FUNCTIONS DEFINED BY
IMPROPER INTEGRALS
William F. Trench
Professor Emeritus
Department of Mathematics
Trinity University
San Antonio, Texas, USA
[email protected]
©Copyright May 2012, William F. Trench This is a supplement to the author’s
Introduction to Real Analysis
1
Foreword
This is a revised version of Section 7.5 of myAdvanced Calculus(Harper & Row, 1978). It is a supplement to my textbookIntroduction to Real Analysis, which is refer-enced several times here. You should review Section 3.4 (Improper Integrals) of that book before reading this document.
2
Introduction
In Section 7.2 (pp. 462–484) we considered functions of the form
F .y/D
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx; cyd:
We saw that iff is continuous onŒa; bŒc; d , thenF is continuous onŒc; d (Exer-cise 7.2.3, p. 481) and that we can reverse the order of integration in
Z d
c
F .y/ dy D
Z d
c Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
!
dy
to evaluate it as
Z d
c
F .y/ dy D
Z b
a Z d
c
f .x; y/ dy
!
dx
(Corollary 7.2.3, p. 466).
Here is another important property ofF.
Theorem 1 Iff andfyare continuous onŒa; bŒc; d ;then
F .y/D
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx; cyd; (1)
is continuously differentiable onŒc; d andF0.y/can be obtained by differentiating(1)
under the integral sign with respect toyIthat is,
F0.y/D
Z b
a
fy.x; y/ dx; cyd: (2)
HereF0.a/ andfy.x; a/are derivatives from the right andF0.b/andfy.x; b/are
derivatives from the left:
Proof IfyandyCy are inŒc; d andy¤0, then
F .yCy/ F .y/
y D
Z b
a
f .x; yCy/ f .x; y/
y dx: (3)
From the mean value theorem (Theorem 2.3.11, p. 83), ifx2Œa; bandy,yCy 2 Œc; d , there is ay.x/betweenyandyCysuch that
From this and (3),
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
F .yCy/ F .y/ y
Z b
a
fy.x; y/ dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a j
fy.x; y.x// fy.x; y/jdx: (4)
Now suppose > 0. Sincefyis uniformly continuous on the compact setŒa; bŒc; d
(Corollary 5.2.14, p. 314) andy.x/is betweeny andyCy, there is aı > 0such that ifjj< ıthen
jfy.x; y/ fy.x; y.x//j< ; .x; y/2Œa; bŒc; d :
This and (4) imply that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
F .yCy F .y// y
Z b
a
fy.x; y/ dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< .b a/
ify andyCy are inŒc; d and0 <jyj< ı. This implies (2). Since the integral in (2) is continuous onŒc; d (Exercise 7.2.3, p. 481, withf replaced by fy),F0 is
continuous onŒc; d .
Example 1 Since
f .x; y/Dcosxy and fy.x; y/D xsinxy
are continuous for all.x; y/, Theorem1implies that if
F .y/D
Z
0
cosxy dx; 1< y <1; (5)
then
F0.y/D
Z
0
xsinxy dx; 1< y <1: (6)
(In applying Theorem1for a specific value ofy, we takeRDŒ0; Œ ; , where >jyj.) This provides a convenient way to evaluate the integral in (6): integrating the right side of (5) with respect toxyields
F .y/D sinxy y
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
xD0D
siny
y ; y¤0:
Differentiating this and using (6) yields
Z
0
xsinxy dxD siny y2
cosy
y ; y¤0:
To verify this, use integration by parts.
We will study the continuity, differentiability, and integrability of
F .y/D
Z b
a
whereS is an interval or a union of intervals, andF is a convergent improper integral for eachy 2S. If the domain off isŒa; b/S where 1 < a < b 1, we say thatF ispointwise convergent onSor simplyconvergent onS, and write
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!b Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx (7)
if, for eachy 2 Sand every > 0, there is anr D r0.y/(which also depends on)
such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
F .y/
Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇD
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; r0.y/y < b: (8)
If the domain off is.a; bSwhere 1 a < b <1, we replace (7) by
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!aC
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
and (8) by
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
F .y/
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
D
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; a < r r0.y/:
In general, pointwise convergence ofF for ally 2 S does not imply thatF is continuous or integrable onŒc; d , and the additional assumptions thatfyis continuous
andRabfy.x; y/ dxconverges do not imply (2).
Example 2 The function
f .x; y/Dye jyjx is continuous onŒ0;1/. 1;1/and
F .y/D
Z 1 0
f .x; y/ dxD
Z 1 0
ye jyjxdx converges for ally, with
F .y/D
8 ˆ <
ˆ :
1 y < 0; 0 yD0; 1 y > 0I
therefore,F is discontinuous atyD0.
Example 3 The function
f .x; y/Dy3e y2x
is continuous onŒ0;1/. 1;1/. Let
F .y/D
Z 1 0
f .x; y/ dxD
Z 1 0
Then
F0.y/D1; 1< y <1: However,
Z 1 0
@ @y.y
3
e y2x/ dxD
Z 1 0
.3y2 2y4x/e y2xdxD
(
1; y¤0; 0; yD0;
so
F0.y/¤
Z 1 0
@f .x; y/
@y dx if yD0:
3
Preparation
We begin with two useful convergence criteria for improper integrals that do not involve a parameter. Consistent with the definition on p. 152, we say thatf is locally integrable on an intervalI if it is integrable on every finite closed subinterval ofI.
