Hamline University
DigitalCommons@Hamline
School of Education Student Capstone Projects School of Education
Fall 2017
Lesson-Plan Delivery Before Lesson-Plan Design:
Defining, Sequencing, And Teaching The Essential
Skills Of An English Language Teacher
Development Program At Induction
Joel Hanson
Hamline University
Follow this and additional works at:https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/hse_cp Part of theEducation Commons
This Capstone Project is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Education at DigitalCommons@Hamline. It has been accepted for inclusion in School of Education Student Capstone Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Hamline. For more information,
please [email protected], [email protected].
Recommended Citation
Hanson, Joel, "Lesson-Plan Delivery Before Lesson-Plan Design: Defining, Sequencing, And Teaching The Essential Skills Of An
English Language Teacher Development Program At Induction" (2017).School of Education Student Capstone Projects. 94.
LESSON-PLANDELIVERYBEFORELESSON-PLANDESIGN:
DEFINING,SEQUENCING,ANDTEACHINGTHEESSENTIALSKILLSOFANENGLISH LANGUAGETEACHERDEVELOPMENTPROGRAMATINDUCTION
ByJoelHanson
A capstone submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in EnglishasaSecondLanguage.
Hamline University Saint Paul, Minnesota
December2017
CapstoneProjectFacilitator:TrishHarvey
2
ThisCapstoneprojectisdedicatedtoMyriamAdyadou, whopatientlytalkedmedownfromthe pedagogicalprecipiceonnumerousoccasionswhile collaboratingonourfirstproject-based course.Yourcreativitymadethecoursewecreatedsomuchbetterthanitwould havebeenhadI
toiledinisolation—asIhavedoneformostof myEFLcareer.This Capstoneprojectisalso dedicatedtoMarkHolbrook,whosecuriosity,equanimity,andpatienceaffordedmethe opportunitytodojustabouteverythingIeverwantedtodoinEFLteachingandtraining—except
3
TABLEOFCONTENTS
Chapter1 Introduction 5
IdentifyingtheProblem 5
MyOwnPathtoTeacherTraining 8 PrerequisitesandObstaclestoaPurposefulTeacherDevelopmentProgram 13 Chapter1SummaryandOverviewoftheRemainingChapters 16
Chapter2 LiteratureReview 19
Introduction/Overview 19
TeacherTrainingProgramPrerequisites 20 ChoosingaCurricularFrameworkCompatible withStudentLearningGoals 22 TheCaseforUsingExistingCoursestoTrainNoviceInstructors 25 FourFrameworksforTeacherDevelopment 29 TwoCentralTasksofLearningtoTeachatthePreservicePhase 38 OneCentralTaskofLearningtoTeachattheInductionPhase 47 AReorderingandRationalefor Feiman-Nemser’sCentralTasksat
Induction
51
ChapterSummary 59
Chapter3 ProjectDescription 62
ChapterOverview 62
ProjectContext 64
PrimaryInstructorIssuesintheClassroom 65 TheProject-BasedCourseonWhichtheInductionTrainingIsBased 68 ThreeGuidingPrinciplesfortheInductionTrainingHandbook 70 AFrameworkforFourPhasesofInductionTraining 76
4 ChapterSummary 78 Chapter4 Conclusion 80 ChapterOverview 80 MajorFindings 81 ComplicationsinResearch 91
ProjectImplications,CommunicationofResults,BenefitstotheProfession 97 ProjectLimitations,NextSteps,andFutureResearch 98
ChapterSummary 101
Conclusion 102
References 105
LISTOFTABLESANDFIGURES
Chapter2 Figure1:TheFreemanandJohnson(1998)KnowledgeBaseforTeacher Education
30 Table1:TheCentralTasksofLearningtoTeach(Feiman-Nemser,2001) 34 Table2:Danielson’sFrameworkforTeaching(2007) 36 Table3:TheFirstTwoPhases ofBambrick-Santoyo’s(2016)Scopeand
