Spe ctr o mete r.
(
Unde r the d ir e ctio n of L O R I A .TODD, Ph.D.
)
A po rtab le ope n
-path F TIR instr ume nt ha s be e n de v eloped, that in c o rpo r ate s a
M
i da c FT I R spe ctr omete r, a mod i fi edW
h ite c el l, a nd a batte ry pa ck. The de sign in clude sa r emo v ab le c o v e r fo r the
W
hite c el l, w h ich al lows fo r e a s e in path leng th dete rm in atio n ,c al i br ation , a nd ba ck gr o und
c ol le ctio n, w h ich a r e chal len ging u sing c o n v e ntio n al ope n
-path FT I R spe ctr omete r s. In the n ew in str ume nt, a fol ded ope n
-path of u
p to 12 0 mete r s
is c r e ated u sing m ir r o r s an dtwo r etr o r ef le cto r s. Du e to the lo ng path le n g ths w h ich c an
be a ch ie v ed, chemic als c a n be dete cted at the pa rt pe r b i l l io n le v el. In ad d itio n
, the IR
be am is c o ntained w ith in a 6 0 L c el l. T he r efo r e, w he n c o n c entr ations of a chem ic al a r e
dete cted in a r o om, the lo c atio n of the c o n c e ntr atio n c a n be pinpointed.
T he instr ume nt ha s be e n e v aluated in a n e x po s u r e cham be r u sin g a r ange of
kn own c o n c entr atio n s. T he chemic als u s ed we r e nitr o u s o xi de, trich lo r o ethyle n e, a nd
methyl eth y l keton e. T he l imit of dete ctio n wa s c alcu lated fo r e a ch chemic al, and fo u nd
to be in the low pa rt pe r b i l l io n le v el fo r n itr o u s oxi de andtrich lo r o ethyle n e. Fo r methyl
ethyl keto n e, the l i m it of dete ctio n wa s fo im d to be appr o ximately 0.1
part s pe r m i l l io n .
Fo r nitr ous o x i de, pe rfo rma nc e pa r amete rs, includ in g pr e c isio n , a c c u r a cy, and b ias we r e
e v alu ated ac c o rd ing t o N I O SH gu i del in es, andthe instrume nt performed wel l w ith in the
N I O SH r e c om me n datio n s, ha vin g b ia s bet te r tha n + /- 10%
a nd a c c u r acy bet te r tha n
+/- 25%
T he a utho r w ishe s to tha nk the 3M Co rpo r atio n a n dM I D AC Co rpo r atio n fo r their
ge n e r o u s s up po rt of th is r e s e a r ch. Gr a nt P lumme r fo r h is te chnic al knowled ge, the
L ist of Tab le s i i
List of F i gur e s iv
L ist of A b breviation s vi
L ist of S ym bols vi i
Intr odu ctio n 1
Ba ckgr o u nd Information 9
Methods 2 2
Re s ults 2 9
D is c u ssio n 3 5
Co n clu sio n 4 1
Refe r e n c e s . .
Ap pe nd ix A
Ap pe nd ix B
Ap pe n d ix C
A ppend ix D
Ap pe nd ix E
A ppe nd ix F
A p pe nd ix G
.4 3
V olume dete rmin ation 4 6
Refe r e n c e Spe ctr a 5 0
SA S A lgo rithm s 5 6
R o ot
M
e a n Squ a r e Nois e 63Limits of Dete ctio n a nd
Q
u a nti fi c atio n 6 8Sample Calc ulatio n s 72
Tab le 1 C ha r a cte ristic abs o rptio n s 9
Tab le 2
W
ate r and Ca rbo n d io xi de r egio n s 10T ab le 3 Fla sk Volume s 2 3
T ab le 4 V olume of Tub in g 2 3
Tab le 5 Co n c e ntr atio n r ange s stud ied 25
Tab le 6 Refe r e n c e Spe ctr a Co n c e ntr atio n s a nd Regio n s fo r
Q
u a nti fic atio n 2 5Tab le 7 Path le ngths us ed 2 6
Tab le 8 A v e r age R
M
S n ois e 29Tab le 9 Summa r y of Re s ults 3 0
Tab le 10 Summa ry of Pr e cisio n, B ia s a n d Ac c u r a cy Re s ults fo r N itr o u s o x i de....3 1
Tab le A - 1 V olume
M
e a s u r eme nts 4 8
Tab le D
-1 R
M
S Nois e 6 5Tab le E- 1 L imits of Dete ctio n 70
Tab le E-2 L imi
ts of
Q
ua nti fi c atio n 7 1Tab le E-3 Pa r amet
e r s u s ed in L OD a nd LO
Q
Calc ulatio n s 7 2Tab le G- 1 0 92 497a ME K 77
Tab le G-2 0 9 2 89 7
a l
M
E K 8 0Tab le G-3 0 9 2 9 9 7a
M
E K 8 4Tab le G-4 10 0 5 9
7a T C E 8 8
Tab le G-5 1 00 5 97b T C E
a nd
M
E K 92Tab le G-7 100897a T C E
. .9 9
T able G- 8 1 0 1 097a N itr o u s o x i de a n d TCE 1 0 1
Tab le G-9 10 12 9 7a N itr o u s o x i de an d TC E 10 3
T ab le G-10 10 139 7a N itr o u s o x i de 10 6
T able G - 1 1 1 0 1 397b N i
tr o u s o x i de 1 08
Tab le G- 12 10 2 2 9 7a N itr o u s o xi de an d SF
e I l l
Table G
-13 120297b ME K a nd T C E 1 14
Table G- 14 0 1 2 898a Nitr o u s o x i de and T C E 1 1 7
Tab le G- 15 013 0 9 8
a N itr o u s o xi de 1 1 9
Tab le G- 16 01319 8a N itr o u s o xi de 12 3
Table G - 1 7 0 2 0 19 8
L is t of F igu r e s
F i gu r e 1
W
h ite c el l O ptic Co nfigu r atio n 5Figu r e 2 Retr o r efl e cto r 5
Figu r e 3 D ispe r siv e I R be am pr odu ctio n 12
Figu r e 4 Dispe r siv e I R in str ume nt de sign 13
Figu r e 5 Inte rfe r omete r 14
Figu r e 6 Inte rfe r ogr am 15
Figu r e 7 S ingle Be am Spe ctr u m 16
F i gu r e 8 Cal i br atio n Cu r v e 2 0
Figu r e 9 Fla sk 2 3
Figu r e 10 C ham be r s et
-up 24
F i gu r e 1 1 N itrou s o xi de gr aph 3 2
F igu r e 12 T rich lo r o ethyle n e gr aph 3 3
Figu r e 13 Methyl ethy l keto ne gr aph 3 4
F i gu r e B
-1 E thyle n e Refe r e n c e S pe ctr um 5 1
F i gu r e B-2 SF
e Refe r e n c e Spe c tr um 5 2
F igu r e B-3 N itr o u s Oxi de Refe r e n c e S
pe ctr um 5 3
Figu r e B-4 Tri
ch lo r o ethyle n e Refe r e n c e Spe ctr um 54
Figu r e B -5
M
ethyl Ethy l Keto n e Refe r e n c e Spe ctr um 5 5
Fi gu r e D
-1 R
M
S Nois e 6 8F i gu r e G- 1 0 9 2 4 9 7a
M
EK 7 6F igu r e G-2 0 9 2 8 97al
M
E K 7 9Figu r e G-5 1 0 0 5 9 7b TCE a nd
M
EK 9 1F igu r e G-6 10 0 6 9 7 b T C E a nd
M
EK 9 4Figu r e G-7 10 0 897a TCE 9 8
Figu r e G-8 1 0 1 0 9 7a N itr o u s o x ide a nd T C E 1 0 0
Fi gu r e G-9 1 0 12 9 7a N itr o u s o x i de and T C E 102
Figu r e G- 10 10139 7a N itr o u s o xi de 10 5
Figu r e G- 1 1 1013 97b N itr o u s o x i de 10 7
F igu r e G- 12 10 2 2 97a N itr o u s o xi de a nd SF
e 1 10
F i gu r e G- 13 12 0297b
M
E K a n d T C E 1 13Figu r e G- 14 0 1 2898a N itr o u s o xi de a nd T CE 1 16
F igu r e G- 1 5 0 13 0 9 8a N itr o u s o xi de 118
F igu r e G- 16 013 19 8a N itr o u s o xi de 122
L ist of A bbr e v iat io n s
A D C An alog to Digital Conv ert e r
C O Ca rbo n
M
o n o x i deF T I R Fo u rie r Tr a n sfo rm Infr a r ed
I R Infr a r ed
LOP I R L o c al iz ed Ope n
-path Infr a r ed
M
I R A N M iniatu r e Infr a r ed An alyz e rN IO SH Natio n al In stit u te of Oc c upatio n al Safety a nd He alth
S Fe Sul fu r He x afl u o ri de
SN R Sign al to Nois e Ratio
R
M
S Ro ot Me a n Squ a r eL ist of Sym bols
A Abs o rba n c e
A i A bs o rba n c e of r efe r e n c e spe ctr um
A 2 A bs o rba n c e fo r s ample spe ctr um
b Path le ngth
bi Path le ng th fo r r efe r enc e spe ctr um
b2 Pathle ngth fo r s ample spe c tr um
c Co n c e ntr atio n
C i Co n c e ntr atio n of r efe r e n c e spe ctr um
C 2 Co n c en tr atio n of s ample spe ctr um
Ci Co n c e ntr ation in
j
ectedCc Co n c e ntr atio n me a s u r ed in the cham be r
I Inte n sity
lo Inte n sit y of ba ckgr o u nd spe ctr um
T Tr ansm it ta n c e
V i Volume in
j
e ctedVc V olume of the cham be r
In the indu stri al hy g ie n e f iel d, two ge n e r al ty pe s of s ampl in g methods, integr ated
a nd r e al-ti m e
, a r e u s ed to e v alu ate ga s a nd v apo r c o n c e ntr atio n s. Integr ated s ampl ing
pr o vi de s the ti me weighted a v e r age c o n c e ntr atio n fo r a few kn own chem ic als at a time,
w he r e a s r e al-ti m e in str ume nts c a n
pr o v i de mo r e detai led e x po s u r e info rmatio n o v e r ti m e.
