Basis Risk Mitigation services
Basis Risk Mitigation services
at ICAP: RESET & ReMATCH
Guy Rowcliffe
CEO RESET and BRM Group
p
July 2012
Definition of basis risk
Definition of basis risk
•
Basis Risk is defined by the Derivative Consulting Group Glossary as:
“The risk of loss arising from the difference between the economic or legal g g terms of two derivative transactions that are intended to hedge each other”
•
Investorpedia.com explains this further:
“What Does Basis Risk Mean?
The risk that offsetting investments in a hedging strategy will not experience price changes in entirely opposite directions from each other This imperfect price changes in entirely opposite directions from each other. This imperfect correlation between the two investments creates the potential for excess gains or losses in a hedging strategy, thus adding risk to the position”
Risk mitigation services at ICAP
Risk mitigation services at ICAP
•
ICAP own and operate two industry leading basis risk mitigation
•
ICAP own and operate two industry leading basis risk mitigation
services: RESET and ReMATCH
•
RESET reduces the basis risk from fixings on financial instruments such
as term rate fixing risk, FX non-deliverable forwards (NDF) fixing risk
and inflation fixing risk It also addresses structural imbalances within
and inflation fixing risk. It also addresses structural imbalances within
trading portfolios such as floating/floating basis
•
ReMATCH rebalances the illiquid basis and market risks inherent in
many Credit Default Swap (CDS) portfolios
•
Both technologies remove significant quantities of these second order
risks from the market and operate in ways distinctly different to voice
risks from the market and operate in ways distinctly different to voice
and electronic market places
Understanding a leading risk
mitigation platform
mitigation platform
To set the scene, it is best to take a look at perhaps the largest basis
p
p
g
risk mitigation platform in the market today and answer the following
questions:
• What do RESET do?
• How do they do it?
• Why is it of value to their customers?
Some key facts about RESET
Some key facts about RESET
•
RESET transacts significant risk mitigating trade volumes and its use is
id
d
th t d
it
widespread across the trader community:
$
– Total notional volumes traded since inception: $900+ trillion
375 client banks and 3 000+ individual users – 375 client banks and 3,000+ individual users
– 700 000 transactions last year or more than 2 500 per day – 700,000 transactions last year or more than 2,500 per day
RESET risk mitigation
RESET risk mitigation
•
RESET provide a service which focuses on risk mitigation in the interest
rate derivative market
•
RESET enables banks and their traders to execute Forward Rate
Agreements (FRA’s) Single Period Swaps (SPS’s) and Non
Agreements (FRA s), Single Period Swaps (SPS s), and Non
Deliverable Forwards (NDF’s) to offset, remove or reduce the
outstanding reset (or fixing) risk from their trading portfolios
Reset or fixing risk explained
Reset or fixing risk explained
•
What is “reset” or “fixing” risk and where does it come from
•
It is a 2
ndorder risk within interest rate derivative portfolios resulting
from the structure of the instruments traded and a mismatch of
exposures over time
exposures over time
•
It is an unwanted by-product of the core trading activity
•
It is an unwanted by-product of the core trading activity
IRS floating rate cashflows
IRS floating rate cashflows
IRS floating rate fixing
IRS floating rate fixing
IRS floating rate fixing
IRS floating rate fixing
How RESET operates
How RESET operates
RESET Traders fill in Once filled Sophisticated RESET sends
sends a Portfolio spreadsheet on day of run their matching options, credit limits for counterparties in, it is emailed back to RESET trade results back to the trader and fi ti proprietary algorithm and multi year risk management expertise to all customers and position interests before a specified cut-off point confirmations go to back office 11
How RESET operates in detail
How RESET operates in detail
• We provide a preset mid market curve (there is no bid/offer spread) with FRA prices for every day’s value out to approximately 1 year in the future
every day s value out to approximately 1 year in the future
• These are the prices at which all participants will trade if liquidity and individual matching criteria allow
• The curve is a snapshot of the market determined from a poll of market participants
• All potential participants receive the prices before executing any trades
• The service allows only market neutral transactions. Every buy must be offset by an equal and opposite amount of notional sell (just for different future value dates)
• Every trader can individually select from a number of standard matching criteria and restrictions that determine which combinations of offsetting trades can be done, from the full set of positions submitted to the service. Each selected criteria or restriction is
incorporated into the algorithmic solutionco po a ed o e a go c so u o
• The service is only run periodically (not daily or live). For example, in liquid currencies such as USD, it is run weekly every Monday
• Traders submit portfolios during the late afternoon and execution only occurs overnight, once all the data has been collected and the matching algorithm run on the full data set
Why RESET is valuable to our
clients
clients
• 1 basis point on $1m for 3 months is worth approx $25
• In a $400m deal that is a risk of $10,000 per basis point move in Euribor/Libor, every 3 months, for the few days between offsetting fixings
• Portfolio owners will have fixings of this type nearly EVERY SINGLE DAY
