• No results found

Lesson-Plan​ ​Delivery​ ​Before​ ​Lesson-Plan​ ​Design: Defining,​ ​Sequencing,​ ​And​ ​Teaching​ ​The​ ​Essential​ ​Skills​ ​Of​ ​An​ ​English Language​ ​Teacher​ ​Development​ ​Program​ ​At​ ​Induction

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2021

Share "Lesson-Plan​ ​Delivery​ ​Before​ ​Lesson-Plan​ ​Design: Defining,​ ​Sequencing,​ ​And​ ​Teaching​ ​The​ ​Essential​ ​Skills​ ​Of​ ​An​ ​English Language​ ​Teacher​ ​Development​ ​Program​ ​At​ ​Induction"

Copied!
111
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

Hamline University

DigitalCommons@Hamline

School of Education Student Capstone Projects School of Education

Fall 2017

Lesson-Plan Delivery Before Lesson-Plan Design:

Defining, Sequencing, And Teaching The Essential

Skills Of An English Language Teacher

Development Program At Induction

Joel Hanson

Hamline University

Follow this and additional works at:https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/hse_cp Part of theEducation Commons

This Capstone Project is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Education at DigitalCommons@Hamline. It has been accepted for inclusion in School of Education Student Capstone Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Hamline. For more information,

please [email protected], [email protected].

Recommended Citation

Hanson, Joel, "Lesson-Plan Delivery Before Lesson-Plan Design: Defining, Sequencing, And Teaching The Essential Skills Of An

English Language Teacher Development Program At Induction" (2017).School of Education Student Capstone Projects. 94.

(2)

LESSON-PLANDELIVERYBEFORELESSON-PLANDESIGN:

DEFINING,SEQUENCING,ANDTEACHINGTHEESSENTIALSKILLSOFANENGLISH LANGUAGETEACHERDEVELOPMENTPROGRAMATINDUCTION

ByJoelHanson

A capstone submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in EnglishasaSecondLanguage.

Hamline University Saint Paul, Minnesota

December2017

Capstone​​​​Project​​​​Facilitator:​​​​Trish​​​​Harvey

(3)

2

ThisCapstoneprojectisdedicatedtoMyriamAdyadou, whopatientlytalkedmedownfromthe pedagogicalprecipiceonnumerousoccasionswhile collaboratingonourfirstproject-based course.Yourcreativitymadethecoursewecreatedsomuchbetterthanitwould havebeenhadI

toiledinisolation—asIhavedoneformostof myEFLcareer.This Capstoneprojectisalso dedicatedtoMarkHolbrook,whosecuriosity,equanimity,andpatienceaffordedmethe opportunitytodojustabouteverythingIeverwantedtodoinEFLteachingandtraining—except

(4)

3

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Chapter1 Introduction 5

IdentifyingtheProblem 5

MyOwnPathtoTeacherTraining 8 PrerequisitesandObstaclestoaPurposefulTeacherDevelopmentProgram 13 Chapter1SummaryandOverviewoftheRemainingChapters 16

Chapter2 LiteratureReview 19

Introduction/Overview 19

TeacherTrainingProgramPrerequisites 20 ChoosingaCurricularFrameworkCompatible withStudentLearningGoals 22 TheCaseforUsingExistingCoursestoTrainNoviceInstructors 25 FourFrameworksforTeacherDevelopment 29 TwoCentralTasksofLearningtoTeachatthePreservicePhase 38 OneCentralTaskofLearningtoTeachattheInductionPhase 47 AReorderingandRationalefor Feiman-Nemser’sCentralTasksat

Induction

51

ChapterSummary 59

Chapter3 ProjectDescription 62

ChapterOverview 62

ProjectContext 64

PrimaryInstructorIssuesintheClassroom 65 TheProject-BasedCourseonWhichtheInductionTrainingIsBased 68 ThreeGuidingPrinciplesfortheInductionTrainingHandbook 70 AFrameworkforFourPhasesofInductionTraining 76

(5)

4 ChapterSummary 78 Chapter4 Conclusion 80 ChapterOverview 80 MajorFindings 81 ComplicationsinResearch 91

ProjectImplications,CommunicationofResults,BenefitstotheProfession 97 ProjectLimitations,NextSteps,andFutureResearch 98

ChapterSummary 101

Conclusion 102

References 105

LISTOFTABLESANDFIGURES

Chapter2 Figure1:TheFreemanandJohnson(1998)KnowledgeBaseforTeacher Education

30 Table1:TheCentralTasksofLearningtoTeach(Feiman-Nemser,2001) 34 Table2:Danielson’sFrameworkforTeaching(2007) 36 Table3:TheFirstTwoPhases ofBambrick-Santoyo’s(2016)Scopeand

