• No results found

Part   2   of   this   thesis   focuses   on   the   role   of   posttranslational   modifications   in   breaking   tolerance   to   self-­‐antigens   in   susceptible   individuals.   Oxidative   modifications   of   known   autoantigens   were   identified   in   lysates   from   hydrogen   peroxide-­‐induced   necrotic   cells.   It   is   unclear   if   oxidative   modifications   are   involved  in  the  pathogenesis  of  autoimmune  diseases.  Several  questions  still  need   to  be  answered.  Are  the  observed  in  vitro  modifications  also  present  in  vivo  and,   more  importantly,  are  proteins  that  are  modified  upon  oxidative  stress  present  in   affected   tissues   of   autoimmune   patients?   Do   healthy   individuals   also   have   such   proteins  and  do  these  differ  between  healthy  and  diseased  individuals?  Can  these   modified   proteins   induce   autoimmunity   in   animal   models?   CVB-­‐3   infected   Min6   cell  lysates  contain  a  Mr  100,000  protein  which  was  recognized  more  frequently   by  T1D  sera  than  by  control  sera.  This  Mr  100,000  protein  most  likely  is  a  cellular   Min6   protein.   The   data   described   in   this   thesis   may   facilitate   follow-­‐up     studies   to   obtain   more   insight   in   the   role   of   posttranslational   modifications   in   autoimmunity.  

References  

1.   Aletaha   D,   Neogi   T,   Silman   AJ,   Funovits   J,   Felson   DT,   Bingham   CO   3rd,   Birnbaum  NS,  Burmester  GR,  Bykerk  VP,  Cohen  MD,  Combe  B,  Costenbader   KH,  Dougados  M,  Emery  P,  Ferraccioli  G,  Hazes  JM,  Hobbs  K,  Huizinga  TW,   Kavanaugh  A,  Kay  J,  Kvien  TK,  Laing  T,  Mease  P,  Ménard  HA,  Moreland  LW,   Naden  RL,  Pincus  T,  Smolen  JS,  Stanislawska-­‐Biernat  E,  Symmons  D,  Tak  PP,   Upchurch   KS,   Vencovsky   J,   Wolfe   F   and   Hawker   G.   2010     Rheumatoid   arthritis   classification   criteria:   an   American   College   of  

Tc Th B Ab APC virus. infecting. beta.cell beta.cell. apoptosis

General  discussion  

 

129  

Rheumatology/European   League   Against   Rheumatism   collaborative   initiative.  Arthritis  Rheum.  2010;  62(9):  2569-­‐2581.  

2.   Tan  EM,  Cohen  AS,  Fries  JF,  Masi  AT,  McShane  DJ,  Rothfield  NF,  Schaller  JG,   Talal  N,  and  Winchester  RJ.  The  1982  revised  criteria  for  the  classification  of   systemic  lupus  erythematosus.  Arthritis  Rheum.  1982;  25:  1271-­‐1277.   3.   Kasukawa   R.   Preliminary   diagnostic   criteria   for   classification   of   mixed  

connective   tissue   disease.   In   R.   Kasukawa   and   G.C.   Sharp   (eds),   Mixed   Connective   Tissue   Disease   and   Anti-­‐Nuclear   Antibodies   1987:   41-­‐47.   Amsterdam:  Excerpta  Medica.  

4.   Sherer  Y,  Gorstein  A,  Fritzler  MJ,  and  Shoenfeld  Y.  Autoantibody  explosion   in   systemic   lupus   erythematosus.   Semin.   Arthritis   Rheum.   2004;   34:   501-­‐ 537.  

5.   Fritzler  MJ.  Autoantibodies  in  scleroderma.  J.  Dermatol.  1993;  20:257-­‐268.     6.   Ho   KT   and   Reveille   JD.   The   clinical   relevance   of   autoantibodies   in  

scleroderma.  Arthritis  Res.  Ther.  2003;  5:  80-­‐93.  

7.   Sokolove  J,  Lindstrom  TM  and  Robinson  WH.  Development  and  deployment   of  antigen  arrays  for  investigation  of  B-­‐cell  fine  specificity  in  autoimmune   disease.  Front.  Biosci.  2012;  4:  320-­‐330.  

8.   Nelson   BP,   Grimsrud   TE,   Liles   MR,   Goodman   RM   and   Corn   RM.   Surface   plasmon   resonance   imaging   measurement   of   DNA   and   RNA   hybridization   adsorption  onto  DNA  microarrays.  Anal.  Chem.  2001;  73:  1-­‐7.  