Theorem 2 (CauchyCriterion for Convergence of an Improper Integral I) Suppose
gis locally integrable onŒa; b/and denote
G.r /D
Z r
a
g.x/ dx; ar < b:
Then the improper integralRabg.x/ dx converges if and only if;for each > 0;there is anr02Œa; b/such that
jG.r / G.r1/j< ; r0r; r1< b: (9)
Proof For necessity, supposeRabg.x/ dx D L. By definition, this means that for each > 0there is anr02Œa; b/such that
jG.r / Lj<
2 and jG.r1/ Lj<
2; r0r; r1< b:
Therefore
jG.r / G.r1/j D j.G.r / L/ .G.r1/ L/j
jG.r / Lj C jG.r1/ Lj< ; r0r; r1< b:
For sufficiency, (9) implies that
jG.r /j D jG.r1/C.G.r / G.r1//j<jG.r1/j C jG.r / G.r1/j jG.r1/j C;
r0r r1< b. SinceGis also bounded on the compact setŒa; r0(Theorem 5.2.11,
p. 313),Gis bounded onŒa; b/. Therefore the monotonic functions
G.r /Dsup˚
G.r1/ ˇ
ˇrr1< b and G.r /Dinf˚G.r1/ ˇ
are well defined onŒa; b/, and
lim
r!b G.r /DL and r!limb G.r /DL
both exist and are finite (Theorem 2.1.11, p. 47). From (9),
jG.r / G.r1/j D j.G.r / G.r0// .G.r1/ G.r0//j
jG.r / G.r0/j C jG.r1/ G.r0/j< 2;
so
G.r / G.r /2; r0r; r1< b:
Sinceis an arbitrary positive number, this implies that
lim
r!b .G.r / G.r //D0;
soLDL. LetLDLDL. Since
G.r /G.r /G.r /;
it follows that limr!b G.r /DL.
We leave the proof of the following theorem to you (Exercise2).
Theorem 3 (Cauchy Criterion for Convergence of an Improper Integral II) Suppose
gis locally integrable on.a; band denote
G.r /D
Z b
r
g.x/ dx; ar < b:
Then the improper integralRb
a g.x/ dx converges if and only if;for each > 0;there
is anr02.a; bsuch that
jG.r / G.r1/j< ; a < r; r1r0:
To see why we associate Theorems2and3with Cauchy, compare them with The-orem 4.3.5 (p. 204)
4
Uniform convergence of improper integrals
Henceforth we deal with functionsf Df .x; y/with domainsI S, whereS is an interval or a union of intervals andI is of one of the following forms:
Œa; b/with 1< a < b 1;
.a; bwith 1 a < b <1;
In all cases it is to be understood thatf is locally integrable with respect tox onI. When we say that the improper integralRabf .x; y/ dxhas a stated property “on S” we mean that it has the property for everyy 2S.
Definition 1 If the improper integral
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!b Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx (10)
converges onS;it is said to converge uniformly.or be uniformly convergent/onS if;
for each > 0;there is anr02Œa; b/such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y 2S; r0r < b;
or;equivalently;
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y 2S; r0r < b: (11)
The crucial difference between pointwise and uniform convergence is thatr0.y/in
(8) may depend upon the particular value ofy, while ther0in (11) does not: one choice
must work for ally 2S. Thus, uniform convergence implies pointwise convergence, but pointwise convergence does not imply uniform convergence.
Theorem 4 .Cauchy Criterion for Uniform Convergence I/The improper integral in(10)converges uniformly onS if and only if;for each > 0;there is anr02Œa; b/
such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y2S; r0r; r1< b: (12)
Proof SupposeRabf .x; y/ dx converges uniformly onS and > 0. From Defini-tion1, there is anr02Œa; b/such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 2 and
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r1
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
<
2; y 2S; r0r; r1< b: (13)
Since
Z r1
r
f .x; y/ dxD
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
Z b
r1
f .x; y/ dx;
(13) and the triangle inequality imply (12). For the converse, denote
F .y/ D
Z r
a
Since (12) implies that
jF .r; y/ F .r1; y/j< ; y2S; r0r; r1< b; (14)
Theorem2withG.r /DF .r; y/(yfixed but arbitrary inS) implies thatRb
a f .x; y/ dx
converges pointwise fory 2 S. Therefore, if > 0then, for eachy 2S, there is an r0.y/2Œa; b/such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y 2S; r0.y/r < b: (15)
For eachy2S, chooser1.y/maxŒr0.y/; r0. (Recall (14)). Then
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dxD
Z r1.y/
r
f .x; y/ dxC
Z b
r1.y/
f .x; y/ dx;
so (12), (15), and the triangle inequality imply that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 2; y2S; r0 r < b:
In practice, we don’t explicitly exhibitr0 for each given . It suffices to obtain
estimates that clearly imply its existence.
Example 4 For the improper integral of Example2,
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z 1 r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇD
Z 1 r j
yje jyjx De rjyj; y ¤0: Ifjyj , then
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z 1 r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
e r;
soR1
0 f .x; y/ dx converges uniformly on . 1; [Œ;1/if > 0; however, it
does not converge uniformly on any neighborhood ofy D 0, since, for any r > 0, e rjyj> 12ifjyjis sufficiently small.
Definition 2 If the improper integral
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!aC
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
converges onS;it is said to converge uniformly.or be uniformly convergent/onS if;
for each > 0;there is anr02.a; bsuch that ˇ
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y 2S; a < rr0;
or;equivalently;
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
We leave proof of the following theorem to you (Exercise3).
Theorem 5 .Cauchy Criterion for Uniform Convergence II/The improper integral
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!aC
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
converges uniformly onSif and only if;for each > 0;there is anr0 2 .a; bsuch
that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r
r1
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y2S; a < r; r1r0:
We need one more definition, as follows.
