Finite sample inference for GMM estimators in linear panel data models

(1)

F

INITE

S

AMPLE

I

NFERENCE FOR

GMM

E

STIMATORS IN

L

INEAR

P

ANEL

D

ATA

M

ODELS

Stephen Bond

Frank Windmeijer

THE INSTITUTE FOR FISCAL STUDIES

DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS

,

UCL

(2)

Ilqlwh Vdpsoh Lqihuhqfh iru JPP Hvwlpdwruv lq

Olqhdu Sdqho Gdwd Prghov

Vwhskhq Erqg

|

Qx!hog Froohjh/ R{irug dqg Lqvwlwxwh iru Ilvfdo Vwxglhv

Iudqn Zlqgphlmhu

}

Fhqwuh iru Plfurgdwd Phwkrgv dqg Sudfwlfh

Lqvwlwxwh iru Ilvfdo Vwxglhv

: Ulgjprxqw Vwuhhw/ Orqgrq ZF4H :DH

Pd|/ 5335

Devwudfw

Zh frpsduh wkh qlwh vdpsoh shuirupdqfh ri d udqjh ri whvwv ri olqhdu uh0 vwulfwlrqv iru olqhdu sdqho gdwd prghov hvwlpdwhg xvlqj Jhqhudolvhg Phwkrg ri Prphqwv +JPP,1 Wkhvh lqfoxgh vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvwv edvhg rq rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv> wzr errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkhvh Zdog whvwv> d yhuvlrq ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw wkdw xvhv d pruh df0 fxudwh dv|pswrwlf dssur{lpdwlrq wr wkh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwru> wkh OP whvw> dqg wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv wkdw kdyh uhfhqwo| ehhq sursrvhg1 Zh frqvlghu erwk wkh DU+4, sdqho prgho/ dqg d ghvljq zlwk suhghwhuplqhg uhjuhvvruv1 Wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw shuirupv vlploduo| wr wkh vwdq0 gdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zklovw wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw/ dqg d vlpsoh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvw fdq surylgh pruh uholdeoh qlwh vdpsoh lqihuhqfh lq vrph fdvhv1

MHO Fodvvlfdwlrq= F45/ F56

Nh|zrugv= Jhqhudolvhg Phwkrg ri Prphqwv/ K|srwkhvlv Whvwlqj/ Ilqlwh Vdpsoh Lqihuhqfh

_{Dfnqrzohgjphqwv= Zh zrxog olnh wr wkdqn Vhxqj Dkq/ Pdqxho Duhoodqr/ Ulfkdug Eoxq0}

ghoo/ Folyh Erzvkhu dqg Ulfkdug Vsdg| iru khosixo frpphqwv1 Ilqdqfldo vxssruw iurp HVUF uhvhdufk judqw qr1 U33355639; dqg wkh HVUF Fhqwuh iru wkh Plfurhfrqrplf Dqdo|vlv ri Ilvfdo Srolf| dw LIV lv judwhixoo| dfnqrzohgjhg1 Wkh xvxdo glvfodlphu dssolhv1

|_{Hpdlo= vwhyh1erqgChfrqrplfv1r{irug1df1xn} }_{Hpdlo= i1zlqgphlmhuCliv1ruj1xn}

(3)

41 Lqwurgxfwlrq

Vwdqgdug Zdog whvwv edvhg rq wzr0vwhs h!flhqw Jhqhudolvhg Phwkrg ri Prphqwv +JPP, hvwlpdwruv duh nqrzq wr kdyh srru qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv lq vhyhudo frqwh{wv1 D ohdglqj h{dpsoh rffxuv lq sdqho gdwd prghov hvwlpdwhg xvlqj vh0 txhqwldo prphqw frqglwlrqv/ zkhuh wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv dydlodeoh jurzv udslgo| zlwk wkh wlph glphqvlrq ri wkh sdqho1 Lq wklv fdvh lw lv zhoo nqrzq wkdw wkh xvxdo dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru fdq eh vhyhuho| ryhuvl}hg/ hyhq zkhq wkh hvwlpdwru lwvhoi kdv yhu| olwwoh eldv +vhh/ iru h{dpsoh/ Eoxqghoo dqg Erqg/ 4<<;,1 Wkh vwdqgdug h{suhvvlrq iru wkh dv|ps0 wrwlf yduldqfh ri wklv hvwlpdwru ljqruhv wkh suhvhqfh ri hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv lq wkh zhljkw pdwul{/ dqg dv d uhvxow wkh xvxdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv fdq eh pxfk wrr vpdoo14 _{Wklv sureohp lv vr vhyhuh wkdw uhvhdufkhuv frpprqo| uhsruw k|0}

srwkhvlv whvwv edvhg rq lqh!flhqw rqh0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv/ iru zklfk vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvwv kdyh ehhq irxqg wr eh pruh uholdeoh1

D glvwlqfw sureohp zlwk lqihuhqfh edvhg rq JPP hvwlpdwruv rffxuv zkhq wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg surylgh rqo| zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhuv/ ru zkhq wkh lqvwuxphqwv dydlodeoh duh zhdn1 Lq wklv fdvh wkh hvwlpdwruv fdq eh vxemhfw wr odujh qlwh vdpsoh eldvhv/ zklfk djdlq uhvxow lq Zdog whvwv ehlqj vhulrxvo| ryhuvl}hg/ lq wklv fdvh iru erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwruv1 Djdlq wklv sureohp rffxuv frpprqo| lq sdqho gdwd dssolfdwlrqv/ zkhuh wkh wlph vhulhv duh riwhq kljko| shuvlvwhqw vr wkdw glhuhqfhv duh gl!fxow wr iruhfdvw/ exw glhuhqflqj0 w|sh wudqvirupdwlrqv duh xvhg wr uhpryh shupdqhqw lqglylgxdo hhfwv15

4_{Vhh Duhoodqr dqg Erqg +4<<4, iru vlpxodwlrq hylghqfh/ dqg Nrhqnhu dqg Pdfkdgr +4<<;,}

dqg Zlqgphlmhu +5333, iru dqdo|vhv1

5_{Vhh lqwhu dold Qhovrq dqg Vwduw} +4<<3, ru Vwdljhu dqg Vwrfn +4<<:, iru dqdo|vhv ri zhdn}

(4)

Dowhuqdwlyh k|srwkhvlv whvwv zlwk ehwwhu qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv duh wkhuhiruh ri frqvlghudeoh lqwhuhvw lq wkh sdqho gdwd frqwh{w1 Zh frqvlghu wzr srwhqwldo uhph0 glhv iru wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ dqg d udqjh ri dowhuqdwlyh whvw vwdwlvwlfv wkdw kdyh uhfhqwo| ehhq sursrvhg1 Rqh dssurdfk lv wr errwvwuds wkh frqyhqwlrqdo Zdog whvw1 Errwvwudsslqj iru JPP lv qrw vwdqgdug/ vlqfh wkh srsxodwlrq pr0 phqw frqglwlrqv gr qrw krog h{dfwo| lq wkh errwvwuds vdpsohv1 Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, sursrvh d uhfhqwhulqj surfhgxuh wr dffrxqw iru wklv/ zklovw Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<, sursrvh gudzlqj errwvwuds vdpsohv zlwk d uhzhljkwlqj ri wkh ruljlqdo revhuydwlrqv1 Zh frqvlghu wkhvh errwvwuds phwkrgv iru Zdog whvwv edvhg rq erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv1 Wkh vhfrqg dssurdfk frqvwuxfwv wkh Zdog whvw xvlqj d pruh dffxudwh dv|pswrwlf dssur{lpdwlrq wr wkh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ zklfk dffrxqwv iru wkh suhvhqfh ri hvwlpdwhg sd0 udphwhuv lq wkh zhljkw pdwul{1 Vxfk d fruuhfwlrq iru olqhdu JPP hvwlpdwruv kdv uhfhqwo| ehhq ghyhorshg e| Zlqgphlmhu +5333,1

Zh frpsduh wkhvh yduldwlrqv rq wkh Zdog whvw wr wkh OP whvw/ dqg wr wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv1 Wkh OP whvw h{sorlwv wkh uhvwulfwlrqv xqghu wkh qxoo k|0 srwkhvlv wr uhgxfh wkh qxpehu ri hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv xvhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh zhljkw pdwul{1 Fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv frpsduh plqlplvhg ydoxhv ri wkh hvwlpdwru*v fulwhulrq ixqfwlrq/ ru htxlydohqwo| whvwv ri ryhulghqwli|lqj uhvwulfwlrqv/ iru wkh uh0 vwulfwhg dqg wkh xquhvwulfwhg prghov1 Kdqvrq/ Khdwrq dqg \durq +4<<9, sursrvh vxfk d whvw edvhg rq wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP fulwhulrq> Lpehqv/ Vsdg| dqg Mrkqvrq +4<<;, sursrvh vxfk d whvw edvhg rq h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj sdudphwhuv> zklovw Erqg/ Erzvkhu dqg Zlqgphlmhu +5334, frqvlghu vxfk d whvw edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq1

(5)

Zh frqvlghu wkh qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv ri wkhvh whvwv iru vlpsoh olqhdu uhvwulf0 wlrqv lq g|qdplf sdqho gdwd prghov hvwlpdwhg xvlqj olqhdu prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Zh frqvlghu erwk d vlpsoh -E prgho zlwk lqglylgxdo hhfwv/ dqg d ghvljq zlwk suhghwhuplqhg uhjuhvvruv1 Lq doo fdvhv rxu vlpxodwlrqv frqup wkh srru shu0 irupdqfh ri wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw w|slfdoo| surylghv d pruh uholdeoh edvlv iru qlwh vdpsoh lqihuhqfh1 Wkh fruuhfwhg yhuvlrq ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw lv irxqg wr kdyh vlplodu qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv wr wklv rqh0vwhs whvw1 Erwk wkhvh Zdog whvwv kdyh jrrg vl}h surshuwlhv h{fhsw lq fdvhv zkhuh wkh JPP hvwlpdwru lv vxemhfw wr vxevwdqwldo qlwh vdpsoh eldv/ ru zkhuh lwv vpdoo vdpsoh glvwulexwlrq ehfrphv glvwlqfwo| qrq0qrupdo1 Wkh errw0 vwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw dqg wkh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvw edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq fdq surylgh pruh uholdeoh qlwh vdpsoh lqihuhqfh lq fdvhv zkhuh wkhvh Zdog whvwv kdyh prghvw vl}h glvwruwlrqv gxh wr vpdoo vdpsoh eldvhv lq wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv1 Wkh OP whvw shuirupv yhu| zhoo h{fhsw zkhq lghqwlfdwlrq lv zhdn/ zklovw wklv vlpsoh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvw dsshduv wr kdyh wkh ehvw vl}h surshuwlhv lq wkh fdvh ri zhdn lqvwuxphqwv1 Errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw fdq eh vhyhuho| xqghuvl}hg lq wkhvh ryhulghqwlhg sdqho gdwd prghov/ zkhuh wkh rswlpdo zhljkw pdwul{ fdq eh srruo| hvwlpdwhg1

Wkh sdshu lv rujdqlvhg dv iroorzv1 Vhfwlrq 5 uhylhzv JPP hvwlpdwruv dqg glvwulexwlrq uhvxowv> Vhfwlrq 6 uhylhzv wkh vwdqgdug Zdog whvw/ dqg glvfxvvhv d qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq iru wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh dqg errwvwudsslqj surfhgxuhv> Vhfwlrq 7 frqvlghuv wkh OP whvw dqg Vhfwlrq 8 frqvlghuv wkh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv> Vhfwlrq 9 glvfxvvhv uhodwhg olwhudwxuh> Vhfwlrq : rxwolqhv rxu vlpxodwlrq ghvljqv> Vhfwlrq ; suhvhqwv rxu pdlq Prqwh Fduor uhvxowv dqg Vhfwlrq < frqfoxghv1

(6)

51 JPP

Frqvlghu wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv

.d}Efc qfo '.d}Eqfo ' fc

zkhuh}Elv d yhfwru ri rughu^/flv d yhfwru ri revhuyhg yduldeohv iru' c c /

dqgqf lv d sdudphwhu yhfwru ri rughu&1 Wkurxjkrxw/ zh dvvxph wkdw& ^1 Wkh

JPP hvwlpdwruqe iru qf wkhq plqlplvhv6 aEq ' % [ ' }Eq & ` % [ ' }Eq & c

zlwk uhvshfw wrq> zkhuh` lv d srvlwlyh vhplghqlwh zhljkw pdwul{ zklfk vdwlvhv

T*4_<"` ' `/ zlwk ` d srvlwlyh ghqlwh pdwul{1 Uhjxodulw| frqglwlrqv

duh dvvxphg vxfk wkdw *4<" S'}Eq ' .d}Eqo dqg I S'}Eqf $ Efc[ Ohw K Eq ' .dY}Eq*Yqo dqg Kf K Eqf/ wkhq s e qqf kdv d olplwlqj qrupdo glvwulexwlrq/sqeqf

