http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/91768/ Version: Submitted Version
Article:
Baird, Benjamin, Cieslak, Matthew, Smallwood, Jonathan orcid.org/0000-0002-7298-2459 et al. (2 more authors) (2015) Regional White Matter Variation Associated with
Domain-specific Metacognitive Accuracy. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience. pp. 440-452. ISSN 0898-929X
https://doi.org/10.1162/jocn_a_00741
[email protected] https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/ Reuse
Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record for the item.
Takedown
If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by
For Review Only
! "# $ " % & % '
# ( ) & % * $+ * , #
-+ % ./ 0 1 ) ) + ! * " + # )
2 % $ * !
!# . $+ %
3 ) + ! / 0 1 ) ) + ! * " + # )
2 % $ * !
! % + % / 0 1 ) ) + ! * " +
4 . $ + # -
For Review Only
!" #
$"
% &
' ( )
% & * + , "
' + (
-. / ( % &
0 ' ( ) ( . 12 34 1443
- /) 5 " )" 3
For Review Only
! ) 6
7 8 9 " .
: )
)
" &
) (
)
" !
) ) )
" $ : )
8 )
" $
) "
8(
8
) " ! ( 8
)
) "
For Review Only
7 "
! ) ; ) ( 7 ) ( 7
( 7 ( 7
< 6! = ( 33>( " 9 )
) 6 = (
11>9" )
( ( ) )
)
6? ( % ( = ? ( 3 @ A = ) ( 3 9" B (
) (
)
6 9 6? ( B ( = % 3 9"
% (
) 6 " "(
= ) ( 33>@ ( 33 9"
8 C )
6# CC = D % 8( 1EF@ B ( ( !G ( H ( = % ( 3 3@
( B ( H ( = A ( 33I@ , ) = $ ( 1EE9" ? 8 (
) )
6, ) = $ ( 1EE9" A :
7 "
A 6 ) 9 8
(
8 8
6 ( # (
( ( = ( 331@ ( ( = B ( 33>@
"( 3 @ ( ( = ( 33F9"
!
" 8
6 ( ( # ( = ( 3 2@
? ( $ ( , ( % ( = ( 3 3@ "( 3 29" !
8
( &? 6 ? = % ( 3 9"
B ( : )
) )
" A ( )
; < ) &? ) )
( 6 "( 3 9" A
For Review Only
( ) ) &?
( ) )
8
6, = , ( 113@ ( 3339"
&
( ) ) "
? ( C
) (
C
6% ( ( $ ( = # ( 3 @ ( J
) ( % ( ( = ( 3 9" ? (
)
) ) " (
7
) " " 6 3 29
&?
( " ? (
" 6 3 29
) "
) &? 8 6 . 9
(
) &?
) 6K&D9"
K ( ) )
)
" $ :
" $ 6% K9 6
"( 33E@ $ ( B ( ! ( ( = $ ( 33I9 8
)
" 8 ) )
(
6?.9( )
) ) : ) 6 (
L H ( = ! ( 3 29" ( %!K
) ) )
) 6. 8 ( B ( D C ( ! ( = & ( 33 @
A "( 33E@ J ( ( J ( = D ( 3 9" K (
% K ) (
8 )
) "
) ( C
)
For Review Only
"
? 8 6 3 ( M F >E (
M "I 9" ?
8 ) / )
( ) N. (
) % K "
) (
) ' (
) ( ) " . 6, M 2F9
(
"
.!D. E"1 6! K "(
, ( .( ' .9 & ! ) 8 2"3 6 ( 11E@
L "( 33E9"
8 # ) 8
4"I 6? .9" - ) "F
) :
" 3O"
8 43 "
2 3
6 9 & )
6$ ( 1FF9" . I :
) F33 "
& 8 /
6 K9 % K 6% K9 :
)
" .
? " ! ) "
! ? " 6 3 39 " 6 3 9"
- 6,M2 39 I3
8 # ) 8 ( )
6K K9 I33 8
( ) I3 8 # )
8 6? .9" K (
# ) 8 " !
; < # )
" ! # )
For Review Only
6? "( 3 3@ D ( 1E 9
E3O " !
) 63" I
9(
) " ? (
# ) " &
6 9 4 6 9
6? "( 3 39" . ) ) "
! / "
) (
) " % (
43 2 3
: " $ I33
) K K 333 8 " %
( 6 9(
" &
6 9 4 6 9" .
