113
"INSECTS
AND
DISEASE."
By
J. S.C
Elkinqton,
m.d., d.p.h,Chief Health
Officer ofTasmania,
(Read
9th
May,
1904.)Dr.Elkington said:
—
The
subjectupon
whichIhave been asked to address
you
thiseveningisonewhich has, witbin the pastsixyears,produced aprofoundalter-ation in several branches of science.
Here
inTasmania
we
arefortunatelyfreefromthosescourges of
humanity
whichareasyet
known
todepend whollyfor theirspread
upon
theagencyof insectlife, buteven with us theproblem is not wholly oneofoutsideinterest, as I willendeavor
to
show
youin relation to typhoid fever.Inthis case,however, the
method
ofcon-veyanceispurely a mechanical one, due
toparticles of infectedmatter clinging to
the legs and bodies of flies, and
subse-quently deposited
upon
food material,whence
it is taken into the alimentarycanal of the victim. It is advisable,
therefore, to clearly distinguish between
thetwo methodsinwhich insects play a
part inspreading disease
amongst
human
beings,whether
—
(a)
As
carryingagentspureand
simple, theinfectingagentundergoing no change andnot being dependent onthe insect inany way.
(b)
As
hosts,intermediateor definitive,the infective organism being dependent
upon
theinsectand undergoing anextra-corporeal phase of development in its
tissues.
The
first group is of distinct importancefromthesanitarian's point of view,
in that it teaches us to guard against
a real danger in times of prevalence
of certain infectious diseases, but the
second one far outweighs it. Into this
second group fall
some
of the chiefscourgesofmankind, in tropical regions
at
any
rate, andof these the greatest ismalaria. Nextto tuberculosis,malariais
probablythe greatestcause of death
and
of ill-healthwith whichmankind
has tocontend.
Some
ofyou
have, no doubt,visited or lived in places where malaria, orevenYellow fever, have claimed iheir
yearlytoll of livesandhealth, have seen
the long white-washed wards
and
wideverandahs of an Indian
Cantonment
Hospital filled with pasty-faced
fever-strickensoldiers, and have heard dayafter
day the drone of the regimental bands
along thedusty white roads to the
ceme-tery.
To
thatsupreme
critic of all ouractions, the
"man
inthestreet,"the proofoftheconveyanceofmalariabytheagency
of certain species of mosquitoes
was
merely aninterestingpieceof knowledge,
buttothose
who
know
what
the diseaseinquestionreallymeans,it
was
a fact of startling importance, presaging theap-proachof effective
means
of checking anenemy
whichintheyear 1897 alone laid75,821 British soldiers by the heels in
hospital outofatotal strengthof178,000
114
2
Anglo-Saxon civilisation to progress in
places where evensixyearsbacka
new-comer
couldcounthisreasonableexpecta-tion of life on the fingers of one hand.
Tropical medicine has
assumed
suchgreatproportions thatitpracticallyforms
the pivot
upon
which turns the wholeguestion of
European
colooisation in thetropics,and,practicallyspeaking, tropical
medicine is verylargely based
upon
the spreadof disease by insects. There,free-dom
from malaria practicallymeans
freedom fromill-health.
The London
andLiverpool schools have received noble
recognition from
Mr
Chamberlain, andfrom hard-headed business
men who
cansee into the future.
Many
a Peter theHermit
is leading a crusade againstdis-easewith knowledge, andoftenwithfunds
suppliedin this way,enabling the British racetogeton a stepfurtherwith colonisa-tion.
America
has taken up thework
withespecially striking results in relation
toYellow fever,
and
ahandfulof workers succeededin clearingHavana
of thisfelldiseaseinninety days
—
after ithad had
an uninterrupted reign for 140 years.
The
discoveries which have beenmade
are,Ithink,but aforetaste ofthose which
are tocome,buttheir histories, with the patient recordofconstanttoil overminute
details, ofthe sacrifice of leisure and
re-creation, and even in
some
casesoftheiives ofthe workersforthefurthermentof
knowledge^form,to
my
mind, oneofthe6<)bl3st
romances
everwritten.The work
ofManson,
Eoss,McCallum,
Reid, andothers have revolutionised the
methods
ofresearchinto
human
disease, andthereislittledoubt that
we
are onthevergeoffurther great discoveries in which the
lower formsoflife will be foundto play
anessentialpartindisease affecting
man-kind.
But
thismay
appear tobesome-thing of a digression fromthe practical
treatment of
my
subject. I trust,how-ever, that I have
shown you
tosome
smallextent theimportanceofthe results
obtained, and thepossibilitieswhichthey
openup. I will
now
endeavor,withtheaid ofafew lantern slides, to indicate in
some
measurethemanner
inwhichthesediscoverieshave been made,the
difficul"-ties against which the workers had to
contend,and the
method
in which theyare practically' applied.
The
classicalexampleis,ofcourse,sup-pliedbymalaria,orpaludism,asitisoften
termed.
As
Ineedhardly pointout,boththesetermsindicate the association with
the presence of marshes,
swamps,
andother wet-soiledlocalities, which has been
forcenturiesnoted inconnectionwiththe
disease, malaria
meaning
merely"bad
air," andpaludismthe condition induced by marshes.Now,
about the middle of lastcentury, certainobserversnoted thepresence of certain
brown
and blackgranules in great
numbers
inthe bloodand organs of malarial patients,
and
in 1880, . Dr, Laveran, a French
military isurgeoh in Algeria,
made
thediscovery that the black granules, which
are
known
asmelanin, were produced bythe action of
immense numbers
of tinyparasites living in the red blood
cor-puscles. This
was
a very notabledis-covery, as it naturally caused enquiry
intothe
manner
in which the parasites gotinto the blood corpuscles, and oncethere
how
they produced the fever.It
was
found that they could not begrown
on artificial media, even frombloodwhich
swarmed
with them, andother discoveries soon
made
it clear thatthey represented a distinct form of
animallife, andnotavegetable one, like
the bacteria for instance.
