APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
Z. H. SIKDER UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND Z. H. SIKDER UNIVERSITY OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY
TECHNOLOGY
Madhupur,Bhedergonj,Shariatpur
ASSIGNMENT ON APPEAL IN A
APPEAL IN A CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE CIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, 1908
COURSE CODE : LAW 232
COURSEURSE T ITLE : CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE ( PART II)
DEPARTMENT OF LAW DEPARTMENT OF LAW
SUBMITTED BY SUBMITTED BY
STUDENT’S NAME : TAWHIDUR RAHMAN MURADTAWHIDUR RAHMAN MURAD STUDENT’S ID :
140314024
140314024
BATCH : 8th8th
DEPARTMENT : LAW
SUBMITTED TO SUBMITTED TO
SUPERVISOR : DR. MD. EMRAN PARVEZ KHAN
DESIGNATION :
PHD IN LAW!ANU,USA"
PHD IN LAW!ANU,USA"
ASSOCIATE PROFESORAPPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
DEAN
DEAN
FECULT
FECULTY OF HUMANITI
Y OF HUMANITIES AND SOCI
ES AND SOCIAL
AL
SCIENCE
SCIENCE&
CHAIRMANDEPARTMENT OF LAW
DEPARTMENT OF LAW
CONTENTS CONTENTSSN TITLE PAGE NO.
. I!"#$%'"$! .2 H*"$#+ A--/0$, 12 .3 A--/0 !%# " *"/""$#+ 0/ $, B/!40/%* 2 .5 A--/0 !%# " C$!*"""$! $, B/!40/%* 2 .6 A--/0* "$ " S-#7 C$#" $, B/!40/%* 3 .8 M/!!4 A--/0$, 315 .9 E**!"/0* 07!"* $, /--/0 5 . P#$'%# R0/"% "$ A--/0 516 .; R4" A--/0$, 618 2. C$7-/# <"! R4" "$ *" /!% #4" "$ /--/0 8 2. A--/0 * / C$!"!/"$! $, S" 819 2.2 A--/0 /!% R=*$! 1; 2.3 F#*" A--/0 /!% S'$!% A--/0 ;1 2.5 C$!=#*$! $, A--/0 !"$ R=*$! 2.6 R4" A--/0$, 2.8 A--/0 ,#$7 O#4!/0 %'# 2.9 W$ 7/+ A--/0> 12 2. W$ C/!!$" A--/0 2 2.; A--/0 <+ $! P0/!",, /4/!*" /!$"# P0/!",, 3 3. A--/0 <+ $! D,!%/!" /4/!*" /!$"# D,!%/!" 3 3. A4#7!" !$" A--/0"$ 3 3.2 A--/0 A4/!*" E? P/#" D'# 5 3.3 N$ A--/0 /4/!*" C$!*!" D'# 516 3.5 A--/0* /4/!*" P#07!/#+ D'# 6 3.6 N$ A--/0 /4/!*" F!/0 D'# 6 3.8 A--/0 /4/!*" @%47!" 8 3.9 A--/0 /4/!*" %/% -#*$! 8 3. G#$!%* ' 7/+ < "/! ! /--/0 8 3.; R@'"$! $# /7!%7!" $, 77$#/!%7* 9 5. S"/+ <+ A--00/" C$#" 91 5. S'#"+ ! '/* $, $#%# ,$# ?'"$! $, %'# /--/0% ,#$7 5.2 P#$'%# H/#!4/" ; 5.3 A##$%& %'( R$)*$+A##$%& %'( R$)*$+ ; 5.5 A--/0 /!% R,#!' 2 5.6 A--/0 /!% R=*$! 212 5.8 C$!'0*$! 2
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
11 I't-(./t*-' 11 I't-(./t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t- H*t- - - A##$%&A##$%&44
Thakker, C.K., Civil Procedure Code, 3rd Edition, Eastern book Company, p - 26
2 !"#3"-32$ %# &' 2(3 ) '&* "#32 PC "6%
3 'kbar vs +. ( * !PC$ "#
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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
13 A##$%& A##$%& .'($ .'($ th$ t%t.t- th$ t%t.t- &%+ -&%+ - B%'&%($h B%'&%($h
S'"$!* ;812 /!% O#%#* 5 "$ 56 $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0* " /--/0
F#*" /--/0*: S*. ;81;;A 9 /!% O#%# JLI.
S'$!% A--/0*: S*. 13 /!% O#%# JLII.
A--/0* ,#$7 $#%#*: S*. 5 1 /!% O#%# JLIII.
A--/0* "$ " S-#7 C$#": S'"$!* ; 2 /!% O#%# JLV.
A--/0* <+ !%4!" -$-0: O#%# JLIV.
I" * ! " </'4#$!% !,$#7/"$! -#$=%% # "/" " /*-'" $, /! /--/0 <!4 / '$!"!/"$! $, " *" 00 < ?/7!%.