Definition 3 Letf D f .x; y/be defined on.a; b/S;where 1 a < b 1:
Supposef is locally integrable on.a; b/for ally 2S and letcbe an arbitrary point in.a; b/:ThenRabf .x; y/ dxis said to converge uniformly onSifRacf .x; y/ dxand
Rb
c f .x; y/ dxboth converge uniformly onS:
We leave it to you (Exercise 4) to show that this definition is independent ofc; that is, ifRacf .x; y/ dx andRcbf .x; y/ dx both converge uniformly onS for some c2.a; b/, then they both converge uniformly onSfor everyc2.a; b/.
We also leave it you (Exercise5) to show that iff is bounded onŒa; bŒc; d andRb
a f .x; y/ dx exists as a proper integral for each y 2 Œc; d , then it converges
uniformly onŒc; d according to all three Definitions1–3.
Example 5 Consider the improper integral
F .y/D
Z 1 0
x 1=2e xydx;
which diverges ify 0(verify). Definition3applies if y > 0, so we consider the improper integrals
F1.y/D Z 1
0
x 1=2e xydx and F2.y/D Z 1
1
x 1=2e xydx
separately. Moreover, we could just as well define
F1.y/D Z c
0
x 1=2e xydx and F2.y/D Z 1
c
x 1=2e xydx; (16)
wherecis any positive number.
Definition2applies toF1. If0 < r1< randy0, then
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
x 1=2e xydx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
<
Z r
r1
x 1=2dx < 2r1=2;
Definition1applies toF2. Since
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
x 1=2e xydx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< r 1=2
Z 1 r
e xydxD e
ry
yr1=2;
F2.y/ converges uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0. It does not converge uniformly on
.0; /, since the change of variableuDxyyields
Z r1
r
x 1=2e xydxDy 1=2
Z r1y
ry
u 1=2e udu;
which, for any fixedr > 0, can be made arbitrarily large by takingysufficiently small andr D 1=y. Therefore we conclude that F .y/ converges uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0:
Note that that the constantcin (16) plays no role in this argument.
Example 6 Suppose we take
Z 1 0
sinu u duD
2 (17)
as given (Exercise31(b)). SubstitutinguDxywithy > 0yields
Z 1 0
sinxy x dxD
2; y > 0: (18)
What about uniform convergence? Since.sinxy/=x is continuous atx D 0, Defini-tion1and Theorem4apply here. If0 < r < r1andy > 0, then
Z r1
r
sinxy x dxD
1 y
cosxy x
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ r1
r C Z r1
r
cosxy x2 dx
; so
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
sinxy x dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 3 ry:
Therefore (18) converges uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0. On the other hand, from (17), there is aı > 0such that
Z 1 u0
sinu u du >
4; 0u0< ı:
This and (18) imply that
Z 1 r
sinxy x dxD
Z 1 yr
sinu u du >
4
5
Absolutely Uniformly Convergent Improper Integrals
Definition 4 .Absolute Uniform Convergence I/The improper integral
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!b Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
is said to converge absolutely uniformly onS if the improper integral
Z b
a j
f .x; y/jdxD lim
r!b Z r
a j
f .x; y/jdx
converges uniformly onS; that is, if, for each > 0, there is anr02Œa; b/such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a j
f .x; y/jdx
Z r
a j
f .x; y/jdx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y2S; r0 < r < b:
To see that this definition makes sense, recall that iff is locally integrable onŒa; b/ for allyinS, then so isjfj(Theorem 3.4.9, p. 161). Theorem4withf replaced by
jfjimplies thatRabf .x; y/ dxconverges absolutely uniformly onS if and only if, for each > 0, there is anr02Œa; b/such that
Z r1
r j
f .x; y/jdx < ; y2S; r0r < r1< b:
Since ˇ
ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r j
f .x; y/jdx;
Theorem4implies that ifRabf .x; y/ dxconverges absolutely uniformly onS then it converges uniformly onS.
Theorem 6 . Weierstrass’s Test for Absolute Uniform Convergence I/ Suppose
M DM.x/is nonnegative onŒa; b/;Rb
a M.x/ dx <1;and
jf .x; y/j M.x/; y2S; ax < b: (19)
ThenRabf .x; y/ dxconverges absolutely uniformly onS:
Proof DenoteRb
a M.x/ dx D L < 1. By definition, for each > 0there is an
r02Œa; b/such that
L <
Z r
a
M.x/ dx L; r0< r < b:
Therefore, ifr0< rr1;then
0
Z r1
r
M.x/ dxD
Z r1
a
M.x/ dx L
Z r
a
M.x/ dx L
This and (19) imply that
Z r1
r j
f .x; y/jdx
Z r1
r
M.x/ dx < ; y2S; ar0< r < r1< b:
Now Theorem4implies the stated conclusion.
Example 7 SupposegDg.x; y/is locally integrable onŒ0;1/for ally 2Sand, for somea00, there are constantsKandp0such that
jg.x; y/j Kep0x; y
2S; xa0:
Ifp > p0andr a0, then
Z 1 r
e pxjg.x; y/jdx D
Z 1 r
e .p p0/x e p0x
jg.x; y/jdx
K
Z 1 r
e .p p0/x
dxD Ke
.p p0/r
p p0
;
soR01e pxg.x; y/ dxconverges absolutely onS. For example, since
jx˛sinxyj< ep0x
and jx˛cosxyj< ep0x
for x sufficiently large if p0 > 0, Theorem 4 implies that R01e pxx˛sinxy dx
andR1
0 e pxx˛cosxy dxconverge absolutely uniformly on. 1;1/ifp > 0and
˛ 0. As a matter of fact,R1
0 e pxx˛sinxy dxconverges absolutely on. 1;1/
ifp > 0and˛ > 1. (Why?)
