&('*),+-+/.103234526),7189+/:;=<)>2?2?.*'@237A2?BC.ADE8)GFH.10I+/)G2?J!71KCLE:;=MG)>8N
)G8PO450326),45M*K?:M>K?)GMG<!.18C2Q71K26B.R03.=ST:)G03.1<!.18C23+K3710Q2?BC. '*.=UT03.V. 71K
W 4%+/2?.V0X71KY[Z)G.V8Z.R)G8P\E71<O:26.10QY[Z)G.V8Z.*]
p '*.VZM,4503.A26BQ452C2?B.Rq97103r!'*.=+/Z03)G;=.*' )>8P2?BC),+'=)/+d+/.1032s452?),718t),+,N%.VuZ5.1O2qtB.V03.
712?B.V03qP),+/. +/234526.='*N%.18C2?)G03.VMGJ<J!71qP8tq97103r!458Q'@Bb4%+v8b712;=.1.V89+/:;=<)G262?.*'w4%+458
.1u[.103Z5),+,.RK3710X4n'*.=UT03.V. 45226B),+710X458J!7126B.10Q:8C)GFH.10I+/)G2?Jx]
Y[),UT8.='vy z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z
{ .*710IU%.R&|8bU%.VM,45r}),+
p 4%UT03.1.R2?BQ452Cv03)G8)G26J\|71M>MG.=UT.Av)G;=0I4503J<45JoM>.18Q'i710QZ71OJ26B),+'*),+d+/.1032s452?),718t:O718
03.*S%:.*+,2s]
Y[),UT8.='vy z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z%z
{ .*710IU%.R&|8bU%.VM,45r}),+
p q71:M,'@MG)Gr}.A2s7A2?BQ458Cr<J!+,:O.V03FC)/+d710Qv03.18b'v458P458QUT8 .VJK3710X45MGM*26B.@4%+d+/),+/23458Z5. p
03.VZ.1)GFH.='i'*:03)G8bUn26B),+Z71:0I+/. 458b' .*+,O.VZ),45MGM>JoKs710Q2?BC.AZ71<!OMG.126),718971KC2?B)/+v26B.=+/),+-]
Bb458rx+45M,+d7A2s7Av03JH8t971MG<!.=+/N%R)>88J4%'*. 458b'i45MGM*<JZM/4%+d+/<4526.=+/N%K3710Q2?BC.1)G0
p 803.1Z.V82J}.=450I+i.18b7103<71:+wO0I7=UT03. +d+iBQ4%+;=.1.18 <4%'*.¡)>87103M,'¢),'*.¡¢.V;
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)G.*+d]AvB)/+£),+9<45r})G8bU2?B.¤¢.1;¥458¦.VFC.V8¦<7103.§O0I71<!),+,)>8QUq945J(2s7
'*.1M>)GFC.V0@.='*:Z4526),718Q45M<4526.103),45M/]H¨P.Vq©2?.1Z5B8Q71M/7=U%J}Nx)G826.=UT0I452?.*'ªqP)G26B.1u[O.103)G.V82?)/45M
.*'=:Z%452?),718CNZ458)G8CZ03.=4%+/.26B. .1K?K6.1Z26)GFH.18.*+d+¤458Q'«.VK?K?)>Z)G.18CZJ¬71K26B.M>.=45038)>8QU
O0I71Z.*+ +-]A345F®4¡Y[.103FHMG.12s+,N ¯
W
vN ¯Y[vN \XY[Y¦458Q's45Fb445OOM>.123+<45rH.'*J}8Q45<)>Z
Z03.*452?),71871Knqt.1;O4%UT.=+/N°.=4%+/)G.10!458Q'03)GZBC.10I]$D+/.10O0I71K6)GMG.=+t4503.qP)/'=.VMGJ±:+,.*')G8
MG.*45038)G8bUw.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s+XZ718C2?03)G;=:26)G8QU8.Vq 45OO0I7=45ZBC.=+X)>82?BC.q945JZ71<O:26.10I+
4503.¥:+/.='©237©'*.1MG)GFH.10².*'=:Z%452?),718b]³0I71K6)GMG.*+¤Z458´;=.µ; :)GMG2¶qt)G2?B´)>8K37103<452?),718
03.*S%:.*+,26.='·'*)G03.VZ2?MGJ¢K60I71< 26B.MG.=45038C.10I+i710PK60I71< 458Q45MGJx+/),+71K¸2?B.£q45J¶MG.=45038C.10I+
)G8C2?.V0I45Z2qt)G2?Bt2?B.RMG.=45038C)G8QU.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s]
vB)/+t2?BC.=+/),+tK371Z5:+,.*+t:O7182?BC.Z03.*452?),71871K49K6MG.1u[)G;=MG.¢458Q'¢03)GZB.V8FH)G0I718<!.1826N
qtB)GZBiZ458i;=.¸:+/.='t2s7¹)G<!O0I71FC.¸2?BC.tS%:45M>)G2?J£458b'tO 71qP.V0n71KvqP.V; º ;4%+/.='tM>.=45038)>8QU}]
p 2O03.*+,.V823+ 4!'*),+,2603)G;=:2?.*'¶45OO0I7=45ZB237i2?BC.'*.*+,),UT8¤458b')G<!OMG.1<!.182s452?),718¤71K¹458
)G<!O0I71FC.*'PMG.=45038C)G8QU|.V8FH)G0I718<!.18C23]V712?Bw)G8b+,2603:Z2?),718b45MQ458b'94%+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2x<452?.103)/45M
qt)GMGMQ;=.£UT.18C.10I4526.='±'=J}8b45<)GZ45M>MGJ£K3710n.=45Z5B:+/.10n:O71803.*ST:.=+/23]»vB.+,Jx+/2?.1<¬qP)GM>M
;=.4%'4 O26)GFH.237:+/.10I+-¼O0I71K6)GMG.*+,NX+-72?Bb452A:+/.10I+nqP)G26B·'*)GK?K6.103.V82AO0I71K6)GMG.*+¸<45J±;=.
O03.*+,.V82?.*'iqt)G2?B'=)>K?K?.V03.18C2bZ71826.18C23]TD+/.10I+°qP)GMGMBb45FC.|Z718260I71M71FC.V0`2?B.V)G0`O0I71K?)>MG.=+-]
&''*)G26),718Q45M>MGJ}N½)G2¹qP)GMGMR;=.ªO7=+-+/)G;=MG.K371026B.¡+,Jx+/2?.1< 237¡45:2371<4526)GZ45MGM>J¶:O'v452?.¾4
O0I71K6)GMG.=]lvBC.¡O4%UT.=+Z7182s45)G8)>8QU¶2 BC.¡<4526.103),45M|qP)GMGM|;=.¡<4%'*.¾:O¿71Kt<7='*:MG.=+-]
W 7='*:MG.*+vZ458t;=.ABC2?<M>N%2?.1u[2?NH45OOM>.123+710Q<:M>2?)G<!.='*),4lK?)>MG.=+-]
&ÀO0I712s712?J}O.+/Jx+,26.1< qt)GMGM`;=.Z503.=452?.*'K3710 2?BC.)G8b+,2603:Z2?)/718·71K W 4526B.V<452?)>Z+¸Ks710
+/.1Z718b'v4503J.='*:Z4526),718Q]°BC.§+,Jx+/2?.1< qt)GMGM¹;=.45F®45)GM,45;=M>.71FH.10w2?BC.7103M,'¤¢)/'=.
¢.V;]x& W )>Z0I7=+d71K62 &EZZ.*+d+|L¹ W YqP)GMGMX;=.£:+,.*'¾K3710t2?BC.¡+/23710I4%UT.¾71Kt+,26:'*.182s+d¼
O0I71K6)GMG.=+/N=)G8b+,2603:Z2?),718b45M°458Q'£4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82x<452?.V03),45M,+-]V345F®4RY[.103FHMG.12s+458Q'P?L¹v\¢qP)GM>M
;=.i:+/.='ªKs710E26B.Z718C8.1Z52?),7182s7i26B.'v452345;4%+/.458Q'£2?B.Z503.=452?)/718¤71K¹45MGM°2?B.¢.V;
1. INTRODUCTION ...1
1.1. INTRODUCTION ...1
1.2. MOTIVATION...1
1.3. OBJECTIVES...2
1.4. APPROACH...3
1.5. DOCUMENT STRUCTURE ...4
2. BACKGROUND...6
2.1. INTRODUCTION ...6
2.2. PEDAGOGY ...7
2.3. LEARNING STYLES ...7
2.3.1 Concepts ...7
2.3.2 Benefits ...8
2.3.3 The Sensory Intake of Information Approach...9
2.4. ASSESSMENT...10
2.5. LEARNING AND THE WORLD WIDE WEB ...11
2.6. LIMITATIONS ...13
2.7. DESIGNING ONLINE LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS ...14
2.8. ADAPTIVE HYPERMEDIA ...15
2.8.1 Adaptive Hypermedia Systems...15
2.8.2 User Profiling ...17
2.9. SUMMARY ...17
3. EDUCATION ON THE WORLD WIDE WEB ...19
3.1. INTRODUCTION ...19
3.2. WEB-BASED LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS...21
3.2.1 Virtual Study Centre ...21
3.2.2 Scoop ...21
3.2.3 TopClass ...22
3.2.5 David Thornton’s Learning Environment ...24
3.2.6 Courseware on the fly...25
3.2.7 Discussion...25
3.3. TEACHING MATHEMATICS ON THE WEB ...27
3.3.1 Web sites for Trigonometry ...28
3.3.2 CONCLUDING REMARKS...30
4. DESIGN...31
4.1. INTRODUCTION ...31
4.2. REQUIREMENTS ...31
4.3. ARCHITECTURE...33
4.3.1 User Profiling ...34
4.3.2 Course Structure...39
4.3.3 Assessment ...40
4.3.4 Course Creation Interface ...41
4.4. DATABASE DESIGN ...41
4.4.1 User Profiling ...45
4.4.2 Instructional Material ...45
4.4.3 Assessment Material ...46
4.5. SUMMARY ...46
5. IMPLEMENTATION ...48
5.1. INTRODUCTION ...48
5.2. TECHNOLOGY...48
5.3. DATABASE ORGANISATION...48
5.4. ARCHITECTURE...49
5.4.1 Servlets ...50
5.4.2 Course Appearance ...50
5.4.3 User Authentication...51
5.4.4 User Profile ...53
5.4.5 Course Contents ...54
5.4.6 Assessment ...55
6. EVALUATION ...57
6.1. INTRODUCTION ...57
6.2. EVALUATION METHODOLOGIES ...57
6.3. EVALUATION OF THE THESIS OBJECTIVES ...58
6.3.1 Constructivists Approach ...58
6.3.2 Adaptation ...59
6.3.3 User Profiling ...60
6.3.4 Course Content Creation...61
6.4. SUMMARY ...61
7. CONCLUSIONS...62
7.1. INTRODUCTION ...62
7.2. THEORY OVERVIEW...62
7.3. SYSTEM OVERVIEW ...62
7.4. IMPROVEMENTS - FUTURE WORK ...64
7.5. CONCLUSIONS ...65
APPENDICES...67
A. DATABASE STRUCTURE ...67
B. LIST OF SERVLETS...71
F
IGURE
3.1 E
VALUATION OF LEARNING
E
NVIRONMENTS
...20
F
IGURE
4.1 O
VERVIEW OF THE
S
YSTEM
’
S
A
RCHITECTURE
...34
F
IGURE
4.2 U
SER
P
ROFILING
– S
CENARIO
1...37
F
IGURE
4.3 U
SER
P
ROFILING
– S
CENARIO
2...38
F
IGURE
4.2 O
VERVIEW OF THE
C
OURSE
S
TRUCTURE
...39
F
IGURE
4.3 D
ATABASE
S
TRUCTURE AND
R
ELATIONSHIPS
...45
F
IGURE
5.1 S
YSTEM
’
S
W
EB ARCHITECTURE
...49
F
IGURE
5.2 S
CREENSHOT OF THE DETAILS ENTERED FOR AUTHORISATION
...52
F
IGURE
5.3 S
CREENSHOT OF THE WELCOME PAGE
...52
F
IGURE
5.4 S
CREENSHOT OF THE PROFILE PAGE
...53
F
IGURE
5.5 S
CREENSHOT OF A PAGE WITH MATERIAL FOR A TOPIC
...54
F
IGURE
5.6 S
CREENSHOT OF AN EXAMPLE TEST
...56
F
IGURE
6.1 A
VAILABILITY OF
C
ONTENT FOR
D
IFFERENT
L
EARNING
S
TYLES
...60
& p &E032?)GK6)GZ),45M p 82?.VMGMG),UT.V8Z.
&EY³ W )GZ50I7=+d71K623ÐÑ+v& Z2?)>FC.RY.V03FC.V0Q³4%U%.*+
&E p &E:'=)/7AR),'*.*7 p 826.103MG.*45FC.*'
&E¢Y &EO45ZB.R¢.1; Y[.103FH.10
\v \E71<O:26.10Q4%+/.='@v0I45)G8)G8bU
L¹P W L¹J}8Q45<)>Z½PJ}O.10326.1u[2 W 4503r º :O458bU%:4%UT.
{
pÓÒ
{ 0I45OB)>Z+
p
82?.V03ZBQ458bUT.
Ò
7103<452
&EP& &'45O26)GFH.APJ}O.V03<.='*),4l&E03ZB)>2?.1Z52?:03.
{
D p
{
0I45OB)>Z45M*D+/.10 p 82?.V03K345Z.
t W tJHO.V032?. u2 W 4503r º:O458QUT:4%UT.
tv³ tJHO.V032?.Vu2C0I458b+,K6.10Q³0I712s71Z71M
pÓÔvÔvÔ p 8b+,26)G2?:26. 71K Ô M>.1Z2603)GZ45Mv458b' Ô MG.VZ2?0I718C)GZ+ Ô 8QUT)G8.V.10I+
pÓÔ Ò p 8C2?.V038.12 Ô 8QUT)G8.V.103)G8bUl4%+/r Ò 7103Z.
pÓW Y p 8b+,2603:Z2?)/718Q45M W 458b4%U%.V<.V82Y[Jx+,26.1<
6³ Ô { s71)G82C³)GZ2?:03. Ô uO.V032 { 0I71:O
6LEv\ s45Fb4lLP45234l4%+/.A\E7188C.1Z26)GFC)>2?J
W 452 B W W 4526B.1<452?)GZ%45M W 4503r}:Ol458bUT:4%U%.
WÕ
Ö@:)>Zr)><.
