arXiv:2101.02080v2 [physics.flu-dyn] 7 Jan 2021
Peng Yue∗ and Jingping Xiao†
University of Electronic Science and technology of China, Chengdu, China and China Aerodynamics Research and Development Center, Mianyang, China
Ke Xu‡ and Yiyu Lu§
University of Electronic Science and technology of China, Chengdu, China Dewei Peng¶
China Aerodynamics Research and Development Center, Mianyang, China
In the field of mechanics, one of important and difficult problem is called by fluid separation. Hitherto, the separation problem can not be described accurately and mathematically, which leads to great errors in the design and problem prediction of fliud machine engineering. Because of the nonlinear uncertainty obvious state of separation, it is difficult to accurately analyze the general law of separation by using experimental methods. Because at the moment of fluid separation, physical field is a state field. It will bring new ideas and methods to the mathematical prediction of fluid separation. In this paper, the state conditions of fluid separation are revealed. Through the mathematical analysis of the famous Navier-Stokes equation, a general separation equation suitable for viscous compressible fluid is obtained. It lays a foundation for the future research on the mechanism of fluid turbulence and solving engineering problems.
I. INTRDOCTION
The earliest study of this phenomenon began in 1883. British scientist Renault discovered two different forms of fluid by using the circular tube flow experiment: one is laminar flow, which is characterized by orderly move-ment and immiscibility with each other; the other is tur-bulent flow, which is characterized by the fluid particles are irregular, intermingled, and the trace is tortuous and chaotic. The dimensionless parameters are defined, i.e. Reynolds number and Sherwood number[1][2]. Reynolds number is mainly used to distinguish the two forms. Sherwood number is the ratio of flow mass transfer and diffusion mass transfer. The current research shows that Sherwood number is related to the spatial distribution of velocity. However, up to now, it is impossible to give a exact definition of turbulence.
In theoretical research, based on the pulsating veloc-ity method in the time domain of Reynolds equation, the physical phenomena described by transition separa-tion are analyzed, the fluid stability theory of transi-tion separatransi-tion is summarized, and the basic equatransi-tions of transition and separation are established. Thus, a semi-empirical mathematical model[3] that can predict the turning point of separation based on experimental data is established.Magdy Saeed Hussin [4]discretized compress-ible Navier-Stokes equations with finite volume method and solved them with semi-implicit pressure linking
algo-∗Emial:[email protected] †Emial:[email protected] ‡Emial:[email protected] §Emial:Yiyu˙[email protected] ¶Email:[email protected]
rithm on unstructured grids. Compared with the classi-cal method, the numericlassi-cal dissipation within the program is reduced and the accuracy of the solution is improved. Maryam Azarpira[5] developed a 3D model to study the flow field in hollow vortices, which can well predict the characteristics of vortices. Qian Weiqi[6] proposed a K-SST two-equation turbulence model considering the in-fluence of intermittent function, and proved through ex-periments that this model has a good ability to predict transition position.
By describing the physical significance of the mathe-matical model of vorticity stability, the law of turbulence occurrence and development as well as the stress response of small disturbances are expounded, and the turbulence which has not been strictly defined in the world is given a qualitative explanation, which is expected to provide a new methodology for turbulence research. In Febru-ary 2018, Jakob Kuhnen [7]in Nature Physics in a paper published: by using the rotor in the circular tube to en-hance the turbulence level, and make severe turbulence flow through the downstream rotor, found that the tur-bulent strength quickly reduce, a laminar flow, the ex-periments show that the interaction between the eddy, and eventually completely dissipation phenomenon, but the study did not quantitative description of separation and the transition phenomenon; In June 2019, Johnstone Shaun P.[8] published an article in Science: observing the non-equilibrium distribution of vorticity through experi-ments, and obtaining the characteristics of inverse energy cascade driven by evaporating heating of vorticity, which provides a novel method for studying critical points of fluid balance.
In the study of mathematical theory, by considering the general existence of solutions of Navier Stokes equa-tions under different physical phenomena of ”explosive solutions”, we can indirectly explain the smooth
solu-tions of Navier Stokes equasolu-tions under extreme condi-tions. It is of great value to prove the smooth solution of Navier-Stokes equation in the future.
