SIFMA Operations Conference:
SIFMA Operations Conference:
Money
Money Market
Market Fund Reform
Fund Reform
Peter Crane Peter Crane
President & Publisher President & Publisher
Crane Data Crane Data Michelle Lens Michelle Lens Senior Vice President Senior Vice President
The Dreyfus Corporation, a BNY Mellon The Dreyfus Corporation, a BNY Mellon
Company Company
This presentation is a summary only, and is qualified in its entirety by the applicable rules and regulations. Where this presentation includes interpretations, there is no assurance that, if asked, the applicable regulators or their staff would agree with these interpretations. These materials are provided for educational and informational purposes for the use of those who may be interested in the subject matter.
Tim Schiltz Tim Schiltz
Senior Director, Product Management Senior Director, Product Management
Ameriprise Financial Inc. Ameriprise Financial Inc.
Joan Ohlbaum Swirsky Joan Ohlbaum Swirsky
Current Stats: Assets, Yields, Expenses
– Recent & Longer-Term Trends
Regulatory Issues: SEC’s MMF Reforms
– Timetable and Key Issues
Money Fund Reform: Update & Implications
Money Fund Reform: Update & Implications
Money Fund Reform: Update & Implications
Money Fund Reform: Update & Implications
– Timetable and Key Issues
Portfolio Holdings Trends & Data
– Latest Data & Pending Disclosures
Global Money Funds, Enhanced, Misc.
Current State of Money Fund Industry
Current State of Money Fund Industry
Current State of Money Fund Industry
Current State of Money Fund Industry
MMF Assets $2.7 Trillion (Record was $3.9T)
– Bank Savings Over $7.3 Trillion
Approx. 24 Million Shareholders
$3.5 Billion in Annual Revenue (down from $9B)
Approx. 1/4 Share of “Cash” Markets (Banks 50%)
Approx. 1/4 Share of “Cash” Markets (Banks 50%)
Shifting Regulatory & Competitive Landscape
Zero Yields, Attrition & Consolidation
Record Levels of “Cash”? (Broke $10 Tril.)
Historical & Recent MMF Asset Flows
Historical & Recent MMF Asset Flows
Historical & Recent MMF Asset Flows
Historical & Recent MMF Asset Flows
Flat Flows (Stable Base)
A New Hope (Bank & Bond Inflows)
Money Funds Are Down $1.2T Since Peak, But Flat Over 3 Years; Still at Mid-2007 Levels.
A New Hope (Bank & Bond Inflows)
MMF Assets by Type: “Prime” Still King
MMF Assets by Type: “Prime” Still King
MMF Assets by Type: “Prime” Still King
MMF Assets by Type: “Prime” Still King
4
Prime Inst 34% … or 20%?
Treas & Govt Inst Much Bigger Than Retail
Banks Take Trillions From MMFs
Banks Take Trillions From MMFs
Banks Take Trillions From MMFs
Banks Take Trillions From MMFs
Crisis, Basel III, Regs.
$4 Trillion in Uninsured Deposits
Spreads, $1 Trillion Flow to MMFs?
Money Funds Are Down $1.0T (-30.0%) Over 5 Yrs.; MMDAs Are Up $2.9T (+64.6%)
Rock Bottom Yields (Crane MFA 7
Rock Bottom Yields (Crane MFA 7--Day)
Day)
Rock Bottom Yields (Crane MFA 7
Rock Bottom Yields (Crane MFA 7--Day)
Day)
Yields Inch Up (Dead Cat Bounce)
Fed Hikes & Projections?
Fee Waiver Unwinding
Fund Expenses & Fee Waivers
Fund Expenses & Fee Waivers
Fund Expenses & Fee Waivers
Fund Expenses & Fee Waivers
Record Low Expenses/Waivers
Revenue Savaged but Shared
Higher Rates Will Explode Revs.
