• No results found

bigbazaar case analysis

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "bigbazaar case analysis"

Copied!
30
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

BIG BAZAAR 

BIG BAZAAR 

Case Analysis

(2)

 Introduction

 Introduction

A

Abboouut t BBiig g BBaazzaaaarr HHyyppeer r mmaarrtt

Chain of development store in India

Chain of development store in India

Out

Out lelett MMoorree ththan 100an 100   outoutlelettss

L

Lococaatted in Indiaed in India

Pa

Par r enentt ggrouproup FFutur utur e ge grouproup

Ow

Ownener r  KisKishor hor e Biyani (CEe Biyani (CEO)O)

F

Fouounded nded 20012001

Head q

Head quuaartrteer r  JJoogesgeswwaar r i ,i , MumbMumbaiai

Ind

Induusstr tr y y ReRettailail

w

wee b bsisittee www.bwww.bigig b bazaazar.comr.com

T

(3)

M M 

ission And Vision

ission And Vision

VISION 

VISION 

F

Futur 

utur 

e G

e Group

roup

s

sh

hall delive

all deliver 

Eve

Ever 

y

yth

thing, Eve

ing, Ever 

y

ywh

whe

er 

e, Eve

e, Ever 

y

y

t

ti

im

me

e

or 

or Eve

Ever 

y Indian C

y Indian Co

ons

nsum

ume

er 

in

in

th

the

e

mo

mos

st

t

 pro

 profi

fit

ta

a

 b

 ble

le

m

manne

anner

r

.

.

 M M 

 ISSION 

 ISSION 

W

W

e s

e s

h

ha

ar 

e

e

th

the visi

e visio

on and

n and b

 belief 

elief th

tha

at

t

our 

our cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

s and

s and

s

st

take

akeho

holde

lder 

s s

s sh

hall

all

 b

 be se

e ser 

ved

ved

o

only

nly

 b

 by

y

cr 

cr 

ea

eat

ting and exe

ing and execut

cuting

ing

utur 

utur 

e s

e s

c

cena

enar 

i

io

os in

s in

th

the

e

co

cons

nsumpt

umpti

io

on s

n s

 p

 pa

ac

ce leading

e leading

to

to

e

eco

con

nom

om

i

ic

c

devel

(4)

P P 

ositioning And Establishment 

ositioning And Establishment 

Customers Segmentation

Customers Segmentation

B

Bi

ig

g

B

Ba

az

za

aa

ar

r

t

ta

ar 

ge

get

ts

s

h

hig

igh

he

er 

and

and

uppe

upp

er

r

m

middle

iddle

c

class

lass

cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

s

s.

.

Th

The

e

la

lar 

g

ge

e

a

an

nd

d

g

grow

rowi

in

ng

g

y

you

oung

ng

wor 

wor 

king

king

popu

popula

lat

ti

io

on

n

i

is

s

a

a

 pr 

 pr 

efe

eferr 

rr 

ed

ed

cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

seg

segm

men

ent.

t.

B

Bi

ig

g

B

Ba

az

za

aa

ar 

s

s

 p

 pe

ec

cifi

ific

cally

ally

ta

t

ar 

ge

get

ts

s

wor 

wor 

king

king

wom

wome

en

n

a

an

nd

d

hom

home

e

m

(5)

*

*HigHighh

or 

or ganizaganizattiioonn val

valuuee

*

*LLowow

cu

cusstomtomeer r valvaluuee

*

*HigHighh

or 

or ganizaganizattiioonn

val

valuuee

*

*HigHighh cucusstomtomee

val

valuuee

*

*LLowow

or 

or ganizaganizattiioonn val

valuuee

*

*LLowow

cu

cusstomtomeer r valvaluuee

*

*LLowow

or 

or ganizaganizattiioonn

val

valuuee

*

*LLowow

cu

cusstomtomeer r valvaluuee

(6)

 P P 

ositioning 

ositioning 

Hig Highh se ser r viviccee

llowow se ser r viviccee L

(7)

(8)

M M 

arketing 

arketing 

 M  M 

ix 

ix 

P Physicalhysical Evidence Evidence P Peopleeople P

Placelace PPromotionromotion

P Pricerice P Productroduct P Processrocess 7 7 µµPP¶¶

(9)

1.

