An adaptive multigrid tool for elliptic and parabolic systems

(1)

This is a repository copy of

An adaptive multigrid tool for elliptic and parabolic systems

.

White Rose Research Online URL for this paper:

http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/1761/

Article:

Jones, A.C. and Jimack, P.K. (2005) An adaptive multigrid tool for elliptic and parabolic

systems. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids, 47 (10-11). pp. 1123-1128.

ISSN 0271-2091

https://doi.org/10.1002/fld.845

[email protected]

https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/

Reuse

See Attached

Takedown

If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by

(2)

White Rose Consortium ePrints Repository

http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/

This is an author produced version of a paper published in International Journal

for Numerical Methods in Fluids.

White Rose Repository URL for this paper:

http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/1761/

Published paper

Jones, A.C. and Jimack, P.K. (2005) An adaptive multigrid tool for elliptic and

parabolic systems. International Journal for Numerical Methods in Fluids, 47

(10-11). pp. 1123-1128.

(3)

$&%('*)+,).- /1032546)7825':9,);</>=@?BACBDBDBD1EGFGF.HJILK>M NO42QP>RS42L?T/1AL=U%>VXWYSZS[\:]1^_a`bc5dG254&AL=:eB%gfh>iijhakliBmakgnSoqpjn)UiSnQr

sutwv3x8vzy{}|6~q6{}|5|5x{}T35|5y{}|v3tqxyvz}vz|5.#{

OG I,¡U¢>£

¤¦¥3 § ¨© £#ªS«I ¬q N®¯°%(=U':±²l³a91e5eB<eQ´ eB0PG/>'µ=:%>V±z°#%(=:p254&AL=U'µ¶!eQ´·¸2L2¹?SA± ·¸2L2¹?SA±·#²ghXmS+lº¸±3°})»3) ¼G½¿¾¾ÀÂÁÃ ÄÅ¸ÆÈÇÉ¸Ê>É#ËÌÍlËjÇ&ÎÌaÆÈÏ#ËjÇÐÊÑTÒ¸ÓJÔaÆÈÕ>ÌaÆUÍÖÔa×(×1Ó¿Øµ×ÌÒ¸Ç&ËÚÙÛÆÈÔaÅÜÊ>Í¸Ê>ÉgÔaÆÈÝ,ËjÓJÞÖÌaËß¸à¸ËBÍáÑqËjÇ&ÅlËjÇÆÈàáÔ¹Ù×âÍgÆUÑqËà¸Ç&ÆÈ×1àlÇjã À ÇLÔ6Ê>à¸Í¸ÊSÌ6ÍÖä¸Ò¸ÓÈÓ À É¸ÉgÌa×BålÆÈÑ8ÊSÔaÆU×>à ¼ Ôa×>Ì6Ê>Õ>Ë"æä À3¼¸ç ÑÒlÓJÔaÆUÕÌaÆUÍâÇ&Î5ÅlËjÑqËÆÈÇÑq×GÍgÆJß.ËBÍ"Ôa×Ñ8Ê>ÆÈà(Ô6Ê>ÆÈàÖËèqÎÆUËàGÔ É#ËÌ&Øµ×ÌaÑ8Ê>àlÎjË×1àÚà¸×>àléÒ¸àlÆJØµ×>ÌaÑêÕ>ÌaÆUÍlÇ!ÊSÌaÆÈÇ&ÆUàlÕÊ>Ç!Ê8ÌaËjÇ&Ò¸ÓJÔaÇ¿×ØÓÈ×(ÎBÊ>Ó ÑqËjÇ&ÅÐÌaËß.àlËjÑqËjà(ÔBãÄÅlÆUÇ¿ÆÈÇ!ÊÎ5ÅlÆUËÝ,ËBÍÐÏGÞ Ê>ÓÈÓÈ×BÙÛÆUàlÕÐÅ.Ê>àlÕ1ÆÈà¸Õàl×GÍlËjÇ!Ôa×ËågÆÈÇLÔXÏ¸ÒlÔXËjàlÇ&ÒlÌaÆÈà¸ÕÔaÅ.ÊÔTÊSÔËBÊÎ5ÅÇLÔ6ÊÕ1Ë8×>Ø ÔaÅlË8ä À¼ ÊÓUÕ>×>ÌaÆJÔaÅ¸ÑÔaÅ¸ËqÇ&×>ÓÈÒlÔaÆÈ×1à ÆÈÇÉgÌa×ë¹ËjÎÔaËBÍìÆUà(Ôa×íÔaÅlËÎj×>àGÔaÆÈàGÒ¸×>Ò¸ÇqÇ&É¸Ê>ÎjËÆÈàâÙÛÅlÆUÎ6ÅâÔaÅlËÅ.Êà¸Õ1ÆÈàlÕîà¸×GÍgËÝ1ÊÓÈÒ¸ËjÇÊÌaËÆÈà(ÔaËÌaÉ#×>Ó:Êà(ÔaÇ×ØÔaÅ¸ËÆÈÌ Îj×,ÊSÌaÇ&ËÕ>ÌaÆUÍÉ.ÊÌaËàGÔÝ1ÊÓÈÒ¸ËjÇjã À à¸×>à¸ÓÈÆÈà¸ËBÊSÌBïlËÓUÓÈÆÈÉlÔaÆÈÎ1ïgß.àlÆJÔaË3ËjÓÈËjÑqËjà(ÔËålÊ>ÑqÉ¸ÓÈËÂÆÈÇ ÉlÌa×SÝGÆ:ÍgËBÍÔa×ÍgËjÑq×1àlÇLÔ&Ì6ÊÔaËÂÔaÅ¸Ë ËèqÎjÆÈËjàlÎÞî×Ø ÔaÅ¸Ë8ÉlÌa×>É#×1Ç&ËBÍÊÓÈÕ1×>ÌaÆJÔaÅlÑãOð3×BÙËÝ,ËÌBïÔaÅlËqÑqËÔaÅ¸×GÍÆUÇTÊ>ÓÈÇ&×ÐÇ&Ò¸ÆJÔ6ÊÏ¸ÓÈËØ@×>ÌTÓÈÆUàlËBÊÌÊ>à¸Íîà¸×1àlÓÈÆUàlËBÊÌ É.ÊSÌ6Ê>Ï#×1ÓÈÆÈÎ!ÉlÌa×>Ï¸ÓÈËjÑqÇjãñ×1É(ÞGÌaÆUÕ>Å(Ô òôó>õ>õ1õqöÎ ×>Å¸à÷ÖÆUÓÈËÞø ¼ ×>à¸Çjï¸ùÔ6Íã

ú}û(üîýXþÿ

ÑqËjÇ&ÅÊ1ÍlÊ>ÉlÔaÆÈÝGÆJÔ¹Þ(ïlä À¼

ÑÒ¸ÓJÔaÆÈÕ>ÌaÆUÍïgß¸à¸ÆJÔaË¿ËjÓÈËjÑqËjà(ÔÛÑqËÔaÅl×GÍ

"!$#%'&)(+*-,/.102* 435 #6*7#6*98:;% .1%40=<):;8< '>?3 :;@:3BA <):> < #6*C.D, (+(E#*-(43 :;@* 3 % 3<)* > %,F! 53GH3 :;% (JI%', : K .5> < >9 .*-.L:3 :M. $435 # ( 3 % 5 .*N.D%',O*F02%'#,P%40 I ! 3 :+@:33 %Q* . 5 #*

3 < H3R3 <)*S,F*-.<T#*.D%'( 5)3 :;% :M.R. 5UN> :;* V3 ( XW$ *Y: =3 <)*-.*Z#6*98':+% . 3 %[%'& 36 : T\>->]5 # H3 *Z.D%'( 5)3 :;% K^ A <):;(M. 3 &_*9: 8=. 5UN> :+* '3 ( `> % #6.*N*-(;.* A <)*-#* 3 %a, Hb :;,F:;.*Y* UN> :;* $>9 dc b) ,O!$(+*.R%0 3 <$:;. 3 !_* #* 5 ,F*9#6% 5 .& 53 : > ( 5 I*O!)< .* W *-(;I[.D:;, 5 ( H3 :+% .%0d# !):MIQ.D%'(+:MI: W>943 :;% K^e .fI*-. > #6:+&_*-I: \g