9.   Piner   RD,   Zhu   J,   Xu   F,   Hong   S   and   Mirking   CA.   Dip-­‐pen   nanolithography.   Science.  1999;  (283):  661-­‐663.  

10.   Delemarche   E,   Bernard   A,   Schmid   H,   Michel   B   and   Biebuyck   H.   Patterned   Delivery   of   immunoglobulins   to   surfaces   using   Microfluidic   Networks.   Science.  1997;  276(5313):  779-­‐781.  

11.   He   X,   Dandy   DS   and   Henry   CS.   Microfluidic   protein   patterning   on   silicon   nitride   using   solvent-­‐extracted   poly(dimethylsiloxane)   channels.   Sensors   and  Actuators  B:  Chemical.  2008;  129(2):  811-­‐817.  

12.   Chandra  PE,  Sokolove  J,  Hipp  BG,  Lindstrom  TM,  Elder  JT,  Reveille  JD,  Eberl   H,   Klause   U   and   Robinson   WH.   Novel   multiplex   technology   for   diagnostic   characterization   of   rheumatoid   arthritis.   Arthritis   Res.   Ther.   2011;   13(3):   R102.  

13.   Vreugdenhil   GR,   Batstra   MR,   Aanstoot   HJ,   Melchers   WJ   and   Galama   JM.   Analysis   of   antibody   responses   against   coxsackie   virus   B4   protein   2C   and   the  diabetes  autoantigen  GAD65.  J.  Med.  Virol.  1999;  59(2):  256-­‐261.   14.   Poole   BD,   Scofield   RH,   Harley   JB   and   James   JA.   Epstein-­‐Barr   virus   and  

molecular  mimicry  in  systemic  lupus  erythematosus.  Autoimmunity.  2006;   39:  63-­‐70.  

15.   McClain   MT,   Heinlen   LD,   Dennis   GJ,   Roebuck   J,   Harley   JB   and   James   JA.   Early   events   in   lupus   humoral   autoimmunity   suggest   initiation   through   molecular  mimicry.  Nat.  Med.  2005;  11:  85-­‐89.  

Chapter  7  

 

130  

16.   Toussirot  E  and  Roudier  J.  Epstein-­‐Barr  virus  in  autoimmune  diseases.  Best.   Pract.  Res.  Clin.  Rheumatol.  2008;  22:  883-­‐896.  

17.   Douche-­‐Aourik   F,   Berlier   W,   Feasson   L,   Bourlet   T,   Harrath   R,   Omar   S,   Grattard   F,   Denis   C   and   Pozzetto   B.   Detection   of   enterovirus   in   human   skeletal  muscle  from  patients  with  chronic  inflammatory  muscle  disease  or   fibromyalgia  and  healthy  subjects.  J.  Med.  Virol.  2003;  71:  540-­‐547.  

18.   Crum-­‐Cianflone   NF.   Bacterial,   fungal,   parasitic   and   viral   myositis.   Clin.   Microbiol.  Rev.  2008;  21(3):  473-­‐494.  

19.   Notkins   AL   and   Yoon   JW.   Virus-­‐induced   diabetes   mellitus.   In   Concepts   in   Viral   Pathogenesis   (Notkins,   A.   L.   and   Oldstone,   M.   B.   A.,   eds)   1984;   241-­‐ 247,  Springer-­‐Verlag,  New  York.  

20.   Yoon   JW,   Austin   M,   Onodera   T   and   Notkins   AL.   Virus-­‐induced   diabetes   mellitus:   isolation   of   a   virus   from   the   pancreas   of   a   child   with   diabetic   ketoacidosis.  N.  Engl.  J.  Med.  1989;  300:  1173-­‐1179.  

21.   Migliorini,   P   and   Schwartz   RS.   Anti-­‐idiotypic   antibodies   in   autoimmune   diseases.  Clin.  Exp.  Rheumatol.  1998;  6(2):  145-­‐150.  

22.   Jerne   NK,   Roland   J   and   Cazenave   PA.   Recurrent   idiotypes   and   internal   images.  EMBO  J.  1982;  1:  243-­‐247.  