1. P P 

roduct 

roduct 

 M  M 

ix 

ix 

A

APPPPARELSARELS

DDenims & T-enims &

T-Shirts

Shirts

Fabric & CutFabric & Cut

piece

piece

Formal WearFormal Wear

Casual WearCasual Wear

PParty Weararty Wear

Ethnic WearEthnic Wear   AccessoriesAccessories   UnderUnder Garments Garments 

Night WearNight Wear

DDress Materialsress Materials   SareesSarees FOO FOODD   StaplesStaples

Ready to eatReady to eat

Ready to cook Ready to cook    InternationalInternational Food Food   SpicesSpices

Imported BazaarImported Bazaar

Tea & CoffeeTea & Coffee

FARM

FARMPPRORODDUCTUCT

FruitsFruits

VegetablesVegetables

Imported FruitsImported Fruits

DDairyairyPProductsroducts

CHILL STATION

CHILL STATION

SoftSoftDDrinksrinks

PPackaged Juicesackaged Juices

Milk ItemsMilk Items

Frozen FoodsFrozen Foods

Ice CreamsIce Creams

HOME & HOME & P PERSONALERSONAL CARE CARE   ShampoosShampoos   DDetergentsetergents   SoapsSoaps

Liquid washLiquid wash

CreamsCreams

DDeodorantseodorants

HomHome cle cleanerseaners   UtensilsUtensils   PPlasticslastics   CrockeryCrockery   SundriesSundries

(10)

Living RoomLiving Room 

Bed RoomBed Room 

KitchenKitchen 

DDinning Roomsinning Rooms 

Kids RoomKids Room 

Been BagsBeen Bags 

PPaintingsaintings 

DDecorative Itemsecorative Items

 P 

 P 

roduct 

roduct 

 M  M 

ix continued«

ix continued«

 . .

ELECTRONICS ELECTRONICS

BAZAAR  BAZAAR 

Television setsTelevision sets   WashingWashing Machines Machines   RefrigeratorRefrigerator

PPersonal Careersonal Care

mBazaarmBazaar

MicrowavesMicrowaves

Small AppliancesSmall Appliances   LaptopsLaptops   ComputerComputer Accessories Accessories   KitchenKitchen Appliances Appliances FASHION & FASHION & JEWELLERY JEWELLERY 

Footwear BazaarFootwear Bazaar 

Beauty CareBeauty Care 

NavaraNavara 

StarStarPParivararivar 

MeenMeenaaBindrBindree

FURNITURE FURNITURE BAZAAR  BAZAAR 

CHIL

CHILDDCARE &CARE & TOYS TOYS

Kids WearKids Wear 

Toy BazaarToy Bazaar 

StationaryStationary 

Child CareChild Care

OTHER SERVICES OTHER SERVICES  Mr. rightMr. right  BakeryBakery 

Loot MartLoot Mart 

TulsiTulsi 

Future MoneyFuture Money 

(11)

2

2 . .  P  P 

rice mix 

rice mix 

VV

al

al

u

u

e

e

 pr 

 pr 

i

i

c

c

ing

ing

P

P

romot

romot

i

i

o

o

nal

nal

 pr 

 pr 

i

i

c

c

ing

ing

 LLowow inintteer r esestt finanfinanccinging

 PsyPsychocholloogigiccal disal discoucounnttinging

 SS p peeccial evenial eventt pr  pr iiccinging

Diffe

Diffe

en

en

t

t

ia

ia

t

t

ed P

ed P

i

i

c

c

ing

ing

 TTiimmee pr  pr iiccinging

(12)

Value

Value

 P  P 

ricing 

ricing 

Big

Big

 b

 bazaa

azaar 

 prom

 promises i

ises it

ts

s

co

cons

nsum

ume

er 

s

s

th

the

e

l

low

owes

est

t

availa

availa

 b

 ble

le

 pr 

 pr 

i

ic

ce

e

w

wi

ithout

thout

coupo

coupon

n

c

cli

li

 pp

 pping,

ing,

w

wai

ait

ting f 

ing f 

or 

or 

dis

discou

coun

nt

t

 promot

 promot

i

io

ons,

ns,

or 

or 

comp

compa

ar 

is

iso

on

n

s

(13)

P P 

romotional 

romotional 

 P  P 

ricing 

ricing 

Big

Big

 b

 bazaa

azaar 

o

offe

ffer 

s

s

finan

financ

cing a

ing at

t

l

low

ow

in

int

te

er 

es

est

t

a

at

te

e.