14
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
A--/0* "$ S-#7 C$#" /# 4$=#!% <+ " P#$=*$!* $, A#"'0* 3 5 /!% 6 $, " C$!*"""$! $, B/!40/%* " #4/#% "$ '=0 7/""#*. S<@'" "$ " -#$=*$!* $, " C$!*"""$! /! /--/0 */00 0 "$ " S-#7 C$#" ,#$7 /!+ @%47!" %'# $# ,!/0 $#%# ! / '=0 -#$'%!4 $, / H4 C$#" , " H4 C$#" '#",* "/" (/) T '/* !=$0=* / *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/ $, 4!#/0 7-$#"/!' /!% (<) I! " $-!$! $, " H4 C$#" " */% *"$! !%* "$ < %'%% <+ " S-#7 C$#". 1
1 A##$%& A##$%& t- th$ t- th$ S.#$5$ S.#$5$ C-.t - C-.t - B%'&%($hB%'&%($h
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
I! aendra ath ey v. 4uresh Chandra ey6 ,*-/!4 ,$# " @%'/0 C$77"" $, P#=+ C$!'04ir insha 5ulla*"/"%:
6 rder 78 o9 the Code o9 Civil Procedure,"#(
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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
17 E$'t*%& E$'t*%& $&$5$'t $&$5$'t - - %##$%&%##$%&99
E=#+ /--/0 /* "# </*' 07!"*:
.A %'*$! (*/00+ / @%47!" $, / '$#" $# " #0!4 $, /! /%7!*"#/"= /"$#"+) 2. A -#*$! /4 4#=% ($ * $,"! " $4 !$ " !'**/#0+ / -/#"+ "$ " $# 4!/0 -#$'%!4) /!%
9 'ttorney :eneral v. 4illem,!"(6;$ " <C =; at p.="%)"" E* "2 at "2#
Tak/ani C. K., Civil Procedure, =th ed., Eastern ook Company, 2";,P,2%% ; i&
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908 3. A #=!4 <$%+ #/%+ /!% 00!4 "$ !"#"/! /! /--/0.
18
18 P-/$(.$ P-/$(.$ R$&%t$( R$&%t$( t- t- A##$%&A##$%&1010
T /--/0 <!4 " '$!"!/"$! $, " *" * 0% !$" "$" /!+ #/*$! " 7/+ < ?/7!% ! " 04" $, " ,$00$!4 -#$-$*"$!*: .T /--00/" '$#" /* /00 " -$#* /!% /* "$ %$ /00 "$* "!4* !'**/#+ "/" / "#/0 '$#" /* /!% /* "$ %$. I! "* *!* =! ! " '/* 4$* $! /--/0 " * @*" " !/7 "/" /* !%#4$! / '/!4 " ,$#7 /!% *<*"/!' *"00 #7/! " */7. 2. I! " */7 =! /* /<$= " /--00/" '$#" /* "$ %$ /00 "/" /* <! %$! <+ " "#/0 '$#" ! "/" -/#"'0/# '/* /!% "! "# /4# $# %*/4# ,#$7 " "#/0 '$#". 3. H!' =! " /--00/" '$#" /* "$ #" / @%47!" /!% -/** / %'#. I! " =!" $, " '$#" -$0%!4 " 0$# '$#"’* %'*$! " /--00/" '$#" 7/+ #" %$! " */7 %'# "$" '/!4!4 " /!% " %'# 00 !$ < %7% "$ /= <! "/" $, " /--00/" '$#". 5. F!/00+ " *" * !$" %7% "$ < ,!/00+ '$!'0%% ,$# 7/""#* $, #* @%'/"/ "00 " /--/0* /# $=#. T* 7-0* "/" " * %7% "/" " */7 *" * -#$4#** =! 0 " /--/0* /# $!. I" * $!0+ ! " '$#"* /= ,!/00+ '$7 "$ / '$!'0*$! /,"# /00 -$**<0 /--/0* /= <! *% /!% "#% <+ " /--00/!" "/" " *" * */% "$ /= <! '$!'0*=0+ %'%%. T /<$= */% -#$-$*"$!* -$!" $" ! **!' /" * 7-0% ! " * */% "/" " /--/0 * / '$!"!/"$! $, " *". T =/#$* -#$=*$!* #0/"!4 "$ " /--/0* /= /0#/%+ <! *"/"% ! " !"#$%'"$! "$ "* $#. A %"/0% 0$$ !"$ "* -#$=*$!* /" "* @!'"# <'$7* -#"!!". 19 19 R*ht R*ht - - A##$%&A##$%& 11 11
rder 7& o9 the Code o9 Civil Procedure,"#(
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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
I! 'nant 5ills Co. td. v. 4tate o9 :u>arat *-/!4 ,$# " S-#7 C$#" K/!!/ . */%: I" * 001*""0% <+ *=#/0 %'*$!* $, "* '$#" "/" " #4"* $, /--/0 * / '#/"# $, / *"/"" /!% "# * !$ #/*$! + " 04*0/"# 0 4#/!"!4 " #4" '/!!$" 7-$* '$!%"$!* ,$# " ?#'* $, *' #4" *$ 0$!4 /* " '$!%"$!* /# !$" *$ $!#$* /* "$ /7$!" "$ !#/*$!/<0 #*"#'"$!* #!%#!4 " #4" /07$*" 00*$#+. 2 2 C-5#%$ C-5#%$ $t+$$' $t+$$' R*ht R*ht t- t- .*t .*t %'( %'( *ht *ht t- t- %##$%&%##$%&1313 T# * / ,!%/7!"/0 %,,#!' <"! *" /!% /--/0 /!% " */7 * <!4 ?-0/!% -#$-#0+ <+ ?. Chandrachud!:ana ai v. 8i>ay Kumar! " ,$00$!4 $#%*:
T# * / </*' %*"!'"$! <"! " #4" $, *" /!% " #4" $, /--/0. T# * /! !#!" #4" ! =#+ -#*$! "$ <#!4 / *" $, / '=0 !/"# /!% !0** " *" * </##% <+ *"/"" $! 7/+ /" $!’* -#0 <#!4 / *" $, $!’* '$'. I" * !$ /!*# "$ / *" $*$=# ,#=$0$* " '0/7 "/" " 0/ '$!,#* !$ #4" "$ *. A *" ,$# "* 7/!"/!/<0"+ ##* !$ /"$#"+ $, 0/ /!% " * !$4 "/" !$ *"/"" </#* " *". B" " -$*"$! ! #4/#% "$ /--/0* * " "
2 :ana ai v. 8i>ay Kumar, !"#=;$ 2 4CC 3#3 at p. 3#=
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
$--$*". T #4" $, /--/0 !#* ! !$ $! /!% "#,$# /! /--/0 ,$# "* 7/!"/!/<0"+ 7*" /= " '0/# /"$#"+ $, 0/. 21 21 A##$%& A##$%& * * % % C-'t*'.%t*-' C-'t*'.%t*-' - - S.*tS.*t A! /--/0 * / '$!"!/"$! $, *" /!% !' %'# -/**% <+ /! /--00/" '$#" $0% < '$!*"#% /* %'# -/**% <+ " C$#" $, ,#*" !*"/!'. A! /--/0 * =#"/00+ / #/#!4 $, " 7/""#. T /--00/" '$#" -$***** " */7 -$#* /!% %"* /* " $#4!/0 '$#". O!' /4/! " !"# -#$'%!4* /# <,$# " /--00/" '$#" ' '/! #= " =%!' /* / $0 *<@'" "$ *"/""$#+ 07"/"$!* , /!+ /!% '/! '$7 "$ "* $! '$!'0*$! $, *' =%!'. I! aya/ati v. &nder>it *-/!4 ,$# " S-#7 C$#" <idayatullah *"/"%: A! /--/0 /* <! */% "$ < " #4" $, !"#!4 / *-#$# C$#" /!% !=$!4 "* /% /!% !"#-$*"$! "$ #%#** " ##$# $, " C$#" <0$’. T $!0+ %,,#!' <"! / *" /!% /! /--/0 * "/" /! /--/0 $!0+ #=* /!% '$##'"* " -#$'%!4 ! / '/* /0#/%+ '$!*"""% <" %$* !$" '#/" " '/*’.5 I" * $<=$* "/" ! /! /--/0 * 7/% " /--00/" /"$#"+ '/! %$ $! $, " ,$00$!4 "# "!4* !/70+: .I" 7/+ #=#* " $#%# !%# /--/0 2. I" 7/+ 7$%,+ "/" $#%# /!% 3. I" 7/+ 7#0+ %*7** " /--/0 /!% "* '$!,#7 " $#%# $, " 0$# '$#" "$" /!+ 7$%,'/"$!. I! /00 "# '/** /,"# %*-$*/0 $, " /--/0 <+ " /--00/" /"$#"+ " $#%# *$ -/**% <+ " /"$#"+ 00 < $-#/"= ##*-'"= $, " ,/'" "/" "* $#%# /* #=#*% 7$%,% $# '$!,#7% " %'*$! $, " 0$# '$#". I! ,/'" " * " /--00/" %'*$! /0$! ' *<**"* /!% $-#/"= /* 00 /* '/-/<0 $, !,$#'7!". 5 *amankutty v. 'vara, !"##;$ 2 4CC 6;2 at p. 6;%
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
A,"# #,##!4 "$ " =/#$* %'*$!* $! " *<@'" " S-#7 C$#" 0/% %$! " ,$00$!4 -#!'-0* #0/"!4 "$ " #4" $, /--/0 ! G/#/-/" =. S<</ C$%/#+. T* /# /* ,$00$*: . T/" " 04/0 -#*" $, / #7%+ *" /--/0 /!% *'$!% /--/0 /# #/00+ <" *"-* ! / *#* $, -#$'%!4* /00 '$!!'"% <+ /! !"#!*' !"+ /!% /# "$ < #4/#%% /* $! 04/0 -#$'%!4. 2. T #4" $, /--/0 * !$" @*" / 7/""# $, -#$'%# <" " * / *<*"/!"= #4". 3. T !*"""$! $, " *" '/##* " " " 7-0'/"$! "/" /00 #4"* $, /--/0 "! ! ,$#' /# -#*#=% "$ " -/#"* "#"$ "00 " #*" $, " '/## $, " *". 5. T #4" $, /--/0 * / =*"% #4" /!% *' / #4" "$ !"# / *-#$# C$#" /''#* "$ " 0"4/!" /!% ?*"* $! /!% ,#$7 " %/" " 0* '$77!'* /!% /0"$4 " 7/+ < /'"/00+ ?#'*% ! " /%=#* @%47!" * -#$!$!'% *' #4" "$ < 4$=#!% <+ " 0/ -#=/0!4 /" " %/" $, " !*"""$! $, " *" $# -#$'%!4 /!% !$" <+ " 0/ "/" -#=/0* /" " %/" $, "* %'*$! $# /" " %/" $, ,0!4 $, " /--/0. 6. T* =*"% #4" $, /--/0 '/! < "/! //+ $!0+ <+ / *<*!" !/'"7!" , " * *$ -#$=%% ?-#**0+ $# <+ !'**/#+ !"!%7!" /!% !$" $"#*. 22 22 A##$%& A##$%& %'( %'( R$)**-'R$)**-' T #=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! $, / H4 C$#" * / -/#" /!% -/#'0 $, " /--00/" @#*%'"$! $, " H4 C$#". W! " /% $, " H4 C$#" * !=$% $! " #=*$!/0 *% " * %$! <'/* " * / *-#$# '$#" /!% " '/! !"#,# ,$# " -#-$* $, #'",+!4 " ##$# $, " '$#" <0$. I" * $!0+ $! $, " 7$%* $, ?#'*!4 -$# '$!,##% <+ " S"/"" </*'/00+ /!% ,!%/7!"/00+ " * " /--00/" @#*%'"$! $, " H4 C$#" ' * <!4 !=$% /!% ?#'*% ! / %# /!% 0/#4# *!*. T %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$! * / #/0 $!. A #4" $, /--/0 '/##* " " / #4" $, #/#!4 $! 0/ /* 00 /* ,/'" !0** " *"/"" '$!,##!4 " #4" $, /--/0 07"* " #/#!4 $! /+ $# " $"#. T -$# "$ /# / #=*$! * 4!#/00+ 4=! "$ / *-#$# C$#" *$ "/" " 7/+ */"*,+ "*0, "/" / -/#"'0/# '/* /* <! %'%% /''$#%!4 "$ 0/.