Some
fiveyearslateranotherdiscovery
was
made, namely,that these parasites breedin theblood,andthat the attacks of fever coin-cidewiththebreaking
up
of thecluster ofspores so formed. It
was
also foundthat threevarieties at least of the
or-ganismsinfect
men,
and that yet otherswere tobe obtained from the blood of
birds, bats, cattle, monkeys,
and
other animals.(Apicture.was then
shown
ofone formofmalarialorganismasitappears under themicroscope inthevarious stages of
development, whichare traceable in the bloodsolongasitretainsitsvitalityafter
removal.)
Under
the microscope, the strange octopus-like creature,which
representsthelaststage of development in blood
specimens,would attract your attention
even
more
than in the lantern pictures, sinceitsarms
are in vigorous motion fromthetime they shoot out from thesurface. Ifkeptmoist and
warm
anotherstrange
phenomenon
occurs.One
or113
3
rate itself from the body
and
to shoot vigorouslyaway. Sovigorously, and with such apparentintention doesitdoso,that it often sets the surrounding corpusclesbobbinglike a
row
ofcorks in a tideway.For
years a discussion raged over thisphenomenon.
Why
did the organism throwout thesearms
only after leaving thebody?The
octopus-like creature, ormale
gamete,was
never seen in bloodimmediately after its removal, but
de-velopedfromcertain of theparasites, but notall,ina shorttime
when
keptwarm
andmoist. Ifnotkept
warm
and moistitdidnot develop. Moreover,
why
was
it that onlysome
ofthe amoeloid organisms threwoutarms and
not all ?And
why
didoneor
more
ofthearms
when
thrownout cast loose from the rest
and
dartaway?
Upon
theseand
similar facts Dr.Manson,
thenofHong
Kong, formulatedin 1894 that fine piece of inductive
reasoningwhichwillalways be associated
with his
name.
Earlier observershad
fromtimetotime
made
suggestions of a similar nature, but itwas
reserved forManson
to formulate from theknown
factsatruescientific hypothesis. Being
a parasite, he argued, the malarial
organism must,like
most
other parasites, live forpart of its existence outside thehuman
body in another host.The
octopus-likemale gamete does not
come
into existence until after leaving the
body, andwhileinthe body the parasite
is incapableofliberating itselfbyits
own
efforts.No
traces of the parasite couldbe found in any of the discharges
of the patient. It
was
there-fore probable that it
was
re-moved
from the body bysome
bloodeatingcreature.
Manson
had
previouslyperformed
some
brilUant researches intothe conveyance of certain other blood parasitesbymosquitoes,and he
was
led tothe conclusion thatsome
distmctkindofmosquito
was
the probable agent, andthat themale gamete formedthefirststage
ofthe extra corporeal development of the
parasite inits
new
host. Ineedscarcelyremind you that in all its
main pomts
Manson's hypothesis has been proved
correct.
Then
Captain (now Major) Ross, ofthe Indian Medical Service, took upthe
work
ofinvestigating thedevelopmentinthemosquito. It
must
beremembered
thathe^began with practically no
know*
ledge of the classification, structure,or
habits of mosquitoes, since at that date
(1895) comparatively little
was
known
evento dipterologists, and that
most
of hiswork
was
done in an up-country Indian station far from theequipment andfacilitiesofamodern
laboratory. For two anda-half years he workedon,dis-secting and examining, cell by cell,
hundreds of mosquitoes without result,
and attempting feeding experiments in vain. Itisnatural that aftersuchan
ex-tended series of negative results he
was
beginningto suspect a flaw in ManFon's
theory.
Then
came
light.A
peculiarspecies of mosquito, which he had once
before noticedin avery malariouslocality
aspossessing dappled wings and laying
boat-shapedeggs,
was
fedupon
thebloodofamalarialpatient, and on dissecting it
hefound,forthefirsttime, in itstissues
granules of that coal black substance
which
I mentioned as being calledmela-nin, and as chara'^teristic of malarial
fever,and in its stomach walls certain
ovalcells. These discoveries practically
solved theproblem.
The
dappledwingedmosquito withboat shaped eggsbelonged
tothegenus Anopheles, andthe oval cells
in thestomach wall were the developing parasitesofremittent malarialfever.
The
restwas
comparatively easyoncethesefacts were
known.
The
plague scareamongst
the nativesmade
it necessary for Rossto pursue hisresearches into the development of the
organisminthemosquito by
means
of a closely similar organism conveyed by aCulexto birds, sinceblood feeding
experi-ments
fromhuman
beingsbecame
practi-callyimpossible,buthe hadsolved thetwogreatproblemsinthe
way
ofthetriumph-ant proof of Manson's hypothesis,
and
thathypothesis
was
provedtobe soundlyfounded.
He
had,moreover,distinguishedthe true malefactor
—
the Anophelesmosquito—
fromthe innocent Culex,and
hisprevious difficulties were tosome
ex-tentexplained by the silent retiring andunobtrusive habitsof the former genus.
The
differences between Culex and Anopheles are clear enough nowaday?,butitisproverbiallyeasytobewise after
the event.