In integr ated s am p l ing, the indu stri al hy gie nist cho o s e s the s ampl ing m ed ia ba s ed o n the
chem ic als of inte r e st in the air, a nd the o nly chem ic als that c a n be qua nti f ieda r e the
chem ic als w h ich ads o rb o nto the med ia. A d d itio n al ly, s ome integr ated methods u s e
chem ic al r e a ctivity a s a way to c ap tur e the c o ntam in a nts. Fo r mo st integr ated methods
,
the s ampl ing med ia mu st be a n alyz ed in a labo r ato ry, w h ich c a n take a few days up to a
few we eks.
^ '
In c o ntr a st to integr ated s am p l in gte chn i qu e s in w h ich the sample s n e ed to be
an alyz ed in a labo r ato ry, real
-ti me methods
g ive a n almo st i m med iate me a s u r eme nt of
the c o n c e ntr atio n of a n atmo sphe ric c o ntam in a nt. Com mo n r e al
-ti m
e methods fo r the
qu a nti f ic atio n of c o ntam in a nts, s u ch a s the miniatur e infr a r ed a n alyzer
(
MIR A N)
(
ma n ufa ctu r ed by T he Fo x bo r o Compa ny in Fo xbo r o,M
a s s a c hu s et ts)
qu a nti fy kn ownc o ntam in a nts in r e al-time
; howe v e r, mo st r e al
-time in str ume nts c an
qu anti f y o n ly o n e
chem ic al at a ti m e an d c a nn ot e a si ly be u s ed to i de nti f y u nkn own s. M I R A N s a r e ba s ed
a h ighe r sign al to n ois e r atio
(
SN R)
a nd h i ghe r r e s olutio n a n d c a n me a s u r e down to pp ble v els fo r s ome chem ic als
/
^ '^In indo o r air qu al ity stud ie s a nd c ommu nity e x po s u r e
stud ie s, w he r e e xpo s u r e to multi p le chem ic als at v e ry low le v els is a c o n c e r n , the r e a r e
few r e al-time in str ume nts which c a n simu lta n e o u sl
y me a s u r e a v a riety o f chemic als at
v e ry low le v els
/
^ ^^A ls o, in wo rk ing w ith ha z a rdo us mate rials, the i de nti fi c atio n of
u nkn own s is a ma
j
o r c o n c e r n V e ry few r e al-ti me in str ume nts al low fo r the i de nti fi c atio n
of u nkn own c o ntamin a nts. Some r e al
-ti me methods
, s u ch a s the H n u photoio niz atio n
method
(
ma n ufa ctv i r ed by H n u Systems In c. in Newto n ,M
A)
c a n be u s ed qu al itativ el y tome a s u r e mixtu r es of chemic als a nd to i de nti fy s ome unknown s in the air.
A single r e al
-ti m e method w h ich c a n qu a nti fy multiple chem ic als si mu lta n e o u sl y
at p pb le v els a nd i de nti fy unknown s is d i f fi c ult to fi nd. T he r efo r e, the r e is a gap in the
me a s u r eme nt te chn iqu e s a v ai lab le to the indu stri al hy gie nist. F T I R spe ctr ometry has
be e n shown to ha v e pr omis e in fi l l ing this gap in e n v ir o nme ntal a n d o c c upatio n al
me a s u r eme nts.
'^ ^ '' ^'^ ^^
U sin g F T I R spe ctr ometry w ith v e ry lo ng path le n gths, multiple
chemic als c a n be qu a nti fi ed simu ltane o u sly at v e ry low le v els (p pb
)
. In add itio n to itsab i l ity to qu a nti fy mu ltiple chem ic als si multa n e o u sly at v e ry low le v els, FT IR te chnology
al lows fo r the i de nti fi c atio n of u nkn own spe cie s u singthe pat te r n of abs o rptio n s in the
fi nge rprint r eg io n of the IR spe ctr a.
Two ge n e r al ty pe s of F T I R spe ctr omete r c o nfi gu r atio n s a r e a v ai lab le, ope n
-path
a nd clo s edc el l e xtr a ctiv e. Using ope n
u s ed; the r efo r e, the method is n o n
-in v a siv e
. T he c o n c e ntr atio n me a s v i r ed is the a v e r age
of that c o ntam in a nt c o n c e ntr atio n alo ng the e ntir e le n g th of the be am. Point
c o n c e ntr atio n s at lo c atio n s alo ng the path c a nnot be kn own u nle s s a n othe r method is
u s ed, s u ch a s tak ing a n a r e a s ample o r u sing be ams that inte r s e ct e a ch othe r, a s in
c om puted tomogr ap h y. '''^
'* ' ^^ H
a ving the be am ope n to the atmo sp he r e intr odu c e s
d i f fi c ultie s in tak ing a cle a n ba ckgr o u nd a nd in c al i br ating the path le ngth. An abs olutely
cle a n ba ckgr o u nd may not be a v ai lab le i f the system is in stal led in a n e n v ir o nme nt w he r e
chem ic als a r e c o n sta ntly being ge n e r ated o r i f the chemic al is al ways pr e sent in the
atmo sp he r e. Calibr atio n is d if fi c u lt be c aus e the r e is n o way to intr odu c e a known
c onc e ntr atio n of a chemic al into the open path. T h is d i f fi c u lt y can s ometi me s be
o v e r c ome by pla cing a clo s ed c el l in the path of the be am . A kn own c o n c e ntr atio n o f a
chemic al n ot n o rmal ly pr e s e nt in the atmo sphe r e, s u ch a s s ul fii r he x af lu o ri de
(
S F 6)
, isge n e r ated in the c el l, a nd the in str ume nt r e spo n s e is c ali br ated. ^'
'^ ^^
In a clo s ed c el l e x tr a ctiv e F TIR spe ctr omete r, the u s e of a clo s ed c el l al lows cle a n
nitr ogen ba ckgr o u n ds to be obtain ed, a nd the path le n gth c a n be c al i br ated u sin g a n
ethy le n e sta nda rd. A ft e r c al ibr atio n, an air s ample ispumped into the c el l, w he r e the
infr a r ed be am pa s s e s thr o u gh the s am p le. T he cel ls in the s e in str ume nts a r e de si gn ed
u sing m ir r o r s to c r e ate a fol ded path fo r the be am. The ty pic al clo s ed c el l fo und in
cha r a cte ristic s of clo s ed c el l e x tr a ctiv e a nd ope n- path FTIR spe ctr omete r s. T he n ew
ins tr ume nt is a Lo c al iz ed O pe n- Path In fr a r ed spe ctr omete r
(
L O P I R)
. It in c o rpo r ate s aMID A C FT I R spe ctr omete r
(
ma n ufa ctu r ed byM
I D A C Co rpo r atio n in Ir vin e, Cal i fo r nia
)
a nd a 6 0 L mod i fi ed
W
hite c el l. L ike a n e x tr a ctiv e F T I R spe ctr omete r, the n ew in str ume ntha s a c el l w h ich u s e s m ir r o r s to c r e ate a fol ded IR be am . In th is in str ume nt
, howe v e r, the
W
h ite c el l ha s be e n modifi ed to in clude both the r emo v able c o v e r a nd two r etr o r efl e cto r s.The c el l c o v e r s c a n be u s edto obtain a cle an nitr oge n ba ckgr o u n d a nd to c al i br ate the
path le n gth, the n they c a n be r emo v edto al low fo r ope n
-path me a s u r eme nts. In o rde r to
c o u nte r a ct the lo s s of l ight inte n sity a s the l i g ht tr a v els o v e r lo nge r d ista n c e s.