$Efc T`/ zkhuh

T` ' EKf`Kf3Kf`[`KfEKf`Kf3 +514,

Dq h!flhqw wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ ghqrwhg qe2/ iru d jlyhq vhw ri prphqw

frqglwlrqv/ lv edvhg rq d zhljkw pdwul{ wkdw vdwlvhv T*4_<"` ' [3/ zlwk

T` ' EKf[3Kf31 D zhljkw pdwul{ wkdw vdwlvhv wklv surshuw| lv jlyhq e|

` e q ' # [ '} e q } e q $3 c +515,

zkhuh qe lv d frqvlvwhqw rqh0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru iru qf edvhg rq vrph nqrzq

zhljkw pdwul{`1 Qrwlfh wkdw ` e q wkxv ghshqgv rq hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv1 6_{Vhh Kdqvhq +4<;5,1}

(7)

Ghqrwh }Eq '

S

'}Eq1 Wkh vwdqgdug whvw iru ryhulghqwli|lqj uhvwulf0

wlrqv lv edvhg rq wkh plqlplvhg JPP fulwhulrq/ jlyhq e|

aqe2 '}qe2 ` e q }qe2 c

zkhuhqe2 lv wkh h!flhqw wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru1 Lq sduwlfxodu wkh whvw vwdwlvwlf

aqe2

kdv dq dv|pswrwlf fkl0vtxduhg glvwulexwlrq zlwk^&ghjuhhv ri iuhhgrp zkhq wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv duh ydolg1 Zh uhihu wr wklv dv wkh Vdujdq whvw lq wkh vhtxho +vhh Vdujdq +4<8;/ 4<;;,,1

Zh zloo frqvlghu JPP hvwlpdwruv lq sdqho gdwd prghov zkhuh doo wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg duh olqhdu lq wkh sdudphwhuv1 Ghqlqj

' Y}Eq

Yq c

rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs olqhdu JPP hvwlpdwruv wkhq vdwlvi|

e qqf ' E`3`}Eqf e q2qf ' _` e q 3_` e q }Eqfc

dqg wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfhv duh frqvlvwhqwo| hvwlpdwhg e|

g @hqe ' E_` 3``3 e q `E`3 g @hqe2 ' _` e q 3 +516,

61 Zdog Whvw

Wkh vwdqgdug Zdog whvw iru whvwlqj o olqhdu uhvwulfwlrqv ri wkh irup oEqf ' f lv

fdofxodwhg dv

(8)

zkhuh - ' YoEq*Yq_{/ dqg kdv dq dv|pswrwlf} 2

o glvwulexwlrq xqghu wkh qxoo1

Edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/qe'qe2/ dqg xvlqj lwv frqyhqwlrqdo dv|ps0

wrwlf yduldqfh hvwlpdwh/@hgqe2

/ wkh Zdog whvw kdv riwhq ehhq irxqg wr ryhuuhmhfw fruuhfw qxoo k|srwkhvhv vhyhuho| frpsduhg wr lwv qrplqdo vl}h1 Wklv fdq rffxu hyhq zkhq wkh hvwlpdwru kdv qhjoljleoh qlwh vdpsoh eldv/ gxh wr wkh idfw wkdw wkh hvwlpdwhg dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv fdq eh vhyhuho| grzqzdug eldvhg lq vpdoo vdpsohv +vhh iru h{dpsoh Duhoodqr dqg Erqg +4<<4, lq wkh fdvh ri olqhdu sdqho gdwd prghov,1 Lq wklv vhfwlrq zh glvfxvv wzr dssurdfkhv wr uhphg| wklv sureohp1 Wkh uvw lv wr xvh d qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq wr wkh hvwlpdwhg dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh ri wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ dv sursrvhg e| Zlqgphlmhu +5333,1 Wkh vhfrqg lv wr xvh errwvwuds phwkrgv dv ghyhorshg iru JPP hvwlpdwlrq e| Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, dqg Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<,1

6141 D Ilqlwh Vdpsoh Fruuhfwlrq iru wkh Dv|pswrwlf Yduldqfh

Zlqgphlmhu +5333, sursrvhg d qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq wr wkh hvwlpdwhg dv|ps0 wrwlf yduldqfh ri wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru wkdw dffrxqwv iru wkh h{wud yduld0 wlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwru gxh wr wkh suhvhqfh ri hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv lq wkh h!flhqw zhljkw pdwul{/`

e

q

1 Wklv yduldwlrq lv qhjohfwhg lq wkh frqyhqwlrqdo dv|ps0 wrwlf yduldqfh h{suhvvlrq +516,/ exw kdv d qrq0qhjoljleoh hhfw rq wkh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwru lq vdpsoh vl}hv wkdw duh w|slfdoo| hqfrxqwhuhg lq sudfwlfh1 Df0 frxqwlqj iru wklv yduldwlrq |lhogv dq lpsuryhphqw lq wkh rughu ri wkh dv|pswrwlf dssur{lpdwlrq lq wkh fdvh ri olqhdu JPP hvwlpdwruv1

Lq sduwlfxodu/ wkh olqhdu wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru vdwlvhv

e q2qf ' _` e q 3_` e q }Eqfc

(9)

zklfk ghshqgv rq wkh rqh0vwhs hvwlpdwru qe yld wkh zhljkw pdwul{ ` e q 1 D Wd|oru vhulhv h{sdqvlrq riqe2qf durxqgqe 'qf uhvxowv lq

e q2qf ' EÈqf3Èqf}Eqf +614, CqfcÈqf e qqf nR 3 2c zkhuh Èqf ' # [ ' }Eqf}Eqf $3

dqg Cqfc`Eqf lv d&& pdwul{ zlwk lwv r0wk froxpq jlyhq e|

CqfcÈqfdc ro ' Y Yqr k E_` Eq3Èq}Eqf l mqf ' rEqfREqf2rEqfc zkhuh rEqf ' E` Eqf3` EqfY` 3 Eq Yqr mqfÈqf REqf ' E` Eqf3` Eqf}Eqf 2rEqf ' E` Eqf3` EqfY` 3 Eq Yqr mqfÈqf}Eqfc dqg Y`3 Eq Yqr ' [ ' # Y}Eq Yqr }Eq _n_} EqY}Eq Yqr $ Wkh whup CqfcÈqf e qqf lv ri rughu RE3/ dqg lqfrusrudwlqj lw lq

wkh hvwlpdwh ri wkh yduldqfh riqe2 zloo lpsuryh wkh dffxudf| ri wkh dssur{lpdwlrq

lq qlwh vdpsohv1 Wkh uvw whup ri Cqfc`Eqfdc ro/ rEqfREqf/ lv d ixqfwlrq

ri REqf zklfk lv wkh eldv ri dq lqihdvleoh JPP hvwlpdwru wkdw xvhv dq h!flhqw

zhljkw pdwul{ wkdw lv edvhg rq wkh wuxh sdudphwhuvqf1 Wklv eldv whqgv wr eh vpdoo

(10)

Vplwk +5333,1 Wkh vhfrqg whup/2rEqf/ zloo lq jhqhudo lqfuhdvh zlwk wkh qxpehu

ri prphqw frqglwlrqv dqg wkhuhiruh grplqdwh wkh eldv fruuhfwlrq1 Cqfc`Eqfdc ro

fdq wkxv eh hvwlpdwhg e|C_e_q₂_c`_E_e_q_dc ro zklfk lv jlyhq e| C_e_q₂_c`_E_e_q_dc ro '_` e q 3_` e q _Y`3 Eq Yqr mqe` e q }qe2

D ihdvleoh vpdoo vdpsoh eldv fruuhfwhg hvwlpdwh ri wkh yduldqfh ri qe2 lv wkhq re0

wdlqhg dv g @hS e q2 ' _` e q 3nC_q_e₂_c`_E_q_e@hgqe C e q2c`Eqe +615, C_q_e₂_c`_E_q_e_` e q 3n_` e q 3C e q2c`Eqe Wklv lv xvhg lq sodfh ri wkh frqyhqwlrqdo@hgqe2 wr frqvwuxfw wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0 vwhs Zdog vwdwlvwlf1 6151 Errwvwuds

Dv errwvwuds phwkrgv iru JPP duh qrw vwdqgdug zkhq wkh prgho lv ryhulghqwl0 hg/ ^ : &/ Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9,/ dqg Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<, kdyh ghyhorshg surfhgxuhv wr errwvwuds wkh glvwulexwlrq ri whvw vwdwlvwlfv/ olnh wkh Zdog whvw/ lq wkh JPP frqwh{w1 Wkhvh errwvwuds phwkrgv lpsuryh qlwh vdpsoh lqihu0 hqfh e| uhgxflqj wkh huuru lq wkh uhmhfwlrq suredelolw| ri wkh whvw vwdwlvwlf17 _Lq

sulqflsoh errwvwudsslqj fdq uhgxfh vl}h glvwruwlrqv lq wkh dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvwv wkdw duh gxh wr qlwh vdpsoh eldvhv lq wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv/ dv zhoo dv wkrvh wkdw duh gxh wr qlwh vdpsoh eldv lq wkh frqyhqwlrqdo dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh pdwul{1

Wkh Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, surfhgxuh vdpsohv wkh revhuydwlrqvEfzlwk uh0

sodfhphqw iurp wkh ruljlqdo vdpsoh1 Dv wkh prgho lv ryhulghqwlhg/ wkh srsxodwlrq

(11)

prphqw frqglwlrqv duh qrw h{dfwo| pdwfkhg e| wkh vdpsoh prphqw frqglwlrqv/ dqg wkh errwvwuds zloo qrw surylgh dv|pswrwlf uhqhphqwv iru wkh uhmhfwlrq sure0 delolwlhv ri wkh Zdog whvw1 E| uhfhqwhulqj wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv lq wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh/ wklv sureohp lv ryhufrph1 Ohw.K _{ghqrwh wkh h{shfwdwlrq uhodwlyh wr wkh}

glvwulexwlrq ri wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh frqglwlrqdo rq wkh ruljlqdo vdpsoh1 Wkhq

.K_}

KEq_f}

e

q' fc

zkhuh K _{ghqrwhv wkh lqgh{ lq wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh dqg/ dv ehiruh/} _}_qe _'

S '} e

q1 Wkh JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh plqlplvhv

[ K_' }KEq} e q` [ K_' }KEq} e qc

zlwkqe'qe iru wkh rqh0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh/ dqgqe'qe2

iru wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwru/ dqg wkh zhljkw pdwul{ vshflhg dffruglqjo|1

Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<, sursrvh lqvwhdg wr uhvdpsoh wkh gdwd zlwk zhljkwlqj wr hqvxuh wkdw wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv krog lq wkh zhljkwhg vdpsoh1 Wkhvh zhljkwv duh rewdlqhg iurp dq hpslulfdo olnholkrrg surfhgxuh xvlqj wkh hi0 flhqw JPP hvwlpdwru1 Frqvlghu wkh fulwhulrq ixqfwlrq wkdw fruuhvsrqgv wr wkh hpslulfdo olnholkrrg hvwlpdwru ghyhorshg lq Rzhq +4<;;,1 Wkh suredelolw| zhljkwv

Z vroyh 4?_Z [ ' *?Z vxemhfw wr [ '} e q2 Z ' f dqg [ 'Z ' c dqg duh hvwlpdwhg dv e Z ' ne_} e q2 ₃

zkhuh e duh wkh hvwlpdwhg wlowlqj sdudphwhuv1 Lqwxlwlyho| wkhvh phdvxuh krz pxfk wkh vdpsoh kdv wr eh uhzhljkwhg lq rughu iru wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv wr krog

(12)

h{dfwo|/ dqg duh hvwlpdwhg dv e '@h}4@ [ ' *? n_} e q2

Wkh errwvwuds vdpsoh lv wkhq gudzq zlwk uhsodfhphqw iurp wkh ruljlqdo vdpsoh/ jlylqj wkh lqglylgxdo revhuydwlrqv Ef wkh suredelolw|Ze ri ehlqj gudzq1

Xvlqj wkh uhfhqwhulqj phwkrg ri Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, ru wkh uhzhljkwlqj phwkrg ri Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<,/ zh rewdlq errwvwuds s0ydoxhv iru wkh Zdog whvw1 Iru h{dpsoh iru wkh vlpsoh whvw Mf G q ' B/ wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs

w0vwdwlvwlf lv jlyhq e|| ' e q2B *u@hgqe2

1 Iru hyhu| errwvwuds vdpsoh zh fdofxodwh/|K ' e qK 2qe2 *u@hgqeK 2 / zkhuhqeK 2 lv wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru

lq wkh K0wk errwvwuds vdpsoh1 Wkh shufhqwloh lq wkh errwvwuds glvwulexwlrq ri

m|m lv wkhq jlyhq e| R| ' K S_K K' m|K m:m|m

/ zkhuh wkh lqglfdwru ixqfwlrq

m|K

m:m|m

htxdovlim|K

m:m|m/frwkhuzlvh/ dqgK lv wkh qxpehu ri errwvwuds

uhsolfdwlrqv1 Wkh whvw uhmhfwv wkh qxoo dw vl}hk li R| k1

71 OP Whvw

Wkh OP whvw lv edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh prgho zklfk lpsrvhv wkh uhvwulfwlrqvoEqf ' f/ dqg fdq eh fdofxodwhg dv8 OP'}qh2 ` h q _` h q 3_` h q }qh2 c

zkhuhqh dqgqh2 duh wkh rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv lq wkh uhvwulfwhg

prgho1 Wkh OP whvw kdv dq dv|pswrwlf2

o glvwulexwlrq xqghu wkh qxoo1

Lw lv ixuwkhu htxlydohqw wr d Zdog whvw lq wkh xquhvwulfwhg prgho/ frqvwuxfwhg xvlqj d wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru zkhuh wkh uhvwulfwlrqv lpsrvhg e| wkh qxoo k|0