On the physical theory research, through the math-ematical description of rotating tear and separation phenomenon, build the transition and separation of the mathematical model and numerical analysis algo-rithms, separation is expected to reveal the nature of the transition phenomenon, further explain the na-ture of turbulence[9][10], turbulence of fluid physics of randomness[11][12], the uncertainty of turbulence[13], etc have important physical meaning.
In practice, computational fluid dynamics (CFD) and experimental methods [14][15][16] are used to predict the location of the turning point, but the relative error is still nearly 20%. Such errors are acceptable in the field of en-gineering. However, theoretical problems of great signifi-cance to individuals cannot be ignored, such as the quasi-ordered structure of large vortices[17][18] and the nature of turbulence occurrence [19]. And advanced unsteady flow field technology in engineering, such as microflow control [20], aircraft design under extreme conditions[21], low-altitude flight stability [22][23][24], etc. Therefore, based on the mathematical model of separation and tran-sition, the development of a calculation method to accu-rately predict the location of transition separation has a great research space.
The paper is studied from the point of view of math-ematics and physics, in order to better predict the loca-tion. According to Eulerian description method, it can be considered that the velocity of a space point in the fluid at a certain time is instantaneous velocity, and the instantaneous velocity minus the time average velocity is pulsating velocity. When the fluid develops into turbu-lence, the fluctuating velocity is uncertain and random. In this study, the sum of average velocity and fluctuating velocity is used to describe the instantaneous velocity of a fluid particle in any flow field, and it is correlated with the Navier-Stokes equations. Finally, the governing equa-tions affecting the separation flow are obtained and the physical essence of separation phenomenon is analyzed.
II. GENERAL MATHEMATICAL MODEL OF FLOWFIELD
In the field of fluid mechanics, Navier Stokes equations are important equations to describe fluidflow. Assuming that the fluidflow space is Ω⊆R3, and the velocity vector field is in the differential manifold, which is constructed byM = (Ω,S), whose cotangent vector field represents
its velocity fieldui∈TM. Since the bounded space Ω is homeomorphic with the smooth manifoldM with edges, we can find a mapping ϕsatisfying the following condi-tions:
ϕ:xj7→ui, xj ∈Ω, ui∈TM
Therefore, for any velocity field, the space-time
evolu-tion of the physical field should satisfy the Navier Stokes equations:
Lemma 1 (The Navier-Stokes equtions). For Ω ⊆R3,
ui =ϕ(xj)∈TM and xj ∈Ω, so ui satisfies continuity
equation
∂ρ ∂t +ρu
•,i
i,•= 0; (1) and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρ∂ui ∂t +ρuju •,j i,• =σ ••,j ij,• +fi (2)
whereρis the density of fluid;fi is the volumetric force
of the fluid;σij =−pδij+τij is the stress state tensor of
the fluid, which is expressed in following expression for Newton fluid in isomorphism.
σij =−pδij− 1 3u
•,k
k,•δij+µ(uj,i−ui,j) (3)
herepis the isotropic pressure, τij is the deviator stress
tensor,δijis the Kronecker symbol;µis the coefficient of
expansion viscosity.
Assuming that there are two kinds of flowfield, station-ary flowfield and impulsive flowfield, then we can get the following theorem.
Definition 1 (Pulsating velocity). For any flowfield
spaceΩ, assuming that the generalized coordinates of the system are∀qi∈TM, the generalized velocity of the fluid
particle isq˙i, the pulsating velocity of the fluid isq˙′i and
the average velocity of the fluid particle is q¯˙i. At a fixed
time, the velocity of any fluid particle in any flowfield is the sum of the pulsating velocity and the average velocity of the fluid:
˙
qi = ˙q′i+ ¯˙qi (4) Since vector field is the basic element of normed vector space and satisfies the superposition principle, theorem 1 can be proved directly, so the proof is ignored.
If the above relation is combined with the Navier-Stokes equations, the Reynolds average equation can be obtained. Turbulence in fluid dynamics is a chaotic state of motion, which is difficult to explain with the current research situation, but it is also a very common phe-nomenon, causing many problems in practical engineer-ing applications.