^ h i 02%# * b ,F!)(+*'kj1<):;(;. 3 %& 36 : : 8 . 5 : 3G &)( #6* W$ *IX,O*.D<a:M. 5) I% 5 & 3 *-I( XS * > *.. # > % I: 3 :;% 02%# '> <):+*-@: 8 4 * U/> :+* V3 .%( 53 :;% : 3 :;.R& X %[,F* .R. 5UN> :;* V3 lj1<)* T3 <)* I ! 3 :;@* (+8'%#6: 3 <),P:M. & .D*I 5 !% X <):;*9# # > < %0 *. 3 *-IE,F*-.<)*-. 3 <)*F, 5 (3 :;8#6:;I !$!)#% > < H35 # (+( . 5 88'*-. 3 .f:3 .D*-(m0 . Q>-4 I:MI 43 *O02%# * UN> :;* V3 .%(;@*9#k 1gn io^ 02%#p* b) ,O!$(+* ^qr % (+: * # 3 :;,F*]stI*9!_* I)* V3 !)#6%&)(;*9, ^ ,F%I*9(;(;: 8 3 <)*Z.!)#6* I: 8S%0 S3 <): I#6%!a%H@*-# #% 5 8<=. 5 #0> * ^ :M.u.%(;@*-IE@*-# * UN> :;* V3 (X5 .: 8 :+,F!)(;:> :3-^k I ! 3 :;@* ^)3 :+,F*]st. 3 *9!$!): 8 (+8'%#6:3 <),v& 5 :+(3 #% 5) I wfxQ, 5 (3 :;8#6:;I[.D%'(+@'*9#$ Q3 < H3 A %#6y/<)% A *9@*-# 3 <)*zI:+{_*-#* V3 8#6:;IY(+*-@*-(;. #*%& 3G : *-I 3 <$#% 5 8< 5) :+02%#6,|8'(+%'& (e#6* W$ *-,F* V3-^ # H3 <)*9# 3 < 4 (;% >- (^) I ! 3:;@*#6* W$ *-,F* V3 ) Y3 <$:;.! !_*9# A *!$#%'!%V.D* .D:;,F!)(;*f02# ,F* A %'#y 3 < H3 (+(;% A . 3<)* * U/> :+* $>] %0J(;% >- (}<):;*9# # > <):>- (l#* W$ *9,F* '3/~ I > % #6.* : 8 3 %S&_* > %,u&$: *I A :3 <X, 5 (3 :;8#6:MI 3 %

k?oo4?DD,H.lo?]?D6¡e q5¡#-9?eGe?,¡.l]ozG5¡#VD6¡.>CLBBÛ¡ J

Î

(4)

«¬+¬;H®°¯±$²Q³¯6´+µ/«4¬¶¬;·¯6´+'¸`¹f¸)'¸)¬+´;¸)²«4º/²9¬;¬;´+³¯6´;»r³$º'¼)¬+²-µ/¶O«¸$½¾¸)¸$¬+´;¸)²-«ºF³$«4ºG«4¼_¬;´;»Y³)º6¼)¬;²9µ/¶ ®´+¯±S¹2·)¬;¬+¿Y´+µF³)¬;´M»]´+¯¯´;µF²z½´;¶6»]º6²]¯6´;¶6«H¯6´+'¸KÀ

Á

±)²rÂ½´;¶6»]'¸)¸)²»?¯²½kÃK'ºFÂ±$«¸)Ä´;¸)Är¸)½²¶9Ãe¯6±$«H¯R«º²R¹2·$¸$½a´+¸a¸)'¸Å·)¸)´+¹2º6µÆµF²-¶±)²-¶p¸$²9²-½a¶³²»]´M«4¬ ¯6º²«H¯µF²-¸'¯d´;¸FºG½²9º}¯6z«Ç´M½u½)´;¶6»]'¸'¯6´+¸·)´+¯´;²-¶d´+¸O¯±$²¶D'¬+·¯6´+'¸KÀ

Á

±)´M¶È±$«'¶ ¼²-²9¸O¯6«'»GÉ¬+²½u´;¸/µ/«4¸¿z®«¿¶ ´;¸$»]¬;·$½´;¸)ÄS«½)½´;¸)ÄYº²9Ê$¸)²9µF²-¸'¯¯Y²9¬;´+µF´;¸$«H¯6²z¯6±)²R±«4¸)Ä'´+¸)ÄY¸)½²-¶OË

ÌoÍ

µF½´+¹2¿V´;¸)ÄZ¯±)²RÊ$¸)´+¯²O²9¬;²9µF²9¸V¯ ¼$«'¶D´M¶uËÎ

Í Ï Ì

º«½)½´;¸)ÄZ»9¸$¶D¯ºG«4´;¸V¯²-ÐV·$«4¯´;¸$¶¹2ºf¯±)²¶D²z¸$½)²-¶OËÑ

Ì

À

Á

±)²u¸$«4¯·)º6²z¹dµu·)¬+¯´;Äº6´;½³_²9¸$¶ ·)³1¯±)²-ºN³)¯´;¸$¶N¹2ºZ½²«4¬;´+¸$Ä=®´m¯6±Ò±$«4¸$Ä´;¸)Ä=¸)½²-¶-À

Á

±$²[ÓÔqÕ

Á

«³)³)º6'«»G±¾4¹zÖºG«4¸$½¯[Ë×

Ì

¶D²9¯6¶ ¯6²9µF³'º6«º¿T«ºD¯6´mÊ_»]´M«4¬Ø´;º6´;»G±)¬;²]¯N»9¸$½´+¯´;¸¶O«4¯F¯±)²Q¼_·)¸½)«4º6´+²¶O4¹«¸¿=¬+»9«¬+¬;¿=º6²]Ê$¸)²½`«º²«¶O«4¸$½ ¶µFV¯±)´;¸)Ä/¯G«4É'²-¶³)¬M«»9²z¸r¯6±)²-¶²z·)¸$´m¹2'ºµÙ¶D·$¼_½'µ/«4´;¸$¶9À

Á

±)²uÚÕÛÜ«4³$³)ºV«»G±r4¹dÓ»ÛÝº6µF´;»GÉaÞ]ßàHá Ëâ

ÌÍ

±$H®Ý²-Ç²9º

Í

·$¶²-¶}¶D³_²-»9´;«¬´;µF³)¬+´M»]´+¯}Ê$¸)´+¯²]ÅÇ'¬+·$µO²9Åo²-¬+²-µF²9¸V¯l¶D¯²9¸¶D´;¬;¶}«H¯l¯±)²Ýº²9Ê$¸)²-µO²-¸V¯q¼'·)¸$½)«º´;²-¶K¯ º6²-¶¬;Ç²¯6±)²fÊ$¸)²f«¸$½Z»9·)ºG¶²Äº6´;½Nº²¶D´M½·$«¬;¶J´+¸Z¯±)´M¶«4º6²-«)À'ãE²³)º6³_'¶²¯O·$¶²f«u³)ºä²-»]¯´;¸NµF²]¯6±)½

Í

'º´;Ä´;¸$«4¬;¬;¿u¶D·$ÄÄ²¶¯6²-½O´;¸F¯±)²»]¸V¯6²]å¯d4¹k¬;´+¸)²«4ºd³$º'¼)¬+²-µ/¶È´+¸EËÑ ÌÍ

¯6z´;µO³_'¶²»9¸$¶D¯ºG«4´;¸V¯6¶ ¸F¯6±)²ÇH«4¬;·)² ¹$¯±$²±$«4¸)Ä'´+¸$Äf¸)½²¶9ÀHãX²±$«Ç'²«'½)«4³¯6²-½u¯±)²¼«¶´;»ÚÕfæRµu·$¬m¯6´+Ä'º´M½uµF²9¯±)½F¶Df¯±«H¯J¶µO¯±)´;¸)Äp»9«¸ ¼_²F³²-ºD¹2'ºµF²-½HÇ²9º¸)'¸Åo·$¸)´m¹2'ºµÙÄ'º´M½)¶«H¯L²-«»G±E¬+²-Ç²-¬À

Á

±)´M¶LµO²9¯±)½E«4¬;¬+H®¶¯±)²F·$¶²O4¹Ý«S¶¯6º6«´+Ä'±V¯ ¹2'º®«4ºG½Z»9¸V¯´;¸·)·$¶ÝÊ$¸$´m¯6²z²9¬;²9µF²9¸V¯½´M¶»9º²9¯´M¶«4¯´;¸KÀ

ÀÕØÕç Áètéê

Ó

ê

æë7Ó êJÁ

ëìØLæ

Á

±)²L«½$«4³¯6´+Ç'²µF²-¶±Z«4¬;Ä'º´+¯±$µí¯6±$«H¯´M¶Ý·¶D²½N´;¸N¯±$´;¶®º6ÉR´M¶¼$«¶²-½N«º'·)¸$½NÐV·$«'½º6´+¬M«H¯6²9ºG«4¬)²-¬+²-µO²-¸V¯6¶ ¯6±$«H¯Z«º²¶D¯'º²½\´;¸1«=Ð'·«½¯6º²-²½)«H¯G«X¶D¯º6·$»]¯·)º6²

