U.K. has a more relaxed standard than the U.S. and this

accounts for the rapid growth of the hedge fund industry there.

(15)

Regulation T

I The U.K. has a more relaxed standard than the U.S. and this

accounts for the rapid growth of the hedge fund industry there.

I The firm Interactive Brokers state “we apply the Regulation T

(16)

Regulation T

I The U.K. has a more relaxed standard than the U.S. and this accounts for the rapid growth of the hedge fund industry there.

I The firm Interactive Brokers state “we apply the Regulation T

(17)

Regulation T

(18)

Maintenance Margin

I The percentage margin is defined as the ratio of the equity value of the account to the market value of the securities.

I Suppose an investor contributes $6, 000to purchase $10, 000

worth of stock at$100per share, borrowing the remaining$4, 000

from a broker. The investor thus buys100shares.

I The initial percentage margin is:

margin= value of equity

value of securities=

$6, 000

$10, 000 = 60%

I If the price declines to$70per share, the value of the securities falls to100 × $70 = $7, 000and the value of the equity falls to

$7, 000 − $4, 000 = $3, 000. I The percentage margin falls:

$3, 000

(19)

Maintenance Margin

I The percentage margin is defined as the ratio of the equity value of the account to the market value of the securities. I Suppose an investor contributes $6, 000to purchase $10, 000

worth of stock at$100per share, borrowing the remaining$4, 000 from a broker. The investor thus buys100shares.

I The initial percentage margin is:

$6, 000

$10, 000 = 60%

I If the price declines to$70per share, the value of the securities

falls to100 × $70 = $7, 000and the value of the equity falls to

$7, 000 − $4, 000 = $3, 000.

I The percentage margin falls: margin= value of equity

$3, 000

(20)

Maintenance Margin

I The initial percentage margin is: margin= value of equity

$6, 000

$10, 000 = 60%

I If the price declines to$70per share, the value of the securities

falls to100 × $70 = $7, 000and the value of the equity falls to

$7, 000 − $4, 000 = $3, 000.

I The percentage margin falls:

$3, 000

(21)

Maintenance Margin

$6, 000

$10, 000 = 60%

I If the price declines to$70per share, the value of the securities falls to100 × $70 = $7, 000and the value of the equity falls to $7, 000 − $4, 000 = $3, 000.

I The percentage margin falls:

$3, 000

(22)

Maintenance Margin

$6, 000

$10, 000 = 60%

I If the price declines to$70per share, the value of the securities falls to100 × $70 = $7, 000and the value of the equity falls to $7, 000 − $4, 000 = $3, 000.

I The percentage margin falls: margin= value of equity

$3, 000

(23)

Margin Call

I Suppose the maintenance margin is 30%. How far could the stock price fall before the investor would get a margin call?

I LetPbe the price of the stock. The value of the investor’s 100

shares is then 100P, and the equity in the account is100P −

$4, 000. The percentage margin for any pricePis:

value of securities =

100P − 4, 000 100P

I The price at which the percentage margin equals the

mainte-nance margin of30%is the solution of:

100P − 4, 000

100P = 0.3

I Solving the equation yieldsP= $57.14.

(24)

Margin Call

I Suppose the maintenance margin is 30%. How far could the stock price fall before the investor would get a margin call? I LetPbe the price of the stock. The value of the investor’s 100

shares is then 100P, and the equity in the account is100P − $4, 000. The percentage margin for any pricePis:

margin= value of equity value of securities =

100P − 4, 000 100P

I The price at which the percentage margin equals the

mainte-nance margin of30%is the solution of:

100P − 4, 000

100P = 0.3

(25)

Margin Call

100P − 4, 000 100P

I The price at which the percentage margin equals the mainte-nance margin of30%is the solution of:

100P − 4, 000 100P = 0.3

I The investor gets a margin call if the price of the stock falls

(26)

Margin Call

100P − 4, 000 100P

100P − 4, 000 100P = 0.3 I Solving the equation yieldsP= $57.14.

I The investor gets a margin call if the price of the stock falls

(27)

Margin Call

100P − 4, 000 100P

100P − 4, 000 100P = 0.3 I Solving the equation yieldsP= $57.14.

(28)

Buying On Margin: Worksheet Application

(29)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Leverage refers to the practice of using borrowed funds to trade in financial and other markets.

I Investors leverage their exposure to financial investments by

borrowing from their broker.

I Investors increase their leverage when they buy securities on

margin.

I Buying on margin can achieve greater upside potential... I ... but exposes investors to greater downside risk!

(30)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Investors leverage their exposure to financial investments by borrowing from their broker.

I Investors increase their leverage when they buy securities on

margin.

I Buying on margin can achieve greater upside potential...

I ... but exposes investors to greater downside risk!

(31)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Investors increase their leverage when they buy securities on margin.

(32)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Margin loans are also subject to margin interest fees. The

(33)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Margin loans are also subject to margin interest fees. The

(34)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

(35)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Suppose IBM stock is selling for $100 per share. A bullish investor with$10, 000 to invest expects the price of IBM to go up by30%during the next year.

I Ignoring dividends, the expected rate of return would be30%if

the investor invested$10, 000to buy100shares.

I Assume the investor borrows another$10, 000from the broker

and invests it in IBM too, for a total of$20, 000for200shares.

