CHAPTER 5 : SUMMARY AND FUTURE WORK
5.2 FUTURE WORK
The CHS concept is relatively new, so the research initiated here leads to the following sequence of work:
• Characterization and measurement on 3D Novel Routing and Advanced Planar Routing to correlate with simulation results.
Experiments on 3D Novel routing and advanced planar structures in future research is
required to correlate with simulation result. In addition, the CHS concept will offer a new
area for comparing traditional and modern (retarded) crosstalk. The parameters that should
be considered in the 3D Novel routing and Novel Coplanar measurement:
Dielectric height variation.
Trace spacing for edge side and broad side variation.
Trace width variation.
Dielectric permittivity variation at different layers.
166
The main challenge for characterizing the 3D novel model is to design the
measurement probe point for extracting accurate S-parameters. The design should include
SMA connectors with different via transitions for each layer. However, the via placement
will extend the length mismatch between conductors and it will be difficult to de-embed
these effects in order to get accurate S-parameter for 3D novel routing. In addition, new
measurement methodology needs to be explored to get accurate result. Another alternative
measurement method is to probe a cross-section of the 3D novel routing board because no
vias would be required. Similar to the innovative technology introduced by 3D CHS novel routing, this measurement methodology will be needed to continue this research work.
Measurement on advanced coplanar with reference plane elimination could also be a
project for future research. In addition, future research could be focused on designing new
parameter variations for edge routing.
The CHS concept initiated here has been shown to be capable of shrinking the cable
and connector size by reducing not only the trace and spacing between signals but the
signal-to-ground ratio as well. So CHS cables and connectors promise to reduce the overall
system dimension and cost. In future research, CHS connectors can be further refined by
correlating the simulation results with fabricated measurement to achieve a proof-of-
concept. Then a ROTI analysis of the measurement results can be performed to determine
the final projected cost of the system.
The CHS concept for microstrip edge routing has been proven by simulation results,
but still needs to be proven by measurement results. However, there is no encoder and
decoder test chip yet developed to correlate the simulation results with any validation
167
level on a transmitter and receiver [1], so this could also be a subject for future research
together with improving the encoder and decoder design for power reduction and cost.
Likewise, limitations on CHS at the circuit level could be explored. Besides that, a ROTI
analysis comparison on the cost between CHS, differential and traditional binary signaling
could be undertaken.
At higher data rates, CHS is limited by loss rather than crosstalk. Therefore, in future
research the CHS static matrix can be modified to include loss information and remove the
effect at the decoder. Besides that, the combination of CHS and equalizer (e.g: CTLE,
DFE) would be worthwhile subject to explore. Thus a combination of all this future
research work will make it possible to achieve the goal of enabling single-ended signaling
168
REFERENCES
1. Chaitanya Sreerama, “Ultra High Bandwidth and Power Configurable Signaling”,
Electrical Engineering Dissertation, University of South Carolina, 2014.
2. C.R.Paul, “Decoupling the multiconductor transmission line equations", Microwave
Theory and Techniques IEEE Transactions on Aug 1996,Vol. 44. Page(s):1429-1440.
3. Paul G. Huray, “The Foundations of Signal Integrity”, Wiley-IEEE Press; 1edition,
2009.
4. Paul G. Huray, “Maxwell's Equations”, Wiley-IEEE Press; 1 edition, 2009.
5. C.R.Paul, “Analysis of multiconductor transmission lines”, 2nd edition, Wiley-
Interscience, New York, NY, 2007.
6. Chaitanya Sreerama, Stephen H.Hall, Paul G. Huray, Antonio Zenteno Ramirez, Mike
Leddige, Feme Oluwafemi, Azniza Abd Aziz and Jeff Wight, “A Crosstalk Friendly
Signaling Method”, in full consideration for publication in Transactions on Microwave
Theory and Techniques.
7. Stephen H. , Howard L. Heck, “Advanced Signal Integrity for High-Speed Digital
Designs”, Wiley-IEEE Press; 1 edition, 2009.
