SU
SA N L YN N BAR BE E
.Ap pli
c atio n o
f I
nVitr o
C
el l
Cu
lt
u r eA
s s ay t
oC
ry p t
o sp
oh diu
mp
a r v umo o c
y
st In a ct i
v atio n
b y Th
e rmal P
r o c e s s e s(
U
nde r
the
dir e c
tio n o
f M
a rk D
.So
bs e
y
)
C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
mis a n
i
mp
o rt
a nt
w ate r
bo r n e
p
atho
g
e n a nd
it
s o o cy
sts a r e v e ry p
e r sis
te nt
in
th
e e n vi
r o nme nt
a nd
v e ry
r e sis
ta nt t
o che
mic a
l
dis
in
f
e ctio
n.In a
ctiv atio n o
f
Cr
y p t
o sp
ori d iu
mp
a r v um o o cy
sts
b y h
e at i
s ap
ote n
tia
l d is
in
f
e ctio n
p
r o c e s sf
o r w at
e r, w a ste w a
t
e r a nd
b
i
o s oli
ds
.W
es
t
ud ie
d the
k in e
t ic s a n
d
e xt
e nt of t he r
mal in a cti
v atio n o
f C
.p
a rw
m o o cy
sts
in
bu
ffe r e
d
w at
e r at
35
° ,4
9
'
,
5
0
°,
5 5
"a n
d
60
°C,
a nd
by th
e rmoph ili
c a n a e r ob i
cdi
g
e sti
o n of
c o w ma n u r e at 55
°C
u s
in
g
mam mal ia n c e
ll
c ult
u r eto
q
u a ntify
o o cy
sts
in
fe c
ti
vity
.Co
mp
a ri
s o n s of i
nfe c
tio u s o o c
y
stc o n c e n
tr a
tio n s
be
tw e e n u n
tr e at
ed
c o ntr o
l
s a nd the rm
ally t
r e at
ed
s amp l
e sin
d ic a
t
ed
sig
nific a n
t
lo s s e s o
f
o o cy
st in
f
e ctivity by hig h
e rte
mp
e r at
u r ethe r
mal t
r e at
me nt in
b
oth
mil ie u
.W hile
t he r e
wer e o n
ly
min o r r e
du c
tio n s o
f
o o cy
st i
nf
e ctiv
ity
in
bu
ffe r e
d
w at
e r aft
e r24
ho u r s a
t
23
° a nd 35
°C,
te
mp
e r at
u r e s of 55
°a n
d
60
°C
r edu c e
d
o o cy
st infe ctiv
it y by 9
9
.9%
with in
6
0
min u
t
e s.Ex
p
o s u r e at
5 5
°C
in a n a e r o
bic a
lly di g
e st
ed
ma n u r ef
o r60
mi
n ute s r e
d
u c ed
o o cy
st inf
e ctiv
ity by 9 9
.9%
,b
ut i
nthe u n
t
r e ated
ma n u r e o o cy
st i
nfe ctiv
ity
w a s st
ab le
fo r
ma ny h
o u r s at 2 3
°C
.T h
e s ed
ata
de
mo n str at
etha
t the
i
nf
e ctiv
ity
of
C
.p
a r v um o o cy
sts
is r a
pi dly
a nd
e xte n s
iv e
ly
r ed
u c ed i
n w ate r
a n
d b
o vin e
ma n u r e at t he r
mop hi li
cte
mp
e r atu r e s a s
lo w a s
5 5
°A C K N OW
L ED G M E NT S
I
w o uld l ike
t
oth
a nk D
rM
a rkSo
bs e
y fo
rhi
sg
ui da n c e a n
d
adv
ic e
du r
i
ng
my
stu
d y i
nt he
D
ep
a rtm
e nt
of En v
i
r o nme nt
al S
cie n c e s a n
d En
g
in e e r
in
g
.He
h
a sbe e n
my
adv o c a
te
du r
in
g
e v e ry
s
te
p
of
my g
r ad
u ate
t
r ain
in
g
, a nd I
r emai
nI
n a w e of h is u n e n
di
ng k
n o wle
d g
e a nd
hi
s ab
ility t
oj
ug gl
e a millio n
thi
ng
s at
o n c e.I
amg
r at
ef
ul to
Dr
.M ic
ha e
l A itke n
,Dr
.Ge
da
l ia
h S he
la
f
a nd D
r.M i ke
Ar r o w o o
d f
o rt he
i
rhe
lpf
ul
adv
ic e
, c om me nts a n
d
s upp
o rt d
u rin
g t h
e c o u r s e of t his r e s e a r c
h
.I
w o uld
als o
l ike
to
th
a nk
D
r.Ric
ha r
d Se e
d fo r c o
min
g t
o my
a s sis
t
a n c e a nd be
in
g
o n e of
my t
e ch
nic a
l
r ep
o rt
r e ad
e r s at the
la s
t p
o s si ble
mome nt
.I th
a nk Do u
g
W
ait
a nd D
o r oth y T h
o mp
s o nf
o r alw a
y
sbe
in
g th
e r e wh
e nI
n e ede
d
t he
m a nd
p
r o vidi
ng
a n e n vir o n
me nt
wh
e r ela
b
o r ato r
y
r e s e a r ch
c o ul
d p
r o c e ed
wit h th
e utm
o st
effic
i
e n cy
.T
oa
l l t he
p
a st
a nd
p
r e s e nt l
abm
at
e s a nd
st
ud
e nt
s, my th
a nk
sf
o r all t h
ehe
lp
a nd fr
ie n
ds
hip
alo n
g th
ew a
y
.i
e sp
e cia
lly
app
r e ci
at
et he
lo v
in
g
s up p
o rt
of
my h
u sba n
d,
J
ohn
, a nd d
a ug
hte r
,Elle n
.T he
y
g
a v e met he
fr e e
d
om,ti
me a nd
lo v e
I
n e ede
d
to
p
u r s u ethis
d
eg
r e e.T h is
p
r oj
e ct w a s s up
p
o rte
d b
y t h
eE
n vir o n m e n
t
al
S
y
ste
ms,Lim
ite
d
-a s u
bs
idi
a ry
of the
T A B L E
O
F
C
ON T EN T S
A B
S
T R A C T
i.