SequenceofActionStepsto LaunchaTeacher’sDevelopment

37 Figure2:Graves’(2000)circularmodelofcoursedesign 52 Table4:Asuggestedalternativeorder ofFeiman-Nemser’scentraltasksof learningtoteachatinduction

53 Chapter3 Table1:ElementsandComponents ofDomain3:Instructionfrom

Danielson’sFrameworkforTeaching(p.4)

76

Table2:MyFourPhasesof InductionTrainingRelatedtoDanielson’s ComponentsofDomains1-3:Planning andPreparation,TheClassroom Environment,andInstruction

(6)

5

CHAPTERONE

INTRODUCTION

“Aconceptualframeworkisthecornerstoneof acoherent[teacher development]program.It offersaviewoflearning,theroleoftheteacher,andthemissionof theschoolingina

democracy.Itprovidesasetofunderstandingsabout learningtoteach.Morethanrhetoric,the valuesandideasthatmakeuptheprogram’smissionandconceptual frameworkinformthe designandsequencingofcoursesandfieldexperiences.Theygettranslated intospecificthemes orcoreabilities.Theyshapecurriculum, culture,pedagogy,andassessmentpractices.”—Sharon Feiman-Nemser(2001,p.1023)

IdentifyingtheProblem

Fortheentiretyofits60-yearhistory,myformeremployerhas operatedalarge, profitablenetworkofEnglishlanguageschoolsinMoroccowithoutapedagogicalframework suchastheonedescribedbyHowey andZimpher(1989) andFeiman-Nemser(2001).

Consequently,theadministrativeassociationanditsnetworkof12languageschools lackaclear missionstatement;precisedescriptionsofwhat constituteseffectiveteachingandstudent

learning;acurriculumwithcourseoutcomestheextendbeyondthedesultory aimsofthe

textbook-driven/grammar-basedsyllabusofthecoursebookstheyareusing;and,mostcrucially, aqualityteachertrainingprogramtoensurethat thestudent-learningaimsofitscoursesare consistentlyrealized.Totheircredit,theschoolsinthenetworkusea

communicative-language-teaching(CLT)approachandprovideagenerallyenjoyable

language-learningexperienceforamajorityofthe Moroccanhighschool andcollegestudents whomakeupanoverwhelmingmajorityoftheircustomers.Theschools alsoprovidenumerous freeextracurricularclubsandengageinsomecharitablecommunityoutreachthatcombines languagelearningwithpersonalskilldevelopmentandpublicservice.Nevertheless,thelargely

(7)

6 unacknowledgedconsequencesofthesecurricularandpedagogicalblindspotsareevidentwhen interactingwithlearnerswhohavecompletedthe school’s18-classprogram: anumberof

studentsarenotproficientinoneormoreofthe fourskillsormanagetoachieveoralfluencybut lackthetextual,compositional,andhigher-orderthinking skillsneededto succeedinan

English-speakingacademicenvironment.

Acursoryglanceattheone-sentencemission statementofthe network’slargestEnglish languageschoolinCasablancarevealsanoticeableabsenceofspecificityregarding thenatureof whateverpedagogyitischampioning:​​Ourschoolexiststogiveallofourstudentsthebest teachingandlearningexperience inCasablanca.Theobviousquestion:How doesonedefine “thebestteachingandlearningexperience”?Undoubtedly,theanswerdependsonwhich director,teachercoordinator,EFLinstructor,orstudentonespeakstoand,itissafetoassume, theirresponseswouldbewidelydivergent.Clearly,thestudentssuffermost fromthisscholastic relativism,asmanyhaveconfessedtomeonnumerousoccasions;eachtimetheystartanew courseandworkwithanewteacherisakinto enteringanewschoolthatbearsnoresemblanceto theoldone;andtheironlyhoperestswiththe goodfortunetobeassignedaninstructorwhois skilledenoughtoassistintheirlanguage-learningprocess.