23.   Tzioufas   AG   and   Routsias   JG.   Idiotype,   anti-­‐idiotype   network   of   autoantibodies:   pathogenic   considerations   and   clinical   application.   Autoimmun.  Rev.  2010;  9:  631-­‐633.  

24.   Hof   D,   Pruijn   GJ,   Van   Venrooij   WJ   and   Raats   JMH.   The   role   of   cell   death-­‐ specific   modifications   in   breaking   tolerance   to   self-­‐antigens.   2007   Kettleword,   CR.(Ed.).   Cell   apoptosis   research   advances.   Nova   Science   Publishers,  Hauppauge  NY,  USA.  

25.   Rutjes  SA,  Utz  PJ,  Van  der  HA,  Broekhuis  C,  Van  Venrooij  WJ  and  Pruijn  GJ.   The   La   (SS-­‐B)   autoantigen,   a   key   protein   in   RNA   biogenesis,   is   dephosphorylated   and   cleaved   early   during   apoptosis.   Cell   Death   Differ.   1999;  6(10):  976-­‐986.  

26.   Lorenz   HM,   Herrmann   M,   Winkler   T,   Gaipl   U   and   Kalden   JR.   Role   of   apoptosis  in  autoimmunity.  Apoptosis.  2000;  5:  443-­‐449.  

27.   Rosen   A   and   Casciola-­‐Rosen   L.   Clearing   the   way   to   mechanisms   of   autoimmunity.  Nat.  Med.  2001;  7:  664-­‐665.  

28.   Scott   RS,   McMahon   EJ,   Pop   SM,   Reap   EA,   Caricchio   R,   Cohen   PL,   Earp   HS   and   Matsushima   GK.   Phagocytosis   and   clearance   of   apoptotic   cells   is   mediated  by  MER.  Nature.  2001;  411:  207-­‐211.  

29.   Lu   Q   and   Lemke   G.   Homeostatic   regulation   of   the   immune   system   by   receptor  tyrosine  kinases  of  the  Tyro  3  family.  Science.  2001;  293:  306-­‐311.   30.   Wang   CY,   Mayo   MW,   Korneluk   RG,   Goeddel   DV   and   Baldwin   AS   Jr.   NF-­‐ kappaB  antiapoptosis:  induction  of  TRAF1  and  TRAF2  and  c-­‐IAP1  and  c-­‐IAP2   to  suppress  caspase-­‐8  activation.  Science.  1998;  281(5383):  1680-­‐1683.  

General  discussion  

 

131  

31.   Greidinger  EL,  Foecking  MF,  Ranatunga  S  and  Hoffman  RW.  Apoptotic  U1-­‐ 70-­‐kd   is   antigenically   distinct   from   the   intact   form   of   the   U1-­‐70-­‐kd   molecule.  Arthritis  Rheum.  2002;  46(5):  1264-­‐1269.  

32.   Greidinger  EL,  Foecking  MF,  Magee  J,  Wilson  L,  Ranatunga  S,  Ortmann  RA   and  Hoffman  RW.  A  major  B  cell  epitope  present  on  the  apoptotic  but  not   the   intact   form   of   the   U1-­‐70-­‐kDa   ribonucleoprotein   autoantigen.   J.   Immunol.  2004;  172(1):  709-­‐716.  

33.   Hof  D,  Cheung  K,  De  Rooij  DJ,  Van  den  Hoogen  FH,  Pruijn  GJ,  Van  Venrooij   WJ  and  Raats  JM.  Autoantibodies  specific  for  apoptotic  U1-­‐70K  are  superior   serological  markers  for  mixed  connective  tissue  disease.  Arthritis  Res.  Ther.   2005;  7(2):  R302-­‐R309.  

34.   Mohan   C,   Adams   S,   Stanik   V   and   Datta   SK.   Nucleosome:   a   major   immunogen   for   pathogenic   autoantibody-­‐inducing   T   cells   of   lupus.   J.   Exp.   Med.  1993;  177(5):  1367-­‐1381.  

35.   Van   der   Woude   D,   Rantapaa-­‐Dahlqvist   S,   Ioan-­‐Facsinay   A,   Onnekink   C,   Schwarte  CM,  Verpoort  KN,  Drijfhout  JW,  Huizinga  TW,  Toes  RE  and  Pruijn   GJM.  Epitope  spreading  of  the  anti-­‐citrullinated  protein  antibody  response   occurs   before   disease   onset   and   is   associated   with   the   disease   course   of   early  arthritis.  Ann.  Rheum.  Dis.  2010;  69(8):  1554-­‐1561.  