Definition 5 .Absolute Uniform Convergence II/The improper integral
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dxD lim
r!aC
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
is said to converge absolutely uniformly onS if the improper integral
Z b
a j
f .x; y/jdxD lim
r!aC
Z b
r j
f .x; y/jdx
converges uniformly onS; that is, if, for each > 0, there is anr02.a; bsuch that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a j
f .x; y/jdx
Z b
r j
f .x; y/jdx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; y 2S; a < r < r0b:
We leave it to you (Exercise7) to prove the following theorem.
Theorem 7 .Weierstrass’s Test for Absolute Uniform Convergence II/ Suppose
M DM.x/is nonnegative on.a; b;Rb
a M.x/ dx <1;and
jf .x; y/j M.x/; y 2S; x2.a; b:
ThenRb
Example 8 IfgDg.x; y/is locally integrable on.0; 1for ally2Sand
jg.x; y/j Ax ˇ; 0 < xx0;
for eachy2S, then
Z 1
0
x˛g.x; y/ dx
converges absolutely uniformly onS if˛ > ˇ 1. To see this, note that if0 < r < r1x0, then
Z r
r1
x˛jg.x; y/jdx A
Z r
r1
x˛ ˇdxD Ax
˛ ˇC1
˛ ˇC1
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ r
r1 < Ar
˛ ˇC1
˛ ˇC1:
Applying this withˇD0shows that
F .y/ D
Z 1
0
x˛cosxy dx
converges absolutely uniformly on. 1;1/if˛ > 1and
G.y/D
Z 1
0
x˛sinxy dx
converges absolutely uniformly on. 1;1/if˛ > 2.
By recalling Theorem 4.4.15 (p. 246), you can see why we associate Theorems6 and7with Weierstrass.
6
Dirichlet’s Tests
Weierstrass’s test is useful and important, but it has a basic shortcoming: it applies only to absolutely uniformly convergent improper integrals. The next theorem applies in some cases whereRb
a f .x; y/ dx converges uniformly on S, but Rb
a jf .x; y/jdx
does not.
Theorem 8 .Dirichlet’s Test for Uniform Convergence I/Ifg; gx;andhare
con-tinuous onŒa; b/S;then
Z b
a
g.x; y/h.x; y/ dx
converges uniformly onSif the following conditions are satisfiedW
(a) lim
x!b (
sup
y2Sj
g.x; y/j
)
D0I
(b) There is a constantM such that
sup
y2S ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z x
a
h.u; y/ du
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
(c) Rabjgx.x; y/jdxconverges uniformly onS:
Proof If
H.x; y/D
Z x
a
h.u; y/ du; (20)
then integration by parts yields
Z r1
r
g.x; y/h.x; y/ dx D
Z r1
r
g.x; y/Hx.x; y/ dx
D g.r1; y/H.r1; y/ g.r; y/H.r; y/ (21) Z r1
r
gx.x; y/H.x; y/ dx:
Since assumption(b)and (20) imply thatjH.x; y/j M; .x; y/2.a; bS, Eqn. (21) implies that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
g.x; y/h.x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< M
2sup
xrj
g.x; y/j C
Z r1
r j
gx.x; y/jdx
(22)
onŒr; r1S.
Now suppose > 0. From assumption(a), there is an r0 2 Œa; b/ such that
jg.x; y/j < onS ifr0 x < b. From assumption(c) and Theorem6, there is
ans02Œa; b/such that
Z r1
r j
gx.x; y/jdx < ; y 2S; s0< r < r1< b:
Therefore (22) implies that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
g.x; y/h.x; y/
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 3M; y2S; max.r0; s0/ < r < r1< b:
Now Theorem4implies the stated conclusion.
The statement of this theorem is complicated, but applying it isn’t; just look for a factorizationf Dgh, wherehhas a bounded antderivative onŒa; b/andgis “small” near b. Then integrate by parts and hope that something nice happens. A similar comment applies to Theorem 9, which follows.
Example 9 Let
I.y/D
Z 1 0
cosxy
xCy dx; y > 0:
The obvious inequality
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
cosxy xCy
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
1 xCy
is useless here, since
Z 1 0
dx
However, integration by parts yields
Z r1
r
cosxy xCy dx D
sinxy y.xCy/
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ r1
r
C
Z r1
r
sinxy y.xCy/2dx
D sinr1y
y.r1Cy/
sinry y.r Cy/C
Z r1
r
sinxy y.xCy/2 dx:
Therefore, if0 < r < r1, then
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
cosxy xCy dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 1 y
2
rCy C
Z 1 r
1 .xCy/2
3
y.rCy/2
3 .rC/
ify > 0. Now Theorem 4implies thatI.y/converges uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0.
We leave the proof of the following theorem to you (Exercise10).
Theorem 9 .Dirichlet’s Test for Uniform Convergence II/Ifg; gx;andhare
con-tinuous on.a; bS;then
Z b
a
g.x; y/h.x; y/ dx
converges uniformly onSif the following conditions are satisfiedW
(a) lim
x!aC
(
sup
y2Sj
g.x; y/j
)
D0I
(b) There is a constantM such that
sup
y2S ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
x
h.u; y/ du
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
M; a < xbI
(c) Rb
a jgx.x; y/jdxconverges uniformly onS.