I Assume an interest rate on the margin loan of9%per year. I Ignoring dividends, what is the investor’s rate of return if IBM

(36)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Ignoring dividends, the expected rate of return would be30%if the investor invested$10, 000to buy100shares.

I Assume the investor borrows another$10, 000from the broker

and invests it in IBM too, for a total of$20, 000for200shares.

I Assume an interest rate on the margin loan of9%per year.

(37)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Assume the investor borrows another$10, 000from the broker and invests it in IBM too, for a total of$20, 000for200shares.

I Assume an interest rate on the margin loan of9%per year.

I Ignoring dividends, what is the investor’s rate of return if IBM

(38)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Assume the investor borrows another$10, 000from the broker and invests it in IBM too, for a total of$20, 000for200shares. I Assume an interest rate on the margin loan of9%per year.

I Ignoring dividends, what is the investor’s rate of return if IBM

(39)

Buying on Margin: Leverage

I Assume the investor borrows another$10, 000from the broker and invests it in IBM too, for a total of$20, 000for200shares. I Assume an interest rate on the margin loan of9%per year. I Ignoring dividends, what is the investor’s rate of return if IBM

(40)

Leverage: Upside Potential

I The 200shares will be worth$26, 000. Paying off $10, 900 of principal and interest leaves:

$26, 000 − $10, 900 = $15, 100.

I The rate of return is:

rate of return =$15, 100 − $10, 000

$10, 000 = 51%

I The 30%rise in the stock’s price has returned a 51%rate of

return on the$10, 000investment!

(41)

Leverage: Upside Potential

$26, 000 − $10, 900 = $15, 100. I The rate of return is:

rate of return =$15, 100 − $10, 000

$10, 000 = 51%

I The 30%rise in the stock’s price has returned a 51%rate of

return on the$10, 000investment!

I The margin loan allows the investor to leverage the trade.

(42)

Leverage: Upside Potential

rate of return =$15, 100 − $10, 000

$10, 000 = 51%

I The 30%rise in the stock’s price has returned a 51%rate of return on the$10, 000investment!

(43)

Leverage: Upside Potential

rate of return =$15, 100 − $10, 000

$10, 000 = 51%

(44)

Leverage: Upside Potential

rate of return =$15, 100 − $10, 000

$10, 000 = 51%

(45)

Leverage: Downside Risk

I . . . but the downside risk is greater!

I Suppose that the price of IBM stock goes down by30%to$70

per share.

I The 200shares are now worth $14, 000 and, after paying off

the$10, 900 of principal and interest on the loan, the investor

is left with$3, 100.

rate of return =$3, 100 − $10, 000

(46)

Leverage: Downside Risk

I Suppose that the price of IBM stock goes down by30%to$70 per share.

I The 200shares are now worth $14, 000 and, after paying off

the$10, 900 of principal and interest on the loan, the investor

is left with$3, 100.

rate of return =$3, 100 − $10, 000

(47)

Leverage: Downside Risk

I The 200shares are now worth $14, 000 and, after paying off the$10, 900 of principal and interest on the loan, the investor is left with$3, 100.

rate of return =$3, 100 − $10, 000

(48)

Leverage: Downside Risk

I The 200shares are now worth $14, 000 and, after paying off the$10, 900 of principal and interest on the loan, the investor is left with$3, 100.

rate of return =$3, 100 − $10, 000

(49)

Summary

1. Buying on margin means borrowing money from a broker to buy more securities than can be purchased with one’s own money alone.

2. By buying securities on a margin, an investor magnifies both

the upside potential and the downside risk.

3. If the equity in a margin account falls below the required

(50)

Summary

2. By buying securities on a margin, an investor magnifies both the upside potential and the downside risk.

3. If the equity in a margin account falls below the required

(51)

Summary

2. By buying securities on a margin, an investor magnifies both the upside potential and the downside risk.

(52)

Problems and Applications

1. You are bullish on Telecom stock. The current market price is $50per share, and you have$5, 000of your own to invest. You borrow an additional$5, 000from your broker at an interest rate of8%per year and invest$10, 000in the stock.

a. What will be your rate of return if the price of

Telecom stock goes up by10%during the next year? (Ignore the expected dividend.)

(53)

Problems and Applications

Telecom stock goes up by10%during the next year?

(Ignore the expected dividend.)

b. How far does the price of Telecom stock have to fall

for you to get a margin call if the maintenance

margin is30%? Assume the price fall happens

(54)

Problems and Applications

b. How far does the price of Telecom stock have to fall

for you to get a margin call if the maintenance

margin is30%? Assume the price fall happens

(55)

Problems and Applications

(56)

Problems and Applications

2. Suppose that you sell short500shares of Intel, currently selling for$40per share, and give your broker$15, 000to establish your margin account.

a. If you earn no interest on the funds in your margin account, what will be your rate of return after 1 year if Intel stock is selling at: (i)$44; (ii)$40; (iii)$36? Assume that Intel pays no dividends.

(57)

Problems and Applications

a. If you earn no interest on the funds in your margin

account, what will be your rate of return after 1 year if Intel stock is selling at: (i)$44; (ii)$40; (iii)$36? Assume that Intel pays no dividends.

b. If the maintenance margin is25%, how high can

(58)

Problems and Applications

b. If the maintenance margin is25%, how high can

(59)