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
R=*$!/0 @#*%'"$! * !$" % !$4 "$ 7/ " H4 C$#" / *'$!% '$#" $, ,#*" /--/0. T H4 C$#" '/!!$" ! ?#'* $, #=*$!/0 -$#* *<*""" "* $! = ,$# " = "/! <+ / *<$#%!/" '$#".
I! 4tate o9 Kerala v. K.5. Charia 'bdullah @ Co. C$#" /* 404"% " %,,#!' <"! " "$ @#*%'"$!* ! " ,$00$!4 $#%*: T# * /! **!"/0 %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$!. T %*"!'"$! * </*% $! " %,,#!'* 7-0'" ! " */% "$ ?-#**$!*. A! /--/0 * / '$!"!/"$! $, " -#$'%!4* ! ,,'" " !"# -#$'%!4* /# <,$# " /--00/" /"$#"+ /!% " /* -$# "$ #= " =%!' *<@'" "$ " *"/""$#+ 07"/"$!* -#*'#<%. B" ! " '/* $, / #=*$! /"=# -$#* " #'**$!/0 /"$#"+ 7/+ $# 7/+ !$" /= " /* !$" " -$# "$ #= " =%!' !0** " *"/"" ?-#**0+ '$!,#* $! " "/" -$#.
I! 'ssociated Cement Co. td. v. Keshavanand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
I" * *<7""% "/" " ,$00$!4 $<*#=/"$!* $, H%/+/"00/ ?. in <ari 4hankar v. *ao :irdhari al Cho/dhury 0/% %$! '$##'" 0/ $! " -$!". S-/!4 ,$# " 7/@$#"+ H* L$#%*- '$!'0%%: T %*"!'"$! <"! /! /--/0 /!% / #=*$! * / #/0 $!. A #4" $, /--/0 '/##* " " / #4" $, #/#!4 $! 0/ /* 00 /* ,/'" !0** " *"/"" '$!,##!4 " #4" $, /--/0 07"* " #/#!4 ! *$7 /+ /* ,!% /* <! %$! * *'$!% /--/0* /#*!4 !%# " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#. T -$# "$ /# / #=*$! * 4!#/00+ 4=! "$ / *-#$# C$#" *$ "/" " 7/+ */"*,+ "*0, "/" / -/#"'0/# '/* /* <! %'%% /''$#%!4 "$ 0/. U!%# *. 6 $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#. " H4 C$#"* -$# /# 07"% "$ * "# ! / '/* %'%%
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
"# /* <! /! /**7-"$! $, @#*%'"$! # !$! ?*"% $# / #,*/0 $, @#*%'"$! # " %% $# "# /* <! 7/"#/0 ##40/#"+ $# 004/0"+ ! " ?#'* $, "/" @#*%'"$!. T #4" "# * '$!,!% "$ @#*%'"$! /!% @#*%'"$! /0$!. I! $"# /'"* " -$# * !$" *$ 07"% /!% " H4 C$#" * !/<0% "$ '/00 ,$# " #'$#% $, / '/* "$ */"*,+ "*0, "/" " %'*$! "#! * /''$#%!4 "$ 0/ /!% "$ -/** *' $#%#* ! #0/"$! "$ " '/* /* " "!* ,".6 23
23 F*t F*t A##$%& A##$%& %'( %'( S$/-'( S$/-'( A##$%&A##$%&1616
T F#*" A--/0 '/! < /%7""% $! " 4#$!%* () *"$! $, ,/'" /!% /0*$ (2) *"$! $, 0/. T S'$!% A--/0 '/! < /%7""% $!0+ $! " -$!" $, *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/’. T F#*" A--/0 '/! < !"#"/!% <+ *<$#%!/" C$#"* "$ D*"#'" %4’* C$#" /!% "$ H4 C$#"*. E?/7-0: A! /--/0 ,#$7 " D*"#'" M!*,, M/4*"#/" * C$#" $# S<$#%!/" %4’* C$#" "$ " D*"#'" %4. T S'$!% A--/0 '/! $!0+ < !"#"/!% <+ " H4 C$#". S'"$!* ;8 "$ ;;1A 9 /!% O#%# JLI %/0* " F#*" A--/0*. S'"$!* "$ 3 /!% O#%# JLII %/0 " S'$!% A--/0. T M7$#/!%7 $, ,#*" /--/0 7*" *" $" " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* "$ " %'# /--/0% ,#$7. S!' " *'$!% /--/0 * 7/!"/!/<0 $!0+ ! " !=$0=* / *<*"/!"/0 *"$! $, 0/ / 77$#/!%7 $, *'$!% /--/0 7*" -#'*0+ *"/" *' *"$!. I" !% !$" *" $" " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* "$ " %'# /--/0% ,#$7.9 24 24 C-')$*-' C-')$*-' - - A##$%& A##$%& *'t- *'t- R$)**-'R$)**-'1818 I, /! /--/0 * -#,##% ! / '/* ! ' !$ /--/0 0* " '$#" 7/+ "#/" " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * / #=*$! $# =' =#*/. S!' "# * !$ *-',' -#$=*$! ,$# *' '$!=#*$! " '$#" $0% < @*",% ! !=$!4 " !#!" -$#* !%# S'"$! 6 /!% ! -/**!4 6 5d. 'bdul <alim) Te1t ook on Civil Procedure.P.2""