Í

«'¶F´+¸CË Ì

À

Á

±)²Q·¶D²Q¹L«=ÐV·$«'½¯º6²9²Q«4¬;¬;H®¶F²-«¶¿ «'»9»]²¶¶u¯X«4¬;¬¬+²-Ç²9¬M¶R®´m¯6±)´+¸\¯±)²rÄ'º´M½=·$¶´+¸$Ä¯º6²9²Y¯ºG«Ç²-º6¶6«4¬d¹2·)¸$»?¯6´+'¸$¶

Í

µ/«ÉV´;¸)ÄE´m¯N«4¸`«4³)³)º6³$º´M«H¯6² »G±)'´;»9²¹2º·$¶²®´+¯±Z«uµu·)¬+¯´;Äº6´M½N¶D'¬+Ç'²9ºÀÕ¯«4¸¿RÄ'´+Ç'²9¸F¯6´+µF²f¯±)²»]·)º6º²-¸V¯JµF²-¶±N´;¶Ýµ/«½²f·)³Z¹k¯±)V¶D² ²-¬+²-µO²-¸V¯6¶J¯±$«4¯»9º6º²¶D³_¸$½O¯6u¬;²-«4¹K¸)½²-¶Ý´+¸Z¯±)²LÐV·$«½¯º6²9²À

Á

±)²fº²9Ê$¸)²9µF²-¸'¯4¹l«¸N²9¬;²9µF²-¸'¯´+¸Ç'¬;Ç²-¶ ¯6±)²p»]º6²-«H¯6´+'¸Z¹q¹2·$º»G±$´+¬M½º6²9¸Y¹2º¯±)²z»9º6º²¶D³_¸½´+¸$Äz¬+²«H¹}¸)½²L´+¸Y¯±)²zÐV·$«'½¯º6²9²'À

Á

F»]V«4ºG¶D²-¸

Í

¹2·)º ²-¬+²-µO²-¸V¯6¶R®´m¯6±`«[¶±$«º²½a³$«4º6²9¸V¯

Í

«4¸½=®±)´M»G±\«4¬;¬»9º6º²¶D³_¸½X¯[¬;²-«4¹¸)½²-¶R4¹¯±)²Z¯º6²9²

Í

µ/«¿a¼² º6²9³)¬M«»9²-½`¼¿=¯±)²-´+ºZ³$«4º6²9¸V¯-Àdî·)µF²9º6·$¶/»9¸$¶D¯ºG«4´;¸V¯6¶/«º²r³)¬M«»9²-½`¸¾¯±)²¶D²r'³²-º6«4¯´;¸$¶F±)H®²9Ç'²9ºR¯ ²-¸$¶D·$º²¯±«H¯-ï

ð

Á

±)²9º6²J´M¶}¸)²9Ç'²9ºlµO'º²Ý¯±«4¸z'¸)²Ý¬;²9Ç'²9¬V4¹$º6²]Ê¸)²9µF²9¸V¯È½´+ñ_²-º²-¸$»]²¼²9¯®Ý²-²9¸u«¸¿f¯®¸)²9´;Ä±¼_·)º6´+¸$Ä ²9¬;²9µF²9¸V¯G¶9À

è

¯¹2'¬+¬;H®¶¯±$«4¯¯±)²-º²p´M¶¸)¬;¿Z²-Ç²-º'¸)²L±$«4¸$Ä´;¸)ÄF¸)½²L³²-º²9¬;²9µF²9¸V¯²½Ä²'À ð Õ|¶³²»]´+Ê$²-½T¸V·$µu¼_²9ºO4¹Nò¶6«H¹2²9¯¿E¬M«¿²-º6¶6óQ«4º6²Z«'½)½²-½=¯¯6±)²Zº6²]Ê¸)²9µF²9¸V¯F«H¯R²«»G±T¬;²9Ç'²9¬oÀ

Á

±)´M¶ ²9¸$¶·)º6²-¶Ý¯±«H¯¯±$²9º6²®´;¬;¬K«4¬;®«¿¶¼²p«4¯¬+²«¶D¯¯6±)´M¶¸V·$µu¼_²9º4¹ ²9¬;²9µF²-¸'¯G¶«H¯²-«'»G±Y¬;²9Ç'²9¬e¼_²]¯®²9²9¸ ¯±)²L´;¸V¯²9º¹«»9²L®´m¯6±r¯±)²p¸)²9å¯Ê¸)²9º¬;²9Ç'²9¬K«¸$½N¯6±)²p´;¸'¯6²9º¹«»9²®´+¯±S¯6±)²p¸)²]å¯»9'«4ºG¶²9º¬+²-Ç²9¬oÀ

Õ¸V¿a²-¬+²-µO²-¸V¯DÅ¼$«¶²-½aº6²]Ê$¸$²9µF²9¸V¯O»9º´+¯²-º´M«Qµ/«¿a¼²Y·$¶²-½=¯6E»9¸V¯º6¬È¯6±)²r«½)«³¯´;Ç´m¯¿

Í

¶·$»G±T«¶R¬;»-«4¬ ²-ºº6º²-¶D¯´;µ/«H¯6²-¶º¶´;µO³$¬+²L²9º6º6º´+¸½´;»-«H¯6ºG¶Ý¼«¶²-½S·)³_¸r¶D'¬+·¯6´+'¸rÄºG«½´;²9¸V¯6¶

Í

¹2º²9å«µF³)¬+²'À

ô

ÀÓõfÔ ÁèDöL÷è

ØøÓ êJÁ

ëìØ

Á

±)²Zµu·)¬+¯´;Äº6´;½aµF²9¯±)½a¯6±$«H¯u®²N³)º6³_'¶²/´M¶u¼$«'¶D²½X·)³'¸=¯±$²ZÚÕfæ=¶6»G±)²-µO²Y«4¸$½X¯6±)²Z·$¶²N¹¸$¸Å ·)¸$´m¹2'ºµ

Í

¬;»9«4¬;¬;¿Nº²9Ê$¸)²½YÄ'º´M½)¶«'¶½²-¶6»]º6´;¼²½Z´;¸r¯±)²p³$º²-ÇV´;·¶¶D²»?¯´;¸qÀ

ê

«'»G±Y¬;²9Ç'²9¬k4¹}¯±$²zµu·)¬+¯´;Äº6´M½ «¬+Ä'º6´m¯6±)µù´M¶¼$«¶²-½S·)³_¸Q«F»]'µO³_'¶´+¯²pÄº6´M½Y»9HÇ²9º6´;¸)Äu¯6±)²p®±)'¬+²p½'µF«´+¸qÀ$Ú}´+Ä'·)º² ú ¶±)H®¶«/¶Dµ/«¬+¬ ¶²-»]¯´;¸Q4¹J«Z»]µF³_'¶´m¯6²uÄ'º´M½Q«H¯¯6±)º6²9²R»9¸$¶²-»9·¯´;Ç²u¬+²-Ç²9¬M¶-Àë²-¸$»]²O«N¶·)´m¯G«4¼)¬;²u¶µFV¯±)²-º

Í

«¶f®Ý²-¬+¬}«¶ ¶·)´+¯6«4¼$¬+²/º6²-¶D¯º6´;»]¯´;¸a«4¸$½E³)º6¬;¸)ÄV«H¯6´+'¸[³_²9ºG«H¯6ºG¶L«4º6²Oº6²-ÐV·)´;º6²-½[¹2ºz¶·$»G±=»]µF³_'¶´m¯6²/Äº6´;½$¶9À

Á

±)²¶D² «º²p½²¶»9º´;¼²½Z´;¸S¯±)´M¶¶²-»]¯´;¸S´+¸S¯±$²z»]¸V¯6²]å¯4¹}«O¯¿³)´M»9«¬k¸)¸$¬+´;¸)²-«ºµO½²-¬K³)º6¼)¬;²9µrÀ

eû?ü9ý-þoÿ ¡?ûYÿtýa¥-ûV "!$#!&%(')+*,-!/.0*-21!4365'7289

:<;<;&=>@?BA

C

(5)