We
must
alwaysrememter
116
4
The
difteirenees aife well exemplifiedin the lantern Blides, which I will
now
show
you, and they extend throughtheinsects'hves from begioniogtoend. In thefirstplace they
may
bereadily enough distinguished by the
attitude
assumed
in resting. Anopheles seems alwaystobe endeavoring to standon its head, while Culex rests parallel
withthe surfaceina
hunched
up position.This,ofcourse,is arough test, but after
alittle whileone
becomes
very expert indistinguishing the
two
in a localitywhere Anopheles are present. I
may
statethat Idonotknow
thatany
species of Anopheles existing in Tasmania,al-though one species has been recently
described as existing in Victoria. I
have not
come
across amember
ofthegenus in a large
number
of mosquitoeslately
examined
inTasmania. All species ofAnopheles arenot capable ofconveyingmalaria, a fact which explains the
presence of this genus in non- malarial
localities where cases are from time to
time introduced.
The
female, by theway,isusually the blood-sucker
amongst
mosquitoes, amealof blood being stated
tobeessential for thefertilisation of the
eggs.
The
male, exceptin thestegomyiaand
afewothers, is an innocent creature,preferring avegetable diet of fruit juices,
ifindeed hedoes feed atall,and not, like
hispartner,varying it with animal food
extracted in a voracious
and
annoyingmanner.
Both
maleand
femalearehere shown,but, taking the latter first,
you
will notethe length of the palpi
—
as long orlonger than the proboscis. This is in
itself, in the female, a
mark
of thegenus.
The
wings are spottedin bothspecimens
—
another fairbut notinfallibleguide-mark to the Anopheles.
Turn-ing to the male, you will note that the palpiare also long, but they are always
long in the male, whether of Anopheles
orCulex. These, however, are clubbed
atthe ends, andin this particularspecies are plumose at the ends.
The
dis-tinguishing
marks
of the male in thiscase, as in others, are the large plumose
antennae
—
regularwhiskers, as befits thesex.
The
adult msects can thus be distinguished,butforcompleteidentification this isnotenough. Variousmarkings of
thelegsand palpi, and the arrangement
ofthewing and body Bcales, are used to
identify species.
The
shape of the eggsisdifferentinthetwogenera, thoseofthe
Anophelespossessing adistinctboat shape, whileCulex eggsareblunterforthe
most
part.They
are laid inmassesoffrom 200to400. These eggsdevelop inthecourse
offrom 12hoursto severaldaysintolarvae,
which are
known
to every boy as the "wigglers,"foundineverytank and poolin fairly
warm
weather.Here
we
noteanother difference in the genera, the
Anopheleslyingparallel with the surface
owingtothe absenceofthelong breathing
tube,whichenables Culexto
hang
down
fromthe surface
—
the direct opposite ofthe position
assumed
byihe adultinsects,as
you
will recollect.The
arrangementofthehairs
upon
the different segmentsenables species to be determined. In a
week
forCulices ormore
forAnopheles—
thetimevariesconsiderably in these
pro-cesses for different species and under
differentconditions
—
the active wiggling larvaafter develops into a pupa, whichagain differsinthe twogenera, and after
a varying period of from two to 10 or
more
daysthepupa
casesplitsdown
the back, the adultinsect emerges, and afterbalancingitselfon the
empty
case for awhilein ordertodryitswings,flies
away
topropagateitskindinturn.
To
sum
up
the points which I haveendeavored to briefly indicate
we
havethe following facts toconsider wherever malaria is to be dealt with. There is firstly a blood parasite, which is the
cause of the disease,
and
nextcome
particular species of a particular genus
of mosquito, whose tissues afford
the only place wherein this parasite
can completeits life cycle. Malaria can
beconveyed from
man
toman
byinject-ing blood in which the organism
is, but this need not be considered in
practice. Therefore,intacklingthe
ques-tion ofstampingoutmalaria
we
naturallyattack the mosquito.
The
adultinsect
may
he guarded against bymos-quito curtains and other measures to
prevent its biting
—
a particularly usefulone by the
way
consists in wearing twopairs of socks after dark, a thick paii
underneath and a thin pair on top, since
more
people are perhaps infectedat the dining tabic than in almost
any
other way, the Anopheles loving the
dark lurking-places under ihat cheerful
117
5
fumigation with sulphur or
pyrethrum
powder. This, however,is an incomplete way,
and
since the Anopheles breedsby preference insmallpuddles
and
shal-lowstretches of
weedy
swamp
or slowlymoving
waterfreefromsmallfish, its de-structionisrather an engineeringthan amedical question.