36.   Heinlen  LD,  McClain  MT,  Merrill  J,  Akbarali  YW,  Edgerton  CC,  Harley  JB  and   James   JA.   Clinical   criteria   for   systemic   lupus   erythematosus   precede   diagnosis,   and   associated   autoantibodies   are   present   before   clinical   symptoms.  Arthritis  Rheum.  2007;  56(7):  2344-­‐2351.  

37.   Nielen  MM,  Van  Schaardenburg  D,  Reesink  HW,  Van  de  Stadt  RJ,  Van  der   Horst-­‐Bruinsma   IE,   De   Koning   MH,   Habibuw   MR,   Vandenbroucke   JP   and   Dijkmans  BA.  Specific  autoantibodies  precede  the  symptoms  of  rheumatoid   arthritis:  a  study  of  serial  measurments  in  blood  donors.  Arthritis  Rheum.   2004;  50(2):  380-­‐386.  

38.   Rantapaa-­‐Dahlqvist   S,   De   Jong   BA,   Berglin   E,   Hallmans   G,   Wadell   G,   Stenlund   H,   Sundin   U   and   Van   Venrooij   WJ.   Antibodies   against   cyclic   citrullinated  peptide  and  IgA  rheumatoid  factor  predict  the  development  of   rheumatic  arthritis.  Arthritis  Rheum.  2003;  48(10):  27411-­‐2749.  

39.   Van  de  Stadt  LA,  Van  de  Horst  AR,  De  Koning  MH,  Bos  WH,  Wolbink  GJ,  Van   de  Stadt  RJ,  Pruijn  GJ,  Dijkmans  BA,  Van  Schaardenburg  D  and  Hamann  D.   The  extent  of  the  anti-­‐citrullinated  protein  antibody  repertoire  is  associated   with   arthritis   development   in   patients   with   seropositive   arthralgia.   Ann.   Rheum.  Dis.  2011;  70(1):  128-­‐133.  

40.   Balaban  RS,  Nemoto  S  and  Finkel  T.  Mitochondria,  oxidants,  and  aging.  Cell.   2005;  120(4):  483-­‐495.  

41.   Marnett  LJ.  Oxyradicals  and  DNA  damage.  Carcinogenesis.  2000;  21(3):  361-­‐ 370.  

Chapter  7  

 

132  

42.   England   K   and   Cotter   TG.   Direct   oxidative   modifications   of   signalling   proteins   in   mammalian   cells   and   their   effects   on   apoptosis.   Redox   Rep.   2005;  10(5):  237-­‐245.  

43.   Noguchi  N,  Yamashita  H,  Hamahara  J,  Nakamura  A,  Kuhn  H  and  Niki  E.  The   specificity   of   lipoxygenase-­‐catalyzed   lipid   peroxidation   and   the   effects   of   radical-­‐scavenging  antioxidants.  Biol.  Chem.  2002;  383(3-­‐4):  619-­‐626.   44.   Quinn   MT   and   Gauss   KA.   Structure   and   regulation   of   the   neutrophil  

respiratory   burst   oxidase:   comparison   with   nonphagocyte   oxidases.   J.   Leukoc.  Biol.  2004;  76:  760-­‐781.  

45.   Fiers  W,  Beyaert  R,  Declercq  W  and  Vandenabeele  P.  More  than  one  way  to   die:   apoptosis,   necrosis   and   reactive   oxgen   damage.   Oncogene.   1999;   18:   7719-­‐7730.  

46.   Wong  GH,  Elwell  JH,  Oberley  LW  and  Goeddel  DV.  Manganous  superoxide   dismutase   is   essential   for   cellular   resistance   to   cytotoxicity   of   tumor   necrosis  factor.  Cell.  1989;  58(5):  923-­‐931.  

47.   Griffiths   HR.   Is   the   generation   of   neo-­‐antigenic   determinants   by   free   radicals   central   to   the   development   of   autoimmune   rheumatoid   disease?   Autoimmun.  Rev.  2008;  7:  544-­‐549.  

48.   Dai  L,  Zhang  Z,  Winyard  PG,  Gaffney  K,  Jones  H,  Blake  DR  and  Morris  CJ.  A   modified   form   of   low-­‐density   lipoprotein   with   increased   electronegative   charge   is   present   in   rheumatoid   arthritis   synovial   fluid.   Free   Radic.   Biol.   Med.  1997;  22:  705-­‐710.  