SequenceofActionStepsto LaunchaTeacher’sDevelopment
37 Figure2:Graves’(2000)circularmodelofcoursedesign 52 Table4:Asuggestedalternativeorder ofFeiman-Nemser’scentraltasksof learningtoteachatinduction
53 Chapter3 Table1:ElementsandComponents ofDomain3:Instructionfrom
Danielson’sFrameworkforTeaching(p.4)
76
Table2:MyFourPhasesof InductionTrainingRelatedtoDanielson’s ComponentsofDomains1-3:Planning andPreparation,TheClassroom Environment,andInstruction
5
CHAPTERONE
INTRODUCTION
“Aconceptualframeworkisthecornerstoneof acoherent[teacher development]program.It offersaviewoflearning,theroleoftheteacher,andthemissionof theschoolingina
democracy.Itprovidesasetofunderstandingsabout learningtoteach.Morethanrhetoric,the valuesandideasthatmakeuptheprogram’smissionandconceptual frameworkinformthe designandsequencingofcoursesandfieldexperiences.Theygettranslated intospecificthemes orcoreabilities.Theyshapecurriculum, culture,pedagogy,andassessmentpractices.”—Sharon Feiman-Nemser(2001,p.1023)
IdentifyingtheProblem
Fortheentiretyofits60-yearhistory,myformeremployerhas operatedalarge, profitablenetworkofEnglishlanguageschoolsinMoroccowithoutapedagogicalframework suchastheonedescribedbyHowey andZimpher(1989) andFeiman-Nemser(2001).
Consequently,theadministrativeassociationanditsnetworkof12languageschools lackaclear missionstatement;precisedescriptionsofwhat constituteseffectiveteachingandstudent
learning;acurriculumwithcourseoutcomestheextendbeyondthedesultory aimsofthe
textbook-driven/grammar-basedsyllabusofthecoursebookstheyareusing;and,mostcrucially, aqualityteachertrainingprogramtoensurethat thestudent-learningaimsofitscoursesare consistentlyrealized.Totheircredit,theschoolsinthenetworkusea
communicative-language-teaching(CLT)approachandprovideagenerallyenjoyable
language-learningexperienceforamajorityofthe Moroccanhighschool andcollegestudents whomakeupanoverwhelmingmajorityoftheircustomers.Theschools alsoprovidenumerous freeextracurricularclubsandengageinsomecharitablecommunityoutreachthatcombines languagelearningwithpersonalskilldevelopmentandpublicservice.Nevertheless,thelargely
6 unacknowledgedconsequencesofthesecurricularandpedagogicalblindspotsareevidentwhen interactingwithlearnerswhohavecompletedthe school’s18-classprogram: anumberof
studentsarenotproficientinoneormoreofthe fourskillsormanagetoachieveoralfluencybut lackthetextual,compositional,andhigher-orderthinking skillsneededto succeedinan
English-speakingacademicenvironment.
Acursoryglanceattheone-sentencemission statementofthe network’slargestEnglish languageschoolinCasablancarevealsanoticeableabsenceofspecificityregarding thenatureof whateverpedagogyitischampioning:Ourschoolexiststogiveallofourstudentsthebest teachingandlearningexperience inCasablanca.Theobviousquestion:How doesonedefine “thebestteachingandlearningexperience”?Undoubtedly,theanswerdependsonwhich director,teachercoordinator,EFLinstructor,orstudentonespeakstoand,itissafetoassume, theirresponseswouldbewidelydivergent.Clearly,thestudentssuffermost fromthisscholastic relativism,asmanyhaveconfessedtomeonnumerousoccasions;eachtimetheystartanew courseandworkwithanewteacherisakinto enteringanewschoolthatbearsnoresemblanceto theoldone;andtheironlyhoperestswiththe goodfortunetobeassignedaninstructorwhois skilledenoughtoassistintheirlanguage-learningprocess.
