Chapter 6 Conclusions and Perspectives
6.1 Conclusions
Functional neuroimaging offers a great opportunity to noninvasively study the
underlying activities in the normal as well as diseased brain. In this dissertation, we have
investigated utilizing EEG source imaging and functional MRI in the diagnosis and
management of epilepsy and pain.
One important application of functional neuroimaging techniques in detecting and
localizing pathological activities lies in pre-surgical evaluations of patients suffering from
intractable epilepsy. In one of the studies presented here, we have proposed an ICA-based
automated method to lateralize and localize hemodynamic foci in focal epilepsy patients
for presurgical evaluation. Focal activities identified by our method were in concordance
with surgical resection in the majority of cases studied. Our findings suggest the
possibility of noninvasively and accurately localizing epileptic foci using fMRI alone in
presurgical planning. This was a feasibility study to demonstrate the value of the
proposed method. Additional features can be incorporated in the algorithm to improve
reliability and performance. A larger patient population needs to be studied to test the
broad applicability of this method. This proposed method can be easily implemented in
the current presurgical workup to provide additional information for guiding the surgical
resection.
Unlike for patients with focal epilepsy, surgical resection is not a viable treatment
116
mechanism of generating wide spread epileptic activity remains poorly understood.
Therefore in order to provide benefits to these patients, there is a pressing need to
improve our understanding of the neural network and mechanism of action in order to
develop novel therapeutic approaches such as deep brain stimulation. In the second study
presented, by combining the complementary strengths of EEG and fMRI, we showed
consistent results concerning the genesis and propagation of GSWDs. EEG-informed
fMRI revealed multiple brain regions that may be involved in GSWDs. By means of
seed-based fMRI, we tested the specific network level activity and found temporal
correlation between cortical and bithalamic BOLD activities. According to the Granger
Causality analysis the mediodorsal nuclei of the thalamus serve as the main driver
throughout the initiation and the propagation of the GSWDs. Once validated, this work
can provide insight in understanding the enigmatic etiology of generalized epilepsy and
offer guidance in treatments. This work suggests the thalamus, especially the mediodorsal
nuclei, may serve as potential targets for deep brain stimulation to treat patients with
drug-resistant generalized epilepsy.
Another field of application of such noninvasive imaging techniques is to provide
better understanding of how the brain processes pain and ultimately to provide an
objective measure of pain. For the study of exogenously elicited pain, by using scalp
EEG we found that the spontaneous rhythms in all frequency bands except gamma band
were suppressed globally at the presence of tonic painful thermal stimulation. The
greatest changes were observed in the alpha power on the contralateral side to the
stimulus in the somatosensory area. Additionally, the results suggested that the degree of
117
connectivity among major brain regions that responsive to pain, which was revealed
through causality analysis. Although the current finding is based on the study of sustained
pain from external stimuli in healthy subjects, it would help broaden our understanding of
cortical response to patients with chronic pain.
In addition to external pain, we also studied patients with sickle cell disease, as
they often suffer from chronic or acute pain as a result of the disease. We found that
through fMRI based functional connectivity analyses, the resting state neural network in
patients deviated from those of the healthy controls with both positive and negative
effects. The default mode network, which is a ubiquitous resting state activity believed to
be responsible for a host of cognitive functions such as memory consolidation and
introspection, is reduced in patients with SCD compared to controls. On the other hand,
insula cortex, which is a key node in the pain network, showed a marked increase in
bilateral synchrony in patients with SCD as opposed to healthy controls.
In summary, the present dissertation research developed and evaluated the
spatiotemporal imaging approaches for the non-invasive mapping of network activities in
the diseased and normal brain. Evaluations were conducted in both patient and healthy
control groups in order to test the clinical applicability of such noninvasive imaging tools.
Regarding epilepsy, two investigations have been conducted to study the localization of
hemodynamic foci in focal epilepsy patients and the widespread GSWDs of generalized
epilepsy patients. The spatial resolution has been further improved by adding the
component of fMRI through an EEG-fMRI integrated imaging framework. For the
application in pain study, two investigations were conducted to study changes in network
118
with SCD. All of the results that were obtained suggest the importance of noninvasive
spatiotemporal neuroimaging approaches for solving clinical problems and for
investigating neuroscience questions. Furthermore, an improved understanding of
neurological diseases and their mechanisms would help us to develop and deliver curative
treatments of neurological diseases.