49.   Jose  SA,  Griffiths  H,  Lunec  J,  Mageed  RA  and  Jefferis  R.  Immunogenic  and   antigenic  epitopes  of  immunoglobulin-­‐XX.  Denaturation  of  human  IgG3  by   free  radicals.  Mol.  Immunol.  1987;  24:  1145-­‐1150.  

50.   Volpe  A,  Biasi  D,  Caramaschi  P,  Mantovani  W,  Bambara  L.M,  Canestrini  S,   Ferrari  M,  Poli  G,  Degan  M,  Carletto  A,  Pieropan  S  and  Minuz  P.  Levels  of   F2-­‐isoprostanes   in   systemic   sclerosis:   correlation   with   clinical   features.   Rheumatology  (Oxford).  2006;  45:  314-­‐320.  

51.   Kurien   BT   and   Scofield   RH.   Autoimmunity   and   oxidatively   modified   autoantigens.  Autoimmun.  Rev.  2008;  7:  567-­‐573.  

52.   Trigwell  SM,  Radford  PM,  Page  SR,  Loweth  AC,  James  RF,  Morgan  NG  and   Todd   I.   Islet   glutamic   acid   decarboxylase   modified   by   reactive   oxygen   species   is   recognized   by   antibodies   from   patients   with   type   1   diabetes   mellitus.  Clin.  Exp.  Immunol.  2001;  126(2):  242-­‐249.  

53.   Casciola-­‐Rosen   L,   Wigley   F   and   Rosen   A.   Scleroderma   autoantigens   are   uniquely   fragmented   by   metal-­‐catalyzed   oxidation   reactions:   implication   for  pathogenesis.  J.  Exp.  Med.  1997;  185:  71-­‐79.  

54.   Servettaz  A,  Goulvestre  C,  Kavian  N,  Nicco  C,  Guilpain  P,  Chereau  C,  Vuiblet   V,  Guillevin  L,  Mouthon  L,  Weill  B  and  Batteux  F.  Selective  oxidation  of  DNA   topoisomerase  1  induces  systemic  sclerosis  in  the  mous.  J.  Immunol.  2009;   182(9):  5855-­‐5864.  

General  discussion  

 

133  

55.   Khan   MW,   Sherwani   S,   Khan   WA   and   Ali   R.   Characterization   of   hydroxyl   radical   modified   GAD65:   a   potential   autoantigen   in   type   1   diabetes.   Autoimmunity.  2009;  42:  150-­‐158.  

56.   Khan   MW,   Banga,   Mashal   SN   and   Khan   WA.   Detection   of   autoantibodies   against  reactive  oxygen  species  modified  glutamic  acid  decarboxylase-­‐65  in   type  1  diabetes  associated  complications.  BMC  Immunol.  2011;  12:  19.   57.   Halliwell  B  and  Gutteridge  JMC.  Biologically  relevant  metal  ion-­‐dependent  

hydroxyl  radical  generation.  An  update.  FEBS  Lett.  1992;  307:  108-­‐112.   58.   Hippeli   S   and   Elstner   EF.   OH-­‐radical-­‐type   reactive   oxygen   species:   a   short  

review   on   the   mechanisms   of   OH-­‐radical   and   peroxynitrite   toxicity.   Z.   Naturforsch.  1997;  52c:  555-­‐563.  

59.   Halliwell  B  and  Gutteridge  JMC.  Oxygen  toxicity,  oxygen  radicals,  transition   metals  and  disease.  Biochem.  J.  1984;  219:  1-­‐14.  

60.   Guptasarma  P,  Balasubramaniam  D,  Matsugo  S  and  Saito  I.  Hydroxyl  radical   mediated   damage   to   proteins,   with   special   reference   to   the   crystallins.   Biochemistry.  1992;  31(17):  4296-­‐4303.  

61.   Kim   NH,   Jeong   MS,   Choi   SY   and   Kang   JH.   Oxidative   modification   of   cytochrome  c  by  hydrogen  peroxide.  Mol.  Cells.  2006;  22(2):  220-­‐227.   62.   Albano  E.  Alcohol,  oxidative  stress  and  free  radical  damage.  Proc.  Nutr.  Soc.  

2006;  65:  278-­‐290.  