) ) "
6 %!9 6# = ( 1449
( : )
)
) ) " .
6; KK<9 KK
6; K<9 6 " "( # ( & (
% ( = $ ( 3329" ! KK 7 )
) ( K
7 ) ) 6 " "(
9 6 (
( = ! ( 1I1@ B ( & ( = ( 3319" %!
: ) 7
) ( )
) 6? = D ( 3 >@ = D ( 3 9"
: ? " 6 3 39"
( )
) K
KK 6 A 9 " ! KK A
) ) 7
" ! A ( 6 M P 9 6 M P
9 (
) ) 8( A 6?
For Review Only
"( 3 3@ # "( 332@ L ) ( 3349" A Q3(3R
Q ( R" ! KK A ) ) )
" . A 8
) ( A
) "
$ KK A ) (
A ) ) ( KK
6L ) ( 3349" ! KK A 6 9
)
K " ! K 6 79 MC6B9 C6?.9( C
) B M 6 M P
M 9 ?. M 6 M P M 9"
N :
8 K " . )
%!
KK ) ) 6 = D ( 3 @
"( 3 29" ! ) 6
= D ( 3 9" ( 8 ) K KK %!
8 ) KK K %!
6 9" 8 6 D-9
K %! ) ) KK
" . ) K
) K /
M " !
: %! )
C ; < ; < K ) : "
B ( *
6 ( $ 8 ( = $ ( 33E@ ( 1F49" $
: %! ( K C A
K ) 6 9
( " ! K
6 79 7MC6B9 C6?.9( C
) B M 6 M P M 9 ?. M
6 M P M 9"
% K ! 2"3 ! !
! : ' (
) K " % K IE 8
) I333 8 C "> 6.8 : ( )3 ( !
M "> ( !- M 2F ( I ( ?AJ M 2 S 2 S 2 9"
( ! :
& .#- : 6! M 233 @ !- M "1F @ M 1T@ ?AJ M I4
@ : 8 C M S S " 9"
! "! #
For Review Only
% K % K 6 " " ) " 9 :
6N % 9 6+ = ! ( 3 9" ! :
C 7 % K
6 %? 9 " , C )
? K
6? K 9 6? D( A8 ( 'L9
% K 6. ) = ? ( 1119" #
) 6+ ( ! ( = ! (
3 29" . ) "4( " N %
% K ) 8 ) (
) " N % " I
) 8 "
% ) = # 6 3 29
% K " ! IIT( C "3 (
3 ( 3"3 ( 8 >33 N.
) %$K ?" ! ?. !
33(333
" )
" K ) 8 I
"
" $#
! ? 6% (
? ( = ( 111@ ? = % ( 333@ ? ( D ( = % ( 33 @ ? "(
33 @ ? ( ( "( 33>@ ? ( ( = % ( 111@ ? ( ( ! ( =
% ( 111@ ? ( L ( "( 33>@ B "( 334@ "( 334@
"( 33>9" . )3 !
6 9 6# = ? ( 3319" .
6B "( 33F9"
! D 33F 22 6F2 9 )3
) U % K " ! )3 ,K 8 N %
) ,K "
) > * ) "
% 6 = # ( 3 29"
%& " #
! 8 ) )
(
% K / C 6#?.9 : 6N.9"
! 8 6?.9
6%!K9( ) 8
( ( 8 (
) 6 " "( L "( 33E@ L ) "( 33I9" D ?. 6 " "( 9(
" B ( ) ( ?.
) ) %!K (
For Review Only
6 " "( = ( 33>9" ( ?.
) ) *
8 ?( 6. 8 (
B ( D C ( ! ( = & ( 33 @ A "( 33E@ J ( ( J ( =
D ( 3 9" #?. 8 ?.
)
6! ( 33>9" #?. ) )
: %?" K ?. )
C ) 6 . ( % 8( = $ ( 3 9"
' ( #?. 6? C (
D ( C ( = ( 3 3@ + ( J ( $ ( ? V C ( = ! (
3 29" N 6N.9( (
%? 6+ ( $ ( = ! ( 3 39" N. )
) ) %?
) 6+ "( 3 39" K ( 8 N.
) 8 " N. )
( ) ) : 6+ "( 3 2)9"
- ) 8
?. "
#?. N. N % %? ,K "
6 "( 3 29 C
) (
) )
" ! 6$ 9( $
8 ? ( ) 8 ( ,K
N % "
) "1 $ " N.
