• No results found

The Present Day Situation in Boera and Amongst the

CHANGES IN POTTERY MANUFACTURE

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS

5.8. The Present Day Situation in Boera and Amongst the

Western Motu

Today the people of Boera have become more dependent on paid employment, with most of the young people working in Port Moresby

or other cities. Education and other factors that have been described in Chapter IV have changed their life-style and the young generation do not follow their parents' traditions. Not only pottery making, but the skill of fishing and canoe manufacturing, for which Boera and other Western Motu villages were once well known, have also declined.

May and Tuckson (1982: 64) mention that in the 1970s the quality of Motu pots deteriorated. They suggest that they were made by non-potters who tried to make money by selling to tourists.

However, there were also good quality water and cooking pots ready for sale. I have not heard that other people besides traditional

potters were trying to make pots in Boera. Probably what May and Tuckson observed was the normal range of pottery quality made by both unskilled and skilled potters, (e.g. Finsch, 1903: 333). The reduced frequency of potting in recent times may also have diminished pot quality.

Most of the potters at Boera expect pottery production to continue. Some of them, like the potters who worked with us, were

happy that they do not have to do it regularly anymore, complaining that it is heavy and dirty work. This statement could be regarded as an expression of pottery as a historically undesirable occupation, in my opinion this attitude is a result of rapid modernization which has relegated potting to an irrelevant occupation amongst modern villagers in Papua New Guinea.

The continuation of the whole pottery tradition is no longer possible since the institution that supported it, the hiri, has already collapsed. However, it might be continued if a new system and motivation were available, such as providing pottery as an extra-curriculum activity at school or even in a special school or course, together with the establishment of a market that can guarantee distribution.

During the last few days of my field work the potters who worked with us had decided to continue potting more regularly and formed themselves into a group called Dadarai (ignorance) with Seneka Moi as the coordinator. By doing this they hoped that the younger women, especially their daughters, would be interested and start to learn. Since Seneka Moi himself is a craftman who makes small lagatoi models for tourists, he already has a market for his craft and contacts with organizations which could be expected to distribute the pottery. Before we left Boera, they had already started to make more pots on order from Port Moresby.

In Boera there seems a possibility for the continuation of pottery making, although perhaps in limited quantity. However, recruitment of younger potters is desperately needed, since the older ones soon will not be able to continue because of their age.

The Dadarai group reflect a different organization of pottery making from the traditional one. Traditionally the potters said they were never told by the men what they should do. Although the men

used to be the middlemen for the potters' trade to the Gulf, they never interfered with the decisions about the types and numbers of pots to be made. Today Seneka Moi is the one who negotiates with purchasers about the type, the number of pots, and the timing, before he asks the potters to work. However, the price of the pots is determined by the potters themselves.

potting activity. Seneka Moi's father also organized pottery

manufacture for the European markets in the 1960s and 1970s. Men are more exposed to foreigners than women and it is therefore

understandable that a man should become the intermediary for the potters in dealing with purchasers. However, one more enterprising woman, Asi Hisiu, is making pottery by herself without any male interference and she is able to sell her pots successfully.

Despite the decline of the pottery industry and the new life-style of the potters it can be said that pottery making in Boera is not considered a marginal occupation that confines the potters to a low stratum of society. The potters themselves are proud of their work and they are also open to new influences and willing and able to experiment.

Bibliography

Allen, J. 1972. "Nebira 4: an early Austronesian site in Central Papua". Archaeology and Physical Anthropology in Oceania 7(2) :92-124. ___________ 1976. "Fishing for wallabies: trade as a mechanism for social

interaction, integration and elaboration on the Central Papuan coast". In Friedman, J. and Rowlands, M.J. (eds), The evolution of social systems, pp. 419-54. London: Duckworth.

___________ 1977a. "Management of resources in prehistoric coastal Papua". In Winslow, J. H. (ed.), The Melanesian Environment, pp. 35-44. Canberra: Australian National University Press.

___________ 1977b. "Sea traffic, trade and expanding horizons". In Allen, J., Golson, J., and Jones. R. (eds.), Sunda and Sahul: prehistoric studies in Southeast A s ia , Melanesia and Australia, pp. 387-417. London: Academic Press.

__________1978. "The physical and cultural setting of Motupore Island, Central Province, Papua New Guinea". Bulletin of the Indo-Pacific Prehistory Association 1:47-55.

___________ 1982. "Pre-contact trade in Papua New Guinea". In May, R. J. and Nelson, H. (eds.), Melanesia: beyond diversity vol. 1, pp. 193-205. Canberra: Australian National University.

___________ 1984. "Pots and poor princess: a multidimensional approach to the role of pottery trading in Coastal Papua". In van der Leeuw, S. E. and Pritchard, A. C .f The many dimensions of pottery: ceramic in

archaeology and anthropology, pp. 407-63. Amsterdam: Universiteit van Amsterdam.