63.   Albano   E.   Oxidative   mechanisms   in   the   pathogenesis   of   alcoholic   liver   disease.  Mol.  Aspects.  Med.  2008;  29(1-­‐2):  9-­‐16.  

64.   Stacchiotti   A,   Morandini   F,   Bettoni   F,   Schena   I,   Lavazza   A,   Grigolato   PG,   Apostoli  P,  Rezzani  R  and  Aleo  MF.  Stress  proteins  and  oxidative  damage  in   a  renal  derived  cell  line  exposed  to  inorganic  mercury  and  lead.  Toxicology.   2009;  264:  215-­‐224.  

65.   Zhang  L,  Li  Y,  Xing  and  Gao  C.  Characterization  of  mitochondrial  dynamics   and   subcellular   localization   of   ROS   reveal   that   HsfA2   alleviates   oxidative   damage  caused  by  heat  stress  in  Arabidopsis.  J.  Exp.  Bot.  2009;  60:  2073-­‐ 2091.  

66.   Kawamura  F,  Hirashima  N,  Furuno  T  and  Nakanishi  M.  Effects  of  2-­‐methyl-­‐ 1,4,naphtoquinone  (menadione)  on  cellular  signaling  in  RBL-­‐2H3  cells.  Biol.   Pharm.  Bull.  2006;  29:  605-­‐607.  

67.   Nicotera  TM,  Privalle  C,  Wang  TC,  Oshimura  M  and  Barrett  JC.  Differential   proliferative   responses   of   Syrian  hamster   embryo   fibroblasts   to   paraquat-­‐ generated   superoxide   radicals   depending   on   tumor   suppressor   gene   function.  Cancer  Res.  1994;  54:  3884-­‐3888.  

68.   Deshmukh  US,  Bagavant  H,  Lewis  J,  Gaskin  F  and  Fu  SM.  Epitope  spreading   within   lupus-­‐associated   ribonucleoprotein   antigens.   Clin.   Immunol.   2005;   117(2):  112-­‐120.  

Chapter  7  

 

134  

69.   Herrick   AL,   Rieley   F   and   Schofield   D.   Micronutrient   antioxidant   status   in   patients   with   primary   Raynaud’s   phenomenon   and   systemic   sclerosis.   J.   Rheumatol.  1994;  21:  1477-­‐1483.  

70.   Iwata  Y,  Ogawa  F,  Komura  K,  Muroi  E,  Hara  T,  Shimizu  K,  Hasegawa  M,   Fujimoto  M,  Tomita  Y  and  Sato  S.  Autoantibody  against  peroxiredoxin  I,  an   antioxidant  enzyme,  in  patients  with  systemic  sclerosis:  possible  association   with  oxidative  stress.  Rheumatology.  2007;  46:  790-­‐795.  

71.   Sambo  P,  Jannino  L,  Candela  M,  Salvi  A,  Donini  M,  Dusi  S,  Luchetti  MM,  and   Gabrielli   A.   Monocytes   of   patients   with   systemic   sclerosis   (scleroderma)   spontaneously   release   in   vitro   increased   amounts   of   superoxide   anion.   J.   Invest.  Dermatol.  1999;  112:  78-­‐84.  

72.   Maxwell   SRJ,   Thomason   H,   Sandler   D,   Leguen   C,   Baxter   MA,   Thorpe   GH,   Jones  AF  and  Barnett  AH.  Antioxidant  status  in  patients  with  uncomplicated   insulin-­‐dependent  and  non-­‐insulin-­‐dependent  diabetes  mellitus.  Eur.  J.  Clin.   Invest.  1997;  27(6):  484-­‐490.  

73.   Rocić  B,  Vucić  M,  Knezević-­‐Cuća  J,  Radica  A,  Pavlić-­‐Renar  I,  Profozić  V  and   Metelko   Z.   Total   plasma   antioxidants   in   first-­‐degree   relatives   of   patients   with  insulin  dependent  diabetes.  Exp.  Clin.  Endo.  Diab.  1997;  105(4):  213-­‐ 217.  

74.   Delmastrol   MM   and   Piganelli   J.   Oxidative   Stress   and   Redox   Modulation   Potential   in   Type   1   Diabetes.   Clin.   Dev.   Imm   2011;   593863.   doi:   10.1155/2011/593863.  Epub  2011  May  18.  