#?. > 8 6?$B 9
# "
#D & F
6$ ! % K , ( ' D 9" ?
) N. #?.( 8
" C
W
3"33I C W 3"3I 6?$- 9"
6 9 (
C 6 ?!9 6B ( & (
D ) C ( $ ( = , ( 33>@ $ ( . ( L ( % ( =
- ( 1119" $ 8 (
( ?!
, ) 8
6 /** " ) " * * X, 9" .
For Review Only
6 "( 33I9" ? D7
? K IFY?.Y K
6 /** " ) " * * * " 9"
' &
K ) ( 6,M> 9
)
) ) 6? 9 6? "( 3 3@ "( 3 29" !
E3O
6? "( 3 3@ D ( 1E 9" .
) 6 M 3"E3E(
! M 3"3 ( M 3"4E 3"E29" A (
6 M 3"41( !M 3"3F( M 3"IF 3"129"
. 8 !
) 6
M 2>"EI( W "33 @ M 2"E4( M 3">39 6 M F">I( W "33 @ M >"21( M 3" E9(
" A (
6 M >"3 ( ! M 3"I19 6 M 2" E(
! M 3"149 Q 6> 9 M I"2 ( W "33 R( ) )
"
6 6> 9 M 3"> ( W "3 9" !
6 "( 3 2@ ? "( 3 @ "( 3 9
)
"
6 %!9 6# = ( 1449 :
) 6; KK <9@ : )
6
9" %! ) : KK
K 6 9
" . ) )
6 9 6 9 K
6 / 6>39 M 3"3E( M 3"4E@ / 6>39 M 3" 1( M 3"349" . (
6 6>39 M 3" ( M 3">19(
" %! )
) (
) " .
6 9
For Review Only
6 9 6 6>39 M 3" I( M 3"2>9(
) 6? 9" !
) 6 9(
" ! 6 6>39 M
3"3E( M 3"4>9( )
) ) )
) " !
8 ) 8 6 "( 3 2@
( C ( & ( = ( 3 >9" B (
( )
8 " ! (
2I " K
) ) 6 6 229 M
3"3I( M 3"IE9"
%& &
$ 8 ) 6
9 ) " . ? 2.
! ) ( 6 9
C
8 6. 9 6 W "3I( ?$- @ 8 W "33I9"
, ) ) : " .
? 2 ! ) ( 6 9
: 8
) 6K&D9 6 W "3I( ?$- @
8 W "33I9" , ) )
C " . ( )
) ( )
) "
$ ) 8 K&D
. " ? (
(
6 ! "! # 9" $
) E3O
" . ? > (
. 2 /
6 ?#9 . ( ?# ?#(
?# . " . ? >)( K&D
3 / K&D 6 ?#9( K&D
( K&D ( K&D
( K&D (
K&D ( K&D ) (
For Review Only
(
( "
6 "( 3 2@ "( 3 >9(
(
) " ! )
6% "( 3 @& = L C ( 33I@ "( 33>@ "( 3 9"
? (
" )
C
8 6. 9(
) :
8 ) 6K&D9 " ! (
8 )
6 "(
3 29 6 "( 3 29"
! .
)
&? 6 9 . (
&? &? ( &? . " !
) 8(
&? (
6 9 6 ( ( = (
3319" ! )
.
)
&? 8 6 . 9 6 "(
3 29" ! )
. ( )
&? .
6? "( 3 9" .
%!K )
) &?
6? "( 3 39" $ ) )
) (
)
) &? (
"
For Review Only
K ( )
8
K&D " ! )
K&D 6 " "( (
( # ( = ( 334@ ( ( = ( 331@ - (
L ( ( J ( = ( 3 9" ? (
( * (
) )
6 " "( "( 334@ "( 3319" ( K&D
6L = ) C ( 33E@
$ = ( 33>9 ; <
6- "( 3 9" ? (
6%
"( 33F@ ( & ( C C( ( = A ( 3 39" !
) )
&? ( 6 ?#9 K&D 6 "( 3 29" !
K&D
?#( ) (
"
. (
7
"
$ 8 ( )
" ! ) )
( )
6? C % : ( ( = & ( 333@ ? = % ( 3 9" K (
)
6 C "( 3 9(
.
6 "( 3319 6 (
' ( ( = , ( 33> 9" K )
)
. 6 "( 3 2@ ? "( 3 9(
" !