(13)

srwkhvlv duh h{sorlwhg wr uhgxfh wkh glphqvlrq ri wkh sdudphwhu yhfwru wkdw lv hvwlpdwhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh zhljkw pdwul{1 Vshflfdoo|

OP'oqe_h₂-_@h_g_q_e

h2

-3oqe_h₂c

zkhuhqe_h₂ lv d wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh xquhvwulfwhg prgho/ rewdlqhg xvlqj wkh hvwlpdwh ri[3_{lq wkh uhvwulfwhg prgho/}_` h q / dv wkh zhljkw pdwul{1 Jlyhq wklv uhodwlrqvkls/ rqh pljkw h{shfw wkh OP whvw wr ehkdyh olnh wkh vwdqgdug Zdog whvw/ hvshfldoo| zlwk dq lqfuhdvlqj qxpehu ri xquhvwulfwhg sdudphwhuv1 Krzhyhu/ lq rxu Prqwh Fduor vlpxodwlrqv/ wkh OP whvw grhv qrw vxhu iurp wkh srru qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv irxqg iru wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Zkhq frqvlghulqj vlpsoh whvwv ri wkh irup Mf G q ' B/ zh qg wkdw wkh vpdoo vdpsoh eldv ri

wkh dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuru ri qe_h₂ lv yhu| vpdoo lq d zlgh ydulhw| ri vhwwlqjv/ dowkrxjk wkh vwdqgdug huuruv ri wkh rwkhu sdudphwhuv wkdw zhuh xquhvwulfwhg xqghu wkh qxoo dqg wkxv hvwlpdwhg lq wkh zhljkw pdwul{`

h

q

glg kdyh wkh xvxdo vpdoo vdpsoh grzqzdug eldv1 Wklv kdsshqv zkhqCqfc`Eqf/ dv ghqhg lq vhfwlrq 614/ lv

+dssur{lpdwho|, d gldjrqdo pdwul{/ dv wkhq wkh vpdoo vdpsoh eldv ri wkh vwdqgdug huuru ri wkh sdudphwhu wr eh whvwhg zloo dxwrpdwlfdoo| eh fruuhfwhg e| lpsrvlqj wkh {hg ydoxh ri wklv sdudphwhu zkhq hvwlpdwlqj wkh rswlpdo zhljkw pdwul{ edvhg rq wkh uhvwulfwhg prgho1

81 Fulwhulrq0Edvhg Whvwv

Wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw fdq htxlydohqwo| eh frpsxwhg dv d fulwhulrq glhuhqfh +vhh Qhzh| dqg Zhvw +4<;:,, Zdog' }qh_e₂` e q }qh_e₂}qe2 ` e q }qe2 c

(14)

zkhuhqe dqgqe2duh wkh rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv lq wkh xquhvwulfwhg

prgho/ zkhuhdvqh_e₂ lv d wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh uhvwulfwhg prgho/ exw xvlqj dv d zhljkw pdwul{ wkh frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwh ri[3 _{edvhg rq wkh xquhvwulfwhg rqh0}

vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/` e q 1

Wkh OP whvw fdq dovr eh frpsxwhg dv d fulwhulrq glhuhqfh OP'}qh2 ` h q }qh2 }qe_h₂` h q }qe_h₂c

zkhuhqh dqgqh2 duh wkh rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv lq wkh uhvwulfwhg

prgho/ zkhuhdv qe_h₂ lv/ dv ehiruh/ d wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh xquhvwulfwhg prgho/ exw xvlqj dv d zhljkw pdwul{ wkh frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwh ri [3_{/ xqghu wkh}

qxoo/ edvhg rq wkh uhvwulfwhg rqh0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/`

h

q

1

Wkh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvw vwdwlvwlf frqvlghuhg e| Erqg/ Erzvkhu dqg Zlqgphl0 mhu +5334, lv jlyhq e| (-L ' }qh2 ` h q }qh2 }qe2 ` e q }qe2 ' aqh2 aqe2 Qrwlfh wkdw` h q dqg` e q

duh erwk frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwhv ri[3 _{xqghu wkh}

qxoo1 (-L lv wkh olnholkrrg udwlr whvw htxlydohqw iru JPP/ vhh h1j1 Gdylgvrq dqg

PdfNlqqrq +4<<6/ ss1 9470953,/ dqg lv vlpso| frpsxwhg dv wkh glhuhqfh ehwzhhq wkh Vdujdq vwdwlvwlfv lq wkh uhvwulfwhg dqg xquhvwulfwhg prghov19 _{Lqwxlwlyho|/ li}

wkh uhvwulfwlrqv duh ydolg/ wkhq lpsrvlqj wkhp vkrxog qrw glvwxue wkh ydolglw| ri wkh ryhulghqwli|lqj uhvwulfwlrqv1 Xqghu wkh qxoo/ (-L kdv dq dv|pswrwlf 2o

glvwulexwlrq1:

9_{Hyhu|zkhuh/ wkh lqvwuxphqw pdwul{ ] lv nhsw wkh vdph lq uhvwulfwhg dqg xquhvwulfwhg prghov1} :_{Wkh G}

UX vwdwlvwlf kdv uhfhqwo| ehhq frqvlghuhg e| Kdqvhq +5333, lq wkh frqwh{w ri whvwlqj

qrq0olqhdu uhvwulfwlrqv lq wkh fodvvlfdo olqhdu uhjuhvvlrq prgho1 Kh vkrzv yld Hgjhzruwk h{sdq0 vlrqv wkdw wkh dv|pswrwlf fkl0vtxduhg glvwulexwlrq surylghv d ehwwhu dssur{lpdwlrq iru wkh GUX

(15)

Kdqvhq/ Khdwrq dqg \durq +4<<9, sursrvhg wkh xvh ri d fulwhulrq0edvhg whvw vlplodu wr (-L/ exw edvhg rq wkhlu frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP hvwlpdwru1 Wklv

hvwlpdwru lv htxlydohqw wr urexvw OLPO dqg lv ghqhg dv wkh ydoxh riq/ ghqrwhg

e qL_{/ wkdw plqlpl}hv} aL_E_q_'_}_E_q # [ '}Eq}Eq $3 }Eq Wkh whvw vwdwlvwlf(L -L lv wkhq ghqhg dv (L -L ' aL_q_hL_aL_q_eL_c

zkhuhqeL _dqg _qhL _{duh wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP hvwlpdwruv iru wkh xquh0}

vwulfwhg prgho dqg wkh uhvwulfwhg prgho uhvshfwlyho|1 Xqghu wkh qxoo/(L

-L kdv dq

dv|pswrwlf2

o glvwulexwlrq1

Wkh whvw sursrvhg e| Lpehqv/ Vsdg| dqg Mrkqvrq +4<<;, lv edvhg rq wkh hpslulfdo olnholkrrg phwkrg1 Wkh h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj hvwlpdwru iru qf plqlplvhv

wkh Nxooedfn0Ohleohu lqirupdwlrq fulwhulrq

4? Zcq [ ' Z*?Z vxemhfw wr [ ' }EqZ ' f dqg [ ' Z '

Wkh hvwlpdwhg suredelolwlhv duh ri wkh irup

ZElc q ' i T El _}

Eq

S

'i T El}Eq

zkhuh l duh wkh wlowlqj sdudphwhuv1 Djdlq/ wkhvh phdvxuh krz pxfk wkh vdpsoh kdv wr eh uhzhljkwhg lq rughu iru wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv wr krog h{dfwo|1;

Wlowlqj sdudphwhuv fdq eh hvwlpdwhg frqglwlrqdo rq wkh vwdqgdug JPP hvwl0 pdwru ri wkh sdudphwhuvq1 Wkh Odjudqjh Pxowlsolhu whvw vwdwlvwlf

a.A _lc_e _q_e 2 'le e lcqe2 e l

;_{Qrwh wkdw wkhvh hvwlpdwhg suredelolwlhv fdq dovr eh xvhg wr uhzhljkw wkh gdwd lq wkh errwvwuds}

(16)

lv d whvw iru zkhwkhu wkh wlowlqj sdudphwhuv/ ru Odjudqjh pxowlsolhuv/ duh htxdo wr }hur/ zkhuh e l '4@ l *? [ ' i Tl_} e q2 c dqg - e lcqe2 ' % [ '} e q2 } e q2 Z e lcqe2 & % [ '} e q2 } e q2 Z2 e lcqe2 &3 % [ ' } e q2 } e q2 Z e lcqe2 & lv d urexvw hvwlpdwh ri wkh yduldqfh ri wkh prphqwv1 a.A _lce _qe₂_{kdv dq dv|ps0} wrwlf2

^3& glvwulexwlrq zkhq wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv duh ydolg1 Wkh fruuhvsrqglqj

fulwhulrq0edvhg whvw iru whvwlqj wkh k|srwkhvlvMf GoEqf ' f lv ghqhg dv (.A -L ' h l h lcqh2 h lle e lcqe2 e l ' a.A _lch _qh₂_a.A _lce _qe₂_c

zkhuhlhlv wkh hvwlpdwru ri wkh wlowlqj sdudphwhuv edvhg rq wkh h!flhqw wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh uhvwulfwhg prgho1 Xqghu wkh qxoo/(.A

-L kdv dq dv|pswrwlf

2

o glvwulexwlrq1

91 Uhodwhg Olwhudwxuh

Wkh qlwh vdpsoh ehkdylrxu ri vrph ri wkh whvw surfhgxuhv ghvfulehg lq wkh suh0 fhglqj vhfwlrqv kdv ehhq dqdo|vhg lq glhuhqw vhwwlqjv e| ydulrxv dxwkruv1 Zlqg0 phlmhu +5333, suhvhqwv Prqwh Fduor uhvxowv iru d vlpsoh olqhdu sdqho gdwd prgho lqglfdwlqj wkdw wkh qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq iru wkh yduldqfh ri wkh olqhdu wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru zrunv zhoo lq wkdw frqwh{w/ ohdglqj wr pxfk pruh dffxudwh lq0 ihuhqfh wkdq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, gr qrw

(17)

frqvlghu sdqho gdwd prghov/ exw vkrz wkh lpsuryhphqw ri wkhlu errwvwuds surfh0 gxuh dv frpsduhg wr wkh xvxdo dv|pswrwlf lqihuhqfh iru ydulrxv qrq0olqhdu JPP hvwlpdwruv1 Eurzq/ Qhzh| dqg Pd| +4<<<, gr frqvlghu sdqho gdwd prghov dqg dovr vkrz wkdw wkhlu errwvwuds phwkrg lpsuryhv wkh qlwh vdpsoh shuirupdqfh ri wkh Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru1 Ehujvwuùp +4<<:,/ dqg Ehujvwuùp/ Gdkoehuj dqg Mrkdqvvrq +4<<:, dqdo|vh wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh wzr errwvwuds surfhgxuhv iru uvw0glhuhqfhg JPP hvwlpdwruv lq olqhdu dxwruhjuhv0 vlyh sdqho gdwd prghov/ dqg vkrz wkdw erwk phwkrgv lpsuryh rq wkh vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf lqihuhqfh iru wzr0vwhs JPP1 Wkhvh sdshuv gr qrw frqvlghu wkh fdvh ri prghov zlwk zhdn lqvwuxphqwv/ ru dgglwlrqdo prphqw frqglwlrqv wkdw duh dydlodeoh iru htxdwlrqv lq ohyhov xqghu lqlwldo frqglwlrqv uhvwulfwlrqv1

Kdqvhq/ Khdwrq dqg \durq +4<<9, frqvlghu wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh fulwhulrq0 edvhg whvw edvhg rq wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP hvwlpdwru/(L