Much may
bedonebypouring kerosene and paraffin on the
surface in the proportion of about
a tablespoonful to every square yard
ofsurface, so as toforma thinfilm,which
clogs the air tubes of the larvae and
pupae, and also kills the adult female
while depositingeggs. This
remedy
willbe found efficient by those of you
who
are worried by the local Culices, which
evinceabloodthirstydisposition in
New-town, atany rate. Culices areespecially
fond of smallcollections of waterin pots
and
tanks—
the saucerofa flowerpotonawindow
sillmay
providesufficientmos-quitoesto
make
the inmates'life a misery, whileanordinary400gallontankwillstock aneighborhood.The
moralof which, asCaptainCuttleis recorded to have remarked, lies
in the application thereof. I need not
say
more
than that the notoriouslymalarious localities of Sierra
Leone
and Freetown, formerly
known
as the " whiteman's
grave" inWest
Africa,have,comparativelyspeaking,beenturned
into health resorts within two years of
organised effort against mosquitoes, and
that at Ismailia, in Egypt, a previously
notoriously malarial town, the average
number
of cases has been reduced from 2000 to 200 perannum
by one season'swork. Practically, there were no fresh
cases of malaria once the
work was
gotgoing,anditis
now
possible to sleeptheren
safetywithoutamosquitonet, probablyforthefirst timeinthe historyofthetown. Probably everyonehere to-night has been
at one time or another subjected,
un-asked, to thegastronomic attentionsofa
femalemosquito,andthe
method
in whichshe performs the operation aftera
pre-liminary song
may
be amore
or lessin-teresting
memory
onthenext occasionyoucommit
culicide. (The lecturer here de-scribed with a lantern diagram themanner
in whichthemosquitofeeds).So far
we
have considered thecor-poreal life of the malarial organism,
that is, the part of its life-cycle which
is passed in the blood of
man,
withthe single exception of that octopus-like
male gamete which,as Ipointedout,only developes afterleaving the
human
body.Turning
now
tothe second,orextra-corpo-realstageofitslifehistory
—
i.e.,that stagewhich, as
we
now
know,is passedin themosquito
—
we
find that there are reallytwo forms ofcell developed
amongst
theorganisms, one the octopus-like
male
gamete, the other a spherical cell.
Now,
itisonlywhen
the Anophelestakesinbloodcontaining parasites at, orabout
this particularstageofdevelopment, that it becomes infected with malaria, and
capableof conveying it to fresh
human
beings, a fact which accentuates the im-portance of protecting malarial patients
by
means
of mosquito nets whereverpossible.
Having
taken in the blood,however, by
means
of the complicated sucking apparatus, which I have de-scribed, the gametes develop into thesexual form,
and
the true function ofthe male's loose
arm
becomes evidentsinceitjoins with a sphericalcellformed
byanother gamete, and impregnates it.
It
was
thefemale gamete whichitwas
insearchof
when
it cast loose.Then
the fer-tilised cellorzygote attachesitself tothestomach wall of the mosquito, boresits
way
through,growsgreatlyinsize,andpro-ceeds to divide into a great
number
oftiny cells. It becomes a cyst,
which
finally bursts and sets free the tiny structureswithin,which havemeanwhile
developed, andthese, set free inthe body
cavity,settleingreatpart in the
veneno-salivary gland at the base of the
pro-boscis, as tiny thread-like bodies,termed
zygotoblasts or sporozoits.
The
glandin which they lie is that
which
secretes the irritating substance ofwhich
we
allknow
the effects incon-nection with a mosquito bite, and ia
the caseof an infected Anopheles, they
are injectedwith this secretion along the
proboscis.
The
process for theirde-velopmentinthemosquitotakes about12
days fromthe date ofthemealofinfected
blood, before the threadlike bodies
appearinthe gland. Afterinjection,along
withthe secretion,the sporozoitsinfectthe bloodcorpuscles, growrapidly,
and
breakup
intosporeswhich in time infect fresh corpuscles, until a hugeswarm
ofpara-sites,with alife cycle of either 48or72
hours is produced in the blood.
The
118
6
the fever-producing substances which
produce the
symptoms
ot malaria.I have given but a rough outline of
the process,but it willserveto
show
themain
points of this complicatedlife-history.
It will be seen, however, that the
process of infection by Anopheles is
7iot a simple mechanical transference of
blood from infected to healthy people,
that
human
cases can only infect theAnopheles at a particular stage in the historyoftheparasite in their blood, and,
particularly, that an Anopheles which
does not bear in its poison gland the
thread-likesporesof malariarepresenting the laststageofthe extra corporeal cycle ofthe organism passed wiihin its body
is asharmless asan
empty
gun.It will be readily understood that the
work
ofRoss andhiscolleagues in other partsoftheworld gave ahuge impetus tothe studyofinsect-borne diseases, and it
has borne noble fruit.
The
connectionof Yellow fever with
Havana
is almostproverbial,andtheaverage deathsfromthat disease alonewereover800in each year. Ithas beenestimated that
some
36,000 persons diedofitfrom 1853to1900,and
in addition the islandof
Cuba
andad-joining parts of Brazil acted as an
endemicfocus, whence,atvarious times, the disease spreadto
many
parts of the world,mcluding Spain,Africa, and even England. In 1897, there were 6000deaths fromit in Cuba. In Bio from
1868-1897, 41,726 deaths.
The
SouthernStatesofAmerica have also experienced dreadful visitations from it. "Yellow
Jack"
was
a dreadedname
throughoutSouth America, the
West
Indies, andtheSouthern United States.
With
the open-ingofthePanama
Canal and theconse-quent shortening of the voyage from
theselocalities toAustraliaand the
Far
East,itisvery probable thatYellowfever
will
some
daybeintroducedto this side ofthe world. Threeor fouryearsago,
Aus-tralian sanitarians regarded this
possi-bilitywith
awe
and
foreboding; to-daytheylook
upon
itcertainly as a seriousproblem,butas one which
would
givecomparativelylittle trouble
compared
tothe introductionofa fewcases of small-pox. I willendeavortoexplain
how
thisremarkable change in views has
come
about.
In1900,after the occupation of
Cuba
by the
American
forces, a commissionof four medical
men
was
appointedtoinvestigatethealarming prevalence of
Yellowfever there,and to devise, if
pos-sible,
means
for combating ifc»A
greatdeal ofwork
had
been done by various observersinseekingforthecause of it ;butnothing
was
accuratelyknown,
andtheearlyworkofthecommission, devoted
to the examination of the blood
and
tissues of patients,only served todisproveprevioustheories, and not to discover
anything new. Absolutely nothing
was
apparent in the blood orelsewhere as a result of the
most
careful bacteriological research.The
nextstepwas
toenquireintoitspro-pagation.
