• No results found

Solving the Axisymmetric Inverse Heat Conduction Problem by a Wavelet Dual Least Squares Method

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2020

Share "Solving the Axisymmetric Inverse Heat Conduction Problem by a Wavelet Dual Least Squares Method"

Copied!
13
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

Volume 2009, Article ID 260941,13pages doi:10.1155/2009/260941

Research Article

Solving the Axisymmetric Inverse Heat Conduction

Problem by a Wavelet Dual Least Squares Method

Wei Cheng

1

and Chu-Li Fu

2

1College of Science, Henan University of Technology, Zhengzhou 450001, China 2School of Mathematics and Statistics, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou 730000, China

Correspondence should be addressed to Chu-Li Fu,[email protected]

Received 17 August 2008; Revised 23 January 2009; Accepted 10 March 2009

Recommended by Ugur Abdulla

We consider an axisymmetric inverse heat conduction problem of determining the surface temperature from a fixed location inside a cylinder. This problem is ill-posed; the solutionif it existsdoes not depend continuously on the data. A special project method—dual least squares method generated by the family of Shannon wavelet is applied to formulate regularized solution. Meanwhile, an order optimal error estimate between the approximate solution and exact solution is proved.

Copyrightq2009 W. Cheng and C.-L. Fu. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

1. Introduction

Inverse heat conduction problemsIHCPhave become an interesting subject recently, and many regularization methods have been developed for the analysis of IHCP 1–13. These methods include Tikhonov method 1, 2, mollification method 3, 4, optimal filtering method 5, lines method 6, wavelet and wavelet-Galerkin method 7–11, modified Tikhonov method 12 and “optimal approximations” 13, and so forth. However, most analytical and numerical methods were only used to dealing with IHCP in semiunbounded region. Some works of numerical methods were presented for IHCP in bounded domain14–

19.

Chen et al. 14 applied the hybrid numerical algorithm of Laplace transform technique to the IHCP in a rectangular plate. Busby and Trujillo 15 used the dynamic programming method to investigate the IHCP in a slab. Alifanov and Kerov 16 and Louahlia-Gualous et al. 17 researched IHCP in a cylinder. However to the authors’ knowledge, most of them did not give any stability theory and convergence proofs.

(2)

measurement equipment of temperatureis installed inside the cylinderat the radiusr1,

0 < r1 < R. The correspondingly mathematical model of our problem can be described by

the following axisymmetric heat conduction problem:

∂u

∂t Δu 2u ∂r2

1

r ∂u

∂r, 0< rR, t >0, ur,0 0, 0≤rR,

ur1, t gt, t≥0, ur, t bounded inr0, t >0,

1.1

where the functions ur,· and g·belong to L20,∞ for every fixedr ∈ 0, R, r is the radial coordinate,gtdenotes the temperature history at one fixed radius r10 < r1 < R

of cylinder. We want to recoverur,·forr1 < rR. This problem is ill-posed problem; a

small perturbation in the data may cause dramatically large errors in the solutionur,· The details can be seen inSection 2.

To the authors’ knowledge, up to now, there is no regularization theory with error estimate for problem1.1in the intervalr1< rR. The major objective of this paper is to do

the theoretic stability and convergence estimates for problem1.1.

Xiong and Fu 11 and Regi ´nska 20 solved the sideways heat equation in semi-unbounded region by applying the wavelet dual least squares method, which is based on the family of Meyer wavelet. In this paper, we will apply a wavelet dual least squares method generated by the family of Shannon wavelet to problem1.1in bounded domain for determining surface temperature. According to the optimality results of general regularization theory, we conclude that our error estimate on surface temperature is order optimal.

