• No results found

Immigration Compliance for the Restaurant and Foodservice Industry: What to Do BEFORE (and After) the Government Comes Knocking

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Immigration Compliance for the Restaurant and Foodservice Industry: What to Do BEFORE (and After) the Government Comes Knocking"

Copied!
28
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

Immigration Compliance for the

Restaurant and Foodservice Industry:

What to Do BEFORE (and After) the

Government Comes Knocking

March 4, 2012

Presented by Kristine A. Sova and Dismas N. Locaria of Venable LLP

(2)

Renewed Enforcement Focus on

Hiring of Undocumented Workers

 Since 2009, the Obama Administration has been targeting employer compliance with I-9 paperwork

 The result?

– Drastic increase in I-9 audits conducted by U.S. Immigration and Customs and Enforcement (ICE)

(3)

Renewed Enforcement Focus on

Hiring of Undocumented Workers

(cont’d)

• The figures?

FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011

Penalties $1.03 million $6.9 million $10.4 million

Criminal Charges 114 business owners and managers 187 business owners and managers 221 business owners and managers

(4)

Renewed Enforcement Focus on

Hiring of Undocumented Workers

(cont’d)

 Who is being targeted?

– Large OR small companies

– Companies that are the subject of a tip or lead – Companies that are the subject of audit or

investigation by any other governmental agency – Specific industries, such as the restaurant industry

(5)

What is at stake with an I-9 audit?

 At the ICE level:

– Knowingly hiring and continuing to employ

violations – $375 to $16,000, with repeat offenders receiving penalties at higher end

– Paperwork violations – $110 to $1,100 for each violation

– Debarment by ICE with respect to participation in future federal contracts and from receiving other

(6)

What is at stake with an I-9 audit?

(cont’d)

 Other: – RICO claims – Discrimination complaints – Shareholder suits

(7)

Debarment

 A lesser known, but potentially ruinous consequence of an Immigration and Nationality Act (“INA”) violation is debarment  Debarment is neither a criminal nor civil action, it is an

administrative action

– Not to be imposed for punishment

• To ensure the public interest is protected from unscrupulous businesses and individuals

– Entities and individuals are judged on whether they are “presently responsible”

(8)

Debarment (cont’d)

INA Basis for Debarment

– A company or individual may be debarred if:

• It is a government contractor; and

• There exists a basis for debarment

– Pursuant to Executive Order 12989, an INA violation is a basis for at least a one-year debarment

– Conviction of an INA violation is sufficient evidence

– An indictment is adequate evidence for suspension (a temporary debarment)

(9)

Debarment (cont’d)

 The real question is: Are you a “government contractor”?

 The Federal Acquisition Regulation defines a

government contractor as an entity/individual that: “Directly or indirectly (e.g., through an affiliate), submits offers for or is awarded, or reasonably may be expected to submit offers for or be

awarded, a Government contract…” 48 C.F.R. §9.403 (emphasis added)

(10)

Debarment (cont’d)

 ICE has taken a very expansive view of this definition – interpreting “reasonably may be expected,” to

include all companies/individuals located within the U.S.

 Based on this definition, ICE:

– Issues notices of proposed debarment to U.S. companies and individuals as a matter of course for INA violations

– To date, ICE has issued hundreds of notices of proposed debarment to entities/individuals, many of which are not traditional government contractors

(11)

Debarment (cont’d)

Year Entity Debarments Individual Debarments

2011 97 115

2010 97 49

2009 30 53

(12)

Ramifications of Debarment

Ramifications of Debarment:

– Prohibits the awarding of new contracts or

subcontracts from the Federal government

– Listing on public websites:

• Excluded Parties List System (EPLS)

• Federal Awardee Performance and

(13)

Ramifications of Debarment

(cont’d)

Practical implications for entities that are not

traditional federal contractors?

– State/local governments inquire as to federal debarment status before awarding contracts

– Large private entities inquire as to debarment status • Government contractors cannot subcontract with

debarred entities

• Do not want to be associated with debarred entities – Reputational harm

(14)

Ramifications of Debarment

(cont’d)

Individual debarment

– In addition to above implications, ineligible to participate in federal subsidized programs –

federally backed home loans, federally subsidized student loans, etc.

– Remain eligible for public entitlements (e.g., social security benefits, etc.)