-L/ lq wkh frq0

wh{w ri qrq0olqhdu Hxohu htxdwlrqv dqg vkrz wkdw wklv whvw kdv vxshulru qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv dv frpsduhg wr wkh vwdqgdug Zdog whvwv edvhg rq wzr0vwhs ru frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP hvwlpdwruv1 Lpehqv/ Vsdg| dqg Mrkqvrq +4<<;, ir0 fxv sulpdulo| rq wkhlu whvw ri ryhulghqwli|lqj uhvwulfwlrqv/a.A_{/ dqg rqo| eulh |}

frqvlghu wkh shuirupdqfh ri(.A

-L iru vrph vshflf qrq0olqhdu prghov1 Djdlq/(-L.A

rxwshuirupv wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Erqg/ Erzvkhu dqg Zlqgphlmhu +5334, vwxg| wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv iru olqhdu dxwruh0 juhvvlyh sdqho gdwd prghov dqg frqfoxgh wkdw wkhvh whvwv kdyh txlwh jrrg qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv lq wklv frqwh{w dqg doo wkuhh ehkdyh yhu| vlploduo| lq wkh prghov wkh| frqvlghu1 Wkh(-L whvw wkhq kdv wkh dgydqwdjh ri ehlqj h{wuhpho| vlpsoh wr

(18)

vwxglhg lq wkh JPP frqwh{w1

Lq wkh iroorzlqj vhfwlrqv/ zh suhvhqw d v|vwhpdwlf frpsdulvrq ri wkh qlwh vdpsoh shuirupdqfh ri wkhvh ydulrxv whvw surfhgxuhv iru d udqjh ri g|qdplf sdqho gdwd prghov1

:1 G|qdplf Surfhvvhv zlwk Lqglylgxdo Hhfwv

Zh uvw frqvlghu wkh olqhdu uvw rughu dxwruhjuhvvlyh sdqho gdwd prgho zlwk lqgl0 ylgxdo hhfwv +#,

+| ' kf+|3n|

| ' #n|

zkhuh' c c dqg| ' 2c c A/ zlwk odujh dqg A {hg1 Xqghu wkh vwdqgdug dvvxpswlrqv

.E# ' fc .E| ' fc .E|# ' f iru' c c dqg | ' 2c c A +:14,

.E|r ' f iru ' c c dqg ;|9'r +:15,

dqg

.E+| ' f iru ' c c dqg |' 2c A/ +:16,

wkh iroorzlqjEA EA 2*2olqhdu prphqw frqglwlrqv duh ydolg

.k+|32 E{+|kf{+|3 l ' f iru |' c c Ac +:17, zkhuh +|32 ' d+c +2c c +|32o> vhh iru h{dpsoh Dkq dqg Vfkplgw +4<<8,1 Zh

fdoo wkhvh prphqw frqglwlrqv wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv/ fi1 Duhoodqr dqg Erqg +4<<4,1 Xqghu wkh dgglwlrqdo phdq vwdwlrqdulw| dvvxpswlrq rq lqlwldo frqglwlrqv

(19)

wkh dgglwlrqdo EA 2 olqhdu prphqw frqglwlrqv

.d{+|3E+|kf+|3o ' f iru |' c c A +:19,

duh ydolg1 Wkh mrlqw prphqw frqglwlrqv +:17, dqg +:19, duh wkh vr0fdoohg V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv/ fi1 Duhoodqr dqg Eryhu +4<<8, dqg Eoxqghoo dqg Erqg +4<<;,1 Ohw ~ eh wkh pdwul{ ri lqvwuxphqwv iru revhuydwlrq / wkhq wkh prphqw

frqglwlrqv fdq jhqhulfdoo| eh zulwwhq dv .d~

/Ekfo ' f1 Wkh h!flhqw rqh0

vwhs JPP zhljkw pdwul{ iru wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv zkhq wkh | duh kr0

prvfhgdvwlf dqg qrw vhuldoo| fruuhodwhg lv jlyhq e| ` '

S '~M~ ₃ / zkhuh M lv d EA 2 vtxduh pdwul{ zklfk kdv 5*v rq wkh pdlq gldjrqdo/ 04*v rq wkh uvw vxegldjrqdov dqg }hurv hovhzkhuh1 Iru wkh V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv wkhuh lv qr vlpsoh rqh0vwhs h!flhqw zhljkw pdwul{/ dqg lq rxu vlpxodwlrqv wkh rqh0vwhs zhljkw pdwul{ lv vhw htxdo wr ` ' S '~~ ₃ 1 Wkh h!flhqw wzr0vwhs zhljkw pdwul{ iru erwk hvwlpdwruv xqghu jhqhudo frqglwlrqv lv jlyhq e|

`Eke ' S '~/Eke/Eke~ ₃ / zlwkke wkh frqvlvwhqw rqh0vwhs JPP GLI ru V\V hvwlpdwru ri k1

Zh dovr suhvhqw vlpxodwlrq uhvxowv iru d pxowlyduldwh g|qdplf sdqho gdwd prgho vshflhg dv

+| ' kf+|3nqf%|n#n|

%| ' 4f%|3nf#n|

| ' wf|3n0|

Wkh %| vhulhv duh fruuhodwhg zlwk # dqg suhghwhuplqhg exw qrw vwulfwo| h{rjh0

(20)

EEA EA 2*2 n EA EA *2prphqw frqglwlrqv .k+|32 E{+|kf{+|3qf{%| l ' f iru |' c c A .k%|3 E{+|kf{+|3qf{%| l ' f iru |' c c Ac zkhuh%|3 ' d%c %2c c %|3o1 Wkh dgglwlrqdo EA 2 n EA prphqw frqgl0

wlrqv xvhg e| wkh V\V hvwlpdwru duh jlyhq e|

.d{+|3E+|kf+|3qf%|o ' firu | ' c c A

.d{%|E+|kf+|3qf%|o ' firu | ' 2c c A

;1 Prqwh Fduor Uhvxowv

;141 Edvlf uhvxowv

Lq Wdeoh 4 dqg Iljxuh 4 zh suhvhqw vrph edvlf Prqwh Fduor uhvxowv iru wkh-E

sdqho gdwd surfhvv1 Wkh fryduldqfh vwdwlrqdu| gdwd jhqhudwlqj surfhvv lv

+| ' kf+|3n#n| # Efc ( |Efc + ' #_k f n0 ( 0 # fc_k₂ f $ Wkh dgglwlrqdo prphqw frqglwlrqv +:19, duh vdwlvhg lq wklv ghvljq/ dqg zh frq0 vlghu lqihuhqfh edvhg rq erwk wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv dorqh/ dqg rq wkh frp0 elqhg V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv1< _{Wkh lqlwldo frqglwlrqv dqg huuru frpsrqhqwv duh}

doo qrupdoo| glvwulexwhg1 Wkh vdpsoh vl}h lv ' ff/ A ' S/ dqg zh uhsruw uhvxowv edvhg rq fcfff uhsolfdwlrqv1 Wkh ydoxh frqvlghuhg iru kf lv fe/ zklfk

<_{Dgglwlrqdo olqhdu prphqw frqglwlrqv wkdw ghshqg rq erwk krprvfhgdvwlflw| dqg fryduldqfh}

vwdwlrqdulw| duh dovr dydlodeoh lq wkh ghvljq xvhg khuh> vhh/ iru h{dpsoh/ Dkq dqg Vfkplgw +4<<8, dqg Nuxlqljhu +5333,1 Zh gr qrw frqvlghu lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkhvh hvwlpdwruv/ dv wkh| duh ohvv frpprqo| xvhg lq dssolhg zrun1

(21)

lv zhoo ehorz wkh udqjh zkhuh sureohpv dvvrfldwhg zlwk zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq duh h{shfwhg wr eh vhulrxv1 Zh frqvlghu whvwv ri wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlvMf Gkf ' fe

Wdeoh 4 suhvhqwv wkh hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv iru erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs yhuvlrqv ri wkh V\V dqg GLI hvwlpdwruv/ dqg Iljxuh 4 suhvhqwv s0ydoxh sorwv wr frpsduh wkh dfwxdo dqg qrplqdo vl}h surshuwlhv ri wkh ydulrxv whvw vwdwlvwlfv> vhh Gdylgvrq dqg PdfNlqqrq +4<<9,1 Iljxuh 4d vkrzv wkh uhvxowv iru wkh ydulrxv Zdog vwdwlvwlfv edvhg rq wkh V\V hvwlpdwru= wkh vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh rqh0 vwhs JPP uhvxowv/`> wkh vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs

JPP uhvxowv/`2> wkh Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwru xvlqj wkh qlwh

vdpsoh fruuhfwhg hvwlpdwh ri wkh yduldqfh pdwul{/`2> wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs

Zdog whvw xvlqj wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} phwkrg/`MM> dqg wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs

Zdog whvwv/`2MM dqg `2/ xvlqj wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} dqg Eurzq0Qhzh|0Pd|

phwkrgv uhvshfwlyho|1 Wkh qxpehu ri errwvwuds uhsolfdwlrqv/K/ lv htxdo wr 8331

Iljxuh 4e vkrzv wkh fruuhvsrqglqj uhvxowv iru wkh OP whvw/u/ dqg iru wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvwv/ (-L/ (-LL dqg (.A-L/ edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs

JPP fulwhulrq/ wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP fulwhulrq dqg wkh h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj fulwhulrq uhvshfwlyho|1 Uhvxowv iru wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ `/

duh uhsurgxfhg khuh wr idflolwdwh frpsdulvrqv1 Iljxuhv 4f dqg 4g wkhq vkrz wkh s0ydoxh sorwv iru wkh vdph vhwv ri whvw vwdwlvwlfv edvhg rq wkh uhvxowv iru wkh GLI hvwlpdwru1

(22)

Wdeoh 41 Hvwlpdwlrq Uhvxowv iru-EPrgho/ ' ff/ A ' S

V\V GLI

rqh0vwhs wzr0vwhs rqh0vwhs wzr0vwhs frh vw ghy frh vw ghy frh vw ghy frh vw ghy

upvh vw huu upvh vw huu upvh vw huu upvh vw huu

kf vw huuf vw huuf

317 316;< 313<9 31736 313;4 31697 3143; 31699 3144;

313<: 313<7 313;4 3138; 31447 31439 31455 313<9

313:< 31449

Uhvxowv duh edvhg rq 43/333 uhsolfdwlrqv

vw huu lv wkh phdq ri wkh hvwlpdwhg dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv

vw huuf lv wkh phdq ri wkh hvwlpdwhg vwdqgdug huuruv fruuhfwhg iru vpdoo vdpsoh eldv Wdeoh 4 vkrzv wkdw zlwk ' ffc A ' S dqg kf ' fe wkhuh lv doprvw qr

eldv irxqg iru wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru xvlqj wkh V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Wkhuh lv d vpdoo grzqzdug eldv/ durxqg 6( ri wkh wuxh ydoxh ri kf/ irxqg iru

wkh rqh0vwhs yhuvlrq/ zklfk dovr kdv d vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq durxqg 4<( kljkhu wkdq wkh dv|pswrwlfdoo| h!flhqw hvwlpdwru edvhg rq wkh vdph prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Krzhyhu zklovw wkh qlwh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri wkh rqh0vwhs hvwlpdwru lv zhoo hvwlpdwhg e| wkh phdq ri lwv xvxdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv/ wklv lv qrw wkh fdvh iru wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwru/ zkhuh wkh phdq ri wkh xqfruuhfwhg dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv kdv d grzqzdug eldv ri durxqg 5;(1 Wkh qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq glvfxvvhg lq Vhfwlrq 614 yluwxdoo| holplqdwhv wklv eldv1 Wkh sdwwhuq ri uhvxowv iru wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv xvlqj rqo| wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv lv eurdgo| vlplodu1 Wkhvh hvwlpdwruv kdyh d grzqzdug eldv durxqg <( ri wkh wuxh ydoxh rikf/ dqg d

vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq durxqg 73( kljkhu wkdq wkh wzr0vwhs V\V hvwlpdwru1 Djdlq wkh fruuhfwhg vwdqgdug huuru surylghv d pxfk pruh dffxudwh jxlgh wr wkh qlwh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri wkh wzr0vwhs yhuvlrq wkdq grhv wkh xvxdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuru/ dowkrxjk wkh grzqzdug eldv lq wkh odwwhu/ durxqg 4<(/ lv vpdoohu

(23)

khuh wkdq iru wkh V\V hvwlpdwru/ zklfk lv edvhg rq pruh prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Rqh ixuwkhu ihdwxuh ri wkhvh uhvxowv lv wkdw wkh rqh0vwhs JPP GLI hvwlpdwru/ zklfk xvhv dq rswlpdo zhljkw pdwul{ lq wklv vlpxodwlrq ghvljq/ kdv d qlwh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq zklfk lv durxqg ;( vpdoohu wkdq wkh dv|pswrwlfdoo| htxlydohqw wzr0vwhs yhuvlrq1