___________ and Rye, 0 . 1982. "The importance of being earnest in

archaeological investigation of prehistoric trade in Papua". In Dutton, T. (ed.) 1982:99-115.

Arnold, D. E. 1988. Ceramic theory and cultural process. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Balfet, H. 1966. "Ethnographical observations in North Africa and

archaeological interpretation: the pottery of the Maghreb". In Matson, F. R., Ceramic and man , pp. 161-77. London: Methuen & Co.

Barton, F. R. 1910. "The annual trading expedition to the Papuan Gulf". In Seligman, C. G. 1910: 96-120.

___________ 1918. "Tattooing in South Eastern New Guinea". Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 48:22-79. Beishaw, C. S. 1957. The great village: the economic and social welfare of

Hanuabada, an urban community in P ap u a. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul.

Bulmer, S. 1971. "Prehistoric settlement patterns and pottery in the Port

Moresby area". Journal of the Papua and New Guinea Society 5(2):29-91. ___________ 1978. Prehistoric culture change in the Port Moresby region.

Unpublished PhD. thesis, University of Papua New Guinea. ___________ 1979. "Prehistoric ecology and economy in the Port Moresby

region". New Zealand Journal of Archaeology 1:5-27.

___________ 1982. "West of Bootless Inlet: archaeological evidence for prehistoric trade in the Port Moresby area and the origin of the hiri". In Dutton, T. 1982:117-130.

Chalmers, J. 1887. "History and description of pottery trade: a Papuan enoch arden". in Lindt, J. W .f Picturesque New Guinea , pp. 118-25. London:

Longmans Green.

___________ 1895. Life and work in New Guinea 1877-1894 . London: The Religious Tract Society.

Chatterton, P. 1968. "The story of a migration". Journal of the Papua and New Guinea Society 2(2):92-6.

___________ 1970. "Interlude between two worlds: Hanuabada in the 1930's". Journal of the Papua and New Guinea Society 4(1 ):73-80.

Dutton, T. (ed.). 1982. The hiri in history: further aspects of long distance Motu trade in Central Papua. Pacific Research Monograph number eight. Canberra: Australian National University.

___________ 1982. "Towards a history of the hiri: some beginning linguistic observation". In Dutton, T. (ed) 1982:65-98.

Fankhauser, B. 1989. Fieldwork proposal. Unpublished.

Finsch, 0 . 1903. "Papua-topferei: aus dem wiegenalter der keramik". Globus 84(21 ):329-334.

___________ 1914. "Sudseearbeiten: gewerbe - und kunstfleiB, tauschmittel und 'geld' der eingeborenen". Abhandlungen des Hamburgischen

Kolonialinstituts 14.

Foster, G. M. 1966. "The sociology of pottery: questions and hypotheses arising from contemporary Mexican work". In Matson, F. R. (ed.), Ceramic and

m a n , pp. 43-61. London: Methuen & Co.

Frankel, D. and Vanderwal, R. 1984. "A note on prehistoric research in the Gulf Province, Papua New Guinea". The Artefact 9(1-4):19-22.

Groves, M. 1954. "Dancing in Poreporena". Journal of Royal Anthropological Institute 84:75-90.

___________ 1960. "Motu pottery". The Journal of the Polynesian Society 69:3-22. ___________ 1963. "Western Motu descent groups". Ethnology 2(1 ):15-30.

___________ 1972a. "Hiri". in Ryan, P. (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Papua New Guinea vol. 1:523-7. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.

___________ 1972b. "Motu". in Ryan, P. (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Papua New Guinea vol. 2:802-5. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.

___________ et al. 1957. "Blood groups of the Motu and Koita peoples". Oceania 28:222-38.

Gwilliam, J. W. 1982. "Some religious aspects of the hiri". In Dutton, T. (ed.) 1982:35-63.

Haddon, A. C. 1900. "Studies in the anthropogeography of British New Guinea". The Geographical Journal 16(3):265-91 and 414-41.

___________ 1901. Head-hunters, black, white and brown. London: Methuen & Co.

Irwin, G. J. 1974. "The emergence of a central place in coastal Papuan prehistory: a theoretical approach". Mankind 9:268-72.

___________ 1977. The emergence of Mailu as a central place in the prehistory of coastal Papua. Unpublished PhD. thesis, Australian National

University. _

___________ 1978a. "The development of Mailu as a specialized Trading and manufacturing centre in Papuan prehistory: the causes and the implications". Mankind 11:406-15.

___________ 1978b. "Pots and entrepots: a study of settlement, trade and development of economic specialization in Papuan prehistory". World Archaeology 9(3):299-319.

Key, C. A. 1973. "Pottery manufacturing techniques in Papua-New Guinea". Asian Perspectives 14:65-8.