By recalling Theorems 3.4.10 (p. 163), 4.3.20 (p. 217), and 4.4.16 (p. 248), you can see why we associate Theorems8and9with Dirichlet.
7
Consequences of uniform convergence
Theorem 10 Iff D f .x; y/is continuous on eitherŒa; b/Œc; d or.a; bŒc; d
and
F .y/ D
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx (23)
converges uniformly onŒc; d ;thenF is continuous onŒc; d :Moreover;
Z d
c Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
!
dyD
Z b
a Z d
c
f .x; y/ dy
!
Proof We will assume thatf is continuous on.a; bŒc; d . You can consider the other case (Exercise14).
We will first show thatF in (23) is continuous onŒc; d . SinceF converges uni-formly onŒc; d , Definition1 (specifically, (11)) implies that if > 0, there is an r2Œa; b/such that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; cyd:
Therefore, ifcy; y0d , then
jF .y/ F .y0/j D ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
Z b
a
f .x; y0/ dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r
a
Œf .x; y/ f .x; y0/ dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇC
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
C
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z b
r
f .x; y0/ dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
;
so
jF .y/ F .y0/j Z r
a j
f .x; y/ f .x; y0/jdxC2: (25)
Sincef is uniformly continuous on the compact setŒa; r Œc; d (Corollary 5.2.14, p. 314), there is aı > 0such that
jf .x; y/ f .x; y0/j<
if.x; y/and.x; y0/are inŒa; r Œc; d andjy y0j< ı. This and (25) imply that
jF .y/ F .y0/j< .r a/C2 < .b aC2/
ifyandy0are inŒc; d andjy y0j< ı. ThereforeF is continuous onŒc; d , so the
integral on left side of (24) exists. Denote
I D
Z d
c Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
!
dy: (26)
We will show that the improper integral on the right side of (24) converges toI. To this end, denote
I.r /D
Z r
a Z d
c
f .x; y/ dy
!
dx:
Since we can reverse the order of integration of the continuous functionf over the rectangleŒa; r Œc; d (Corollary 7.2.2, p. 466),
I.r /D
Z d
c Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx
From this and (26),
I I.r /D
Z d
c Z b
r
f .x; y/ dx
!
dy:
Now suppose > 0. SinceRb
a f .x; y/ dx converges uniformly onŒc; d , there is an
r02.a; bsuch that
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ Z b r
f .x; y/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; r0< r < b;
sojI I.r /j< .d c/ifr0< r < b. Hence,
lim
r!b Z r
a Z d
c
f .x; y/ dy
! dx D Z d c Z b a
f .x; y/ dx
!
dy;
which completes the proof of (24).
Example 10 It is straightforward to verify that
Z 1 0
e xydxD 1
y; y > 0;
and the convergence is uniform onŒ;1/if > 0. Therefore Theorem10implies that if0 < y1< y2, then
Z y2
y1 dy
y D
Z y2
y1
Z 1 0
e xydx
dyD
Z 1 0
Z y2
y1
e xydy
dy
D
Z 1 0
e xy1 e xy2
x dx:
Since
Z y2
y1 dy
y Dlog y2
y1
; y2y1> 0;
it follows that
Z 1 0
e xy1 e xy2
x dxDlog y2
y1
; y2y1> 0:
Example 11 From Example6,
Z 1 0
sinxy x dxD
2; y > 0;
and the convergence is uniform onŒ;1/if > 0. Therefore, Theorem10implies that if0 < y1< y2, then
2.y2 y1/ D
Z y2
y1 Z 1 0 sinxy x dx dyD Z 1 0
Z y2
y1 sinxy x dy dx D Z 1 0
cosxy1 cosxy2
The last integral converges uniformly on. 1;1/(Exercise 10(h)), and is therefore continuous with respect toy1on. 1;1/, by Theorem10; in particular, we can let
y1!0Cin (27) and replacey2byyto obtain
Z 1 0
1 cosxy x2 dxD
y
2 ; y0:
The next theorem is analogous to Theorem 4.4.20 (p. 252).
Theorem 11 Letf andfy be continuous on eitherŒa; b/Œc; d or.a; bŒc; d :
Suppose that the improper integral
F .y/ D
Z b
a
f .x; y/ dx
converges for somey02Œc; d and
G.y/D
Z b
a
fy.x; y/ dx
converges uniformly onŒc; d :ThenF converges uniformly onŒc; d and is given ex-plicitly by
F .y/ DF .y0/C Z y
y0
G.t / dt; cy d:
Moreover,F is continuously differentiable onŒc; d ; specifically,
F0.y/DG.y/; cyd; (28)
whereF0.c/andfy.x; c/are derivatives from the right, andF0.d /andfy.x; d /are
derivatives from the left:
Proof We will assume thatf andfy are continuous on Œa; b/Œc; d . You can
consider the other case (Exercise15). Let
Fr.y/D Z r
a
f .x; y/ dx; ar < b; cyd:
Sincef andfyare continuous onŒa; r Œc; d , Theorem1implies that
Fr0.y/D
Z r
a
fy.x; y/ dx; cyd:
Then
Fr.y/ D Fr.y0/C Z y
y0
Z r
a
fy.x; t / dx
dt
D F .y0/C Z y
y0
G.t / dt
C.Fr.y0/ F .y0// Z y
y0
Z b
r
fy.x; t / dx !