W
71FH)G.*+
W ³ Ô { W 7126),718P³)GZ52?:03. Ô u[O.1032 { 0I71:O
Õ L¹v\ Õ O.V8PLP45234l4%+/.A\E7188C.1Z26)GFC)>2?J
Õ Ô Õ ;1×G.1Z2Cv)G8r})G8bUo458b' Ô <!;=.='v'*)G8QU
³L Ò ³71032s45;=MG.ALP71Z:<.V82 Ò 7103<452
³³ ³71qt.103³71)G8C2K?)>MG.AKs7103<452
Ø LE W Y Ø .1M,4526),718Q45M»L452s4ll4%+/. W 458b4%UT.1<.V82
ØW Ø
.=45M*Y[Jx+,26.1<+
W
.*'=)/4lK37103<452
Y[LEÙ Y71K?26q94503.AL¹.1FH.1M/71O<.18C2ÙR)G2
Y
{
W Y[23458b'450I'
{
Y[ Ò Y[BQ71Zr}45FH. Ò M,4%+/BPK6)GMG.AKs7103<452
v\³ v0I458Q+/O71032\E718C2?0I71M*³0I712s71Z71M
v\³Ú p ³ v0I458Q+/O71032\E718C2?0I71M*³0I712s71Z71M
DELE³ D+,.V0QL452s4%U%0I45<¦³0I7 2371Z71M
D Ø DE8)GFH.10I+-45M Ø .=+-71:03Z.A71Z452s710
¢&E 45FH.AK6)GMG.AKs7103<452
WÒ ¢)G8b'v71q9+ W .1234 Ò )GM>.
¯ W Ô u[2?.18b+,)>;=MG. W 4503r º :O458bU%:4%UT.
p 8·03.VZ.18C2 J}.=450I+o.V8Q7103<71:+oO0I7=UT03.=+-+oBb4%+o;=.1.V8<4%'*.)>87103M,'¢¢),'*.¢.1;
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)G.*+d]½ B),+),+<45r})G8bU¢26B.¾¢.1;à458.VFC.V8<7103.¡O0I71<)/+,)G8bU¶q945J²237
'*.1M>)GFC.V0².='*:Z452?)/718Q45M<4526.103),45M/] W 458CJ¬Z%71:0I+,.*+¤BQ45FH.«;=.V.18 '*.1FH.1M/71O.='ÀK3710
O0I71FH),'*)G8QU'*),+/23458CZ.¹.='*:Z452?)/718N*qtB.103.¹OBJx+/)GZ45MCZ7182s45Z2x;=.V2?qt.1.18w2?BC.t+,26:'=.V82s+
458b'26B..*'=:Z%4523710°),+8b712$8.VZ.=+-+-4503J®]vB.A7103M,'¢)/'=.A¢.1;),+45M,+d7A: +/.='i4%+O45032
71K¶42?0I4%'*)G2?)/718Q45MZ71:0I+/.O0I71FC),'*)G8bU;712?Bá<45)G8710²+/:OOMG.1<!.18C234503J¥Z71:0I+/.
<452?.103)/45Mv718MG)>8.=]
vB.¾03.=+/.=4503ZB )G82?B.4503.=45NA2?BQ71:UTBCN),+Z71826)G8:71:+-]v.1Z5B8Q71M/7=U%J}N)>82?.*UT0I452?.='
qt)G2?B O.='v4%U}7=UTJ²458Q'±.1u[O.103)G.V82?)/45MR.*'=:Z%452?),718CNlZ458¢)G8CZ03.=4%+/.92?BC.9.1K6K?.1Z52?)GFH.18C.=+-+
458b'.1K?K6)GZ)G.V8Z J±71K2?BC.tM>.=45038)>8QUPO0I71Z.*+d+-]¢.1;O4%U%.*+½Z458ª;=.!UT.18C.10I4526.='718£2?BC.
K6MGJ}NlST:)GZ5rH.V0t458Q'9qP)G26B03)GZBC.10¸Z71826.18C2¸4%+X26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)G.*+MG)>rH.t.=]âU}]»345F®4|Y[.103FHMG.12s+,N
¯ W vN¯Y[vN\YY[Ns45Fb4¶45OOM>.123+£458b'<:MG26)G<.*'=)/4ªZ45O45;=)GMG)>2?)G.*+P;=.1Z71<!.±<7103.
+-71OB),+/2?)>Z452?.*']®D+,.V0O0I71K?)GM>.=+w4503.Z718C2?03)G;=:26)G8QU8.Vq 45OO0I7=45ZBC.=+ )G8¤2?B.q945J
Z71<!O:2?.V0I+(4503.á:+/.='ã237ã'=.VMG)GFH.10.='*:Z4526),718Q]³0I71K?)GM>.=+§Z458ä;=.¥;=:)>MG2¢qP)G26B
)G8CK37103<452?),718§03.=ST:.=+/2?.*''*)G03.VZ2?M>J¤K60I71< 26B.M>.=45038.V0I+!710K60I71< 458b45MGJx+,)/+w71K¹2?BC.
q45J2?B.¹MG.*45038.10I+b)G8C2?.V0I45Z2xqt)G2?Bw2?BC.EM>.=45038)>8QUE.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s]IY7¹)G2v),+®O7=+-+/)G;=MG.¸237
;=:)GM/'9M>.=45038)>8QU .18CFC)G0I718C<.V823+`2?Bb452l8b712n718M>J9<45r}.tM>.=45038)>8QUP<7103.o)G8C2?.10I45Z52?)GFH.
;=:2b45M,+d7 4%'v45O26.='@237A26B.A)>8Q'*)GFH),'*:45M*MG.=45038C.10I]
Ý$Þ>å$Þ æ Æ¾ÁEÊÏΣÁEÊIƱÉ
vB.V03.µ),+4«UT0I71qP)>8QUµ)G8C2?.103.*+,2±)G8ã.='*:Z4526),718Q45Mª)G8Q+/2?)G26:2?),718b+¶)G8 '*.VFC.VM,71O)G8QU
MG.*45038)G8bU .V8FH)G0I718<!.18C23+àKs710¬718MG)G8C. '*.1MG)>FC.V03J 71K .='*:Z4526),718Q]
W
+/:OOMG.1<!.18C2Q237@Z71:0I+/.=+)>8K345Z. º 2s7 º K345Z5.@ZM,4%+-+,.*+d]T&EMG2?Bb71:U%B2?B.|.1K?K6.1Z26)GFH.18.*+d+R71K
26B.·7103M,' º ¢)/'=.¢.1;4%+¡4¶<.*'*)G:< K3710§'*.1M>)GFC.V03)G8QU·.='*:Z4526),718«Bb4%+;=.1.V8
ST:.=+/2?)/718.='*N%26B.AZ5:0303.182CO0I45Z2?)>Z. 458b' 03.*+,.*4503ZB9+ .1.V<+237AO0I71FH.A)G2b712?BC.103qP)/+,.*]
p
8 4¢.1; º ;4%+,.*' M>.=45038)>8QU .18CFC)G0I718C<.V82à2?B03.V. '*)G<!.18b+,),718b+©+,Bb71:M,' ;=.
Z718b+,)/'=.V03.='vy¹26B.¦+-71Z),45M'=)><.18b+,)/718NP26B.·26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)GZ45Mª'*)G<!.18Q+/),718ã458b'à2?BC.
.*'=:Z%452?),718b45M'*)G<.V8Q+/),718Q]»vB.t<4ç×,7103)G2?J¾71K¢.1; º ;4%+/.='M>.=45038)>8QUP.18CFC)>0I718<.V82s+
26BQ4529.1u[),+/29K371Z:+<7103.à718 2?BC.·2?.VZB8b71M,7=UT)GZ45M'*)G<.V8Q+/),718©458b'MG.*+d+¾718«2?BC.
.*'=:Z%452?),718b45M710¶26B.µ+d71Z)/45M'*)G<.V8Q+/),718Q] Ø .*+,.*4503ZB¿)G8¿2?B.²K6)G.1M,'71K¡450326)GK?)>Z),45M
)G8C2?.VMGMG),UT.18CZ.)G8.='*:Z452?)/718Z458O0I71FH),'*.:+`qP)G26B),'*.=4%+`K3710n<7103.PO.V0I+d718b45MG)Gè%.='
MG.*45038)G8bU .18CFC)>0I718<.V82s+d]¸D+/.10¡O0I71K6)GMG.*+¢4503.)>8Z03.*4%+,)G8bUTMGJµ:+/.=')G8¥MG. 45038C)G8QU
.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s+d]
&+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2)/+n458)><O710323458C2°O45032X71KX458±718MG)G8C. MG.=45038C)G8QU.18CFC)G0I718C<.V82X4%+)G2Q)/+
Ks710458CJªMG.*45038)G8bUiO0I71Z5.=+-+d] p 8 4%'v'*)G26),718237.VFb45MG:4526)G8QU2?BC.£+/2?:'*.18C23+-¼CO0I7=UT03.=+-+,N
4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82xB.1M>O+X+/2?:'*.V823+bMG.*45038Q]V&µ+/2?:'*.18C23¼>+b03.*+,:MG2s+b)G84%+-+/.=+-+,<!.1822?.*+,2s+bZ458
;=.03.VZ 710I'*.=')G8¡26B.+,26:'=.V82s¼>+nO0I71K?)GMG.VNQ<45r})G8bU9)>2AO7=+-+,)G;=M>.K3710 26B.+,Jx+/2?.1< 237
4%'v45O2237i2?B.iq45J.=45ZB§+/2?:'*.18C2MG.=45038b+d]}&|M,+-74%'v'*)G2?)/718Q45M)G8Ks7103<452?)/718Z458;=.
O0I71FH),'*.='@237ABC.1MGO+/2?:'*.V823+ZM,4503)>K?J2?BC.1)G0Qqt.=45rO71)G82s+d]
Õ FH.10I45M>MGNx718MG)[email protected])>0I718<.V82s+A+/BQ71:M,';=.|<7103.|2?Bb458q45J®+X71K`'*.VMG)FH.103)G8bU 26.1u[23]
vB.±Z718C2?.18C2t<!:+,2o;=.'=J}8b45<)GZ¶45MGM,71qP)>8QU¡K3710)G826.10I45Z26),718«45Z5Z710I'*)G8QU¡2s7±2?BC.
Z718b+,2603:Z2?)>FC),+/245OO0I7=45ZBb]vB.¡O0I45Z2?)GZ5.1N¸BQ71qt.1FH.103Nt+,Bb71q9+i2?BQ452P<7=+/2£71K2?BC.
.Vu),+/2?)>8QU718CMG)G8C.MG.=45038C)G8QU.18FH)G0I718C<.18C23+tM/45Zr)G8àST:45MG)>2?J(458b'¤:+/.¤71Kw45MGMn2?BC.
K6.=452?:03.*+71KC<7='*.1038t2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ ]
Ý$Þ>é$Þ
ƱÃXêÅÈÁ|ÊÏΣÅ
•
vB.±'*.*+,),UT871Ko4'*JH8b45<)GZ458b'§4%'v45O26)GFC.MG.=45038C)G8QU9.18CFC)G0I718C<.V8271FH.1026B.A¢¢ä26BQ452b71K?K?.V0I+dy
o
&'45O26)GFH.'*.1M>)GFC.V03J71Kx26B.¹.='*:Z4526),718Q45MC<452?.V03),45M2s7E2?BC.t+,26:'=.V82s+,ì
458b'
o
&E894%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82Q+/Jx+,26.1<¦2?BQ452bUT)GFC.*+vK6.1.*'=;45Z5ro2s7A2?BC. +/J®+/2?.V<]
•
vB.¡)G<OMG.V<.V8234526),718¿71K£4O0I712s712?J}O.²+/J®+/2?.V< 2?Bb452£45ZZ710I'*)G8bU¶237¡2?BC.'*.=+/),UT8ãqP)GMGMª;=.À4%'v45O26)GFC.à237à2?B.à:+/.10I+-¼iO0I71K6)GMG.=+-] Ô u45<OMG.Z71:0I+/.
<452?.103)/45M¬Ks710 2?BC. 2?.=45Z5B)G8bU 71K <452?BC.1<452?)GZ+ íî2?03),U}718b71<.12603Jxï)G8
+/.1Z718b'v4503J .*'=:Z%452?),718 qt)GMGM¢;=.À:+/.='v]vB.ÀO0I712s712?J}O. +/Jx+,26.1< qt)GMGM
+/:OO71032Q'*J}8 45<!)GZ½Z03.*452?),71871K3y
o
qt.1;O4%UT.*+lZ7182s45)G8)G8bUt2?BC. )G8Q+/2?03:Z52?),718b45M<452?.V03),45MGN®45ZZ710I'*)G8QU237
26B.A:+/.10I¼ð+vO0I71K6)GMG.VìH458Q'
o
45:2s7AZ710303.1Z26.='@2?.*+,2s+vKs710Q2?BC. 4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82Q71KC2?BC.A:+/.10I+-]
•
vB.)G<OMG.V<.V8234526),718©71K26B.)>82?.V03K345Z.K37102?BC.<458b4%UT.1<.V8271K2?BC.Z71:0I+/.w+/2?03:Z26:03.w458Q'2?B.|Z71:0I+,.|<452?. 03),45M71FH.102?BC.@7103M,'¢),'*.@¢.1;]
vB.¿)G8C2?.V03K345Z.¿<:+/2 <45r}.¿)G2 .=4%+/J´K3710 8Q718 º Z71<!O:2?.10 .1u[O.1032s+§237
O71O:M,4526.A26B.AZ%71:0I+,.R<452?.V03),45Mv'v452345;4%+/.=]
Ý$Þ>ñ$Þ Â£òòÍÆ¾Â£Èó
p 8à2?BC),+'*),+d+/.1032s452?),718àO03.1FH),71:+q97103r()>8¦26B.4503.=4¾qt)GMGMo;=.¤Z%718Q+/),'*.103.='v]BC.
O0I712s712?J}O.¾qt)GMGME;=.¾)G<!OMG.1<!.18C2?.='(458b'§2?.*+,26.='*NA<7=+,26MJK60I71< 4£2?.VZB8b71M,7=UT)GZ45M
O71)G8C2n71KFC)G.Vq9]»vB.tO.='v4%U}7=UT)GZ45Mb),+-+/:.=+½qP)GM>M®;=.o2345r}.18)G82s7tZ718b+,),'*.V0I452?),718;=:2
qt)GMGMX;=.26.=+/2?.*'458Q'¾.VFb45M>:452?.='±2?BQ710I71:UTBCMGJ¶K?0I71< .*'*:Z4523710I+E2s45r})G8QU£2?B. W Y[Z]
Z71:0I+/.!ô p )>8 Ô '*:Z4526),718Qõ5NH)G89v03)G8C)G2?J!\|71M>MG.=UT.=]%vB.V03.1K37103. 26B. O0I712s712?J}O. <:+/2
;=.w0I71;=:+,2|458 'K6:MGMGJK6:8Z26),718)G8bU.18b45;=MG)G8QU26B.w)G8Q+/2?03:Z523710I+237!:+/.w)G2Rqt)G2?Bb71:2
03.*S%:)>03)G8QU'=.V2345)GM>.='¥rH8b71qPMG.*'vU%.¥71K2?BC.öZ71<O:26.10 2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ)/+d+/:.=+§í÷.=]âU}]
<45)G8MGJ¡:+,.*'¾237£Z718Q+/2?03:Z2t4ª+,26:'=.V82 ¼>+|O0I71K?)>MG.1ì2?B.£O03.VK?.10303.*'¾MG.*45038)G8bU¶+,26J}MG.
458b'2?B.'*)GK?K6)GZ:MG26J·MG.1FH.1M/]vB.±MG.=45038C)G8QU·+/2?J}MG.71K!458)>8Q'*)GFH),'*:45MEqt)GMGM¹8Q712;=.