Now,
one attack of |Yellowfever safeguards the patient against a
second one,producinga condition of
im-munity, asitiscalled. It
had
been notedthat patients could be safelynursedby
non-immune
nurses, and that patieats dischargedafter anattack did not cause fresh outbreaks of diseasein thosenon-immune
persons theycame
in contactwith. It
was
obviously, therefore, not contagious,nordid the infection persist ina virulent form inthe discharges.The
next matter
was
to settle the disputed questionofthemfectivityofclothing and beddingwhichhad
been in contact withpatients.
To
this end, a small hutwas
erected, verydeficientin ventilation, andspeciallyconstructedso as to maintain a hot moist atmosphere within it.
The
windows
and doors—
please note this—
were carefully screened with fine wire gauze,ofsmall
enough
gauge to prevent the entryofmosquitoes. Into thishouse were piled sheets, blankets, mattresses,pillows, and clothing of all description
from the Yellow fever hospitals,
and
amongt
them, in the bedsand
coveredwith the bedding of patients,
who
hadjustdied ofYellow fever, even wearing
the clothing taken from the bodies, and
stainedwith the bloodand " blackvomit"
discharge, seven
young
non-immune
Americans, including
members
of thecommission,slept twoorthreeat a time
foratotalperiodof sixty-three nights in
all.
Not
a single one of thesenon-im-mune men
developed the disease. Thiseffectuallyprovedthatclothing and
bed-ding alone were incapable of conveying
1
The
nextstepwas
to enquire into the questionof insecttransmission.A
com-mon
domestic mosquito ofCuba
is theStegomyia fasciata, a strikingly
marked
insect ofvoracious habits, and suspicionhad
already attached itselfto it.Both
sexesof itsuckblood, and itis probably
the
most
widely distributed of allmos-quitoes, being found practically all
throughthe tropical world, and also in
many
sub-tropical localities. Twelveplucky
young
Americans, two ofwhom
had
taken part in theexperiments withclothing previouslydescribed,v©lunteered
as subjects. Allthese were living under
exactlythe
same
conditions as scores ofother
non-immune
residentsofthe camp,and
thetwo
I have mentionedhad
beenfree for30 days from their self-imposed
imprisonmentinthe infected clothes hut.
All were deliberately subjected to the
bites ofspecimensof thismosquito,which
had
been previously allowedto bite early cases of Yellowfever. After periods offrom three and a-half to sixdaysfrom
bemg
bitten, ailexcepttwo
developedtrue attacksofYellow fever.One
experiment in the batchwas
of especial interest.A
newly- erectedbuilding
was
divided into two partsby fine-wire screens. In one partwere
let loose 15 infected mosquitoes, and
in theother half, separated only by a
wire screen,
two
non-immune
men
livedand
slept.The
volunteer subject entered the partin which werethe mosquitoesonthreeoccasionsof about twenty minutes
each, and
was
freely bitten oneachoccasion.
On
the fourth day afcerhisvisithedeveloped a severe attack of
Yellowfever, while thetwo
men
inthe partontheotheL'side ofthe gauze screen continuedfor 18 nights to sleep in andbreathe the
common
atmosphere of theroom
without any ill effect. Thiswas
prettyfairevidenceevenfor thescientific
mind
that the mosquitoes were the con-veyors ofthedisease, and subsequentex-periments provedthis to be so beyondall
doubt. \
The
organism which is the actualcause of Yellow fever has not been
discovered, probably because it is so
minute as to escape the highest
powers of the microscope. This is the
more
likely since, as in the case ofmalaria, the injection of blood from an
acute casewillproduce the disease in a
non-immune
subject,but, unlike malaria, thebloodremainssimilarly infective afterithas been passed throughthefinest
Berk-feld filter, thus proving the extreme
minutenessoftheorganism, since such a
filterwill stopthe smallestof
known
bac-teria. Thatit IS not a bacteria, but an organism
more
ofthetypeofthe malarialorganismisvery probable from the fact
that theinfection cannot be obtained by
the mosquitofrom the blood, except in
the first three days of illness, and the
mosquitodoes not
become
capableofin-fectingfreshpersonsuntil12daysor
more
afterithasfedupon
a case at thispar-ticular stage.
The
factthat an outbreakofYellowfevertook a]Jfortnight or so to light upafter the introduction of a case
into alocality
had
longbeen noticed,and
this explained thereasonthereof.Having
obtained these facts, thebattle against Yellow fever
assumed
anew
aspect.Huge
sums
had
been spent during previous years in
indiscriminate disinfecting of articles
which
had
been in contact withYel-low fever patients—quite harmless as
we
now know
—
and in other expensivemeasures, absolutely without avail.
The
campaign was
now
begun by awholesaledestruction of mosquitoes and their
breeding places in
swamps
and puddles,and
by the careful screening ofYellow fever patients for the three
firstdangerousdays,from mosquito bite inorderto prevent the loadingup offresh
wingedcarriers of disease. Quarantine
of cases
was
givenup—
ithad
beenen-forced for
many
years without avail,—
and
the only quarantine orderwas
thatof the mosquito net.