A C KN O W L ED
G
M EN T S
ii
.T A B L
E O
F
CO
N T E NT
S
ii i.
LI
S
T
O
F T A B LE
S
vi.
L I
S
T
O
F F I
G
U R E
S
vil
.C
H A P
T
E
R 1
:IN T R
O
D
UC
T I
O
N
1
.C
H A P
T E
R
2
:LIT ER AT
U
R
E
R E
V
I
E
W
P
atho
g
e nC
ha r a c
te r
istic s
H i
sto ry
3
.T
a x o n omy
4
.L ife
C y
cle
5
.C
ry pt
o sp
o ridi
o sis
7
.T
r a n smis s
io n
9
.W
ate r
bo r n e
O
utb
r e ak
s10
.A
n aly
sis o
f C
ry p t
o sp
o ri
d
iu
mC
o n c e nt
r at
i
o n a nd Re c o v e r
y
11
.W
at
e rS
ampl
e s11
.O
rg
a nic
S
amp l
e s -F
e c e s,
S
l
ud g
e a nd Se w a
g
e1
3
.P
u rific a
tio n
14
.D
et
e ctio nA
n aly
sis
15
.I
nd ic a
t
o r s1
6
.M
et ho
d
sf
o rEv a
lu a
ti
ng
O
o cy
st V ia
b
ility
A
nim
al In
fe c
ti
vity
17
.// I w
fr
oE
x cy
sta
ti
o n1
8
.V
it
al D y
eS
t
ai
ni
ng
1
9
.P
C
R
2
0
.In v
itr o
C
ell
C
ult
u r eA
s s ay
20
.O
c c u r e n c e a nd
S
o u r c e s of
O
o cy
sts
in
the
E
n vir o n
me nt
S
o u r c eW
at
e r2 3.
D
rink in
g W
ate r
2 5
.W
a ste w at
e r2
6
.Dr
in
k in
g
Wa
t
e rT
r e at
me nt
2 8
.Ph y
sic a
l Pr o c e s s e s
29
.In a c
tiv a
tio n
Pr o c e s s e s
30
.Wa st
e w ate r
T
r e atm
e nt
32.
Slu
d g
eTr e a
t
me nt
33
.Se w a
g
eSlu
d
g
e3
3
.A
ni
mal W
a ste35
.Oo c
y
sts
S
u r viv a
l i
nthe
En v
i
r o nme nt
36
.Sta n
da r
ds a n
d Re
g
ula
to r
y
Co n
t
r ol
of
Oo
cy
stsin
the
En v
i
r o nme nt
W
ate r
-R
a w a n
d F in
is
he
d
39
.W
a stewate r
40
.Se w a
g
eS lu
d g
e4
0
.A
nim
al W
a ste
4 0.
C
HA PT ER
3:
R
ESEA R
CH
OBJ ECT IV ES
42.
C
HA PT ER 4
:IN IT IA L R ES
EA R
C
H
ON A
C
E LL
CU LT U R E IN F ECT IV IT Y A S
SAY
M E
T H
OD
IN T R
OD U CT ION
4 3
.M A T E R IA L
S
A N D M ET H O D S
So u r c e a n
d
p
r odu c
tio n
C
.p
a r v um o o cy
st
s43
.H
o st
c ells
-MD
C
K
c e
ll
c ultu r e s
4
4
.M
o n o clo n a
l
a nti bo
dy p
r ep
a r atio n
4 4
.Oo c
y
st p
r ep
a r atio n a n
d
e n ume r atio n
f
o r e xp
e rim
e nt
s4 5
.M D
C
K in
fe c
tiv
it y
a s s ay
of Cr
y
p
to s
p
ori diu
m o o cy
st
4 5
.Da
ta a n a
l
y
sis
46
.R E
S
U LT
S
Effe c
t
of in c u
b
atio n
tim
e o np
a r a site
de v e
lo
p
me nt
of
Cr
y p t
o sp
ori diu
mliv
i
ng
s
ta
g
e s4 7
.D
o s e-r e s
p
o n s e r ela
tio n s
h
ip
of the
q
u a nt
al in vit
r oi
nfe c
tiv
ity
a s s ay
4
9
.D ISC
U
SSI
O
N
50
.C
H A PT ER 5
:KI
NET I
CS O
F T H ER M A L
IN A
CT IVA
T ION O
F
C
.PA R VUM OOCY
STS
IN
BUF F
E
RED
WA TE
R
IN T R O D U CT IO N
58
.M AT E R IA LS
A
ND M
ET H
ODS
So u r c e
,p
r ep
a r ati
o n, e n ume r atio n a n
d i
nfe c
tiv
itiy
a s s ay
of
Cr
y p
to s
p
ori
diu
mM D
C
K in
fe c
tiv
ity
a s s ay
5 9.