4%+-+,.*+d+/.='ö;=J2?BC.O0I712s712?J}O.=]A7(4%+-+,.*+d+92?BC.1)G0O03.VK?.103.V8Z.*+)G8¦M>.=45038)>8QUTN@2?BC.
+/2?:'*.18C23+|Z458 :+/.¾45Fb45)GM/45;=MG.¾4%+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2oS%:.*+,26),7188b45)G03.=+P718¢2?B.9¢.V;710458 J
7126B.10+-71:03Z.*]®BC.¢+/2?:'*.18C2|BC)G<+/.1MGKEqP)GM>M'*.1Z),'*.ª2?B.ªMG.1FH.1M 71K'*)GK?K6)GZ:MG26J¢;=.=+/2
+/:)G2?.*'tK37102?BC.n.1u[),+/2?)G8bU¹r}8Q71qtMG.='vUT.o7182?BC.o+,:;1×G.1Z2s]Ï&à+/)G<OM>.n)G8260I7='=:Z5237103JP26.=+/2
qt)GMGM;=.45F®45)GM,45;=M>.4%+lqt.1MGM4%+26B.w71O26),7189237 ZBQ458bUT. 2?B.w'*)GK6K?)GZ5:MG2?J!MG.1FH.1M'*:03)G8QU
26B.Z71:0I+/.1N!45ZZ%710I'=)>8QU·237 2?.*+,203.*+,:M>23+-]nvBC),+¡45OO0I7=45ZBµMG.18b'+£)G23+/.1M>K2372?BC.
Z718b+,2603:Z2?)>FC),+/23+-¼`45OO0I7=45ZB¢26BQ452n2?BC.MG.*45038.10<!:+,2O450326)GZ)GO4526.45Z26)GFC.VMGJ±)G8¶2?BC.
MG.*45038)G8bUO0I71Z.=+-+d]
vB.+/J®+/2?.V<¬qt)GMGMx;=.45F®45)GM,45;=M>.71FH.10R2?BC.o7103M/'!¢),'*.¢.1;][LP452345;4%+/.=+lqt)GMGM;=.
:+/.=' K3710¿2?BC. +/23710I4%UT. 71K«+,26:'=.V82s+d¼O0I71K?)GM.*+458b' 71K¥45MGM26B.¬<452?.V03),45MGN
)G8b+,2603:Z2?)/718Q45ME458Q'§4%+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C23]BC.±+,Jx+/2?.V< qP)GMGM;=.±'*J}8Q45<!)GZ]³4%U%.*+EqP)>MGM`;=.
UT.18C.10I4526.='718·26B.K6MGJqt)G2?B·26B.:+/.¤71K 345F®49Y[.103FHMG.V23+458b' s45Fb45Y[Z03)GO2|qPB.V8
8C.1Z.*+d+-4503Jx]vB.oO4%U%.*+½Z7182s45)G8)G8bUP2?BC.o<452?.V03),45Mxqt)GMGM;=.<4%'*.:O¢71K°<7='*:MG.*+d]
W 7='*:MG.*+|Z458 ;=.BC2?<!MGNl26.1u[2?Nn45OOM>.123+710t<:MG26)G<.*'*),4wK6)GMG.=+-]BC.92?.Vu2o710oB26<M
Z718C2?.V82°71K°4½<7='=:M>.Z458P;=.R)G8Q+/.10326.='i'*)G03.1Z52?MGJ)G8C237A2?BC. 'v452345;4%+/.1NH710X+/237103.*'@)G894
K6)GMG.¹qP)G26B4R03.VK?.V03.18Z5.E2s7E)G2)G8!26B.P'v452345;4%+/.=]V&EMGMQ7126B.10K?)GM>.=+®qP)>MGMC;=.¸:OM,7=4%'*.*'t237
26B. +/.103FH.10X458b'@03.1K?.V03.18CZ.='@)G8t2?B.@'v4 2345;4%+/.=]
Ý$Þ>ù$Þ ß±Æ¾ÈPÌ æ ÅɾÁ
Á|ÍÌ£ÈÁEÌ£ÍÅ
vB)/+ZBb45O2?.10q4%+µ458 )G8C2?0I7='*:Z26),718 237À26B.ä'*),+-+/.103234526),718 O03.*+,.V826)G8QUÀ2?BC.
71;1×G.1Z26)GFC.*+¾458b'ö2?B.ö45OO0I7=45ZBµ2s45r}.18Q]X.VM,71q ),+4¾;=03)G.1K'*.=+/Z03)GO26),718À71Kw2?BC.
+/2?03:Z26:03. 71KC2?B)/+v03.VO71032Q458Q'i71KC2?B.RK371MGM/71qP)G8bUnZ5BQ45O2?.V0I+d]
•
úQûü5ýþsÿ
ú
•
úQûü5ýþsÿ
ú
"!
vB)/+AZBQ45O26. 0|qt)GMGMA'*.=+/Z03)G;=.ª458Q'£.1F®45MG:452?.MG.*45038)G8bUw.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s+@458Q'
<452?.103)/45Mv45Fb45)>M,45;=MG. 718t2?BC.A¢.1;]
•
úQûü5ýþsÿ #"$"%
vB)/+iZBb45O2?.V09qP)GMGM71:2?MG)>8.±2?B.±03.=ST:)G03.V<.V823+£458b'2?B.'*.=+/),UT8«71Ko2?BC.
O0I71O7=+/.='i4%'v45O2?)GF .AM>.=45038)>8QU.18CFC)G0I718C<.V823]
•
úQûü5ýþsÿ &'(""')
*
vB)/+ZBb45O2?.V0nqP)GMGM®O03.=+/.1822?BC.P)G<!OMG.1<!.182s452?),718¶71Kl26B.PO0I712s712?J}O.P;=:)>MG2
Ks710Q2?B)/+'*),+-+,.V03234526),718Q]
•
úQûü5ýþsÿ +,
)
-&Z503)G2?),ST:.71K2?B.AO0I7123712?J}O.@+,Jx+/2?.1<¦;=:)GMG2CK?0I71< 4l26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)GZ%45M*O71)G82b71K
FH)G.1q qP)GM>M*;=.AO03.*+,.V82?.*'@)G8P26B),+ZBQ45O26.10I]
•
úQûü5ýþsÿÔ 030I710/. Ø .1K6.103.18CZ. +-71:03Z.R8Q712Ks71:8Q'v]
ú
ú
0$"$
vB.V03.µ),+4«UT0I71qP)>8QUµ)G8C2?.103.*+,2±)G8ã.='*:Z4526),718Q45Mª)G8Q+/2?)G26:2?),718b+¶)G8 '*.VFC.VM,71O)G8QU
MG.*45038)G8bU .V8FH)G0I718<!.18C23+àKs710¬718MG)G8C. '*.1MG)>FC.V03J 71K .='*:Z4526),718Q] W 4526.103),45M)/+
O:;=MG)/+,BC.='¿718µ26B. p 82?.V038.V2?Nw45)G<!)G8QU237BC.1MGOã'*),+ 23458CZ.¤.='*:Z452?)/718Ni7103Ni4%+4
+/:OOMG.1<!.18C2A237Z%71:0I+,.*+¸)G8¾K345Z. º 2s7 º K345Z5.ZM,4%+-+/.=+-]&|MG26BQ71:UTB¾<458J03.*+,.*4503ZB.V0I+
ST:.=+/2?)/718¢)G23+E.VK?K6.1Z26)GFC.V8.*+d+/N26B.97103M,' º ¢),'*.9¢.1;+,.V.1<+¹2379;=.4O0I71<),+/)G8QU
<!.='*)G:< Ks710'*.VMG)GFH.103)G8bU.*'=:Z%452?),718718CMG)G8C.=]b971qt.1FH.103N2?BC.103.),+8Q7¢+/23458b'450I'
26BQ452¤'*.=+/Z03)G;=.*+¾B 71q 26B.öZ71:0I+/.ö<452?.103)/45M±+,Bb71:M,'¿;=.¥'=.VMG)GFH.103.*'¬71FH.10 2?BC.
8C.12?q7103rx]
\:0303.18C2§O0I45Z52?)GZ.71K '*.1FH.1M,71O)G8bU´718M>)G8.¿Z71:0I+/.=+Ks45MGM,+)G8C237718C.¬71K¤26q97
Z4526.=U}7103)G.*+dy=Z:+/2371<ä)G8C)G2?),4526)GFH.=+@'*.1FH.1M/71O.=';=Jª2?BC.)G8Q+/2?)G26:2?),718b+R2?BC.1<+,.VMGFC.*+,N710
Z:+/2371<!),+-45;=MG. 45OOMG)>Z452?),718b+vK60I71<µ26B. +-71K?26q94503.R)G8Q'*:+/2?0 Jx]
v03J})G8QU£237),'*.18C2?)GK6J¾26B.Z%71<O718.V82s+P71K4¢.1; º;4%+,.*'M>.=45038)>8QU9.18FH)G0I718C<.18C2
26B03.1. '*)G<.V8Q+/),718Q+ +,Bb71:M,' ;=. Z718b+,)/'=.V03.='vy2?BC. +-71Z),45M©'*)G<!.18b+,),718CNö2?BC.
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)GZ45M@'*)G<.V8Q+/),718ö458b'¡2?BC.ª.*'=:Z%452?),718b45M '*)G<.V8Q+/),718Q]BC.ª<4ç×ç7103)G26J71K
¢.V; º ;4%+/.=' MG.*45038)G8bU .18FH)G0I718C<.18C23+ 26BQ452 .1u[),+/2 Ks71Z: + <7103. 718 2?BC.
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)GZ45M¥'=)><.18b+,)/718 458Q' MG.*+d+ã718 26B. .='*:Z452?)/718Q45M¥7102?B. +-71Z),45M
'*)G<!.18Q+/),718b]
Õ
8CMG)G8C..18FH)G0I718C<.18C23++/BQ71:M/'¤;=.<7103.26BQ458·q45J®+71Kw'=.VMG)GFH.103)G8bU±26.1u[23]QBC.
Z718C2?.V82²<:+/2²;=. '*J}8Q45<!)GZ45MGM,71qP)>8QU¬Ks710µ)G8C2?.10I45Z52?),718 45ZZ710I'*)G8bU¬237 2?BC.
Z718b+,2603:Z2?)>FC),+/2 45OO0I7=45Z5BQ]\E718Q+ 2?03:Z26)GFH),+,2s+ +,:U}UT.=+/2¬26BQ452ã)G8Ks7103<4526),718 )/+
O0I71Z.*+d+/.='i)G8±4nO.10I+-718Q45Mvq945J458Q'w26B. MG.*45038.V0RZ718b+,2603:Z23+rH8b71qPMG.*'vU%. )>8Q+/2?.=4%'
4%'v45O2?)>FC.R237A2?BC.Aq45J+/2?:'*.V823+MG.*45038P;=.=+ 23]
å$Þ>å$Þ òÅ߾£˱ƾË43
Õ FH.10|2?B.wJ}.=450I+/N®26B.103.iBb4%+A;=.1.18§4!+,BC)GK?2)G8O.='v4%U}7=UT)GZ45MO.10I+/O.1Z26)GFH.=+AK?0I71< 4
52?0I458b+,<!),+d+/),718 5 <7='*.VMXí÷2?BC.),'*.=4@26BQ452½MG.*45038)G8bUi)/+X.=+-+/.1826),45MGMGJ2?BC.£4%+-+,)G<!)GM,4526),718
71K)G8CK37103<4526),718Qï®2s7i26B.4%'v71O2?)/718¤71K¹4<7103. 5 Z718b+,2603:Z2?)>FC),+/2 5 K?0I45<.Vq97103r¶í÷2?BC.
),'*.*4¹2?Bb452°MG.=45038C)G8QU )/+n458¡45Z52?)GFH.O0I71Z.=+-+n71K°Z718Q+/2?03:Z26)G8QU<.*458)G8bU71892?BC. O45032
71KC.=45ZBt)G8Q'*)GFH),'*:45M*MG.*45038.10Iï6]
p 8¦B),+92?BC.=+/),+±ô5\|71:0I+/.1q4503.(718¦2?B.§K?MGJxõ5N L¹)GMGM,718 6 Ü87 03.1FH)G.1q+926B.¤MG.=45038C)G8QU
26B.=7103)>.=+-y.VBQ45FH),71:03),+/<N(\E7=UT8)G26)GFH),+,< 458Q' \E718Q+/2?03:Z52?)GFH),+/<]§t),+À2?B.*+,)/+
)G8CZMG:'*.=+ 4%+/O.1Z 23+µK?0I71< 45MGM2?BC03.1. 2?BC.=7103)G.*+µ;=:2<45)G8CMGJ Z718b+,2603:Z2?)GFH),+/<]
\E718Q+/2?03:Z52?)GFH),+/<N®qtB)GZ5B±q4%+A)G8K6MG:.18CZ.='M,450IUT.1MGJ;=J¢+,Z)>.18Z5.w26.=45ZBC)G8QUTN½4%+d+/.1032s+
26BQ452orH8b71qPMG.*'vU%.),+PZ%718Q+/2?03:Z26.='§;=J26B.MG.*45038.103NR8Q712O4%+-+,)GFH.1M>J03.1Z.V)GFH.='ö710
4%+-+,)><)GM,4526.='v]l792?BC.9Z718Q+/2?03:Z52?)GFH),+/23+EFH)G.1qtN°MG.=45038C)G8QU9),+P458 4%'45O26)GFH.O0I7=UT03.=+-+
458b' Z%458P;=. '*.*+,Z03)>;=.='i4%+4lZ5BQ458QUT.RZ718Q+/2?03:Z26.='@K?0I71<¦.1u[O.103)G.V8Z.*]
Õ 8CMG)G8C.MG.*45038)G8bU '*.VFC.VM,71O<.V82(+/BQ71:M/'äKs71Z:+718 +/:OO71032?)>8QU2?BC.´45Z52?)GFH.
O450326)GZ)GO4526),718 71K 2?BC. +,26:'=.V82 )G8 Z%718Q+/2?03:Z26)G8QU O.10I+-718Q45MGMGJ <.*458)G8bUTK?:M
03.VO03.=+/.182s452?),718b+«71K·2?BC. <4526.103),45M,] p 2<:+/28 712;=.à×ë:+/2O03.=+/.18C23452?)/718 71K
)G8CK37103<452?),718CN$;=:226B.+,26:'*.182<:+/2°2?BC)G8r45;71:2°26B.<4526.103),45MO03.=+/.18C2?.='v]BC.
+/2?:'*.18C2<:+/2¹458Q45MGJx+/.2?B.)>8K37103<452?),718O03.*+,.V826.='¡458b'¡'*),+/Z:+-+R)G2`qP)>2?B¤712?BC.10
+/2?:'*.18C23+-]
å$Þ>é$Þ ÄÅ£ÍɾÊÏÉ±Ë Á93|ÄÅ
2.3.1 Concepts
v.=45038C)G8QU+,26JHM>. BQ4%+;=.V.18±'*.1K6)G8.*'w)G89<458J'*)GK6K?.V03. 826NCJ}.V2X+,)G<!)GM,450Xq945Jx+-]ÙR.1.1K6.