III. MATHEMATICAL AND MECHANICAL CONDITIONS OF FLUID SEPARATION
At present, the phenomenon of transition from laminar flow to turbulent flow in fluidflow can be partly explained by bifurcation theory. For example, by simulating the
flowfield characteristics near the common subsonic air-foil, it can be seen that there is a strong correlation be-tween separation and bifurcation phenomenon of nonlin-ear dynamics. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a mathematical model of separated flow.
Therefore, in order to accurately describe the flowfield characteristics from the mathematical and physical point of view, it is assumed that the turbulence is in a new fluc-tuating velocity fluidfield, which also exists in the man-ifold ∀q′
j ∈ TM. Therefore, it is assumed that there is a fluid particle in the field. In a spherical region with the particle as the center and the radius ε > 0 estab-lished, if the pulsating velocity of the point ˙q′
i satisfies the following conditions:
Theorem 1 (Conditions of Fluid Separation).
Assum-ing that position xk ∈ Ωhas a neighbourhood U(xk, ε),
there is xj ∈ {xi|xi ∈U(xk, ε),kxk −xik < ε,∀ε > 0},
the generalized velocityq˙j satisfies the following form for
state equation, which is the pulsating velocity at the sep-aration position is 0, can be exprssed as:
˙
q′
j = 0, (5)
for first order derivative process equation, when the spa-tial derivative of the fluctuating velocity at the separation position is not zero, is expressed as:
dq˙′ j dt = ∂q˙′ j ∂t + ˙qkq˙ ′•,k j,• 6= 0 (6) whenε→0,xk ∈Ωis the fluid separation position.
The formula 5 and formula 6 can be regarded as the basic condition of separation. When the particle is at the separation position, although the pulsating velocity has not occurred, there is pulsating acceleration. As time goes on, the pulsating acceleration will induce the ap-pearance of pulsating velocity at the next moment, mak-ing the fluid particles separate. Moreover, because of the radius of the spherical region, the pulsating velocity of the particle may be different from that of its neighbor-ing fluid particles, that is, the velocity vector is different. To sum up, this phenomenon induces fluid separation, and the fluid particles with fluctuating velocity gradu-ally evolve into turbulence, while the unchanged particles are still laminar flow, which is one of the reasons for the phenomenon of separated flow.
IV. MATHEMATICAL MODEL OF SEPARATED IN FLUIDFLOW
To sum up, the mathematical relationship between the two velocities before and after the separation position is an important physical quantity. In order to clearly describe the process of fluid separation, we set up a new physical quantity
Definition 2(Velocity strain tensor). ForΩ⊆R3,λji ∈
TM, if satisfies the fowlloing relationship
˙
q′
i= ¯˙qjλji,q˙′i ∈TM,q¯˙j∈TM (7)
then tensor λji ∈TM is called by velocity strain tensor,
in physics, it can be used to evaluate the measurement tensor of the ratio of pulsating velocity to average veloc-ity.
According to the sensitivity principle of the initial boundary value problem of nonlinear dynamics, consid-ering the external physical factors, the fluid separation phenomenon will also occur. So the reason of fluid sepa-ration can be divided into two factors: active factor and passive factor. Between them, the active factors are all kinds of influence factors caused by the initial state of the fluid, while the passive factors are all kinds of influ-ence and interferinflu-ence caused by the geometry and phys-ical conditions of the fluid. At present, this study does not specifically analyze which factor causes the separa-tion phenomenon of fluid, but discusses the basic situ-ation of the two states of fluid from the perspective of phenomenological physics.
Then we consider two scenarios, one is that the fluid does not separate and the other is that the fluid separates under the action of physical properties.