A
s s e s sme nt
of tr
eate
d
o o cy
st
s60.
R E
S
U LT S
T he rm
al In a c
tlv a
tio n o
f C
.p
a r v um60
.D IS C U S S IO N
6 2.
C HA PT E R 6
:R EC
OV ER Y O F
OO
CYST S F ROM F EC A L M AT ER IA L A N D T H E INA C T IVA T IO N
O F C
.PA R V
l
/M OOCY ST S BY T H E R M O PH ILICA L LY A NA E R O BIC S L U DGE D IG EST ION
INT
ROD UCT ION
70
.MAT
ERI
A L
S
A
N D
M ET
HODS
So u r c e
, str a
in
,p
r ep
a r atio n a n
d
e n ume r atio n o
f
C
ry p t
o sp
ori d iu
m7 1
.W
a ste s a
mp l
e c olle c
ti
o n a nd
p
r o c e s si
ng
7 1
.Se e
di
ng
stu
die s o n
C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
m r e c o v e ry f
r om w a ste72
.O
p
e r ati
o n of
abe n c
h
,l
abo r a
to r
y
-s c a
le
mode
l the r
mop hili
c a n a e r obi
cdi
g
e st
e r73
.Effe c
ts o
f t he r
moph ili
c e xp
o s u r e s o n s u r viv a
l
of Cr
y p t
o sp
ori diu
m o o cy
st
s74
.M D C K
c ell
c ultu r e
in
f
e ctivity
a s s ay
75
.Cr
yp
to s
p
ori d iu
m o o cy
st i
nf
e cti
vity d
ete r
min a
ti
o n75
.RESULTS
In
iti
al
cha r a ct
e riz ati
o n of
c o wf
e c e s7
6
.O
p
e r ati
o n ch
a r a cte r
i
stic s of
s emi
-c o n
ti
n u o u s, mode
l
a n a e r obic
,th
e rmoph ili
cd
i g
e ste r7 6
.Re c o v e r
y
of
o o cy
stsfr o
m w a ste a nd
c o nti
-o
l
s amp l
e s7
6
.As s e s s
me nt
of
tr e a
te
d
oo cy
sts7 7
.D ISC
USS
I
ON
7 8
.C
H A PT E R V I:
SU
M M A R Y A N D
CO
N
C LU
SI
O
N S
8 5.
R EF ER E NCE
S
86
.L
I S
TO
F T A B LE S
T
ab le
2 1L
ev el
s of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
iumO
o cystsin
Su r
f
a c e and G
r o u nd w
ate r s 2 7T
ab le
2 2 Le v el
s o{ C
ry p
to sp
o rid
iumO
ocystsi
n Dri
nk i
ng
W
ate r 2 7 T ab le
2 3O
cc ure nce of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
ium O
o cystsin
S
ew
ag
e a nd S lu
dg
e 2 8T
ab le
2 4O
o cysts R em
o v al R
ate sb
yD
ri
nk i
ngW
ate rT
reatm
e nt Pr o c e s s e s 3 0.T
ab le
2 5O
o cy
sts R ed
u ctio n sb
yW
a stew
ate rT
r e atm
e nt 3 3.T
ab le
2 6
E f fe c
t of E
n vir
onm
ental E
xp
o sure o nO
ocy
stsV i
ab i li
ty 3 8T
ab l
e 2 7T h
e rm
al I
n activ
atio
n of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
iumO
o cysts3
8 T ab le
4. 1 InV it
r oC
el l C
ult
u r e of C
.p
a r v umin
M
D C
K c ell
c ul
tu r e-
N
um b
e r of
D
e v el
op m
e ntal St
ag
esC
o u nted/
M
i
c r o s c op i
c Fi
el d
4 8T
ab le
4 2
K
r u sk
al
-W
al li
sN
onp
aram
etri
cA N O V A T
e st 48
.T
able
4 3
D
u nn'
s
M
ul
tip l
eC
om p
ari
s on sT
ests on th
eM
e anD i f fe
r e nce sin
L i
vi
ng S
tag
e s Betw
e e nD i f fe r e n
tI
n c ub
atio n
T im
e s 4 9T
ab le
4 4I
nf
ectiv
i
t y of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
ium O
o cysts of D if fe r e n
tA g
e s a nd
L otN
um b
e r s 5 0.T
ab le
5 1T h
e rm
al
In a ctiv a
tio n
of C p
a r v umO
o cys tsi
nP
BS
6 9T a
b le
6 1O p
erati
onal C
ond i
tio n s o
f B
e n ch
-Sc a
l
eD i g
e ste r 7 6L I
S T O
FF
IG
UR
ES
F i
gur e2
1 T a x o n om
y oi C
ryp
to sp
o rid
ium 5F i
gu r e 2 2L i fe
C
ycl
e o^ C
ry p
to sp
o rid
ium 7F i g
u r e 4 1O
W
5 0 - FI
TC l
ab
ele
d C p
ar v um o o cystin
M
D C K
c el l
c ult
u r e5
3F i g
u r e 4 2C Y
3-C 3
-C
3la
b
el
e
d C
.p
a r v um o o cystsin
M
D C K
c el l
cul
tu re5
4F i g
u r e 4 3E ff
e ct of I
n c ub
atio
nT i m
e o nP
a r a sit
eD
e velo
p
em
e nt at1
8,2
4 and 4
8H
ou rI
ncub
atio n s
5 5
.