.

Th

The idea

e idea

o

of 

f u

using

sing

 p

 psy

sycho

chol

lo

ogi

gic

cal dis

al discou

coun

nt

ting

ing

(a

(at

t

s

s.

.

99 ,

99 ,

s

s.

.

49

49)

)

is

is

u

used

sed

as

as promot

 promoti

io

onal

nal

too

tool

l.

.

Th

They

ey

als

also

o

c

ca

at

te

er 

s

s

o

on s

n s

 p

 pe

ec

cial

ial

even

event

t

 pr 

 pr 

i

ic

cing

ing.

.

(

(

c

cl

lo

ose

se

to

to

di

(14)

DD

ifferentiated 

ifferentiated 

 P  P 

ricing 

ricing 

T

Ti

im

me

e

 pr 

 pr 

i

ic

cing i

ing i.

.e

e.

.

diffe

differ 

en

enc

ce in

e in

a

at

tes

es

 b

 based

ased

o

on

n p

 peak and n

eak and no

on

n

 p

 peak 

eak 

hour 

hour 

s

s

or 

or 

days

days

o

of s

f shopp

hopping

ing

is als

is also

o

a

a

o

one kind

ne kind

o

of 

 pr 

(15)

3 3 . .  P  P 

lace

lace

BIG BAZAR  BIG BAZAR  INDIA INDIA 

 N Numbumbeer r oof f outout lelet-

t-mor 

mor ee ththan 100an 100..

 LLococaatted aed att mmainain cciittyy-

-t

tieier r I &I & ttieier r cciittyy--II;II;

 AAr r eaea--10,000sq f 10,000sq f t- t-120000 sqf  120000 sqf tt;;   HigHighh sstr tr eeeett aar r eaea oof f  c ciitty; &y; &  AA ppro pproaachchaa b blele des

(16)

4

4 . .  P  P 

romotion

romotion

CCoupooupon, disn, discoucounntt,,mor mor ee ooththee pro prodductuct aatt nnormormalal

 pr 

 pr iicce, gif e, gif tt wwiithth purch purchase,ase, compcompeettiittiioon, andn, and pr  pr izes,izes,

mo

moneyney b baacck k ooffeffer r , ex, exchchangeange ooffeffer r , s, s p peeccialial occoccasiasioonn..

Big BazaaBig Bazaa, in ass, in assocociaiattiioonnwwiithth SSttaaIndia PvIndia Pvtt LLttd,d,

h

has laas lauunnchched aed a cocollellectctiioonnoof designef designer r eeththninicc wweaear r 

u

undender r ththee br  br and "Sand "Sttaar r PaPar r ivaaivaar r 

Bel

Below

ow

th

th

e

e

Line

Line

P

Promot

romoti

io

on

n

Giving adveGiving advertrtise in neise in newwss p paa p pee,, TTVV.. InIntteenenett ((owownn

w

wee b bsisittee whwhiichch givegive oonline snline shopphopping seing ser r viviccee)),,

ppaartrtnenesshhii p pwwiithth Bigfilx, Big FBigfilx, Big FMM 9292.7..7.

A

A

 bo

 bove

ve

th

the

e

Line

Line

P

(17)
(18)

5  . .  P  P 

eople

eople

w

well

ell

tr 

tr 

ained s

ained st

taff;

aff;

w

well

ell

s

su

ui

it

ted f 

ed f 

or 

or 

et

e

tail ind

ail indu

us

str 

tr 

y

y

.

.

e

emp

mpl

lo

oyees a

yees ar 

e

e

mot

motiva

ivat

ted

ed

to

to

th

think 

ink out

out

o

of 

f th

the

e

 bo

 box,

x,

to

to

t

take inn

ake inno

ova

vat

tive s

ive st

te

e

 p

 ps

s.

.

e

emp

mpl

lo

oyees

yees

c

cl

lo

ose

se

to

to

10000

10000

 p

 pe

eop

ople and

le and

e

ecru

crui

it

ts nea

s near 

ly

ly

500

500 p

 pe

eop

ople eve

le ever 

y

y

mo

mo

n

nth.

th.