)G8C2?.V0I45Z23+¢qP)G26B 458b'03.=+/O718Q'v+¶237¦26B.àMG.=45038C)G8QUµ.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s] 345<!.=+²458Q'
{ 450 '*8.V0 6÷Û 7 '*.1K?)>8.='àMG.=45038C)G8QU«+/2?J}MG.¦4%+26B.²q945J«)>8áqtB)GZ5BáM>.=45038.V0I+;=.=+/2
O.V03Z.1)GFH.1N%O0I71Z5.=+-+,NH+/237103.@458Q'@03.1Z45M>M*qPBb4522?BC.1J!4503. 45262?.V<O2?)>8QU237AMG.*45038Q]
v.=45038C)G8QU+/2?J}MG.w<7='*.VM,+Fb4503J)G8<458Jq45J®+-]
W
Z5l71:UTBCMG)G8 6
ø;7
'*),+/Z:+d+/.=+A26q97
'*)GK6K?.103.V82v2?0I4%' )G26),718Q+®)>8MG.=45038C)G8QUt+,26JHM>.=+x03.*+,.*4503ZBQ] Õ 8. 45OO0I7=45ZB'*.103)GFH.=+xK60I71<
O+/J}ZBQ71M,7=UTJ í÷Z7=UT8C)G2?)GFH. º O.103Z.VO2?:45M,ï458Q'äK371Z:+/.=+à718 '*)GK6K?.103.V82§<7='*.=+à71K
O0I71Z.*+d+/)G8bU458Q'tO03.*+,.V82?)>8QUE)G8CK37103<452?),718b] Ø ),'*)G8QU458b't\B.V.1<4 6;7 ),'*.18C2?)GK6J2?BC.
<8=?>A@CBED@GF H I8J8I8>CK;DL@AF
458Q' MNEO*P I8>G@CB
NEO
H
)><4%UT.10EMG.=45038C)G8QU+/2?J}MG.*+d]}vB.ª+,.VZ718Q'¡45OO0I7=45ZB
íîMG.=45038C)G8QU º Z5.182603.=' 2?0I4%'*)G2?)/718QïK371Z5:+,.*+´718 45OO0I7=45ZB.*+237 MG.*45038)G8bU%Nµ458Q'
Z718CZ.1O26),718Q+71KXMG.=45038C)G8QU}]CL¹)GK6K?.103.V82XMG.=45038C)G8QU+/2?J}MG.w2?Bb452BQ45FH.w;=.V.18),'*.18C2?)GK6)G.='
BC.103. 4503.@45Z2?)>FC),+/23+/N%03.1K6MG.1Z523710I+/N%2?B.*7103),+/23+458Q'@O0I4%UT<452?)/+,2s+d]
&EMG2?Bb71:U%B )G2),+¡O7=+-+/)G;=MG.237),'*.1826)GK?J2?BC.(MG.=45038C)G8QU+,26JHM>.=+71K)G8b'*)GFC)/'=:45M/+,N
Ø 71;712?Bb45< 6 187 ST:.=+/2?)/718Q+öqPBC.12?BC.10©+/:ZB 458 45OO0I7=45ZB ),+F®45MG),'v]t.ã)/+
Z718CZ.1038C.='2?Bb452x:+/)G8bU|.1u[),+,26)G8QU|)>8FH.182s7103)G.=+71KMG.=45038C)G8QU+/2?J}MG.*+,N»)G8Q'*)GFH),'*:45M,+4503.
45MGM/71Z452?.*'ª23748b45030I71q 0I458QUT.71K`Z452.=U}7103)G.=+/NZ7182s45)G8)G8bU4 MG)G<!)G2?.*'8:<!;=.10P71K
MG.*45038)G8bUP45Z26)GFH)G2?)G.*+2s7nqtB)GZ5B2?BC.1J4503.1N)G826B.=7103J}N;=.=+/2°+/:)G2?.*'v] t.+/:UHUT.*+,2s+2?Bb452
MG.*45038.V0I+`+,Bb71:M,'t;=.t+,.VMGKº '*)G03.1Z26.='458b't2?Bb452v2?B.VJ<:+/2vBQ45FH.¸2?B.¸ZBb71)GZ.¸237¸:+,.t4
O450326)GZ:M,450MG.*45038)G8bU¢+,26J}MG.¶710P8Q7123] Ò .VM,'*.10 6 287 )/+w45M/+d7¶'*),+/Z:+-+,)>8QU2?BC.ª;=.V8.VK?)G2s+
K60I71< 2?.=45Z5B)G8bU+/2?:'*.18C23+qt)G2?B±45MGMvMG.*45038)G8bU+/2?J}MG.*+d]%P. 03.VK?.10I+237 )G24%+Aô526.=45ZBC)G8QU
450I71:8b' 26B.RZJ}ZMG.=õ%]
2.3.2 Benefits
71qP.1FH.10l2?B.¹;=.18C.1K6)G23+bK?0I71<á:+/)G8QU|MG.*45038)G8bU+,26J}MG.=+®)G8i26B.¸MG.=45038C)G8QU¹O0I71Z.=+-+`4503.
8b712ST:.=+/2?),718C.=';=J!<7=+,271Kx03.=+/.=4503ZBC.10I+-] W :MG2?)><.='*),4 458b'Z71<O:26.10¹+-71K?2?q4503.
Z458;=.o:+,.*'2374%'v'*03.=+-+½2?B.o8.V.='v+¸71K4¹Fb4503)G.V2?J±71KMG.=45038C.10I+-] W 7182sU}71<.103J 6:;7
260I4%'=)>2?),718b45M*MG.=45038C)G8QU<!.12?Bb7='v+vZ458C8Q712s]
&E8Q712?BC.10;=.V8.1K6)G2|K60I71< 45262?.18b'*)G8QU237M>.=45038)>8QU +,26J}MG.=+ ),+ 2?BQ452EqP.ªOM,45Z.<7103.
03.*+,O718b+,)G;=)>MG)G2?J 718 2?B.´+,26:'*.182s+²26B.V<+/.1MGFH.=+-]¨9712¤.1FH.103J};7='*Jä),+.=ST:45MGMGJ
O0I7='*:Z26)GFC.@45226B. +-45<.R2?)G<!. 71KC2?B.@'v45J458b'i+d71<!.A<45J03.*S%:)>03.A<7103.R;=03. 45rx+-]
2.3.3 The Sensory Intake of Information Approach
p 82?BC),+½2?BC.=+/),+¸458¡45OO0I7=45Z5B;4%+/.='718¡71:0@+,.V8Q+-7103J)G8C2345r}.!71K)>8K37103<452?),718£qt)GMGM
;=.¦4%'v71O2?.*']
{
.182603J 6Q;7 Z4526.=U}7103),+/.²MG.=45038C)G8QU¦+,26JHM>.=+¶4%+-y¸OBCJx+,)GZ%45MGN+/.18b+d7103J
O03.VK?.103.V8Z.*+®)G82s7¹FH),+/:45MGN45:'*)G2s7103JHN[2345Z52?)GMG.o4 8b'or})G8b45.=+/2?B.V2?)GZ%]Ï&EM,718QU¸2?B.*+,.nM>)G8.*+,N
4`MG.=45038C)G8QUt+,26J}MG.o+,:03FH.1J'*.1FH.1M,71O.*'452L¹),45;=M,7n@45MGM>.1JP\E71MGM>.=UT. 6 Ü 7 O0I71FH),'*.=+458
718CMG)G8.@ST:.=+/2?),718C8Q45)G03.R),'*.1826)GK?J})G8bU2?B.RK371MGM/71qP)G8bUnM>.=45038)>8QU+,26J}MG.=+-]
vB.RR)/+,:45M,Ú*X.103;45M*v.*45038)G8bUnY[2?J}MG.
v.=45038C.10I+71K2?B)/+Q26J}O.EMG.*45038!; .*+,2vqtB.18i)G8CK37103<452?),718i),+®O03.*+,.V82?.*'tFH),+,:45M>MGJ£458Q'
)G84Rqt03)G2?26.18wK37103<452s]VvB.VJ;=.18.VK?)G2K?0I71<áBQ45FH)G8bU|MG),+/23+bqP)G26B!26B.¸.=+-+/.1826),45MHO71)G82s+
458b'¢71:2?MG)G8C.=+'*:03)G8QUM>.1Z26:03.458b';=J2345r})G8QU8b712?.*+d]CvBC.1J2?.V8Q'ª2s7+/2?:'*J)G8§4
ST:)G.V20I7=71<]
vB.RR)/+,:45M,Ú@¨718FH.103;45M*v.=45038C)G8QUY[2?J}MG.
v.=45038C.10I+ 71K$2?BC),+l+/2?J}MG.M>.=45038;=.*+,2$qtB.V8)G8Ks7103<4526),718),+vO03.=+/.1826.='@FH),+,:45M>MGJ}N%)G894
O)GZ52?:03.P710¸'*.=+/),UT8!Ks7103<4523]IBC.1J;=.V8.1K6)G2K?0I71<¿)G8Q+/2?03:Z523710I+®qPBb7¹:+/.¸FC),+/:45M®45),'v+
+/:ZB 4%+K?)GMG<!NiFC),'*.*71Nw<45O+458b'¿ZBb450323+-]@BC.1Já;=.18C.1K?)>2K?0I71< )G8Ks7103<4526),718
71;=2s45)G8.*' K60I71<µ26B.AO)>Z2?:03.*+458b'w'*),4%UT0I45<+v)G8 2?.Vu26;7=71r®+-]
vB.R45Z2?)GM>.=Ú@ÙA)G8b45.=+/2?BC.12?)>Z½v.=45038)>8QUY26J}MG.
v.=45038C.10I+@71K`26B),+|+,26JHM>.MG.=45038;=.*+,2½qtB.V8OBJx+/)GZ45MGMGJ.18bU}4%U%.*'£)>8 4 5 Bb458Q'v+|718 5
vB.R&|:'*)G2s7103J®Ú@X.103;45M*v.*45038)G8bUnY[2?J}MG.
v.=45038C.10I+n71K°2?BC),+l2?J}O.MG.*45038;=.*+,2°qtB.18£)G8CK37103<452?),718£),+lO03.*+,.V82?.*'45:'*)G237103J)G8
458710I45MM/458QUT:4%UT.@K37103<4523] p 84AZ5M,4%+d+/0I7=71<ä+/.1262?)G8bUTN=2?B.VJi;=.18.VK?)G2xK?0I71<MG),+/2?.18C)G8QU
2s7©MG.VZ2?:03.*+«458Q' O45032?)GZ5)GO452?)G8bUã)G8 '*),+/Z:+-+,)/718Q+-]£vB.VJ 45M,+-7 ;=.18.VK?)G2·K60I71<
71;=2s45)G8)G8bU)G8Ks7103<452?)/718PK?0I71<À45:'*),7=]
å$Þ>ñ$Þ Â Å æ ÅXɱÁ
&+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2)/+n458)><O710323458C2°O45032X71KX458±718MG)G8C. MG.=45038C)G8QU.18CFC)G0I718C<.V82X4%+)G2Q)/+
Ks710458CJMG.*45038)G8bUwO0I71Z.*+d+-] p 2¹'=.V<718b+,260I452?.=+2372?BC.)G8b+,2603:Z237103Nv;=:2¸45M,+-72372?BC.
+/2?:'*.18C23+ª26B.V<+/.1MGFH.=+/N2?B.O0I7=U%03.*+d+¾+,26:'*.182s+¡450 .<45r})G8QU}] p 8©4%'v'*)G2?)/718«237
.VFb45MG:4526)G8QU¶26B.1)>0O0I7=UT03.=+-+,N4%+-+/.=+-+,<!.182oB.VMGO+£+,26:'*.182s+MG.=45038b]Y$71<!.71Ko2?BC.
4%'*F®458234%UT.*+71K458718CMG)G8.4%+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2+,Jx+/2?.V< 4503.@2?Bb452b)G2+-45FH.=+26)G<.|K37102?:2s710I+
qtB)GMG.¤2?BC.§K6.1.*'=;45Z5r(237§26B.+,26:'=.V82s+9)/+±ST:)GZ5rH.V0I] p 84%'v'=)>2?),718CNi4+/2?:'*.18C23¼ð+
O0I71K6)GMG.nZ458 ;=.n;=:)GM>22?B0I71:UTB4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82<45rH)>8QU¹)>2O7=+d+/)G;=MG.nKs71026B.o+/J®+/2?.V<¥237
4%'v45O2237t26B.oq945J9.=45Z5B¶+/2?:'*.18C2M>.=45038Q+n458b'!K371Z5:+n718.*45ZB¾+,26:'*.182s¼>+lqt.=45r}.=+/2
O71)G8C23+-]
Õ
¼
Ø
.V)GMGMGJö458Q' ³452?2?.V0I+d718
[11]
'*),+,Z5:+d+2?B.)G<O71032s458Z. 71K4%+d+/.=+-+,<!.18C2@2372?BC.
MG.*45038)G8bUO0I71Z.=+-+¢458Q' 2?B.²:+/.¦71K26B.²¢¢ 2s7.V8BQ458CZ.¦4%+d+/.=+-+/<.18C2£)G8
MG.*45038)G8bU¡Z71826.1u[23+-]
p
8CZ7103O710I452?)>8QU¾26B.)G826.10I45Z26)GFH.±8b452?:03.§71K¢¢ Ks7102?BC.
O:03O7=+/. 71K4%+-+/.=+-+,<!.182iZ458Z7=+/2iMG)G262?MG. ;=:2ª4%'v' Fb45M>:.¤)>8(O7=+d+/)G;=)GMG)>2?)G.*+!K3710
Z71M>M,45;710I452?)GFH.1N%03.*+d71:03Z5. º ;4%+/.='@MG.*45038)G8bU}]
vB.VMGq945M>M
[12]
+,:03FH.1J +d71<!. 71K²26B.©03.=4%+-718Q+Ks710µ:+/)G8QU¬Z%71<O:2?.V0I+K3710
4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V82s]nvBC.03.=+/:MG23+¾+,Bb71qP.*'26BQ4520I458b'71< º ;4%+/.='(2?.*+,2s+Z71:M,'(BQ45FH.4
8C:<;=.10(71K4%'*F®4582s4%U%.*+·71FC.V0K6)Gu.*'´4%+-+,.*+d+/<.V823+-]o&+d+/.=+-+/<.18C2BQ4%+¡237;=.
FH)G.1qt.='9qP)G26B)G82?B.PMG.=45038C)G8QU.18CFC)G0I718C<.V82½)G8qPB)>ZB)G2½)/+|+/)G2?:4526.='458Q' )G2Z458
Õ U}452s4 N DRI?>AS
)G8á2?B.V)G0¶O45O.V0
[13]
'*.*+,Z03)>;=.«4ö+/Jx+,26.1< K3710²+/:OO71032?)>8QU2?BC..VuZBb458QUT.71Kx<4503r}.=' º :O±'71Z5: <.18C23+Q;=Ji. º <45)GM,] Ò 710½26B.¹03.1O03.=+/.18C234526),71871K2?BC.