8 &bid
9 ational ank vs 4unil ;%* %;=
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
/--#$-#/" $#%#* /* 7/+ < !'**/#+ ! " !"#*"* $, @*"'. T# * !$"!4 0 / -#$% $, 07"/"$! ,$# 7/!4 /! /--0'/"$! ,$# '$!=#*$! $, /! /--/0 !"$ #=*$! $# =' =#*/. A00 "/" * ##% "$ < *! * , " /--/0 $# " #=*$! /% <! ,0% "! " "7 -#*'#<% ,$# " ,0!4 $, " /--/0 $# " #=*$! /* " '/* 7/+ <.; 2 2 R*ht R*ht - - A##$%&A##$%&2020 T #4" $, /--/0 * / =*"% #4" /!% *' / #4" "$ !"# " *-#$# '$#" /''#* "$ " 0"4/!" /!% ?*"* /* $! /!% ,#$7 " %/" " 0* '$77!'* /!% /0"$4 " 7/+ < /'"/00+ ?#'*% ! " /%=#* @%47!" * -#$!$!'% *' #4" * "$ < 4$=#!% <+ " 0/ -#=/0!4 /" " %/" $, " !*"""$! $, " *" $# -#$'%!4 /!% !$" <+ " 0/ "/" -#=/0* /" " %/" $, "* %'*$! $# /" " %/" $, " ,0!4 $, " /--/0. 26
26 A##$%& A##$%& -5 -5 O**'%& O**'%& ($/$$($/$$2121
S'"$! ;8 $, " '$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0* " A--/0 ,#$7 O#4!/0 %'# () S/= # $"#* ?-#**0+ -#$=%% ! " <$%+ $, "* C$% $# <+ /!+ $"# 0/ ,$# " "7 <!4 ! ,$#' /! /--/0 */00 0 ,#$7 =#+ %'# -/**% <+ /!+ C$#" ?#'*!4 $#4!/0 @#*%'"$! " C$#" /"$#% "$ /# /--/0* ,#$7 " %'*$!* $, *' C$#". (2) A! /--/0 7/+ 0 ,#$7 /! $#4!/0 %'# -/**% ? -/#". (3) N$ /--/0 */00 0 ,#$7 / %'# -/**% <+ " C$#" " " '$!*!" $, -/#"*.
; ahori v. 8idya *am, '&* "#=( 'll 2##
2 4ection #6
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
(5) N$ /--/0 */00 0 ?'-" $! / *"$! $, 0/ ,#$7 / %'# ! /!+ *" $, " !/"# '$4!*/<0 <+ C$#"* $, S7/00 C/** ! " /7$!" $# =/0 $, " *<@'"17/""# $, " $#4!/0 *" %$* !$" ?'% "! "$*/!% #-*. 27 27 Wh- Wh- 5% 5% A##$%&A##$%& S'"$! ;8 $, " C$% #'$4!* " #4" $, /--/0 ,#$7 =#+ %'# -/**% <+ /!+ '$#" ?#'*!4 $#4!/0 @#*%'"$!. I" %$* !$" #,# "$ $# !7#/" " -#*$!* $ 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0. B" <,$# /! /--/0 '/! < ,0% !%# "* *'"$! "$ '$!%"$!* 7*" < */"*,%: .T *<@'"17/""# $, " /--/0 7*" < / %'#’ "/" * / '$!'0*= %"#7!/"$! $, " #4"* $, " -/#"* " #4/#% "$ /00 $# /!+ $, " 7/""#* ! '$!"#$=#*+ ! " *" /!% 2. T -/#"+ /--/0!4 7*" /= <! /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ *' %"#7!/"$!. T $#%!/#+ #0 * "/" $!0+ / -/#"+ "$ / *" /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# $# /!+ $, * #-#*!"/"=*1!1!"#*" 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0. B" / -#*$! $ * !$" / -/#"+ "$ / %'# $# $#%# 7/+ " " 0/= $, " '$#" -#,# /! /--/0 ,#$7 *' %'# $# $#%# , * "# <$!% <+ " $#%# $# * /44#=% <+ " $# * -#@%'/00+ /,,'"% <+ ".22
I" /* $<*#=% ! " '/* $, Krishna Chandra :older v. 5ahesh Chandra 4ahu " *"$! $ 7/+ /--/0 * %"#7!/<0 <+ " '$77$! *!* $, '$!*%#/"$! "/" "# '/! < !$ /--/0 # "# * !$"!4 "$ /--/0 /<$".23 F#$7 " /<$= 4!#/0 -#!'-0* " ,$00$!4 -#*$!* /# !""0% "$ /--/0 !%# "* *'"$!: .A!+ -/#"+ "$ " *" $ * /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# $# " "#/!*,# $, !"#*" $, *' -/#"+ /* <! /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'# -#$=%% * !/7 /* !"#% !"$ #'$#% $, *".
