A. Conclusions
Based on the research findings and discussions in the previous chapter, the following conclusions are presented:
a. The student’s problems in summarize a text were: the lack of vocabularies, structure or grammar, and translating. For the improvement of their ability in Reading Comprehension expecially in Summarize a text, the teachers should be good in teaching translation, fix their articulation and teach the students vocabulary building by strategies that they used to teach in Reading Comprehension.
b. Using Summarizing text is able to improve the students’ ability in Reading Comprehension. It was proved by the students’ achievement in table 2 and table 3 total of mean score in each literal comprehension was 5,3 and their Reading test was 6,6.
c. Using Summrizing Text combined with main idea is able to make the students more interested in learning process, especially in reading activities.
d. The process of the test and data collecting were well during the research at class XI Ipa 2 because the students were spirit and enjoy to learn English.
Besides that, the writer also got full support by the teachers.
30
B. Suggestions
In relation to the reading comprehension in terms of literal reading comprehension and summarizing in this thesis, the writer would like to give some suggestions to the students (learners), the English teacher and the next researchers as follows:
1. For the Students
Students need practice and learn more not only in the informal education, but also the formal education to improve their reading comprehension.Students need to learn the new vocabularies and structure of the sentence in order to improve their skill in translating the text that related to their lesson.
2. For the English Teacher
The application Summarizing Text as the one of Literal Comprehension was strongly suggested to be applied in teaching reading in the classroom in order to increase the students’ reading comprehension.
3. For the Next Researchers
To improvement the students’ reading comprehension generally, there are many cases which must be improved such as: literal reading comprehension. But in this research, the writer focused attention on students’ Reading Comprehension . So for the next researcher, they can take the other case of reading to be students’ reading comprehension with different discussions.
and Reading Ability at The Second Years students of SMP negeri 2 Sungguminasa. Unpublised Thesis : Makasssar. Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Asmawati, 2012. Thesis. The use of Individual Reading Method at the Second Year of SMA Negeri 1 Galesong Utara. Unpublished Thesis. Makassar:
Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Ambruster, B.B, Anderson, T.H, & Ostertag,J, 1987. Does text structure/summarization instruction facilitate learning from expository text? Journal of Reading Research Quarterly.
Brown,A.L, & Day,J.D, 1983. Macro-rules for summarizing texts: The development of expertise. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior.
Carnie. 1990. Doughlas, Jerry Silbert, and Edward Kameenui. Direct Interaction Reading Second Edition USA. Menrill Publishing Company.
Doctorrow, M.J, Wittrock, M.C & Marks, C.B, 1978. Direct Interaction Reading Second Edition USA : Menrill Publishing Company.
Grellet, Francoise,1981. Developing Reading skills.London: Combridge.
Gay.1981. Educational Research. U.S.A : Charles E.Merril Publishing.Co
Harvey & Goudvis.2007.National Reading Panel. Ohio: National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.
Hasman,Sugiratna,2011. Improving students Reading comprehension through Shared Reading Strategy at the second years of Sma Negeri 1 Kajang Bulukumba Regency. Unpublised Thesis. Makasssar: Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Hasnawati, 2000. The Difficulties Encountered by the second Year Students of SLTP Negeri 2 Takalar in Reading Comprehension. Unpublised Thesis.
Makasssar: State University of Makassar.
Hikmawati,2011.Improving Reading Comprehension through Think Aloud Strategy at second years of MTS Muhammadiyah Lempangan Kab. Gowa.
Unpublised Thesis. Makasssar. Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Indrayana, Imelda,2012. Improving the Students Reading Comprehension
Through Paraphrase Passport Strategy at the Second Year the Students (1F) of SMA Muhammadiyah Limbung. Unpublished Thesis. Makassar:
Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
John C. Bean, 2004 . Virginia Chappell, and Alice M. Gillam, Reading Rhetorically. Pearson Education.
Layman,1972. Teaching in Testing. New York: Oxford University Press
Nuttal, Cristine.1982.Teaching Reading Skills in a Foreign Language. London:
ELBS.
Nurhayati.2011. Thesis. Developing the students’ reading comprehension through cognitive reading strategies. Unpublised Thesis. Makasssar:
Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Nurfaedah,2012. Thesis. Improving the students’ Reading Comprehension through GIST Strategy at the second year students of MTs Muhammadiyah Lempangan Gowa. Unpublised Thesis. Makassar: Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Pose. 1976. Assessing Reading. Cambridge: The press syndicate of the University of Canbridge.
P.Rachmawati,2012. Improving students’ Reading Comprehension through reciprocal method. Unpublished Thesis. Makassar: Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Smith, J. Richard and Jhonson, D. Dale. 1980. Reading Instruction for Today’s Children. United States of America: Practice Hall, Inc.
Sudijono,Anas.2014. Pengantar Statistik Pendidikan. Jakarta: PT. Raja Grafindo Persada.
Susilawati,Dewi,2012. Improving Studentes’ Reading Comprehension Through Mood Understand Recall Digest Expand and Review (Murder) Strategy at the Ninth Grade Students of SMP Muhammadiyah 5 Mariso Makassar.
Unpublished Thesis. Makassar: Muhammadiyah University of Makassar.
