Backup Exec 3600 vs Unitrends
AppAssure
-vs-Unitrends
A GLANCE INSIDE:
Company Overviews
Competitive Analysis
» Product and Licensing
» Support
» Recovery and Restore
» Monitoring and Management
» Backup
» Technology
Learn More About Unitrends
Unitrends’ Success Story
C
OMPETITIVE ANAL
AppAssure vs Unitrends
Company Overviews
AppAssure
AppAssure’s Replay software is best suited for storage specialists who want to focus on high touch
backup and who also want to integrate multiple storage, networking, and software components in
order to stitch together a solution that meets their needs. This approach is the opposite of
Uni-trends’ appliance-based value proposition which wants you to focus on your business instead of
on your backup.
Unitrends
Unitrends offers data protection appliances that provide the lowest total cost of ownership (TCO)
in the industry. Our family of disk-to-disk (D2D) appliances provides unmatched backup and rapid
recovery of lost systems, applications, and unstructured and structured data. Our backup,
ar-chiving, and cloud-based disaster recovery appliances eliminate the need for multi-vendor
soft-ware and hardsoft-ware. Instead, Unitrends provides an integrated, simple, and elegant solution that is
designed from the ground-up for small- and medium-sized enterprises.
Competitive Analysis
Product and Licensing
AppAssure Unitrends More Detail
Non-restrictive licensing No Yes Standard licensing does not include restrictions on fea-tures, platforms supported, or per-client fees. Integrated appliance No Yes Support handles a vertically integrated data protection ap-pliance - not just software. Available as physical
appliance No Yes
Available as an integrated server, storage, networking, operating system, backup software, archiving software, replication software, and so forth.
Available as virtual
appliance No Yes
Available as an integrated operating system, backup soft-ware, archiving softsoft-ware, replication softsoft-ware, and so forth as a virtual appliance.
Available as software only Yes No Available as a non-integrated software. AppAssure is pri-marily sold in this manner. Unitrends does not offer non-integrated software at this time.
AppAssure vs Unitrends
AppAssure Unitrends More Detail Supports hardware and
software No Yes
Support handles a vertically integrated data protection ap-pliance - not just software. AppAssure doesn't do this with their software product. However, Unitrends does this with their physical appliance.
Proactive hardware
monitoring No Yes Standard support includes proactive hardware monitoring. Remote diagnostics No Yes Remote diagnostics are available from support.
Self-installable Yes Yes The product may be installed by a customer. On-site support No Yes On-site support is available.
Phone support Yes Yes Telephone support is available. E-mail support Yes Yes E-mail support is available. Online interactive chat
support No Yes Online interactive chat support is available. Online support form Yes Yes An online support form (or portal) is available. Knowledgebase Yes Yes A knowledgebase is available.
User forums No Yes Support monitored and managed user forums are avail-able. Video tutorials Yes Yes Video tutorials are offered by the backup vendor.
Recovery and Restore
AppAssure Unitrends More Detail Instant recovery for
Windows Yes Yes Recovery from a failed Windows server in less than 5 min-utes. Instant recovery for
VMware Limited Yes
Recovery from a failed VMware server in less than 5 min-utes. Since AppAssure does not leverage VADP, instant re-covery is limited to virtual machines running the Windows operating system.
Dissimilar bare metal
restore Yes Yes
This includes P2P, P2V, V2P, and V2V. Unitrends has inte-grated dissimilar bare metal restore support. AppAssure requires an additional licensed product to offer this capa-bility.
Heterogeneous bare metal
restore No Yes
This includes not only Windows but also VMware, Hyper-V, XenServer, Linux, Solaris, Mac OS X, and other operating systems. AppAssure only supports Windows environments whereas Unitrends has integrated bare metal restore sup-port for Windows, Linux, Mac and many other operating systems.
Heterogeneous backup No Yes AppAssure only supports Windows environments, while Unitrends supports a variety of operating systems, applica-tions, and hypervisors.
Monitoring and Management
AppAssure vs Unitrends
Appliance-based monitoring and
management No Yes
Monitoring and management of data protection software, operating system, storage, server, and other solution com-ponents.
Single pane of glass Yes Yes Monitoring and management of multiple Replay Cores (in the case of AppAssure) or appliances (in the case of Uni-trends) from a single web-based user interface.