SinceIbeganpursuingmyMAinAdultESLatHamline,Ihavebeeninterestedin helpingthethelargestlanguageschoolinCasablanca moreclearlydefinethelearninggoalsof itscoursesasabasisforestablishinggreaterpedagogicalconsistencyamong the75-teacherstaff andmoreaccuratelyassessingstudentperformance.Therefore, withthegoal ofcreatinga

handbookofinstructionalsequencesforacomprehensive52-weekinductiontrainingcourse,this Capstoneprojectseekstouncovertheessentialtasks andsequencesofEFLteachertrainingat

(8)

7 inductionand,intheprocess,providemyformer employerandsimilarEFLinstitutionswitha blueprintforestablishingcompelling—andexplicit—learning outcomesandequippingteachers withtheskillstohelptheirstudentsachievethose coursegoals.Thestudents whocometotheir schoolsforlanguageinstructiondeservenoless.AsI reviewsomeofthe availableliteratureina searchforcommonalitiesinvariousteacherdevelopmentprogramframeworks,Iwillcontend withthefirstoftwocentralresearchquestions:

Whataretheessentialsetofteachingskills/practices attheinductionportionofteachertraining thatareapplicabletomyEFLteachingcontext?​​Then,Iwillcombinethoseskillframeworksin theliteraturereviewtoanswermysecondresearch question:​​Inlightofthespecificteacher preparationanddevelopmentneedsofthestaff intheaforementioned 12-schoolnetworkin Morocco,howshouldtheseskillsbesequencedand taughtduringtheinductionportionofan Englishlanguageteacherdevelopmentprogram?

Intherestofchapter1,Iwillbrieflydocumentmyownprofessionalpathfromnovice instructortoteachertrainerandthepedagogicalepiphany Ihadalongthatway—inshort,that identifyingcourseoutcomesandhelpinginstructorsacquiretheskillsnecessaryforconsistent studentachievementofthecourseoutcomesareparamounttoproviding“the bestteachingand learningexperiences.”Drawingonmypersonalexperiencein thefieldasthebasisforfurther reflection,Iwillthenconsiderwhatcomponentsshould serveasthefoundationforaviable inductiontrainingprogram.Intheprocess,Iwill alsoexplorewhatalanguageschoolwould needtoconstruct(e.g.aclearvisionofthestudentlearningitistrying topromote,aspecific curricularframeworkwithclearlydefinedcourseoutcomes, andwell-definedset ofskillsand

(9)

8 practicesteachersshouldpossessatvariousstagesof theircareer)beforeitcouldcreatea

purposefulteachertrainingprogram.

MyOwnPathtoTeacherTraining

Mypersonalinvestmentintheoutcomeof thisprojectshould beself-evident:Purposeful teachertrainingprogramsaretheexceptionratherthanthe ruleasevidencedby thatfactthatin my16-year,seven-countrycareer—mostlyasanEnglishasaForeignLanguage(EFL)

instructor,Ihaveyettoworkforaninstitutionthat hadaclearvisionofwhatitwantedits studentstoaccomplishintheclassroom.​​Equallyimportant,noneofthese institutionshada teachertrainingprogramtoensurethatitsteachers possessthepedagogicaltoolstohelptheir studentsdeveloptheskillsneededtoachievethe coursegoals.Manyteachertrainingprogramsat theprivatelanguageschoollevel—myformer employerincluded—focusonbrief,off-site

preservicepreparationandlargelyignorethe inductionandongoingprofessionaldevelopment aspectsofateacher’scareer.Perhapsthat isbecauseadministrators areoftenworking

autonomously(likemyformeremployer)andtypically lacktheknowledge, vision,andqualified personneltoinitiateateacherdevelopmentprogram orbecausethey believetheirlargely

unskillednative-speakingEFLinstructorsarenotgoingtobearoundthatlong.

Afterall,asGilman(2016)haspointedout, theEnglishasaForeignLanguage(EFL) worlddifferssignificantlyfromitsEnglishasaSecondLanguage(ESL) counterparteventhough thetwotermsareoftenusedinterchangeably.TheEFLworldcontainsboth

non-native-English-speakingteachers(NNESTs)wholearnedEnglish asasecondorthird languageandteachittostudentsofasimilar linguisticandculturalbackground inacountryin whichEnglishisaminoritylanguage. AndthereareNative-English-speakinginstructors

(10)