F i g
ur e 44
E ff
ect of
In c r e a si
ng
o ocy
stsI
n o c ulu
m
a nd I
ncub
a ti
o nT i m
e o nD
e v el
op
em
e nt of L iv
in
g S
tag
e s of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
iumin
M
D C K C
el l
C
ult
u r e s : En um
e r ati
v e A s s ay56
.F i g
u r e 45
E ff
e ct of
In c ub
atio n
Ti m
e onO
o cysts Inf
ecti
vit
y
of C
ry p
to sp
o rid
iumi
nM
D C K C
el l C
ult
u r e s:Q
u a ntal A
s s ay 5 6.F
i g
u r e 4 6 Lin e a r
Regr e s si
o nA
n al y
si
s of
Do s e-Re sp
o n s eD
ataf
o rC
el l
C
ult
u re Inf
e ctiv
i
ty
of U
ntr e ated C
o ntr ol C
ryp
to sp
o ri d i
um O
o cysts 5 7.F i g
u r e5 1
E
xp
o s u r e a nd R
e c o v e ry
of C
.p
a r v umO
o cystsfr o
m
P BS
6 4F i g
ur e5
.2
T h
e rm
al I
nacti
vatio n
of C
.p
ar v um in
P BS
at 35
°
C
6 5F i g
u r e5
.3T h
e rm
al I
n a ctiv a
tio
n of C
.p
ar v umin
P BS
at 4 9 °C
6 6F i g
u r e5
4T h
e rm
al I
n a cti
v atio n
of C
./
?a r v MWin
P B S
at5 5
°C
67F i g
u r e5 5
T h
e rm
al I
n a cti
v atio
n of C
./
?a /
-v M 7w
in
P
BS
at 6 0°C
6 8.F i g
u r e 6 1I
n a ctiv a
tio n
of C p
a r v um i
nPB
S
a nd
M
a n u r e at2
3°C
82IN T R
OD U C T IO N
Cr
y p t
o sp
ori diu
mp
a r v um r ep
r e s e nts a
hig hly i
nfe ctio u s
,eme rg i
ng di
s e a s e, e sp
e cia
ll y
amo n
g i
m mu n o c omp
r omis e
d in
div
id
u als
.T he r o
b
u st
n at
u r e of the o o c
y
sts, alo w
in
fe ct io u s
do s e
c om
b in e
d
wit h
r e sist
a n c eto c o
m mo nly
u s ed d is
i
nfe c
ta n
t
s mak
eth
ese o rg
a nis
msdif fi
c ult to c o n
tr o
l
a n
d
a s e rio u s
t hr e a
t to
p
ublic
he a
lth
O
o cy
sts
fo
llo w a
fe c a
l
o r al
r o ut
e, a nd
c a nbe
tr a n s
mitte
d
th
r o ug h
mult ipl
e s o u r c e s.Sy
mpt
omatic a n
d
a sy
mpt
omatic
hu
ma n sp l
u sfe r a
l
a nd d
ome stic
a n
i
mal
s c a n she
d
o o cy
sts,whic
h
c a nbe c a r r
ie
d int
o w at
e r c o u r s e s a nd
le a
d t
o o utb
r e aks o
f
e n
t
e ricd is e a s e
.T he
US
En v
ir o n
me nt
al Pr o
t
e ctio n
A g
e n cy
(
U SE PA
)
,by th
edir e c
tio n o
f the
Sa
fe
W
ate r
Dr
in
k i
ng
A
ct
.pl
a c ed Cr
y p t
o sp
ori diu
m o nits
D
rin
k i
ng W
ate r
Pr
io r
ity L i
st in
1986
T he
En
h
a n c ed
Su r
f
a c eW
ate r
Tr e a
tm
e nt Ru
le c u r r e n
tl y
r eq
uir e s
mo nito r
in
g
of th is o r
g
a nis
mby l
a rg
e uti litie s u s
in
g
s u r
fa c e a n
d g
r o u nd
w at
e r s a sdir e c
te
d b y th
e r eg
ula
t
o ry
n eg
otia
te
d In
f
o rmatio n
C
olle c
tio n
Ru
le
(
I
C
R
)
.In
fo r
mati
o ng
ai
n ed thr o u
gh thi
s st
ud y
wi ll be u s e
d to
de v e
lo
p
r eg
ula
tio n s a n
d
e v alu a
te
th
ee
ffe c
tiv e n e s s o
f tr e a
tm
e nt
me a s u r e s a nd
th
ep
o s sible c o s
t
of im
p l
eme nti
ng
c o ntr o
l
me a s u r e s.Sin c e
d
ete c
tio n o
f
o o cy
st
si
sp l
ag
u ed
with p
r obl
ems,it is e x
p
e cte
d tha
t
r eg
ul
atio n w
ill
r eq
uir e
t
r e at
me nt p
r o c e s s e sto r e
mo v e99
.9
%
of
o o cy
sts
.Co n
t
rol
of t his o r
g
a nis
mis
be s
t
mad
eth
r o ug h
amu
lti
p
le
ba r r
ie r a
pp
r o a ch.