Therefore,
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Fr.y/ F .y0/ Z y
y0
G.t / dt
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ j
Fr.y0/ F .y0/j
C ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ Z y y0 Z b r
fy.x; t / dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ dt: (29)
Now suppose > 0. Since we have assumed that limr!b Fr.y0/D F .y0/exists,
there is anr0in.a; b/such that
jFr.y0/ F .y0/j< ; r0< r < b:
Since we have assumed thatG.y/converges fory 2Œc; d , there is anr12Œa; b/such
that ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ Z b r
fy.x; t / dx ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< ; t 2Œc; d ; r1r < b:
Therefore, (29) yields
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Fr.y/ F .y0/ Z y
y0
G.t / dt
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< .1C jy y0j/.1Cd c/
if max.r0; r1/r < bandt 2 Œc; d . ThereforeF .y/converges uniformly onŒc; d
and
F .y/ DF .y0/C Z y
y0
G.t / dt; cy d:
SinceG is continuous onŒc; d by Theorem10, (28) follows from differentiating this (Theorem 3.3.11, p. 141).
Example 12 Let
I.y/D
Z 1 0
e yx2dx; y > 0:
Since
Z r
0
e yx2dxD p1 y
Z rpy 0
e t2dt;
it follows that
I.y/D p1 y
Z 1 0
e t2dt;
and the convergence is uniform onŒ;1/if > 0(Exercise8(i)). To evaluate the last integral, denoteJ./DR
0 e t2
dt; then
J2./D
Z
0
e u2du
Z
0
e v2dv
D Z 0 Z 0
e .u2Cv2/du dv: Transforming to polar coordinatesrDrcos,vDrsinyields
J2./D
Z =2
0 Z
0
r e r2d r dD .1 e
2 /
4 ; so J./D
q
.1 e 2 /
Therefore
Z 1 0
e t2dtD lim
!1J./D
p
2 and
Z 1 0
e yx2dx D 1 2
r
y; y > 0:
Differentiating thisntimes with respect toyyields
Z 1 0
x2ne yx2dxD 13 .2n 1/
p
2nynC1=2 y > 0; nD1; 2; 3; : : : ;
where Theorem 11 justifies the differentiation for every n, since all these integrals converge uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0(Exercise8(i)).
Some advice for applying this theorem: Be sure to check first that F .y0/ D Rb
a f .x; y0/ dxconverges for at least one value ofy. If so, differentiateR b
a f .x; y/ dx
formally to obtainRb
a fy.x; y/ dx. ThenF0.y/ D Rb
a fy.x; y/ dx if y is in some
interval on which this improper integral converges uniformly.
8
Applications to Laplace transforms
TheLaplacetransformof a functionf locally integrable onŒ0;1/is
F .s/D
Z 1 0
e sxf .x/ dx
for allssuch that integral converges. Laplace transforms are widely applied in mathe-matics, particularly in solving differential equations.
We leave it to you to prove the following theorem (Exercise26).
Theorem 12 Supposef is locally integrable onŒ0;1/andjf .x/j Mes0xfor
suf-ficiently largex. Then the Laplace transform ofF converges uniformly onŒs1;1/if
s1> s0.
Theorem 13 Iff is continuous onŒ0;1/andH.x/DR1 0 e
s0uf .u/ duis bounded
onŒ0;1/;then the Laplace transform off converges uniformly onŒs1;1/ifs1> s0:
Proof If0rr1, Z r1
r
e sxf .x/ dx D
Z r1
r
e .s s0/x e s0x
f .x/ dt D
Z r1
r
e .s s0/t
H0.x/ dt: Integration by parts yields
Z r1
r
e sxf .x/ dt De .s s0/xH.x/
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ r1
r
C.s s0/ Z r1
r
Therefore, ifjH.x/j M, then
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
e sxf .x/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
M
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
e .s s0/r1
Ce .s s0/r
C.s s0/ Z r1
r
e .s s0/x dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
3Me .s s0/r
3Me .s1 s0/r
; ss1:
Now Theorem4implies thatF .s/converges uniformly onŒs1;1/.
The following theorem draws a considerably stonger conclusion from the same assumptions.
Theorem 14 Iff is continuous onŒ0;1/and
H.x/D
Z x
0
e s0u
f .u/ du
is bounded onŒ0;1/;then the Laplace transform off is infinitely differentiable on
.s0;1/;with
F.n/.s/D. 1/n
Z 1 0
e sxxnf .x/ dxI (30)
that is, then-th derivative of the Laplace transform off .x/is the Laplace transform of. 1/nxnf .x/.
Proof First we will show that the integrals
In.s/D Z 1
0
e sxxnf .x/ dx; nD0; 1; 2; : : :
all converge uniformly onŒs1;1/ifs1> s0. If0 < r < r1, then
Z r1
r
e sxxnf .x/ dxD
Z r1
r
e .s s0/x e s0x
xnf .x/ dxD
Z r1
r
e .s s0/x
xnH0.x/ dx: Integrating by parts yields
Z r1
r
e sxxnf .x/ dx D r1ne .s s0/r1H.r / rne .s s0/rH.r /
Z r1
r
H.x/e .s s0/xxn0 dx;
where0indicates differentiation with respect tox. Therefore, ifjH.x/j M 1on Œ0;1/, then
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
e sxxnf .x/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
M
e .s s0/r
rnCe .s s0/r rnC
Z 1 r j
.e .s s0/x
/xn/0jdx
:
Therefore, sincee .s s0/rrn
decreases monotonically on.n;1/ifs > s0(check!),
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
Z r1
r
e sxxnf .x/ dx
ˇ ˇ ˇ ˇ
< 3Me .s s0/r
rn; n < r < r1;
so Theorem4implies thatIn.s/converges uniformlyŒs1;1/ifs1 > s0. Now
The-orem11implies thatFnC1 D Fn0, and an easy induction proof yields (30)
Example 13 Here we apply Theorem12withf .x/D cosax (a ¤ 0) ands0 D 0.