Iljxuh 4d frqupv wkdw lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw frxog eh yhu| plvohdglqj lq wklv frqwh{w1 Dw d qrplqdo vl}h ri 8(/ iru h{dpsoh/ wklv whvw idovho| uhmhfwv wkh fruuhfw qxoo k|srwkhvlv wkdw kf ' fe lq durxqg 4:(

ri wkh uhsolfdwlrqv1 Lq frqwudvw/ ghvslwh wkh juhdwhu eldv ri wkh rqh0vwhs JPP V\V hvwlpdwru/ lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lv pxfk pruh uholdeoh/ zlwk d uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqf| ri durxqg 9( dw wkh 8( qrplqdo vl}h1 Wklv sdwwhuq lv w|slfdo ri d zlgh udqjh ri h{shulphqwv wkdw zh kdyh frqvlghuhg/ d vhohfwlrq ri zklfk duh uhsruwhg ehorz1 Wkh srru shuirupdqfh ri wkh frqyhqwlrqdo wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw khuh lv sulqflsdoo| gxh wr wkh grzqzdug eldv lq wkh xvxdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv/ zklfk gr qrw dffrxqw iru wkh hvwlpdwlrq ri sdudphwhuv xvhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh rswlpdo wzr0vwhs zhljkw pdwul{1 Zh kdyh vhhq lq Wdeoh 4 wkdw wkhuh lv doprvw qr eldv lq wkh phdq ri wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwhv lq wklv h{shulphqw/ dqg Iljxuh 7d ehorz frqupv wkdw wkh qlwh vdpsoh glvwulexwlrq ri wklv hvwlpdwru khuh lv v|pphwulf dqg dssur{lpdwho| qrupdo1 Frqvhtxhqwo| zh zrxog h{shfw wkdw xvlqj wkh fruuhfwhg hvwlpdwhv ri wkh vwdqgdug huuruv wr frqvwuxfw d Zdog vwdwlvwlf edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru vkrxog surgxfh d frqvlghudeoh lpsuryhphqw lq wkh vl}h surshuwlhv ri wkh whvw/ dqg wklv lv lqghhg zkdw zh qg lq wkh uhvxowv ri wklv h{shulphqw1 Wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog vwdwlvwlf +`2, kdv uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv wkdw duh yhu| forvh wr wkrvh ri wkh vwdqgdug

(24)

rqh0vwhs Zdog vwdwlvwlf +`,1 Djdlq wklv sdwwhuq lv w|slfdo ri d zlgh udqjh ri

h{shulphqwv lq zklfk zh irxqg wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw wr kdyh vl}h surshuwlhv vlplodu wr/ ru pdujlqdoo| ehwwhu wkdq/ wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1

Ilj 4d1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=7/ V\V/ W @ 9 Ilj 4e1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f@ 3=7/ V\V/ W @ 9

(25)

Wxuqlqj wr wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh Zdog whvwv/ Iljxuh 4d vkrzv wkdw wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} surfhgxuh +`MM, grhv h{wuhpho| zhoo lq fruuhfwlqj wkh vpdoo

vl}h glvwruwlrq irxqg iru wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv h{shulphqw1 Qhl0 wkhu wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} qru wkh Eurzq0Qhzh|0Pd| surfhgxuhv duh vr vxffhvvixo iru wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zlwk erwk wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv whqglqj wr uhmhfw wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv wrr lqiuhtxhqwo| uhodwlyh wr wkhlu qrplqdo vl}h1 Wklv sdwwhuq zdv djdlq frpprq lq wkh h{shulphqwv zh frqvlghuhg/ dqg vrph fdvhv lq zklfk wkh srru shuirupdqfh ri wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv ehfrphv pruh h{wuhph zloo eh looxvwudwhg lq odwhu vhfwlrqv1

Iljxuh 4e vkrzv wkdw wkh OP whvw dovr shuirupv zhoo lq whupv ri vl}h lq wklv h{shulphqw1 Zh irxqg wklv wr eh wkh fdvh lq doo h{shulphqwv zkhuh wkh sdudph0 whu ri lqwhuhvw lv zhoo lghqwlhg> wkh h{fhswlrq ehlqj wkh czhdn lqvwuxphqwv* fdvh frqvlghuhg lq Vhfwlrq ;1415 ehorz1 Wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv duh dovr irxqg wr kdyh txlwh jrrg vl}h surshuwlhv lq wklv h{shulphqw/ zlwk uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv ri durxqg 9( dw wkh 8( qrplqdo vl}h1

Wkh uhvxowv glvfxvvhg deryh/ edvhg rq wkh v|vwhp JPP hvwlpdwru zklfk kdv olwwoh eldv lq wklv ghvljq/ kdyh whqghg wr eh uhodwlyho| idyrxudeoh wr wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Zh pljkw h{shfw wkh errwvwudsshg/ OP ru fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv wr rhu pruh lpsuryhphqw lq vhwwlqjv zkhuh wkhuh lv pruh eldv suhvhqw lq wkh xqghuo|lqj JPP hvwlpdwru1 Iljxuhv 4f dqg 4g looxvwudwh wklv e| frqvlghulqj wkh vdph whvw vwdwlvwlfv edvhg rq wkh uvw0glhuhqfhg JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkh vdph h{shulphqw1 Dv zh vdz lq Wdeoh 4/ wklv hvwlpdwru grhv kdyh d odujhu qlwh vdpsoh eldv lq wklv frqwh{w1 Djdlq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw kdv d pxfk juhdwhu vl}h glvwruwlrq wkdq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Lq wklv fdvh/ wkrxjk/ zh qg

(26)

wkdw wkhuh lv d vpdoo lpsuryhphqw rhuhg e| wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ dqg d frqvlghudeoh lpsuryhphqw rhuhg e| hlwkhu wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw/ ru wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv/ frpsduhg wr wkh vl}h shuirupdqfh ri wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Lq wklv h{shulphqw wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv dovr kdyh uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv wkdw duh yhu| forvh wr wkh qrplqdo vl}h/ dowkrxjk zh zrxog fdxwlrq wkdw wklv uhvxow zdv qrw w|slfdo ri rxu qglqjv iru wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv1

;14141 Yduldwlrqv= A ' H dqg qrq0qrupdo huuruv

Wdeoh 5 dqg Iljxuh 5 suhvhqw wkh qglqjv iru wzr ixuwkhu h{shulphqwv zkhuh lqwhu0 hvwlqj uhvxowv zhuh rewdlqhg1 Wkh uvw ri wkhvh frqvlghuv wkh hhfw ri lqfuhdvlqj wkh wlph glphqvlrq ri wkh sdqho iurp A ' S wr A ' H/ nhhslqj ' ff dqg

kf ' fe1 Qrwlqj wkdw wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv lqfuhdvhv dw wkh udwh

A2_{/ wklv dssur{lpdwho| grxeohv wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg e| wkh}

V\V hvwlpdwru iurp 47 wr 5:/ zklovw kroglqj frqvwdqw wkh furvv0vhfwlrq glphqvlrq ri wkh sdqho rq zklfk wkh odujh / {hg A dv|pswrwlf dssur{lpdwlrqv ghshqg1 Wkh vhfrqg yduldwlrq pdlqwdlqv wkh ' ffc A ' Sc kf ' fe frpelqdwlrq xvhg

lq wkh suhylrxv vhfwlrq/ exw lqwurgxfhv qrq0qrupdo glvwxuedqfhv lqwr wkh -E

surfhvv1 Lq sduwlfxodu zh khuh gudz wkh wlph0ydu|lqj huuruv +|, iurp d vnhzhg 2

glvwulexwlrq/ fhqwhuhg wr kdyh phdq }hur dqg vfdohg wr kdyh yduldqfh rqh1 Wkdw lv/ zh uhsodfh wkh vwdqgdug qrupdo udqgrp yduldeoh e|

| 2 *s2

Rwkhuzlvh lq erwk fdvhv wkh ghvljq lv lghqwlfdo wr wkdw ghvfulehg suhylrxvo|1 Wr frqvhuyh vsdfh zh irfxv khuh rq wkh uhvxowv iru wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv edvhg

(27)

rq wkh frpelqhg vhw ri V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Frpsdulqj Wdeohv 4 dqg 5/ zh vhh wkdw dgglqj wzr dgglwlrqdo |hduv ri gdwd wr wkh sdqho uhgxfhv wkh qlwh vdp0 soh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrq ri erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs V\V hvwlpdwruv e| durxqg 55(/ dowkrxjk wkhuh lv qrz pruh qlwh vdpsoh eldv/ sduwlfxoduo| iru wkh rqh0vwhs hvwlpdwru1 Wkh grzqzdug eldv lq wkh frqyhqwlrqdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv iru wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwru lqfuhdvhv wr durxqg 73(/ dowkrxjk erwk wkh frqyhqwlrqdo rqh0vwhs dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv dqg wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs vwdqgdug huuruv frqwlqxh wr surylgh uholdeoh hvwlpdwhv ri wkh qlwh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrqv iru wkh uhvshfwlyh hvwlpdwruv1

Wdeoh 51 Hvwlpdwlrq Uhvxowv iru DU+4, Prgho/ ' ff

V\V

A ' H A ' S/ 2 huuruv

kf vw huuf vw huuf

317 316:7 313:9 316<4 31396 316;: 313<6 31733 313:8

313:; 313:7 31395 3136: 313<7 313;: 313:8 31376

31394 313:4

vw huuf lv wkh hvwlpdwhg vwdqgdug huuru fruuhfwhg iru vpdoo vdpsoh eldv

vw huuf lv wkh phdq ri wkh hvwlpdwhg vwdqgdug huuruv fruuhfwhg iru vpdoo vdpsoh eldv Iljxuh 5d vkrzv wkdw wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw lpsuryhv rq wkh vl}h shuirupdqfh ri wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv h{shulphqw/ dqg wkh Kdoo0 Krurzlw} yhuvlrq ri wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw grhv h{wuhpho| zhoo djdlq khuh1 Krzhyhu wkh vwulnlqj ihdwxuh ri wkhvh uhvxowv lv wkh vl}h glvwruwlrq irxqg iru wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zkhuh zh rewdlq uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv ri durxqg 4( dw wkh 8( qrplqdo vl}h1 Iljxuh 5e vkrzv wkdw

(28)

wkh OP whvw djdlq lpsuryhv rq wkh vl}h shuirupdqfh ri wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Wkh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvwv edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug JPP dqg frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP fulwhuld djdlq shuirup txlwh zhoo/43 _{dowkrxjk wkdw edvhg rq wkh}

h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj fulwhulrq lv irxqg wr eh pruh vhqvlwlyh wr wkh lqfuhdvh lq wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg1

Ilj 5d1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=7/ V\V/ W @ ; Ilj 5e1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=7/ V\V/ W @ ;

Ilj 5f1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=7/ V\V/ "2/ W @ 9 Ilj 5g1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f@ 3=7/ V\V/ "2/ W @ 9

43_{Dv zdv wkh fdvh zlwk W @ 9 lq wkh suhylrxv vhfwlrq/ wkhvh wzr fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvwv zhuh}

irxqg wr kdyh ehwwhu vl}h surshuwlhv wkdq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw iru uhvxowv edvhg rq wkh GLI JPP hvwlpdwru dw W @ ;1

(29)

Wkh lqwurgxfwlrq ri vnhzhg/ qrq0qrupdo huuruv dovr uhvxowv lq d pruh sur0 qrxqfhg grzqzdug eldv lq wkh dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv iru wkh wzr0vwhs hvwl0 pdwru1 Djdlq wkh rqh0vwhs dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv dqg wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs vwdqgdug huuruv shuirup zhoo1 Iljxuh 5f vkrzv d vlplodu sdwwhuq wr wkdw irxqg lq Iljxuh 5d/ zlwk wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw shuiruplqj zhoo/ exw zlwk wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv xqghu0uhmhfwlqj uhodwlyh wr wkhlu qrplqdo vl}h1 Iljxuh 5g vkrzv wkdw wkh OP whvw rhuv d frqvlghudeoh lpsuryhphqw rq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv fdvh1 Wkh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv duh dovr irxqg wr eh txlwh urexvw wr wklv irup ri qrq0qrupdolw|/ zlwk wkh vlpsoh whvw edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug JPP fulwhulrq kdylqj uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv vlplodu wr wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw dw frqyhqwlrqdo ohyhov ri vljqlfdqfh1

;14151 Zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq= kf ' fH

Wdeoh 6 dqg Iljxuh 6 frqvlghu wkh uholdelolw| ri wkhvh whvw surfhgxuhv lq d fdvh zkhuh wkh lghqwlfdwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhu ri lqwhuhvw ehfrphv zhdn1 Vshflfdoo| zh frqvlghu wkh fryduldqfh vwdwlrqdu|-E surfhvv dv ghvfulehg suhylrxvo|/ zlwk

' ff dqg A ' S dqg qrupdoo| glvwulexwhg huuru frpsrqhqwv/ exw zh qrz lqfuhdvh wkh wuxh ydoxh ri wkh sdudphwhu kf wr 31;1 Wklv lv lq wkh uhjlrq zkhuh

Eoxqghoo dqg Erqg +4<<;, uhsruwhg yhu| srru qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv iru wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv edvhg rq wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv/ hvvhqwldoo| ehfdxvh odjjhg ohyhov ri wkh vhulhv surylgh yhu| zhdn lqvwuxphqwv iru vxevhtxhqw uvw0glhuhqfhv dv wkh-E surfhvv dssurdfkhv wkh udqgrp zdon +k' , fdvh1