• Average daily Euribor/Libor volatility reached as high as 8-10 basis points during the credit crisis
• Removing offsetting positions removes exposure to this risk and is demonstrated graphically on the next slides
Typical IRS portfolio fixing
exposures (client X)
exposures (client X)
Same client X portfolio after a
RESET run
RESET run
Now moving to ReMATCH
Now moving to ReMATCH
ReMATCH was established by ICAP in 2009 to perform basis risk
mitigation for credit derivatives
mitigation for credit derivatives
• Credit derivatives market size in gross notional outstanding: $25 trillion (DTCC)
• Credit derivatives market size in net notional outstanding: $2.5 trillion (DTCC)
• However, there is a significant risk management challenge:
– Net Open Position (NOP) is a multiple of net notional outstanding
• NOP adds all net notionals per maturity date across the curveNOP adds all net notionals per maturity date across the curve
• Net notional risks change quarterly for individual market makers
• Managing micro curve risks is extremely difficult
• Exiting of odd-dates is often cost prohibitive
– Little liquidity
C h d t d fi
– Curves are hard to define
ReMATCH
ReMATCH
•
ReMATCH offers a solution
ReMATCH offers a solution
•
ReMATCH’s proprietary technology allows clients:
– Access to “pooled” liquidity on many maturity dates; allowing the opportunity to exit these ‘forward risks’
– Mid-market execution which removes prohibitive crossing of bid-offerMid market execution which removes prohibitive crossing of bid offer
– The ability to rebalance their portfolios utilising a range of powerful controls
– A discreet moment for the industry to access across-the-curve liquidity
•
ReMATCH success in this area:
Over $600 billion in NOP reduced
– Over $600 billion in NOP reduced
– Deep penetration into the topical Western Sovereign and Emerging Market Sectors
– New solutions; Working with industry experts to development of a solution to mitigate additional second order risks; such as Quanto 17
Portfolio risk mitigation methodology (generic)
g
gy (g
)
Client 1
Client 1 Client 2Client 2 Client 3Client 3 Client 4Client 4 Client 5Client 5 CLIENTS: CLIENTS: Risk Risk 3 KEY CLIENT 3 KEY CLIENT Curve Opinions
Curve Opinions Risk PortfoliosRisk Portfolios
Risk Constraints P&L Tolerance Risk Constraints P&L Tolerance 3 KEY CLIENT INPUTS: 3 KEY CLIENT INPUTS: Matching Algorithms Matching Algorithms Curve Normalization &
Smoothing
Curve Normalization & Smoothing PLATFORM ACTIONS: PLATFORM ACTIONS: Platform output: Bulk Trades Platform output: Bulk Trades
Trade Execution and Processing Trade Execution and Processing ALL AGREED:
ALL AGREED: Trade Execution and ProcessingTrade Execution and Processing ALL AGREED:
ALL AGREED:
Characteristics of RESET and ReMATCH
d t ICAP’
i
d E Pl tf
compared to ICAP’s voice and E-Platforms
Voice or Reset ReMatch
Platform type
E-Platform
Price determination Bid-offer Platform sets a mid market
price
Platform sets a mid market price
Feature
price price
Market type Continuous Regular scheduled (weekly
or less frequent)
Irregularly scheduled
Risk positioning Individual risk assuming Bulk risk mitigating Bulk risk mitigating
Risk inputp Individual trade interest Portfolio level risk interests Portfolio level risk interests
inc bid or offer
Execution model Trader driven execution Platform determined
ti
Platform determined ti
execution execution
Results Individual transaction Bulk runs of transactions Bulk runs of transactions
Revenue models
Revenue models
•
Generally they follow the same charging methodologies as the voice
b i
d
t bli h d
f
th
d t t d d S
businesses and established norms for the products traded. So vary
from fractional percentages on notional amounts and linked to the tenor
of trades to fixed amounts per million traded
•
Across both businesses and all products it is a varied value proposition.
Charges should be viewed in relation to the underlying volatility of the
Charges should be viewed in relation to the underlying volatility of the
risk they reduce and the liquidity of the relevant market
•
The scale of charges goes from a significant discount to voice execution
where volumes are high, liquidity good, and underlying volatility low….to
a premium in the more illiquid, highly volatile markets where the risk
mitigating value is particularly high
Performance and opportunity
Performance and opportunity
• These basis risk mitigation technologies remove significant risk from the
financial system. An increasingly valuable capability in today’s regulatory and financial system. An increasingly valuable capability in today s regulatory and risk focussed environment
• RESET and ReMATCH showed a 13% increase in revenues last year despiteRESET and ReMATCH showed a 13% increase in revenues last year despite an economic backdrop of persistent, low and stable interest rates. This is a
fundamentally unattractive environment when you consider that LIBOR volatility should be the main demand driver for significant areas of the core businessg
• In the case of RESET expansion of services into additional markets and asset classes such as inflation, floating/floating basis and government bonds have , g g g been major steps towards leveraging both the core business model and the strength of the ICAP franchise. Additional opportunities and projects are in development
• In the case of ReMATCH direct potential within its original core area remains untapped whilst additional types of basis risk within the CDS space present significant opportunity. A “Quanto” service was launched last year to significant success and more recently an Indices product has been rolled out