A fi
r st b
a r rie r
in
p
r ote c
ti
ng d
rin
k i
ng
w at
e r s o u r c e sis w a s
t
e w ate r
t
r e at
me nt
.Stu
d ie s
ha v e s
ho w n
th
at
o o cy
st
s a r ep
r e s e nt
at hig h l
e v els
in r a w s e w a
g
e a nd t ha
t
t
r e atm
e nt p
r o c e s s e s alo n e c a n n o
t be r e a
l is
tic a
lly d
ep
e nde
d
up
o nto
p
r e v e nt the r e
le a s e o
f
o o cy
sts
i
nto
the e n v
ir o n
me nt
.W
a ste w a
te r
t
r e atm
e nt p
r o c e s s e s c o n c e nt
r ate o o c
y
stsin
to
t he s e w a
g
es
lu
d g
e s,the r e
fo r e
p
r o c e s s e st ha
t tr e a
t
slu
d g
e a r eim
p
o rt
a nt i
np
r e v e ntio n o
f
r el
e a s e of
o o cy
st
si
ntot he e n v
ir o n
me nt Stu
d ie s
to
da
t
eha v e s
ho w n
t ha
t
o o cy
sts a r e e
ffe c
ti
v el y i
n a cti
v ate
d by
a n a e r o
bic a n
d
a e r obic
dig
e stio n
bo
th i
nth
eth
e rmop hili
c a nd
me s op hil i
c r a ng
e, a s e vi de n c e
d b y
t he rm
op hili
cd
i
g
e stio n
is a n e
me rg
in
g t
r e atm
e nt p
r o c e s sfo r
mu nic
i p
al
slu
d
g
e s a nd
o n eth
at i
sbe
i
ng
u s ed
t
otr e a
t
wa ste a
t
s omela r
g
ed
air
y f
a cil itie s
.T
o a s s e s sthe e
ffe c
tiv e n e s s o
f ph y
sic a
l
a nd
che m
ic a
l tr e a
t
me nt p
r o c e s s o nth
e via
b ility
o rin
f
e cti
vity
of
C
.p
a r v umt
hr e e
ba s
ic
metho
ds
ha v e
be e n e
mpl
oy
ed
:1
)
in v
it
r o e x cy
st
atio n o
f
o o c
y
sts
,2
)
vita
l d y
e st
ai
nin
g
(
D A Pl/P I
)
, a nd 3
)
i
n viv o
in
f
e cti
o n of
a s uita
ble a n
im
al
mode
l
.W h ile
a n
im
al
mode
ls a r e a c c e
pt
ed
a st he
"g
old
st
a nd
a rd
"fo r a s s e s s
in
g
via
b ility
a nd i
nf
e ctiv
ity
,the
y
a r ec o s
tly
a nd
d
o n ot
alw a
y
sy i
el d p
r e cis e
q
u a ntitativ e
da
t
a.V ia
bility h
a sbe e n a
d dr e s s e
d b y
a
p
p
l ic a
tio n o
f in v
itr o e x c
y
sta
ti
o n a nd
stain
in
g
with
vit
al d
y
e s.Qu e s
ti
o n s r emai
n a sto
t he a
b
i lit y
of
t he s e
met ho
d
st
op
r edic
t i
nfe cti
vity
r elia
b ly b
e c a u s e r e s ults a r e o
f te n n o
t
c o r r ela
t
ed
wit h
p
r ed ic
ti
o n sfr o
m a nim
al
mode
l
s(
Fi
n ch
et
al
,19
93 & Ko r
ic
h
et
al,
19 90
)
.Re c e n
t
adv a n c e s
in
in
v
iti
^o c e
ll
c ult
u r e a s s ay
metho
ds
(
Ar r o w o o
d
et
al,
1996,
Slifc o e
t
al,
1996
)
mak
eth is a n a
tb
-a cti
v ea
lt
e r n ati
v ebe c a u s e
t he
y p
r o vi de
in
fo r
mati
o n o nt he v
ia
bility
of ti
"e a
t
ed
o o cy
st
s a sde
t
e rmin e
d by
t he a
bil ity t
oin
iti
at
einf
e ctio n a nd p
r olife r at
e.T he a
bil ity t
ode
te c
t q
u a nti t
ati
v ely t h
einf
e cti
vity
of C
.p
a r v um o o cy
sts
in c e
ll
c ult
u r ep
r o vide s a c o n v e n
ie n
t to o
l fo r
b
ette r
de
te r
min a
ti
o n of
w at
e r,w a s
t
e w ate r a n
d
sl
udg
et
'e a
ti
n e nt effe c
ti
v e n e s s a nd
a s s e s sin
g
risks
to
t he
p
ub
lic
he a
lt h
.T he
p
u rp
o s e of thi
s stu
dy
w a st
o e v alu a
t
ethe
M
adi
nDa r
by
c a nin e
k id
n ey
(
M D
CK
)
c ell
c u
ltu r e a s s a
y
metho
d fo r u s e a s a
to o
l fo r
q
u a nti t
ati
v e a s s e s sme nt of to
'e a
ti
n e nt
ef fic
ie n c
ie s
;the n
a
pp ly thi
s metho
do
lo
gy t
oq
u a nti
fy th
e r edu c
ti
o n s of
o o cy
st i
nf
e cti
vity i
nthe r
mal
p
r o c e s s e s a nd
a n a e r o
bic
the rm
op hili
cd ig