75.   Lenzen  S.  Oxidative  stress:  the  vulnerable  β-­‐cell.  Biochem.  Soc.  Trans.  2008;   36(3):  343-­‐347.  

76.   Lenzen   S,   Drinkgem   J   and   Tiedge   M.   Low   antioxidant   enzyme   gene   expression  in  pancreatic  islets  compare  with  various  other  mouse  tissues.   Free  Rad.  Biol.  Med.  1996;  20(3):  463-­‐466.  

77.   Tiedge  M,  Lortz  S,  Drinkgem  J  and  Lenzen  S.  Relation  between  antioxidant   enzyme   gene   expression   and   antioxidative   defense   status   of   insulin-­‐ producing  cells.  Diabetes.  1997;  46(11):  1733-­‐1742.  

78.   Grankvist   K,   Marklund   SL   and   Taljedal   B.   CuZnsuperoxide   dismutase,   Mn-­‐ superoxide   dismutase,   catalase   and   glutathione   peroxidase   in   pancreatic   islets  and  other  tissues  in  the  mouse.  Biochem.  J.  1981;  199(2):  393-­‐398.   79.   Jaïdane   H,   Sané   F,   Gharbi   J,   Aouni   M,   Romond   MB   and   Hober   D.  

Coxsackievirus  B4  and  type  1  diabetes  pathogenesis:  contribution  of  animal   models.  Diabetes  Metab.  Res.  Rev.  2009;  25:  591-­‐603.  

80.   Bach   JF.   The   effect   of   infections   on   susceptibility   to   autoimmune   and   allergic  diseases.  N.  Engl.  J.  Med.  2002;  347:  911-­‐920.  

81.   Goldberg   E   and   Krause   I.   Infection   and   type   1   diabetes   mellitus—a   two   edged  sword?  Autoimmun.  Rev.  2009;  8:  682-­‐686.  

82.   Christen  U,  Bender  C  and  Von  Herratch  MG.  Infection  as  a  cause  of  type  1   diabetes?  Curr.  Opin.  Rheumatol.  2012;  24(4):  417-­‐423.  

General  discussion  

 

135  

83.   Yoon   JW.   A   new   look   at   viruses   in   type   1   diabetes.   Diabetes   Metab.   Rev.   1995;  11:  83-­‐107.  

84.   Richer   MJ   and   Horwitz   MS.   Coxsackievirus   infection   as   an   environmental   factor   in   the   etiology   of   type   1   diabetes.   Autoimmun.   Rev.   2009;   8:   611-­‐ 615.  

85.   Jaïdane   H   and   Hober   D.   Role   of   coxsackievirus   B4   in   the   pathogenesis   of   type  1  diabetes.  Diabetes  Metab.  2008;  34:  537-­‐548.  

86.   Sarmiento   L,   Cabrera-­‐Rode   E,   Lekuleni   L,   Cuba   I,   Molina   G,   Fonseca   M,   Heng-­‐Hung   L,   Borroto   AD,   Gonzalez   P,   Mas-­‐Lago   P   and   Diaz-­‐Horta   O.   Occurrence  of  enterovirus  RNA  in  serum  of  children  with  newly  diagnosed   type  1  diabetes  and  islet  cell  autoantibody-­‐positive  subjects  in  a  population   with  a  low  incidence  of  type  1  diabetes.  Autoimmunity.  2007;  40:  540-­‐545.   87.   Elfaitouri   A,   Berg   AK,   Frisk   G,   Yin   H,   Tuvemo   T   and   Blomberg   J.   Recent  

enterovirus  infection  in  type  1  diabetes:  evidence  with  a  novel  IgM  method.   J.  Med.  Virol.  2007;  79:  1861-­‐1867.  

88.   Hyöty  H.  Enterovirus  infections  and  type  1  diabetes.  Ann.  Med.  2002;   34:   138-­‐147.  

89.   Haverkos  HW,  Battula  N,  Drotman  DP  and  Rennert  OM.  Enteroviruses  and   type  1  diabetes  mellitus.  Biomed.  Pharmacother.  2003;  57:  379-­‐385.  

90.   Moya-­‐Suri   V,   Schlosser   M,   Zimmermann   K,   Rjasanowski   I,   Gurtler   L   and   Mentel   R.   Enterovirus   RNA   sequences   in   sera   of   schoolchildren   in   the   general   population   and   their   association   with   type   1-­‐diabetes-­‐associated   autoantibodies.  J.  Med.  Microbiol.  2005;  54:  879-­‐883.  