'v71Z:<!.182s+®\E71<<:8C)GZ4526)GFC. W 4503r º :O!458QUT:4%UT.Píî\\ W ïîN»qPBC)GZBi),+x;4%+/.='!718
Y {
W
N»q94%+b:+,.*'v]VvB.¹03.=+/:MG23++/BQ71qP.*'t2?Bb452vqP)G26Bw26B.¸.1u[ZBb458QUT.t71K<4503r}.=' º :O
'v71Z:<!.182s+)G2bq4%+.*4%+,JwK3710E+/2?:'*.18C23+2s7@:8Q'*.10I+/23458b'i26B.@26.=45ZBC.10I¼>+°Z710303.1Z52?) 718b+
;=.VZ45:+,[email protected].*'=;45Z5ro26B.VJoqt.103.@U%.V2?26)G8QU}]
å$Þ>ù$Þ ÄÅ£ÍɾÊÏÉ±Ë ÂÉ±ß Á|ó±ÅUTƱÍÄß TÊÏß±ÅUTÅÃ
vB.¹03.1O71032s+71Kx<458J03.=+/.=4503Z5B.10I+458b'P2?B.¹Z718C2?)G8C:)G8QUE03.*+,.*4503ZBª718i2?B.t+/:;1×ë.VZ2
)G8b'*)GZ452?.926BQ452n26B.97103M,'¢),'*.¢.1;),+t458¶.1K6K?.1Z52?)GFH.<.*'*)G:< K3710!'*.1M>)GFC.V03)G8QU
.*'=:Z%452?),718b]
450IUT.10WV 450IUT.10
[14]
+,.V.O7=+-+,)G;=)>MG)G2?)>.=+9K3710)G8C2?.10I45Z52?),718¦2?B0I71:UTB¦2?B.§¢.1;'*.=+/O)G26.i'*)GK?K6.103.18C271O)G8C),718Q+°2?BQ452®2?B.|¢.1;ª'v71.=+8b712b2?03:M>J!O0I71<712?.@MG.*45038)G8bUi4%+
26B.8C.126q97103rZ7188C.1Z26),718·+/O.1.*'v+t458b'26B.wBQ450I'*q94503.wMG)G<!)G234526),718Q+'v7!8b712@UT)GFH.
26B. 45<71:82b71K)G8C2?.10I45Z52?),718tMG.=45038C)G8QU'*.1<458Q'v+ ]
71qP.1FH.103N2?B. p 8C2?.1038C.12),+¡;=.VZ71<)G8bU¦<7103.03.VMG),45;=MG.458Q'á.1F®71MGFC.*+¡)G82s74
Z71<!<:8C)GZ452?)/718Q+o<!.='*)G:< 45M>M,71qP)G8bUKs710i03)GZB)G8C2?.V0I45Z2?),718b]bBC.7103M,'¢¢),'*.
¢.V;8b712¤718MGJ´'=.VMG)GFH.10I+¾26.1u[2;=:2¤45M,+-7+/:OO710323+¾26B.(:+/.¿71K<!:MG2?)G<!.='*),4
.VMG.1<!.182s+458b'@Z71<<!:8)GZ4526),718971O26),718Q+
[15]
]
vB.4%'*Fb458C234%UT.=+o71KA26B.:+/.71KR¢.1; º ;4%+,.*'Z71:0I+,.Vq94503.VN4%+4+,:OOM>.1<.V82X237
26B.2?0I4%'*)G2?)/718Q45M '*.VMG)GFH.103J²71Kt4wZ%71:0I+,.£)G8 2?BC.£ZM,4%+-+,0I7=71<!Nn4503.¾'*),+,Z5:+d+/.='¾K60I71<
³45O4%+/OJ}0I71: N DXI?>GS
[16]
]vB.¾+/2?:'*.18C23+|Z458 +/2?:'*J¶26B.£<4526.103),45M|452¸2?B.V)G0971qt8
O45Z.VN½458CJ26)G<.VN K60I71< 458JOM,45Z.9458Q'92?B.P2?.=45Z5B.10t45Z2s+|4%+K345Z)GM>)G23452s710P4%+-+/),+,26)G8QU
26B.@MG.*45038)G8bUO0I71Z5.=+-+d]TvB.+,Jx+/2?.1<´'*.1FH.1M,71O.*')/+R4 '*),+/2?03)G;=:26.='£+/J®+/2?.V<:+/)G8QUi4
458b' Z%ï[2?BC.AZ71<!<:8C)GZ452?)/7189+/:;+,Jx+/2?.1<]
W 45r}0I45r}),+ N DYI?>AS
[17]
ZM,45)G<!.='¾26BQ452t458 .1K6K?.1Z52?)GFH.¾71O.18 458Q''*),+/23458CZ.£MG.=45038C)G8QU
íÕ LEïvBJ}O.103<!.='*),4+/Jx+,26.1<ãZ458ª;=.oO0I7='*:Z.='O0I71FH),'*.='26BQ4522?BC.tZ71:0I+/.1q4503.
),+`qP.VMGM'*.=+/),UT8.*'458Q'qP)G26B¢'*J}8Q45<!)GZ@)G8C2?.10 Ks45Z.=+-]vB.o.1K6K?.VZ2?)GFH.18C.=+-+¸71K4E¢.V; º
;4%+/.=' Õ LEÀ+,Jx+/2?.V< '=.VFC.VM,71O.='¦458Q'²2?03),45M :+/.='à4522?BC.¶¨94526),718Q45M v.VZB8C)GZ45M
DE8)GFH.10I+/)G2?Jã71K£&E2?B.V8Q+¢íî¨PvD|&ï÷N
{
03.V.1Z.VNPq94%+.VFb45M>:452?.='v]¸BC),+.1F®45MG:4526),718
03.*+,.*4503ZB+,:U}UT.=+/23+26BQ452ª+,:Z5B4§+,Jx+/2?.V< '*.*+,),UT8+/BQ71:M,' ;=. Z.V82603.='«7182?BC.
ZBb450I45Z2?.V03),+/2?)GZ+·7 K26B.+,26:'*.182s+,N!2?BC.àZ%71:0I+,.Vq94503.458Q'26B.(8b452?:03.á71K2?BC.
MG.*45038)G8bU2s4%+,r¦0I452?B.V0¾26BQ458ã718¥26B.·:8Q'*.V03MGJ})G8QU²2?.1Z5B8Q71M/7=U%)>Z45MiOM,452?Ks7103<]&
8C:<;=.1071K+,:U}UT.=+/2?)/[email protected].ª<4%'=.K3710945ZB)G.VFC)>8QU2?BC),+/N¸+,:Z5Bö4%+-yx)G8CZMG:'*)G8QU
<7103. )G826.10I45Z26)GFC. .Vu$45<!OMG.=+/N 4%+d+/),UT8<!.182s+,N 458)><452?)/718N 458Q' .1u[.103Z)/+ .*+,N
.V803)GZBC)G8QU£2?BC.9Z71826.182AqP)G26B¶8.Vq´<4526.103),45M`qtB)GZB·+,Bb71:M,';=.O03.=+/.1826.=')G8²4
<7103.458Q45MGJ}2?)>Z45Mq945J}NEO0I71FH),'*)G8bU+/:<<4503)>.=+45226B.¶.V8Q'à71K.=45Z5BöZBQ45O26.103N
BC),UTBMG),UTBC2?)G8bU2?B.¤<4ç×,710 4%+/O.1Z2s+±458b'r}.1J(Z718CZ.1O2s+,N458Q' O0I71FH),'*)G8QU¤;=.12?26.10
Z718b+,)/+,26.18Z5J71KC2?BC.A2371O)>Z+,N%.*+,O.VZ),45MGM>Jo;=J< .10IUT)G8QU+/<45MGM»:8)G2s+d]
vB.¡O0I45Z2?)GZ5.1N¸BQ71qt.1FH.103Nt+,Bb71q9+i2?BQ452P<7=+/2£71K2?BC.¶.1u[),+/2?)G8bU 718CMG)G8C.¶MG.=45038C)G8QU
.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s+¤M,45Z5rã)>8 ST:45MG)G26J 458b'À:+,.À71K·45MGM26B.¦K?.=4526:03.=+71K¡<7='=.V038
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJx] W ),7='*:+,.V0 N DZI?>GS
[18]
O03.=+/.1824+,26:'*J71KE2?BC.ZBb450I45Z2?.V03),+,26)GZ+w71K¢.V;+,)G2 .=+ª4%+w2?.*45ZB)>8QU458Q'·MG.=45038C)G8QU¢.18CFC)G0I718C<.V823+-]½vB.1JZM,45)>< 2?Bb452<7=+/2
+/)G2?.*+,N qt)G2?BÀ718MGJ+-71<.§.1u[Z.1O26),718Q+/Nw71K?K6.10OM,45)G8¦)G8Ks7103<4526),718N qt)G2?B¦M,45Zr71K
)G8C2?.V0I45Z2?)GFH)G26J 458Q'qP)>2?BQ71:2¤2345r})G8bU´4%'*Fb458C234%UT.¬71K 2?B.¿8C.1q 2?.VZB8b71M,7=UT)GZ45M
03.*+d71:03Z.*+íî.=]âU}]5K37103<+,N%s45Fb4n45OOM>.123+/N%Y[BQ71Zr}q945FH.=ï6]
Õ 8 + 71<!. 712?BC.10 71ZZ4%+/),718NDE8)GFH.10I+/)G2?J 71K4%+,BC)G8QUT23718 K?:8b'45<!.18C2345MGMGJ
03.V2?BQ71:UTBC2)G23+§45OO0I7=45ZBÀ2s7(26B.«+,:OO71032¶71K2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ¿)G826.=45ZBC)G8QU¿458Q'
MG.*45038)G8bUí
[19]
ï6]AvB.1J03. º .1u45<)>8.='ö)G2s+£O0I7=UT0I45<+,N O0I45Z26)GZ.*+¾458b'(Ks45Z)GMG)>2?)G.*+,N.V8QU}4%UT.='¡+/2345r}.VBQ71M,'*.10I+X)G8;=0I7=4%'Z718CFC.V0I+d4 26),718Q+|7182?B.P0I71MG.£71K½26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ)G8
2s7=71Mº Ks71Z:+,.*' 2?BQ458 O.=71OMG. º Ks71Z:+,.*' 458Q' .1u[O03.=+-+,.*' 2?B. ;=.1MG)>.1Kµ26BQ452àK3710
26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ2s7±;=..1K6K .1Z52?)GFH.)G23+P:+/.<:+/2o;=.§'*03)GFH.18²K?)>0I+,2!458Q'¤K37103.1<7=+,2 ;=J
O.*'4%U}7=UT)GZ45MUH7=45M/+d]
å$ÞG[$Þ ÄÊ æ ÊÏÁEÂÁEÊÏÆ¾É
vB.9)>8)G26),45M`.1K6K3710323+¸2371q450I':+/)G8QU92?BC.¢.1;Ks710o26.=45ZBC)G8QU9q94%+t'v718.;=J+d71<!.
.*4503MGJ 4%'71O26.10I+
[20]
8b712?.='À26BQ452·458¬.1u45<)G8b452?),718 71K¡26B. +/2?03:Z52?:03.=+458Q'4%+-+,:<!O2?),718b+l2?Bb452 :8b'*.103MG)G.!'*.1Z5),+,)/718Q+n45;71:2°O.='v4%U}7=UTJ458Q'i)G<OM>.1<.V82s452?),718b+
4503. 26B. <7103. 03.VMG),45;=MG. r}.VJ®+237 .=+/2345;=MG),+/B)>8QUw+d71:8b'i)G8b+,2603:Z2?)/718FC)/4o'*),+/2?03)>;=:2?.='
MG.*45038)G8bU¸.V8FH)G0I718<!.18C23+-] vBC.M,45Zr71K$Z718b+,),'*.V0I452?),718Ks710°O.='v4%U}7=U%)>Z45M=),+-+,:.*+vBb4%+
BC)G8Q'*.103.*'@:2?)GMG)>èH452?),71871K2?BC.AMG.*45038)G8bU.18FH)G0I718C<.18C23+ K3710Q.*'=:Z%452?),718b45M*O:03O7=+,.*+d]
Ö@:.V826)G8 º l45u[2?.V0I¼>+¬+,26:'=J
[21]
Bb4%+¿)G8CFC.*+,26),U}452?.*' 26B. :+,. 71Kµ)G8C2?.10I45Z52?)GFH.BCJHO.V03<.*'=)/4MG.=45038C)G8QU¶.18CFC)>0I718<.V82s+d] p 8 2?BC),+ª+/2?:'*J}NnO45032971K4M,450IUT.109³BCL
+/2?:'*J}N@45:'*)G2 260I45)GM,+458b'ST:.=+/2?)/7188Q45)>03.=+oqt.103.:+/.='¢23703.VFC.*45Mn2?BQ452+,26:'=.V82s+
7 FH.103.*+,26)G<4526.='w26B.w45<71:8271Kb<452?.V03),45M2?BC.1J45ZZ.=+-+/.='K?0I71<À26B.@2s712345M45<71:8C2
45F®45)GM,45;=MG.*]TBC.@)G8C2?.10I45Z52?)GFH.+/2?0I4526.=UTJª4%'71O26.=';=JiMG.=45038C.10I+X45K?K6.1Z26.='2?BC.45<71:8C2
71K±)G8Ks7103<4526),718 45Z5Z.=+-+,.*'*NST:.=+/2?),718C)G8QUµ26B.à)G8Z03.*4%+,)>8QUµ:+/.À71K)G8C2?.10I45Z52?)GFH.
BCJHO.V03<.*'=)/4)G8P2?.=45Z5B)G8bU¸qt)G2?Bb71:2$K?:0326B. 0°03.*+,.*4503ZBQ]vB.K6)G8Q'*)G8bU}+l71K$26B),++,26:'=J
45OO.*4503.='237@Z718260I4%'*)GZ2bqt)G2?B26B.@Z%718Z.VO2b2?Bb452bMG.=45038C.10I+°rH8b71qµqtBQ4523¼ð+°;=.*+,2xK3710
26B.1<]
450I4\VàÙAMG)G8bU
[22]
03.1O7103226BQ452+/2?:'*.18C23+-¼K603:+,260I452?),718¾q94%+o4P;=),UO0I71;=MG.1< )G8'*),+/23458CZ. .='*:Z4526),718Q] Õ 8CMG)G8.MG.=45038C)G8QU BQ4%+²O712?.18C2 ),45M¢Ks710O0I71FC),'*)G8bU©03)>ZB
.V8FH)G0I718<!.182s+®K3710+,26:'=.V82s+,N;=:2l45M/+d7¸2?0I4%'*. º 71K?K3+-] BC.1J+,2s452?.n2?Bb4522?BC.n.1<OBb4%+,)/+
),+¸UT)GFH.18237t26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ458b'!8Q712°O.*'4%U}7=UTJx] Ø .=+/.=4503ZB£),+l8C.1.*'=.*'*NQ'*.=+/),UT8.*'!237
26.=45ZB²)G8b+,2603:Z23710I+PBb71q 26B.:+/.71K26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ458b'§O.='v4%U}7=UTJZ71:M,' <45r}.
[23]
),+-71M,4526),718O0I71;=MG.V<)G8¶718MG)>8.PM>.=45038)>8QU£458Q'BQ71q237tr}.V.1O +/2?:'*.18C23+½<7126)GF®452?.='v]
v.1Z5B8Q71M/7=U%J Z458 B.VMGO 8Q712 718M>J qP)>2?B Z71<!<:8)>Z452?),718 237=71M,+ í÷.1<45)GMGN
FH),'*.=71Z7 8CK?.V03.18Z5.1NZBQ452sïl;=:2o45M,+d79qP)>2?B¶26B.),'*.*471K +,Bb4503.='¤+,O45Z.458Q'¤718MG)G8C.