2. Formulation of Solution of Problem

1.1

As we consider problem1.1inL2Rwith respect to variablet, we extendur ,·, g· : ur1,·, f·:uR ,·, and other functions of variabletappearing in the paper to be zero for t <0. Throughout the paper, we assume that for the exactgthe solutionuexists and satisfies an apriori bound

f·

p:uR,·pE, p≥0, 2.1

wheref·pis defined by

f·

p:

−∞

1ξ2p 2 1/2

. 2.2

Sinceg is measured by the thermocouple, there will be measurement errors, and we would actually have as data some functionL2R, for which

(3)

where the constantδ >0 represents a bound on the measurement error, and · denotes the

L2Rnorm and

√1

2π

−∞e

iξthtdt 2.4

is the Fourier transform of functionht. The problem1.1can be formulated, in frequency space, as follows:

iξur, ξ 2ur, ξ

∂r2

1

r

∂ur, ξ

∂r , r ∈0, R, ξ∈R, 2.5

ur1, ξ gξ, ξ∈R, 2.6

u0, ξ<, ξ∈R. 2.7

Then we have the following lemma.

Lemma 2.1. Problem2.52.7has the solution given by

ur, ξ I0

iξr I0

iξr1

gξ, r∈0, R, ξ∈R, 2.8

whereI0zdenotes modified spherical Bessel function which given by [21]

I0z ∞

k0

1

k!2

z

2

2k

. 2.9

Proof. Due to21, we can solve2.5, in the frequency domain, to obtain

ur, ξ AξI0

iξrBξK0

iξr ξ∈R, 2.10

whereK0zdenotes also modified spherical Bessel function which is given by

K0z −I0z

lnz

2 C

k1

1

k!2

11

2 · · ·

1

k z

2

2k

. 2.11

Combining limz→0K0z ∞with condition2.7, we obtain0, that is,

ur, ξ AξI0

iξr, r∈0, R, ξ∈R. 2.12

According to21, there holds

I0

iξrber|ξ|riσbei|ξ|r

k0

|ξ|r/24k

k!22k! 1/2

(4)

whereσsgnξ, both berxand beixdenote the Kelvin functions. Since 0≤rR,|ξ| ≥0, we have

k0

|ξ|r/24k

k!22k! 1

|ξ|r/28

2!24!

|ξ|r/212

3!26! · · · ≥1. 2.14

Therefore, for 0≤rR, ξ∈R,

I0

iξr

k0

|ξ|r/24k

k!22k! 1/2

≥1. 2.15

Solving the systems2.6and2.12using2.15we get

Aξ I−1 0

iξr1

gξ. 2.16

Substitution ofin2.16into2.12, we obtain2.8.

Applying an inverse Fourier transform to2.8, problem1.1has the solution

ur, t √1

2π

−∞e

iξtI0

iξr I0

iξr1

gξdξ, r, t∈0, R×R. 2.17

In order to obtain ill-posedness of problem1.1forr, t ∈ r1, R×R, we need the

following lemma.

Lemma 2.2. If function |I0

iξr| satisfies 2.15, then there exist positive constants ck, k

1,2,3,4,such that, forr ∈r1, R

c1exp

|ξ|/2rr1

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

c2exp

|ξ|/2r−r1

, ξ∈R, 2.18

c3exp

|ξ|/2r−R

I0

iξr I0

iξR

c4exp

|ξ|/2r−R

, ξ∈R. 2.19

Proof. First, due to21and2.15, we have, forr ∈r1, Rand|ξ| → ∞,

I0

iξrber2|ξ|rbei2|ξ|r1/2 exp

|ξ|/2r

2πr|ξ|

1O

1

(5)

then there exist positive constantsck, k1,2,3,4,such that, for|ξ|large enough, say|ξ| ≥ξ0

c1

exp|ξ|/2r

2πr|ξ|

I0

iξrc2

exp|ξ|/2r

2πr|ξ|

, r∈r1, R,

c3

exp|ξ|/2r1

2πr1

|ξ|

I0

iξr1≤c4

exp|ξ|/2r1

2πr1

|ξ| .

2.21

From these we know that there exist positive constantsc5andc6such that, forr ∈r1, Rand

|ξ| ≥ξ0,

c5exp

|ξ|/2r−r1

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

c6exp

|ξ|/2r−r1

. 2.22

Then, since function|I0

iξr/I0

iξr1|is continuous in the closed regionr1, R×−ξ0, ξ0.

Threrfore, there exist constantsc7andc8such that, forr∈r1, Rand|ξ| ≤ξ0,

c7exp

|ξ|/2rr1

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

c8exp

|ξ|/2rr1

. 2.23

Finally, combining inequalities2.22with2.23, we can see that there exist others constants

c1 and c2 such that, for r ∈ r1, R, inequalities 2.18 are valid. Similarly, we obtain

inequalities2.19.