e ste
d
slu
dg
e.T his s
t
ud y p
r e s e nts
da
ta o n
the
th
e rmal in a c
ti
vati
o n of C
.R EV IEW OF T H
E
L IT ER A T
URE
Pa
t ho g e n
Ch
a r a cte r
iz a
tio n
H is
t
o ry
Cr
y p t
o sp
oridiu
mp
a r v um w a sfi
r st
de s c r
ibe
d
a s a n e w sp
e cie s
in
1912 b
y th
eA
me ric a n
p
a r a sito
lo
g i
st Er n e st Edw a r
d T y
z z e r(
T y
z z e r,19 29
)
.It
w a sd isti
ng
uis
he
d f
r omp
r e vi
o u sly id
e ntified
s
p
e ci
e s of C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
mby it
s siz e
(
3
-7 p M
)
a nd it
s r e st
rictio n
to
the
d ig
e st iv etr a c
t
of
a s
y
mpt
omatic
la
bo r a
to r
y
mic e
.T y
z z e r 's
in
itia
l in v e s
tig
atio n s o
f this
g
e n u s of p
a r a sit
e s elu c
ida
t
ed
th
ed
eta
ils o
f the c o
mpl
e xl if
e cy
cl
e of this o r
g
a ni
sm wh i
ch
e v e nt
od
ay h
ol
d
s up
a sth
ede
fin
itiv e
de s c r
i pti
o n of th
ei
r r ep
r odu ctio n
de v e
lo
p
me nt
a nd
mo rph
olo
gy
{
T y
z z e r,19 07
)
.R
eg
a rde
d
a s a n opp
o rtu n
i
stic z o o n o s
i
s with l ittle
if
a ny
medic a
l in
te r e s
t
o r e c o n omi
cim
p
a ct
(
C
a s emo r e a nd Ja c
ks o n
,19 84 & Sc
hu
ltz
,198 3
)
,C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
m r e c eiv e
d
vi
rtu ally
n oa
tte n
tio n
f
o r mo r etha n s
ix
t y y
e a r s afte r
it
w a sdis c o v e r e
d
.Ev e n
tho u
g h
n ume r o u s r ep
o rtsc o n
fi
rmed the
p
r e s e n c e of this
p
a r a site
i
n ma ny h
o st
sp
e cie s
it
r emai
n ed
r ela
tiv e
ly
obs c u r e
.In
1
9
7 1
,C
.p
a r v um w a s a s s o cia
te
d
with
a c a s e of b
o vi
n edia r r
he a a n
d t he
i
nte r e s
t
of the v e
te r
in a r
y
c om mu n
ity
w a s stim
ul
ate
d
a sits r o
l
e a s ap
atho
g
e ni
n a nim
als w a s a
ffir
med
.T he
fi
r st de s c r
ip ti
o no
f
ahu
ma n c a s e w a s r ep
o rte
d fiv e
y
e a r sla
te r w
he n
In
19 76
at hr e e
-y
e a r-o
ld im m
u n o c omp
et
e nt
c
hil d fr o
m a r u r al fa r m
in
g
c om mu nity
de v e
lo
p
ed in
fe c
ti
o nd
u eto z o o no
tic
t
r a n smis s
io n
(
N im
e et
al
. ,19 76
)
.W it hin a
mo nt h, a n ot he r r e s
id
e nt
of
af
a rmin
g
c o mmu nity
w a sd ia
g
n o s ed
with
c r
y pt
sp
ori dio s
is
(
N im
e et
al
,19
76 & Meis e
l
et
al
,19 76
)
.Re
p
o rts o
f hu
ma n c ry pt
o sp
o ridio s
is
r ema
in e
d
r a r e u ntil 198
2
wh
e nphy
si
cia n s
thr o u
gh
o ut t he
U
nit
ed Sta
te s
be
g
a n r ep
o rtin
g
a n e v e rin c r e a s
in
g
n umb
e r of
c a s e s, e sp
e cia
lly
amo ng y
o u ng
male s w
ith
a cq
uir e
d im m
u n ode
fic
ie n c
y
d is e a s e
,to
t he
C
e nt
e r sfo r
D is e a s e
C
o nt
r ol
.W hile a
p p
a r e ntly
a s elf li
mit
ed d is e a s e
in
h
e althy
p
e opl
e,p
atie n
ts w
ith
s up p
r e s s ed im m
u nitie s c a n
de
velo
p
chr o n
ic
in
f
e cti
o n s with hi g h
mo rt
ality
r a
te s
.Sin c e
th
e e a rly
80
'
No w a c c e
p
t
ed
a s ap
r o mi
n e nt
ag
e nt of
d
ia r r
he a
in
l
i uma n s a nd d
ome stic ate
d
a nim
al
st hr o u
g h
o ut th
e w ori d
,C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
mis
t he
le a
di
ng
c a u s e of
w ate r
bo r n e o u
tbr e a
ks
fo r w
hic
h
a ne
tio
lo
gi
c ag
e nt ha s
be e n
ide n
tifie
d in
t he
Un
ite
d St
at
e s(
Kr a
me r,19 9
6
)
.T h
eC D C
r e c e ntly
i de n
tifie
d C.