Regulatory: Final SEC MMF Reforms
Regulatory: Final SEC MMF Reforms
Regulatory: Final SEC MMF Reforms
Regulatory: Final SEC MMF Reforms
Rule 2a-7 Amendments (2/10)
President’s Working Grp (10/10)
SEC Cancels Vote (8/12)
FSOC Issues Draft (11/12)
Timeline of Events
Timeline of Events
Timeline of Events
Timeline of Events
FSOC Issues Draft (11/12)
SEC Reform Proposal (6/13)
Comment Letters Due (9/13)
Final MMF Reforms (7/14)
Fund Cos Prep for Regs (2/15)
New Disclosures Start (4/16)
Floating NAV/Gates-Fees (10/16)
New Rules
New Rules
New Rules
New Rules
Floating NAV (Prime Inst) &
Liquidity Fees & Gates (Prime)
2a-7 Tweaks, No Buffer
Fundamental Money Market
Fundamental Money Market
Fund Reforms
Fund Reforms
•
Floating NAV for institutional MMFs,
including tax-free MMFs
–
Retail MMFs are exempt from the floating NAV,
but are subject to fees/gates
10
but are subject to fees/gates
–
U.S. Government MMFs are exempt from the
floating NAV
Floating NAV
Floating NAV –
– Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Exemption
Exemption
“Retail” MMF is a
“Retail” MMF is a
MMF
MMF with policies
with policies
and procedures reasonably designed
and procedures reasonably designed
to limit all beneficial owners of the
to limit all beneficial owners of the
fund to natural persons
fund to natural persons
fund to natural persons
fund to natural persons
••
For
For MMF
MMF shares held in omnibus
shares held in omnibus
accounts
accounts if
if underlying beneficial owner is
underlying beneficial owner is
a natural person, shares may be
a natural person, shares may be
considered
Fees and Gates
Fees and Gates
Applicable to all money market funds other than
U.S. Government MMFS:
•
Board can impose
up to 2% “Liquidity Fee”
(redemption fee) and/or “Redemption Gate”
(temporary block on redemptions)
–
if weekly liquid assets (WLA) fall below 30% of
12
–
if weekly liquid assets (WLA) fall below 30% of
total assets
•
1% fee must be imposed if WLA fall below
10% of total assets
unless Board decides
otherwise
•
U.S. Government MMFs may opt into
fees/gates
Fundamental Reforms
Fundamental Reforms -- Overview
Overview
Treasury and U.S.
Government MMFS
Municipal MMFs Prime MMFS
Retail (SEC said most Municipal MMFs would fit here, but not all
Stable NAV No fee nor gate
Stable NAV Fee and gate
Stable NAV Fee and gate
here, but not all do) Institutional (Includes some Municipal MMFs) Stable NAV No fee nor gate
Floating NAV Fee and gate
Floating NAV Fee and gate (SEC said Prime Institutional
Additional Requirements
Additional Requirements
•
Enhanced disclosure
and reporting
- VNAV, liquidity, flows
- Form N-MFP (no more 60 day lag)
14
- Form N-MFP (no more 60 day lag)
•
Enhanced diversification testing of
issuers and providers of credit support
Compliance timeline
Compliance timeline
•
July 14, 2015 – Money market funds must
begin to report negative events to SEC
•
April 14, 2016 – Money market funds must
comply with changes other than floating
comply with changes other than floating
NAV and fees/gates (e.g., disclosure,
stress testing)
•
October 14, 2016 – Money market funds
Fees and gates
Fees and gates-- Operational
Operational
complications
complications
•
Can intermediaries impose fees/gates on the
Board’s demand?
•
Can intermediaries change the fee level on the
16
•
Can intermediaries change the fee level on the
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—What Does It
What Does It
Mean?
Mean?
• Floating NAV MMF must compute its NAV in
compliance with Rule 2a-4 (definition of “current net asset value”), limiting its use of amortized cost as a fair value to securities with 60 days or less remaining to maturity
– Government and retail MMFs may use amortized cost, but
– Government and retail MMFs may use amortized cost, but must shadow price daily
• Will the NAV float? 60-Day max maturity funds.
• Funds will need to close early to provide same day settlement?
Tax Complications of Floating
Tax Complications of Floating
NAV
NAV –
– Treasury & IRS issue final &
Treasury & IRS issue final &
proposed relief
proposed relief
•
Shareholder recognizes small gains and losses on
redemption; results in potential issues
• Issue: Must brokers do 1099 reporting for redemptions of
floating NAV MMF shares
18
• Issue: Wash sales – Shareholder purchases shares in fund
within 30 days before or after a loss is recognized on redemption – results in disallowance of loss
• Issue: Complexity of shareholder reporting of G/L
•
IRS has proposed a solution to all three issues in
Tax Complications of Floating
Tax Complications of Floating NAV
NAV—
—
Treasury & IRS Issue Proposed and
Treasury & IRS Issue Proposed and
Final Relief
Final Relief
• Brokers will not be required to do 1099-B reporting:
– Proposed regulations provide that existing exception to 1099-B for MMF shares includes shares in floating NAV MMFs
• Wash sale rules will not apply to shares of floating NAV MMFs – Revenue Procedure 2014-45 provides that wash sale rules will not
– Revenue Procedure 2014-45 provides that wash sale rules will not apply to floating NAV MMF shares
• Proposed “NAV Method” (where applied) also makes wash sale rules irrelevant.
– Relief applies to an institutional MMF even if the fund’s holdings mature within 60 days (and therefore generally are valued at amortized cost)
• Proposed regulations include a simplified method of tax
Tax Complications of Floating
Tax Complications of Floating NAV
NAV—
—
Proposed
Proposed NAV
NAV Method
Method
• Shareholder may adopt the “NAV Method” of accounting so that gains/losses are recognized based on change in aggregate value of shares over a period of time (that does not exceed one year and does not stretch across two tax years) selected by shareholder, rather than at each redemption
• G/L = value of MMF shares at the end of the period, minus value of
20
• G/L = value of MMF shares at the end of the period, minus value of MMF shares at the end of the prior period, minus the taxpayer’s “net investment” in the MMF during the period
– Similar to mark-to-market tax accounting
– “Net investment”= aggregate cost of the shares purchased during the computation period minus the aggregate amount received upon taxable redemptions during such period
– All gains and losses are short-term capital gain/loss if the MMF shares are a capital asset
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Exemption
Exemption
• “Retail” MMF is a MMF with policies and procedures
reasonably designed to limit all beneficial owners of the fund to natural persons
• Tough questions if one or a few institutions appear in the fund . . . ?
