Overlay Analysis and Assessment
3.1.2 GIS and Optimization Modelling in this Study
The GIS and Optimization modelling system intended for this research theoretically and fundamentally is divided into four main key constituents or subsystems (Figure 3.2). The different factors are:
3.1.2.1 Geo-Database Management System: which stores the required data in the
necessary format for management and manipulation of data.
3.1.2.2 Land Suitability Analysis and Assessment Component: Land suitability is an
important link form between land use resources appraisal and evaluation of the decision procedure in land-use management and planning. This element plays an important role in land-use management and planning. Land evaluation and suitability assessment for each specified use is the key work of this element.
3.1.2.3 Scenarios Development and analysis (SDA): Scenarios are generated and
implemented based on future climate change and a range of possible policies.
3.1.2.4 Development of the linear modelling (LM) approach and calculation of Carbon
under different scenarios: This will be used to find the optimal spatial distributions of land-use based on the results of scenarios and data analysis.
The role of this system is to provide a flexible mechanism for communicating between data, models, and knowledge rules in the quantification of carbon and other GHG, energy storage and emissions respectively under possible future land use change. In this study some assumptions are made such as no change in the amount of soil carbon over time; land evaluation process takes into account to control on distribution of land cover. Also, it has been assumed that all agricultural and forestry lands are fulfilled in accordance to the principles of the best management practise and carbon saving intention, presuming suitable and adequate use of inputs, policies and methods.
70
Figure 3.2: Conceptual Framework of Methodology Employed in the Research.
Footprint:
= Process, = Input Data, = Model Outputs
Farm Income
Optimization Results
- Objective Functions
- Land Use Allocations
- Output for Scenarios
Analysis Result Presentation
-Tables and Reports -Figures and Maps
Current Carbon Density in TV Land Evaluation and Land
Suitability Analysis Geo-DatabaseManagement
System
Scenario Development and Analysis Resource Base, Current Land Uses, Problems and Policy issues
Definition of Activities and Inputs
Land uses Constrain: Land Allocation Definition of Objective Functions
Linear Programming Model
Policy Issue Land Cover Soil Carbon Biomass Emissions DEM
71
3.1.2.1 Geo-Database Management System
In land-use management spatial and non-spatial data with different formats and structures are needed. In order to develop the methodological system, there is a need to use a geo-database management system to create the potentialities that are the objectives of this research. The first important capacity, in relation to this requirement, is the integrated abilities and potentials of the system, which means that the different models and modules should combine and work together in an appropriate way and transfer data to each other. The synergistic relationship of the policies and economics in different parts of the system also is another key capacity. The geo-database management system can provide an appropriate and proper data model for managing different data types needed for land-use management and planning, as stated above, and allows the ability and potential for fundamental interaction with different sub systems and models.
The processes of developing the geo-database management system in this research are explained as follows:
a) Identifying and categorizing of data which are required in the land-use scenario generation procedure, as part of the set-up and construction of the system.
b) Evaluating and assessing the purposes of the system which has fundamental
interactions with databases in order to evaluate the system for data storage and management.
a) Evaluating and assessing the existing software for an expanded geo-database management system and selecting the one which meets the assessed needs.
b) Designing, aiming and implementing the data model and organisation of the geo- database management system.
c) Generating datasets (Table 3.1) required for the analysis, including details of the types of data available to the geo-database.
72
Table 3.1: Required datasets for the geo-database in this site study (Met-office, British
Geological Survey, 1985, LCM 2000, Soils and their use in Southwest England., 1984, Soils in the British Isles, 1990).
Data Type Geometry Resolution Source
Land cover /Land use Raster 25m LCM2000
Soils Vector 1:25,000 Soil survey of England and
Wales
Elevation Raster 1:25,000 Digital elevation model
(DEM)
Aspect Raster 1:25,000 Digital elevation model
(DEM)
Slope Vector 1:25,000 Digital elevation model
(DEM)
Soil Depth Vector 1:25,000 Soil survey of England and
Wales
Soil Bulk Density Vector 1:25,000 Soil survey of England and Wales
Soil Organic matter Vector 1:25,000 Soil survey of England and Wales
3.1.2.2 Land Suitability Analysis and Assessment Component (LSA)
This phase of the project will identify criteria and constraints for each specified land-use type and develop spatial models to assess suitability and appropriateness of the study area for different land cover types. These models will be developed and expanded based on Multi-Criteria Analysis/ Evaluation (MCA/E) and the FAO’s land elevation (Food and Agricultural Organization) technique and classification, which involves finding out the factors, constraints, limitations and alternatives for each land use. There are two key stages in developing the LSA model:
a) Identification of the environmental, policy and socio-economical factors, which explain current land cover and land use in the study area.
b) Implementing and using the MCA/E suitability models, such as Linear Combination (LC), to produce and generate a final suitability value for each land area type.
73
3.1.2.3 Scenario Development and Analysis (SDA)
The three main key conceptions of this stage are scenario building, land-use future studies and forecasting of the land-use changes, including future hindrances and uncertainties.
This stage was initiated through a literature review on scenario typologies, evaluation, analysis, the methods of scenarios to handle uncertainty and existing work on land cover change scenarios (Refer to chapter 2). The results of this stage are to identify what types of scenarios can be created for land-use management and how these are applied and to choose the most suitable and appropriate methodological approach. Also to evolve a methodology and implement this for scenario generation, development and scenarios for land cover changes in the Tamar Valley catchment.
The second action is to recognise and define the driving powers for future land cover change and spot the critical policy objectives, ideas and consider the landscape-scale storage and emissions of GHG and energy under the range of different scenarios for different periods in the 21st century for the Tamar Valley catchment area. This methodology will be based on computer implementation to make possible the relation and fundamental interaction of policies and climate change in scenario generation and analysis (refer to Chapter 5).
3.1.2.3 Development of the LM (Linear Modeling) approach and calculation of
Carbon under different scenarios
In this section of the methodology approach, the key components are defined as: definition of activities, land assessment and evaluation, and finding of inputs of the activities (refer to Figure 3.2 in this Chapter). The land use activities have been defined on the basis of environmental and available economic-socio information, taking into consideration the current land use situation and crisis recognised.
The linear programming (LP) model (addressed in Chapter 5) employs the linear purposes to connect the land use activities, constraints and objective functions. A complex and adaptable process is used that permits the model to find out the carbon value, GHG and energy emissions, and farm business income. The constraints and limitations of the model are split into land use (resource) constraints. These constraints include the available land allocation. The objective functions are categorised based on land and GHG National Inventory policies
74
and problems defined that could be maximized and minimized in this research. Each of the objective functions is activated as a limit and constraint or non-connecting objective when has not optimized. The scenarios are adjusted and generated by different objective functions with different concern places (see Chapter 5). The objective functions are calculated independently (separately) with the model, and the scenarios in a repetitive process. Firstly, each of the picked objective functions is optimized independently with enforcing constraints under the range of different scenarios, and is then assessed. With considering this optimization model, in relation with the farm income, the results have been produced (Chapter 5 and 6). In the end, the total outputs are presented in different tables, maps, and figures.