Level N

Level N − 1

Level N − 2

zv{}|B~Tn$(T}xBJce&{T|OT{2i{}T B|{}|<xT0{T

qs0i B¡¢£4¤+¥ s¦O£2¢O§

¨ª©s«¬ª®¯m°m«¯o©±-®±©<²+³O´¶µs«·2¬T¸s¹4·¶º»¬m·`±e¯ªµs¯o®B«e¼½®¾²"©&³°o±e©sº¿µn±-·¶ºmÀs´¶®Á©pÂm®O´¯m«©sÃª´2®BÁÄ©sºm´¶¸s¹4ª© ¼½®BÅs®O« ¬m®0·`Â&®Bµ±Æ¯m«®B±®Oº¬®BÂn®Çp¬®OºªÂnºªµ<¬°m«µ<´¶´¶¸¬©ÈÁ©s«®xÀs®Bºm®O«µ<´^®B´2´¶·¶¯&¬·`³x¯m«©sÃª´2®BÁ±µ<ºªÂu¬©¬ª®É±©s´¶°&¬·¶©sºÊ©s² ¯ªµs«µsÃo©´2·`³¯m«©Ãm´¶®OÁ±Ë°ª±·2ºmÀ·¶Á¯m´2·`³·2¬Æ¬·2Á®x±-¬®O¯ª¯m·2ºªÀªÌmÍËm®eÁ©&Â&®O´/¯m«©Ãm´¶®OÁÎ³O©sºª±·¶Âm®O«®BÂcm®O«®·¶±BÏ

ÐJÑ¾ÒÓÔ¿ÕvÓ6Ö×0ØÚÙ Û-ÜÝ

©ºÚ¬m®ÞÂ&©Áµs·2ºàß

ØáÛTÐeÜsâBÜÝ¾ãäÛTÐeÜâOÜÝ

µsºªÂä±-°mÃmåT®B³¬Ê¬©

ÓæØèç

©sºÚ¬m®êéJ·¶«·`³m´¶®¬XÃ6©s°mºoÂmµ<«¸sÌ ¨ª©s«¿¬ª®ë¯ª°m«¯6©±®B±¿©s²¬®B±-¬·¶ºmÀì¬m®í±©s°m«³®ê¬®B«Án¹

Ù

¹e·`±î³m©±®Oºï¬©ä¯6®O«Á·¬î¬m®ð±-©´2°&¬·2©º^Ï ÓñØ Ü¾ÐóòTôõ/ö[Û÷4ÛDø

Ò

Ôìù

Ò

Ðóú

Ò

Ý-Ý

ÌûÍËm·¶±u±©s´¶°&¬·¶©sºíoµs±µü«®B´¶µ<¬·¶Ås®B´2¸ý±-Áµs´2´µ<«®Bµî©s²xm·2Àó³°ª«Å µ ¬°m«®X·2º ¬m®«®BÀs·¶©sºÈ©s²

ø

Ò

Ôþù

Ò

Øíú

Ò

¹Áµsÿ·¶ºmÀ¾·¬ûµ<ºnµ<¯ª¯m«©¯m«·¶µ<¬®Æ¯m«©sÃª´2®BÁ ¬©¾®OÅ µ<´¶°ªµ ¬®J¬m®Á0°m´2¬·¶Às«·`Â±©s´¶Ås®O« ©ºþm·¶Àsª´2¸þ«® ºm®BÂþÀs«·`Âm±OÌ^¨ª©s«¬m®«®±-°ª´¬±·2ºþ¬m·`±e¯ªµs¯o®B«

ÕêØ Ü

¹

÷»Ø µ<ºoÂ

úóØ

Ò

Ì µs´2®B«ÿp·¶º ºª·¬®e®O´¶®OÁ®Oº¬JÂ&·`±³O«®O¬·`±µ<¬·¶©sºc©<²$¬m·`±û¯m«©sÃm´¶®OÁÎÀs·¶Ås®B±Ëµ¾ºm©ºm´2·¶ºm®µ<«Æµ<´¶Às®BÃm«µ<·`³±¸&±T¬®OÁ ©s²[¬m®²"©s«ÁnÏ

Û"Ó ÝÓ Ø

â ÛsÝ

¼ûm®B«®

Û"Ó Ý

·`±Ê¬m®üÁµ ¬«·2ÇÚ©Ã&¬µs·2ºª®BÂì²"«©sÁ ¬m®ëµs±±-®BÁ0Ãm´¶¸ó©s²¬m®Þ®B´2®BÁ®Oº¬»±-¬·6ºª®B±±XÁµ ¬«·`³®±O¹ ¼û·2¬m©°&¬Æ«®OÀµs«ÂÈ²"©s«Ë¬m®eªµ<ºªÀs·¶ºmÀºm©&Â&®B±B¹&Áµ<«ÿs®BÂc¼û·2¬0·2ºÊ¨$·2À°m«®

Ü

ÌªÍËm®B±®ªµ<ºªÀs·¶ºmÀºm©&Â&®B±ûµs´2´¶© ¼ Â&·`±³©sº¬·2ºp°m·2¬·¶®B± ·2º¬m® ºm·¬®®B´2®BÁ®Oº¬+±¯ªµs³O®Jµ<´¶©sºªÀ¬m®®BÂ&À®B±¼ûª®O«®Æ¬ª®O¸´2·¶®sÌíÀ®Oºm®B«µs´ª±©s´¶°&¬·¶©sº©s² ¬m·¶±J±-¸&±-¬®OÁÎ¬m®B«®O²"©s«®´2·¶®B±û·¶ºn¬ª·¶±ûºª©sº³©º&²"©s«Á·2ºmÀ±¯ªµs³O®sÌmÍËm®x¨uÁ0°m´2¬·¶Às«·`ÂcÁ®O¬m©&Âu®OÁ¯m´¶© ¸s®Â m®B«®Ë±®O®Oÿ&±/¬©±-©´2Å®½µÁ©pÂm· ®ÂxÅ®O«±-·¶©sºx©s²m¬ª·¶±(¯m«©sÃª´2®BÁìÃp¸e©ºm´2¸e®BÅs®B«[¼+©s«ÿp·2ºmÀ·2º¾±-¯6®B³O· ³½±°mÃª±¯ªµs³O®B± ©s²[¬m®B±®ºm©sº³©º&²"©s«Á·2ºªÀ¾±¯ªµs³O®B±ûµ<¬Ë®µs³u«® ºm®BÁ¾®Bº¬Ë´¶®OÅ®O´GÌ

e¤+¥ O¢ ¢¡"!# s¦ $&%6§ ')(m¢O¥

ÍËm®ÉÁ0°m´2¬·¶Às«·`ÂÊ±-Á©p©<¬m®O«J¬ªµ<¬·`±Æ°ª±®BÂXÂm®Bµ<´`±Æºoµ ¬°ª«µs´2´¶¸¼û·2¬þªµ<ºmÀ·2ºªÀºm©&Â&®B±µ<ºªÂn·`±Ãªµs±®BÂn©ºn¬m® * «®³©sºoÂ&·¬·2©ºm®BÂ+* «©såT®B³¬®BÂ-,½©sº<åT°mÀµ<¬®.«µsÂ&·¶®Oº¬c±³m®BÁ¾®þÂ&°m®X¬©0/Ê®B¸s®O«¹213 4@Ì5+¬u®Bµ³ð´2®BÅs®O´¼½® ±Á©©s¬c¬m®eºª©sºm´¶·2ºª®Bµ<«Æ±¸&±T¬®OÁnÏ 687

ÛDÓ Ý

6

Ó Ø 687

â Û

y

Ý

¼ûm®B«®

ÛDÓ Ý

·`±xµs±·¶º:9<;°ªµ ¬·2©º Û Ý

µ<ºªÂ

6

·`±eµuÁµ ¬«·2Çi¼ûm·`³þ¯m«©<åT®³¬±J¬m®È±©s´¶°&¬·¶©sº»Ås®³¬©«·2º¬© ¬m®0³©º¬·¶º°ª©s°ª±Æ±°mÃª±¯ªµ³®sÌoÍËm®x®=v®B³¬J©<²

6

·`±û¬©© Å®O«¼û«·2¬®¬m®xÅ µ<´¶°m®x©s²(®µs³nªµsºmÀs·¶ºmÀºm©&Â&®x¼û·2¬ ¬m®e´2·¶ºm®µ<«û·¶º¬®O«¯o©´¶µsº¬Ë©s²[·2¬±û¯oµ<«®Oº¬ûºm©&Â&®B±BÌ>@¬Æ·¶±Æ·2Á¯6©s«¬µ<º¬Ë¬©ºm©s¬®¬ªµ ¬

6

7

6

Ó Ø? 686

7

Ó ?ØýÓ

Ì

Æ¯m¯ª´2¸p·¶ºmÀÊ¬ª®±T¬µ<ºªÂªµ<«Âþºª©sºm´¶·2ºª®Bµ<«ÉÂmµ<Á¯6®BÂA@µs³O©sÃm·³O©s««®³¬·¶©sºî±³m®OÁ®¬©Ê¬m·`±xºª®O¼ ¯m«©<åT®B³¬®Â ±¸&±T¬®OÁ ¼û·¶´2´ºm©<¬Þ¯m«©&Â&°ª³O®ýµä³O©sº¬·¶ºp°m©s°ª±î±©s´¶°&¬·2©º^ÌxÍËm®ð³©««®B³¬·¶©sºCBEDs¹e²"©s«îºª©pÂm®0Fª¹eÁÉ°ª±-¬ÞÃo® ²"©«Á®BÂê°ª±·2ºªÀþÅ®B³¬©s«±³©sº¬µ<·¶ºm®BÂü·2º+GH