W
h ite c el lsa r e de sign ed u sing pa r abol ic mir r o r s to r efo c u s the be am with e a ch pa s s thr o ug h the c ell.
The r etr o r efle cto r s in th is c el l, s e r v e to elo ngate the path le n gth.
W
he n the be am isd ir e ctedtowa rd both r etr o r efle cto r s, the le ngth of the be am c a n be tripled.
The sho rte st path le ngth po s si b le in th is pa rtic ula r c el l is 4 m a n d the lo nge st
po s si b le is 120 m . The
path le ngth c a n be ad
j
u sted in 4 m in c r eme nts betwe e n them ini mum a nd ma x i mum path le ngths by cha ng in g the a n g le of the fi r st pa r abol ic mir r o r.
Fo r the 4 m path le ng th
, the be am e nte r s the c el l a nd is r efl e cted by the fi r st pa r abol ic
m ir r o r. It the n h its the fi el d m ir r o r at the bot tom of the c el l a nd is r efl e cted to the s e c ond
pa r abol ic m ir r o r . T he be am is the n r ed ir e cted, e x its the cel l
, a nd e nte r s the de te cto r
(
s e efi el d m ir r o r
to dete cto r fr om s o u r c e
F igu r e 1
W
h ite Cel l optic c o nfigu r atio nT he fi el d mir r o r a nd pa r abolic mir r o r s a r e u s edto obtain path le ngths fr om 4 to 4 0
m in le ngth. To r e a ch path le n gths abo v e 4 0 m, the two r etr o r ef lecto r s mu st be u s ed.
W
he n the be am r e a che s the si de o f the c el l w he r e it wo u l d n o rmal ly be d ir e cted int o thedete cto r, it e n c o u nte r s the fi r st r etr o r efl e cto r a nd is r eturn ed alo n g the s ame pathto the
oppo site si de of the c el l. T he r e, it e n c o u nte r s the s e c o nd r etr o r efl e cto r a nd is again s e nt
ba ck o n the s ame pathto the dete cto r
(
s e e F igu r e 2)
. ^^^l ight be am
\
-r etr o r efl e cto r
F igu r e 2 Retr o r efl ecto r
r
r
lo nge r tha n the ty pic al 10 m c el l fo u nd in mo st e xtr a ctiv e F T IR in str ume nts. Lowe r
le v els of c o ntam in a nts c a n be dete cted, a nd the LOP IR c a n be u s ed to me a s u r e v e ry low
c o n c e ntr atio n s of chemic als
(
pp b)
. The c o n c e ntr atio n at o n e lo c atio n can be pr e cis el yme a s u r ed be c a u s e the LO P I R in v olv e s a lo c aliz ed ope n- path; the e ntir e pathle n gth is
c o ntain ed w ith in a 6 0 L c el l lo c ated at the height of a huma n br e ath ing z o n e. T he
in str ume nt its el f fits w ith in a spa c e 2 '
6"
x 2'6"x 6'8".
T he LO PI R u s e s a M IDA C
(
model M2 50 1-C, s e rial n um be r 20 0
)
s o u r c e. It c a nbe ope ra ted o n bat te ry powe r o r u sing ele ctricit y fr om a n o utlet. T he be amspl itte r is
made of Pota ssium br omi de
(
K Br)
w ith a Germa n ium(
Ge)
c oating o n o n e hal f. K Br istr anspa r e nt to infr a r ed l ig ht, a nd Ge is r efle ctiv e. A Ge o n KBr be amspl it te r is ef fe ctiv e
o v e r the r a nge o f wa v e n umbe r s fr om 400 to 400 0/cm. On e dr aw ba ck to the K Br
be amspl it te r is the fa ct that i t w i l l abs o rb wate r v apo r a nd fog a s ti me pa s s e s. The
dete cto r is a li qui d nitr oge n c o oled
M
e r c u ry Cadmium T ellu ri de(M
C T)
dete cto r. On theL O PIR, the pr e
-An alo
g to D igital Co n v e rte r
(
A D C)
gain is adj
u sted u singj
umpe r s toam p l i fy the sign al befo r e it is d igitiz ed a nd s e nt to the c ompute r fo r pr o c e s sing.
T he L O P IR c a n be ope r ated in c o n
j
u n ctio n w ith AutoQ
u a nt Soft wa r e fo r Ga sPha s e S pe ctr al An alysis
(
a v ailab le fr omM
ID AC Co rpo r atio n in Ir vin e, Cal i fo r nia)
. T hepr ogr am r equir e s a c ompute r w ith 1 6
M
B of R AM
to fu n ctio n pr ope rl y. A utoQ
u a nta utomatic al ly c alc ulate s the single be am a n dabs o r ba n c e spe ctr a fr om the inte rfe r o gr ams
othe r pa r amete r s u s ed to dete rmin e the c onc en tr atio n a r e spe cifi ed in a method c r e ated by
the us e r. To c r e ate a method to a n alyz e a chem ic al c o n c e ntr atio n u sing Auto
Q
u a nt, ar efe r e n c e spe ctr um of the a n alyte mu st fi r st be s ele cted, w h ich mu st be of the s ame
r e s o lutio n a s the s ample spe ctr um. In the method
, the path le ngth of the in str ume nt mu st
be spe ci fi ed, alo ng w ith the c o n c e ntr atio n of the r efe r e n c e spe ctr um in p pm
* m
. A
r egion of the r efe r e n c e spe c tr um is s ele cted fo r the pr ogr am to u s e in qu a nti fi c atio n of
that chem ic al. Fa cto r s in v o lv ed in the choic e of the spe ctr al r egio n fo r qu a nti fi c atio n a r e
the r egio n of the spe ctr v im, the c onc e ntr ation of the a n alyte, the shape of the pe ak, the
size of the pe ak, a nd inte rfe r e nt pe aks. A uto
Q
u a nt al lows the ope r ato r to pr e s et thenumbe r of s c a n s to be c o ad ded fo r e a ch me a sur eme nt and the total numbe r of
me a s u r eme nts to be take n. I f de sir ed
, the inte rfe r ogr ams ca n be s a v ed. T he pr ogr am
al low s mo r e tha n o n e ba ckgr o u nd to be take n at a ny n um be r o f s c a n s. Multi ple
chemic als c a n be in cluded in the s ame method a nd c a n be qu a nti fi ed si multa n e o u sly.
T he pu rpo s e of th is r e s e a r ch is to e v alu ate the L O P I R '
s pe rfo rma n c e in
qu an ti fyin g chem ic als u n de r c o ntr ol led labo r ato ry c o nd itio n s, w iththe go al of ha ving the
LO PI R a c c epted a s a Natio n al In stitute of Oc c upatio n al Safet y a nd He alth
(
NIO SH)
method fo r indu str ial h ygie n e me a s u r eme nts. The En v ir o nme ntal Pr ote ctio n Age n cy
(
E P A)
ha s be e n in v esti ga ting F T I R methods fo r e n v ir o nme ntal me a s u r eme nts. Cu r r e ntly,the r e a r e thr e e pr opo s ed te st methods u sing e xtr a ctiv e F T I R spe ctr omete r s, Method 3 18,
M
ethod 3 2 0, a nd Method 3 21, and a pe rfo rmanc e spe ci fi c atio n fo r Extr a c tiv e FT I Rspe ctr omete r s w h ich a r e all awaitin g fi n al ap pr o v al. '^
-'' '^'^^
the An alys e s of Ga s e o u s Emis sio n s fr om Statio n a ry So u r c e s. *'*
' I
n ad d itio n , the EPA is
als o in v e stigating the u s e o f ope n
-path F T I R spe ctr omete r s fo r e n v ir o nme ntal
ap pl ic atio n s
/
^'The L OP I R is a hybri d of e x tr a ctiv e a nd ope n
-path spe ctr omete r
c o nfi gu r atio n s a nd is de stin ed fo r u s e in the e v alu atio n of o c c upatio n al e xpo s u r e s.