In order to formulate problem1.1forr1 < rRin terms of an operator equation in

the spaceXL2R, we define an operatorK

r :ur,· →g·, that is,

ur,·∈X, Krur, t gt, r1< rR. 2.24

From2.8, we have

Krur, ξ

I0

iξr1

I0

iξr ur, ξ gξ. 2.25

DenoteKrur, ξ : Krur, ξ , and we can see thatKr : L2R → L2Ris a multiplication

operator:

Krur, ξ

I0

iξr1

I0

iξr ur, ξ. 2.26

(6)

Lemma 2.3. LetKrbe the adjoint toKr, thenKr corresponds to the following problem where the

left-hand side∂u/∂tof problem1.1is replaced by∂U/∂t, says

∂U

∂t ΔU 2U

∂r2

1

r ∂U

∂r , 0< rR, t≥0, Ur,0 0, 0≤rR,

Ur1, t gt, t≥0, Ur, t bounded inr0, t >0,

2.27

Kr

I0

iξr1

I0

iξr

. 2.28

Proof. Via the the following relations, combining with2.26,

Kru, υ

Kru, υ

u, Kr

υu, Krυu, Krυ, 2.29

we can get the adjoint operatorKr ofKr in frequency domain

Kr Kr

I0

iξr1

I0

iξr

. 2.30

On the other hand, the problem 2.27 can be formulated, in frequency space, as follows:

iξUr, ξ 2Ur, ξ

∂r2

1

r

∂Ur, ξ

∂r , r∈0, R, ξ∈R,

Ur1, ξ gξ, ξ∈R,

U0, ξ<, ξ∈R.

2.31

Taking the conjugate operator for problem 2.5–2.7, we realize that Ur, ξ ur, ξ . Therefore, byLemma 2.1, we conclude that

Ur, ξ ur, ξ I0

iξr I0

iξr1

(7)

that is,

I0

iξr1

I0

iξr

Ur, ξ KrUr, ξ :KrU. 2.33

Hence the conclusion ofLemma 2.3is proved.

The Parseval formula for the Fourier transform together with inequality2.18, there holds

ur,·2ur,·2

−∞ur,·

2

−∞

gξerr1

|ξ|/22

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

2

c21

−∞

gξerr1

|ξ|/22dξ.

2.34

This implies that , which is Fourier transform of exact datagt, must decay rapidly at high frequencies sincer1< r. But such a decay is not likely to occur in the Fourier transform

of the measured noisy datatatr r1. So, small perturbation ofgtin high frequency

components can blow up and completely destroy the solutionur, tgiven by2.17forr ∈ r1, R.

3. Wavelet Dual Least Squares Method

3.1. Dual Least Squares Method

A general projection method for the operator equationKug,K:X L2RXL2Ris

generated by two subspace families{Vj}and{Yj}ofXand the approximate solutionujVj

is defined to be the solution of the following problem:

Kuj, yg, y,yYj, 3.1

where·,·denotes the inner product inX. IfVjRK∗and subspacesYjare chosen in such

a way that

KYj Vj. 3.2

Then we have a special case of projection method known as the dual least squares method. If

{ψλ}λI

jis an orthogonal basis ofVjandis the solution of the equation

(8)

then the approximate solution is explicitly given by the expression

uj

λIj

g, yλ 1

ψλ. 3.4

3.2. Shannon Wavelets

In22, the Shannon scaling function isφ sinπt/πtand its Fourier transform is

φξ

1, |ξ| ≤π,

0, otherwise. 3.5

The corresponding wavelet functionψis given by its Fourier transform

ψξ

eiξ/2, π≤ |ξ| ≤2π,

0, otherwise. 3.6

Let us list some notation:φj,kt:2j/2φ2jtk,ψj,kt:2j/2ψ2jtk,j, k∈Z,Ψ−1,k :φ0,k

andΨl,k:ψl,kforl≥0, the index set

I {j, k}:j, k∈Z⊂Z2, IJ

{j, k}:j −1,0, . . . , J−1;k∈Z⊂Z2. 3.7

BecauseVJ VJ−1⊕WJ−1 VJ−2⊕WJ−2⊕WJ−1 · · · V0⊕W1⊕ · · · ⊕WJ−1, hence we can

define the subspacesVJ

VJspan{Ψλ}λIJ. 3.8

Define an orthogonal projectionPJ :L2R →VJ:

PJϕ

λIJ

ϕ,Ψλ

Ψλ,ϕL2R, 3.9

then from3.4we easily conclude uJ PJu. From the point of view of an application to

the problem1.1, the important property of Shannon wavelets is the compactness of their support in the frequency space. Indeed, since

ψj,kξ 2−j/2ei2

j

ψ2−jξ, φj,kξ 2−j/2ei2

j

φ2−jξ, 3.10

it follows that for anyk∈Z

suppψj,k

ξ:π2j ≤ |ξ| ≤π2j1, supp φj,k

(9)

From3.9,PJ can be seen as a low-pass filter. The frequencies with greater thanπ2J1are

filtered away.

Theorem 3.1. Ifur, tis the solution of problem1.1satisfying the conditionuR,·p≤E, then for any fixedr∈r1, R

ur,·PJur,·c−1 3

2J1−perR

1/2π2J

E. 3.12

Proof. From3.9, we have

ur,· λ

ur,·,Ψλ

Ψλ,

PJur,·

λIJ

ur,·,Ψλ

Ψλ.

3.13

Due to Parseval relation and2.8,2.19, and2.1, there holds

ur,·PJur,·ur,·PJur,·

λI

u,Ψλ Ψλ

λIJ

u,Ψλ Ψλ

λIjJ1

u,Ψλ Ψλ

λIjJ1 I0

i·r I0

i·r1

!

g·,Ψλ

" Ψλ

λIjJ1 I0

i·r I0

i·R

!

f·,Ψλ

" Ψλ ≤ sup

π2J≤|ξ|≤π2J1

|ξ|−p

I0 iξr I0 iξR

λIjJ1

#

1 ·2p/2f·,Ψλ

$ Ψλ ≤ sup

π2J≤|ξ|≤π2J1

c4ξperR

|ξ|/2Ec 4

2J1−perR

1/2π2J

E.

3.14

Hence the conclusion of Theorem3.1is proved.

4. Error Estimates via Dual Least Squares Method Approximation

Before giving error estimates, we present firstly subspacesYj. According toKYj Vj, the

subspacesYjare spanned byρλ, λIJ, where

Kρλ Ψλ, kλρλ−1,

ρλ

(10)

ρλcan be determined by solving the following parabolic equationseeLemma 2.3:

∂U

∂t ΔU 2U

∂r2

1

r ∂U

∂r , 0< rR, t≥0, Ur,0 0, 0≤rR,

Ur1, t Ψj,kt, t≥0,

Ur, t bounded inr0, t >0.

4.2

Since suppψj,kis compact, the solution exists for anyt∈0,∞. Similarly the solution of the

adjoint equation is unique. Therefore for a givenΨλ,ρλcan be uniquely determined according

to4.2, furthermore

ρλ I0 iξr I0 iξr1

Ψλξ⇐⇒

I0 iξr I0 iξr1

Ψλξ, λ{j, k}. 4.3

The approximate solution for noisy datais explicitly given by

PJuδr, t J

λIJ

uδ,Ψλ

Ψλ

λIJ

gδ, yλ

1

Ψλ. 4.4

Now we will devote to estimating the errorPJuδPJu.

Theorem 4.1. If is noisy data satisfying the condition g·−· ≤ δ, then for any fixed

r∈r1, R

PJuδPJuc4err1

1/2π2J

δ. 4.5

Proof. From4.3, we have I0

iξr/I0

iξr1kλΨλ. Note thatPJuδgiven by4.4,PJu

given by3.4and2.18, forr1< rR, there holds

PJuδr,·−PJur,·

λIJ

g, yλ

1

Ψλ

λIJ

g, yλ

1 Ψλ

λIJ

g,

I0

i·r I0

i·r1

Ψλ

" 1 Ψλ ≤ sup

π2J−1≤|ξ|≤π2J

I0 iξr I0 iξr1 ·

λIJ

g, Ψλ Ψλ

(11)

≤ sup

π2J−1≤|ξ|≤π2J

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

· PJgδg

≤ sup

π2J−1≤|ξ|≤π2J

I0

iξr I0

iξr1

·δ

c2 sup

π2J−1≤|ξ|≤π2J

err1

|ξ|/2δ

c2err1

1/2π2J

δ.