ôJIpÖpÛ

6

Ý

·¶ºë©s«Â&®O«¾¬©»Às°oµ<«µ<º¬®B®È¬oµ ¬¬ª®O¸Þ¼û·¶´2´û¯ª«®±-®B«Å® ¬m®e³©sº¬·2ºp°m·2¬T¸©<²/¬m®±-©´2°&¬·2©º^ÌÆºu®Çp¬«µÉ¯m«©såT®B³¬·¶©sº

6

·`±½¬m®B«®O²"©s«®µÂmÂ&®Â¬©É¬ª®ºp°mÁ®B«µ<¬©s«+µ<ºªÂ Â&®Bºm©sÁ·¶ºªµ ¬©s«(©<²o¬m®Æ±-¬µsºªÂmµs«Âx²"©s«Á0°m´`µ¬©Áµ<ÿs®KBLDûµÅµs´2·`Â³©««®B³¬·¶©sº^ÌÍËm·`±&*«©<åT®B³¬®ÂM@µs³©Ãm·

Û

*N@

Ý

rPOEQ RTSUWVEX=Y[Z\^]E_E_E_a`EOEXcb2d"UWeWfgRh¿wTOEbcikjflYnmlo pgq'r)sutvswyxvz5{k|}s ~M{}rcsxvE]E_E_E_vWT

(6)

±¬²P³¬´µk¶¸·¹´º»lµL´º»½¼¾µ¿¬¶¹¼}ÀJÁ±µºÀJ».Â À»lµkº»±¬ºÃµÄÅ³¶v¼}²½ºÃµ¶Mµ¿¬¶MÆ´JÂEµµk¿½´µ2µ¿¬¶ÈÇ½»¬ºµk¶¸¶ Á¶ ·¹¶ »lµ8´¼¼}¶T·MÉ¬ÁÄ"ºÊ¼ ²¶ ËkÆ)ÀË·¹¶T³"º»Ìµk¿½¶8»¬À»ÍgÂ=ÀJ»Æ)ÀË·¹º»½Î¸¼k²½´Â ¶Ï

ÐEÑÒ+Ó[ÔÕ×ÖnÕ8Ø&Ù Ú Û

Õ8Ø Ù Ü«Ý ÞßÑ

ÔÕ×ÖÌà àvávâ Õ Ø Ù ÜÅÝ Þgß Ñäã Ö lÞ ålæÊåJæÅçPè¬éMêÅëìîínïÃðñEïò¹ó2ìðJôñEïõíõèö ÷

ÁÎJÀËºÃµ¿¬· ø ³¬¶=µ´ºÁÊ¼Ìµk¿½¶ù´ÁÎJÀËºÃµ¿¬·úÆ)ÀËÌµk¿½¶ùû<ËkÀü¶TÂ=µk¶T³þý ÷2ÿ

·M±¬ÁµkºÎËºÊ³ µk¿ ´'µÅº¼Ì²¬ËÀ²ÀJ¼k¶T³

ý½ÀË ¼kº·¹²¬ÁºÊÂ=ºµÄ ´ùÉ½´J¼}ºÊÂÌµ5À:ÎËº³¶TË¼kºÀ» º¼×²½Ëk¶v¼}¶T»Jµ¶T³a¿¬ºÊÂL¿-Â ´» ¶v´¼kºÁÄ0É¶«¶lµ¶ »½³¬¶T³ µkÀ0´ Æ)±½ÁÁ ¾Í Â ÄÂ Á¶

¿¬¶[Ëk¶v¼µËkºÊÂEµºÀJ» ÀJ² ¶TË´µkÀJË¼

´»½³

u³¶ »½Àµk¶"¼}º·¹²¬Á¶[º»'ü¶vÂEµºÀJ»a¿¬ºÁ¼}µ Æ)±¬ÁÁ5¶ ºÎ¿lµº»¬ÎÅºÊ¼ ±½¼k¶T³ Æ)ÀJË8µk¿½¶[²¬ËÀÁÀ»¬Îl´'µºÀJ»À²¶ ËL´'µÀË

¿¬¶ Ë¶T¼}µkËºÂ=µkºÀ»

º¼È´Å²Àº»JµkÍaºÊ¼k¶×À²¶ ËL´'µkÀJË8Æ)ÀË µk¿¬¶ ¼kÀÁ±µkºÀ»a¿¬ºÁ¶

Ë¶T¼kÀÁ¶v¼<µ¿¬¶ ³º¶TËk¶T»½Â=¶8º» µk¿½¶8¶ Á¶ ·¹¶ »lµ2¼k±¬²¬²ÀËkµ¾´Ë¶T´ÈÆ)ÀËaµ¿¬¶8Ë¶T¼kº³± ´ÁÉ¶=µ5¶ ¶ » µ¿¬¶¾µ5À8ÎËº³¹Á¶J¶ ÁÊ¼ ¿¬¶T¼k¶¾À²¶ ËL´'µÀËL¼ ³À »½Àµ<º»lµk¶ ËkÆ)¶ Ë¶!aºµk¿¹µ¿¬¶²¬ËÀü¶vÂEµºÀJ»¸·¹¶ µk¿¬À³

¿¬¶¾Ç »¬¶¾ÎËºÊ³ Ë¶T¼kº³¬±½´Á#"

$&% '&( )+* ÖÕ8Ø

Þ

É¶=Æ)ÀË¶5ºÃµ&ºÊ¼Ë¶T¼}µkËºÊÂEµk¶v³ ¼kÀ´ÁÁ'´Á±¬¶T¼yÂ ÀËËk¶v¼}²À»½³¬º»¬Î¾µkÀ¿½´»¬ÎJº»½Î»¬À³¶v¼u´Ëk¶

,

¶ ËÀ

-¿¬¶TËk¶ Æ)ÀË¶ »¬À º»Æ)ÀJËk·×´'µºÀJ»Åº¼ÁÀl¼µ´'µ¾µ¿¬¶MÉÀ±¬» ³¬´Ëº¶v¼¾É¶=µ5¶ ¶T»ÅÁ¶¶ ÁÊ¼¾ÉÄÌ±½¼kº»¬Î[º»'ü¶vÂEµºÀJ»ÅÆ)ÀË µ¿¬¶KËk¶v¼}ºÊ³±½´ÁlË¶T¼}µkËºÊÂEµkºÀ»

.

»ü¶TÂEµºÀJ»ÈºÊ¼&´ÁÊ¼kÀ´²¬²¬ËÀ²¬Ëº´µk¶<Æ)ÀËuµk¿¬¶a¼kÀÁ±µkºÀ»¸Ë¶T¼}µkËºÂ=µkºÀ»cÀ» ìîï0/é 1

J¼}º»½Â=¶ ºµ¸ÂT´»¬»¬ÀµÈÂ=Ë¶T´µk¶ ´Å»½À»ÍgÂ=ÀJ»Jµº»±¬ÀJ±½¼ Â ÀJ´ËL¼k¶¸ÎJËkºÊ³:¼kÀÁ±µkºÀ»ùÆ)ËÀ· ´«Â=ÀJ»lµkº»l±½À±½¼°Ç »¬¶[ÎJËkºÊ³:¼}ÀJÁ±¬µkºÀ»

º

¶

ºÃÆ2

$3% '&( )+* ÖnÕ

Þ

µ¿¬¶ »2

$% '&( )+* ÖnÕ

Þ

54

º6J¶aºÊ¼}¶2µk¿¬¶Æ)±¬ÁÁ5¶ ºÎ¿lµkº»¬Î¸²¬ËÀÁÀ»¬Îl´'µkºÀ»[À²¶ ËL´'µkÀJË ±½¼k¶T³¹ÀJ»

ìîï0/é87å

aºÁÁÂ=Ë¶T´'µ¶¾´°Ç½»¬¶2ÎËº³¸¶TËkËÀË9a¿½ÀJ¼k¶KÇ½»¬¶Á¶J¶ Á¬»½À³¬¶:'´Á±¬¶T¼N´Ë¶aÁº»¬¶v´Ë º»lµk¶ Ë²ÀÁÊ´»lµ¼ ÀÆ<µk¿½¶ ºË8²½´Ë¶ »lµ°»¬À³¶;c´Á±½¶T¼