Indu strial hy gie n e methods a r e e v alu ated a c c o rd ing to c rite ria put fo rth by N I O S H. '^' "^
In o rde r fo r a n ew method to be ap pr o v ed a s a N I O SH method, c ompr ehe n siv e chambe r
a n d fi el d e v alu atio n stud ie s mu st be pe rfo rmed. The pr e cisio n
, b ia s, and a c c u racy of the
method n e ed to be dete rm in ed. * ^
In o rde r to be a c c ep tab le, b ia s mu st be 10% o r le s s
w ith 9 5% c o nfi de n c e. Pr e cisio n is the r elativ e st anda rd de v iatio n of a s et of
me a s u r eme nts fo r al l ge n e r atio n s of a c onc e ntr atio n o r o v e r a r a nge of c o n c e ntr atio n s.
The a c c u r a cy is defi n ed a s the ma xi mum e r r o r of the me a s u r eme nt giv e n a s a pe r c e ntage
of the c o n c e ntr atio n me a s u r ed that is giv e n w ith 9 0% c o nfi de n c e by that method. In
ad d itio n to the pr e cisio n , a c c u r a cy , a nd b ia s, the l i m it of dete ctio n
(
LO D)
a nd l i m it ofqu a nti fi c atio n
(
LOQ)
mu st be dete rmin ed. Inte rfe r e n c e s sho u l d be i de nti fi ed, a n dthe
ef fe ct of e n v ir o nme ntal pa r amete r s, s u ch a s tempe r atu r e, pr e s s u r e, a nd hum i d ity must be
e v alu ated. *' °' I
n the fi eld, si de -b
y- si d
e c ompa ris o n s w ith a c c epted NIOS H metho ds
M ole c ule s c a n take o n e n e rgy w he n they a r e e x po s ed to ele ctr omagn etic
r ad iatio n . The e x tr a e n e rg y c a n bo o st ele ctr o n s to a h ighe r le v el o r c a u s e the mole c ule to
str etch, be nd, o r r ot a te. Abs o rptio n of in fr a r ed
(
IR)
l ight c a u s e s vi br atio n al e n e rg ycha n ge s, i.e. str etch in g o r be nd ing of the mole c ule.
W
ith the e x c eptio n of eleme nts,in o rganic s alts, and d iatom ic mole c u le s
(
O2, N2, C I2)
, mo st s ubsta n c e s abs o rb in the IRr egio n Not o nl y mu st c ompo u nds ha v e bo nds to abs o rb in the I R , but als o a n y
mo v eme nt of the atoms in the mole c ule mu st c a u s e a rhyth m ic cha n ge in the d i pole
mome nt of the c ompo u nd.
M
ole c ule s w ith str o ng d ipole s w i l l u s u al ly ha v e str o n g I Rabs o rptio n. The wa v ele n gths abs o rbed by a c ompo u nd depe nd o n the r elativ e ma s s e s of
the atoms, their bond fo rc e c on sta nts, a nd the geometry of the at oms in the
mole c ule. ^' '
'' '^
T he r egio n of infr a r ed l i ght of gr e ate st inte r e st to chemists is the m i d-IR
(
4 0 0 0 to4 0 0/cm
)
.^^ °^ Th i
s r egio n c a n be d ivi ded into a fu n ctio n al gr o up r egio n
(
400 0-1300 /cm
)
a nd a fi nge rprint r eg io n
(
13 0 0-9 0 0 /cm)
. ^^ '^ In the fu n ctio n al gr o up r eg io n, c ommo n
cha r a cte ristic abs o rptio n s c a n be i de nti fi ed fo r v a rio u s ft mctio n al gr o ups,
(
s e e Tab le 1)
.C-C
, C
-0
, C
-N
C= C
, C
= 0 , C
=N , N
=N
C=C , C=N
C
-H, 0 -H
, N
-H
13 00-80 0/cm
19 0 0-1 50 0/cm
23 0 0-2 0 0 0 / cm
3 8 0 0-270 0/cm ^ ^ "^
Tab le 1 C ha r a cte ristic A bs o rptio n s
T he functio n al gr o up abs o r ptio n s can be u s ed to dete rm in e the cla s s of an unknown
c om po u nd, fo r e x ample, w hethe r it is a keto n e, c a rbo xyl ic a c i d, o r o x i de of nitr oge n . The
u s edto i de nti fya n u nkn ow n. En a ntiome r s, mole c ule s wh ich a r e mir r o r image s of one
a n othe r, w i l l giv e v e ry si m i la r I R abs o rptio n pat te r n s /
'
IR spe ctr a a r e u s ed qu alitativ el y fo r i de nti fi c atio n of a n u nkn own o r
qu a ntitativ ely to dete rmin e the c o n c e ntr atio n of a kn own c ompo u nd. The te chn iqu e c a n
be u s ed o n mo st c ompo u nds, but it do e s ha v e l i m itatio n s. Be c a u s e it pr o vi de s n o
s epa r atio n a ndmake s n o d istin ctio n be twe e n mo le c ule s in a s ample, it c a n be u s ed o n
si m p le m ixtu r e s w ith a l i m ited n um be r of c ompo n e nts. IR spe ctr ometry is n ot go od fo r
aqu e o u s s olutio n s be c a u s e wate r giv e s str o ng abs o rptio n in the I R r egio n.
^ ' C a rbo n
d io x i de abs o rbs in the I R a s wel l. T he fa ct that wate r v apo r an d c a r bo n d io x i de a r e
al ways pr e s e nt in the atmo sphe r e make s atmo sphe ric I R m e a s u r eme nts tricky. T he s e
c om mo n inte rfe r a nt c ompo u nds giv e str o n g abs o rptio n bands in the fol low in g r eg io n s
(
s e e Tab le 2)
.W
ate rCar bo n d io xi de
3 9 0 0-3 40 0 /cm 18 50- 13 50 /cm
2 3 5 0 /cm 6 6 7 /cm ^
' ^^
Tab le 2
W
ate r a nd Ca rbo n d io x i de Regio n sIn o rde r to a v oi d inte rfe r e n c e, the spe ctr al r egio n cho s e n to qu a nti fy the c om po u nd of
inte r e st sho ul d be o utsi de the s e r egio n s.
•
In o rde r fo r the info rmatio n fr om a single be am spe ctr um to be u s eful, the spe ctr al
fe atu r e s pr e s e nt du e to the s am p le mu st be is olated. Va riatio n s in instr ume nt r e spo n s e
a nda ny c ompo u nds n o rmal ly pr e s en t in the s ampl ing a r e a mu st be a c c o u nted fo r by
r ecorded with n o c ompo u n d of inte r e st pr e s e nt in the be am. T he s amp le a nd ba ck gr o u n d
sin gle be am spec tr a a r e r atio ed, a ndthe abs o rba n c e o r tr a n smis sio n spe ctr um r e s u lts.
A bs o rba n c e a nd tr a n sm is sio n a r e loga rith m ic al ly r elated te rms :
A= -lo
gi o
(
%T)
E qn . 1w he r e %T =
(
I/Io)
W
he r e : A = abs o rba n c e T= tr a n sm it ta n c e1= inte n sity of the s am p le spe ctr um Io
= inte n sit
y of the ba ckgr o u nd spe ctr um. '
A bs o rba n c e o r pe r c e nt tr a n smis sio n is then p lot ted v e r s u s wa v e n umbe r, g ivin gthe
abs o rbanc e o r tr a n sm is sio n spe ctr um.