The
resuUwas
amazing. Inninetydays from the
com-mencement
of operationsHavana
was
freed from Yellow feverfor thefirsttime
in 140 years. Repeated introductions
from without, where the measure?
were not in force and where Yellow
fever
was
raging unchecked, as ithad
donefor decades pastatthatseason,were promptly stampedout, and the fact
was
realised that although every effortknown
to sanitary sciencehad
beenputforthwithout avail
up
toMarch,1901, thechangeeffected in the measures bythe recognition of the mosquito as
the carrying agent
had
enabled theau-thorities to obtain in 13 weeks a
120
8
more
than ten times asmany
years.Epidemics of Yellow fever, thanks to
those able
and
heroicAmerican
doctors,area thingof thepast in civilised
coun-tries,and the
name
of Dr. Lazear,who
contracted the diseaseand died of it dur-ing the enquiry,anotherof the
numerous
martyrs
whom
science has claimed, willalways occupy an honored place in
the scrollofhygienic fame.
I willnotdo
more
thangivetheoutlines ofcertain otherwork
which has been car-ried out in this direction.The
recent investigationswhich have beenmade
intoSleeping sickness
—
that strange diseasewhich
overwhelms
its victims withan increasing languor and somnolence
until they perishof an apparentfailure
of all the faculties—has received a
good deal of notice in the press.
The
researches of Dr. Castellani, Dr.
Bruce,and others, go to
show
that theconveyingagentin thiscaseisthe Tsetse
fly, previously well
known
forthe fatal effects of its bite on horses andcattle, but only lately
known
to beconnected with disease in
human
beings.The
mortalityfrom Sleeping sickness in certainpartsofAfricahas been alarming,and whole districts have been decimated byitsravages.
The
causativeagentappearstobeaformoforganism
known
as atry-panosome, or,as itshould be
more
cor-retly termed, a herpetomonas, whichlivesintheblood andfluids ofthe victim.
Further
work
yet requires to be done,but little doubt remainsthat the curious
andfatal diseasewhich almost invariably
kills its victim, and which has been
known
asa scourge ofWesternAfricaforover100 years, has been brought within thegrasp of science,andwillbedealtwith
as effectually asmalariaand Yellow fever
arebeingdealtwith.
Whether
theorgan-ism undergoes a part of its life history within the Tsetse fly's body is not yet
definitely settled by actual observation,
butitseemsprobable thatitdoesso.
The
presenceofplagueinAustralia ren-dersits causation andspread amatterofperhaps
more
acuteinterestthantheexotic diseases with whichIhave beendealing.The
causativeagent is,of cour«e, awell-known
bacillus, but themeans
wherebyitishabituallyconveyed to
human
beingsto infectthem
have beenwidely discussedamongst scientific
men,
and there is agrowing tendency onthe partofthose
who
have to deal with this diseasetoregard
more
andmore
suspiciously a certaininsect which already possesses an evil
reputation in domestic sanitation; I
allude to theflea.
A
good deal ofwork
has been done on these insects of late
years, andit
may
surprise you to learn thatmore
than 130 distinct species of fleahave been classified, and that
new
onesare
coming
into knowledgemonth
aftermonth.
Eemarkable
differences arefound in their structure and habits,
but in the particular connection with which
we
have to considerthem
to-night, one genus attains prominence
—
the true pulicesof which thetypeisthe
human
flea.Now,
in considering the histories ofplagueoutbreaks in different partsof the world, one is at once struckbya curious
fact, namely, that while preceding or
simultaneous outbreaks of the disease
amongst rats and other small rodents,
haveformed a
marked
feature ofplagueepidemics in the East, nothing of the
kind has attracted the attention of the chroniclersof the
European
outbreaks ofthemiddleages,
and
of the greatplagueof
London
in 1665.The phenomenon
isstrikingenoughto attract the attention of
any
ordinary observerwhereitoccurs,andasignificant allusion toitistobefoundin
theFirst
Book
ofSamuel. Other and evenmore
definite allusions occur scatteredthrough Eastern literature from a very
early date,so that it appears tohave
attracted attention, and could scarcely
haveescaped the acute chroniclers
who
have left us such a vivid picture of
medieval andseventeenth century plague.
Itisneedlesstoremind youthatthe
same
phenemenon
occurs in Australia andinSouth Africa at the present day.
The
domesticrats of the East, of Australia,
and SouthAfricaareverysimilar tothose
ofEurope, andall readilycontract plague
when
infected experimentally.But
on examination of their parasitesa curiousfact
was
noticed in that thecommon
rat fleas of Australia, of India, andofSouthAfricaare widely different insects from
the
common
rat flea of Europe,bothinstructure and habits.
They
are veryclosely allied to the
human
flea, soclosely, infact, that iheir relative identi-ficationis a matter of extreme difficulty,
without previous acquaintance with the
varieties,will,on ooeasiots, aoli as para^
sites to
man, and
will bite vigorously.The
common
European
rat flea, orcera-tophyllusfa8ciatu8,ontheotuerhand,differs
inimportant structural respects,and can, only with greatdifficulty,beinducedtofeed
on
man.
Does
it not appear to besomething
more
than a coincidence thatwherewe
find a ratflea closely allied to thehuman
flea,therewe
have plagueamongst ratsas well as
man,
whereas inplaces where the ratflea varies widely
from the
human
flea the occurrence ofepidemicrat-plagueis,atany rate,notan important
phenomenon.
The
theorywas
for long held that the plague baccilus lives and multiplies inthe earth, but out of innumerable
at-tempts at its recovery from the earth-floors of plague-infectedEastern hovels,
iiot a single success has resulted under
natural conditions.
As
in the case ofYellow fever,it hasbeen stated to have beenspread byinfectedclothing. It
pro-bablyis sospread,but in
some
otherway
thanthe
mere
bacillaryinfection of suchclothing, for theplaguebacillushas never beenrecoveredfrominfectedclothing,
un-less in cases of grossexperimental
con-tamination. Plague is particularly a
disease oflocality, and especiallytendsto infect those
who
sleep insucha locality,sparing those
who move
activelyaboutduringtheir visits andsleep or rest
else-where. Itchooses dark, squalid, vermin-hauntedvicinities, andavoids to a great extentairy, well-litplaces.