U

Use

se

o

of 

f t

te

ech

chn

no

ol

lo

ogy like

gy like

s

sc

cena

enar 

i

io

o p

 planning f 

lanning f 

or 

or 

de

(19)

6  . .  P  P 

rocess

rocess

Th

The g

e goo

ood dis

d dis

 p

 pa

atch

tch

and

and

 purchasing a

 purch

asing ar 

ea

ea

h

has

as

c

ce

ert

rtain silen

ain silent

t

fea

featur 

tur 

e:

e:

mu

mul

lt

ti

i

 p

 ple

le

cou

coun

nt

te

er 

s

s

wi

w

ith

th

availa

availa

 b

 ble

le

trolleys

tro

lleys

to

to

c

ca

arr 

rr 

y

y

i

it

te

em

m

 purch

 purchased

ased.

.

P

Prop

rope

er 

dis

dis

 p

 play/

lay/

 po

 pos

st

te

er 

s

s

o

of 

f th

the

e

 p

 pla

lac

ce

e.

.

H

Hom

ome delive

e deliver 

y

y

cou

coun

nt

te

er 

s a

s ar 

e n

e now

ow

op

opened a

ened at

t

m

many

any

 p

(20)

7  . .  P  P 

hysical evidence

hysical evidence

I

It

t

deals

deals

w

wi

ith

th

th

the final delive

e final delive

a

a

 b

 ble

le

or 

or th

the dis

e dis

 p

 play

lay

o

of 

f wr 

wr 

i

itt

tten

en

fa

(21)

BB

rand Extension Actually

rand Extension Actually

 M 

 M 

ade And Future

ade And Future

 P  P 

ossibilities

ossibilities

Big Bazaar Big Bazaar Express Express (<40000 sq.ft) (<40000 sq.ft) Standard Standard Big Bazaar Big Bazaar (40000 to 80000sq. Ft) (40000 to 80000sq. Ft) Big Bazaar Big Bazaar Supercentres Supercentres (<75000 sq ft) (<75000 sq ft) In JV with In JV with Foreign

Foreign PPartnerartner Big Bazaar Big Bazaar Front end Front end operation operation Back-end Back-end Operation Operation

(22)

Consumer Insights And 

Consumer Insights And 

 P 

 P 

erceptions

erceptions

Big

Big

 b

 bazaa

azaar 

is

is b

 based

ased

o

on 3

n 3-

-C

C

th

the

eor 

or 

y

y

o

of Kis

f Kishor 

hor 

e

e

Biy

B

iyan

ani

i.

.

Th

The 3

e 3-

-C

C

de

det

te

erm

rm

ines

ines

change, confidence and consumption,

change, confidence and consumption,

and a

and accor 

ccor 

ding

ding

to

to

th

this

is

th

the

eor 

or 

y

y

, ³

, ³ch

change and

ange and

co

confiden

nfidenc

ce is leading

e is leading

to

to

ise in

ise in

co

cons

nsumpt

umpti

io

on´,

n´,

Th

They divided Indian

ey divided Indian

cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

s into

s in

to

3

3

c

ca

at

teg

egor 

or 

ies:

ies:

India

India

o

o

ne:

ne:

C

Co

ons

nsum

um

ing

ing

c

class,

lass,

cons

co

nst

ti

itut

tutes

es

o

only 14%

nly 14%

o

of Indian

f Indian

 popu

 popula

lat

ti

io

on

n.

.

Upp

Uppe

er 

m

middle

iddle

c

class and

lass and

mo

mo

st

s

t

o

of 

f th

the

e

cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

s

s

h

have s

ave sub

ubs

st

tan

ant

tial dis

ial dis

 po

 posa

sa

 b

 ble in

le incom

come

e.

.

(23)

India

India

two

two

:

:

Se

Ser 

ving

ving

c

class

lass

wh

whi

ich

ch

in

inc

cl

lu

udes

des

 p

 pe

eop

ople like d

le like dr 

ive

iver 

s,

s,

hou

house

se-ho

-hold

ld

h

hel

el

 p

 ps,

s,

o

offi

ffic

ce

e

 p

 pe

eo

ons, e

ns, etc.

tc.