22 iscttits vs Prince <otel, l2 C "6#
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
2. A -#*$! '0/7!4 !%# / -/#"+ "$ " *" $# / " #/!*,# $, " !"#*"* $, *' -/#"+ $ *$ ,/# /* *' !"#*" * '$!'#!% * <$!% <+ " %'# -#$=%% * !/7 * !"#% $! " #'$#% $, " *". 3. A 4/#%/! /% 0"7 /--$!"% <+ " '$#" ! / *" <+ $# /4/!*" / 7!$#. 5. A!+ $"# -#*$! " " 0/= $, " '$#" , * /%=#*0+ /,,'"% <+ " %'#. 28 28 Wh- Wh- C%''-t C%''-t A##$%&A##$%&2424 I, / -/#"+ /4#* !$" "$ /--/0 $# /=* * #4" "$ /--/0 '/!!$" ,0 /! /--/0 /!% 00 < <$!% <+ /! /4#7!" , $"#* *' /4#7!" * =/0%.26 S' /! /4#7!" 7*" < '0/# /!% !/7<4$*. W"# / -/#"+ /* $# /* !$" /=% * #4" $, /--/0 %-!%* -$! " ,/'"* /!% '#'7*"/!'* $, /' '/*.28 S70/#0+ # / -/#"+ /* /''-"% " <!,"* !%# / %'# $, " '$#" '/! < *"$--% ,#$7 *"$!!4 " 04/0"+ $, " %'#.29 A*4crutton, .?. $<*#=% I" *"/#"0* 7 "/" / -#*$! '/! */+ "/" @%47!" * #$!4 /!% /" " */7 "7 /''-" " -/+7!" !%# " @%47!" /* <!4 #4"Q.I! 7+ $-!$! +$ '/!!$" "/ " <!," $, / @%47!" /* <!4 4$$% /!% "! /--/0 /4/!*" " /* <!4 </%. F!/00+ " =*"% #4" $, /--/0 * %*"#$+% , " '$#" "$ ' /! /--/0 0* * /<$0*% /0"$4"# "$" /!+ ,$#7 <!4 *<*"""% ! "* -0/'. 29
29 A##$%& A##$%& -'$ -'$ P&%*'t* P&%*'t* %%*'t %%*'t %'-th$ %'-th$ P&%*'t* P&%*'t* 2828
25 ibid
26 'mir 'li v. &nder>eet 4inh, !"(="$ "; 5&' 23 !PC$
28 Protap Chunder v. 'rathoon, &* !"((2$ ( Cal ;%%
29 e1ters td. v. <ill Crest il Co., !"#26$ " K 3;(
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
A* / 4!#/0 #0 $! -0/!",, '/!!$" ,0 /! /--/0 /4/!*" / '$1-0/!",,. B" # " 7/""# ! '$!"#$=#*+ ! " *" ,$#7* *<@'"17/""# $, %*-" <"! -0/!",,* !"# * /! /--/0 '/! < ,0% <+ $! -0/!",, /4/!*" /!$"# -0/!",,.2; 3 3 A##$%& -'$ D$$'(%'t %%*'t %'-th$ D$$'(%'tA##$%& -'$ D$$'(%'t %%*'t %'-th$ D$$'(%'t3030 T -#!'-0 ' /--0* "$ ,0!4 $, /--/0 <+ $! -0/!",, /4/!*" /!$"# -0/!",, /00+ /--0* "$ /! /--/0 <+ $! %,!%/!" /4/!*" /!$"# %,!%/!". 3 I" * $!0+ # " %*-" * !$" $!0+ <"! -0/!",,* /!% " %,!%/!"* <" <"! %,!%/!"* !"# * /!% *' %'*$! /%=#*0+ /,,'"* $! %,!%/!" /4/!*" " $"# "/" *' /--/0 $0% < '$7-"!".32 31
31 A$$5$'t A$$5$'t '-t '-t t- t- A##$%&A##$%&3333
A #4" $, /--/0 * / *"/""$#+ #4". I, / *"/"" %$* !$" '$!,# *' #4" !$ /--/0 '/! < ,0% =! " " '$!*!" $# /4#7!" <"! " -/#"*. B" /! /4#7!" <"! " -/#"* !$" "$ ,0 /! /--/0 * =/0% , " * </*% $! 0/,0 $# 04/0 '$!*%#/"$! /!% , $"#* " * !$" 004/0.35W" " 0/= $, " '$#" /!+ 4#$!% '/! < #4% <,$# " '$#" /!% -/#"'0/#0+ / 4#$!% $! / *"$! $, 0/ '/! < #4% -#$=%% " $"# *% * /#% "$" <!4 -#@%'%. 36 'bduvs TaAlu. ;( * 36"
2; 8ithu v. hima, &* !"(#"$ "% om ";%
3l3 * "%
3 irmala ala v. alai Chand, '&* "#6% 4C "(=;
32 ?oy vs 4ita. ; * ;
33 ibid
352( * !4C$
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
32
32 A##$%& A##$%& A%*'t A%*'t E: E: P%t$ D$/P%t$ D$/$$$$3636
S'"$! ;8(2) $, " C$% $, C=0 P#$'%#; %/0* " A--/0 A4/!*" E? P/#" D'#. T %,!%/!" /4/!*" $7 /! ? -/#" %'# /* <! -/**% /* " ,$00$!4 #7%* /=/0/<0 "$ 7:39 () A--0+ "$ " '$#" <+ ' *' %'# * -/**% "$ *" " /*%: O#%# IJ R0 3 $# (2) P#,# /! /--/0 /4/!*" *' %'#: S'"$! ;8(2) ($# "$ ,0 / #=*$! !%# S'"$! 6 # !$ /--/0 0*)