Fo r qu a ntitativ e analysis, abs o rba n c e spe ctr a mu st be u s ed be c a u s e the height o r
ar e a o f the abs o rba n c e pe ak
(
A)
ispr opo rtio n al to the c o n c e ntr atio n of the a n alyte. Ther elatio n sh ip fol lows Be e r '
s Law :
A =8bc E
qn . 2
w he r e : A is the abs o rba n c e
(
height o r a r e a)
8 is the abs o rptiv ity of the c ompo u nd in
(p
pm *mete r s)
"^b is the path le ngth in mete r s
a nd c is the c o n c e ntra tio n in p pm . ^ '^
A bs o rptivity is a physic al pr ope rty of the c ompo u nd a n d is a c o n sta nt fo r the s ame
c ompo u nd at the s ame wa v enum be r. ^^ '^
Nois e is a r a ndom fl u ctu atio n in sign al str e n gth that c a n be c a u s ed by many
Be c a u s e ele ctric al me a s u r eme nts a r e qu a ntiz ed, the n um be r of p hoto n s emit ted w il l
fl u ctu ate r a ndom ly o v e r ti me w ith the n um be r of fl u ctu atio n s pr opo rtion al to the squ a r e
r o ot of the inte n sity of the be am. Sti l l mo r e n ois e c a n c ome fr om the dri ft of ele ctr o nic
c ompo n e nts that c ome s abo u t du e to cha n ge s in ma
j
o r e n vir o nme ntal c o nd itio n s, l i ketempe r atu r e. Th is ty pe of n ois e in c r e a s e s a s the sign al go e s up . Othe r s o u r c e s of n ois e
in clude the motio n of ele ctr o n s in cir c uits, w h ich is indepe nde nt of the inte n sity of the
si gnal.
^^ '^
T he sign al to n ois e ra tio
(
SNR)
is a me a s u r e of the amo u nt of n ois e in theme a s u r eme nt c ompa r edto the si gn al du e to the s am p le. In o rde r fo r a spe ctr al fe atu r e to
be c o n si de r ed " r e al,
"
the abs o rba n c e at that wa v ele ngth mu st be gr e ate r tha n thr e e ti me s
the n ois e in the sign al. T he L O D fo r a s ubsta n c e is c alc ulated a s the amo u nt of a n alyte,
w h ich w i l l g iv e a n abs o rba n c e pe ak with a si gn al w ith a n amp l itude that is thr e e ti me s the
n ois e, o r in othe r wo rds, ha s a n SNR of thr e e. The LO
Q
is c onsi de r edto be the amo u ntof s ubsta n c e, w h ich giv e s a n abs o rba n c e si gn al that is te n ti m e s the n ois e.
^^ ^^
Origin al ly, IR spe ctr ometry wa s pe rfo rmed u sin g o n ly d ispe r siv e in str ume nts. In
a d ispe r siv e spe ctr omete r, a prism s epa r ate s the br o ad ba n d be am into its c ompo n e nt
wa v ele n gths, a nd a sl it fi lte r s o ut al l bu t the de sir ed wa v ele ngths
(
s e e F i gv i r e 3)
.pn sm
I R l i g ht s o u r c e
(
3
Figu re 3 D ispe r siv e IR be am pr odu ctio n
W
he n the prism r otate s, the wa v elength pa s sing thr o ug h the fi lte r v a rie s. T her otatio n of the prism c a u s e s the in str ume nt to s c a n thr o ug h the infr a r ed wa v ele ngths, and
the dete cto r me a s u r e s the inte n sit y of the l ight. In d ispe r siv e in str ume nts, the be am is
sp l it into two pa rts T he fi r st pa rt tr a v els thr o ugh the s amp le c el l, a nd the othe r tr a v els
thr o ugh a b la nk c el l. The be am that tr a v els thr o u gh the bla nk c el l is the ba ck gr o u nd
(
s e eFigu r e 4
)
.to dete cto r
t
samp le cel l
I R l ight s o u r c e
(
~
^
1
be amspl it te r ba ck gr o u n d c el l
to dete cto r^^^
Figu r e 4 Dispe r siv e I R in str ume nt de sign
F T IR spe ctr omete r s u s e the s ame prin ciple s a s d ispe r siv e IR spe ctr omete r s, in that
both ty pe s of in str ume nts u s e IR l i ght abs o rptio n to i de nti fy a nd qu a nti fy c ompo u nds.
D ispe r siv e I R a nd F T IR spe ctr omete r s d i f fe r in that FT I R spe ctr omete r s take adv a ntage
o f c on str u ctiv e a nd de str u ctiv e inte rfe r e n c e of wa v e s to s c a n thr o ugh a la rge n um be r of
wa v ele ng ths quick ly.
Ce ntr al to F T I R spe ctr ometry is a de v ic e c al led a n inte rfe r omete r, w h ich is
in c o rpo r ated into al l FT I R in str ume nts. I t e x p loits the fa ct that l i g ht wa v e s c o n str u ctiv el
a nd de str u ctiv ely inte r fe r e with e a ch othe r c r e atin g pr ed ictab le inte rfe r e n c e pat te r n s with
the wa v ele ngths of I R l ight. To a c c om
pl ish th is, a n inte rfe r omete r ha s fo u r br a n che s.
On e br a n ch ho u s e s the I R l ight s o u r c e. T he l ight tr a v els fr om the s o u r c e to a
be amspl it te r. T he be amspl itte r is tr a n spa r e nt o n o n e half a nd r efl e ctiv e o n the othe r hal f.
As the be amspl it te r tu r n s, hal f of the optic al be am is s e nt into e a ch of two br a n che s. In
the f ir st br a n ch is a fi x ed m ir r o r a nd in the othe r is a mo v ing m ir r o r. T he pa rt of the
be am w h ich h its the mo vin g m ir r o r w i l l ha v e tr a v eled a d is ta n c e w h ich is d i f fe r e nt fr om
the pa rt of the be am w h ich h it the fi x ed m ir r o r . Ea ch pa rt of the be am bo u n c e s of f a
m ir r o r a n dthe n, at the be amspl it te r, the be am r e c om b in e s a nd is d ir e cted into the fo u rth
br a n ch of the inte rfe r omete r. Th is r e c om b in ed be am the n pa s s e s thr o u gh the s am p le a nd
into the dete cto r
(
s e e F i gu r e 5)
. ^^ '^A mo v i ng mi r r o r
I R l i g ht s o u r c e
(
^
~\
V
be amsp l it te r
fi x ed m ir r o r
to s amp le, dete cto r
^^ '^
Figu r e 5 Inte rfe r omete r
W
he n the mo ving m ir r o r a nd the fi x ed m ir r o r a r e at the s ame d ista n c e fr om thebe amsp l it te r, al l of the wa v ele ng ths c o n str u ctiv el y inte rfe re in the r e c om b in ed be am, a nd
the si gn al is ma x imiz ed. T h is c o r r e s
po nds to the z e r o path d i f fe r e n ce
(
Z PD)
. T her e s u lting point in the inte rfe r ogr am is a h i gh inte n sity pe ak c al led the c e nte rbu rst. If the
be am w h ich h it the mo ving mir r o r w i l l ha v e tr a v eled a dista n c e d if fe r e nt fr om the s e c o nd
pa rt of the o ptic al be am, w h ich str u ck the fi x ed m ir r o r. The m ir r o r d ispla c eme nt
(
A)
isthe d ista n c e of the mo ving m ir r o r fr om the po sitio n of z e r o path di f fe r e n c e. The
d i f fe r e n c e in the d ista n c e the two be ams tr a v el is c al led the optic al path d i f fe r e n c e
(
6)
which is tw ic e the m ir r o r d ispla c eme nt
(
5= 2 A)
. Co n str u ctiv e a nd de str u ctiv e inte rfe r e n c ein the r e c omb in ed be am c a u s e a pat te r n c al led the inte rfe r ogr am w he n the l ight r e a che s
the dete cto r.
^^'^ '^
T he inte rfe r ogr am is the p lot of l i ght inte n sity v s. optic al path
d i f fe r e n c e a n d is the r esult of the supe rpo sitio n of the wa v elen gths pr e sent in the beam
(
s e e Figu r e 6)
. ^ 'c
»*«♦
optic al path d i f fe r e n c e
F igu r e 6 Inte rfe r o gr am
A ft e r pa s sing thr o ugh the s am p le, the optic al be am is r efo c u s ed o nto a dete cto r
fi lame nt. The dete cto r sign al is pr opo rtio n al to the inte n sity of the I R l ight that h its it. I R
p hoto n s a r e abs o rbed, givin g the ele ctr ons in the dete cto r fi lame nt h i g he r e n e rg y. Ha ving
h ighe r e n e rg y ele ctr o n s is n ot e n o u gh to pr odu c e a si gn al. A v oltage is ap p l ied a c r o s s the
fi lame nt, a nd the h i gh e n e rg y ele ctron s ge n e r ate a n ele ctric al c u r r e nt. Th is c u r r e nt is
T he sign al mu st be c o n v e rted fr om a c u r r e nt to a d igital sign al that the c ompute r
c a n u nde r sta nd. This c o n v e r sio n is acc ompl ished by the a n alog to d igital c o n v e r te r
(
A D C)
. The A D C is made up of b its. T v«o r ais ed to the powe r of the n um be r of b its is
the la r ge st si gn al that c a n be ha nd led by the ADC. A n AD C w ith a h igh n um be r of b its is
de sir ab le. The d yn amic r a nge of the AD C is the di ffe r enc e betwe e n the h ighe st a nd
lowe st sign als it c a n hand le. In F T IR, the siz e of the c e nte rbu r st is the sign al str e ngth
that dete rm in e s how much of the A D C dyn amic r a nge is u s ed. If the ce nte rbu r st is to o
la r ge, the inte rfe r o gr am is c ut of f, a nd the SNR w i l l n ot be i mpr o v ed by c o ad d ing spe ctr a.