Under the first circumstance, due to various reasons, there is no fluid separation in the flowfield. There is no pulsating velocity. The velocity of fluid particle is only related to the average velocity of fluid. Therefore, the pulsating velocity of fluid ˙q′
iin formula 4 can be regarded as 0, so formula 4 can be simplified as:
˙
qi = ¯˙qi (8) By introducing formula 8 into the Navier-Stokes equa-tions describing fluid motion, the de equaequa-tions without fluid separation can be obtained as follow, for continuity equation
∂ρ ∂t + (ρq¯˙i)
•,i
,• = 0 (9)
and for momentum equation under the action of viscosity, the temporal and spatial variation of the flowfield can be described as following: ρ∂q¯˙i ∂t +ρq¯˙kq¯˙ •,k i,• =σ ••,k ik,• +fi (10) However, it can be seen from the subscript of formula 8 that the frames of the two fields of the index coincide. In order to make the expression of the formula more clear and avoid problems in later calculation and simplifica-tion, formula 9 and formula 10 can be established the following theorem.
Theorem 2 (No separation). For Ω⊆R3,q˙∈TM and
˙
under the action of physical properties,q˙i satisfies conti-nuity equation ∂ρ ∂t +ρ •,iq¯˙ jδij+ρq¯˙ •,i j,•δ j i = 0 (11)
and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρ∂(¯˙qjδ j i) ∂t +ρq¯˙j1q¯˙ •,k j2,•δ j1 k δ j2 i =g (1) i (12)
whereρis the density of fluid;fi is the volumetric force
of the fluid; σik(1) is the stress state tensor of the fluid under the first circumstance, external force field gi(1) =
σik,(1)•••,k+fi.
Under the second circumstance, when the fluid is sep-arated and due to the generation of pulsating velocity, the velocity of fluid particles should not only take into account the average velocity of the fluid, but also its pulsating velocity. Therefore, in order to calculate the instantaneous velocity of the fluid particle at this time more simply, the pulsation velocity is replaced by the av-erage velocity by formula 7 and substituted into formula 4 to obtain the simplified expression for the velocity of the fluid particle, establish the concept of separation ra-tio tensor.
Definition 3(Separation ratio tensor). For Ω⊆R3,ξji
andλji ∈TM, if they satisfy the fowlloing relationship
ξij=δ j i +λ
j
i (13)
then tensor ξij is separation ratio tensor, which can be
used to evaluate the measurement tensor for describing the ratio of average velocity to instantaneous velocity.
Therefore, we can draw the following conclusion ˙ qi = ¯˙qjδ j i + ¯˙qjλ j i = ¯˙qj(δ j i +λ j i) = ¯˙qjξ j i (14) At the same time, the condition of fluid separation changes accordingly. According to the above analysis and formula 5 and formula 6, when the pulsation velocity of the fluid particle is 0 and the pulsation acceleration is not 0, this moment is the moment when the particle is the separation position. Therefore, the following theory is obtained:
Theorem 3 (Conditions of Fluid Separation). If there
is the fluid separation under the action of physical prop-erties, the velocity strain tensor λji)∈TM satisfies
con-tinuity equation
λji = 0 (15)
for time derivative of the velocity strain tensor, when the spatial derivative of the fluctuating velocity at the sepa-ration position is not zero, is expressed as:
dλji dt = ∂λji ∂t + ˙qkλ j,k i,• 6= 0 (16)
Therefore, in order to make a better comparison with the phenomenon without fluid separation, formula 14 and formula 15, formula 16 are combined with Navier-Stokes equations, and the following equations can be obtained: Theorem 4 (Seprated). For Ω ⊆ R3, q˙ ∈ TM and
˙
qi=ϕ(xk), xk ∈Ω, If there is the fluid separation under
the action of physical properties, q˙i satisfies continuity
equation
∂ρ ∂t +ρ
•,iq¯˙
jξij+ρq¯˙jξj,ii,•= 0 (17) and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρ∂(¯˙qjξ j i) ∂t +ρq¯˙j1q¯˙ •,k j2,•ǫ j1j2 kl +ρq¯˙j1q¯˙j2ǫ j1j2,k kl,• =g (2) i (18)
where λji ∈ TM is the separation ratio tensor, ρ is the
density of fluid; fi is the volumetric force of the fluid;
σik(1) is the stress state tensor of the fluid under the first
circumstance, here adjustment tensor coefficient ǫj1j2ki =
ξkj1ξ j2
i , external force field g (2) i =σ
(2)••,k ik,• +fi.