Wdeoh 6 frqupv wkh vhulrxv grzqzdug eldv dqg lpsuhflvlrq suhylrxvo| uh0 sruwhg iru wkh GLI JPP hvwlpdwruv lq wklv frqwh{w1 Dv vwuhvvhg e| Eoxqghoo dqg Erqg +4<<;,/ wkh V\V JPP hvwlpdwruv kdyh frpsdudwlyho| vpdoo qlwh vdpsoh

(30)

eldvhv/ durxqg 5( ri wkh wuxh ydoxh ri wkh sdudphwhu/ dqg pxfk juhdwhu suhflvlrq1 Ri pruh lqwhuhvw khuh/ zh qg wkdw erwk wkh frqyhqwlrqdo dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug hu0 uruv iru wkh rqh0vwhs hvwlpdwruv/ dqg wkh fruuhfwhg vwdqgdug huuruv iru wkh wzr0vwhs hvwlpdwruv/ frqwlqxh wr surylgh yluwxdoo| xqeldvhg hvwlpdwhv ri wkh uhvshfwlyh qlwh vdpsoh vwdqgdug ghyldwlrqv/ iru erwk wkh V\V dqg wkh GLI prphqw frqglwlrqv1

Wdeoh 61 Hvwlpdwlrq Uhvxowv iru-EPrgho/ ' ff/ A ' S

V\V GLI

kf vw huuf vw huuf

31; 31;4< 31433 31;4; 313<9 318:< 3156: 31886 315:<

31435 313<: 313<; 31386 31657 3155; 316:6 31538

313<7 315:5

vw huuf lv wkh phdq ri wkh hvwlpdwhg vwdqgdug huuruv fruuhfwhg iru vpdoo vdpsoh eldv Qrw vxusulvlqjo|/ erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv edvhg rq wkh vhul0 rxvo| eldvhg GLI hvwlpdwruv surylgh xquholdeoh lqihuhqfh/ dv vhhq lq Iljxuh 6f1 Wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw xvlqj wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} surfhgxuh surylghv olwwoh lpsuryhphqw khuh> dqg wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv dovr uhpdlq frqvlghudeo| ryhu0vl}hg1 Iljxuh 6g vkrzv wkdw wkh OP whvw dovr rhuv rqo| d vpdoo lpsuryhphqw ryhu wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv h{shulphqw> olnh wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw vhhpv wr eh vxemhfw wr d vhulrxv vl}h glvwruwlrq zkhq wkh sdudphwhu ri lqwhuhvw lv rqo| zhdno| lghqwlhg1 Wzr ri wkh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv duh irxqg wr kdyh frpsdudwlyho| vpdoo vl}h glvwruwlrqv khuh1 Krzhyhu zh vkrxog qrwh wkdw wklv lv olnho| wr eh ri vrphzkdw olplwhg xvh

(31)

iru dssolhg uhvhdufk> dv wkh sdudphwhu ri lqwhuhvw lv hvwlpdwhg vr lpsuhflvho| xvlqj wkhvh prphqw frqglwlrqv/ zhoo0ehkdyhg whvw surfhgxuhv zloo vlpso| whoo xv wkdw wkh udqjh ri ydoxhv iru wkh sdudphwhu wkdw fdqqrw eh uhmhfwhg lv h{wuhpho| zlgh144

Ilj 6d1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=;/ V\V/ W @ 9 Ilj 6e1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f@ 3=;/ V\V/ W @ 9

Ilj 6f1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f@ 3=;/ GLI/ W @ 9 Ilj 6g1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=;/ GLI/ W @ 9

(32)

Ilj 7d1 V\V hvwlpdwru/ f @ 3=7/ W @ 9 Ilj 7e1 V\V hvwlpdwru/ f @ 3=;/ W @ 9

Shukdsv pruh vxusulvlqjo|/ zh qg wkdw erwk rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv edvhg rq wkh pxfk ohvv eldvhg V\V hvwlpdwruv kdyh vlploduo| srru vl}h surshuwlhv wr wkrvh edvhg rq wkh GLI hvwlpdwruv/ dv vhhq lq Iljxuh 6d1 Wkh sureohp khuh fdq eh wudfhg wr wkh vkdsh ri wkh qlwh vdpsoh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh V\V hvwlpdwru lq wkh

kf ' fH fdvh1 Iljxuh 7 vkrzv wkh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv

edvhg rq wkh V\V prphqw frqglwlrqv lq rxu h{shulphqwv/ dw erwkkf ' fe dqg

kf ' fH145 Zklovw lq wkh iruphu fdvh wkh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhu hvwlpdwhv

lv v|pphwulf durxqg wkh phdq ri 317 dqg dssur{lpdwho| qrupdo +Iljxuh 7d,/ lq wkh odwwhu fdvh wkh glvwulexwlrq lv kljko| vnhzhg/ zlwk wkh prgh ehlqj udwkhu kljkhu wkdq wkh phdq +Iljxuh 7e,1 Wkxv zklovw wkh fruuhfwhg dv|pswrwlf dssur{lpdwlrq dsshduv wr surylgh d jrrg jxlgh wr wkh uvw wzr prphqwv ri wklv glvwulexwlrq/ dv zh vdz lq Wdeoh 6/ lw surylghv d srru jxlgh wr wkh kljkhu prphqwv1 Lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkh Zdog whvwv uholhv rq wkh dv|pswrwlf qrupdolw| ri wkh hvwlpdwru/ dqg khqfh lv lqdffxudwh lq wkhkf ' fHfdvh1 Shukdsv uhodwhg wr wklv/ zh qg wkdw wkh

(33)

errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw rhuv qr lpsuryhphqw ryhu wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv frqwh{w1 Khuh zh qg wkdw wkh Eurzq0Qhzh|0Pd| yhuvlrq ri wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw shuirupv txlwh zhoo/ exw zrxog fdxwlrq djdlqvw uho|lqj rq wklv surfhgxuh lq jhqhudo1 Shukdsv pruh xvhixoo|/ Iljxuh 6e vkrzv wkdw wkh OP whvw edvhg rq wkh V\V hvwlpdwru kdv uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv yhu| forvh wr qrplqdo vl}h lq wklv h{shulphqw1 H{fhsw iru wkh fdvh ri zhdn lqvwuxphqwv vkrzq lq Iljxuh 6g/ wkh OP whvw lv irxqg wr kdyh jrrg vl}h surshuwlhv lq doo wkh fdvhv zh kdyh frqvlghuhg1 Wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv dovr surylgh d frqvlghudeoh lpsuryhphqw rq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wklv h{shulphqw/ dowkrxjk dv zdv wkh fdvh iru wkh GLI hvwlpdwru/ wkh yhuvlrq edvhg rq wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP fulwhulrq shuirupv uhodwlyho| srruo| lq wklv jurxs1

;151 D Pxowlyduldwh G|qdplf Prgho

Doo wkh ghvljqv frqvlghuhg lq wkh suhylrxv vhfwlrq frqwdlqhg rqo| rqh sdudphwhu ri lqwhuhvw +kf,/ dqg wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv ehlqj whvwhg surylghg d frpsohwh vshf0

lfdwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhu yhfwru1 Dv d uhvxow/ lq irupxodwlqj wkh OP vwdwlvwlf dv d Zdog whvw xvlqj d wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru zkhuh wkh uhvwulfwlrqv lpsrvhg xqghu wkh qxoo duh xvhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh zhljkw pdwul{ +vhh Vhfwlrq 7,/ zh kdyh d vhhplqjo| yhu| vshfldo fdvh lq zklfk qr sdudphwhuv qhhg wr eh hvwlpdwhg wr rewdlq wklv zhljkw pdwul{1 Lq wklv frqwh{w lw pd| eh xqvxusulvlqj wkdw wkh OP whvw dyrlgv wkh vl}h glvwruwlrq irxqg iru wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zklfk lv fohduo| uhodwhg wr qhjohfwlqj wkh hvwlpdwlrq ri vxfk sdudphwhuv lq wkh xvxdo ghulydwlrq ri wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh pdwul{1 Wkxv lw lv lpsruwdqw wr frqvlghu wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh OP whvw lq ghvljqv zlwk d kljkhu glphqvlrqdo sdudphwhu yhfwru/ dqg sduwlfxoduo| lq uhodwlrq wr k|srwkhvlv whvwv wkdw ohdyh vrph ri wkhvh

(34)

sdudphwhuv xquhvwulfwhg146 _{Pruh jhqhudoo| lw lv xvhixo wr fkhfn wkdw wkh qglqjv}

suhvhqwhg suhylrxvo| duh qrw vshfldo wr wkh vlpsoh-E prgho1

Lq wklv vhfwlrq zh wkhuhiruh suhvhqw vrph Prqwh Fduor uhvxowv iru d pxowlyduldwh g|qdplf prgho vshflhg dv= +| ' kf+|3nqf%|n#n| %| ' 4f%|3nf#n| | ' wf|3n0| Wkh sdudphwhuv zhuh fkrvhq wr eh kf ' fD/ qf ' / 4f ' fD/ f ' f/ wf ' f/ # Efc/ | Efc/ 0| Efc/ ' ff dqg A ' S1 Zh irfxv rq wkh

hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhuvEkfc qflq wkh uvw htxdwlrq/ dqg vlpsoh k|srwkhvlv

whvwv ri wkh irup Mf G kf ' fD ru Mf G qf ' lq wklv vhwwlqj1 Wkh %| vhulhv duh

fruuhodwhg zlwk # dqg suhghwhuplqhg exw qrw vwulfwo| h{rjhqrxv zlwk uhvshfw wr

| lq wklv htxdwlrq1 Wkh fkrlfh ri sdudphwhuv lv djdlq lqwhqghg wr dyrlg vhulrxv

sureohpv ri zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq1 Qrwh wkdw wkh lqfoxvlrq ri wkh suhghwhuplqhg

%| yduldeoh lq wkh prgho wr eh hvwlpdwhg djdlq kdv wkh hhfw ri dssur{lpdwho|

grxeolqj wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg e| wkh V\V JPP hvwlpdwru/ frpsduhg wr wkh vlpsoh -E prghov frqvlghuhg suhylrxvo| zlwk ' ff dqg

A ' S1

Wdeoh 7 suhvhqwv wkh hvwlpdwlrq uhvxowv iru wkh V\V JPP hvwlpdwruv/ dqg Iljxuh 8 suhvhqwv s0ydoxh sorwv edvhg rq fcfff uhsolfdwlrqv1 Wkhvh hvwlpdwruv kdyh olwwoh eldv/ dqg erwk wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs dv|pswrwlf vwdqgdug huuruv dqg wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs vwdqgdug huuruv shuirup yhu| zhoo lq wklv ghvljq1 Iljxuhv

46_{Wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv whvwhg e| wkh idploldu cw0udwlr* lq d pxowlyduldwh prgho surylghv d ohdglqj}

(35)

8d dqg 8f vkrz wkh uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv iru wkh ydulrxv Zdog whvwv ri fruuhfw qxoo k|srwkhvhv frqfhuqlqj kf dqg qf uhvshfwlyho|1 Erwk Iljxuhv kdyh wkh idploldu

sdwwhuq/ zlwk wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw vhulrxvo| ryhu0uhmhfwlqj dqg wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv xqghu0uhmhfwlqj uhodwlyh wr wkhlu qrplqdo vl}h1 Wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw shuirupv ehwwhu wkdq wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv/ sduwlfxoduo| lq Iljxuh 8f/ zlwk vlplodu vl}h surshuwlhv wr wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw> zklovw wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw shuirupv yhu| zhoo lq erwk fdvhv1 Qrwlfh wkdw e| frqvwuxfwlrq wklv lv d ghvljq lq zklfk wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv kdyh olwwoh eldv/ vr wkdw wkh vl}h glvwruwlrq ri wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lv douhdg| vpdoo1

Wdeoh 71 Hvwlpdwlrq Uhvxowv iru pxowlyduldwh prgho/ ' ff/A ' S

V\V

k q

kf vw huuf qf vw huuf

318 31836 3138: 31845 31385 413 31<<< 313;9 31<<; 313;5

3138; 31389 31387 31369 313;9 313;7 313;5 31393

31385 313;3

phdqv dqg vwdqgdug ghyldwlrqv ri 43/333 uhsolfdwlrqv

(36)

Ilj 8d1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=8/ V\V/ W @ 9 Ilj 8e1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 3=8/ V\V/ W @ 9

Ilj 8f1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 4/ V\V/ W @ 9 Ilj 8g1 S0ydoxh sorw/ f @ 4/ V\V/ W @ 9