To ad
j
u st the siz e of the inte rfe r ogr am c e nte rbu r st, the gain s ett in g is u s ed. ^ ^'A ft e r the in te rfe r o gr am is d i g itiz ed a nd r e a che s the c ompute r, the Fo u rie r
Tr a n sfo rm is the mathematic al tr a n sfo rmatio n that cha nge s the inte rfe r ogr am, a plot of
inte n sity v s. optic al path d i f fe r e n c e, to a single be am spe ctr um, a plot of inte n sity v s.
wa v e n vmibe r
(
s e e Figu r e 7)
. '^^ '^c
ff'%^* !>
W
a v e n um be r(
cm'
)
FT IR spe ctr omete r s ha v e ma ny adv an tage s o v e r dispe r siv e I R in str ume nts. T he s e
adv a ntage s in clu de a h ig he r SNR a nd gr e ate r s e n sitiv ity and pr e cisio n . The SNR a nd
s e n sitivity of a n F T I R spe ctr omete r a r e bet te r tha n tho s e of d ispe r siv e in str uments
be ca us e al l wa v ele n g ths of the l ight r e a ch the dete cto r at the s ame ti me, a s c ompa r ed to a
dispe r siv e in str ume nt w he r e o nly a few wa v ele ngths r e a ch a dete cto r at a ny o n e time.
The s e n sitivity of the dete cto r in c r e a s e s w ith the inte n sity o f the IR l ight that r e a che s the
detecto r. The fa ct that al l of the wav ele ngths r e a ch the dete c to r at the s ame ti me g iv e s a
bet te r SNR be c a u s e a ny n ois e pr e s e nt in the sign al is sha r ed amo ng al l of the
wa v ele n gths.
^' ''^ '^
A d d itio n al r e a s o n s fo r bette r SN R in FT I R in str ume nts tha n in d ispe r sive
in str ume nts in clu de the fa ct that FTI R spe ctr omete r s allow s c a n s take n at c o n stan t
r e s olutio n to be c o ad ded, s o that r a ndom f lu ctu atio n s in the si gnal w i l l c a n c el e a c h othe r
o u t, r edu cingthe n ois e. Using mo r e c o ad ded s c a n s w i l l giv e a bet te r SNR. In ad d itio n ,
the n ois e in me a s u r eme nts depe nds o n the amo u nt of the ti me spe nt me a s u ring that
wa v e n um be r. F T IR in str ume nts spe nd m u ch m o r e ti m e obs e r vin g e a ch wa v ele ngth
du ring e a ch s c an c om pa r edto d ispe r siv e in str uments.
^" '^ '^
FT I R spe ctr omete r s als o ha v e gr e ate r pr e cisio n than d ispe r siv e I R in str uments
beca u s e they in c o rpo r ate a Hel ium-N
e o n la s e r a s a n inte rnal wa ven umbe r sta n da rd.
T he se la s e r s ha v e a wa v e n umbe r of 15,7 9 8.6 3 7 /cm, a nd al l the I R wa v e n um be r s are
me a s u r ed r elativ e to it. T he la s e r is als o u s ed to tr a ck the
po sitio n of the mo ving m ir r o r .
la s e r w i l l c on str u ctiv ely inte rfe r e e v e ry 0.63 2 |Lim. The dista n c e the moving m irr o r ha s
tr a v eled is dete rm in ed u sing the n um be r of ma x ima in the inte rfe r o gr am of the la s e r. On e
l i m itatio n of the F T I R sin gle be am te chniqu e is that the ba ck gr o u nd is me a s u r ed at
a n othe r ti me tha n the sam p le, c ompa r ed w ith d ispe r siv e I R spe ctr o s c op y w he r e the
ba ck gr o u nd is c ol le cted at the s ame time a s the s amp le. ^^ ^'^ ^^
Re s olutio n, SN R, and s am p l ing ti me af fe ct e a ch othe r, a n d mu st be opti m iz ed
a c c o rd ing to the n e eds of the s ample. R e s olutio n is a me a s u r e of the in str ume nt '
s ab i l ity
to dete ct spe ctr al fe atu r e s that a r e clo s e to e a ch othe r. In o rde r to r e s olv e fe atu r e s , the
wa v ele ngths at w h ich the fe atu r e s ap pe a r mu st go in , the n o ut, and fi n al ly ba ck into
pha s e. In c r e a sing the optic al path d i f fe r e n c e giv e s bet te r r e s olutio n . A t h ighe r
r e s olutio n s, the r e a r e mo r e data points. T he n um be r of data points c a n be dete rm in ed by
the fo l low ing equ atio n :
W
a v e n umbe r r a nge / r e s o lutio n = n umbe r o f data points. E qn .3Be c a u s e r e s o lutio n is a me a s u r e of the minimum d ista n c e s epa r ating two fe atu r e s at
w h ichthey c a n be d is tinguished o n a spe ctr um, r e s olutio n improv e s a s the n um be r
de s c ri b ing it de c r e a s e s. ^^ '^
C ha r a cte ristic s of the s amp le c a n c o ntri bute to po o r r e s olutio n . T he w i dth of the
abs o rba n c e ba nds fo r a n y c om po u n d depe nd o n the n um be r of inte r a ctio n s that spe cie s
has w ith d i f fe r e nt chem ic al e n vir o nme nts. The n um be r of chemic al e n vir o nme nts a
man y d i f fe r e nt ty pe s of mo le c u le s a r e in the s ample. In a s ample that c o n sists of o n e
pur e s ubsta n c e, the spe cie s of inte r e st
o nly c ome s into c o nta ct w ith its elf; it ha s few
chemic al e n vir o nme nts. T he w i dth of the ban ds is als o in f lu e n c ed b y the atmo sphe ric
c o n d itio n s of the s ample, s u ch a s the tempe r atu r e a n d pr e s s u r e. In o r de r to opti m iz e the
time fo r the me a s u r eme nts, the r e s olutio n sho uld be s et s o that it is 4
-5 ti me s bet te r tha n
the n a r r owe st pe ak. In ga s e s, the mole c ule s a r e v e ry fa r apa rt and inte r a ct w ith few othe r
mole c ule s; thu s, they ha v e v e ry n a r r ow ba n ds.
W
hen me a s u rin gga s e s, h igh r e s olution isn e ededto r e s olv e the spe ctr a. *^ ^'
N ois e in c r e a s e s a s the r e s olutio n i mpr o v e s be c a u s e the n ois e is c o n sta nt o v e r the
w hole inte rfe r ogr am. At h ighe r res olu tio n s, the optic al path d i ffe r e n c e is lo nge r, the
inte rfe r ogr am w ill ha v e lo n ge r si de a rms, a nd the n ois e wi l l be a h i ghe r pe r c e ntage of the
total sign al. To obtain a h igh SN R at h igh r e s olutio n, it is be st to c o ad d ma ny s c an s
The h ighe r the num be r of s c a n s, the h ighe r the s am p l ing ti me. Thu s, the ope r ato r mu st
de cide to bala n c e a r e a s o n ab le s amp l ing ti me with hi gh r e s olutio n a nd a go od SN R. ^^ ' '
The n ois e in the me a s u r eme nts is r epo rted asr o ot me a n squ a r e
(
RM
S)
n ois e. It isc alc ulated by tak ing two ba ck -to -b
a ck me a s u r eme nts a n d u sing the f ir st a s the
ba ckgr o u ndto c r e ate a n abs o rba n c e spe ctr um w ith the s e c o nd. A r eg io n of the spe ctr um
1 0-2 0 data
points in w i dth is s ele cted in a n a r e a of inte r e st. In the r eg io n cho s en
, a be st
fi t lin e is plot ted, a nd the r o ot mea n squ a r e d i f fe r e n c e of the data
points fr om the l in e is
c alc u lated. R
M
S n ois e is a n i mpo r ta nt pa r amete r fo r tr a ck ing in str ume nt pe rfo rman c e
In F T IR a n alysis, qu a nti fi c atio n of chemic al c o n c e ntr atio n s is pe rfo rmed u sin g
r efe r e n c e spe ctr a. Be c a u s e B e e r '
s Law is a s s umedto be l in e a r, the c ali br atio n c u r v e is
the l in e fr om the point
(
0,0)
to the po in t g iven by the r efe r e n c e spe ctr um on a c u r v eplot teda s abs o rba n c e v s. c o n c e ntr atio n . In th is plot, the c o n c e ntr atio n is giv e n a s the
pr odu ct of the c o n c e ntr atio n in p pm a nd the path le n gth u s ed fo r data c o l le ctio n in mete r s
(
s e e F i gu r e 8)
.X) <
(p p
m* m, A
)
Figu r e 8 Cal i br atio n c u r v e
Co n c en tr atio n
(p p
m* m)
T he c o n c e ntr atio n s of the r efe r e n c e spe ctr a a r e given a s the pr odu ct of c o n c e ntr atio n a n d
path le n gth, p p m * m
, s o that the abs o rbanc e, A ^^ebc i
s sta nda rd iz ed. A n in str ume nt w ith
a ny path le ngth c a n be u s edto c ol le ct the s ample spe ctr a.