) ? " 6 3 9 ? = %
6 3 9 )
6 ( . 9 &? (
) "
K ( )
(
6, = , ( 1139" . ) (
For Review Only
: )
K&D )
6 " "( "( 334@ "( 331@ - "( 3 @
L = ) C ( 33E@ $ = ( 33>9" $
( K&D
6 ) C ( ( A ( = ( 33F@
A = ( 331@ $ ( ( L ( = ( 33I9" ? ( K&D
)
6$ "( 33I9(
) 6 ( 333@ J ) = ( 33F@ J ) ( ( = (
3349( ) 8 6. (
( L ( & ( = ( 33F9" . (
8 K&D
) ) K&D
) ( ( "
? )
"
. ) ( )
8
) 8 6 "( 3 2@ (
C ( & ( = ( 3 >9" ? (
)
6,M 2I9 )
) " $
( )
)
) " . ) (
( 6 "( 3 29
) " .
) ( 8 ) "
" 6 3 29
) )
( ) "
B ( ( "
) ) ) "
A ) ) ) )
" ? 8 ( 8
" . (
" 6 .? 9
8 * (
)
6 ( ( = B ( 33I9" ! ( " .?
) ( .?
* " $
(
For Review Only
) ( " K )
8
K )
) C ) "
. ( " 6 3 29
" 6 3 29 :
( )
) " ! )
(
)
( 8
) "
K ( ) )
( ) ) )
K 6? (
% ( % )) ( = ) C ( 3349"
K ( )
( )
6 "( 3 29" !
6 ) ) : 9
"
,
" ! ) N.
#?. ( 8 ".
)
" . (
: "? ( #?. N. )
6 " "( 9(
#?. N. )
) 6+ "( 3 2)9"
For Review Only
$ & ( C ( C
"$
, K D/ , ? - 6% 3I29 , ?
, 31432 4" " " ) , ? #
? # , " %#- 3E3E>23" ! )
'" " % - # 23I. 3 EE " $" " !
'" " # (
) "
For Review Only
. 8 ( ." D"( B ( L" "( D C ( "( ! ( " "( = & ( %" D" 6 33 9"
. K"
( )*6I9( EE3 EF3"
. ( " ."( ( " "( L ( " %"( & ( &" J"( = ( ." -" 6 33F9"
& ) /
"+ & ( ),6E9( F33 F "
. B ( " "( ( " "( ( "( & ( "( = ( " D" 6 3 39"
? ) U "+ ( ,*6>9(
II3 I4 "
. ) ( "( = ? ( L" " 6 1119" , C )
"- ( .6>9( I> 44"
( ." 6 3339" ! ) / Z
/ ( )6 9( > E > 2"
( "( ( "( # ( L" "( = ( %" " 6 3 29"
D , . & 8 .)
& " & 0 + ( 116> 9( 44IE 444I"
( "( C ( "( & ( %" !"( = ( " $" 6 3 >9" %
) "0
23 & 4 5 6
( !" "( = ( " ." 6 33>9"
) "+ ( 776 9( >F >1 "
( "( ( B"( = ( " ?" 6 3319" )
8 C "
& 0 + ( 786>9( EI 13"
( %" B" 6 11E9" ! & ! ) 8" 9 ( $:6>9( >22 >24" ( " D"( . B ( " "( = ( %" D" 6 33F9" ! ) U
/ ( ( " + ; ( $$7)(
2F"
) C ( "( ( -"( A ( K" "( = ( " 6 33F9" ! 8
/ "+ < + ( 86F9(
4 2 4 I"
( L"( # ( ." "( ( "( ( "( = ( " $" 6 3319"
-8 K 8
) " + ( 346 9( FE 1 FE >"
( -" ?"( ( %" D"( # ( -"( = ( " ." 6 3349"
' / ,
) "+ ( 78( I3
43"
( -" ?"( ( %" D"( = ( " ." 6 3319" , /
"0
/ + ( 7$619( EI E4I"
( "( = # ( " !" 6 3 >9" D /
"' & (=6 9( 1 11"
For Review Only
( ?" "( ( !" #"( = ! ( $" 6 1I19" ! A
" & 0 & ( 1$6I9(
4 1 423"
. ( "( % 8( "( = $ ( D" D" 6 3 9" N
) N )
"0 ( 116I9( 1> 3F"
% ( ." "( ? ( "( = ( " K" 6 1119" ) " K" "+ ( 86 9( E1 1>" % ( ." "( ( ,"( $ ( "( = # ( " 6 3 9" ?