The
experienceof plague hospitals is a curious one, for whilst, inancient days,evena short visit
toa pest-house
was
attended with great danger,it is rare for an attendant in amodern
plague-hospital to be attacked.Thatthe diseaseitselfhasnot variedfrom
ancienttimes
we
know
from contemporaryrecords, but whilst the
modern
hospital isespecially builtwitha viewto cleanli-ness, lightand airiness, the ancienthos-pitals
seem
to havecombmed
all the hygienicoffences ofitsday.To
sum
upwe
havecertain facts which
seem
to pointin a particular direction. Plague does not,apparently, thrive in the soil,nor is it
known
toenterthebodywith thefood, inhuman
cases at least. In the ordinaryform—
excluding plaguepneumonia—
itenters by the skin, and in thebubonic
form itcertainlyentersinthe lymphatic
area drained by the first affected
gland, Wfttei? play* no parfc ia
its dissemination. Meteorological
fac-tors have no influence except in
one significant indirect instance—that
inIndia the plague mortalityisnoticed to rise materially after a cold night, or a
heavyfallof dew, and especially after rains during the dry season,
whereby
peopleare driveninto their
homes
insteadofsleeping outside asusual. Clothing is
apparently capable of conveying the
disease; but thebacillusis not
recover-ablefromclothing.
And
lastly, amarked
associationof the rat with plague
out-breaks has been noticed since remote
periods inpartsoftheworld where the
rat flea closelyresemblesthe
human
flea,and no such association where the rat
fleashows,at anyrate atthe present day,
widestructural differencesfromthe
human
flea.
This circumstantial evidenca appears
to incriminate the insect, but
circum-staniial evidence is not enough. Dr.
Simond, in 1897,
had
proved thatby infecting into a
mouse
broth inwhich fleas had been emulsified, after
having fed on a plague-stricken animal,
plague could be produced in that
mouse. This experiment
was
success-fullyrepeatedonseveral occasionsby
my-self
and
others,and
the results obtainedwere sufficiently encouraging toinduce
further work. Fleas of certain species
werefedonplague-infected animals,
and
aftervarying periods of starvation wereallowedto bitehealthyrats under
condi-tions which excluded any probability qf
the disease being contracted otherwise
than byfleabite. These rats died of un-deniable plague,andit
was
foundthat thefleacouldconveyplaguein this.
way
upto at leastthreedaysafteramealofinfected blood. Thereisno reason
why
itshouldnotdoso forvery
much
longer. Itwas
foundthatinone case, at least, this
con-veyancefrom rat to rat
was
effected by ahuman
flea. In other cases the rat-pulexwas
used.A
further experimentwas
performedin whichplague
was
conveyed from ahuman
beingtotworatsbymeans
offleas. Thislatter experimentwas
of especial significance, since, onsubse-quent examination, it
was
found that while threeof the insects used for thepurpose werethe pulex palladus of rats,
one
was
a pulex irritans, orhuman
flea.1*
10
meal of infected blood, and examining
them
undera microscope, largenumbers
of bacilli indistinguishable from plaguebacilli intheirmicroscopical
characteris-tics,were foundin apeculiarorgan form-ing a partoftheoesophagus;whileinfleas,
which
had
beenfedon healthy blood, no suchbacilli werefound.The work which
I have alludedtowas
performedinIndiacertainly with allthe
facilities ofone of the biggest bacterio-logicallaboraties in theworld,butwithout
much
assistancefrom special literatureonthesubject, forthe verygood reason that
none existed to indicate the technical
difficultiestobeovercome.
As you
may
readilyimagine, these were considerable,
for tosecuresuch an active and minute
creatureasthefleainsuch a
manner
as toallowitto feed, and yettoensure that itshould not getaway
afteritsdangerousmeal
of plague infected blood,was
anoperationofnolittle difficulty, and also of
some
danger, bothtothe experimenter and to hisneighbors. After a good dealof trial, the device
was
hitupon
ofconfining
them
in a glass tube—
anordinarytesttube
was
used—
and
coveringtheopenend with a cap of finegauze,
through the
meshes
of whichthefleacould protrudeitsproboscis,but could not escape. This difficulty overcome, it
was
necessary to find
some
distinguishingmarks
by which to identify the speciesused. This
was
affected after atime, andthefew species employed were
readily
enough
identified.The
habitualspread of plague by fleas ofthetypeIhaveshown you
isnot to betakenasa universally accepted fact, but
strong evidence exists that this will
eventually prove to be, at anyrate, an importantfactor in epidemics.
You
may
recollectanallusionmade
tothework
ofDr.,now
Sir,PatrickManson,
m
relation to certain bloodworms,
whichare fairly
common
amongsthuman
beingsinthe tropics.
No
lessthanfivedifi'erentkindsof these
worms
areknown,
andone inparticular, the filaria nocturna, so called because it is only found in the blood during sleeping hours, is of par-ticular interest, in thatit causesa good
deal of illness by blocking up the
deli-cate lymphatic ducts, andisalmost cer-tainly in this
way
the cause of that strange disease elephantiasis. Filariaeoccur amongst other tropical and
subtropical places in Queensland and
Northern Australia to about the
lati-tude of Brisbane, and the
manner
inwhich the filaria noctutna completes
its Hfe cycle is of interest.