W
ith the path le ngth an d
abs o rba n c e kn own, the c o n c e ntr atio n c a n be fo u nd:
bl C l^ 2 C 2=A l/ A Eqn. 4. 1
s o, A2bi C ]/ A ]b2 =
C 2 Eqn. 4.2
w he r e, A i is the abs o rba n c e o f the r efe r e n c e spe ctr um
b] C i is the c o n c e ntr atio n o f the r efe r e n c e spe ctr um in p pm* m
ba is the path le ngth fo r the s ample spe ctr um
In o rde r to be a c c u r ate, t he r efe r e n c e spe ctr um c o n c e ntr atio n in p pm
* m m
u st be
h ighe r than the s amp le c o n c entr ation in ppm*m. In ad d ition
, the r efe r e n c e and s amp le
M
et hodsT he L O P I R wa s pla c ed in side a stainle s s ste el cham be r, 2 '
6" x 2
' 6"
x6 '
8"
, wh ich
wa s 10 19 L in v olume w ith the in str ume nt in si de. T he cham be r hadtwo 4
"
e x ha u st
v alv e s. On e of the s e e xha u st v alv e s c o ul d be ope n ed fo r make
-up air
, a nd the othe r wa s
c o n n e cted to the labo r ato ry e xha u st system. T he cham be r als o had fo u r 1/4
"
Swagelok
port s. T wo of the S wagelok port s we r e u s ed fo r the pump in
j
e ctio n s, a nd two we r e u s edfo r syrin ge in
j
e ctio n s.C hem ic al s ele ctio n wa s ba s ed o n to xicity, T LV , u s age in indu stry, fu n ctio n al
gr o ups, a nd str u ctu r e. Fr om an initial l ist of chemic als c om mo nly u s ed in in du stry,
chemic als, w h ich we r e simi la r in structu r e a n d fu n ctio n al gr o up, we r e el i m in ated. T he
adv e r s e he alth ef fe cts, w h ich the TLV wa s s et to pr e v e nt, we r e take n into a c c o u nt, a nd
the chem ic al w ith the lowe r to x icity wa s cho s e n . The chem ic als s ele cted had v a ried
str u ctu r e s a nd fu n ctio n al gr o ups, in clud ing a keto n e gr o up, a n o x i de of nitr o ge n, a nd a
ch lo rin ated hydr o c a rbo n.
K n own c o n c e ntr atio n s of trich lo r o ethyle n e, methyl ethyl keto n e, a ndn itr o u s
o x i de we r e ge n e r ated in the cham be r b y in
j
e cting 500 p pm ga s e s in nitr oge n(
+/ -1%)
.T he in
j
ectio n v olumeswer e ge n e r ated u sing spe cial l y made filter fl a sks. F i lt er fl asksfr om 12 5 to 20 0 0 m L we r e alte r edto in clu de two a rm s 1/4" in d iamete r. On e a ch a rm
was a stopc o ck and Swagelok c o n necto r . In ad d itio n , the o rigin al a rm wa s remo v ed, a nd
Swagelok
stopc o ck
stopc o ck
Swagelok
Fi gu r e 9 Fla sk
T he v olume of the fl a sks wa s dete rmin ed by fil l ing the fl a sk w ith wate r a n d
me a s u rin gthe amo u n t of wate r in e a ch fl a sk w ith gr adu ated cyl in de r s. T h is pr o c e s s wa s
r epe ated thr e e ti me s fo r e a ch fl a sk
(
s e e Table 3)
.F la sk siz e
(
mL)
125
250
5 0 0 10 0 0
10 0 0
2 0 00
2 0 0 0
A ctual v olume
(
mL)
17 5 2 8 0 5 87 118 0
117 5 2 1 9 4
2 12 3
Standa rd de viatio n
0.5 8 5.0 3
1.73 0.5 8
1.15
0.96 2.2 2
T ab le 3 F la sk Volume s
The v olume of the tub ing u s ed in the e xperi me nts wa s fo u nd u sin g the d iamete r
a nd length of e ach p ie ce of tub ing
(
s e e Tab le 4)
.Tub in g Volume
(
m L)
B l 3 2. 1
B2 3 9.0
B3 3 2.4
Fo r e a ch e xpe rime nt, thr e e ba ck gr o u n ds we r e take n at 2 5 6 s c a n s. Beg inning in
Ja n u a ry 19 9 8, a nitr oge n pu r ge wa s pe rfo rmed in the cham be r prio r to tak ing the
ba ckgr o u n ds a n d ge n e r atin g the s ample. The in
j
e ctio n wa s pr epa r ed by f low in g 50 0p pmga s thr o u gh a f la sk u nti l the n um be r of air e x cha nge s wa s suf f icie nt fo r the e ntir e v olv ime
of the f la sk to be 50 0p pm, at le a st 2 0 m in ute s. The stopc o cks we r e clo s ed, a nd the n the
f la sk wa s c o n n e cted to the cham be r in s e ries w ith a pump.
e xha u st v alv e
pump
fl a sk
Figu r e 1 0 C ham be r s et-u p
A ir wa s pum ped fr om the cham be r, thr o u gh the fl a sk, a nd ba ck into the cham be r.
The pump wa s al lowed to r u n u nti l the c o n c e ntr atio n me a s u r ed by the L O PI R r e a ched
ste ad y state, a nd the n the pum p wa s tu r n ed of f, aft e r w h ich fi v e me a s u r eme nts at 12 8
s c a n s pe r me a s u r eme nt we r e a v e r aged. T he a v e r age c o n c e ntr atio n me a s u r ed wa s
c ompa r ed w ith the e x pe cted c o n c e ntr atio n . T he e xpe cted c o n c e ntr ation wa s c alc ulated
V ,
* C
i= V c* Cc
So , Cc
=V
i* Ci/V c
E qn. 5.1
Eqn . 5.2
W
he r e, V iwa s the v olume inj
e ctedCiwa s the c o n c e ntr atio n in
j
e ctedVc was the total v o lume of the chambe r, tub ing, and fl a sks
And Cc wa s the c o n c e ntr atio n c alc ulated in the cham be r.
The v olume of the cham be r wa s dete rmin ed w ith the in str ume nt in si de the cham be r
(
s e eA p pen d ix A
)
. The r e s olutio n wa s 0.5 /cm, and tria ng le apod iz ation wa s u s ed. Ea c hc o n c e ntr atio n wa s r epe ated a ta rget of fo u r ti me s
(
s e e Tab le 5)
.C hem ic al
N itr o u s o x i de
Trich lo r o ethy le n e
Methyl ethyl keto n e
Ra nge
0.0 8 5 5 - 0
.86 2 p pm
0.0 84 4 - 1
.0 56 p pm
0.0 8 5 3
- 0
.2 8 6 p pm
Tab le 5 Co n c e ntr atio n r a nge s stud ied
T he Ha n st l ibr a ry r efe r e n c e spe ctr a we r e u s ed fo r the qu a nti ficatio n of nitr o u s
ox i de, trich lo r o ethyle n e, a n d methy l eth y l keto n e. 3
M
ge n e r ated r efe r e n c e spe ctr a we r eused fo r the quanti fi c ation of ethy le ne a nd S Fe
(
s ee Tab le 6)
.(
Fo r e x amp le s of r efe r e n c espe ctr a, s e e Ap pe ndix B.
