INSU 2500
Chapter 9
October 10, 2006
2
CHAPTER 9
BASIC PROPERTY AND LIABILITY
INSURANCE CONTRACTS
3Common Elements of
Insurance Contracts
Declarations Insuring Agreement Deductibles Definitions Exclusions Conditions Endorsements & Riders 4Declarations
• Facts of Policy
• Usually first page of an insurance
contract contains such things as:
– Identifies the insurance company – Identifies the named insured – Policy period– Policy limits – Deductibles – Premium
– Identifies forms and / or endorsements
5
Insuring Agreement
• The words that give force to the contract
and describe in broad language the rights
and duties of both parties to the contract.
– Broadly describes what is covered and the
insurer’s and the insured’s rights,
obligations, and duties.
• Example:
– Auto (PAP): Personal auto policy
6
Insuring Agreement Example
“We will pay for bodily injury and property
damage for which an insured person is legally
liable. Liability must arise from the ownership,
maintenance or use of your insured aircraft or
use of the premises on which it is stored. The
bodily injury and property damage must occur
during the Policy Period and be caused by an
accident. When bodily injury and property
damage are covered under this Insurance, we
will also provide an insured person with a legal
defense against such claims for bodily injury
and property damage.”
7
Definitions
• Found in the contract when words or
phrases are to be defined in a specific
way.
• Try to minimize ambiguous terms and
words in the contract for legal
interpretation purposes.
• Also reduces word count when words
that need to be defined are used multiple
times.
8
Exclusions
• Identify losses that are not covered.
• Designed to:
– Eliminate catastrophic events - flood, war
– Eliminate moral or morale hazards - intentional loss, failure to protect property
– Require extra charge - unfair to charge all insureds for covering $100,000 gun collections
– Eliminate coverage where another policy is specifically designed for the coverage – To truncate the doctrine of proximate cause
9
Endorsements
• Modify standard insurance contracts in
predetermined ways
• Examples:
– Expand coverage
– Delete exclusions in contract
– Change definitions
• e.g.: “Baby-sitting is NOT a “business”
– Add locations / insureds / perils
– Add additional insureds
10
Conditions
• If you want the claim paid, you must meet the
conditions stated in the contract. These
include:
– No Concealment or Fraud – No Suspension of coverage – Cancellation – policy must be in force
– Other insurance does not apply or loss is shared – Meet your duties after a loss
– Abide by the appraisal procedure – Agree to salvage
– Agree to claims payment - time limits
11
Fraud
• Homeowners contract:
– Intentionally concealed or misrepresented any
fact or circumstances;
– Engaged in fraudulent conduct; or
– Made false statements; relating to the
insurance.
12
Cancellation
• The insured may cancel the HO contract at any
time and receive a refund for any unearned
portion of the premium.
– When the insureds cancel, the short-rate cancellation schedule is used (allowing insurers to recover expense).
• Insurers also may cancel property policies.
– When the insurers cancel, the pro rata cancellation method is used.
• What is the difference between the two
approaches?
13
Other Insurance
• If a loss covered by this policy is also
covered by other insurance, the insurer
will pay only the portion of the loss that the
limit of liability that applies under this
policy bears to the total amount of
insurance covering the loss.
• <Example> A $250,000 house insured
with 2 insurance contracts (each contract
covers up to $250,000). What happens if
the house is totally destroyed by fire?
14
Insured’s Duties After Loss
Homework!
15
Appraisal
• Appraisal procedure:
– Unsettled disagreements about the property
losses.
– Appraisers selected
– Umpire then chosen by the appraisers
– If still not settled, the case goes to the court
– Each party pays its own appraiser; and
– Bear the other expenses of the appraisal and
umpire equally.
16
Deductibles
• Straight deductible - amount paid by insured
before the insurer pays any money
– Example: from the loss v. from the claim • $25,000 loss
• $20,000 coverage • $ 1,000 deductible • Deductible from the loss
– $25,000 - $1,000 = $24,000; $20,000 paid because hit policy limit
• Deductible from claim
– $20,000 - $1,000 = $19,000; deductible taken from claim
17
Reasons for Deductibles
• Reduces moral and morale hazard since
insured pays a small portion of each loss
• Eliminates the expenses involved in small,
frequent claims and most losses are small
• As a result premiums are lower.
• Deductibles can be treated as risk
assumption or risk transfer?
18
Objective Question #1
• Deductibles
a. Cause the insured to pay the first dollars of a loss. b. Cause the insurance company to pay the first
dollars of a loss.
c. Cause the loss to be deducted from the policy face.
d. Cause the policy face limit to be deducted from the loss.