4.6

Hence the conclusion ofTheorem 4.1is proved.

The following is the main result of this paper.

Theorem 4.2. Letube the exact solution of 1.1and letPJuδbe given by4.4. Ifggδ ≤δand

JJδis such that

J log2

2

π

1

Rr1

ln

E δ

lnE

δ

−2p 2

, 4.7

then for any fixedr∈r1, R

ur,·PJuδr,·

E1−Rr/Rr1δRr/Rr1

lnE

δ

−2p1−Rr/Rr1

Co1 forδ−→0,

4.8

whereC c4R−r12pc2.

Proof. CombiningTheorem 4.1withTheorem 3.1, and noting the choice rule4.7ofJ, we can obtain

ur,·PJuδr,·

c4

2J1−perR√1/2π2J

Ec2err1

1/2π2J

δ

c4E

Rr1

2p

ln

E δ

lnE

δ

−2p !−2p E

δ

lnE

δ

−2p!rR/Rr1

c2δ E δ

lnE

δ

−2p!rr1/Rr1

E1−Rr/Rr1δRr/Rr1

lnE

δ

−2p1−Rr/Rr1% c4R−r1lnE/δ2p

lnE/δlnE/δ−2p2p

c2

&

.

(12)

Note that

lnE/δ

lnE/δlnE/δ−2p

lnE/δ

lnE/δ−2plnlnE/δ −→1 forδ−→0, 4.10

thus, there holds, forδ → 0

ur,·PJuδr,·

E1−Rr/Rr1δRr/Rr1

lnE

δ

−2p1−Rr/Rr1 c4

Rr1

2p

c2o1

.

4.11

Hence the conclusion ofTheorem 4.2is proved.

Remark 4.3. iWhenp0 andr1 < r < R, estimate4.8is a H ¨older stability estimate given

by

ur,·PJuδr,·c

4c2E1−Rr/Rr1δRr/Rr1. 4.12

iiWhenp >0, r1< r < R, estimate4.8is a logarithmical H ¨older stability estimate. iiiWhenp >0, rR, estimate4.3becomes

uR,·R,·≤E

lnE

δ

−2p

c4R−r12pc2o1

−→0 forδ−→0. 4.13

This is a logarithmical stability estimate.

Remark 4.4. In general, the a-priori boundEis unknown in practice, in this case, with

Jlog2

2

π

1

Rr1ln

1

δ

ln1

δ

−2p 2

, 4.14

then

ur,·PJuδr,·≤δRr/Rr1

ln1

δ

−2p1−Rr/Rr1

Co1 forδ−→0, 4.15

whereCc4R−r12pEc2.

Acknowledgments

(13)

Fundamental Research Fund for Natural Science of Education Department of Henan Province of ChinaNo. 2009B110007.

References

1 A. Carasso, “Determining surface temperatures from interior observations,”SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics, vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 558–574, 1982.

2 C.-L. Fu, “Simplified Tikhonov and Fourier regularization methods on a general sideways parabolic equation,”Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, vol. 167, no. 2, pp. 449–463, 2004.

3 D. A. Murio, The Mollification Method and the Numerical Solution of Ill-Posed Problems, A Wiley-Interscience Publication, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, USA, 1993.

4 D. N. H`ao and H.-J. Reinhardt, “On a sideways parabolic equation,”Inverse Problems, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 297–309, 1997.

5 T. I. Seidman and L. Eld´en, “An ‘optimal filtering’ method for the sideways heat equation,”Inverse Problems, vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 681–696, 1990.

6 L. Eld´en, “Solving the sideways heat equation by a method of lines,”Journal of Heat Transfer, vol. 119, pp. 406–412, 1997.