(3) A--0+ ,$# #=: O#%# JLVII R0 $# (5) F0 / *" $! " 4#$!% $, ,#/%. T /<$= #7%* /# '$!'##!" /!% "+ '/! < -#$*'"% *70"/!$*0+ $# '$!'##!"0+. A* /* <! #4"0+ */%: W# "$ -#$'%!4* $# "$ #7%* /# -#$=%% <+ / *"/"" $! $, "7 7*" !$" < "/! /* $-#/"!4 ! %#$4/"$! $, " $"#.3 I! /! /--/0 /4/!*" /! ? -/#" %'# " /--00/" '$#" * '$7-"!" "$ 4$ !"$ " *"$! $, " -#$-#"+ $# $"#* $, " ? -/#" %'# -/**% <+ " "#/0 '$#". 33 33 N- N- A##$%& A##$%& %%*'t %%*'t C-'$'t C-'$'t D$/$$D$/$$3939
36 Anwara vs Shahttnetrctz.43 DLR (AD) 156 Anwara vs Shahttnetrctz.43 DLR (AD) 156
39 4ection #6!2$
3 '>udhia Prasad v. almukund, &* !"(66$ ( 'll 3%; !B$
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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
34 A##$%& A##$%& %%*'t %%*'t P$&*5*'% P$&*5*'% D$/$$D$/$$4242
A! /--/0 0* /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'#. A -#07!/#+ %'# * /* 7' / ,!/0 %'#. I! ,/'" / ,!/0 %'# * <" 7/'!#+ ,$# " 7-07!"/"$! $, / -#07!/#+ %'#. F/0# "$ /--/0 /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'# !' -#0%* " /44#=% -/#"+ ,#$7 '/00!4!4 " ,!/0 %'#. W# /! /--/0 * ,0% /4/!*" / -#07!/#+ %'# /!% * /00$% /!% " %'# * *" /*% " ,!/0 %'# ,/00* "$ " 4#$!% /* !,,'"= *!' "# * !$ -#07!/#+ %'# "$ *--$#" " ,!/0 %'#.53 3
3 N- N- A##$%& A##$%& %%*'t F*'%& %%*'t F*'%& D$/$$ D$/$$ +h$$ +h$$ '- '- A##$%& A##$%& %%*'t P$&*5*'% %%*'t P$&*5*'% D$/$$D$/$$
I! *"* ' '$!"7-0/" " 7/!4 $, "$ %'#*1/ -#07!/#+ %'# /!% / ,!/0 %'#1" %'# ' $0% < ?'"/<0 $0% < " ,!/0 %'#. B" " ,!/0"+ $, / %'# $# / 5 Katikara Chintamani ora v. :untreddi 'nnamanaidu, !"#=;$ " 4 CC %6= at pp. %(;-(%
5 Thakur Prasad v. ha/an as, '&* "#(% 5P "="
52 ibid
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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t %%*'t ;.(5$'t;.(5$'t4747 T '$% $, '=0 -#$'%# ; -#$=%* /! /--/0 ,#$7 / %'# /!% !$" ,#$7 / @%47!". A! /44#=% -/#"+ $=# 7/+ ,0 /! /--/0 /4/!*" " @%47!" , / %'# * !$" %#/! - <+ " '$#". 37 37 A##$%& A##$%& %%*'t %%*'t ($%( ($%( #$-'#$-'4848 N$ /--/0 '/! < !*"""% /4/!*" / %/% -#*$!. S' /! /--/0 "#,$# '/! < #4/#%% /* / *"00<$#! /--/0. I! *' '/** /! /--0'/"$! '/! < 7/% -#/+!4 ,$# " *<*"""$! $, " 04/0 #-#*!"/"=* $, " %'/*% #*-$!%!" $ %% -#$# "$ " ,0!4 $, " /--/0. I! "/" '/* " /--/0 '/! < "/! "$ /= <! ,0% $! " %/" $, " /--0'/"$! ,$# *<*"""$! $, " 04/0 #-#*!"/"=*. I, <+ "/" "7 " /--/0 * "71</##% " /--00/!" '/! * '$!%"$! $, %0/+. 55 ?obeda vs Kshenta0 ( * 2%(
56 an/ari al v. Chando evi, !"##3$ " 4CC %("
58 8enkata *eddi and thers v. Pothi *eddi, "#63 '&* ##2, "#63 4C* 4upl. !2$ 6"6
59 ibid