Iljxuhv 8e dqg 8g vkrz wkh uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv iru wkh OP whvw dqg wkh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv lq wkh vdph h{shulphqw1 Wkh vlpsoh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq shuirupv zhoo lq erwk fdvhv/ zklovw wkh vhqvlwlylw| ri wkh uhvxowv iru wkh h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj fulwhulrq wr dq lqfuhdvh lq wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv/ qrwhg lq Vhfwlrq ;1414/ lv djdlq dssduhqw khuh1 Shukdsv ri prvw lqwhuhvw lv wkh urexvwqhvv ri wkh jrrg vl}h shuirupdqfh ri wkh

(37)

OP whvw wr vhwwlqjv zkhuh sdudphwhuv xvhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh zhljkw pdwul{ duh ohiw xquhvwulfwhg e| wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv/ dqg wkhuhiruh qhhg wr eh uhsodfhg e| frqvlvwhqw hvwlpdwhv lq rughu wr frqvwuxfw wkh OP whvw1 Rxu vxvslflrq zdv wkdw wkh OP whvw zrxog shuirup pxfk ohvv zhoo lq wkhvh fdvhv/ exw kdsslo| wkdw grhv qrw vhhp wr eh wkh fdvh1 Wkh h{sodqdwlrq iru wklv frqyhqlhqw urexvwqhvv olhv lq wkh dssur{lpdwh eorfn gldjrqdolw| surshuw| ri wkh qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq iru wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh pdwul{ ri wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ glvfxvvhg lq Vhfwlrq 71 Dv d uhvxow wkh qhhg wr hvwlpdwh sdudphwhuv wkdw duh qrw vshflhg dv sduw ri wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv kdv olwwoh hhfw rq wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh OP whvw147

Lqghhg lq pdq| fdvhv wkh OP whvw vhhpv wr kdyh ehwwhu qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv wkdq wkh ihdvleoh yhuvlrq ri wkh fruuhfwlrq wr wkh vwdqgdug Zdog whvw/ lpsohphqwhg dv`2 lq rxu vlpxodwlrqv dqg glvfxvvhg lq Vhfwlrq 6141

;161 Vxppdu| ri Vl}h Surshuwlhv

Rxu uhvxowv rq wkh vl}h surshuwlhv ri wkhvh dowhuqdwlyh whvw vwdwlvwlfv fdq qrz eh vxppdulvhg1 Lq fdvhv zkhuh wkh prphqw frqglwlrqv xvhg surylgh uhdvrqdeoh lghqwlfdwlrq ri wkh sdudphwhuv ri lqwhuhvw/ ru zkhuh wkh lqvwuxphqwv duh qrw zhdn/ wkhq wkh qrplqdo vl}h ri wkh OP whvw surylghv dq dffxudwh jxlgh wr lwv uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqf| lq vdpsohv ri wkh vl}h frqvlghuhg khuh1 Wklv zdv irxqg wr eh wkh fdvh lq doo wkh h{shulphqwv frqvlghuhg/ h{fhsw iru wkh zhdn lqvwuxphqwv h{dpsoh lq Iljxuh 6g1 Lq doprvw doo wkhvh fdvhv/ wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrq ri wkh rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ xvlqj wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} uhfhqwhulqj phwkrg/ lpsuryhg rq wkh dffxudf| ri wkh dv|pswrwlf rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ dqg surylghg uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv yhu| forvh wr

47_{Zh frquphg wkdw wkh OP whvw frqwlqxhg wr shuirup zhoo lq ghvljqv zlwk pdq| dgglwlrqdo}

(38)

wkh qrplqdo vl}h1 Wklv zdv sduwlfxoduo| wkh fdvh zkhuh vpdoo vl}h glvwruwlrqv lq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw zhuh dwwulexwdeoh wr vpdoo qlwh vdpsoh eldvhv lq wkh JPP hvwlpdwru/ dv lq Iljxuhv 4d/ 4f/ 5d/ 5f/ 8d dqg 8f1 Wkh h{fhswlrq zdv lq wkh uhvxowv edvhg rq wkh V\V hvwlpdwru dwkf ' fH+Iljxuh 6d,/ zkhuh wkh vl}h

glvwruwlrq lq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw zdv dwwulexwdeoh wr wkh glvwlqfwo| qrq0qrupdo qlwh vdpsoh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh hvwlpdwru1

Wkh shuirupdqfh ri wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw zdv frpsdudwlyho| glvdssrlqwlqj/ zlwk wkhlu qrplqdo vl}h vhulrxvo| ryhuvwdwlqj wkhlu qlwh vdpsoh uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqflhv lq fdvhv vxfk dv Iljxuh 5d/ 5f dqg 8f1 Wkh idfw wkdw wkh Kdoo0Krurzlw} surfhgxuh zrunv zhoo iru wkh rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq wkhvh fdvhv vxjjhvwv wkdw wkh sureohp lv qrw zlwk wkh phwkrg ri errwvwudsslqj iru JPP shu vh exw udwkhu lv uhodwhg wr wkh qhhg wr hvwlpdwh d zhljkw pdwul{ rq hdfk uhsolfdwlrq lq rughu wr lpsohphqw errwvwudsslqj iru wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw148

Xqiruwxqdwho| wklv zrxog vxjjhvw wkdw wkh errwvwudsshg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv zloo eh ohdvw uholdeoh lq wkh vdph vhwwlqjv dv wkh dv|pswrwlf wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zkhuh wkh vl}h glvwruwlrq lv dovr uhodwhg wr wkh hvwlpdwlrq ri wkh zhljkw pdwul{1 Rxu vlpxodwlrqv vxjjhvw wkdw wkh ihdvleoh yhuvlrq ri wkh qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq vxj0 jhvwhg e| Zlqgphlmhu +5333, zloo riwhq uhvxow lq pruh uholdeoh lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru wkdq wkhvh dssurdfkhv wr errwvwudsslqj/ dw ohdvw lq wkh frqwh{w ri wkhvh hvwlpdwruv iru g|qdplf sdqho gdwd prghov149 _{Wklv fruuhfwhg}

wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw lv jhqhudoo| irxqg wr kdyh vlplodu vl}h surshuwlhv wr wkh vwdq0

48_{Wklv kdv ehhq qrwhg suhylrxvo| lq d glhuhqw vhwwlqj e| Dowrqml dqg Vhjdo +4<<9,> vhh dovr}

]loldn +4<<:,1

49_{Errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw zhuh irxqg wr kdyh vlplodu sure0}

ohpv wr wkrvh uhsruwhg iru wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Djdlq wklv vhhpv olnho| wr eh uhodwhg wr wkh qhhg wr hvwlpdwh wkh rswlpdo zhljkw pdwul{ lq hdfk uhsol0 fdwlrq ri wkh errwvwuds1

(39)

gdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Erwk wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw dqg wkh OP whvw fdq surylgh pruh vxevwdqwldo lpsuryhphqwv/ dv looxvwudwhg lq Iljxuhv 5f dqg 5g1 Krzhyhu qrqh ri wkhvh whvw surfhgxuhv lv irxqg wr kdyh jrrg vl}h surshuwlhv lq wkh zhdn lqvwuxphqwv fdvh looxvwudwhg lq Iljxuhv 6f dqg 6g1

Ri wkh wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv frqvlghuhg/ wkh vlpsohvw yhuvlrq edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq zdv irxqg wr eh wkh prvw urexvw lq rxu h{shulphqwv1 Wkh yhuvlrq edvhg rq wkh h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj fulwhulrq zdv uhodwlyho| vhqvlwlyh wr lqfuhdvlqj wkh qxpehu ri prphqw frqglwlrqv +Iljxuhv 5e/ 8e dqg 8g,/ zklovw wkh yhuvlrq edvhg rq wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg JPP fulwhulrq zdv uhod0 wlyho| srru lq wkh fdvh ri zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq +Iljxuh 6g,1 Wkh (-L vwdwlvwlf lv

h{wuhpho| vlpsoh wr frpsxwh dqg kdv uhdvrqdeoh vl}h surshuwlhv lq doo wkh h{0 shulphqwv zh kdyh frqvlghuhg1 Wklv whvw shuirupv vxusulvlqjo| zhoo lq wkh zhdn lqvwuxphqwv h{dpsoh ri Iljxuh 6g/ dqg fdq dw ohdvw eh h{shfwhg wr uhyhdo wkdw wkh sdudphwhuv ri lqwhuhvw duh qrw hvwlpdwhg zlwk dq| xvhixo suhflvlrq lq wklv vhwwlqj1 ;171 Srzhu Frpsdulvrqv

Kdylqj irfxvhg rq wkh qlwh vdpsoh vl}h surshuwlhv ri wkhvh whvw vwdwlvwlfv/ lq wklv vhfwlrq zh eulh | frqvlghu wkhlu srzhu wr uhmhfw lqfruuhfw qxoo k|srwkhvhv lq wklv vhwwlqj1 Rxu lqwhqwlrq lv qrw wr surylgh d frpsuhkhqvlyh hydoxdwlrq iru doo wkh whvwv suhylrxvo| frqvlghuhg/ exw udwkhu wr fkhfn wkdw wkrvh whvwv iru zklfk zh kdyh irxqg uhodwlyho| vpdoo vl}h glvwruwlrqv gr qrw shuirup sduwlfxoduo| srruo| lq whupv ri srzhu1

(40)

Ilj 91 Srzhu sorw/Mf Gkf ' fe/ V\V

Wr gr wklv zh uhwxuq wr wkh edvlf-Evshflfdwlrq xvhg lq Vhfwlrq ;14/ zlwk

' ff dqg A ' S/ dqg frqvlghu whvwv ri wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv Mf G kf ' fe iru

d udqjh ri wuxh ydoxhv ri wkh sdudphwhu kf ehwzhhq 3158 dqg 318814: Zh irfxv

rq wkh whvwv suhylrxvo| irxqg wr kdyh uhdvrqdeoh vl}h surshuwlhv lq d zlgh udqjh ri h{shulphqwv= wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw/ dqg wkh vlpsoh fulwhulrq0 glhuhqfh whvw +(-L, edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq1 Iljxuh 9

suhvhqwv wkh srzhu sorwv iru wkhvh whvwv edvhg rq wkh JPP V\V hvwlpdwru/ xvlqj wkh fulwlfdo ydoxhv wkdw duh irxqg wr jlyh d 8( uhmhfwlrq iuhtxhqf| iru hdfk whvw dw wkh ydoxh ri kf ' fe frqvlghuhg lq wkh qxoo k|srwkhvlv14; Lq wklv h{dpsoh

4:_{Vshflfdoo| zh xvh wkh sdudphwhu ydoxhv +3158/ 3163/ 3168/ 3173/ 3178/ 3183/ 3188,1} 4;_{Wkh uhvxowv duh edvhg rq 8333 uhsolfdwlrqv1}

(41)

zh qg d vpdoo lpsuryhphqw lq srzhu iru wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw dqg wkh(-L whvw/ frpsduhg wr wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ zklovw

wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw kdv yhu| vlplodu srzhu wr lwv dv|pswrwlf frxqwhusduw1 Lq d zlghu udqjh ri h{shulphqwv zh kdyh irxqg qr fdvhv lq zklfk wkhvh dowhuqdwlyh whvw vwdwlvwlfv kdyh orzhu srzhu wkdq wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw xqohvv wkh hvwlpdwru lwvhoi lv vxemhfw wr txlwh vhulrxv qlwh vdpsoh eldv1

<1 Frqfoxvlrqv

Zh vwxg| wkh qlwh vdpsoh surshuwlhv ri whvwv ri olqhdu uhvwulfwlrqv lq wkh frqwh{w ri g|qdplf sdqho gdwd prghov hvwlpdwhg xvlqj olqhdu prphqw frqglwlrqv1 Rxu uhvxowv frqup wkh yhu| srru surshuwlhv ri wkh vwdqgdug dv|pswrwlf Zdog whvw edvhg rq wkh rswlpdo wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ hyhq zkhq wklv hvwlpdwru kdv olwwoh eldv dqg lv dssur{lpdwho| qrupdoo| glvwulexwhg1 Wklv lv h{sodlqhg e| wkh qhjohfw ri vdpsolqj yduldqfh lq wkh hvwlpdwhg sdudphwhuv xvhg wr frqvwuxfw wkh zhljkw pdwul{/ zklfk fdq uhvxow lq vhulrxv vl}h glvwruwlrqv lq sdqhov zlwk glphqvlrqv wkdw duh riwhq hqfrxqwhuhg lq sudfwlfh1

Zdog whvwv edvhg rq rqh0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwruv wkdw xvh d {hg zhljkw pdwul{ w|slfdoo| surylgh d pruh uholdeoh edvlv iru qlwh vdpsoh lqihuhqfh1 Zh kdyh frqvlg0 huhg d udqjh ri dowhuqdwlyh whvw surfhgxuhv= errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs dqg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvwv/ dq dowhuqdwlyh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw wkdw xvhv d qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwlrq iru wkh dv|pswrwlf yduldqfh pdwul{/ wkh OP whvw/ dqg wkuhh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvwv1 Zh qg wkdw wkh errwvwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw xvlqj wkh uhfhqwhulqj phwkrg sursrvhg e| Kdoo dqg Krurzlw} +4<<9, zrunv h{wuhpho| zhoo/ h{fhsw lq fdvhv zkhuh wkh sdudphwhuv ri lqwhuhvw duh rqo| zhdno| lghqwlhg ru zkhuh wkh vl}h glvwruwlrq lq