Web-based management No Yes Monitoring and management can be performed via the web. SNMP/SMTP/alert-based
notifications Limited Yes
Notifications are available via SNMP traps, SMTP e-mail, and alerts. AppAssure only supports SMTP and does not support SNMP trap notifications.
Backup
AppAssure Unitrends More Detail
Virtual and physical backup Limited Yes Supports virtual and physical environments. AppAssure has limited support for physical environments, largely due to the lack of protection for heterogeneous environments. Heterogeneous backup No Yes AppAssure only supports Windows environments, while Unitrends supports a variety of operating systems,
applica-tions, and hypervisors. Heterogeneous storage
protection Limited Yes
Support for protecting NAS and SAN volumes. AppAssure only supports SAN and DAS configurations. NAS is not sup-ported by AppAssure. Unitrends supports SANs, NASs and DAS configurations.
Integrated fixed/rotational
archiving No Yes Integrated disk-to-disk-to-disk, -tape, -SAN, and -NAS for both long-term retention and disaster recovery. Continuous incrementals
supported Yes Yes Continuous-based incremental backup is available (in-cludes near-CDP snapshot). VMware CBT (Change
Block Tracking) No Yes
Support for VMware CBT is available. AppAssure does not leverage the vStorage API for Data Protection (VADP) and relies on the "Smart Agents" to be installed in the guest virtual machines.
Support for Hyper-V
Clus-ter Shared Volumes (CSV) No Yes Protect virtual machines configured in a Clustered Shared Volume configuration. Hyper-V CBT (Change
Block Tracking) No Yes
Support for Hyper-V CBT (which Microsoft does not sup-port) is available. AppAssure seems to protect the entire host volumes rather than tracking the changes on the virtual machine hard disks.
Application-level backups Yes Yes Application-level backup is available. Differential backups
sup-ported Yes Yes Differential backup is available.
Direct backup to tape No No Direct backup to tape (also called D2T) is available. Maximum concurrent
AppAssure vs Unitrends
Technology
AppAssure Unitrends More Detail
Supports agents Yes Yes Supports client-level, agent-based protection where neces-sary. Supports agentless No Yes Supports agentless-based protection where necessary; Unitrends supports agentless-based protection for
VM-ware, NAS storage, and iSeries (AS400) environments. Deduplication Yes Yes Supports deduplication; Unitrends supports target-based, byte-level (content-aware) deduplication. AppAssure
sup-ports target level, block deduplication.
Retention control policies Limited Yes Supports minimum and maximum retention settings. Encryption No Yes At least AES-256 level encryption. AppAssure does not support encryption of data. Unitrends encrypts data at rest
as well as in-flight to the off-premise appliance. Failover virtualization Yes Yes Supports Windows and VMware instant recovery. Grid-based scalability No Yes Backup servers (AppAssure Replay Cores or Unitrends appliances) are configured in a grid for interoperability,
monitoring, and management. Integrated symmetric and
asymmetric replication Yes Yes
AppAssure supports replication to a private cloud; Uni-trends offers both private and public cloud protection for disaster recovery.
Hub-spoke replication Yes Yes AppAssure supports replication to a private cloud; Uni-trends offers both private and public cloud protection for disaster recovery.
Integrated peer-to-peer
replication Yes Yes
AppAssure supports replication to a private cloud; Uni-trends offers both private and public cloud protection for disaster recovery.
Integrated private cloud
replication Yes Yes
AppAssure supports replication to a private cloud; Uni-trends offers both private and public cloud protection for disaster recovery.
Integrated public cloud
replication No Yes
AppAssure does not seem to support public cloud disaster recovery; Unitrends offers Vault2Cloud, which is a multi-tenant public cloud disaster recovery solution.
Unitrends makes this document available for informational purposes only. While we do our best to keep this up-to-date and accurate, we can not and do not represent, warrant or guarantee that it is complete, accurate, or up-to-date, nor does Unitrends offer any certification or guarantee with respect to the opinions expressed herein. Changing circum-stances may change the accuracy of the content herein. Opinions presented in this reflect judgment at the time of publication and are subject to change. While every precaution has been taken in the preparation of this document, Unitrends assumes no responsibility for errors, omissions, or damages resulting from the use of the information herein.