<

¶ » Â=¶=²½ËkÀ>ºÊ³º»½Î

*

$?% '&( )+* ÖnÕ Þ µ¿¬¶¹Ëk¶v¼}±½ÁÃµ8ÀÆNµk¿¬¶¹²¬ËÀÁÀ»½ÎJ´'µºÀJ» * $% '(=)+* ÖÕ Þ ÷

ÁÃµ¿¬À±¬ÎJ¿[ºµ5ºÊ¼5»¬ÀµK¿¬ºÎ¿¬ÁºÎ¿lµk¶v³ ¶@²¬ÁºÊÂ=ºµkÁÄ×º»[µk¿¬ºÊ¼5»¬ÀµL´'µkºÀ» µk¿¬¶°À²¶ ËL´'µÀËL¼

Õ

´»½³

Õ8Ø

½´Ë¶Â Á¶v´ËÁÄ"³ºAP¶ Ë¶ »lµaÆ)ÀJËa¶T´ÂL¿"ÎËº³"Á¶¶TÁ

¿¬¶°·¹¶T´¼k±¬Ë¶±½¼k¶T³Ì´¼5´¹¼µÀ²¬²½º»¬Î¹Â=Ëºµk¶ ËºÀ» ·È±½¼µaÉ¶8´»"´JÂ Â ±¬Ë´µk¶2Ëk¶T²¬Ëk¶v¼}¶T»lµ´'µºÀJ» ÀÆµk¿¬¶8¼kÄ¼µ¶ · É¶ º»¬Î ¼kÀÁ¶T³

ý¬ÀË<¶@¬´·¹²¬Á¶='µ¿¬¶aË¶T¼kº³± ´Á»¬ÀJËk·C·M±½¼}µ É ¶2Â ´ÁÊÂ=±½Á´µk¶T³È±½¼kº»½Î ´°Ëk¶v¼}ºÊ³±½´Á+¶TÂ=µkÀJËBaºÃµ¿¬º» % '&( )+*

ÖÕ Þ Ï " Ò Õ×ÔÕ Ø Ù Ú Û Õ Ø Ù Ü«Ý ß ã CEDGFIH-J>KMLNOQP û ËÀü¶TÂ=µk¶v³[ý ÷2ÿ&R ±½ÁÃµºÎJËkºÊ³"Í NÀTSËº³ ÿ ÂL¿¬¶T·¸¶ UWVX Ò

Á¶¶ Á »l±½·MÉ¶ ËaÀÆyÂ=±¬ËË¶ »lµaÎËº³ YVZ Ò X Û ø Ö

Á¶¶ Á »l±½·MÉ¶ ËaÀÆyÎËºÊ³[ÀJ»¬¶8Â=ÀJ´Ë¼k¶ ËNµk¿ ´»

X Þ [V]\ ¿½ÀlÀl¼}¶°º»¬ºµkºÊ´ÁÇ½»½¶ÎJËkºÊ³Ì¼}ÀJÁ±µºÀJ»E2 ¼}À¸µ¿½´'µ Õ 2 Ò 2 º ¶ 2

$% '&( )+* ÖnÕ Þ ^ V]\ ´ÁÂ ±¬ÁÊ´'µk¶µ¿¬¶8ËkºÎ¿lµkÍ¿½´»½³[¼kºÊ³¶ Ù Ú ´»½³Ì¼}¶ µ Ú Ò Õ8Ø&Ù Ú _V` ²³½´'µk¶82 ÉÄ[¼}·¹ÀÀµ¿¬º»¬Î;a+bµº·¹¶T¼!aºÃµ¿"µ¿¬¶ ¼kÄ¼}µk¶T· Õ8Ø Ù Ü Ö Ý ÞgÝ Ò Ú ±½¼kº»¬Î ûc dV ýuº»½³ÌËk¶v¼}ºÊ³±½´Áe" Ï Ò Ú Û Õ8Ø Ù Ü Ö 2 Þ 2 f Vg ¶T¼}µkËºÂ=µ¾Ëk¶v¼}ºÊ³±½´ÁI" Ï Ò Ö " Þ hVg ¶T¼}µkËºÂ=µ¼}ÀJÁ±µºÀJ»E2 Ï Ò Ö 2 Þ iV]\

´ÁÂ ±¬ÁÊ´'µk¶8Â ÀJ´ËL¼k¶2ÎJËkºÊ³[ËºÎ¿lµ}Í¿½´» ³[¼kº³¶

Ú Ï Ò " Tj Õ8Ø Ù Ü Ö 2 Þ 2 UlkV ÿ

´m¶2µk¿¬¶8º»¬ºµkºÊ´Á Â ÀJ´ËL¼k¶2ÎJËkºÊ³"¼kÀÁ±µºÀJ»E2 no=nAp Ò 2 UWUWV ÿ

ÀÁ¶µk¿¬¶ ¼kÄ¼µ¶ · Õ8Ø Ù Ü Ö 2 Þ 2 Ò Ú ¶@¬´JÂEµkÁÄ UlYVq\

´ÁÂ ±¬ÁÊ´'µk¶µ¿¬¶ Â=Àl´ËL¼}¶ÎËº³ÌÂ=ÀJËkË¶TÂ=µkºÀ»

* Ò 2 Û 2 no=nAp Ul[V

û<ËkÀJÁÀJ»¬ÎJ´µk¶µk¿¬¶ Â ÀËËk¶vÂEµkºÀ» * Ï Ò Ö * Þ

U ^ Vq\

ÀJËkË¶TÂ=µNµ¿¬¶°Ç½»¬¶8ÎJËkºÊ³Ì¼}ÀJÁ±µºÀJ»E2 Ò 2 j * Ul_Vr` ²³½´'µk¶82 ÉÄ[¼}·¹ÀÀµ¿¬º»¬Î;a#sµº·¹¶T¼!aºÃµ¿"µ¿¬¶ ¼kÄ¼}µk¶T· Õ8Ø Ù Ü Ö Ý ÞgÝ Ò Ú ±½¼kº»¬Î ûc £utWvwxy{zW|@}~ YWkWkWk

¤WtW|m Ey{{wù¨tWm#}l¢ >M+rllmeIW

YWkWkWk¡£¢£¢+V{U¥¤d

¦

(7)

1e-08

1e-07

1e-06

1e-05

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

0

1

2

3

4

5

6 Log( Residual )

V-cycle

Multigrid convergence for uniform and adaptive grids at various grid levels

Uniform Level 6

Adaptive Level 6

Uniform Level 7

Adaptive Level 7

Uniform Level 8

Adaptive Level 8

Uniform Level 9

Adaptive Level 9

1

10

100 1000

10000

100000

1000

10000

100000

1e+06

1e+07

Log( Execution Time (secs) )

Log( System Size )

Execution time for various system sizes

Uniform Grids

Adaptive Grids

Line of slope 1

ÌuÍAÎÏ ÐÑÓÒ£ÔÆÕÐlÖ× Ø#Ù]ÙØ ÚWÛ9ÍAÜ ÎÝØ Ñ Þ Ï ÝßàÍàÎÐÍAáãâäÚÜ£åmÑÐÎÑäÜ âäÑÓÖ@ÝqÙÑäåmÑæÐlÖß ÎÐÍAáçßàÑäåÑäßàÙrÖÜáÝØ Ñ]Ñæè=ÑäâäÏ=ÝÍàÚÜçÝÍàÞ8ÑréÚÐêåÖ@ÐÍàÚÏ#Ù9Ù¥ë=Ù¥ÝÑäÞìÙÍàíäÑäÙ