(42)

wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw uhvxowv iurp wkh vpdoo vdpsoh glvwulexwlrq ri wkh JPP hvwlpdwru ehfrplqj qrwlfhdeo| qrq0qrupdo1 Lq frqwudvw wkh errwvwudsshg yhuvlrqv ri wkh wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw shuirup frpsdudwlyho| srruo|/ zklfk vhhpv wr eh uhodwhg wr wkh sureohp ri hvwlpdwlqj wkh rswlpdo zhljkw pdwul{1 Lq jhqhudo wkhvh errwvwudsslqj surfhgxuhv gr qrw surylgh d uholdeoh fruuhfwlrq iru Zdog whvwv edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru lq wkhvh ryhulghqwlhg sdqho gdwd prghov1 Wkh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw ghyhorshg e| Zlqgphlmhu +5333, riwhq surylghv pruh uholdeoh lqihuhqfh edvhg rq wkh wzr0vwhs JPP hvwlpdwru/ zlwk vl}h surshu0 wlhv vlplodu wr wkrvh ri wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Wkh OP whvw lv irxqg wr kdyh vpdoohu vl}h glvwruwlrqv wkdq wkh rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw lq d qxpehu ri rxu h{shulphqwv/ dqg shuirupv zhoo h{fhsw lq wkh fdvh ri zhdn lghqwlfdwlrq1 Wkh vlpsoh fulwhulrq0glhuhqfh whvw edvhg rq wkh vwdqgdug wzr0vwhs JPP fulwhulrq lv irxqg wr shuirup txlwh zhoo lq doo wkh fdvhv zh kdyh frqvlghuhg/ dqg vhhpv wr surylgh wkh prvw uholdeoh lqihuhqfh lq wkh fdvh ri zhdn lqvwuxphqwv1 Wkh whvwv edvhg rq wkh frqwlqxrxvo| xsgdwhg ru h{srqhqwldo wlowlqj fulwhuld duh irxqg wr eh ohvv urexvw1

Lq frqfoxvlrq zh qg wkdw wkh qlwh vdpsoh fruuhfwhg wzr0vwhs Zdog whvw sur0 ylghv d uhdvrqdeoh dowhuqdwlyh wr wkh vwdqgdug rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw1 Wkh errw0 vwudsshg rqh0vwhs Zdog whvw/ wkh OP whvw dqg wkh vlpsoh fulwhulrq0edvhg whvw fdq surylgh pruh uholdeoh qlwh vdpsoh lqihuhqfh lq fdvhv zkhuh wkhvh Zdog whvwv kdyh prghvw vl}h glvwruwlrqv gxh wr vpdoo vdpsoh eldvhv lq wkh JPP hvwlpdwruv1

(43)

Uhihuhqfhv

^4` Dkq/ V1F1 dqg S1 Vfkplgw +4<<8,/ H!flhqw Hvwlpdwlrq ri Prghov iru G|qdplf Sdqho Gdwd/ Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrphwulfv/ 9;/ 805;1

^5` Dorqvr0Eruuhjr/ F1 dqg P1 Duhoodqr +4<<<,/ V|pphwulfdoo| Qrupdolvhg Lqvwuxphqwdo0Yduldeoh Hvwlpdwlrq xvlqj Sdqho Gdwd/ Mrxuqdo ri Exvlqhvv ) Hfrqrplf Vwdwlvwlfv 4:/ 6907<1

^6` Dowrqml/ M1J1 dqg O1P1 Vhjdo +4<<9,/ Vpdoo Vdpsoh Eldv lq JPP Hvwlpdwlrq ri Fryduldqfh Vwuxfwxuhv/ Mrxuqdo ri Exvlqhvv dqg Hfrqrplf Vwdwlvwlfv 47/ 68606991

^7` Duhoodqr/ P1 dqg V1U1 Erqg +4<<4,/ Vrph Whvwv ri Vshflfdwlrq iru Sdqho Gdwd= Prqwh Fduor Hylghqfh dqg dq Dssolfdwlrq wr Hpsor|phqw Htxdwlrqv/

Uhylhz ri Hfrqrplf Vwxglhv 8;/ 5::0<;1

^8` Duhoodqr/ P1 dqg R1 Eryhu +4<<8,/ Dqrwkhu Orrn dw wkh Lqvwuxphqwdo0Yduldeoh Hvwlpdwlrq ri Huuru0Frpsrqhqwv Prghov/Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrphwulfv 9;/ 5<0841 ^9` Ehujvwuùp S1 +4<<:,/ Rq Errwvwuds Vwdqgdug Huuruv lq G|qdplf Sdqho Gdwd

Prghov/ Zrunlqj Sdshu Qr1 4<<:256/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Xssvdod1

^:` Ehujvwuùp S1/ P1 Gdkoehuj dqg H1 Mrkdqvvrq +4<<:,/ JPP Errwvwudsslqj dqg Whvwlqj lq G|qdplf Sdqhov/ Zrunlqj Sdshu 4<<:243/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Xss0 vdod1

^;` Eoxqghoo/ U1Z1 dqg V1U1 Erqg +4<<;,/ Lqlwldo Frqglwlrqv dqg Prphqw Uh0 vwulfwlrqv lq G|qdplf Sdqho Gdwd Prghov/Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrphwulfv/ ;:/ 4480 4761

(44)

^<` Erqg/ V1U1/ F1 Erzvkhu dqg I1 Zlqgphlmhu +5334,/ Fulwhulrq0Edvhg Lqihuhqfh iru JPP lq Dxwruhjuhvvlyh Sdqho Gdwd Prghov/Hfrqrplfv Ohwwhuv :6/ 6:<0 6;;1

^43` Eurzq/ E1Z1/ Z1N1 Qhzh| dqg V1 Pd| +4<<<,/ H!flhqw Errwvwudsslqj iru JPP/ plphr/ PLW1

^44` Gdylgvrq/ U1 dqg M1J1 PdfNlqqrq +4<<6,/ Hvwlpdwlrq dqg Lqihuhqfh lq

Hfrqrphwulfv/ R{irug Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv/ Qhz \run1

^45` Gdylgvrq/ U1 dqg M1J1 PdfNlqqrq +4<<9,/ Judsklfdo Phwkrgv iru Lqyhvwl0 jdwlqj wkh Vl}h dqg Srzhu ri K|srwkhvlv Whvwv/Pdqfkhvwhu Vfkrro 99/ 40591 ^46` Kdoo/ S1 dqg M1O1 Krurzlw} +4<<9,/ Errwvwuds Fulwlfdo Ydoxhv iru Whvwv edvhg rq Jhqhudol}hg Phwkrg ri Prphqwv Hvwlpdwruv/Hfrqrphwulfd/ 97/ ;<40<491 ^47` Kdqvhq/ E1H1/ +5333,/ Hgjhzruwk H{sdqvlrqv iru wkh Zdog dqg JPP Vwdwlv0

wlfv iru Qrqolqhdu Uhvwulfwlrqv/ plphr/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Zlvfrqvlq1

^48` Kdqvhq/ O1S1/ +4<;5,/ Odujh Vdpsoh Surshuwlhv ri Jhqhudolvhg Phwkrg ri Prphqwv Hvwlpdwruv/Hfrqrphwulfd 83/ 435<043871

^49` Kdqvhq/ O1S1/ M1 Khdwrq dqg D1 \durq +4<<9,/ Ilqlwh0Vdpsoh Surshuwlhv ri vrph Dowhuqdwlyh JPP Hvwlpdwruv/Mrxuqdo ri Exvlqhvv ) Hfrqrplf Vwdwlv0 wlfv 47/ 59505;31

^4:` Krurzlw}/ M1O1 +5334,/ Wkh Errwvwuds/ lq M1M1 Khfnpdq dqg H1H1 Ohdphu +hgv1,/Kdqgerrn ri Hfrqrphwulfv Yroxph 8/ Hovhylhu Vflhqfh1

(45)

^4;` Lpehqv/ J1Z1/ U1K1 Vsdg| dqg S1 Mrkqvrq +4<<;,/ Lqirupdwlrq Wkhruhwlf Dssurdfkhv wr Lqihuhqfh lq Prphqw Frqglwlrq Prghov/ Hfrqrphwulfd 99/ 666068:1

^4<` Nohlehujhq/ I1 +5334,/ Whvwlqj Sdudphwhuv lq JPP zlwkrxw Dvvxplqj wkdw wkh| duh Lghqwlhg/ Wlqehujhq Lqvwlwxwh Glvfxvvlrq Sdshu 5334039:27/ Dpv0 whugdp1

^53` Nrhqnhu/ U1 dqg M1D1I1 Pdfkdgr +4<<<,/ JPP Lqihuhqfh zkhq wkh Qxpehu ri Prphqw Frqglwlrqv lv Odujh/Mrxuqdo ri Hfrqrphwulfv <6/ 65:06771 ^54` Nuxlqljhu/ K1 +5333,/ JPP Hvwlpdwlrq ri G|qdplf Sdqho Gdwd Prghov zlwk

Shuvlvwhqw Gdwd/ TPZ/ Xqlyhuvlw| ri Orqgrq/ Ghsw1 ri Hfrqrplfv Zrunlqj Sdshu Vhulhv Qr1 75;1

^55` Pruhlud/ P1 M1 +5334,/ Whvwv zlwk Fruuhfw Vl}h zkhq Lqvwuxphqwv fdq eh Duelwudulo| Zhdn/ plphr/ XF Ehunhoh|1

^56` Qhovrq/ F1U1 dqg U1 Vwduw} +4<<3,/ Wkh Glvwulexwlrq ri wkh Lqvwuxphqwdo Ydul0 deoh Hvwlpdwru dqg Lwv w0udwlr zkhq wkh Lqvwuxphqw lv d Srru Rqh/ Mrxuqdo

ri Exvlqhvv ) Hfrqrplf Vwdwlvwlfv 96/ 8458084731

^57` Qhzh|/ Z1N1 dqg U1M1 Vplwk +5333,/ Dv|pswrwlf Eldv dqg Htxlydohqfh ri JPP dqg JHO Hvwlpdwruv/ Zrunlqj Sdshu/ PLW Ghsduwphqw ri Hfrqrplfv1 ^58` Qhzh|/ Z1N1 dqg N1G1 Zhvw +4<;:,/ K|srwkhvlv Whvwlqj zlwk H!flhqw Phwkrg ri Prphqwv Hvwlpdwlrq/ Lqwhuqdwlrqdo Hfrqrplf Uhylhz 5;/ :::0 :;:1

(46)

^59` Rzhq/ D1 +4<;;,/ Hpslulfdo Olnholkrrg Udwlr Frqghqfh Lqwhuydov iru d Vlqjoh Ixqfwlrqdo/ Elrphwulnd :8/ 56:057<1

^5:` Vdujdq/ M1G1 +4<8;,/ Wkh Hvwlpdwlrq ri Hfrqrplf Uhodwlrqvklsv xvlqj Lqvwux0 phqwdo Yduldeohv/ Hfrqrphwulfd/ 59/ 65<066;1

^5;` Vdujdq/ M1G1 +4<;;,/ Whvwlqj iru Plvvshflfdwlrq diwhu Hvwlpdwlrq Xvlqj Lq0 vwuxphqwdo Yduldeohv/ lq= H1 Pddvrxpl +hg1,/Frqwulexwlrqv wr Hfrqrphwulfv=

Mrkq Ghqlv Vdujdq/ Yroxph L/ Fdpeulgjh Xqlyhuvlw| Suhvv1

^5<` Vwdljhu/ G1 dqg M1K1 Vwrfn +4<<:,/ Lqvwuxphqwdo Yduldeohv Uhjuhvvlrq zlwk Zhdn Lqvwuxphqwv/Hfrqrphwulfd 98/ 88:08;91

^63` Zlqgphlmhu/ I1 +5333,/ D Ilqlwh Vdpsoh Fruuhfwlrq iru wkh Yduldqfh ri Olqhdu Wzr0Vwhs JPP Hvwlpdwruv/ Lqvwlwxwh iru Ilvfdo Vwxglhv Zrunlqj Sdshu Vhulhv Qr1 Z3324</ Orqgrq/ kwws=22zzz1liv1ruj1xn2zrunlqjsdshuv2zs334<1sgi1

^64` ]loldn/ M1S1 +4<<:,/ H!flhqw Hvwlpdwlrq zlwk Sdqho Gdwd zkhq Lqvwuxphqwv duh Suhghwhuplqhg= Dq Hpslulfdo Frpsdulvrq ri Prphqw0Frqglwlrq Hvwlpd0 wruv/ Mrxuqdo ri Exvlqhvv ) Hfrqrplf Vwdwlvwlfv 48/ 74<07641