" & & &
'4 ' (1,.6 I1>9( 2E1 213"
% ( &" " "( . ( %"( ( -"( ( "( L ( ." " ,"( ( L" "(
" 6 33F9" % 8 Z/
-"+ & ( ),6E9( E>2 EII"
- ( " ."( L ( -" "( ( %" -"( J ( ."( = ( ." &" 6 3 9" ,
"/ ' & + ( $7629( I11 431" ? C % : ( %"( ( " ."( = & ( " K" 6 3339" -8
"/ / ( 86 & 9( FF 23E"
? ( "( = % ( ." " 6 3339" ) 8
" + > ( 8.6 39( 3I3 3II"
? ( "( D ( ."( = % ( ." " 6 33 9" . /
)
8" 222 ( 7:6 9( E3 F3"
? ( "( ( %" B"( ( -"( . ) ( "( % ( "( B ( "( " 6 33 9"
$ ) / )
) "+ ( 11629( 2> 2II"
? ( "( ( %" B"( L ( ." "( ( ,"( ( ?"( N ( " !"( "
6 33>9" : "
+ ( 71 $( 41 F>"
? ( "( ( " K"( = % ( ." " 6 1119" ) " KK/
K ( ( ) "+ ( 86 9(
1I 3E"
? ( "( ( " K"( ! ( " "( = % ( ." " 6 1119" B
) "- '
( =6>9( E F>"
? ( "( L ( ."( % 8( "( B ( -"( ( ?"( ( %" B"( "
6 33>9" . ) 8"/ / 3(
$)6 9( "
? ( " "( % ( " "( % )) ( K" #"( = ) C ( " 6 3349" ) "/ / 3( $,6 9( 4 2 423"
? ( " "( = % ( " " 6 3 9" ! ) ) " &
? ' ' ( 1,.6 I1>9( 22F 2>1"
For Review Only
? ( " "( % ( " "( = ? ( " %" 6 3 9" / ( )
" & & & '4 '
( 24E6 I1>9( F3 F4"
? ( " "( B ( "( = % ( " " 6 3 9" & )
"0 + ( 176 F9( 4 E 4 I"
? ( " "( = D ( B" " 6 3 >9" B "+ 4 @
- + (=( >>2"
? ( " "( $ ( " "( , ( ["( % ( " "( = ( #" 6 3 39"
) " (
1786I11F9( I> I>2"
? C ( L" B"( D ( ?" "( C ( B" &"( = ( " 6 3 39" A
: ) / $ N )
Z+ ( *$6 9( > I "
# ( " "( & ( " J"( % ( J"( = $ ( " 6 3329" !
) / ) "
& ' ( $:6>9( F>2 FE4"
# CC ( " "( = D % 8( " -" 6 1EF9" & " , + / & & "
# ( %" "( = ( " ." 6 1449" & & & / $ " # ( %" ,"( = ? ( " 6 3319" . ) )
) ) "+ ( )=6 9( 42"
B ( D"( ( &"( !G ( "( H ( "( = % ( !" 6 3 39"
/ ) "/ (
E6 9( I> 4 "
B ( &"( ( D"( # ( \"( ( "( B ( " "( $ ( J" "( =
( A" 6 33F9" ) 8" ?
(,6E9( I1"
B ( \"( ( "( ( %"( L ( ."( N ( "( C ( "( " 6 3349"
) K ) /
( "+ (
176 9( F3 1>"
B ( "( & ( L" D"( D ) C ( K"( $ ( L" "( = , ( !" -" 6 33>9"
, C "
+ ( 776 9( 4E4 4FE"
B ( &" ."( & ( !" "( = ( %" 6 3319" K : "0
23 & 4 ? ( ( / ( 1*6 9( IE"
( &"( B ( D"( H ( "( = A ( ." 6 33I9" ?