9 (NESTs)instructorslikemyselfwhomovetoa foreigncountrytoteachthelanguage,often withoutknowingmuchaboutthenativelanguageand cultureoftheirstudents.Incontrast,the ESLworldalmostexclusivelycontainsNESTswhoteachEnglish inacountryin whichitisthe dominantlanguage.Itisagrossunderstatementtoassert thattheEFLworld containsafareasier pathtocertification;aglaringlackofuniformityinthetrainingthatisoffered tobothnoviceand experiencedinstructors;professionalresponsibilitiesthatdiffer widelyfromcountrytocountry andwithinschoolsinthesamecountry.Itisalsoimportanttonote,as Gilman(2016)did,that manyNESTEFLteachersaredrawntothe professionnotbecausetheyarepassionateabout learningthecraftbutbecauseteachingabroadprovides theeasiestpathtoanexcitingbut ephemerallifestylechangeinaforeignculture;and,consequently,theseteachers tendtoview theiridentityandrolewithinthatinstitutionasmoretransitory.More importantly,asGilman (2016)summarized,atrainingprogramthathelps teachersreconciletheir identityasinstructors notonlyinstillsastrongerdesireinteachersto improvetheirjobskills butincreasesthechance thattheywillremaininaprofessioninwhich,accordingto Bambrick-Santoyo(2016)citing statisticsfromtheNationalCommissiononTeachingandAmerica’sFuture(NCTAF),nearly halfofAmericanteachersquitlessthanfiveyearsintotheircareer.Eventhoughsimilarstatistics havenotbeencompiledfortheircounterpartsintheEFLworld,theattritionrateisprobably muchhigher.Qualityinductiontrainingmayalso reducetheresentment NNESTsfeeltoward theirNESTcounterpartswhousuallyhaveless teachingexperienceand fewerpedagogicalskills, arelesscommittedtotheirjobs,butneverthelessreceivebetterbenefitsinanattempttolure themfromthehomecountries.

(11)

10 DuetotheaforementionedrealitiesoftheEFLworld,itshouldcomeasnosurprisethat theschool-sponsoredtrainingI​​have​​receivedhas,forthemostpart, beendesultory,superficial, andlargelydisconnectedfromthespecificsof mymostdaunting classroomchallenges.An informalteachersurveyIconductedatthreeofthe12languageschoolsintheMoroccannetwork yieldedsimilarobservations:sporadictrainingworkshops whichwerefrequentlyunrelatedto teachers’mostvitalinstructionalneedsandageneralabsenceofa coherentprogramfor sustainedteacherdevelopment.Therefore,Iwantto createateacher developmentprogramfor EFLinstructorsatthestageofdevelopmentwheretheyneeditmost:theinductionportionof theirprofessionalcareer—thetimewhentheyaremostlikelytoabandon theprofessionbecause thepre-servicetrainingtheyreceivedisincongruent withthepedagogical exigenciesoftheir employerandtheyhavebeenlefttosortoutthetransitional shockforthemselves.

FormostofmyESL/EFLcareer,Ihavebeenattemptingto countertheprototypical patternofprofessionalisolationIhaveexperiencedin everyteachingcontextIhaveworkedin andcreatewaysformycolleaguestoshare ideas,collaborateonlessonplansandcourse material,and,subsequently,initiatetheirownprofessional development.AsI mentionedinthe previousparagraph,teaching,atleastwhenaninstructorhascompletedpreservicepreparation andisattemptingtoapplythosepedagogicalinsightstoanactualclassroom,isoftenalonely profession.Uponcompletionoftheirfour-weekCELTAorTESOLcertificationcourse,teachers typicallylosecontactwiththeirpreserviceteachereducatorsand,asFarrell (2009)remarked,are askedtoperformthesametasksoflesson-planninganddeliveryas theirmoreexperienced colleagues,oftenwithoutanyguidanceorsupportfrom theiremployer.Inotherwords,theyare beingaskedtolearntwojobssimultaneously,asWildman etal.(1989,as citedinFarrell,2012)

References

Outline

Related documents

2005– Digital TV will replace analog service and start to provide interactive services in addition to broadcast service; third generation cellular systems and WLAN

ATLAS Reprocessing Campaigns 1 PB 2010 data reprocessing 0.25 PB HI data reprocessing campaign 2011 data reprocessing 0.21 PB muon reprocessing campaign Group Production:

Before starting your application, Eclipse will display following window to select an option where you want to run your Android application.. Select mobile device as an option and

Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary in this Trust, if the Corporate Trustee is granted the authority to make discretionary distributions of income and/or principal for

and all angles of equal measure is called a regular polygon..  Axes of the coordinate

In addition, the Government of Vietnam might consider greater action in their own (public sector) use of voluntary, globally accepted standards or generally accepted industry

Check Point, AlertAdvisor, Application Intelligence, Check Point Endpoint Security, Check Point Endpoint Security On Demand, Check Point Express, Check Point Express CI, the

Based on Model 3, in the Terai, a one-year increase in mean years of schooling was associated with a two-fifths (1-exp[-0.49]) decline in the number of families affected due to floods