SinceIbeganpursuingmyMAinAdultESLatHamline,Ihavebeeninterestedin helpingthethelargestlanguageschoolinCasablanca moreclearlydefinethelearninggoalsof itscoursesasabasisforestablishinggreaterpedagogicalconsistencyamong the75-teacherstaff andmoreaccuratelyassessingstudentperformance.Therefore, withthegoal ofcreatinga
handbookofinstructionalsequencesforacomprehensive52-weekinductiontrainingcourse,this Capstoneprojectseekstouncovertheessentialtasks andsequencesofEFLteachertrainingat
7 inductionand,intheprocess,providemyformer employerandsimilarEFLinstitutionswitha blueprintforestablishingcompelling—andexplicit—learning outcomesandequippingteachers withtheskillstohelptheirstudentsachievethose coursegoals.Thestudents whocometotheir schoolsforlanguageinstructiondeservenoless.AsI reviewsomeofthe availableliteratureina searchforcommonalitiesinvariousteacherdevelopmentprogramframeworks,Iwillcontend withthefirstoftwocentralresearchquestions:
Whataretheessentialsetofteachingskills/practices attheinductionportionofteachertraining thatareapplicabletomyEFLteachingcontext?Then,Iwillcombinethoseskillframeworksin theliteraturereviewtoanswermysecondresearch question:Inlightofthespecificteacher preparationanddevelopmentneedsofthestaff intheaforementioned 12-schoolnetworkin Morocco,howshouldtheseskillsbesequencedand taughtduringtheinductionportionofan Englishlanguageteacherdevelopmentprogram?
Intherestofchapter1,Iwillbrieflydocumentmyownprofessionalpathfromnovice instructortoteachertrainerandthepedagogicalepiphany Ihadalongthatway—inshort,that identifyingcourseoutcomesandhelpinginstructorsacquiretheskillsnecessaryforconsistent studentachievementofthecourseoutcomesareparamounttoproviding“the bestteachingand learningexperiences.”Drawingonmypersonalexperiencein thefieldasthebasisforfurther reflection,Iwillthenconsiderwhatcomponentsshould serveasthefoundationforaviable inductiontrainingprogram.Intheprocess,Iwill alsoexplorewhatalanguageschoolwould needtoconstruct(e.g.aclearvisionofthestudentlearningitistrying topromote,aspecific curricularframeworkwithclearlydefinedcourseoutcomes, andwell-definedset ofskillsand
8 practicesteachersshouldpossessatvariousstagesof theircareer)beforeitcouldcreatea
purposefulteachertrainingprogram.
MyOwnPathtoTeacherTraining
Mypersonalinvestmentintheoutcomeof thisprojectshould beself-evident:Purposeful teachertrainingprogramsaretheexceptionratherthanthe ruleasevidencedby thatfactthatin my16-year,seven-countrycareer—mostlyasanEnglishasaForeignLanguage(EFL)
instructor,Ihaveyettoworkforaninstitutionthat hadaclearvisionofwhatitwantedits studentstoaccomplishintheclassroom.Equallyimportant,noneofthese institutionshada teachertrainingprogramtoensurethatitsteachers possessthepedagogicaltoolstohelptheir studentsdeveloptheskillsneededtoachievethe coursegoals.Manyteachertrainingprogramsat theprivatelanguageschoollevel—myformer employerincluded—focusonbrief,off-site
preservicepreparationandlargelyignorethe inductionandongoingprofessionaldevelopment aspectsofateacher’scareer.Perhapsthat isbecauseadministrators areoftenworking
autonomously(likemyformeremployer)andtypically lacktheknowledge, vision,andqualified personneltoinitiateateacherdevelopmentprogram orbecausethey believetheirlargely
unskillednative-speakingEFLinstructorsarenotgoingtobearoundthatlong.