In order to better compare the two assumed flowfield states, the following relationship are needed and easy to get. ǫj1j2ki =ξj1k ξij2−δ j1 k δ j2 i =λ j1 k λ j2 i +λ j1 k δ j2 i +δ j1 k λ j2 i (19) The flowfield separation is determined by the physical properties of the fluid itself. Therefore, if the separation field is subtracted from the assumed non separation field, the equation causing the separation can be obtained Theorem 5 (Separation equation). For Ω ⊆ R3, q˙ ∈
TM and q˙i =ϕ(xk), xk ∈Ω, If there is the fluid
sepa-ration under the action of physical properties,q˙i satisfies
continuity equation ρ•,iq¯˙ jλ j i+ρq¯˙ •,i j,•λ j i+ρq¯˙jλ j,i i,• = 0 (20) and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρ ∂q¯˙jλji ∂t +ρq¯˙j1 ¯˙ q•j2,,k•ǫ j1j2 ki + ¯˙qj2λ j1 k λ j2,k i,• =gi (21)
where λji ∈ TM is the separation ratio tensor, ρ is the
density of fluid;ǫj1j2kl is the adjustment tensor coefficient,
external force fieldgi=σ(2)•• ,k ik,• −σ (1)••,k ik,• , hereσ (1) ik and
σik(2) is the stress state tensor of the fluid under the first
and second circumstances.
At the same time, equation 15 and equation 16 with the separation condition is substituted into equations 20 and 21, and the following equations can be obtained: Theorem 6(Difference equation). ForΩ⊆R3,q˙∈TM
under the action of physical properties,q˙i satisfies
conti-nuity equation
λj,ii,•= 0, λ
j
i ∈TM (22)
and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρq¯˙j
∂λji
∂t =gi (23)
where λji ∈ TM is the separation ratio tensor, ρ is the
density of fluid;ǫj1j2kl is the adjustment tensor coefficient,
external force fieldgi=σ (2)••,k ik,• −σ (1)••,k ik,• , hereσ (1) ik and
σik(2) is the stress state tensor of the fluid under the first and second circumstances.
At this point, the mathematical significance of formula 22 can be described according to Gauss theorem: when fluid separation is about to take place, the separation position is taken as the origin and an open sphere with radius ε > 0 is established. Once again, according to Formula(13) and using Gauss’s theorem, the following conclusions can be drawn:
λj,ii,•= lim∆τ →0 1 ∆τ I σ λjin idσ= 0 (24) In the study of fluid mechanics, the velocity of fluid is one of the important parameters to describe the fluid motion, and there are many application methods to mea-sure the velocity of any particle in the fluid, such as pitot tube, hot-wire anemometer and so on. According to the derivation of the above equations, it can be seen that the generation of separation flow and transition phenomena have important relations with the flow velocity of the fluid. Due to the difference of velocity field, and many factors will lead to changes in speed, such as the shape of flow, the flow of the variable form, the friction factor of fluid, heat and other factors, such as surface roughness, so based on the research of the speed, can will most of the factors are taken into account, improve the accuracy and completeness of the mathematical model.
As there are various small vortices produced in the turbulence of the separation flow, these vortices can be regarded as the result of the change in the direction and magnitude of the pulsation velocity caused by the pulsa-tion accelerapulsa-tion at the separapulsa-tion posipulsa-tion before, that is, the vortices with uncertain magnitude and direction of the velocity are generated. According to formula 24, which can be seen that the velocity strain tensor is in the open sphere with radius of adjacent domain at the separation position, from which the streamline formed by the fluid particles to the original velocity is a closed curve. In 1972, lugt vortex proposed this phenomenon is defined as many fluid particles around a common center of rotation, but was unable to predict the orientation of the center of rotation and movement, so confirmed when, namely, the divergence is zero, the particle in the position of the separation position, which validate the correctness
of the mathematical model. In summary, the stream-line formed by the stress on the original velocity field is a closed curve, and the divergence of the velocity strain tensor is zero, indicating that the fluid particle is passive.
