Finding out
3.3.3 Professional roles: different sides of the same coin
3.3.4.2 Trying to adjust and move on In making sense of their
neuropsychological assessment experience, all participants described ways in which they attempted to adjust and cope with their neuropsychological assessment
outcome. Participants had described how emotionally impactful receiving their results was for them and how for many this had threatened their prior sense of self (see section 3.3.4.1). The way in which participants coped was influenced by the outcome they were given and the way in which they made sense of this. Participants tried to adjust and cope in a range of different ways, including trying to compensate, trying to carry on as normal, accepting limitations, remaining hopeful, and
reassuring themselves. Coping strategies adopted seemed to be self-protective or integrative and aimed at trying to achieve a positive sense of self.
Participants who received a diagnosis of AD described ways in which they attempted to compensate for their difficulties. Terry had talked about his shock at receiving his diagnosis and fear of losing control, and here he describes attempting to compensate for his future loss by organising and planning ahead:
“and on a Friday the last thing I do is get everything ready to make
she knows where everything is, sorted, life insurance, pensions, everything else” (Terry, p. 27, lines 440-443)
In planning ahead now, it seems that Terry is perhaps preparing for an unknown and potentially threatening future by trying to ensure that his family are looked after, thus maintaining his role as husband and father and sense of himself as a competent, whole individual. Completing this task also appears to provide Terry with a sense of accomplishment and self-efficacy despite him feeling worried that his abilities have deteriorated (see section 3.3.1.1).
For David, using external aids enables him to compensate for his memory problems and allow him to maintain a sense of normality and control in his life now:
“I can live my life, I keep a day pad everything that I need to do today and then I’ll start sticking on things for tomorrow, I’ve got a laptop which I keep going erm, so I know what I’m doing” (David, p. 14, lines 223-235)
What came across from his account was how adopting his usual problem- solving strategy enabled him to maintain his sense of self as capable, which was in stark contrast to his experiences during the neuropsychological assessment testing phase when he felt unable to complete the tests (see section 3.3.2.2). Feeling and being perceived as capable and normal was important for David and he had spoken
about not wanting others to know he had been diagnosed with AD, perhaps suggesting how stigmatising the label of having dementia was for him.
For others, accepting their difficulties enabled them to integrate new
knowledge gained from the neuropsychological assessment into a new view of their self. For Jean this translated into her accepting her difficulties within the context of her current capabilities and using this to remain optimistic about the future:
“I’ll consider myself quite fortunate if I continue to the end of my life...as I am NOW, I’d like to be brighter, I’d like to be a...as I used to be may be, erm...but...I feel at the moment I can...plod along quite merrily, quite happily erm, you know, ad infinitum” (Jean, p. 19-20,
lines 323-327)
Although Jean acknowledges her deterioration and desire to want to return to her prior self, focusing on her current capabilities and what she can do has enabled her to accept herself. There is a sense that her acceptance only extends to how she views herself now, and despite her doubts, her hope that she remains the same is evident. The researcher wondered if this reflected her uncertainty about the meaning of being diagnosed with MCI.
For other participants (Mick and Derek), being told their problems were associated with psychological factors posed much less of a threat to their sense of self than being diagnosed with dementia, making it much easier for them to accept their difficulties. Here Mick describes his experience:
“now I don’t really think about it...it’s how I am...that’s me
really...but a relief it’s ok...well not ok but you know...it could have been much worse” (Mick, p. 19, lines 270-272)
For Mick, finding out his difficulties were likely to be related to psychological factors was a huge sense of relief and seemed to immediately
alleviate his distress. There is a sense that Mick felt that any other explanation was better than being told he had dementia, perhaps highlighting how stigmatising he viewed dementia as a diagnostic label. Mick’s acceptance of his difficulties is demonstrated here in how he refers to his “current self” in the present tense “it’s
how I am”. This seems to indicate how Mick has integrated his understanding of his
difficulties into a new and updated view of self.
For Derek feeling accepting of his problems enabled him to change his style of coping and become more accepting of himself. Rather than feeling frustrated and becoming angry with himself, he instead engaged in reassuring self-talk:
“now I know it’s based on anxiety and stress if I forget something then I just say to myself “well I’m a bit stressed out that’s obviously why I’ve forgotten it” (Derek, p. 28, lines 481-484)
In contrast with Derek and Mick, Eric’s attempts to reassure himself that he did not have dementia were less successful:
“and I have to keep reminding myself that, you know that there isn’t anything there, it’s not showing but err...I dunno know...I dunno, things just keep...you know my memory’s still bad, so...(sighs) (Eric,
p. 21, lines 365-368)
Eric had previously spoken about his doubts over his neuropsychological assessment results and how they appeared to conflict with his self concept and experience of the neuropsychological assessment (see section 3.3.4.1). Here he describes trying to reassure himself “that there isn’t anything”, however continuing to have memory problems seems to reinforce his doubts, making it difficult for him to accept his results. His difficulty in accepting his results means his uncertainty about himself is maintained.
For participants who received inconclusive results (Janet and Zeena), coping was aimed as trying to adjust to the uncertainty of not knowing. In the absence of a definitive answer, both Janet and Zeena attempted to carry on as usual, thus
demonstrating how they were still the same person. For Zeena this meant maintaining her usual “fighting” spirit:
“I’m trying to FIGHT everything, you know, that...to try and
remember, you know, and I’m...I...I don’t want to be in that stage and things like that, you know, so I try to write everything down, you
know, I try not to be in that stage, you know, I’m a positive person, you know” (Zeena, p. 16, 269-273)
What comes across here is how Zeena is determined to tackle her problems head on and not be held back by her difficulties. There is also a sense that she is “fighting” the possibility of having dementia, in the way she talks about not wanting to “be in that stage”. Fighting seems to serve a dual purpose in enabling Zeena to manage her difficulties as well as trying to maintain a view of herself as a person who does not have dementia.
Janet also talked about trying to carry on as normal, however for her the worry that she might have dementia seemed to interfere with her achieving this:
“I have to get on with it...trying to get on with it...trying to be normal
(laughs) what that is (said quietly) trying to enjoy things, forget it”
(Janet, p. 16, lines 253-255)
What comes across here is how, in the absence of knowing whether or not she had dementia, Janet feels there is no other alternative than to try and accept things and get back to normal. However the uncertainty of not knowing continues to threaten Janet’s sense of self, making it difficult for her to know what normal is. It is interesting how at the end of her sentence she says “forget it”; the researcher
wondered if this, perhaps, represents just how impossible it feels for her to carry on as normal.