knowledge
Chapter 6 Discussion
6.4 A database of knowledge
All the managers agreed that a database of employees' non-clinical skills and
qualifications would be useful. Staff responded to a similar question regarding
putting their qualifications, skills and languages on a database with 50.1% of
respondents answering positively, 28.1% negatively, the remaining did not answer the
question. If and how a database could be set up was not tackled in this research. If
the organisation decided that a database could be useful then a starting point could be
at a ward level. From the research we see that at a ward level managers are not aware
of all the knowledge that is held within the ward. All staff including managers
expressed concern about the impact the use of non-clinical skills would have on the
clinical workload of the wards. If a database was first set up at a ward level then the
knowledge in that ward could be utilised within the ward making the time used in
non-clinical and clinical work more flexible and easy to monitor to ensure time is not
taken from the patients. If this system worked it could then be extended to a business
unit level. Further research would be needed to investigate the cost benefit of setting
up the database and then it's use within the ward or business unit. Other possible uses
of the database would also need to be researched including career and succession
The organisation could benefit from closer investigation of staff who indicated that
they hold other qualifications, skills or languages. From Table 4.5 we see that three
of the respondents indicated that they hold a Grade 1 position, all indicated that they
have other skills and two indicated that they have other languages. The most junior
respondents were all able to identify skills that could be useful for the organisation.
In contrast of the most senior respondents that of ANUM only 57% indicated that they
have other skills and only 14% indicated that they have other qualifications. If this
group of respondents wish to further their career they will need to be able to identify
other skills and qualifications to enable them to function in a higher grade or position.
The recognised next step in the career path of this group is into a Unit Managers
position or into education, both of which will require non-clinical skills.
A further interesting finding is that the highest percentage of staff having other
qualifications was found in the Senior Grade 2 group. Here 30% indicated that they
have other qualifications. This is the highest percentage of any group for
qualifications. This group also had a high percentage of other skills, with 50%
indicating that they possessed other skills. Further research into this group of
employees to investigate why they do not hold more senior positions, such as CNS or
ANUM positions, may be of benefit. It may be that they have been focusing on
gaining further qualifications in order to obtain new positions. If these targeted
positions are not within the organisation then the organisation may need to discover
what knowledge may be lost by these employees leaving. This knowledge would
include additional qualifications and skills that they possess as well as clinical skills
of these staff members and the use of career planning at a ward and business unit level
could assist both the employees and the organisation to retain clinical expertise and
additional knowledge. To use career and succession planning the organisation needs
to be aware of the additional skills and qualifications that employees hold, as this
research shows at present management are not aware of the depth of non-clinical
knowledge held by staff.
6.6 Conclusion
This research provides grounds for the assumption that the nursing staff within NWH
have skills and knowledge which are currently untapped by the organisation. Many
reasons have been identified as to why their knowledge is not being utilised.
Management is largely vinaware of the knowledge held by their staff members.
Managers appear to lack the managerial and leadership skills to be able to utilise the
knowledge other than clinical knowledge. A lack of trust exists between staff and
management, leaving staff reluctant to utilise their knowledge. Staff were concerned
about the effect the utilisation of their non-clinical knowledge would have on their
clinical workload and the ultimate effect on their patients. Concerns were also raised
by both staff and management about the administrative processes required to utilise
knowledge. Any system introduced would need to ensure that clinical areas were not
adversely affected
Knowledge management involves the recognition and the utilisation of
knowledge to benefit both the organisation and the individual. The use of intellectual
organisation and individuals. This research has found that a vast reserve of
knowledge is held within NWH, this knowledge is not being managed or utilised to assist either the organisation or individual employees. Further research is necessary to ascertain the benefits North Western Health could gain from managing the knowledge within the organisation effectively and also to determine the most appropriate