8. Stephen H. Hall, Garrett W. Hall, James A. McCall, “High-Speed Digital System
Design: A Handbook of Interconnect Theory and Design Practices”, Wiley-IEEE
169
9. Peng Ye, “The Retarded Solutions of Fields”, Electrical Engineering Dissertation,
University of South Carolina, 2015
10.David M. Pozar, “Microwave Engineering”, John Wiley &Sons,Inc; 4 edition ,2012.
11.Stephen C. Thierauf, ”Understanding Signal Integrity”, Artech House, 1 edition, 2011.
12.Hanqiao Zhang, Steven Krooswyk,Jeff Ou “High Speed Digital Design: Design of
High Speed Interconnects and Signaling”,Morgan Kaufmann, 2015
13.Hamid Kiumarsi, Hiroyuki Ito, Kenichi Okada, Yusuke Uemichi, Yasuto Chiba,
Noboru Ishihara, Kazuya Masu “A 60Ghz 3-dB tandem coupler using offset broadside-
coupled line on a silicon substrate”, IEICE Electronic Express January 2013, Vol.10,
No.2, 1-12.
14.Jason, Lawley, “Understanding Performance of PCI Express System”, White Paper
WP350(V1.2) October 28,2014.
15.Broyde F., Clavelier E., “A new method for the reduction of crosstalk and echo in
multiconductor interconnections”, Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers, IEEE
Transactions on Feb. 2005, Vol. 52. Page(s): 405-416
16.P. Milosevic, J. Schutt-Ain_e, and W. Beyene, ”Crosstalk mitigation of high-speed
interconnects with discontinuities using modal signaling", Conference on Electrical
Performance of Electronic Packaging and Systems (EPEPS) 2010. Page(s): 21-24.
17.Milosevic P., Schutt-Ain .E., Beyene W.T., “Crosstalk mitigation of high-speed
interconnects with discontinuities using modal signaling”, IEEE Electrical
170
18.Pavle Milosevic, José E. Schutt-Ainé, Naresh R. Shanbhag, “DSP-based Multimode
Signaling for FEXT Reduction in Multi-Gbps Links”, Electrical Performance of
Electronic Packaging and Systems, 2009. Page(s): 45- 48.
19.Yongjin Choi, Braunisch H., Aygun K., Franzon P.D., “Analysis of inter-bundle
crosstalk in multimode signaling for high-density interconnects”, Electronic
Components and Technology Conference, 2008. Page(s): 664-668.
20.Yongjin Choi, Chanyoun Won, Franzon P.D., Braunisch H., Aygun K., “Multimode
signaling on non-ideal channels”, IEEE Electrical Performance of Electronic
Packaging, 2008. Page(s): 51-54.
21.Pavle Milosevic, “Crosstalk Mitigation of High-Speed Interconnects using Modal
signaling”, Electrical Engineering Dissertation, University of Illinois at Urbana-
Champaign, 2011.
22.Constantine A. Balanis, “Advanced Engineering Electromagnetics”, Wiley,Second
edition, 2012.
23.Howard Johnson, Martin Graham, “High-Speed Signal Propagation, Advanced Black
Magic”, Prentice Hall, 2003.
24.Eric Bogatin, “Signal and Power Integrity Simplified”, Prentice Hall, Second edition,
2010.
25.Kenneth D. Marx, “Propagation Modes, Equivalent Circuits and Characteristic
Terminations for Multiconductor Tranmission Lines with Inhomegenous Dielectrics”,
IEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques on July 1973, Volume: 21,
171
26.José A. Branda�o Faria, “A New Generalized Modal Analysis Theory for Nonuniform Multiconductor Transmission Lines”, IEEE Transaction on Power System on May
2004, Volume:19, Issue: 2. Page(s) 926-933.
27.Ross A. Speciale, “Even and Odd-Mode Waves for Nonsymmetrical Coupled Lines in
Nonhomogeneous Media”, IEEE transaction on Microwave Theory and Techniques on