91.   Vreugdenhill  GR,  Batstra  MR,  Aanstoot  HJ,  Melchers  WJG  and  Galama  JMD.   Analysis  of  antibody  response  against  Coxsackie  virus  B4  protein  2C  and  the   diabetes  autoantigen  GAD65.  J.  Med.  Virol.  1999;  59:  256-­‐261.  

92.   Gamble   DR,   Kinsley   ML,   FitzGerald   MG,   Bolton   R   and   Taylor   KW.   Viral   antibodies  in  diabetes  mellitus.  Br.  Med.  J.  1969;  3:  627-­‐630.  

93.   Jun   HS   and   Yoon   JW.   A   new   look   at   viruses   in   type   1   diabetes.   Diabetes   Metab.  Res.  Rev.  2003;  19:  8-­‐31.  

94.   Richer   MJ   and   Horwitz   MS.   Viral   infections   in   the   pathogenis   of   autoimmune   diseases:   focus   on   type   1   diabetes.   Front.   Biosci.   2008;   13:   4241-­‐4257.

     

Chapter  8  

 

Summary  

Samenvatting  

List  of  publications  

Curriculum  vitae  

Dankwoord  

 

Summary  

 

139  

Summary  

Autoimmune   diseases   arise   from   an   inappropriate   immune   response   towards   substances   and   tissues   normally   present   in   the   body.   One   of   the   characteristic   features   of   autoimmune   diseases   is   the   occurrence   of   high   titers   of   autoantibodies   in   the   sera   of   these   patients.   In   sera   of   patients   suffering   from   rheumatoid   arthritis   (RA)   autoantibodies   are   found   targeting   citrullinated   proteins,   and   these   autoantibodies   sometimes   can   be   detected   years   before   disease   onset.   These   anti-­‐citrullinated   protein   antibodies   (ACPA)   are   exclusively   found  in  RA  patients  and  recently  it  was  shown  that  the  RA  patients  who  don’t   produce   ACPA   represent   a   specific   subpopulation   of   patients   with   a   different   prognosis   than   ACPA-­‐positive   RA   patients,   making   ACPA   a   very   good   diagnostic   and  prognostic  tool.    

 

Although  the  clinical  utility  of  these  autoantibodies  is  appreciated,  little  is  known   about   the   mechanisms   related   to   their   production   and   the   regulation   of   the   autoimmune   response.   One   model   hypothesizes   that   posttranslational   modifications   occurring   during   cell   death   can   result   in   the   generation   of   neo-­‐ epitopes  and  the  loss  of  immunological  tolerance  to  self-­‐antigens.  

 

The   increasing   number   of   distinct   autoantibodies   and   the   diversity   of   autoantibodies  with  similar  or  related  specificities  motivate  the  need  for  assays  in   which   multiple   autoantibodies   in   the   same   sample   can   be   detected   simultaneously.   The   goal   of   the   first   studies   described   in   this   thesis   was   to   develop   a   multiplex   assay   based   on   imaging   surface   plasmon   resonance   (iSPR),   which  can  be  used  to  subdivide  RA  patients  based  on  their  autoantibody  profile   (described  in  Part  1:  Chapters  2  to  4).  Another  goal  was  to  gain  more  insight  in  the   development   of   autoimmune   diseases   and   to   investigate   the   role   of   cell   death-­‐ associated   protein   modifications   in   the   initiation   of   the   autoimmune   response   (described  in  Part  2:  Chapters  5  and  6).  

 

This   thesis   starts   with   an   introductory   chapter,   Chapter   1,   which   gives   an   overview  of  our  current  knowledge  on  the  generation  of  autoantibodies,  with  a   special  focus  on  the  proposed  role  of  cell  death-­‐associated  protein  modifications   in   breaking   immunological   tolerance.   In   addition,   the   iSPR   technology   for   measuring  autoantibody  profiles  in  a  multiplex  format  is  introduced.  

 

The   presence   of   (auto)antibodies   in   biofluids   can   be   measured   by   various   experimental   approaches,   such   as   enzyme   linked   immunosorbent   assay   (ELISA),   immunodiffusion,  immunoprecipitation,  immunoblotting,  etc.  Multiplex  platforms   have   the   advantage   to   test   for   the   presence   of   multiple   autoantibodies