45Z26)GFH)G2?)G.*+d]
å$ÞG^$Þ ß±Å
ÊÏ˱ɾÊÏÉ±Ë Æ¾É±ÄÊIɱŢÄÅÂÍPɾÊÏÉ±Ë ÅɱΣÊIÍPÆ¾É æ ÅɱÁ
¢)GM/'_V Õ <4503)
[24]
71:26MG)G8C.PZ.V032345)G8ªO.='v4%U}7=U%)>Z45MbZBb450I45Z2?.V03),+,26)GZ+¹71Kn458¶718MG)G8C.MG.*45038)G8bUª.18CFC)>0I718<.V82t458Q'+d71<!.¡71K¸26B.£MG)G<!)G234526),718 71K¹26B.£¢.1;¾2?Bb452o718MG)G8C.
Z71:0I+/.'=.*+,)/U%8C.10I+<:+/2¤BQ45FH.)G8 <!)G8Q'v]wvBC.áK6.=4526:03.=+('*.1<458Q'*.='¬Ks710¥4
Z718b+,2603:Z2?)>FC),+/2Q45OO0I7=45Z5B94503.=y
•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N%;=.V2?qt.1.18tMG.=45038C.10X458b' <452?.V03),45M,+í÷)G8CK37103<4526),718Qï6]•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N%;=.V2?qt.1.18tMG.=45038C.10X458b' Z%7182?.V82b45:2?BQ710Xíî)G8Q+/2?03:Z523710Iï?]•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N%;=.V2?qt.1.18tMG.=45038C.10 +237A2s45rH.@45Z2?)/7189718P)>8K37103<452?),718b]•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N%;=.V2?qt.1.18tMG.=45038C.10I+237A8C.=U}712?),4526.A2s4%+,r!U}7=45M,+-]•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1Nv;=.V2?qP.V.18M>.=45038.V0I+X2s703.VK?MG.VZ2¸458b'£)G8C2?.V0I45Z2½qP)>2?B¢'*.*+,Z03)>O2?),718b+71KC2?B.Rq97103M,'v]
•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N ;=.12?qt.1.V8 .Vu26.18Q'*)G8bU 710 4%'v45O26)G8QU 26B. <4526.103),45M/+íî)G8Ks7103<452?)/718Qï?]
•
L¹),45M,7=UT:.1N»;=.12?qt.1.V8 O0I71FH),'*)G8QU|K6.1.*'=;45Z5rHN.=+/O.1Z)/45MGMGJ)G8C2?03)G8b+,)>ZRK6.1.='*;45Zr}N718tMG.=45038C.10I+-ÐI45Z52?),718b+d]
Õ 03.V8 N D`I?>GS
[25]
O0I71O7=+,.P4RO450326)GZ:M,450½.*'*:Z452?),718b45MZ718CK?),UT:0I4526),718!;4%+/.='9718w2?BC.
Z71<!;=)G8Q4526),718¢71K2?BC03.1.PZ%71<O718.V82s+dy4|FH)G032?:45M®Z71<<!:8)G26J±í?+-71Z),45M`'*)G<!.18b+,),718bï
Bb7=+,26.='¢;=Jö45845O O0I71O03)/452?.FH)G032?:45Mn.V8FH)G0I718<!.18C2ií÷26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)GZ45Mo'*)G<!.18b+,),718bï
458b'¬.1<!;7='=J})G8bU´4%'*Fb458CZ.='ãO.='v4%U}7=U%)>Z45M¾)/'=.*4%+(í÷.*'=:Z%452?),718b45M'*)G<!.18b+,),718bï?]
Y[.18b+,.£71K;=.1M,718bUT)G8QUTN.1u[2?.V8Q'71KlO03.*+,.V8Z.458Q'+/23452?:+¹'*.1K6)G8)G26),718¢4503.452?2603)G;=:2?.*+
26BQ452«Z718C2?03)G;=:26. 237 26B. K6:8Z26),718 71K©4Z71<!<:8C)G2?Jx]¡v.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ º ;4%+/.='
Z71<!<:8C)GZ452?)/718Q45M*<!.=458Q+458Q'@<!.1234 º MG.1FH.1M'=.*+,)/U%8b]
p 8¶458)G8C)G2?)/452?)GFH.PM,45;=.VMGMG.*' 5\E452345MGJx+/2 5N$LP718Q71F®458aV W 45Zr}MG)G8
[19]
:+/.='26B.o¢.1;
4%+A26B.iO03)G<4503J<.=458b+A237ª'=.VMG)GFH.10P+,:OO71032s]}vBC.K?)G8b45MA'*.*+,),UT8¤71K`26B.\E452345MGJx+/2
¢.V;w+,)G26.A)G8CZMG:'*.=+K?)>FC.RZ7103.AZ71<!O718.V823+-y
•
W .V2?BQ7=' { :),'*.=+/N K371Z:+/)G8QU 718 )G8b+,2603:Z2?)/718Q45M O0I45Z26)GZ.=+ 458Q')G<!OMG.1<!.18C23452?)/718Q+71K2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ2?BQ452CZ458P.V8Q45;=MG.R2?BC.=+/.AO0I45Z26)GZ.=+/ì
•
³0I7 K6)GMG.=+X71K®Z%45<O:+Q.='*:Z4523710I+/N'*.=+/Z03)G;=)G8bU|)G8w2?B.V)G0¸71qt8!q710I'+b26B.¹:O+458b'w'v71qt8Q+71K2?BC.1)G0Q.VuO.V03)G.18CZ.=+:+/)G8QU2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ}ì
•
Ö@:)>Zr{
:),'*.*+,N°O0I71FH),'*)G8QU±+,2s458Q'v450I'*)Gè%.='*N°234%+/r º 7103)G.V826.=' UT:),'*.=+n2372?BC.
)G<!OMG.1<!.18C23452?)/718971KQ4lO450326)GZ:M,450Q26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ}ì
•
v.1Z5B8)>Z45MbLP71Z:<.V823+/N$O0I71FH),'*)G8QU +/2?.VO º ;=J º +/2?.VOBQ71q º 2s7t)G8Q+/2?03:Z52?),718¡7184lqt),'*.A0I458QUT.@71K2371O)>Z+,ì
•
DE¢)G03.='7=71M,+/N45MGM,71qt)G8QU.*'=:Z%4523710I+237UT.V8.10I4526.!Z5:+,2s71< +/Z03)GO2s+nK60I71<¢.V; º ;4%+/.='K37103<+,NªO0I71FC)/'=)>8QU26B.1< qt)G2?B 4%'*Fb458CZ.='ãK?:8Z52?),718b45MG)G2?J
qt)G2?Bb71:2Q458JO0I7=UT0I45<<!)G8QU}]
å$ÞGb$Þ Â£ß±ÂòÁEÊIΣŢó43|òÅÍ æ ÅXß±ÊÏÂ
2.8.1 Adaptive Hypermedia Systems
&öM/712`71K®03.*+,.*4503ZB)/+R'v718.EZ:0303.18C2?MGJª718!2?B.4503.=4 71KxqP.1; º ;4%+,.*'.='*:Z452?)/718458Q'
71K4%'v45O2?)GFH.¸BJ}O.103<!.='*),4E+,Jx+/2?.1<+`í÷&EPYï?]I&EPY <45rH.nO7=+-+/)G;=MG.n2?BC.o'*.1MG)GFH.103J71K
O.V0I+d718b45MG)Gè%.='<4526.103),45M2s7@2?B.|:+,.V0I+A71Kb26B.i+/Jx+,26.1<]TL¹)GK?K6.103.V82b26.1ZBC8),ST:.=+°BQ45FH.
;=.V.18á'*.1FH.1M,71O.*'2s7 4%'v45O24¤+,Jx+/2?. < 2s7 4:+/.10I¼ð+wO0I71K?)>MG.=]½v03:+,)>M,71Fb+/r}J 6î~ 187
•
\:0303)GZ:M>:< +/.=ST:.V8Z)G8bU¾2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJO0I71FH),'*.=+P2?BC.§+,26:'=.V82qP)>2?B·2?BC.ô%71O26)G<45M*O4526BQõl26B0I71:UTBP26B.AM>.=4 038)>8QU<4526.103),45M,]
•
p8C2?.VMGMG),UT.18C2!458Q45MGJx+/),+971K!+,26:'=.V82!+-71MG:2?),718b+9'*.=45M,+tqt)G2?Bà+/2?:'*.V823+-¼lK?)>8Q45M
458b+,qt.10I+b237E.*'*:Z452?),718b45MO0I71;=MG.V<+/N+/:OOMGJ})G8QU¹K?.1.*'*;45Zr8Q712718CMGJ)GKv2?BC.
458b+,qt.10),+xqP0I718bU¹;=:2°45M/+d7qPBb452$.1u45Z26MGJt)/+qP0I718bUTN[qtBQ452$)/+<)/+d+/)G8QUo458Q'
UT)GFH.A.Vu26.18Q+/)GFH.AK6.1.='*;45Zr2s7A2?B.@+,26: '*.182s]
•
p8C2?.V0I45Z2?)GFH.oO0I71;=MG.1< +d71M>FC)G8bU+/:OO71032O0I71FH),'*.=+l26B.!+/2?:'*.18C2qt)G2?B£BC.1MGO
718ª.=45ZB¶+,26.1O¤71KlO0I71;=M>.1< +-71MGFH)G8QU9í6UT)GFC)>8QUPB)>823+¸710.Vu.VZ:2?)>8QUP2?BC.t8C.1u[2
+/2?.VOï?]$vB.s45Fb42?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ¾O0I71FH),'*.=+o4P8)>Z.)G8C2?.V0I45Z2?)GFH.)>82?.V03K345Z.!K3710
26B.A)><OMG.V<.18C234526),718971Kb+,:ZB+,Jx+/2?.V<+-]
•
Ôu45<OMG. º ; 4%+/.='±O0I71;=M>.1< +-71MGFC)>8QU¡+/:OO71032nB.VMGO++/2?:'*.18C23++-71MGFH.8.Vq
O0I71;=MG.V<+:+,)>8QUTNH4%+vBC.1MGON%.Vu$45<!OMG.=+K?0I71<¦2?BC.1)G0Q.*4503MG)G.10Q.VuO.V03)G.18CZ.=]
•
vB.4%'v45O2?)GFH.áO03.=+/.182s452?),718 2?.VZB8b71M,7=UTJ 4%'v45O23+2?BC.Z718C2?.V8271Kö4BCJHO.V03<.*'=)/4O4%U%. 237 26B. :+/.10I¼ð+¬U}7=45M,+/Nr}8Q71qtMG.='vUT.1N(458Q' 712?BC.10
)G8CK37103<452?),718ª+/237103.=' )G8i2?B.¸:+/.10<7='*.1M,] p 8ª+,:Z5B4E+/Jx+,26.1<¥O4%UT.=+½4503.n8b712
+/234526)GZ½;=:2Q4%'v45O26)GFC.VMGJ!UT.18.V0I452?.*']
&'45O2s452?),718 26.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UT)G.*+¦Z458 )><O0I71FH.´2?BC. ST:45MG)G2?J 71Kö26B.´qt.1; º ;4%+/.='
.*'=:Z%452?),718458Q'¶45M>2?BQ71:UTB2?BC.=+/.i2?.1Z5B8Q71M/7=U%)>.=+ 4503.i<7=+/2?MGJ)G8§4o03.=+/.=4503Z5B±M>.1FH.1MGN
+-71<.@71K2?BC.1<À4503.A;=.1)>8QU)G<OM>.1<.V826. 'v]
7103r})G8bU¹)G826B.+-45<. 4503.=45NLE.A0I4 6î~
287
'*),+,26)G8QUT:),+/B.*+;=.V2?qP.V.18£4%'v45O2s45;=MG.458Q'
4%'v45O2?)>FC.@BCJ}O.103<.*'*),4%] p 84%'v45O2345;=MG.EBJ}O.103<!.='*),4A26B.|:+/.10`O0I71FH),'*.=+X4AO0I71K?)>MG.
458b'ä26B.´45OOMG)GZ4526),718 Z710303.*+,O718b'v+²2s72?B.+/.1MG.VZ2?.*'O0I71K?)GMG.*] p 8 4%'v45O2?)GFH.
BCJHO.V03<.*'=)/4¤2?BC.à+,Jx+/2?. < <718)>23710I+ª26B.·:+/.10I¼>+;=.1BQ45FH),71:0458Q'4%'45O2s+ª2?BC.
O03.*+,.V8234526),718 45ZZ710I'*)G8bU%M>J®]
Ò
)G8Q45MGM>JHNB.£;=.1M>)G.1FH.=+|26BQ452¸2?BC.8b452?:03.¾71Kn2?BC.9¢.1;
71K$26B.@4%'45O26)GFH. +/J®+/2?.V<+'*.1FH.1M,71O.*' 26B.RO.=71OMG.RqPBQ7 '*.VFC.VM,71O2?BC. 45OOMG)GZ%452?),718b+
qtBQ7o4503.n:+,:45MGM>JPZ71<!O:2?.10A+/Z)G.18CZ.O.*71OMG.1NC'v72?B. 45:2?BQ7103)>8QUo4%+qP.VMGM,]v:2$)G2$)/+
ST:)G26.AZ71<!OMG)GZ4526.='@K3710QO.*71OMG.Aqt)G2?Bt8Q712.V8Q71:UTBPZ%71<O:2?.V0Q;45ZrxUT0I71:8Q'v]
Ô
F®45MG:452?)G8bU£458&|tY!)/+E4'*)GK6K?)GZ:M>2l234%+/r¾4 +qt.1MGM/]»LE.t0I4458b'03:+/)GM,71F®+/rHJ 6î~
:;7
'*.=+/Z03)G;=.)G2R4%+nô%4¸Z71<;=)G8b452?),718¾71K°2?BC.!4%'45O26)GFH.o<!.126BQ7='v+n458Q'i2?.1Z5B8)/S%:.*+2?Bb452
4503.£:+/.='458b'71K¸2?B.£q45J¶)G8 qPBC)GZB 2?BC.¡4%'v45O2s452?),718 ),+|:+/.='võ%]vBC.1J¶03.VFC)G.Vq
+-71<.R.1F®45MG:452?),718b+71KC&|tYEK6)G8Q'*)G8bUn)><O0I71FH.1<.V82s+v)G8+,26:'*.182CO.10 Ks7103<458Z5.=]
2.8.2 User Profiling
vB.v.*45038)G8bU±v.1ZBC8Q71M,7=UTJ§Y2s458Q'v450I'*)GèH452?),718\|71<!<)G262?.V. 71K@2?BC. pÓÔvÔvÔ 71K6K?.V0I+
+/23458b'450I'v+ ;712?B´Ks71026B.©'*.*+,Z03)>O2?),718 71K¡.*45038)G8bU Õ ;1×ë.1Z52 W .12s4%'v45234¥458Q'
³.V0I+d718b45Mv458Q'@³.103Ks7103<458CZ. p 8CK37103<452?),718í÷³&|³ p ï?]