Since
Z x
0
cosau duD sinax a
is bounded on.0;1/, Theorem12implies that
F .s/D
Z 1 0
e sxcosax dx
converges and
F.n/.s/D. 1/n
Z 1 0
e sxxncosax dx; s > 0: (31)
(Note that this is also true ifaD0.) Elementary integration yields
F .s/D s s2Ca2:
Hence, from (31),
Z 1 0
e sxxncosaxD. 1/n d
n
dsn
s
9
Exercises
1. Supposegandhare differentiable onŒa; b, with
ag.y/b and ah.y/b; cyd:
Letf andfybe continuous onŒa; bŒc; d . DeriveLiebniz’s rule:
d dy
Z h.y/
g.y/
f .x; y/ dx D f .h.y/; y/h0.y/ f .g.y/; y/g0.y/
C
Z h.y/
g.y/
fy.x; y/ dx:
(Hint: DefineH.y; u; v/DRv
u f .x; y/ dxand use the chain rule.)
2. Adapt the proof of Theorem2to prove Theorem3.
3. Adapt the proof of Theorem4to prove Theorem5.
4. Show that Definition3is independent ofc; that is, ifRc
a f .x; y/ dxand Rb
c f .x; y/ dx
both converge uniformly onSfor somec2.a; b/, then they both converge uni-formly onSand everyc2.a; b/.
5. (a) Show that iff is bounded onŒa; bŒc; d andRb
a f .x; y/ dxexists as a
proper integral for eachy 2 Œc; d , then it converges uniformly onŒc; d according to all of Definition1–3.
(b) Give an example to show that the boundedness off is essential in(a).
6. Working directly from Definition1, discuss uniform convergence of the follow-ing integrals:
(a)
Z 1 0
dx
1Cy2x2dx (b) Z 1
0
e xyx2dx
(c)
Z 1 0
x2ne yx2dx (d)
Z 1 0
sinxy2dx
(e)
Z 1 0
.3y2 2xy/e y2xdx (f)
Z 1 0
.2xy y2x2/e xydx
7. Adapt the proof of Theorem6to prove Theorem7.
8. Use Weierstrass’s test to show that the integral converges uniformly onS W
(a)
Z 1 0
e xysinx dx, SDŒ;1/, > 0
(b)
Z 1 0
sinx
(c)
Z 1 1
e pxsinxy
x dx, p > 0, S D. 1;1/
(d)
Z 1
0
exy
.1 x/y dx, SD. 1; b/, b < 1
(e)
Z 1
1
cosxy
1Cx2y2dx, SD. 1; [Œ;1/, > 0.
(f)
Z 1 1
e x=ydx, S DŒ;1/, > 0
(g)
Z 1
1
exye x2dx, S DŒ ; , > 0
(h)
Z 1 0
cosxy cosax
x2 dx, SD. 1;1/
(i)
Z 1 0
x2ne yx2dx, SDŒ;1/, > 0, nD0,1,2,. . .
9. (a) Show that
.y/D
Z 1 0
xy 1e xdx
converges ify > 0, and uniformly onŒc; d if0 < c < d <1.
(b) Use integration by parts to show that
.y/D .yC1/
y ; y 0;
and then show by induction that
.y/D .yCn/
y.yC1/ .yCn 1/; y > 0; nD1; 2; 3; : : : :
How can this be used to define .y/in a natural way for ally ¤ 0, 1, 2, . . . ? (This function is called thegamma function.)
(c) Show that .nC1/DnŠifnis a positive integer.
(d) Show that
Z 1 0
e stt˛dtDs ˛ 1 .˛C1/; ˛ > 1; s > 0:
10. Show that Theorem8 remains valid with assumption(c) replaced by the as-sumption thatjgx.x; y/jis monotonic with respect toxfor ally2S.
11. Adapt the proof of Theorem8to prove Theorem9.
(a)
Z 1 1
sinxy
xy dx (b) Z 1
2
sinxy logx dx
(c)
Z 1 0
cosxy
xCy2 dx (d) Z 1
1
sinxy 1Cxydx
13. Supposeg; gx and h are continuous on Œa; b/S; and denote H.x; y/ D Rx
a h.u; y/ du; ax < b:Suppose also that
lim
x!b (
sup
y2Sj
g.x; y/H.x; y/j
)
D0 and
Z b
a
gx.x; y/H.x; y/ dx
converges uniformly onS:Show thatRb
a g.x; y/h.x; y/ dxconverges uniformly
onS.
14. Prove Theorem10for the case wheref D f .x; y/is continuous on.a; b Œc; d .
15. Prove Theorem11for the case wheref D f .x; y/is continuous on.a; b Œc; d .
16. Show that
C.y/D
Z 1
1
f .x/cosxy dx and S.y/D
Z 1
1
f .x/sinxy dx
are continuous on. 1;1/if
Z 1
1j
f .x/jdx <1:
17. Supposef is continuously differentiable onŒa;1/, limx!1f .x/D0, and
Z 1 a j
f0.x/jdx <1: Show that the functions
C.y/D
Z 1 a
f .x/cosxy dx and S.y/D
Z 1 a
f .x/sinxy dx
are continuous for ally ¤ 0. Give an example showing that they need not be continuous atyD0.