Afterall,asGilman(2016)haspointedout, theEnglishasaForeignLanguage(EFL) worlddifferssignificantlyfromitsEnglishasaSecondLanguage(ESL) counterparteventhough thetwotermsareoftenusedinterchangeably.TheEFLworldcontainsboth
non-native-English-speakingteachers(NNESTs)wholearnedEnglish asasecondorthird languageandteachittostudentsofasimilar linguisticandculturalbackground inacountryin whichEnglishisaminoritylanguage. AndthereareNative-English-speakinginstructors
9 (NESTs)instructorslikemyselfwhomovetoa foreigncountrytoteachthelanguage,often withoutknowingmuchaboutthenativelanguageand cultureoftheirstudents.Incontrast,the ESLworldalmostexclusivelycontainsNESTswhoteachEnglish inacountryin whichitisthe dominantlanguage.Itisagrossunderstatementtoassert thattheEFLworld containsafareasier pathtocertification;aglaringlackofuniformityinthetrainingthatisoffered tobothnoviceand experiencedinstructors;professionalresponsibilitiesthatdiffer widelyfromcountrytocountry andwithinschoolsinthesamecountry.Itisalsoimportanttonote,as Gilman(2016)did,that manyNESTEFLteachersaredrawntothe professionnotbecausetheyarepassionateabout learningthecraftbutbecauseteachingabroadprovides theeasiestpathtoanexcitingbut ephemerallifestylechangeinaforeignculture;and,consequently,theseteachers tendtoview theiridentityandrolewithinthatinstitutionasmoretransitory.More importantly,asGilman (2016)summarized,atrainingprogramthathelps teachersreconciletheir identityasinstructors notonlyinstillsastrongerdesireinteachersto improvetheirjobskills butincreasesthechance thattheywillremaininaprofessioninwhich,accordingto Bambrick-Santoyo(2016)citing statisticsfromtheNationalCommissiononTeachingandAmerica’sFuture(NCTAF),nearly halfofAmericanteachersquitlessthanfiveyearsintotheircareer.Eventhoughsimilarstatistics havenotbeencompiledfortheircounterpartsintheEFLworld,theattritionrateisprobably muchhigher.Qualityinductiontrainingmayalso reducetheresentment NNESTsfeeltoward theirNESTcounterpartswhousuallyhaveless teachingexperienceand fewerpedagogicalskills, arelesscommittedtotheirjobs,butneverthelessreceivebetterbenefitsinanattempttolure themfromthehomecountries.
10 DuetotheaforementionedrealitiesoftheEFLworld,itshouldcomeasnosurprisethat theschool-sponsoredtrainingIhavereceivedhas,forthemostpart, beendesultory,superficial, andlargelydisconnectedfromthespecificsof mymostdaunting classroomchallenges.An informalteachersurveyIconductedatthreeofthe12languageschoolsintheMoroccannetwork yieldedsimilarobservations:sporadictrainingworkshops whichwerefrequentlyunrelatedto teachers’mostvitalinstructionalneedsandageneralabsenceofa coherentprogramfor sustainedteacherdevelopment.Therefore,Iwantto createateacher developmentprogramfor EFLinstructorsatthestageofdevelopmentwheretheyneeditmost:theinductionportionof theirprofessionalcareer—thetimewhentheyaremostlikelytoabandon theprofessionbecause thepre-servicetrainingtheyreceivedisincongruent withthepedagogical exigenciesoftheir employerandtheyhavebeenlefttosortoutthetransitional shockforthemselves.
FormostofmyESL/EFLcareer,Ihavebeenattemptingto countertheprototypical patternofprofessionalisolationIhaveexperiencedin everyteachingcontextIhaveworkedin andcreatewaysformycolleaguestoshare ideas,collaborateonlessonplansandcourse material,and,subsequently,initiatetheirownprofessional development.AsI mentionedinthe previousparagraph,teaching,atleastwhenaninstructorhascompletedpreservicepreparation andisattemptingtoapplythosepedagogicalinsightstoanactualclassroom,isoftenalonely profession.Uponcompletionoftheirfour-weekCELTAorTESOLcertificationcourse,teachers typicallylosecontactwiththeirpreserviceteachereducatorsand,asFarrell (2009)remarked,are askedtoperformthesametasksoflesson-planninganddeliveryas theirmoreexperienced colleagues,oftenwithoutanyguidanceorsupportfrom theiremployer.Inotherwords,theyare beingaskedtolearntwojobssimultaneously,asWildman etal.(1989,as citedinFarrell,2012)