Thank you all for the great feedback – keep it coming! If you have a question, or believe
there is an error in our reporting, please contact us at info@unitrends.com
About Unitrends
Family of scalable, integrated backup, archiving and di-saster recovery appliances enables businesses to de-crease capital and operational costs associated with procurement, integration, management, monitoring and troubleshooting of disparate hardware and software tech-nologies. A federated, scalable architecture also means flexible deployments and no more “fork-lift” upgrades. No per-licensing fees with Unitrends No Limits Licens-ing™ enables businesses to have the freedom to pro-tect rapidly growing IT environments without having the dreaded “backup tax” imposed - no nickel and diming on protected system count, operating systems or applica-tions.
Enterprise-level heterogeneous backup offers net-work, server and storage administrators advanced administrative policies and multiple backup method-ologies for 100+ versions of computers, storage de-vices, operating systems, hypervisors and applications. Adaptive byte-level deduplication enables not just block-level deduplication but content-aware, byte-level deduplication to offer more “bang for the buck” in terms of backup retention. Integrated dissimilar bare metal recovery for physical and virtual servers helps in quickly restoring systems, not just data, for both physical and virtual systems. P2P (physical-to-physical), P2V (physical-to-virtual), V2P (virtual-to-physi-cal) and V2V (virtual-to-virtual) are all supported.
Instant Recovery with failover virtualization drastically reduces downtime due to a Windows or VMware system failure. It also offers better business continuity with typi-cally less than five minutes to recover your system. Live and audit modes are supported for system recovery and verification in a sandbox virtualization environment.
Physical and virtual versions of the Unitrends’ backup, archiving and disaster recovery appliances are available. They work together in heterogeneous environments to best match the needs of each business.
Intuitive, federated, web-based user interface al-lows administrators to monitor and manage one to hundreds of physical and virtual appliances from a single pane of glass web 2.0 user interface. Cloud-based disaster recovery enables private cloud via our appliances and public cloud disaster recov-ery via our Vault2Cloud. Our vaulting is WAN-opti-mized, asymmetric (appliances don’t have to be the same size) and allows true disaster recovery of entire premises from an off-site disaster recovery location. High-performance rotational archiving with disk, tape, NAS and SAN via USB 2.0, eSATA and LAN.
High performance networking support enables support of up to 8x1Gb Ethernet, 2x10Gb Ethernet and 8Gb Fibre Channel interfaces.
Learn
more
about
Unitrends
.
Unitrends Recovery- and vRecovery-series of physical and virtual appliances provide
next-genera-tion data protecnext-genera-tion. Here’s just a few of the features that come standard with our appliances.
De
Success Story: Arrowhead Dental Laboratory
TMQuick Facts
Industry • Healthcare Protected Platforms • HP Proliant Servers • Windows • Linux Challenges• Need for a simple, easy-to use backup solution • Rapid Recovery • Data security • Unified Reporting Solution • Recovery Appliance • Vault2Cloud Benefits
• Easy single-user interface • Automatic scheduled
back-ups
• Rapid, reliable whole sys-tem recovery
• Expert 24/7 product sup-port
“Unitrends was hands down the best option at the best price point
that would allow us to quickly visualize and monitor our recovery
readiness, while at the same time allowing us to backup our data
within a specific time frame, all from one interface.”
Matthew Cook, Arrowhead Dental Laboratory
Customer Profile
Arrowhead Dental Laboratory is a large dental lab serving
dental professionals in both North America and Europe.
The company produces precision dental restorations such
as crowns and dental implants. Arrowhead Dental has a
single production facility and is heavily dependent on its
information infrastructure to coordinate daily operations.
The production facility uses HP Proliant servers running
both Windows and Linux operating systems, alongside
their Network Attached Storage (NAS). Among these,
there are seven key servers with a combined data volume
of about 900 GB.
Challenges
In a fast-paced medical production facility dependent on
data systems, IT director Matthew Cook, must prepare his
data center for anything. Cook was under pressure to find
a backup solution that would keep him ahead of the game
to help the facility run as smoothly and efficiently as
pos-sible.
“This is especially critical because we ship everything next
day early delivery. A case that doesn’t ship means there is
a doctor with a patient in the chair that won’t be getting his
case,” Cook said.
TM