F

For 

or 

eve

ever 

y India

y India

O

One

ne

th

the

er 

e a

e ar 

e a

e at

t

leas

least

t

India

India

T

T

wo

wo

and

and

h

have 55%

ave 55%

o

of Indian

f Indian

 popu

 popula

lat

ti

io

on

n.

.

India

India

thr 

thr 

ee:

ee:

S

Stru

truggling

ggling

c

class,

lass,

e

em

maining

aining

 popu

 popula

lat

ti

io

on

n

o

of India

f India.

.

Cann

Cannot

ot

aff 

aff 

or 

or 

d

d

to

to

ins

ins

 pi

 p

ir 

e f 

e f 

or 

or 

 b

 be

ett

tte

er 

living

living.

.

 Need

 Need

c

cann

annot

ot

 b

 be add

e addr 

essed

essed

 b

 by

y

curr 

curr 

en

ent

t bu

 business

siness

mo

model

del.

.

Th

The

e

 pot

 poten

ent

tial

ial

cu

cus

stom

tome

er 

s

s

o

of 

 b

 big

ig

 b

 bazaa

azaar 

a

ar 

e India

e India

O

One and India

ne and India

Two.

(24)

 ThThee cucusstomtomeer r insiginsighthtsswweer r e devele developopeded b byy cclloosese obobseser r vavattiioonn oof f ththee

t

taar r gegett seset.t. ThThe insige insighthtss ththaatt ccaammee outout wweer r e:e:

 ThThee cclean and slean and shhiny enviiny enviroronnmmenentt oof f momodeder r nn r r eettail sail stor tor eses

cr 

cr eaeatteses ththee p peercrcee pt ptiioonn ththaatt ssuchuch sstor tor e ae ar r ee tootoo exex p pensive andensive and

ex

excclluusive, and asive, and ar r e ne notot mmeaneantt f f or or IndiaIndia Two.Two.

 IndiaIndiatwotwo findsfindsmomoves and find a lves and find a lotot oof f comcomf f ortort inin crowcrowds,ds,

th

they aey ar r e ne notot individindividuualisalisttiic.c.ThTheyey pr  pr efeefer r toto b be in qe in quueeuueses..

 IndianIndian--nenessssis is nnotot aa bout bout b beingeing swadeshi swadeshi, i, it¶t¶s as a bout bout b believingelieving

in Indian

in Indian wwaysays oof df dooinging ththingsings..

AdveAdvertrtiseisemmenentts as a bout bout sschcheemmes andes and ooffeffer r ssthrouthrougghh llococalal

ne

newwss p paa p peer r ,, r r adiadiooin lin lococal langal languuage insage ins p piir r eses mor mor ee cucusstomtomeer r ss

mor 

mor ee ththanan ththee tr tr adiadittiioonalnal wwaysays..

 HyHy p peermrmaar r keketts in India ss in India shouhouldld b be sie situtuaatted ined in ththee cciittyy uunlikenlike

w

(25)

 Advertising 

 Advertising 

Adve

Advert

rtising is

ising is

th

the essen

e essent

tial

ial

compo

componen

nent

t

o

of 

 br 

 br 

and

and

 bu

 building

ilding

.

.

th

the adve

e advert

rtise

isem

men

ent

t

is d

is do

one

ne

throu

throug

gh

h

var 

va

i

iou

ous

s

w

ways,

ays,

t

te

ech

chniq

niqu

ues

es

u

used a

sed ar 

e:

e:

T

Tag

ag-

-line

line

P

Pr 

in

int-

t-ads

ads

T

T

VV

-

-ads

ads

o

oad side

ad side

ho

hoa

ar 

ding

ding

Radi

Radio

o

ads

ads

Fas

Fash

hi

io

on s

n show

hows

s

(26)

(27)

Fa

Factor 

ctor 

s

s

th

tha

at

t

s

sh

ha

a

 p

 ped

ed

the

th

e

 br 

 br 

and d

and dur 

ur 

ing i

ing it

ts life

s life

c

cy

yc

cle a

le ar 

e:

e:

Infl

Infl

u

u

en

en

c

c

e

e

o

o

f Sa

f Sa

v

v

a

a

n

n

a

a

S

S

tor 

tor 

es l

es l

oc

oc

a

a

t

t

ed in

ed in

Th

Th

eyag

eyag

aya

aya

 Naga

 Naga

in C

in C

h

h

ennai

ennai

Ob

Ob

se

se

ving

ving

cu

cu

s

s

tom

tom

e

e

s

s

eg

eg

u

u

la

la

ly

ly

.