7 L. Eld´en, F. Berntsson, and T. Regi ´nska, “Wavelet and Fourier methods for solving the sideways heat equation,”SIAM Journal on Scientific Computing, vol. 21, no. 6, pp. 2187–2205, 2000.

8 T. Regi ´nska and L. Eld´en, “Solving the sideways heat equation by a wavelet-Galerkin method,”

Inverse Problems, vol. 13, no. 4, pp. 1093–1106, 1997.

9 T. Regi ´nska and L. Eld´en, “Stability and convergence of the wavelet-Galerkin method for the sideways heat equation,”Journal of Inverse and Ill-Posed Problems, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 31–49, 2000.

10 C.-L. Fu and C. Y. Qiu, “Wavelet and error estimation of surface heat flux,”Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, vol. 150, no. 1, pp. 143–155, 2003.

11 X.-T. Xiong and C.-L. Fu, “Determining surface temperature and heat flux by a wavelet dual least squares method,”Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics, vol. 201, no. 1, pp. 198–207, 2007.

12 W. Cheng, C.-L. Fu, and Z. Qian, “A modified Tikhonov regularization method for a spherically symmetric three-dimensional inverse heat conduction problem,” Mathematics and Computers in Simulation, vol. 75, no. 3-4, pp. 97–112, 2007.

13 U. Tautenhahn, “Optimal stable approximations for the sideways heat equation,”Journal of Inverse and Ill-Posed Problems, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 287–307, 1997.

14 H.-T. Chen, S.-Y. Lin, and L.-C. Fang, “Estimation of surface temperature in two-dimensionnal inverse heat conduction problems,”International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, vol. 44, no. 8, pp. 1455–1463, 2001.

15 H. R. Busby and D. M. Trujillo, “Numerical soluition to a two-dimensionnal inverse heat conduction problem,”International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 349–359, 1985.

16 O. M. Alifanov and N. V. Kerov, “Determination of external thermal load parameters by solving the two-dimensional inverse heat-conduction problem,”Journal of Engineering Physics, vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 1049–1053, 1981.

17 H. Louahlia-Gualous, P. K. Panday, and E. A. Artyukhin, “The inverse determination of the local heat transfer coefficients for nucleate boiling on horizontal cylinder,”Journal of Heat Transfer, vol. 125, no. 1, pp. 1087–1095, 2003.

18 Y. C. Hon and T. Wei, “A fundamental solution method for inverse heat conduction problem,”

Engineering Analysis with Boundary Elements, vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 489–495, 2004.

19 A. Shidfar and R. Pourgholi, “Numerical approximation of solution of an inverse heat conduction problem based on Legendre polynomials,”Applied Mathematics and Computation, vol. 175, no. 2, pp. 1366–1374, 2006.

20 T. Regi ´nska, “Application of wavelet shrinkage to solving the sideways heat equation,”BIT Numerical Mathematics, vol. 41, no. 5, pp. 1101–1110, 2001.

21 M. Abramowitz and I. A. Stegun, Eds.,Handbook of Mathematical Functions: With Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables, Dover, New York, NY, USA, 1972.

References

Related documents

(2005) Physical education, youth sport and lifelong participation: the importance of early learning experiences... Andrew Sprake and

Be- cause compartments have the ability to choose whether data is stored to the compartment, via the secure store instruction, or stored to the shared compartment using a regular

To respect the privacy of the individual I arranged for two user profile bits to be added to our existing profile facility (which determines whether a user automatically sees a

Council Comments and Recommendations 1 Executive Summary 15 Chapter 1 Introduction 21 1.1 Background and purpose of study 22 1.2 Focus on 55-69 year olds 23 1.3 Study design 25

5 VPO Power supply output (Positive – to next device) 6 VP’ Power Supply output (Negative – to next device) 7 DP’ NAi data (Positive – to next device). 8 DN’ NAi data

There are a lot of companies getting into cloud services now, but what separates Concerto from the others is their proven expertise and the seamless way they work with my

12. Point to the label again and read, “geography”.. Pick up the compass and say, “This compass helps us to figure out which direction we are going.” Hold it up so that the

The Method of Least Squares is a procedure to determine the best fit line to data; the proof uses simple calculus and linear algebra.. For example, the force of a spring