– Listed on the EPLS and FAPIIS

– Cannot hold a principal, board, executive or managerial position with an entity that receives federal contracts or subcontracts

(15)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond

 Inspection process begins with service of Notice of

Inspection (NOI) on employer – notice compels production of I-9 forms

 NOI will also often request supporting documentation – i.e., payroll, current list of employees, Articles of Incorporation, and business licenses, as well as no-match letters issued by Social Security Administration (SSA)

(16)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond (cont’d)

Employer Response to NOI:

– Insist on 3 business days’ notice before inspection of I-9 forms (this is minimum amount of notice the federal agency must provide)

– Document any communications with government – Keep a copy of all documents provided to

government

(17)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond (cont’d)

 Government will notify audited employer of results of inspection, in writing, once completed

 Types of Notices:

– Notice of Inspection Results – Notice of Suspect Documents – Notice of Discrepancies

– Notice of Technical or Procedural Failures – Warning Notice

(18)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond (cont’d)

Notice of Intent to Fine (NIF)

– Charging documents will be provided specifying the violations committed by the employer

– Employer can either negotiate a settlement or request a hearing before the Office of the Chief Administrative Hearing Officer (OCAHO) within 30 days of receipt of the NIF

– If employer takes no action after receiving a NIF, ICE will issue a Final Order

– If hearing is requested, OCAHO assigns case to an

Administrative Law Judge, and sends all parties a copy of a Notice of Hearing and government’s complaint, putting the adjudicative process in motion

(19)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond (cont’d)

 Determination of Recommended Fines in NIF is based on a formula involving:

– Percentage relating to violations and number of employees

– Tiered fine schedule

(20)

ICE Audit: What to Expect and

How to Respond (cont’d)

Challenging Debarments

– Administrative process

• Respond to notice in writing

• In-person meeting with ICE debarment official – Adverse final decisions

• Seek reconsideration

(21)

I-9 and Employment Eligibility

“Best” Practices

 Properly Completing an I-9 Form  Self-Audit of I-9 Forms

 Compliance Plan

(22)

Properly Completing the Form I-9,

Employment Eligibility

Verification Form

 Employers must complete an I-9 form each time they hire any person to perform labor or services in the U.S. in return for wages or other renumeration (e.g., food and lodging).

 The form requires that the employee present his/her employer an original document or documents showing his/her identity and employment authorization within 3 business days of the date employment begins.

(23)

Properly Completing the Form I-9,

Employment Eligibility

Verification Form (cont’d)

 The I-9 form identifies proper forms of documentation that an employer may accept. (Note: Some aliens have and present an Individual Taxpayer Identification Number (ITIN) from the Internal Revenue Service to employers. An ITIN is

never acceptable for employment eligibility verification purposes.)

 Employer must re-verify an employee’s employment if the employee indicates that he/she is only authorized to work in

(24)

Guidelines for Self-Audits of I-9

Forms

 Confirm there is an I-9 form on file for: – Every current employee,

– Every employee hired within the last three years, whether or not still employed, and

– Every former employee who left employment within the previous year

 Discard any I-9 forms you are no longer required to maintain

 Confirm there is a consistent practice on photocopying supporting documents

 Confirm all I-9 forms are filled out completely and correctly – Be transparent about any corrections that are made – Complete new form for any required forms that are

(25)

Guidelines for Compliance Plans

• Plan should include:

– Description of roles/accountability of various departments and/or positions in your restaurant/organization

– Time-frames in which actions should occur – Mechanisms to address:

• Allegations that your restaurant’s workers are unauthorized • Discrepancies in payroll and identity information regarding

your employees

– Description of how and when certain issues should be escalated to upper management, in-house counsel, and outside counsel

– Union relations/obligations

• Conduct staff training on plan and ensure employees have the necessary tools to implement the plan

(26)

E-Verify / IMAGE Program / I-9

Compliance Software

E-Verify / IMAGE Program

– Pros: Mitigating factor

– Cons: Government access to employer information;

invitation/agreement to government audit; no safe harbor

I-9 Compliance Software

– Pros: Some programs assist with quality control; some programs store data online

– Cons: Not all programs comply with law/regulation, creating liability

(27)

Additional Resources

 For updates, go to: www.uscis.gov (select “Resources” and then “Get Email Updates”)

 Revised “Handbook for Employers (M-274)” from USCIS (revised June 1, 2011), available at:

www.uscis.gov/files/form/m-274.pdf

 I-9 Central (launched by USCIS in mid-May 2011) is a new online resource center that contains resources, tips, and guidance to properly complete the Form I-9, available at:

(28)

Questions?

Contact information:

Kristine A. Sova

212.808.5662

kasova@venable.com

Dismas N. Locaria

202.344.8013

dlocaria@venable.com

References

Related documents

For a single incoming phone line, all phones in the building will usually be wired using the RED and GREEN wires of the phone cord.. The other two wires, black and yellow, are

The case descriptions of grief are discussed in the context of substance misuse, mental health and the triggers associated with relapse in an attempt to further

non-farm functions.. • Enhanced Access to Broadband Service to Rural Areas provided $10 million-$20 million per year, FY2002-FY2007, in grants and loans. • Rural Local

This data descriptor presents the database of hydrographic (i.e., temperature and salinity) profiles obtained by instrumented seals in the Southern Indian Ocean.. This database is

Em razão da importância deste tipo de estudo com espécies florestais nativas, para as quais há ainda necessidade de muita informação, o presente trabalho teve por objetivo estudar

Because JFF is involved in supporting school implementation, the organization recommends specific and detailed policy changes for various states with clusters of early college