)
C hemic al Refe r e n c e Co n c e ntr ation Reg ion fo r
Q
ua nti fi c ationMethyl ethyl keto n e 762 p pm* m 1 1 4 4.0 - 12 3 3.9 /cm
T rich lo r o ethyle n e 2 82 p pm* m 9 0 9.7
- 9 67 .4 /cm
N itr o u s o xi de 80 p pm * m 2 17 4.9 - 2 2 55.0 /cm
Sul fu r he x afl uo ri de 2.9 9 p pm
* m 9 3 8
. 1
- 10 17
.4 /cm
Ethyle n e 2 0 6.6 ppm
*m 8 5 8
.7 - 1 13 2
.0 /cm
Tab le 6 Refe r e n c e spe ctra c o n c e ntr atio n s a nd r eg io n s fo r qu a nti fi c ation
W
ith the c o v e r s o n the in str ume nt, o n e ba ck gr o u nd wa s take n at 2 5 6 s c a n s, a nd the n ultr ah igh pu r ity n itr oge n wa s f lowed thr o u gh the c el l u nti l the spe ctr al wate r l in e s stop ped
be c om ing n egativ e. T he nitr oge n f low wa s c o ntin u ed w h i le thr e e ba ckgr o u nds we r e
take n at 2 5 6 s c a n s. T he n ethy le n e wa s al lowed to f low thr o ugh the c ell u nti l the
c o n c e ntr atio n r e a ched a ste ad y state. ^' ^^
Ea ch me a s u r eme nt wa s pe rfo rmed by c o ad d ing
12 8 s c a n s. Fiv e me a s u r eme nts we r e a v e r a
ged, a n d the pathle ngth wa s the n c alc ulated:
BiCi = B2C2 Eqn . 6. 1
s o, B2= B]C,/ C2 Eqn . 6.2
w he r e : B i wa s the o r igin al pathle n gth
Ci wa s the c o n c e ntr atio n me a s u r ed
B2 wa s the new, c alc ulated path le n gth
a n d C2 wa s the c o n c e ntr atio n of ethyle n e in the cyl inde r
(
s e e T ab le 7)
.Date
8 /20 / 97
1 0/4/ 97
1/ 1 3/ 9 8
Path le n gth
3 0.6 6
3 6.2 8
3 9.4 3
Tab le 7 Path le ngths u s ed
The data we r e an alyz ed fo r b ia s, pr e cisio n, a n d a c c u r a cy, a s wel l a s L O D a nd
LO
Q
. B ia s, pr e cisio n, a nd a c c u r a cy we r e c alc u lated u sin g the method pr e s e nted in theN I O SH Gui del in e s fo r Sampl ing a nd Analytical
M
ethod De v elopment a n d Ev alu ationA ppe nd ix 1
, a s s umin g that the b ia s wa s n ot known , a nd the tr u e c o n c e ntr atio n s we r e
known by stoich iometr ic dete rm in atio n . Pr e cisio n was defi n ed a s the r elativ e sta nda rd
deviatio n of a s et of mea s u r eme nts at c o n c e ntr atio n i. T he equ atio n u s edto fi n dthe
J H i
Sri 2=
/
I 2(
Ciji- Cij)
'E qn . 7
J
(
ni - 1)
Cj
W
he r e : J wa s the n um be r of ge n e r atio n s of c o n c e ntr atio n iH i wa s the n um be r of me a s u r eme nts du rin g e a ch ge n e r atio n of i Cijiwa s a sing le me a s u r eme nt
Cjj wa s the a ver age of the me a s u r eme nts du ring e a ch ge n e r atio n of i
Ci wa s the a v e r age of the me a s u r eme nts o v e r al l ge n e r atio n s at i
/
" '^T he b ia s wa s defi n ed asthe r elativ e d i f fe r e n c e betwe e n the mea n of the me as ur eme nt s
and the c alc ulatedc o n c e ntr atio n. T he equ atio n u s ed to fi nd the b ia s fo r e a ch
c o n c e ntr atio n ge n e r ated wa s :
Ci
Bi = - 1
E qn. 8 e i
W
he r e : &i wa s the c alc ulated c onc e ntr ationCi wa s the a v e r age of me a s u r eme nts o v e r al l ge n e r atio n s of c o n c e ntr atio n i^ ^^
T he o v e r al l b ia s wa s c alc ulated u sing the fol low ing equ ation:
^ S B
i
B =
E qn. 9 k
W
he r e :k wa s the n um be r of c o n c e ntr atio n s ge n e r ated And Bjwa s the b ia s at e a ch c o n c e ntr atio n i.^^°^
T h is equatio n a s s umed that the n umbe r of me a s u r eme nts pe r ge n e r ation of e a ch
c o n c e ntr atio n we r e equal a ndthat the n um be r of ge n e r atio n s pe r c o n c e ntr atio n we r e
equ al. T he po oledpr e cisio n wa s c alc ulated u sin g the fol low ing equ atio n :
S„
^
i :(
f,(
S™)
'/ f
)
E qn . 1 0W
he r e : Sr xi is the pr e cisio n at e a ch c o n c e ntr atio n fi is degr e e s of fr e edom, m- 1
a nd f is the s um of al l fi * ' °^
W
he n c alc ulating the po oled pr e cisio n a nd s ubs equ e nt c o nfide n c e statistic s fo rpr e cisio n , the r e c om me n ded pum p e r r o r of 0.0 5 wa s n ot in cluded be c a u s e the L OP I R d i d
n ot u s e a pump. The 9 5% c o n fide n c e inte r v al fo r po oled pr e cisio n and o v e r al l b ia s
, as
well a s the a c c u r a cy a nd 9 0% c o nfide n c e inte r v al fo r a c c u r a cy we r e c alc ulated u sin ga
SA Sal go rithm pr e s e nted by NIO SH
(
s e e Ap pe nd ix C)
.^" ^'
T he a c cu r a cy is c alc ulated in
two ways by the al go rithm :the Bo nfe r r o ni pr o c edu r e a nd the hy pe rbol ic ap pr o x i matio n .
Fo r trichlo r o eth yle n e a nd m ethyl ethyl keto n e, the N IO SH r e c om me nded method
fo r c alc ulatin g the po oledpr e cisio n a n d o v e r al l b ia s we r e n ot ap pl ic ab le be c a u s e the
Re s u lts
In o rder to fi nd the L O D a nd L O
Q
, ba ck to ba ck sin gle be am spe ctr a we r e u s ed tomake an abs o rbanc e spe ctr um. The R
M
S n ois e wa s c alc ulated in thr e e r egio n s : 9 7 0- 9 5 0
,
12 90- 1270
, a nd 2 8 40
-2 8 20
(
s e eA p pe nd ix D
)
. The a v e r age RM
S n ois e wa s c alc ulated ine a ch r egio n a nd fo u n dto be 1.8x 10 "^
in the r egio n of the spe ctr um fr om 97 0- 9 5 0 /cm
,
3.3x 1 0
"^
in the r eg io n fr om 129 0- 12 7 0 /cm
, a nd 3.3x 10
"^
in the r egion fr om
2 84 0-2820 /cm
(
s e e T ab le 8)
.
Regio n 9 7 0-9 5 0 /
cm 12 9 0- 12 7 0 /cm
^
2 84 0-2 8 2 0 /
cm
A v e r age R
M
Sn ois e l.Sx l O -'3.3x 10 3.3x 10
"
Tab le 8A v e r age R
M
S n ois eThe L OD a nd L O
Q
we r e c alc ulated using the RM
S n ois e c alc ulated fo r e a chr eg io n o n e a ch date
(
s e e A p pe nd ix E)
. T he lowe st l i m it of dete ctio n at a 4 0 m path le ng thwa s 0.0 09p pm fo r nitr o u s o x i de
, 0.015pp m fo r trich lo r o ethyle n e, a n d 0. 11 1ppm fo r
methyl ethyl keto n e. T he lowe st l i m it o f qu an ti fi c atio n at a 4 0 m path le n g th wa s 0 .0 32
pp m fo r nitr o u s o xi de, 0.05 p pm fo r trich lo r o eth y len e
, and 0.3 7 1 fo r methyl eth y l keto n e
(
s e e Tab le 9)
.Fo r trich lo r o ethyle n e, w he n the me a s u r edc o n c e ntr atio n s w e r e plot ted v s. the
c alculated c o n c e ntr atio n s, the be st f it l in e had a slope o f 0.94 0 3, inte r c ept of 0.0 16 3, a nd
R^ v alu e of 0.99 8 4