TOWARDS PROGRESSIVE MATHEMATISATION PHASE 1: Preliminary design of an instructional sequence
3.5.2 Number pattern competencies for mathematising
In Section 3.5.1 number pattern competencies have been mapped (Table 3.1) so that mathematising competencies for number patterns can be developed. Table 3.2 separates horizontal and vertical mathematising competencies and focuses each competency on one or more sub-competency. Ellis’ taxonomy (2007a, 2007b) uses various activities to characterise a learner’s generalisation activities into specific levels. Using these levels and explanations, competencies can now be identified by looking at a learner’s external representations, i.e. what the learner does, says, makes and writes. These activities serve as indicators to acknowledge whether horizontal and vertical competencies are utilised when working through a number pattern modelling problem.
Internalising is the horizontal mathematising competency when a learner explores the real
problems so that he understands the problem and is able to simplify the problem. The
competency internalising can be identified when a learner rephrases the problem into his own language, when he explains or notes important information. According to the generalisation taxonomy (Ellis, 2007a, 2007b) a learner relates back to previous problems when attempting to make sense of a current problem. During the competency interpreting, the learner recognises quantities that influence the situation and make assumptions to note conditions that will work or not work for a problem. When a learner is interpreting he recognises quantities that influence the situation. In Ellis’ taxonomy relating objects can be compared with interpreting while searching can be compared with the competency structuring. Structuring involves setting up a real model based on relationships and patterns. The external representations of a learner when he is
64
Table 3.2: Number pattern competencies for mathematising
Competencies Sub-competencies What the learner does, says, makes or writes
Horizontal Internalising Understanding the problem
Distinguishing between relevant and irrelevant information
Simplifying the situation
Learner states the problem in language he understands
Learner notes/explains important information
Learner notes/explains/relates a previous problem that is similar to the current one
Interpreting Making assumptions
Identifying conditions
Identifying constraints
Recognising quantities that influence situation
Learner makes assumptions
Learner notes conditions that will work/not work for a problem
Learner recognises quantities that influence the situation
Structuring Setting up a real model
Naming quantities
Identifying key variables
Recognise patterns
Recognise relationships
Learner looks for a pattern/relationship
Learner notes a recurring value or situation in the problem
Learner recognises a pattern/relationship
Learner states the relationship or pattern
Symbolising Choosing appropriate mathematical symbols
Using symbols
Setting up a mathematical model
Switching between symbolisations
Learner draws pictures to represent the problem
Learner draws pictures to show the relationship/pattern
Learner uses objects to build the pattern
Vertical Learner uses symbols to represent his pictures/patterns
Learner forms a pattern using symbols
Learner extends his pattern
Learner formulates a rule using symbols
Learner creates a model of Adjusting Rephrasing the problem
Refining
Using and switching between operations
Learner adapts his pattern so that it makes sense for the situation
Learner tests his pattern
Learner refines his pattern after testing it
Learners reflects back to the pattern/symbols
Learner reflects back to the real problem
Learner creates a model for Organising Viewing problem in a different form
Use mathematical knowledge to solve problem
Using heuristics
Combining
Integrating
Learner constructs a rule that works for all elements
Learner reflects back to the real problem
Learner uses the rule to solve a problem
Learner validates his solution
Learner creates a model for Generalising Establishing similar relationships in different
problems
Independent reasoning and acting
Learner uses deductive reasoning to prove his rule
Learner uses/adapts the rule for another situation
The competency symbolising can be a horizontal or a vertical competency. Activities that identify horizontal competencies can be: the learner draws pictures to represent the problem, he shows the relationship or pattern in the problem, he uses objects to build the pattern. Vertical mathematising can be identified when learners use symbols to represent the problem. When a learner is adjusting, the emphasis is on refining the symbolisations. Adjusting can be noted when a learner refines his symbolisations. Ellis’ taxonomy (2007a, 2007b) summarises the
identification or statement to be focused around a continuing phenomenon, a statement of commonality or similarity or a general principle. This means the act of finding a pattern or rule that symbolises a common element. The competency organising is identifiable when a learner constructs a rule that works for all elements. Generalising involves independent reasoning and acting and a learner can now use or adapt the rule for another situation.
The third goal in the phenomenological analysis was to develop mathematising competencies specifically for number patterns. The number pattern competency continuum will be used in Chapter 5 as a tool to identify competencies during the teaching experiment.
3.6 GOAL 4: ESTABLISHING THE LEARNERS’ PRE-KNOWLEDGE
The starting point of the HLT is dependent on the learners’ prior knowledge. A baseline assessment is an effective tool to establish a learner’s mathematical skills and knowledge. The baseline assessment provides a teacher the opportunity to effectively plan the learning process. Kyriakides (2002) notes that the baseline assessment is used to identify what the learner can and cannot do so that differentiated learning needs can be targeted. The baseline assessment also serves as a basis for measuring future progress. The baseline assessment will provide important information about groups and individuals in the mathematics classroom and how the groups in a class can be structured. It will focus the HLT.