V. STRESS STATE ANALYSIS OF SEPARATED FLOW
In fluid mechanics, the stress state at any point in the fluid is uniquely determined by the stress vectors on the three orthogonal planes of action at that point, and each stress vector can again be represented by three compo-nents. Therefore, this study assumes that the fluid in the flowfield is isotropic, the stress tensor and the de-formation rate tensor are linear, and their homogeneous function relationship can be expressed as folmura 3.
For the first state where the fluid does not separate, the stress tensor of the fluid particle can be expressed as the following equation:
σik(1)=−p(1)δik− 1 3q¯˙
•,s
s,•δik+µ(¯˙qi,k+ ¯˙qk,i) (25) Thus, above formula is calculated and its gradient is as follows: σ(1)ik,•••,k=−p •,k (1)δik− 1 3q¯˙ •,sk s,••δik+µ ¯˙ q•i,k,••k+ ¯˙q •,•k k,i• (26) According to the consistency of the flowfield frame, the index of variable subscript can be transformed, so formula 26 can be expressed as follows:
σ(1)ik,•••,k=−p•(1),kδik− 1 3q¯˙ •,sk t,••δikδst +µq¯˙•j,k,••kδ j i + ¯˙q •,•k j,i•δ j k (27) For the second fluid separation state, the stress tensor of the fluid particle can be expressed as the following equation: σ(2)ik,•••,k=−p•(2),kδik− 1 3q¯˙ •,sk t,••δikξst− 1 3q¯˙ •,s t,•δikξt,ks,• +µq¯˙j,k•,••kξ j i + ¯˙qj,kξ j,k i,• + ¯˙q •,•k j,i•ξ j k+ ¯˙qj,iξ j,k k,• (28) Combining formula 13 and formula 28, we can get its gradient as: σik,(2)•••,k=− 1 3δik ¯˙ q•t,,sk••λts+ ¯˙q •,s t,•λt,ks,•+ ¯˙q• ,sk t,••δst +µq¯˙•j,k,••kλji + ¯˙qj,kλj,ki,•+ ¯˙q •,•k j,i• λ j k+ ¯˙qj,iλ j,k k,• −p•(2),kδik+µ ¯˙ qj,k•,••kδij+ ¯˙q •,•k j,i•δ j k (29)
In order to better and more obviously see how the stress of the fluid particle changes when the fluid is sep-arated, formula 27 and formula 29 are used to subtract, and the change of the stress of the particle at the moment
of two states’ transformation can be obtained, as shown in the following: σik,(2)•••,k−σik,(1)•••,k=p(1)•,i−p(2)•,i− 1 3q¯˙ •,k j,•λ j,• k,i+µq¯˙j,kλ j,k i,• (30)
Combining with the coordinate transformation law, we can develop the following theorem
Theorem 7 (Stress state equation). For Ω⊆R3,g i ∈
TM and q¯˙j =ϕ(xk), xk ∈Ω, If there is the fluid
sepa-ration under the action of physical properties, when the stress state is gi=Pi− 1 3θλ k,• k,i +µq¯˙j,kλ j,k i,• (31) where λji ∈ TM is the separation ratio tensor, µ is the
dynamic viscosity coefficient of fluid, θ = ¯˙qj,•,j• is expan-sion volume for velocity andgi=σ
(2)••,k ik,• −σ (1)••,k ik,• , here σik(1) and σ (2)
ik is the stress state tensor of the fluid
un-der the first and second circumstances,Pi is the pressure
gradient differencePi=p(1)•,i−p (2)
•,i.
Thus, the final Newtonian fluid separation law is ob-tained by synthesizing formula 23 and formula 31. Theorem 8 (Separation law). For Ω ⊆R3, u
j ∈ TM,
If there is the fluid separation under the action of phys-ical properties, velocity strain tensor λji ∈ TM satisfies
continuity equation
λji(xk) = 0, λ j,i
i,•(xk) = 0 (32) and momentum equation for viscous medium
ρuj ∂λji(xk) ∂t =Pi− 1 3θλ k,• k,i(xk) +µuj,kλj,ki,•(xk) (33) where λji ∈ TM is the separation ratio tensor, ρ is the
density of fluid, µis the dynamic viscosity coefficient of fluid,θ is expansion volume for velocity,xk∈Ωis
coor-dinates of separation position.