³&E³ p 6÷~ Q;7 2?03)>.=+½237+/23458b'v450I'=)/+,.2?B .q945J26B.!+,26:'*.182°03.VZ710I'v+n4503.o03.VO03.=+/.18C2?.='
458b'¥Bb71q 26B),+)G8Ks7103<4526),718),+¤+/.182ª237¥7126B.1045OOM>)GZ452?)/718Q+-]|BC.¥+/23458b'450I'
'*),+/2?)G8bUT:),+,BC.=+;=.126qP.V.182?BC.wO.V0I+d718b45M458b'ª2?BC.iO.103K37103<458Z.i)G8CK37103<452?),718§458Q'
O0I71O7=+/.=+2?Bb452ª26B.1J¥<!:+,2;=.rH.VO2¶+/.1O450I4526.1MGJ¥Ks710¶O03)GF®45ZJ¥03.=4%+-718Q+-]EvB)/+
+/O.1Z)K?)GZ4526),7189'*.*+,Z03)>;=.=+)G89UT.18C.10I45M*26B.@+,2603:Z2?:03.@4n+,26:'=.V82C03.1Z710I'@<:+/2Bb45FC.*]
vB. pÓÔvÔvÔ ³ Ü5ø8:%ø ]Ü ~HÚ*L ø ]â¡+/23458Q'v450I'ö+/O.1Z5)GK?)G.*+P2?BC.+/J}82s45u458Q'ö+/.1<4582?)>Z+971K
MG.*45038)G8bU 71;1×G.1Z2P<.12s4%'v45234 í÷ Õ@W ï6]` Õ@W Z458;=.²'*.1K?)>8.='à4%+2?B.452?2603)G;=:2?.*+
03.*S%:)>03.='ö237K6:MGMGJ458Q'¿4%'*.=ST:452?.VMGJ'*.=+/Z03)G;=.(4¡M.=45038)>8QU71;1×ë.VZ23]RvBC.§ Õ@W
+/23458b'450I'Ks71Z:+,.*+R718w2?BC.E<!)G8)><45MQ+/.12l71KO0I71O.1032?)>.=+b8.V.='*.='P2s745MGM,71qàMG.=45038C)G8QU
71;1×G.1Z2s+v2s7A;=.A<458b4%UT.='*N%M,71Z4526.='*NH458Q'@.1F®45MG:4526.='v]
å$ÞGc$Þ Ì
ææ
£Íd3
vB.2?BC.=7103.V2?)GZ45Mw;45ZrxUT0I71:8Q'¦Ks710¡26B),+¢'*),+-+,.V03234526),718¿q94%+¢'*),+/Z:+d+/.='à)G8¿2?B)/+
4%'v45O2?)>FC. BCJHO.V03<.*'=)/4t+/Jx+,26.1<+qP.103.'=)/+,Z:+-+/.='v]T&+-+,.*+d+/<.V82bq4%+03.1Z%7=U%8C)Gè%.='
4%+n458£)G<!O7103234582QO45032Q)>892?B. M>.=45038)>8QUoO0I71Z5.=+-+d]%vB. 8.Vu2QZ5BQ45O2?.V0Rqt)GMGMvO03.=+/.18C2
Y71<.i)G8b+,26)G2?:26),718Q+RBb45FC.2s45r}.182?BC.45OO0I7=45ZB237'*.=+/),UT8¤458Q'£;=:)GM,'26B.V)G071qt8
7103M,' º ¢),'*.¢.1;(O4%UT.*+£qtB)GMG.ö712?BC.10I+9O03.1K?.V02?BC.ö+-71K?26q94503.¤O45Zrx4%UT.=+K3710
'*.1FH.1M/71O)G8QU©¢.1; Z71:0I+,.*+ 2?Bb452·2?BC. +d71K62?q94503. )>8Q'*:+,2603J 71K6K?.V0I+d]Y71K?2?q4503.
O45Zrx4%UT.=+03.*ST:)G03.²2?B.²:+/.¦71K.VuO.V8Q+/)GFH.µ+/.103FH.10I+¢458b'¦2?BC.¦+,:OO71032¾71K¾458
)G8CK37103<452?),718 º +/.103FH)GZ.=+ '=.VO45032?<!.1826N¿qPB)>MG. 712?BC.10I+ 4503. '*.=+/),UT8.=' 237 MG.V2
O0I71K6.=+-+d710I+Z503.=452?.718MG)G8C.@Z71:0I+/.@<4526.103),45M/+qP)>2?BMG)>2?2?M>.i7108Q7i+,:OO71032s] Y$71<!.i71K
26B.O0I7=UT0I45<+lBQ45FH.K?.*452?:03.=+n+/:ZB¾4%+n718M>)G8.Z718CFC.V0I+d4526),718Q+n458b'!2?)G<!.='ª718MG)G8C.
ST:)Gè%è%.*+,N;=:2712?BC.10I+71K6K?.V0<!:ZB +/)G<OM>.10²234%+/rx+,N£O0I71FH),'*)G8QUã718MGJãZ71:0I+/.
<452?.103)/45M,+458b'@MG.1Z26:03.A8b712?.=+-]
Y[.1FH.10I45M+/2?:'*)G.=+Aí÷.=]âU}] 6÷ÛH 7N
[31]
ïBQ45FH. ;=.1.18 Z718Q'*:Z26.='2?03J})G8QU [email protected]:4526.i458Q'Z71<!O4503.§26B.45OOMG)GZ4526),718Q+Z71<!<.V03Z),45MGMGJá45F®45)GM,45;=M>.=]R& ;=03)G.1Ki.VFb45MG:4526),71871K
? i``jgEh ?? m
~l zEy8~ zEAy
x`l~zE`~{|s)||{u8 9`u8zEl
oqzEjzEs{yA{
}\{~?u8z/l
~¡|¢?lu8)w
rtz/lu8u8
n{;~u-oqu8 ~l~ s~
£l`mhjkli`h k¤ ?? m
oqu8)l|~w)yAzE ¥A ¢ ¦zE zE¢§{ ¢
¨ y{A ~~|{ ¢
¨ y{A ~¢?lz/ { ¢
oq)|u8¦{©E~ª|)`~ ¥¥s)l«{s)yA)
rt);~ ¥lzEs¬§{ ¢
||{¢? 9su8)l|~®zE~l{zEy
rt~yA ~|)u8lAzEy8¯§)~|{u8 |
° hi`±;fE`h ?? m
)~ {szEAu8
`u8u8¬?¦z/l¬¦zE zE¢?~¦~
²
)yA{¦~`Az³|)w)w)u8l
´
{yA~|)?¦A||*Au8 |
µ lu8¢?«~||¶lzEs¬?A ¢
ssv~||¶uZ¢?«zE`~|
)u8¦z/~¢?yAu8||*z/l
)u8¦z/~A ¥;~·Xu8u8y
¨ y{A ~~y{w
rt~zE«su8u8y
rt);~ ¥u8¦~w)zE¢§~
¸\gE;gE¹?f
fE`h ??
m
rt);~ ¥w)lu8Ay{~
¨ y{A ~º~yAw
» {|¥u8|*);~ |
rt);~ «¼|¶w)~lu8l¦z/ ¥sv~
»
u8¢?u8)
`z/w){½§~ªuZ)|~¾w)lu8Ay{~|
¿`ÀLÁ` Ïÿ³ Ã Ä üÅ Â ü5þ ÀÇÆÉÈÊÆÉË Å3ÿ%ü
ÈÌÀÈ"Á È Ä À ÆÉÈ"Í
ÿ
È
3.2.1 Virtual Study Centre
vB.9X)G0326:45M Y[2?:'*J¾\X.V82603.±í÷XY\Eïl),+4MG.*45038)G8bU.18CFC)>0I718<.V82n26BQ452Bb4%+¹;=.1.V8
)G<!OMG.1<!.18C2?.=' ;=Jo2?B.Rv.1MG.V<452?)>Z+v\[email protected])GFH.10I+/)G26J71K Ô u.V2?.103N%Y[ZBb7=71Mv71K
Ô '*:Z452?)/718Q]QBC.R)>032?:45M¸Y26:'*J\.18C2?03.),+t:+/.=' 237¤71K?K6.10ª718MG)>8. WÔ 'vÚ*³BC)GM
<7='=:M>.=+x2s7¸26.=45ZBC.10I+-]ÏvB.n)>8Q+/2?03:Z2s710'*.1M>)GFC.V0I+x2?BC.n<4 26.103),45M};=JoO:;=MG),+/B)G8bU¸)G2Q4%+
458£P W O4%UT.!710A;=JU%)>FC)G8bUt03.1K6.103.V8Z.*+237w45032?)GZ5MG.=+710X;7=71rx+2?Bb452QBQ45FH. 237 ;=.
03.*4%']$vB.<452?.V03),45M`O:;=MG),+/B.*')/+¹.18C03)GZBC.='qP)G26B²45:'*),7458Q'FC),'*.*7=]Y26:'=.V82s+
'*.1M>)GFC.V0Q2?BC.1)G0Qq7103ro26BQ452C),+v:+/:45MGMGJ!458t.=+-+d45J;=J.1<45)GMG)G8bUn2s7A2?BC.A)G8b+,2603:Z23710I]
XY\ :+,.*+ \.1)GM>),'*B237)G<OMG.V<.V82¹'*),+/Z:+d+/),718¤UT0I71:O+-]=\.V)GMG),'*B),+E4i'=)/+,Z:+-+/),718
+-71K?26q94503.¸O0I7='*:Z2vK?0I71<¥v)GMG)Grx71)}Y71K?2?q4503.1N458Q'),+x:+/.='oKs710O0I71FH),'*)G8bU¹2?BC03.=4%'*.='
;=:MGM>.12?)>8;7=450I'v+ qt)G2?B¬K?)GM>. 452?2s45ZB<!.18C2458b'. º <45)GM,] p 8Q+/2?03:Z2s710I+¢Z%458¬O7=+/2
<!.=+-+d4%UT.=+n23726B.ÑÐ8Q7126)GZ.!;7=450I'¼ð]C&|M>Ml:+/.10I+FC)>.1q 2?B.*+,.w<.*+d+-4%UT.=+-]CvB.V03.!),+4
+/.1O450I4526. '*),+/Z:+d+/),718t2?BQ452b718MGJ26B.A)>8Q+/2?03:Z2s710I+vZ458tO45032?)GZ5)GO452?.*]
Õ 26B.V0R2s7=71M,+:+/.='w)>892?B. XY[\)G8CZMG:'*. 2?BC.@Z45MG.V8Q'v4503N}qP)G26B2?BC.i+,Z5B.='*:MG.|K3710E45MGM
Z71:0I+/.=+/N*MG)>8rx+b237¹03.VMG.1F®4582vqt.1;9+/)G26.=+`458Q'4XMG)G;=0I4503JPqP)G26Bw03.VK?.V03.18Z5.=+`458Q'718MG)G8C.
×,71:038Q45Mv45032 )GZMG.*+d]
3.2.2 Scoop
Y[Z7=71O¿),+O4503271K Õ 0I45ZMG.*¼>+ W )GMGMG.V88)>:< ³0I7-×ë.VZ2vB)>8rx]Z71<Nw458b'öO0I71FC),'*.*+
O03)G<4503J·458b'+/.1Z718b'4503J¾.='*:Z4526),718+,Z5BQ7=71M,+íî2?.*45ZB.V0I+458Q'§+,26:'=.V82s+dïlqt)G2?B4
2s7=71M2s7i;=:)>M,'Z71M>M,45;710I452?)GFH.MG.*45038)G8bUwZ71<!<:8)>2?)G.*+d]*Y[J®+/2?.V<´:+/.10I+XZ%458Z03.=4526.1N
Z71<!<:8C)GZ452?.458Q'Z%71MGM,45;710I452?. )G8 4¦ZM,7=+/.='*N 458b'O0I712?.VZ2?.*'.='*:Z452?)/718Q45M
.V8FH)G0I718<!.1826N·4%+qt.1MGM4%+.1u[OM,7103.©2?BC. p 82?.V038.V2à458Q' Z503.=452?. 26B.V)G0À71qt8
Z718C8.VZ2?.*'£Z71<!O:2?.V0P4%+O45032¸71K¸718C.£710n<7103.tZ71<<!:8)G26).=+-]»& +/.=4503ZBª237=71Mb)/+
O0I71FH),'*.='í÷t.10I45M,'*N}2?BC.@YZ%7=71OBb71:8Q'vïC2s7 K6)G8Q'45032?)>ZMG.=+/N'*),+/Z:+d+/),718b+R458b'8C.1q+d]
D+,.V0I+¹Z458²+/.12A:O718MG)G8C.'*),+/Z:+-+,),718UT0I71:O+,NQ;=0I45)G8b+,2s7103<+o458Q' '*.1;4526.=+-]BC.
+/Jx+,26.1< 71K?K6.10I+4q945J K3710¡426.=45ZBC.10¡710ª.VuO.V032237¢<.*'=)/452?.458Q'àUT:),'*.¶2?BC.
'*),+/Z:+-+,),718b]}v.*45ZB.V0 +RqP)GM>M;=.45;=M>.237<4503rZBC)GM,'*03.18bÐ+q97103r¡718MG)>8.£458b'£O7=+/2
458w.18CZ71:0I4%UT)G8QU|8b712?.¹qP)G26B!Z71<!<.V823+-]Vv)G8Cr®+b2s7E03.1MG.VFb458C2 p 82?.V038.V2½+/)G2?.*+®Z458i;=.
4%'v'*.='@237A26B.RZB)GM/'ÐÑ+O4%UT.=]
Ô <45)>M,+Z458718MGJ;=.¤03.VZ.1)>FC.*' K?0I71< O.*71OMG.4%+403.1OMGJ 237458(.1<45)>MoK60I71<
458b712?B.V0°:+,.V03N%:8MG.*+d+2?BC.A:+/.10 BQ4%+4%'v'*.='@2?BC. +/.18Q'*.V0Q237A2?BC.1)G0QO.V0I+d718b45Mv4%'v'*03.=+-+
;7=71rx] p 2X45M,+-7!45MGM/71q9+Ks710R<45)GMvK?)GMG26.103)G8bUo;=J!;=M,71Zr})G8QU.1<45)GMvK?0I71< :8Q45:26BQ7103),+/.='
O.V0I+d718b+¹71:2s+,)/'=.o2?BC..18FH)G0I718C<.18C23]?Ò71:ªZ458£FC),+/)G2R4¹Z%71<<:8C)G2?J}NC;=:2Jx71:ªZ458
718CMGJo×,71)G8±4¸Z%71<<:8C)G2?J!)GKQ)G8CFC)G26.='i237w'7w+-7=] Ô 45ZB9Z71<!<:8C)G2?J!BQ4%+ 4<458Q4%UT.10
qtBQ7BQ4%+@+-71<.Z718C2?0I71MR71FH.10¹qPBQ452`)/+RO:;=MG),+/B.*'¡458Q'£qPBb7i),+|45MGM,71qP.*'2s7@×,71)G8
26B.AZ%71<<:8C)G2?Jx]
Y[Z7=71O¶:+/.=+
Õ
0I45ZM>.