The
parent female
worm
issome
4inlong, and lives in
some
part of thelymphaticsystem, in
company
withthemale, which is slenderer and smaller.
There she produces a great
number
ofembryos, which
make
iheirway
intotheblood, and live during, the day in the
vessels of the internal organs.
About
5.or6 p.m.,ininfectedpersons
who
dotheirsleeping at night,they begin to appearin
gradually increasing
numbers
in theperi-pheralcirculation, or vessels in the ex-tremities and at the surface, increasing tillaboutmidnight, and thendecreasing,
untilabout8 or 9 in the morningthey
have alldisappearedfrom the peripheral blood for the day. It is acuriousfact
that in infected persons,
who
dotheirsleeping during the day and remain
awake
at night, the embryos reverse the timeof their appearance, and turn upduring the day in the peripheralvessels,
disappearing at night.
Each embryo
isabout l*80in long, and is containedin a loosesheath or sack
somewhat
longerthanitself.
They
are very active organ-isms, andwriggle about strongly,but thesheathkeeps
them
from changingtheirposition
much
; in other words, theyarenot locomotory.
The
function ofthe sheath is to keep
them
fromusing the strong boring apparatus which theyhave ontheir heads, and so
escap-ing from the blood vessels.
As
I havesaid, they appear in the surface blood
vessels at night as a rule, and this is obviouslyfortheconvenience of the
con-veyingmosquito,which principally feeds atnight, and into
whose
stomachsome
oftheembryos
are takenwith the mealofblood.
The
ordinarymosquito soact-ingisaspecies ofCulex,andinitsstomach
the blood becomes
much
thickerbyco-agulation.
The embryo
within thesheath is thus able to get a purchaseonthesheath, and eventually to
ram
itsway
outthrough one end by butting
vigor-ously while the sheath is stuck fast in
the thickened blood. Of course, while
theblcodwasfluid in the
human
host's vessels, it could not do this because thesheath could only be
bumped
along by11
Onee loose it bores through the
stomach wallof the mosquito, gets into
the muscles, and changes its formvery
considerably. Finally, after
some
16days,
h
appears in the head andpro-boscis,notinthepoison glandsas didthe
sporozoites of malaria, but coiled
up
under the pharynx and in that part of
the proboscis
known
asthe labium.They
can remainherefor an indefinite period
awaiiing the chance to pass into the
tissues of a warm-blooded vertebrate
when
ibemosquitolakesitsnext mealof blood. Apparentlytheycandiscriminate,forno
amount
offeeding oftheinsect on banauas or other fruit (upon which itordinarily subsists, will cause
them
tocome
out.When,
however, the insectticks its proboscis into a
human
being thefiiariaefind theirway
throughaweak
spot which exists in the labium where
the labellae splay out, and pass along thetrackoftheproboscis into thetissues of the victim.
The
filariae apparentlyendeavor to emerge in pairs, male and
female,andupon establishingthemselves
intbetissues of iheir
new
host, they setup
housekeeping, and begin again theprocess of which
we
know
the resultsundfir ibe
name
of the filariasis, be it€leph**Diiasisorany ofthe other peculiar
conditions by which
we
recognise theblockios of the lymphatic channels by
their offspring.
I trust that I have been able to give
some
indication of the verypromi-nent part played by certam insects
in certain exotic diseases, but there is
little doubt that they also assist in
disseminating others which are with
us already.
The
ordinary house fly isubiquitousinitshabitsand unpleasantin his historyand associations. That it
is capable of conveying on its feet
and body the germs of disease under
experimental conditionshas been
demon-strated and thatitfrequently does so innatureis freelyadmitted. In a
more
en-lightened age the housewife will regardflies wirb the
same
horror and disgust asshe
now
regards bugs and fleas,and most thinking folk will even
now
cordiallyagreewith herintheoryifnotin
practice.
From
the time inwhich it isengendered in a heapof
manure
to thefatefulhour in which it
commits
suicide inthe milkjug,or perishes inthe stickyrecessesofthe
summer
butterpat,thelifeof the average fly ispassed amidst
more
than questionable surroundings. Its
ubiquity renders the whereabouts of its
last alightingplace a subjectfor
uncanny
speculation
when
it settles on an article of food, and I have little doubt thatdomestic flies, so-called, are responsible
for afairproportionofcasesof
communi-cabledisease, especiallyperhapsoftyphoid
fever. Itspossibilities, however, do not
end there; exanthematous diseases,
especially perhaps smallpox,
may
bereadilyconceivedasspreadbythismeans.
I confessin fact toadoubtas to whether
therealcauseofthe aerial convection of
smallpoxisnot partly or wholly due to insectlife.
Many
pointsin the availableevidence
upon
itappeartorender such ahypothesistenable,and
£y
proof doorand
windows
coverings should certainly forma partofthefurnishing of isolation
hos-pitals for this disease.
The
possibilities of this line of researchare, however,boundless, and in time to
come
the labors of tbe biologistand
naturalist will
become
of luore andmore
importance fromthestandpointof
human
disease.The
extension of research inconnection with cancer in the lower
animalshas resultedinitsdiscovery in a
large
number
of creatures,includingevenfish. Similarresultshave been obtained
with the tubercle bacillus,
whose
rangeappearstobepracticallyuniversal.
The
diseases ofwhichIhave spoken tonightdo notby
any
means
include all thoseinrespect ofwhichinsectsare
known,
orsuspected,toplayan important or
essen-tialpart, but theywill serve as illustra-tions ofthe pioneering
work
which hasbeen, andis dailybeingdone by
many
in-vestigators in differentparts of theworld
for the benefit of