p
a r v um a s a n eme rgi
ng i
nfe c
tio u s
dis e a s e
d
u eto e v
i de n c e s u
g g
e st in
g th
at it is n e w
ly
s
p
r e ad
a nd
n e wly
ab l
et
o c a u s elife
th
r e at
e nin
g d i
s e a s e.It
s r ole
in
th
e ep id
emi
c o utb
r e ak i
nM ilw a u
k
e ein
1993
g
e n e r at
ed
mu ch p
ublic a
tte n
tio n a n
d
c o n c e r nf
o rth
ep
ot
e ntia
l fo r w a
t
e rbo r n e
t
r a n smis s
io n
.It
'
s u
biq
uit
o u s n at
u r e, small
si
z e a nd
alo w
i
nf
e ctio u s
do s e c o
mb in e
d
with its r e
la
tiv e
r e s
is
t
a n c et
oty pi
c al
w ate r
tr e a
t
me nt p
r o c e s s e s a nd dis
in
fe c
tio n
make s
it
of p
a rtic ula r c o n c e r n
t
ot he
p
ub lic
he a
lt h
.T
a x o n omy
Cr
y p t
o sp
ori diu
mbe
lo n
g
st
othe
g
e n e r a of C
o c cid
a ep
r oto z o a n
p
a r a site s
in
t he
p hy l
umA
p
ic o
mpl
e x a(
t he s
p
o r o z o a n s)
.T he
membe r s o
f this
g
e n u sde v e
lo
p
with in
t he e
pit h
el ia
l
c ells o
f
t he
g
a str o
in
t
e stin al
a nd
r e sp
ir a
to r
y t
r a cts o
f
v e rte
b
r at
es.Sp
e cie s w
ithi
nthi
sg
e n u s c omp
l
ete
the
i
rlife c
y
cle w
ithin a s
in
gl
eh
o st
a nd
ha v e
the s
malle s
t
o o cy
sts amo ng th
e c o c cid ia
.A ltho u
g
h
o n c ec o n s
ide r e
d
str
ic
tly h
o st
sp
e cific
,the
y
a r e n o wk
n o w nt
ob
e c r o s str a n s
mis s
ible
(
Pa
y
e r a nd U
ng
a r,1
9
86
)
,be
t
w e e ndiff
e r e nt ho sts w
ith in
th
e s ame v e rt
eb
r at
e cla s s
.In
itia
lly
, n ome n cla
t
u r e w a sb
a s ed
o nt he s
p
e cific
ho s
t
-p
a r a sit
e r ela
tio n s
hi p
(
Pa
y
e r et
al
,1
9
9 0
)
a nd
a s ma ny
a stw e n
ty
-o n ed
iff
e r e nt
s
p
e ci
e s w e r eid
e ntifie
d
.T
a x o n omi
c cl
a s sific a
tio n
r emain s c o n
f
u sin
g d
u et
oth
ela c
k
of ho st
sp
e cific
ity
a nd Is
t he r e
f
o r e u nde r r e v
is
io n
.A t p
r e s e nt
, s
ix
s
p
e cie s o
f
C
ry p t
o sp
ori diu
m a r e a c c ep
te
d
(
C
a s emo r e,1
990
)
;
C
.p
a r v umin
fe c
t
s mam mals
,
i
n clu
d
i
ng
ma n;
C
. mu n sin
f
e ct r od
e nts
;C
.b
aile
y
a nd C
. me/e a
g
n'
cl/s
inf
e ct
b
ir
d
s;C
. c r ofa
// i
nf
e cts
r eptil
e s; a nd
C
. n a s o r umin
f
e cts
fis
h.
