Chapter. 5 Testing the model through case studies
2. Managed Some LCC and risk analysis are developed but they are at initial
6.2 Future researches
Future works may regard possible improvements of the maturity model. In particular, the maturity assessment proposed in this thesis does not cover the issues and the needs of organizational contexts where more divisions/more plants operate in order to achieve a unique business strategy. Hence, to extend the use of the maturity model, we suggest to add another part about internal coordination in which questions may refer to how the different plants or national/regional divisions interact each other (i.e.
sharing of information and resources) and to how policies and goals are defined (i.e.
definition of targets, budget allocation between different parts of the organization).
Another cue for the study may be to extend the external coordination part. In fact, we must not forget that PAM strategy is strictly related to the business strategy: all the operations and maintenance activities are managed to reach the vision of the company and PAM becomes a key factor to achieve business success. In this perspective, more questions about the stakeholders management, such as how stakeholders influence company’s actions, how the company tries to understand their requirements, etc…, are important to fully capture the meaning of PAM and to extend the assessment from the tactical to the strategic level of the organization.
The last recommendation regards the use of the maturity model. As said in section 6.1, the main outcome of the research is the model itself that, thanks to the use of standardized and well recognized terms, can be applied both in manufacturing plants and infrastructures. In fact, the experience gained during the case studies has not shown the existence of sectorial barriers in understanding of the specific terms of PAM, even in case of low maturity levels. For this reason we want to encourage the research along the different sectors with a dual purpose:
• extend the library of PAM practices;
• Identify the boundary conditions that affect (positively or negatively) the implementation and the optimization of PAM practices.
Maturity assessment for Physical Asset Management: Evidence from Manufacturing Plants and Infrastructures
References
AIRMC, ALARM, IRM. "A risk management standard." 2002.
Amadi-Echendu J. E. "Curriculum Development and Delivecy in Physical Asset Management." 4' Global Congress on Engineering Education. Bangkok, Thailand, 2004.
Amadi-Echendu J. E. "Managing Physical Assets is a Paradigm Shift from Maintenance." IEEE Transactions on Engineering Management (Department of Engineering and Technology Management, University of Pretoria, South Africa), 2004.
Armenakis Achelles A. and Stanley Harris G. "Crafting a change message to create transformational readiness." Journal of Organizational Change Management, 2002:
Vol.15 N.2; pp.169-183.
Baglee David, Knowles Michael, and Yau Chi-Yung. "Development of Techniques to Manage Asset." In Asset Management. The state of Art in Europe from Life Cycle Perspective, by Paulien Herder, Ype Wijnia and Telli van der Lei, pp.143-154.
Springer, 2012.
Barringer P.E. "Life cycle cost and reliability process equipmnet." 8th Annual Energy week conference and Exhibition. Houston, Texas, 1997.
Barringer P.E. "A Life Cycle Cost Summary." International Conference of Maintenance Societies. Humble, Texas: Barringer & Associates, Inc., 2003.
Blanchard and Fabrycky. Systems Engineering and Analysis. Upper Saddle River, NJ, Prentice - Hall, 1998.
Bohn R.E. "Measuring and managing technological knowledge." Sloan Management Review, 1994: Vol.36 No.1, pp.61-73.
Maturity assessment for Physical Asset Management: Evidence from Manufacturing Plants and Infrastructures
Brent Alan C. and Schuman Charles A. "Asset life cycle management: towards improving physical asset performance in the process industry." International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 2005: Vol. 25 Iss: 6, pp.566 - 579.
Brenta A.C. and Visser J.K. "An environmental performance resource impact indicator for life cycle management in the manufacturing industry." Journal of Cleaner Production, 2005: 13, pp.557 - 565.
Brown E. and Humphrey G. "Asset Management for transmission and distribution."
IEEE, 2005.
Brundtland. Brundtland Report. World Commission on Environment and Developement, ONU, 1987.
Brunetto Y. and Xerri M. "Examining employee attitudes toward change, organisational culture and their relationship with infrastructure and engineering asset management performance." 2012.
Càceres. "Como incrementar la ocmpetitividad del negocio mediante estrategias para gerenciar el mantenimento." VI Congreso Panamericano de ingneria de manteniemento . Mexico: D.F, 2004.
COSO. Patent Enterprise risk maangement - integrated approach: executive summary. 2004.
Crespo Márquez A., Moreu de León P., Gómez Fernández J.F., Parra Márquez C., López Campos M. "The maintenance management framework: A practical view to maintenance management." Journal of Quality in Maintenance Engineering, 2009.
Criscimagna, Ned. 2002.
http://www.theriac.org/DeskReference/viewDocument.php?id= 121.
Culture, Wikipedia. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture.
Dawson. "Knowledge capabilities as the focus of organisational development and strategy." Journal of Knowledge Management, 2000: 4, pp.320-327.
Deeb C, Demand Media. Top-Down Approach to Policy Decisions. 2012.
http://smallbusiness.chron.com/topdown-approach-policy-decisions-35494.htm.
DJSI. 2005. www.sustainability-index.com.
Maturity assessment for Physical Asset Management: Evidence from Manufacturing Plants and Infrastructures
Dunn R. "Advanced maintenance technologies." Plant Engineering, 1987: Vol. 40, pp.
80-2.
Fumagalli L, Di Leone F, Jantunen E, Macchi M. "Economic Value of Technologies in an e- Maintenance Platform." Preprints of 1° IFAC Workshop, A-MEST'10. Lisboa, Portugal: Advanced Maintenance Engineering, Services and Technology, 1-2 July 2010.
Galar D, Parida A, Kumar U, Stenström C, Berges L. "Maintenance metrics: A hierarchical model of balanced scorecard." IEEE, 2011.
Grencik J and Legat V. "Maintenance audit and benchmarking - search for evaluation criteria on global scale." Warszawa: PNTTE, 2007. Nr 3 (35), pp.34-39.
Haider Abrar. "Fallacies of Technological Determinism – Lessons for Asset." 2008.
Hastings Nicholas A. J. Physical Asset Management. Springer-Verlag London Limited, 2010.
Healy Dr.J A. "Criticality in asset management." JAHCon Physical Asset Management Pty. Ltd., WCEAM 2006, 2006: Paper 145 Page 1-15.
Herder P.M and Wijnia Y.C. "The state of asset management in the Netherlands."
Delft University of Technology, Faculty of Technology, Policy and Management,, 2009.
Herder Paulien and Wijnia Ype. "A systems view on Infrastrucuture asset management." In Asset Management. The state of art in Europe from a life cycle perspective, by Pauliene Herder, Ype WIJNIA Telli Van der Lei, pp.31 - 46. Springer, 2012.
Hofstede G. Culture’s consequences. Newbury Park, CA: Sage, 1984.
Hofstede G. "A case for comparing apples with orange." International Journal of Comparative Sociology, 1998: 39 (1), pp.16-31.
Ilie L and Gavrea C. "The link between organizational culture and corporate performane - An overview." Annals of Faculty of Economics, 2008: 4 (1), pp.322 - 329.
ISO. Patent ISO 3100: Risk Management - principles and guidelines. 2009.