19
Objective Question #2
If an insured cancels her insurance policy:
a. The short-rate cancellation table is used to
calculate the refund.
b. The Greenwich mean cancellation table is
used to calculate the refund.
c. The pro rata cancellation calculation is used
to calculate the refund.
d. The mensa table is used to calculate the
refund.
20
Objective Question #4
The purpose of the declarations section of an
insurance policy is to:
a. Declare the insurance company’s intention to provide coverage.
b. Declare the insured’s intention to purchase insurance.
c. State the important facts about the coverage provided and personalize the coverage to a particular insured. d. Declare the policy to be canceled by mutual
agreement.
21
Objective Question #5
The clause that creates a binding agreement
between the insurer and insured is called
the:
a. binding clause
b. mutual agreement
c. ratification clause
d. insuring agreement
22Objective Question #7
If an insured files a fraudulent claim after a loss
occurs, the most likely result will be:
a. The insured will go to jail.
b. The insurer will not pay the claim after the fraud is discovered.
c. The insurer will pay the claim, but try to recover the insurance proceeds by way of subrogation against the insured.
d. The insured will collect, but only for half the amount claimed, with half the loss being considered a “fraud” penalty.
23
Objective Question #8
To settle disagreements over the amount of
property losses, the ___________
procedure is used:
a. appraisal
b. settlement / pro rata
c. disagreement
d. salvage
24
Topic Objectives
• Types of Torts
• Defenses Against Negligence
• Liability and Risk
• Tort Liability Trends
• Tort Limitations
•
•
A tort is a legal wrong for which the law
A tort is a legal wrong for which the law
allows a remedy in the form of money
allows a remedy in the form of money
damages.
damages.
What is a Tort?
•
Person harmed: plaintiff or
claimant.
•
Person alleged to cause the
harm: defendant or
tortfeasor.
• Intentional Torts
Intentional act or
omission that causes harm
Examples: assault,
trespass, fraud, libel and slander.
• Absolute Liability
Injurer liable for
damages, regardless of negligence. Examples: Work injuries, blasting, explosives, foods, medicine, wild animals.
Types of Torts
• Negligence
Injurer is liable for damages to the injured when he fails to exercise the proper ‘standard of care’.
• Criteria
Legal duty existed. Duty not performed. Damages were incurred. Failure to perform duty proximate cause of damages.Types of Torts (cont.)
28
Types of Damages
• Special Damages
can be determined & documented
e.g., wage loss, medical expense, property damage
• General Damages (Non-Economic)
cannot be measured e.g., pain and suffering
• Punitive Damages
intended to punish and discourage others from committing the same wrongful act
• Contributory Negligence
No damages if person hurt contributed to injury.
• Comparative Negligence
Financial burden shared according to relative fault.
•
Last clear chance rule
•
Assumption of risk
Injured person recognized
risk inherent in activity.
Defenses Against Negligence
• Imputed Negligence
Employer-Employee
Vicarious Liability
Family Purpose Doctrine
Dram Shop Laws
• Res Ipsa Loquitur
“The things speaks for
itself”
presumption of negligence
e.g., doctor amputates
wrong leg
31
Potential Tort Situations
• Property Owners
• Attractive Nuisance Doctrine
• Owners/Operators of Autos
• Governmental Liability
erosion of sovereign immunity
• Charitable Institutions
• Employer and Employee Relationship
• Parents and Children
• Animals
• What is the traditional purpose of tort
law?
• Liability, compensation & deterrence
• Tort law and insurance.
Moral Hazard? Adverse Selection? Principle of Indemnity?
Liability and Risk
• Recent expansion of
liability, i.e.
increased
willingness of courts
to find one party
liable for damages.
• Products Liability &
Professional Liability
have become
problems
Trends in Tort Law
• Traditional standard:
contributory negligence
Many states have moved to
comparative negligence
standard.
Assumption of risk defense has weakened over time.
• Expansion of liability for product defects
Demise of “Privity of Contract” principle. Expansion of defects to include design defects. Extension of defects to include “failure to
adequately warn of dangers”.
More Trends
• Increased general damage awards
Evidence suggests it is faster than the
inflation rate.
Total damage amounts vary more.
“At this time the family is grieving and suing.”
and More Trends
36
Implications
• Greater safety?
• Avoidance of
activities
• Higher insurance
rates
• Higher consumer
prices, diminished
product choice
“I liked recess a lot better before the safety helmets.”
• Limits on pain and
suffering
• Limits on joint and
several liability
• Encourage dispute
resolution
• No-fault insurance
Thank you for not suingThank you for not suing
•
Pros and Cons of Tort Limits
How are different interests affected?Moral hazard and deterrence?