) " ( 1$:6IE>I9(
4 1"
( %"L"( L H ( !" " = ! ( " 6 3 29" $ ( ) (
/ ! U U K"+ ( .1( 21 I>"
( "( C ( "( # ( %"( B ( -"( L ( ."( # )( "( "
6 3349" ) K /
"+ ( 1:6 9( >24 >>2"
For Review Only
L ( B"( = ) C ( " 6 33E9" ! /
" & 0 + (
7.6>I9( 13 1E"
L ( "( ( %"( & ( %"( K ( ."( ( "( = ( " 6 33E9"
$ 7 & ) 8 2" ( 1,6 >9( " 4"
L ) ( %" -" 6 3349" ( / )
) " & & ( ,=629( 212 > >"
L ( " ?"( ( !"( ( " &"( $ ( " "( ( " ."( = D ( %" "
6 33E9" $ ) /
"' ( $1:6 39( I3F I 1"
L ) ( "( & ( B"( $ ( "( , ( &"( ( "( ( "( " 6 33I9" %!K
! ) C / "
+ ( 7,6>9( 31 F"
D ( B" 6 1E 9" ! " & 0 &
( )8( >4E"
( ,"( L ( %" ,"( K ( "( ( ." #"( $ ( "( ( J" "(
" 6 33I9" )
/ : ( ( %! K "/ / 3( $*649(
FI> F41"
( "( = D ( B" 6 3 9" .
"/ / ( 7$6 9( > >23"
( " #"( % 8 ( "( L ( L"( D ( K"( = ( L" 6 3 9" K
8 K
"+ ( II629( 1F 23I"
( D" +"( ( "( ( "( D ( L" +"( D ( ?" &"( = D ( B"
6 3 29" . ) %
J & " & 0 + ( 116I9( F1E 134"
( " -"( = ( ." &" 6 11>9" 4 A < < / ! K! & "
( "( J ) ( " \"( % ( &"( ( &"( = ( ." L" 6 3 9"
C /
" & & & '4 '
(1,.6 I1>9( 21 >33"
C ( "( ( %" L"( ( "( $ ( D"( . ( " &"( = AU ( " " 6 3 9"
" & 0 + ( 176>19(
E4 E4 1"
( D"( $ 8 ( " !"( = $ ( &" -" 6 33E9" . :
" & ' ( $)6I9( FIF F4I" ( !" $" "( )( %" -"( ( " %"( $ ( B" "( ( -" "( =
D ( " " 6 33I9" - 8 8
8 8 ) )
) C "+ ( 7=629( I>> II "
, ( !" A"( = , ( D" 6 1139" / .
" & & ( 7,( I > "
For Review Only
, ) ( " -"( = $ ( !" %" 6 1EE9" ! / J )
" & <( =)629( 2 "
A ( L"( [ ( L"( . ( L"( ? ( ."( ( B"( D ( \"( """ = ( " 6 33F9"
B ) /
"+ ( >2629( >>E >IE" A ( K" "( = ( " 6 3319"
) "+ ( 8$6 9(
II 4I"
A ( B"( + ( L"( ( L"( L C ( A"( L ) ( !"( K ( B"( " 6 33E9" %
) ) 8 C /
) " 0
+ ( 7=649( 3 34"
A ( "( = ) ( L" 6 3 9" L /
" & & &
'4 ' ( 24E6 I1>9( FE 14"
& ( " L"( = L C ( ." $" 6 33I9" 8
/ "+ & ( $*629( 3I 23"
( L" "( ' ( "( ( -" ."( = , ( " 6 33>9" !
8 " ( 1:,6I41I9( >>2"
( " ?"( ( !" -"( = ( B" 6 3349"
2 8"/ / 3( $,6 39( > F >23"
( " %"( & ( %" ,"( $ ( "( % ( #"( %U. ( B" -"( ( ."
"( " 6 33E9" . ) ) / )
"' ( $1:629( 423 4I2" ( " %"( ( -" -"( - ( ?" "( = ? ( " " 6 33F9" )
" & + < ; ( $$)76 9( 44 231"
( %" "( J ( "( . 8 ( " &"( D ? ( #"( , ( D"( = L C (
." $" 6 33>9" . 8
/ 8"
+ & ( )7( 1IE 144"
( "( = ) ( " ." 6 33>9" -8 ( ( 8
"0 ( $$6E F9( E F"
( " $" 6 33 9" / % ) 8
" ( ,6F9( 221 2>>"
( " $"( ( -" %"( = B ( %" J" 6 33>9" [ /
- ) 8 " &
4 9 & ( 32 4"
( " $"( ( "( ( L"( B ( !" "( ( -" %"( = ( "
." 6 3 9" ( "
( I6E9( 2 1 2 4"
( ?"( % ( ." "( ( -"( # ( "( ( %"( B ( B" L"( " 6 33>9" .