.

I

I

mb

mb

i

i

 b

 b

ed en

ed en

tr 

tr 

e

e

 pr 

 pr 

ene

ene

ur 

ur 

ial s

ial s

 p

 p

i

i

i

i

t

t

in

in

th

th

e

e

or 

or 

ganiza

ganiza

t

t

i

i

o

o

n

n

.

.

(28)

 Strategic

 Strategic

 D D

ecision Taken To

ecision Taken To

 B

 B

uild 

uild 

 B B

ig 

ig 

 B B

azaar 

azaar 

 B B

rand 

rand 

 RealReal--esesttaatte gae gamme:e: 

AAccor ccor dingding toto kiskishor hor ee bbiyani,iyani, r r eal eseal esttaattee cocosstt sshouhouldld b bee

lesse

lesser r ththan 5%an 5% oof f tottotal salesal sales oof sf stor tor e ine in or or deder r toto pro providevide

m

maxiaximummum b benefienefittss toto cucusstomtomeer r 

 ThThe se str tr aattegiegicc dedeccisiisioonsns toto sesecur cur e se s p paacceses b bef ef or or ee othotheer r 

r eettaileailer r s js jooin inin in hhaveave r r esesuulltted ined in cocosstt savingsaving..

 N Nurtur urtur ingingr r elaelattiioonsnshhii p p:: 

 KisKishor hor ee BiBiyyanani f i f oollllowowssththe se str tr aattegyegy toto develdevelopop trutrusstt

and n

and nurtur urtur ee r r elaelattiioonsnshhii p pwwiithth ssuppupplielier r ss..WWhohoeveevewor wor ksks

w

wiithth FFutur utur e Ge Grouproup, ei, eiththeer r leaves in inileaves in inittial dealsial deals or or 

co

(29)

 UUsese oof f tteechchnnoolloogy, sgy, sccenaenar r iio-po-planning & slanning & stor tor yy ttelling:elling: 

 ssccenaenar r iioo p planning and slanning and stor tor yy ttellingellingtteechchniqniquuesesuused f sed f or or 

s

stor tor e design laye design layoutout and sand stor tor ee--llococaattiioon selen selectctiioonn..

 DesignDesign mmanageanagemmenentt 

DesignDesign--ledled ththinkinginking hhelel p ped Big Bazaaed Big Bazaar r toto aachchieveieve

µ

µcucusstomtomeer-r-fifir r sst¶t¶obob je jectctive andive and uullttiimmaattely ledely led toto finanfinanccialial

 p

 peer r f f ormormananccee..

 BaBacck k --endend opopeer r aattiioons, sns, suppupplyly chchain:ain: 

 IndiaIndia mmay nay notot hhave aave a momodeder r n sn suppupplyly chchainain but but iitt

defini

definittelyelyhhas aas a cocosst-t-effeeffectctiveive oone ine i..ee.. PanPanttalaloooon's sn's suppupplyly

ch

(30)

References

Related documents

We find that (i) a higher emission tax may increase (decrease) R&amp;D investment when the burden of the tax payment in the polluters’ marginal costs and the price-elasticity of

To test if recombinant protein yields were increased in these three vankyrin-enhanced cell lines compared to their respective parental cell lines, we infected cells with a YFP-

Seed material from four androgenetic pepper genotypes was collected: Kurtovska kapija SR, Zlaten medal SR, Piran and Féherözön, and were used for breeding process

In addition, the causality test shows that South Africa, India and China induce Brazil’s economic growth.. The results of this study carry implications for future world

The model established by Hutchinson and Waters aims to build a support to language use and shows that from, NIA process, the required input can be selected to achieve

Introduction: We compared the pathologic outcomes of prostate cancer patients who did not qualify for active surveillance according to the tumor visibility on multiparametric

From the original SDE (1.1), the authors find the coefficients (transition rates) of a Markov jump process (MJP) by balancing the fluxes between adjacent grid points such that the

32 Another type of migration that may be relevant is illegal immigration into a state. This may be somewhat more likely to occur when minimum wages are high, because the high