î-ïqð!ñò5ó:ô+õ!ò

õ]ö5÷¼ø9øùú@û÷ü=ýçþ5ÿùølùý#ûæøûþ5÷¼ú-ÿùøûæø 5ù;ü=ý-ølûÿ>ûæ÷ý ûæö5ùqùTú÷ùý-ú£ý =úú5ÿ=ú8üIûö5ùqþ-ÿü þÆü#ølù ;ù@ûæö5ü eï-ü=ÿûö5ùqølûù ølû£ûùûùøû9þ5ÿæüù ú@ü=ýÆøl÷ +ùÿæù ö5ùÿæù û÷!=ÿæ÷! øúäö5ù;ùr÷¼ø"-øù $#&%q÷ûö ü+úçùølöãÿæù'Æý5ù;ùý#û(-ý +ùÿû)=ùý*&0ûùÿBûö-ù øü!+û÷ü=ý;÷¼ø9ü5û£÷ý5ù +>û9ûæö5ù!þ5ÿæù,÷ü-øù, ùï.- ø÷!çþù øü!+û÷ü=ý/ ÿ. +÷ùý#û0;ü=ý5÷ûü ÿ÷¼ø0-øù ûæü3ûÿæ÷.=ùÿ0ü+úêÿæù'Æý5ù;ùý#ûï21!ü3 +ù4¥ÿù'-ý5ùçùý#û÷ø5-øù ö5ùÿù ø÷ýÆú@ù!ûæö5ù:þ-ÿü.ù ÷¼ørøûæù çølû£ûù=ï6-rûù=úäö+ù, ù-üeûö5ù7!8 Aûæ÷ ÿ÷ ;ûæö5ù:ÿæùø÷! Æü=ý;ûö-÷ø9=ÿæ÷! ;÷¼ø -øù : ø]ûö-ùøûæü=þ5þ-÷ýEú@ÿæ÷Aûæùÿæ÷ü ýï-õ]ö5ù;'Æÿæølû=ÿ£þ5öü÷!5ÿæù < øö5ü&%!ørûö8>û:ûæö5ùÊÿæùø÷! ÷¼ø!ÿæù -ú@ù 6==ý>;ü#øû!ú@ü ý-ølû£ý#û?@=ú@ûü=ÿ£û!ù úäö=A4ú+úù8ü ýB$5ý-÷CMü ÿDE£ý Eý5ü=ý4F5ý-÷CMü ÿDG ÿ÷ 5øï

õ]ö5ùãølùú@ü ý H ÿ=þ5öÃü?÷!5ÿæù < øö5ü&%!ø ûö8>ûÓûö5ùãùI+ùú5û÷ü=ý û÷!çùã÷¼øJ÷ý5ù£ÿK 5ùþIùý +ùý#ûÊü=ý ûö5ù øD+øûæù øl÷!Lù ï#õ]ö5÷¼ø9ÿæù>ûæ÷ü ý-øö5÷þã÷¼ø? +÷CMuùÿæùý#û(6+Êúü=ý-ølû=ý û?;ü5ý#û(Iù@û%rùùýãûö-ù75ý5÷Mü=ÿN£ý ãý-ü=ý4 5ý-÷CMü ÿD ú ølùø9ø÷ý-úù!ûæö5ùÿæù!÷¼ø9ÊøD÷ ö û=ÿæù£ûùÿ9ü&,=ùÿö5ù ÷ýTûö5ùO =þ+û÷!,=ù:ú=øùMü=ÿÿù'-ý5ùçùý#û9£ý ö=ý=÷ýÊý-ü6 5ù:ü=þIùÿ>ûæ÷ü ý-øï.1!ù,=ùÿlûæö5ùùøæøBûæö5ù:ûæ÷;ùøDP,÷ý øêüQ £þ+ûæ÷,÷û5@=ÿü.+û%ù÷ ö-øûæö5÷ø?;÷ý5ü=ÿ ü&, ùÿæö5ù. eï

÷ý!#mý5ü=ûùûö£û"Mü=ÿ"Æü=ûö 5ý5÷Mü=ÿ!0£ý8 0üú!8ÿæù'Æý5ù 5=ÿæ÷! 5øûö-ùrùÿÿæü=ÿR=úäö5÷ù, ùøûö5ù]ùI+þIùú@ûù STVU8WX

Iùö8P,#÷ü-ÿïrõ2ù Y ÷!Æøûæÿ£ûùøTûö5÷¼ø#? ø*%rù!O øøö5ü&%q÷ý ûö5ùZ +÷CMuùÿæùýÆú@ùÃ÷ý øD+øûæù øl÷!Lù Iù@û%rùùýEûæö5ùJ5ý5÷Mü=ÿ[=ý \. £þ5û÷!,=ù8ú ølùøï

Ë

ï^]_Ylò`róò5ò6YDaO1

bù ö8P,=ùÃþ-ÿùølùý ûæù c ý5ù%d5û÷!=ÿæ÷ ûüü.7Mü ÿ>. £þ5û÷!,=ù! ÿù'-ý5ù c;ùøö5ùøE÷ý û%rüe +÷!;ùý-ø÷ü=ý-ø =ý H ÷, ùý ù,÷! 5ùý-úùçü÷ûæøÊø>ûæ÷ø@=ú@ûü ÿD3ú@ü ý6,=ùÿ=ùý-ú@ù£ý Z=úú5ÿ=ú=ïeõ]ö5ù+£÷ýZ. ,&£ý#û=ùçüûö5ù þ5ÿæü=þIü øù >;ùûö5ü 3ü&, ùÿ7Aûæùÿæý>ûæ÷, ùø!øD-úäöK=ø fg h÷¼ø!÷ûæøø÷;þ÷ú÷Aû÷ýH +ù÷ý=%q÷AûæöH£ÿ5÷ûÿ£ÿ=üú ÿæù'-ý-ù;ùý#ûqþ>ûûùÿý-øïY¥û:øö5ü! B¼ølüIù8ý5ü£ûæù Eûö8>û#8ûö5ü.=öø;üü£ûæö5÷ý;÷ø^5ý8 +ùÿû)=ùý&ü&,=ùÿrûö5ù ùý ûæ÷ÿæùi +ü.=÷ý;£ûù úäöOù, ùF#Wûö-ùêú@ü#øûþIùÿjA74¥ú+úù9÷øøûæ÷!=ü þ+û÷!+%qö5ùý8ÿù'-ý5÷ýq÷ý ûæü7£ý6'Æý5÷AûæùøD4 +ü.+£÷ý&ü ÿ7£ý6øö5ü+ú)ü ÿÆü.5ý =ÿD\!P ùÿïYý&ûö5ùú=øù8ü;ü=ý5ù4k 5÷;ùýÆøl÷ü=ý$Æü.5ý =ÿD\!P ùÿ#6Mü=ÿ ùI;þù.##ûö5ùý65Iùÿ]ü25ý)ý5ü&%qý-ø^£þ-þ5ÿüPI+÷!+>ûù +ü.ùø^>û]ù úäö==ÿæ÷ +ù,=ùl=ý ãûæö5ùùTú@÷ùý-ú úäö5÷ù,=ù ÷¼ø8ûæö5ùÿæùMü ÿùTø÷!ç÷!£ÿ8ûæü3ûö£û ü.+û=÷ý5ù Z%qö5ùým=þ5þ!÷ý: û÷!=ÿæ÷! ûæüH3ü=ý-ù4n +÷;ùý-ølü ý þ5ÿæüùo-ø÷ýO5ý5÷Mü=ÿ ÿæù'-ý-ù;ùý#ûï-7Aûæö5ü=ö;ÿùøAûäøR=ÿùrü=ýÊþ-ÿùølùý ûæù ö5ùÿæù?Mü=ÿiøl÷ýù]ù!÷þ+ûæ÷ú

ÇlprqstFuwvrxy=z{}|r~r~r~rprxP_\uwwnsO ÉprPDÀyV n&R"?DQ5P$r2|r~r~r~wk ¡

¢

(8)

¾l¿À.ÁCÂÃÄP¾¿ÀÁÅÂiÆnÇÈrÉiÊÅËÌ^ÍÇ.ÂÆnÈÁÅÎ.ÍÊÅÈË0¿ÏÏÎÐ¿ÏÑO¿ËÒOÆkÑÆkÍÂÓÔÆnÊÅÕÂÖÈÐ

×

¿ÐÊCÈÎÆiÌÐÊCÒÁÅÂ

×

ÂÁÅÆØÊÅËÍÇ.Â^ÎË.ÊÅÖ!ÈÐÓo¿Ë6Ò¿Ò¿ÙÍÊ

×

Â^Ïr¿ÆnÂÆ

ÚÂ

×

ÂÁÜÛ9ËÊwÖÈÐÓ Ý?Ò¿Ù.ÍÊ

×

Â

Þ9È.Ä.Þ?ÈÒ.ÂÆ Úlßà@Ë.ÈÐÓáÈÖQâjÐnÐÈÐ Þ?È.Ä.Þ?ÈÒÂÆ Úlßrà@ËÈÐÓãÈÖjâ$ÐnÐÈÐ

ä ßåæ ßÄçäPèèéèêêëæÂàVçê ßåæ ßÄçä&èèéPè&êêëæÂàVçê è êçåæ éÄëéåêrìêäPèìPëÂàVçPß êrçåæ éÄëéåêìêä&èìëÂàVçß é äPßßè êÄéåéPèßåäPëééÂàVçPß äPçæì êÄéåéPèßåçåPë&êÂàVçß