It can be seen from the folmura 31 that the reasons why the separation phenomenon can be divided into two situations:
1. External cause: the change of pressure difference around the separation position. The study of pressure can reflect the changes of other flow parameters. Ac-cording to formula 31, it can be seen that there is a non-negligible relationship between the stress change of fluid particles and the pressure difference.
However, for practical application and experimen-tal measurement, the pressure parameter is usually
not directly measured. Direct numerical simulation method, experimental method and large eddy simulation method are generally used, but the power spectrum semi-empirical model is mostly used for the balanced turbu-lence boundary of the plate, and the performance of the experimental instrument is too high and the experiment time is too long, so it is not widely used. In engineering applications, in the design of aircraft and ships, pressure difference is generated due to the change of pressure in-side the fluid, leading to a sharp change in fluid velocity, that is, the velocity gradient becomes larger, so there is a greater friction force inside the fluid, which also means that a larger strength vortex will be generated.
Therefore, pressure is an important research direction both from the perspective of mathematics or physics and from the perspective of practical experimental applica-tion. In addition, the cognition of the influence of pres-sure on separation flow and transition is still relatively weak in the current research. Formula 31 has a good explanation for this problem.
2. Internal cause, viscous term and diffusion term of velocity. In the Navier-Stokes equations, the pressure term and the viscous term (diffusion term) describe the effect of pressure and viscous force on the fluid, respec-tively. Re=U0L ν = ρU2 0/L µU0/L2 ≈ kρu· ▽uk kµ▽2uk (34) As can be seen from the definition of Reynolds number (see formula 34), when the Reynolds number is high, it means that in the Navier-Stokes equation, relative to the viscous term, convection term is dominant. And differ-ent from the viscous term of the linear term, the convec-tion term is a nonlinear term with certain uncertainty and is very sensitive to the slight change of parameters, which will increase all kinds of influences of the slight dis-turbance. And the higher the Reynolds number is, the more easily the flow becomes unstable. Therefore, when the Reynolds number of fluid flow is relatively high, it is more likely to lead to the occurrence of turbulence, that is, the viscous term and the diffusion term of velocity both have a certain influence and relationship with fluid separation and transition.
To sum up, according to the derivation of the above equations, the root cause of separation obtained is deter-mined by external and internal causes, among which the external reason is caused by the change of pressure dif-ference around the separation position, and the internal reason is caused by the viscous term and the diffusion term of velocity.
[1] Hall M.G. Computational Fluid Dynamics. A Revolu-tionary Force in Aerodynamics[J]. AIAA Paper, 1981,
[2] Viviand H., Lecomte C. Computational Fluid Dynam-ics in France[C]. AIAA 8th. Comput. Fluid Dyn. Conf., 1967, 336–351.
[3] Wuyi Wan,Song Zhu,Yunjin Hu. Analysis of Flow Shock Attenuation Characteristics in Pipes with Laminar Turbulence Alternation [J]: Applied Mathematics and Mechanics,2010,31(10):1152-1159.
[4] Magdy Saeed Hussin,Ashraf Ghorabb Mohamed A,EI-Samanudy.Computational analysis of two-dimensional wing aeroelastic flutter using Navier-Stokes model[J]:Ain Shams Engineering Journal,2018,Volume 9,Issue 4 Pages 3459-3472
[5] D.I.Pullin,P.G.Saffman.VORTEX DYNAMICS IN TUR-BULENCE[J]:Annu.Rev.Fluid. Mech.1998.Vol. 30:31-51 [6] Weiqi Qian,Hao Zhan,Junqiang Bai,Bin Mou. A
Transi-tion PredicTransi-tion Method Based on Turbulence Mode [J]: Journal of Aerodynamics,2006(04):502-507.