) ) K"+ ( 77629( 343
3EI"
C ( "( = & ( %" 6 1F>9" ? )
"23 ' &( **6 9( 23 2 "
For Review Only
( ." &" 6 3339" ! 8 "
& ( 7=6 9( 3E F"
( " "( & ( &" J"( C C( +" "( ( " -"( = A ( K" " 6 3 39"
% )
) "/ / 3( 7:6 9( >E1 >FI"
( "( ( "( = ( " $" 6 33F9" $ / !
" B / ( 24649( >> I3" ( "( L ( "( ? ( " "( $ ( " "( C ( %" "( = ( #" 6 3 9"
"/ / ( 7:6>9( EFE E1 "
( " ." 6 1F49" ? A /
" & ' ( 886 9( F 1F"
! ( B" "( = ( " " 6 33>9" & ? / 4 C D
/ 4 C D / / A8
' & "
! ( %" " 6 33>9" N ) " ( *7649( 2IF 2E "
J ) ( L"( = ( " 6 33F9" 8/
"+ & ( ),6E9( EFE" J ) ( L" D"( ( " ?"( = ( " %" 6 3349" ! )
"' &( $$776 9( 4 "
J ( " D"( ( ." ["( ? 8( " %"( ( " "( . ( " "( ( " -"( " 6 3349"
"0 + & ( 8,649( 2I E 2I2 "
J ( " "( ( %" L"( J ( " ."( = D ( ." 6 3 9" &
%!K "+ ( **6>9( I44 IE4"
$ ( ." %"( ( " "( L ( K"( = ( " D" 6 33I9" & )
) " / ( 8619( >>I >I2"
$ ( J" "( B ( &"( ! ( $" +" K"( ( !" #"( = $ ( " " 6 33I9" 8
" ( *)649( 2EE 2F4"
$ ( " -"( = ( " D" 6 33>9" ?
) "+ ( 7$6>9( 22E 2>1"
$ ( " 6 1FF9" & % ) / ) (
"33"' & & & ( ( B / ( 7:6 9( 4 3"
$ ( L"( . ( "( L ( !"( % ( %"( = - ( ." 6 1119" %
"- ( =6 29( 1F 3 "
+ ( ?" "( ! ( &" ?"( = ! ( $" +" K" 6 3 2 9" % K
) "
+ 4 (7( 1 1 "
+ ( ?" "( J ( !" %"( $ ( +"( ? V C ( " "( = ! ( $" +" K"
6 3 2)9" % % ? ) ! K ) N
. " ( =6 9( F3E 2"
+ ( ?" "( $ ( J" "( = ! ( $" +" 6 3 39" # C K "
( 222 ( 78619( 4 4 4"
For Review Only
Table 1. White matter microstructure associated with metacognitive ability in memory and perception domains
Region Volume
(mm3)
Peak MNI Z-value
X Y Z
Quantitative Anisotropy (QA)
Memory (Mratio)
R inferior parietal lobule WM 93 42 -48 27 3.85 Perception (Aroc)
No suprathreshold clust. N/A N/A N/A
Generalized Fractional Anisotropy (GFA)
Memory (Mratio)
No suprathreshold clust. N/A N/A N/A
Perception (Aroc)
R anterior cingulate cortex WM 78 12 30 33 3.48
*All clusters significant at p < .05, FWE corrected (height threshold, p < .005).
For Review Only
!"# $% & ' ( & ) * & + (
' ,-,% & .$$ & + ( ' ( & ) * , &
+ ( & ( * + ( & '
+ + (% &
* + / + '
/ + 0 1 * &
( & ( & &
+ & % ) & % 2 3 ( 4 ' ( &
' ( ' + )$ + (
& & # $ + + + + & & &
& & + + & & + + +%
+ / + +
+ &
) 5 #$$ #$$ ,%
For Review Only
! " # $ %&' # $ (") *&+," ($$ + ($$ -./
For Review Only
! "" #
$ !
%&' ( )* + ( ))* ,
-. . / $ . 0 . 1
23 !45 )) ! )) 6&%
For Review Only
! " # ! $ % & " # ! " #
$ ' & " # ! ! $ ! & ( !
) # $ % & ! $ !! & !
$ & % ! % ! ! $ ! & *
$ + ! & ! $! ! & ! ! ! , !
!
-./0102/ $0/ 1 0/ 3 & 3