ë êééäê ä.ÄßëëßäçPßëèåÂàVçì ååPëì ä.ÄßëëßäPåßåççÂàVçì

å ééçäæ êÄçPëìåPëääçäPéÂàVçì ßìäPßè êÄçëìæêråêèåèÂàVçì

æ ßéìêéæ ßÄéåëëåßìéPèèÂàVçä ëçäåPè ßÄéåæçèåçåäìÂàVçä

êç êçPèçéPßè éÄëßìççêrìæPëëÂàVçPè ßßëéåê éÄëëìçìPèä&èëëÂàVçè

íîïðñòóõôDöò;óòôDöï÷Böøù^ðòòú:øííñ!û!ò÷BüûCôö>òýþøñjùDþÿÿòùù9ôDï*øüû÷ò;îøúòOïRúïúñû!úòøîòñ!ñû!íôû!ÿ øú÷íøîøðïñ!û!ÿï&üeíîïðñ!òó+ù øóíñ!òù"ï8ôöòñ!øôôòîiû!úÿñ!þ÷òþññ û!óíñ!û!ÿûCô(÷ûùÿîòôDûùø&ôDû!ïú8ù"ïôDöò

ï.îDï.þù:ò÷ûþó9ýþø&ôûï.ú Pÿï.ú.òÿôDû!ïún÷ïóû!úø&ôò÷Jÿï.úòÿôDû!ïún÷ûþ8ùû!ïú;íîïðñòóù! ðïôö ùDûú.ñò òý.þ8ø&ôDû!ïú8ù_øú÷Kù"6ùôDòó+ù$#%løú÷:úï.úñ!ûúòøîOíöø.ùò&('òñ!÷Hù)ùôDòó+ù_þùDò÷:ôï=óï÷òñ"îøíû÷KùDïñ!û!÷û*'8ÿø&ôûï.ú + , -/.7ïôDò5ôDöøô7ôöòùDò0ñøùô7ôü?ï*ò% øóíñ!òù06ûòñ!÷:úïúnù)6óóòôîDûÿ;øñòðîøû!ÿ;ù"ùôòó+ùïiòýþøôDû!ïúù ï.îüöû!ÿöBôöò;íîï1òÿôDò÷*ó5þñCôû.îDû÷>øñïîûôDöóõü?ïî$2ù9òýþøñ!ñ=ü9òññ

±2³$»¶"µ43656·¹7R·l½J·¶98

:>Â¿ÐÂ

×

ÂDÐnÑÌÐ¿ÍÂÖ!ÎÁÍÈ<;?ÐrÄ=¿Ð?>@::¿ÁA>ÁÅÂÑ5ÖÈÐ?ÇÊÅÆ

×

¿ÁCÎ¿À.ÁCÂÊCÒ.Â¿Æ9¿Ë6ÒÆnÎ.ÌÌÂÆkÍÊÅÈËÆ(ÐÂÏÂÊ

×

ÂÒ+Ò.Î.ÐÊÅË.ÌJÍÇÂ ÏÈÎÐÆnÂÈÖ$ÍÇ.ÊCÆ"ÉRÈÐ?>Ä

B

·DC·

B

·¶"³l·$¸

E

²D3GFIH?H?JKH?L(±2±!M½ONILLP)QSRT8M6¸U-FVPWHYXH?L

B

´P²³TZ\[^]IN_-P$_(`KZ\a@ZWXbcH)acbIL`_(H?dNcd`KaIefPf]IFIPWdHhgVH?JKbi[^ZbcH)J²j/kcl\mno-prq E)s\s\tcuVvvwxWy%t"zx\{\x

²

x

²ºDLZ)|\P$_PWdÔ¶MG7}Z\JKbIH?acXH?JKb ¶M*¹~PWa%_()`Ke ´P²*±}bVPW]_`|%H[^H)d(FLHYgVacH)[^H?a%_U?Z\[^]INc_P$_(`KZ\aZWXdZ\JK`Kbc`gVU)P$_`KZ\a [^`KL(U?Z\d(_(LNIUY_(NILH?dNId`KacehbcQaVPW[^`KUbVP$_Phd(_(LNcU?_(NIL(H)d²%Yp\D(%9cp\n\p%j/kcl\mno)m

E)s\s\scu&wx\{\"zx\s\

²

t

²47~PWd(\H?JKJºTM´%`K[PWUHº»hM(¸H?JKJK`KH?L½M~8FcZ\[^]IdZ\a2½²"·^U?`KH)a%_PWacbPWU?U)NcL-P$_(HG_(`K[^HPWbVPW]c_(`|%HG[!NIJ_`Ke\L(`Kb d(`K[hNIJAP$_(`KZ\aIdZWXDbILZ\]IJKHY_9d]IL(H)PWbI`KaIeP² -V¡"Yp\n\p\\cYp\c?\¢¡"Yno-p\£i¡)kc"¤\mnr¥/n¤\m

x\\WyIu§¦wKE\E){cE-z E\E)¨\{

²

y

²47}Nc]c_-P2±\»?²D±©gVaI`_(H4H?JKH?[^H)a%_XZ\L_LPWaId`_(`KZ\aXLZ\[ªPgVaIH/_(Z~PU)Z%PWL(dH4e\L(`Kb²\ -V¡)Yp%n\p\I%Yp\"?\/¢¡)Yno-p\ £S¡"kc)¤%m«n*f¬\n¡-¡)Yn

E)s%®W¨cuc¯wt\$°y%

²

²D3@PWaIe«3H²¸]H)U?`APWJ±I`KJK`KaIH)PWLD²NVPWbcL`KJAP$_(H)LPWJH)JKH?[^H?a%_d/XZ\LJKZU)PWJKJQ

B

HYgVaIH?b^gVaI`_(H9H?JKH?[^H?a&_/e\L`KbId²³I µ´~£¶c\cYp\% ³§o)n¡)Vn·/o0\}cn

x\\cE\u¯¯wx\\x\s"zx\\\

²

{

²l½OHYQ%H?L;±9²QºDLZW¸µH?U?_(`KZ\a¹_H?U-FcaI`K²NcH)diH?[h±H?bIbIH?bª`Kaº_FIHº$³7"½»XZ\LOFVPWacbIJK`KaIe¼FVPWaIe\`KaIeGaIZbcH)diPWaIb½±Z\NIaIbIPWL(Q L(H?d(_(L`KUY_`KZ\acdD²8¼aº¬4%n*¡-¡"Yn*¹\}p\n\p\^¾¡-oYkc\-\l$¿98Z\]I]I`KaIeRR²(²ÀhMDRT`_µ_aIPWLrÁÃÂH?bIdYÄk²j¸cP$ÅH

°

³TZ\±INIL(e ºDNI±IJK`KU)P$_(`KZ\aId"M¸%_`KL(JK`KaIeIM&¸&U)ZW_(JAPWaIbM

x\\\xcuE?y&®)zE){\

²

®

²TRTLPWaIbc_±9²½ONIJ_(`

°

JKHY|%H?JVPWbVPW]c_(`|%H~dZ\JKN_`KZ\aId_Z«±Z\NIaIbIPWL(Q

°

|\PWJKNIH9]ILZ\±cJKH)[^d²£ip\kc¡"hp\no)m}(!\}cp%n\ E)s%®\®u Æ

Â

E)t\¨

Ä

wt\t\t"zt\s\

²

¨

²T9PWL(_5/M6½OU³TZ\L([^`KU-0¸Mµ!Ç7~PWJKJAPWe\FcH)Li±(²8FIH^XPWdµ_PWbVPW]c_(`|%HfU?Z\[^]Z\d`_(H

°

e\L`KbS[^HY_(FIZb¼ÂC±2³Ä

w

PWJKe\Z\L(`_FI[^dXZ\L PWb|\PWaIU?H?b<U?Z\[^]INc_(H)L(dD²V´%n¡-¤£ip\kc¡)p\no"m«p\¤i\}p\n\

E)s\¨\{cuÈwKE)\t"zE)x\

²

s

²TR4PW`KacH)d½;ÍMD9Nc±I±VPWLb=½J·M´%`K[PWUºl»hM8´\Z\aIH?d±2³"²¸U)PWJKHf`Ka&|WPWLÀPWa%_^[^Z"|`KaIe<gVaI`_(HOH?JKH?[^H)a%_(dhXZ\LhaIZ\aIJK`KaIH)PWL ]IPWL(_(ÀPWJbI`ÉH?LH?a%_ÀPWJH?²&NVP$_(`KZ\aIdD².¸Nc±I[^`_(_(H?bf_(Z´%n¡-¤^¢ch¡"Yno-p\£ip\kc¡"hp%no)m

x\\Wy

²

³TZ\]&QL`Ke\F%_

U

Ê

x\\\

´\Z\FIaf3G`KJKHYQrË ¸Z\aId"Mc5_(b² YVÍÌ}cÌ¢~ch¡")Ì£i¡)kIÌ4¥/cn¤\m