[7] Jakob K¨uhnen,Baofang Song,Davide Scarselli,Nazmi Burak Budanur,Michael Riedl,Ashley P. Willis,Marc Avila,Bj¨orn Hof.Destabilizing turbulence in pipe flow[J]:Nature physics,2019, volume 14, pages386–390(2018)
[8] Shaun P. Johnstone,Andrew J. Groszek,Philip T. Starkey,Christopher J. Billington,Tapio P. Sim-ula,Kristian Helmerson.Evolution of large-scale flow from turbulence in a two-dimensional superfluid[J]: Science 28 Jun 2019,Vol.364,Issue 6447,pp.1267-1271 [9] Yunjun Yang. Study on Angle of Attack Effect of
Bound-ary Layer Transition [A]. Chinese Society for Mechanics, Zhengzhou University. [C]: Chinese Society for ics, Zhengzhou University: Chinese Society for Mechan-ics,2009:1.
[10] Yujie Li,Jianping Kuang,Zhenbing Luo. Numerical Sim-ulation of Flow Separation of Icing Airfoil Controlled by Synthetic Double Jet at Low Reynolds Number [J]: Gas Physics,2019,4(01):23-32.
[11] Hui Huang,Jian Xiong ,Xiang Liu,Maolin Zhu,Yonghong Li.Research on boundary layer transition measure-ment technology based on temperature-sensitive paint[J]:Experimental Fluid Mechanics,2019,33(02):79-84.
[12] Meng Wang,Hai Zhong,Hongjie Zhong,Hongzhou Wang,Yujun Li.Flight test application research of infrared thermal image boundary layer transition detection[J]:Acta Aerodynamics,2019,37(01):160-167.
[13] Karthik Duraisamy,Gianluca Iaccarino,Heng Xiao. Tur-bulence Modeling in the Age of Data[J]:ANNUAL RE-VIEW OF FLUID MECHANICS,2019,Vol.51:357-377 [14] Dexin He, Weizhi Zhang. Manual of aerodynamic
per-formance of wind turbine airfoil at high angle of attack. Mianyang: China Aerodynamics Research and Develop-ment Center, 1989.
[15] Zhiquan Ye, Jixiong Huang, Yan Chen, Nengsheng Bao, Fupeng Huo. Experimental research on aerodynamic per-formance of a new airfoil suitable for wind turbines. Acta Energia Sinica, 2003, 24(4): 548-554.
[16] Bo Xue, Weizhi Zhang, Jinsong Lei. Experimental study of DU 93-W-210 airfoil wind tunnel. Dongfang Electric Review, 2012,
[17] Wanli Shi. Large Eddy Simulation of Turbine Flow Field and Study of Quasi-order Structure[D]: Nanjing Univer-sity of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2012.
[18] Yi Liu, Yincheng Guo, Huiqiang Zhang, Xilin Wang, Wenyi Lin.Large eddy simulation of coherent struc-ture of mixed-layer flow[J]:Chinese Journal of Applied Mechanics):22-26+139,2002,02
[19] Parviz Moin,Krishnan Mahesh.Direct numerical simula-tion:A tool in turbulence research[J]:ANNUAL REVIEW OF FLUID MECHANICS,1998,Vol.30:539-578
[20] David J.Beebe,Jeffrey S.Moore,Joseph M. Bauer,Qing Yu,Robin H. Liu,Chelladurai Devadoss ,Byung-Ho Jo.Functional hydrogel structures for autonomous flow control inside microfluidic channels[J]:NATURE; 2000(04), 404, pages588–590
[21] Agnieszka Kwiek.Conceptual design of an aircraft for Mars mission[J]:Aircraft Engineering and Aerospace Technology,2019,91(6).
[22] Chengpeng Jiang. Research on the Random Influence Law of Complex Low-altitude Flight Situation[D]: Nan-jing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, 2018. [23] Xinzi Tang , Pengcheng Li, Ruitao Peng, Xinyu
Lu.Aerodynamic characteristics and robust optimiza-tion of airfoils for small wind turbines under turbu-lent conditions[J/OL]:Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering:1-9,2019,10.09
[24] Lin Zhou, Zhao Yang, Jie Li.Experimental research on the influence of Reynolds number on the aerodynamic characteristics of transportation aircraft[J]:Chinese Jour-nal of Applied Mechanics,2019,36(04):