Lauer, P.K. 1970. "Amphlett Islands' pottery trade and the Kula.H Mankind 7(3) :165-76.

___________ 1971. "Changing pattern of pottery trade to the Trobriand Islands." World Archaeology 3:197-209.

___________ 1973. "The technology of pottery manufacture on Goodenough Island and in the Amphlett group, South-east Papua." Occasional Papers in Anthropology 2:25-59. University of Queensland.

___________ 1974. "Pottery tradition in the D’Entrecasteaux Island of Papua. Occasional Papers in Anthropology 3. University of Queensland.

Lawes, W. G. 1878. "Ethnological notes on the Motu, Koitapu, and Koiari tribes of New Guinea". Journal of the Royal Anthropologial Institute 8:369-376. Lewis, A.B. 1951. The Melanesians: people of the South Pacific. Chicago:

Chicago Natural History Museum.

Macintyre, M. 1982. "Pottery Manufacture on Tubetube". Canberra Anthropology 5(2) :34-57.

May, P. and Tuckson, M. 1982. The traditional pottery of Papua New Guinea. Sidney: Bay Book.

Moi, K. K. 1979. "The first hiri trade expedition from the central province". Oral History 7(6):41-81.

Murray, J. H. P. 1912. Papua or British New Guinea. London: T. Fisher Unwin. Nicklin, K. 1971. "Stability and innovation in pottery manufacture". World

Archaeology 3:13-48 and 94-8.

___________ 1979. "The location of pottery manufacture". Man 14:436-58. Oram, N. D. 1968a. "Culture change, economic development and migration

among the Hula". Oceania 38(4):243-75.

___________ 1968b. "Taurama - oral sources for a study of recent Motuan prehistory". Journal of the Papua and New Guinea Society 2(2):79-91. ___________ 1977. "Environment, migration and site selection in the Port

Moresby coastal area". In the Winslow, J. H. (ed.), Melanesian environment, pp. 74-99. Canberra: Australian National University Press.

___________ 1982. "Pots for sago: the hiri trading network", in Dutton, T. (ed.) 1982:1-33.

Pawley, A. 1975. "The relationships of the Austronesian Languages of Central Papua: a preliminary study. In Dutton, T. (ed.), Studies in languages of Central and South-East P ap u a, pp. 3-105. Canberra: Australian National University.

Rhoads, J. W. 1980. Through a glass darkly: present and past land use systems among Papuan sagopalm users. Unpublished PhD. thesis, Australian National University.

___________ 1982. "Prehistoric Papuan exchange systems: the hiri and its antecedents". In Dutton, T. (ed.) 1982:131-51.

Romilly, H. H. 1893. Letters from the Western Pacific and Mashonaland 1878-1891. London: David Nutt.

Rosenstiel, A. 1953. The Motu of Papua-New Guinea: a study of successful Acculturation. PhD. thesis, Columbia University.

Ryan, D. 1970. Rural and urban villagers: a bi-local social system in Papua. PhD. thesis, University of Hawaii.

Rye, O. S. 1976. "Keeping your temper under control: material and the manufacture of Papuan pottery". Archaeology and Physical Anthropology in Oceania 11 (2):106-37.

Cambridge University Press.

Stone, O. C. 1876. "Description of the country and native of Port Moresby and neighbourhood, New Guinea". Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 46:34-62.

___________ 1880. A few months in New Guinea . London: Sampson Low, Marston, Searl and Rivington.

Swadling, P. 1977. "A review of the traditional and archaeological evidence for early Motu, Koita and Koiari settlement along the Central South Papuan coast". Oral History 5(2): 37-57.

___________ . 1981. "The settlement history of the Motu and Koita speaking people of the Central Province, Papua New Guinea". In Denoon, D. and Lacey, R.

(eds.), Oral Traditions in Melanesia, pp. 240-51. Port Moresby: University of Papua New Guinea.

Thompson, K. 1982. Beyond description: a compilation and explanation of pottery from six archaeological sites in the Gulf Province, Papua New

Guinea. Honors thesis, La Trobe University.

Thomson, J. P. 1892. British New Guinea . London: G. Philip and Son. Tueting, L. T. 1935. "Native trade in Southeast New Guinea". Bernice Bishop

Museum Occasional Papers 11(15).

Turner, W. Y. 1878. "The Ethnology of the Motu". Journal of the Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland 7:470-97. Vanderwal, R. L. 1973. Prehistoric studies in Central Coastal Papua.

Unpublished PhD. thesis, Australian National University.

___________ 1976. "Tradition, history and potting: a papuan example of changing settlement and economy". Oral History 4(2): 2-15.

___________ 1978. "Exchange in prehistoric coastal Papua". Mankind 11:416-28. Williams, F. E. 1924. The natives of the Purari Delta . Anthropology Report no.