• Tough questions if one or a few institutions appear in the fund . . . ?
• Board must decide at what point procedures are not “reasonably designed”
• Beneficial ownership “typically means” direct or indirect, sole or shared voting, and/or investment power
• Release also mentions Exchange Act Rule 16a-1(a)(2), which refers to beneficial ownership via pecuniary
Floating
Floating NAV
NAV—
—Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Examples
Examples
• SEC says if underlying beneficial owner is a natural person (including shares held in omnibus accounts), shares may be considered retail
• Possible earmark of natural persons—social security number or similar identifier unique to natural persons
22
number or similar identifier unique to natural persons
• SEC gives examples of accounts beneficially owned by natural persons
– Managed investment accounts in which only natural persons have a pecuniary interest
– Tax-advantaged savings accounts such as certain retirement, college, or health plans
– Personal trusts established for the benefit of natural persons
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Exemption
Exemption—
—Examples
Examples Not
Not Retail
Retail
• SEC gives examples of accounts that are notbeneficially owned by natural persons (for example, accounts not associated with social security
numbers), such as those opened by numbers), such as those opened by
– businesses, including small businesses
• Corporations, partnerships, limited liability companies, business trusts, or other businesses requiring TINs
– defined benefit plans, or
– endowments
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Exemption
Exemption—
—Procedures
Procedures
• SEC mentions Possible Procedures– Social Security Number provided directly on account
opening
– Social Security Number provided indirectly to adviser
24
– Social Security Number provided indirectly to adviser
that is record-keeper for a plan or for beneficiaries when account is opened for a trust
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—Retail Fund
Retail Fund
Exemption
Exemption—
—Intermediaries
Intermediaries
• Fund must reasonably conclude that beneficial shareholders who own through intermediaries are natural persons
• SEC gives examples of how to satisfy the definition
• SEC gives examples of how to satisfy the definition with intermediaries:
– contractual arrangements
– periodic certifications
Complications of the Floating
Complications of the Floating
NAV
NAV—
—Transition
Transition
• How to transition without triggering a pre-emptive run (e.g., if NAV is slightly below $1.00, shareholders may redeem prior to transition)
• SEC says: “money market fund managers could take
26
• SEC says: “money market fund managers could take steps to ensure that the fund’s market-based NAV is $1.00 or higher at the time of conversion and
Floating NAV
Floating NAV—
—Government
Government
Money Market Fund Exemption
Money Market Fund Exemption
• 99.5% of a Government MMF’s total assets must be:– Government securities as defined by ICA §2(a)(16)
– Repurchase agreements collateralized fully under rule 2a-7(a)(5) (only government securities and cash permitted as 7(a)(5) (only government securities and cash permitted as collateral)
– Cash
Confirms for Floating NAV Money
Confirms for Floating NAV Money
Market Funds
Market Funds
• SEC proposed an exemption from Rule 10b-10 that will allow floating NAV MMFs to provide periodic
statements rather than transactional confirmations if:
– Notice is given of the right to request a con-firmation, and
28 – Notice is given of the right to request a con-firmation, and
Big Issues with Brokerage Sweep
Big Issues with Brokerage Sweep
Big Issues with Brokerage Sweep
Big Issues with Brokerage Sweep
What is a “natural person”?
Social Security, Codes
Intraday Pricing
Same-day settlement
Costs, frequency
Pricing to 4 decimal places
Mini Y2K problem?
Gates & Fees
Timing
Preparing for Reforms: Recent Moves
Preparing for Reforms: Recent Moves
Preparing for Reforms: Recent Moves
Preparing for Reforms: Recent Moves
30
Fidelity Prime to Govt
Federated Short WAM
JPMAM Retail vs. Inst
Largest Issuers & Largest Credit Issuers
Largest Issuers & Largest Credit Issuers
Largest Issuers & Largest Credit Issuers
Largest Issuers & Largest Credit Issuers
Ultra
Ultra--Short, Enhanced Cash & SMAs
Short, Enhanced Cash & SMAs
Ultra
Ultra--Short, Enhanced Cash & SMAs
Short, Enhanced Cash & SMAs
Bond Funds & Ultra-Shorts
Bonds $3.5T But Ultras < $200B
ETFs (<$100B)
PIMCO MINT, Guggenheim, SHY
Enhanced Cash (maybe $200B)
34
Enhanced Cash (maybe $200B)
Banned from using stable NAV?