Winne, P.H, & Hadwin, A.F, 1998. Studying as self-regulated learning. In D, Metacognition in educational theory and practice. Hillsdale, NJ : LEA (Anonymous).(n.d). Types of Reading. Retrieved March 25, 2009 from
http://www.readinganswer.com/display/php
( Sma 14 Makassar class XI ipa 2 ) No Students’
code Main Idea Summarizing Total Score
Total Score 68 65 165,3
Mean Score 2,7 2,6 6,6 Fairly Good
a. Means Score Literal Comprehension.
1) Mean Score Main Idea 2) Means Score Summarizing
7
2 RNA Fadillah Astri oktaviani
3 VNA Venny Amaliah
4 STN Siti Nurhaliza
5 FAO Rini Anriani
6 NRS Nurul shifa
7 EDS Ersa Dwi Saharani
8 FTW Fitri Wulandari
9 NRA Nurul Azizah
10 EKA Eka
11 FTA Fitri Anggraini. A
12 SKS Sukmawati Sukri
13 IKS Ikeh Septiani
14 MWS Mawarsari
15 NFR Nur Fajrianti Rais
16 JHA Jihan Amir
17 FKB Fikri Bakri
18 AGB Agustino. B
19 YRM Yusuf Rezki Muharram
20 MRR Muh. Rahmat. R
21 ADR Adiya Risbayu Esa
22 KRS Kurniawan. S
23 MSH M. Syukur. H
24 MRA M. Rifki Aditya. AR
25 MDF Muhammad Dwi Farhan
What Are the difficulties that you found in summarize a Narrative Text?
summarize narrative which too long story and new vocabularies.
S-2 I’m difficult to read narrative without understand the words
which contained in it.
S-3 I didn’t understand the tenses that used in narrative text.
S-4 I ‘m difficult to answer without learning new vocabularies first.
S-5 I’m difficult to arrange my words into a good sentence
grammatically.
What Are the tanpa mengerti kosa kata yang terdapat di bacaannya.
Fitri Anggriani. A Saya tidak mengerti tentang tenses yang terdapat pada teks narasi.
Nurul Azizah Saya sulit menyusun kalimat sesuai tata bahasa.
What are the difficulties that you found in
summarize a Narrative Text?
Low in vocabulary
Its difficult to translate a text
Grammar
1. Do you understand about narrative text?
Sometimes, only by the familiar words that i ever memorize.
2. What are the difficulties that you found in summarize narrative text?
I can’t read narrative which too long story and new vocabularies.
3. How could you comprehend a reading text besides summarize?
I usually open the dictionary or use google translate machine to understand the text. But i didn’t get what the text tell about.
4. What are the benefits of Summarizing Text in your study?
I can comprehend the idea of the text that i’ve read.
5. What are your prospects for teacher in teaching Reading Comprehension?
I hope, the teacher will teach us about the difficult words and structures that related in the reading text.
1. Do you understand about narrative text?
No, i dont.
2. What are the difficulties that you found in summarize narrative text?
I can’t read narrative without understand the words.
3. How could you comprehend a reading text besides summarize?
I usually use google translate machine to understand the text, I didnt know how to translate it by dictionary.
4. What are the benefits of Summarizing Text in your study?
I can comprehend at least 30% of the text.
5. What are your prospects for teacher in teaching Reading Comprehension?
I hope, the teacher will teach us more intensive in translating the text.
1. Do you understand about narrative text?
Sometimes, i can comprehend it by the words that i used to hear.
2. What are the difficulties that you found in summarize narrative text?
I can’t understand the tenses that used in narrative text.
3. How could you comprehend a reading text besides summarize?
I usually use dictionary and translate words by words.
4. What are the benefits of Summarizing Text in your study?
I can understand the main ideas in the reading text.
5. What are your prospects for teacher in teaching Reading Comprehension?
I hope, the teacher using good translation in teach us reading comprehension.
1. Do you understand about narrative text?
Not really, because i can’t understand what the text tell about.
2. What are the difficulties that you found in summarize narrative text?
I can’t answer without learning new vocabularies which appears in the text.
3. How could you comprehend a reading text besides summarize?
I tried to translate the each of paragraph by dictionary.
4. What are the benefits of Summarizing Text in your study?
I can comprehend the purpose of reading text.
5. What are your prospects for teacher in teaching Reading Comprehension?
I hope, the teacher will read the text first with good translation in order to makes the students were understand .
1. Do you understand about narrative text?
Sometimes, i am not sure with my vocabularies.
2. What are the difficulties that you found in summarize narrative text?
I can’t arrange my words into a good sentence grammatically.
3. How could you comprehend a reading text besides summarize?
I usually use google translate machine to understand the text, I didnt know how to translate it by dictionary.
4. What are the benefits of Summarizing Text in your study?
I can comprehend half of the text.
5. What are your prospects for teacher in teaching Reading Comprehension?
I hope, the teacher will teach us more intensive in translating the text.
marriage parents Abidin and Marlina.
In 1997 the writer registered as a students of elementary school Inpres Mariso II Makassar and she graduated in 2003. The next in the same year the writer registered as a students in SMP Negeri 3 Makassar and graduated in 2006. Then the writer registered as a student in Sma Negeri 14 Makassar graduated in 2009. In 2009, the writer registered her study as a student of English Department In Makassar Muhammadiyah University.