:
)A4%+A2?BC.
p
826.1038.V2OM,452?Ks7103< )>82?.*UT0I452?)G8bU458Q'ªZ5.18260I45MG),+/)G8QU
26B.A)>8K37103<452?),718b]5vB. +/Jx+,26.1<¦Z458P03.VZ7=UT8),+/.A26.1u[2?N%)G<4%U%.*+,N%FH),'*.=7 458b'i45:'=)/7=]
3.2.3 TopClass
71O\M,4%+-+Eq94%+t'=.*+,)/U%8C.='¤458Q'¤'*.1FH.1M,71O.*'§45226B.DE8)GFH.10I+/)G26J¾\E71MGMG.*UT.LE:;=M>)G8N
p 03.VM,458Q'¤458Q'),+t'=)/+,2603)G;=:2?.*';=J±¢v§Y[Jx+,26.1<+-] p 2<458Q4%UT.=+¸2?B.'=.VMG)GFH.103J§458Q'
+/:OO7103271K260I45)G8)G8bU¾458b'.*'*:Z452?),718¡:+,)G8bU£26B.¢.V;=NX458Q'),+o45Fb45)>M,45;=MG.71845MGM
<4ç×ç710OM,452?Ks7103<+-]l71O\M,4%+-+Z%7182345)>8Q+·237=71M,+·K 710(Z71:0I+/.Z503.=452?)/718NZ71:0I+/.
<458Q4%UT.1<!.1826NE+,26:'=.V82@<458Q4%UT.1<!.18C2?N`)G8C2?.10I45Z52?)GFH.¢ST:)Gè%è%.*+!458b'4%+-+/),UT8<.V82s+,N
458b' Z%71<<:8C)GZ4526),718Q+-]
vB.tLE)/+,Z:+-+/),718v),+/2l),+¹458¢4503.*4|)G8qPB)>ZB¶'*),+/Z:+-+,)/718ªZ4582345r}.oOM,45Z.o;=.126qP.1.V8
<45)GM°+/J®+/2?.V<äíî2?B)/+R+/Jx+,26.1<)/+°2s712345MGMGJª+/.1O450I4526.|K?0I71<2?BC.|O.10I+-718Q45M.1<45)>M,ï?]1D+,.V0I+
Z458¥+,.V8Q'·<45)GM@2s7·712?BC.109O.=71OM>.¡)G8 2?B.V)G09ZM,4%+-+/Nn:+,)G8bU¶2?B.¾:+,.V0IÐÑ+i71O\M,4%+-+
:+/.1038b45<.=][ô5\M,4%+-+&|8C8Q71:8CZ.1<!. 82s+dõ¸71O26),718),+S%:)>2?.+/)G<)>M,450°2372?BC.LE)/+,Z:+-+/),718
v),+/2?NX;=:2 B.V03.1N|718MGJ¤2?BC. +,Jx+/2?.V< 4%'*<)G8C),+,260I4523710I+!458Q'¢)G8Q+/2?03:Z2s710I+oZ458<45r}.
O7=+/2?)G8bU}+d]@vB.ö\M,4%+-+±&E88b71:8Z.V<.18C23+O4%UT.),+:+,:45M>MGJ¿:+,.*'¥Ks710¢O7=+,26)G8QU
Ø .=4%'*)G8bUàv),+/23+458b'¬7126B.V0¤)>8K37103<452?),718ä71K UT.18.V0I45M9:+,.237öO.=71OMG.2345r})G8QU
Z7 :0I+/.=+-]
71O\M,4%+-+`Z%71:0I+,.'*.=+/),UT8.10I+lZ%458O0I71FH),'*.!718 º '=.V<458b'45:'*),7458b'!FC)/'=.*7o:+/)G8QU
Ø .=45MG¨t.126q97103rx+dÐ Ø .*45MG&|:'*),7w458Q' Ø .=45MGX),'*.=7@2?.VZB8b71M,7=UT)G.=+-]T&|M,+-7@:+,)>8QUw458B26<M
45:26BQ7103)G8bUw237=71M°26B.Z71:0I+/.45:2?Bb710EZ458Z5BQ458QUT.26B.M,7=71r¶458Q'K6.1.VMA71K`26B.qt.1;
O4%UT.=+R458Q')G8CZMG:'*.X×,45Fb4A&EOOMG.12s+d]1³71q .103O71)G8C2®O03.=+/.18C234526),718Q+QZ458;=.4%'v'=.*'£4%+
qt.1MGM,]
&E:237¹Z%710303.1Z26.='t26.=+/23+`458Q'oB:<458iZ710303.VZ2?.*'t2?.*+,2s+`4503.¸:+,.*'t)G8i71O\XM/4%+d+-] p 2Z458
O.V03K37103< 45Z2?),718b+½;4%+,.*'718ª26B.!+,Z%7103.=+l03.1Z5.1)GFH.='!)>8¡45:2s7oZ710303.VZ2?.*'!2?.*+,2s+d] W 7103.
q7103rZ71:0I+,.¹<4526.103),45MCZ458i;=.t4%''*.*'710n48Q712?.¸;=.t+/.182v2s7P458i)G8Q+ 2?03:Z5237103N»;4%+/.='
718t2?B.R03.=+/:MG23+03.1Z5.1)GFH.='v]
3.2.4 WebCT
¢.V;=\X),+¹4|237=71M½'*.1FH.1M,71O.*')G8ª26B.oLE.VO45032?<!.182A71K\|71<!O:2?.V0YZ5)G.18CZ.4522?BC.
DE8)GFH.10I+/)G2?J 71KE03)>2?),+/B\E71MG:<!;=),4%] p 2|Ks45Z)GMG)>23452?.*+26B.ªZ03.=4526),718(71KE7103M,'¡¢),'*.
¢.V; º ;4%+/.='.='*:Z4526),718Q45M.18CFC)G0I718C<.V823+458b'Z458¾;=.i:+/.='ªKs710|26B.iZ03.=4526) 718§71K
.V82?)>03. 718M>)G8.RZ71:0I+,.*+710Q2s7AO:;=MG),+/BP<452?.103)/45M,+vKs710Q.1u[),+/2?)G8bUnZ%71:0I+,.*+d]
p 245MGM,71q+26B.Z71:0I+,.¡'*.=+/),UT8.V0237¶'*.V2?.103<!)G8.2?BC.¶45OO.*450I458Z.¡71K¹2?B.Z71:0I+/.
O4%UT.=+í÷M/45J®71:26N%Z71M,71:0I+/N%2?.Vu26N%Z71:826.10I+/N%.12?Z%ï?]
.VFb45MG:4526),718237=71M/+½í?718CMG)G8.VN$45:2s71<4526)GZ45MGMGJt<4503r}.='!ST:)Gè%è%.=+/N$458b'Z%7182?.V82 º 03.1M/452?.='
<!:MG2?)GOM>.PZBb71)GZ.9ST:.*+,26),718Q+-ï÷N4+/.=4503ZBb45;=MG.o)G<4%UT.4503ZB)GFH.1NQ4EMG)G8Cr®45;=M>.UTM,7=+-+d4503J
'v452345;4%+/.1Nw+/2?:'*.V82Z%71MGM,45;710I452?) 718 458Q'öO03.*+,.V8234526),7184503.=4%+/Ni+,26:'*.182wZ718C2?.18C2
458C8Q71234526),718N+/2?:'*.V82BQ71<.VO4%UT.UT.18C.10I4526),718N*Z%71:0I+,.¹8Q45FH),U}452?),718CN*)G8b'=.Vu)>8QU458Q'
+/.=4503ZBC)G8QU2s7=71M,+,NH45Z5Z71:82b4%'=<!)G8)/+,260I452?),718t237=71M,+458Q'@<7103.*]
&'=<!)G8)/+,260I452?)GFH.2s7=71M,+§4%+-+/),+,2ª)G826B.«'=.VMG)GFH.103J¬71K¡4§Z71:0I+/.=]EvB.*+,.)G8CZMG:'*.
+/2?:'*.18C2EO0I7=U 03.*+d+@2?0I45Z5rH)>8QUTN½Z71:0I+/.¶45Z5Z.=+-+@2?0I45Zr})G8bU%Nn4!Z452?.*U}7103)Gè%.='ST:.*+,26),718
'v452345;4%+/. 458Q' 718M>)G8. ST:)Gè´Z03.*452?),718 237=71Mí÷qt)G2?B BC),+,2s7103)GZ45M+,2s452?),+/2?)>Z+¥718
O.V03K37103<458CZ.9458b'45:2371<4526)GZ@<4503rH)>8QU}ï÷N4ST:.*+,26),7188b45)G03.'*.VMG)GFH.103J±458Q'03.VO71032
2s7=71MGN+/2?:'*.18C245ZZ5.=+-+Z%7182?0I71M>NUT0I4%'=.±<45)>82?.V8Q458CZ.458b' 03.1O710326)G8QU¡2s7=71MGN458Q'
<7103.=]
3.2.5 David Thornton’s Learning Environment
LP45FC)/'ªvBQ710382s718§'=.*+,)/U%8C.='¶4:8)GK6)G.='¡+,Jx+/2?.1<äKs710E26B.'*.1FH.1M/71O<.18C2?Nl'*.1MG)GFH.103J
458b'±4%'*<!)G8),+/2?0I4526),718¢71KZ71:0I+/.=+¹71FC.V0n2?B.
p
826.1038C.123]»vBC.Pq97103r£q4%+O4503271KlB)/+
'*),+-+,.V03234526),718§Ks7102?BC.¶'*.*U%03.V.¶71K W 4%+/2?.10971KEY[Z)G.V8 Z.)G8¤\|71<!O:2?.V0PY[Z)G.18CZ.1N237
v03)G8C)G2?J\E71MGMG.*U%.VN%LE:;=M>)G8Q]
vB.nZ503.=452?)/71871K2?B.nZ%71:0I+,.n<452?.103)/45MH)/+½'v718.n:+/)G8QUt458B26<M=.='*)G2s710I]BC.Z71:0I+/.
+/2?03:Z26:03.),++/237103.*'¤)G8à4903.1M,4526),718Q45Mt'v452345;4%+/.¤íW )>Z0I7=+d71K62 &|ZZ5.=+-+dïAO0I71FH),'*)G8QU
03.V:+d45;=)GM>)G2?J¬458Q'«.Vu26.18Q+/)G;=)GM>)G2?Jx] W :MG26)G<.*'=)/4Z71826.182¡+/: OO710323+)G<4%UT.*+¤í6UT)GK?N
;=<!ON×ëOU}ïîN 45:'*),7íîq945FHNA0I45NR<O.=U}ïîNAFH),'*.=7í645FC)>NA<71FHNA<!O.=UTNA03<!N 4%+/K3ï458Q'
458C)G<4526),718K?)>MG.=+Eí?+/qPK?NK6M,45N45FH)GN<71F®ï?]
W
:MG26)G<.*'*),4|Z71826.18C2l),+`.1<!;=.='v'*.='23794
qt.1; O4%UT.A:+/)G8QU71K6K º 26B. º +/B.1M>K237=71M/+d]
\E71:0I+/.'*.1M>)GFC.V03J),+'v718.¹:+,)G8bU|P W ]V&²qP.V;P;=0I71q9+/.102?Bb452 +/:OO710323+®K60I45<.*+
458b'w&|Z52?)GFH.1¯¶Z%7182?0I71M/+<:+/2b;=.@:+/.='í÷O03.VK?.10I45;=M>J W )GZ50I7=+d71K62 p 826.1038C.12 Ô u[OM,7103.10
]â%ï6]¬\E71MGM,45;710I452?)>FC. 45Z2?)>FC)G26)G.=+ 4503. +,:OO710326.=' :+,)G8bU¸\:Y[.1.
W
t W ±O4%UT.=+E4503.£UT.18.V0I452?.*'¾71826B.K6MGJ}Nv2345r})G8QU2?BC. Z71:0I+/.Z718C2?.18C2lK60I71<2?BC.
03.VM,452?),718b45M'v452345;4%+/.=] p 2$:+/.=+v)>FC.Y71K?26q94503.*¼>+ Ø :894×ç45F®4n+,.V03FC.V0Q.1u[2?.18b+,)/718P2?Bb452
+/:OO710323+§s45Fb4öY[.103FHMG.12s+d]\E71<O4526)G;=MG.©+/.103FH.10I+ 2?Bb452¶Z458´;=.«:+/.=' )G8CZMG:'*.
&EO45ZB.VN
pÓp
YP458Q'@¨P.V23+/Z45O.
Ô
826.103O03),+/.AY[.103FH.10I]
3.2.6 Courseware on the fly
L¹)GMGM,718 6 Ü87 )G8 B )/+'=)/+d+/.1032s452?),718 :+/.='458 710I45ZMG.¾'v452345;4%+/.£237¾+,2s7103.26B.£Z71:0I+/.
+/2?03:Z26:03.9458b'926B.tZ71:0I+,.tZ71826.18C23]»vB.t:+,.V0I+E4503.458Q+/qP.V03)G8QU94ST:.*+,26),7188b45)G03.
45;71:2bqtBQ452b26B.VJ!q4582bK60I71<À2?BC.@Z71:0I+/.i458Q'qPBb452®),+Q2?BC.1)G0`r}8b71qPMG.*'UT.7182?BC.
+/:;1×ë.VZ23]*vB.£45OOM>)GZ452?)/7182?BC.18qt)GMGMXUT.18C.10I452?.P2?B.PZ7 :0I+,.+,2603:Z2?:03.t2?Bb452n+/:)G2?.*+
;=.*+,2237 26B.:+,.V0I¼>+ '*.=+/)G03.=+-] W .V234 º )>8K37103<452?),718áq94%+:+/.='µ2s7µ'*.=+/Z03)G;=.²2?BC.
.*'=:Z%452?),718b45MP71;1×G.1Z2s++-726BQ452 2?BC.¤45OOMG)GZ4526),718q71:M,' ;=.¢45;=MG.237Z718b+,2603:Z2i4
<!.=458)>8QUTK?:M,]
3.2.7 Discussion
X)G032?:45M=Y[2?:'*Jo\.182603.q94%+v)G<OM>.1<.V826.=' K?0I71<«26B.DE8)GFH.10I+/)G2?J!71K Ô u .126.10X458b' )/+
8b7124Z71<<!.103Z),45M`O0I7='*:Z2s]
p
2),+¸8Q7124%+¸Z71<OMG.V2?.4%+¸2?BC.O71O:M,450 71O\M,4%+-+
458b' ¢.V;=\l]
Y[Z7=71OBb4%+`4XOMG.*4%+d458C2vM,7=71r}N»),+®K6:88JP237¹OM/45JqP)G26Bi;=:2 p 26B)G8CrP26BQ452718M>)G8.nBC.1MGO
),+`8Q712+,:K6K?)GZ5)G.18C2ní?4|O4%UT.'=.*+,Z503)G;=)G8QUPBb71q26B.o<.V<;=.10I+½Z458:+/.t)G2),+½<)/+d+/)G8QU
458b'q971: M,';=.o:+,.VK?:M,ï6]Y[Z7=71O),+½8Q712)G8C2?.18b'*.='237o;=.4¸MG.=45038C)G8QUo.18FH)G0I718C<.18C2
;=:2w49Z71MGM,45;710I4526)GFH..18CFC)G0I718C<[email protected]®71:8bU§+/2?:'*.V823+Z458)G8C2?.V0I45Z2i458Q'