18. EvaluateF .y/and use Theorem11to evaluateI:
(a) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
dx
1Cy2x2, y ¤ 0; I D Z 1
0
tan 1ax tan 1bx
x dx,
(b) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
xydx,y > 1; I D
Z 1 0
xa xb
logx dx, a,b > 1
(c) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
e xycosx dx, y > 0
I D
Z 1 0
e ax e bx
x cosx dx, a,b > 0
(d) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
e xysinx dx, y > 0
I D
Z 1 0
e ax e bx
x sinx dx, a,b > 0
(e) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
e xsinxy dx; I D
Z 1 0
e x1 cosax
x dx
(f) F .y/ D
Z 1 0
e xcosxy dx; I D
Z 1 0
e xsinax x dx
19. Use Theorem11to evaluate:
(a)
Z 1
0
.logx/nxydx, y > 1, nD0,1,2,. . . .
(b)
Z 1 0
dx
.x2Cy/nC1 dx, y > 0, nD0,1,2, . . . .
(c)
Z 1 0
x2nC1e yx2dx, y > 0, nD0,1,2,. . . .
(d)
Z 1 0
xyxdx, 0 < y < 1.
20. (a) Use Theorem11and integration by parts to show that
F .y/D
Z 1 0
e x2cos2xy dx
satisfies
F0C2yF D0:
(b) Use part(a)to show that
F .y/D
p
2 e
y2 :
21. Show that
Z 1 0
e x2sin2xy dxDe y2
Z y
0
eu2du:
(Hint: See Exercise 20.)
22. State a condition implying that
C.y/D
Z 1 a
f .x/cosxy dx and S.y/D
Z 1 a
aren times differentiable on for ally ¤ 0. (Your condition should imply the hypotheses of Exercise16.)
23. Supposef is continuously differentiable onŒa;1/,
Z 1 a j
.xkf .x//0jdx <1; 0kn; and limx!1xnf .x/D0. Show that if
C.y/D
Z 1 a
f .x/cosxy dx and S.y/D
Z 1 a
f .x/sinxy dx;
then
C.k/.y/D
Z 1 a
xkf .x/cosxy dx and S.k/.y/D
Z 1 a
xkf .x/sinxy dx;
0kn.
24. Differentiating
F .y/D
Z 1 1
cosy x dx under the integral sign yields
Z 1 1
1 xsin
y x dx;
which converges uniformly on any finite interval. (Why?) Does this imply that Fis differentiable for ally?
25. Show that Theorem11and induction imply Eq. (30).
26. Prove Theorem12.
27. Show that ifF .s/D R1 0 e
sxf .x/ dxconverges fors
Ds0, then it converges
uniformly onŒs0;1/. (What’s the difference between this and Theorem13?)
28. Prove: Iff is continuous onŒ0;1/andR1
0 e s0xf .x/ dxconverges, then
lim
s!s0C
Z 1 0
e sxf .x/ dx D
Z 1 0
e s0x
f .x/ dx:
(Hint: See the proof of Theorem 4.5.12, p. 273.)
29. Under the assumptions of Exercise28, show that
lim
s!s0C
Z 1 r
e sxf .x/ dxD
Z 1 r
e s0x
30. Supposef is continuous onŒ0;1/and
F .s/D
Z 1 0
e sxf .x/ dx
converges forsDs0. Show that lims!1F .s/D0. (Hint: Integrate by parts.)
31. (a) Starting from the result of Exercise18(d), letb ! 1and invoke Exer-cise30to evaluate
Z 1 0
e axsinx
x dx; a > 0:
(b) Use(a)and Exercise28to show that
Z 1 0
sinx x dxD
2:
32. (a) Supposef is continuously differentiable onŒ0;1/and
jf .x/j Mes0x; 0
x 1:
Show that
G.s/D
Z 1 0
e sxf0.x/ dx
converges uniformly onŒs1;1/ifs1> s0. (Hint: Integrate by parts.)
(b) Show from part(a)that
G.s/D
Z 1 0
e sxxex2sinex2dx
converges uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0. (Notice that this does not follow from Theorem6or8.)
33. Supposef is continuous onŒ0;1/,
lim
x!0C
f .x/ x
exists, and
F .s/D
Z 1 0
e sxf .x/ dx
converges forsDs0. Show that
Z 1 s0
F .u/ duD
Z 1 0
10
Answers to selected exercises
5. (b)Iff .x; y/ D 1=y fory ¤ 0andf .x; 0/ D 1, thenRb
a f .x; y/ dx does not
converge uniformly onŒ0; d for anyd > 0.
6. (a),(d), and(e)converge uniformly on. 1; [Œ;1/if > 0; (b),(c), and(f)
converge uniformly onŒ;1/if > 0.
17. LetC.y/ D
Z 1 1
cosxy
x dxandS.y/ D
Z 1 1
sinxy
x dx. ThenC.0/ D 1and S.0/D0, whileS.y/D=2ify¤0.
18. (a)F .y/ D
2jyj; I D 2 log
a
b (b)F .y/D 1
yC1; I Dlog aC1 bC1
(c)F .y/ D y
y2C1; I D
1 2
b2C1 a2C1
(d)F .y/D 1
y2C1; I Dtan
1b tan 1a
(e)F .y/ D y
y2C1; I D
1
2log.1Ca
2/
(f)F .y/D 1
y2C1; I Dtan 1a
19. (a). 1/nnŠ.yC1/ n 1 (b) 2 2n 1 2n n
!
y n 1=2
(c) nŠ
2ynC1 .logy/
2(d) 1
.logx/2
22.
Z 1
1j
xnf .x/jdx <1
24.No; the integral definingF diverges for ally.
31. (a)
2 tan