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908 38 38 <-.'( <-.'( +h*/h +h*/h 5% 5% $ $ t%=$' t%=$' *' *' %##$%&%##$%& T /--00/!" */00 !$" ?'-" <+ 0/= $, " C$#" #4 $# < /#% ! *--$#" $, /!+ 4#$!% $, $<@'"$! *" ,$#" ! " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 <" " A--00/" C$#" ! %'%!4 " /--/0 */00 !$" < '$!,!% "$ " 4#$!%* $, $<@'"$!* *" ,$#" ! " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 $# "/! <+ 0/= $, " C$#" !%# "* #0: P#$=%% "/" " C$#" */00 !$" #*" "* %'*$! $! /!+ $"# 4#$!% !0** " -/#"+ $ 7/+ < /,,'"% "#<+ /* /% / *,,'!" $--$#"!"+ $, '$!"*"!4 " '/* $! "/" 4#$!%.5; W! / %'# * !"#% ! ,/=$# $, " -0/!",, * !""0% "$ *--$#" " %'# ! * ,/=$# /0*$ $! 4#$!%* ,$!% /4/!*" 7 Probodh vs 'bdu. "2 * ;%# 39 39 R$;$/t*-' R$;$/t*-' - - %5$'(5$'t %5$'(5$'t - - 5$5-%'(.55$5-%'(.5 () W# " 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * !$" %#/! - ! " 7/!!# #!<,$# -#*'#<% " 7/+ < #@'"% $# < #"#!% "$ " /--00/!" ,$# " -#-$* $, <!4 /7!%% "! / "7 "$ < ,?% <+ " C$#" $# < /7!%% "! /!% "#. (2) W# " C$#" #@'"* /!+ 77$#/!%7 " */00 #'$#% " #/*$!* ,$# *' #@'"$!. (3) W# / 77$#/!%7 $, /--/0 * /7!%% " %4 $# *' $,,'# /* /--$!"* ! "* </0, */00 *4! $# !"/0 " /7!%7!". 4 4 St% St% A##$&&%t$ A##$&&%t$ C-.tC-.t00 () A! /--/0 */00 !$" $-#/" /* / *"/+ $, -#$'%!4* !%# / %'# $# $#%# /--/0% ,#$7 ?'-" *$ ,/# /* " A--00/" C$#" 7/+ $#%# !$# */00 ?'"$! $, / %'# < *"/+% <+ #/*$! $!0+ $, /! /--/0 /=!4 <! -#,##% ,#$7 " %'# <" " A--00/" C$#" 7/+ ,$# *,,'!" '/* $#%# *"/+ $, ?'"$! $, *' %'#. 5; Probodh vs 'bdu. "2 * ;%# 6 'bu vs 4u>ayat. 3l * !'$ 326
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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t *' S$/.*t *' /%$ - /%$ - -($ -($ - - $:$/.t*-' - $:$/.t*-' - ($/$$ ($/$$ %##$%&$( -%##$%&$( -55 2 2 6 . ev,an vs analdesh. ;3 * 22"
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
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t %t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aar vs hirendra. 3 * 2;. 63 4hah vs :olam !5d$ %2 * !'$ "6 65 4k. Pir vs 'minuddin. "" * 3;%
APPEAL
APPEAL IN A IN A CIVIL SUIT UCIVIL SUIT UNDER THE CONDER THE CODE OF CIVDE OF CIVIL PROCEIL PROCEDURE, 1908DURE, 1908
R= * / "$$0 "/" * *% <+ /! /44#=% -/#"+ "$ #*" / '$#" $, 0/ "$ "/ / *'$!% 0$$ /" "* %'*$! $# =#%'". R= * *% ! *"/"$!* # "# * !$ -#$=*$! ,$# /! /--/0. R= * !$" / *"/""$#+ #4" $, " -$-0 /!% * '$!*%#% / %*'#"$!/#+ #4" $, / '$#" /* " '/! #@'" " #*" ,$# / #=. R= * *$4" ! " */7 0/ '$#" ,#$7 # " $#4!/0 %'*$! '/7. T# * !$ *+*"7 $, / *'$!% #=. R= '/! < !%#"/! *$ 7$"$ <+ / '$#" $, 0/. 43 43 A##$%& A##$%& %'( %'( R$)*$+R$)*$+ R= * 7$*"0+ '$!'#!% " " '$##'"!** $, " 04/0 7/""#* $, / %'*$! #/* /! /--/0 * 7$*"0+ '$!'#!% " " '$##'"!** $, " %'*$! "*0,. R= * ,0% ! " */7 '$#" #/* /--/0 * ,0% ! / 4# '$#". A--/0 * / *"/""$#+ #4" $, " !%=%/0 #/* #= * / %*'#"$!/#+ #4" $, " '$#". 44 44 A##$%& A##$%& %'( %'( R$$$'/$R$$$'/$66 A #4" $, /--/0 * / #4" '$!,##% $! " *"$# 0 " -$# $, #,#!' * =*"% ! " '$#". R,#!' * /0/+* 7/% "$ " H4 C$#" 0 /! /--/0 * -#,##% "$ / *-#$# '$#" ' !% !$" !'**/#0+ < H4 C$#". T 4#$!%* $, /--/0 /# %# "/! " 4#$!%* $, #,#!'. R,#!' * 7/% ! / -!%!4 *" /--/0 $# ?'"$! -#$'%!4 ! $#%# "$ !/<0 " '$#" "$ /##= /" / '$##'" '$!'0*$! 0 /! /--/0 * -#,##% /,"# " %'# * -/**% $# /! /--/0/<0 $#%# * 7/%. 4 4 A##$%& %'( R$)**-'A##$%& %'( R$)**-'77
66 5ulla0s Civil Procedure Code, "3th Edn., 8ol. ", p. "%%