V
ari
atio n s w
ithi
nh
o st
sp
e cif
icity
, s
it
e s of in
fe ctio n a n
d
p
atho
g
e ni
city
may
e v e nt
u ally l
e ad to v a
li da
tio n o
f
add itio n a
l
spe c
ie s
.A ltho u
gh
c r o s str a n s
mis s
io n
do e s o c c u r
,C
.p
a r v umis
the s
p
e cie s r e s
p
o n sible
fo r
mo st hu
ma n a nd
a nim
al i
nf
e ctio n s a n
d it is
t he o n
ly
w ate r
bo r n e
C
o c ci d t
oin
fe c
t hu
ma n s(
C
u rd
s,1992
)
.s
p
o r o z oite s
f
r omh
uma n,ho r s e a n
d
c alf
s o u r c e s.Fo u r o r
fiv e o
f the s e
is o
la
te s s
ho w e
d
s uf fic
ie n
t
diffe r e n c e s
i
np
eptid
ep
r op
e rtie s
t
o al lo w
ide n
tific a
tio n o
f the
is o
l
ate
.Ye
t
,the r e
is s
till i
n s uf fic
ie n
t
e vi
d
e n c et ha
t Is o
la
te s c a n
be s u
bd iv
ide
d ba s e
d
o n a ntig
e nic o r o
t he r s u
btyp
e s(
Ca s e
mo r e,198 4
)
.Ot he r s
t
udi
e sh
a v eid
e ntifie
d d iffe r e n c e s
be
t
w e e nis o
la
te s a
t the
g
e n etic a n
d p h
e n otypi
cle v e
l,
b
ut
a r e n '
t
c o n clu s
iv e
(
N ic
ho
ls e
t
al,
199 0,
Aw
ad
-EI
-Ka rie
m et
a
l
,19 95
,Ca r r a
way
et
al,
19 96
)
.In a r e c e n
t
dis
p
at
ch i
nC
D
C
's
Em
e rg
i
ng
I
nfe c
tio u s
Dis e a s e
j
o u r n al
,i
n v e sti
g
ato r s
de s c r
ibe
d
ag
e n etic
p
oly
mo rp
h is
m withi
nthe
T RA P
-2 g
e n e wh ic
h
m ay
al lo w
f
o rth
eide n
tific a
t io n o
f th
e s o u r c e of
o o cy
sts
(
Pe n
g
et
al,
199 7
)
.T he a u
tho r s r e
p
o rte
d tha
t b
o vi
n e a nd hu
ma ni
s ola
te s c a n
be
d is
ti
ng
uis
he
d b
a s ed
o nthe s e
mole c u
la r
te c
hn
i q
u e s.T his r e
p
r e s e nts a s
ig
nific a n
t br e a
kt hr o u
g h if
the
y
a r e able
to v e r
ify th i
sp
atte r n w
ith fu r
th
e r r e s e a r ch
.De
te r
min a
tio n o
f
s o u r c e s of
o o cy
stsis
im
p
o rt
a nt in
th
ein v e s
ti g
atio n o
f f
ut
u r e o utb
r e ak i
n v e sti
g
atio n s a n
d
c o ntr o
l
ef fo rt
s.F i
g
u r e2
.1
T
ax o n omy
of
Cr
y
p
t
o sp
ori d i
um
P h y la Sar co m a st igophora
(
a m o eba s,f lagellate s, Entamo eba. G ia rd ia)
Orde rSubo rde r Fam ilie s Gene ra
Pr oto z o a A p lc om p le x a
(
spo r o z o a n s)
C iliop ho r a
(
ciliate s)
Eu c o c ci d lo rida
.E imio rin a^., ^ ^ ^
Sa r c o cyst ida e Cry p to spori dilda
T
^ Eiin e ii ida e Sa rc o cyslis,To x op la sma
Cry pto spo rid ium E ime ria, Is o spo r a
Life
C
y
cle
Cr
yp t
o sp
o ridiu
m, a mo n e cio u s
p
a r a site
, c omp l
et
e sit
s e ntir e
life c
y
cle w
ithi
n a sin
gl
eho st
.It
slife c
y
cle
is s
im
i l
arto o
the r
Co c
cida e
in
tha
t it
c a nbe
d i
vide
d int
o six
dis
tin c
tiv e
p h
a s e s :e x c
y
st
atio n
, me r og
o ny
,g
ameto
g
o ny
,f
e rti l iz a
tio n
, o o cy
st
s w all fo r
mati
o n, a nd
sp
o r og
o ny
(
C
u r r e nt,
198 7
)
.I
nfe cti
o nis
in
iti
ate
d f
ollo w
in
g i
ng
e sti
o n of the
th ic
k
w alle
d,
e n vir o n
me nta
lly
r e sis
ta nt
o o cy
st
w
hic
h
is s
he
d in
the
fe c e s o r n a s a
l
s e c r eti
o n s of the
in
fe c
t
ed
ho s
t
s.Oo c
y
st
s c a nbe
p
r e s e nt in
c o nt
amin a
te
d
fo o
d,
w ate r o r
the
g
e n e r al
e n vir o nme nt
a nd
a r e e xti
'f
r omt
he o
ocy
stsi
nthe
g
a str oi
nte stin a
l
o r r e sp i
r ato ry t
r a ct
a nd
in
f
ect
ep
it he
li
al
c ells
.A ll
e n
do
g
e n o u s sta
g
e s of the
p
a r a sit
e a r efo u n
d
at the
lu
min a
l
s u rfa c e of the e
p it h
eliu
m.W hile
a n ato
mi
c al
site s o
f In
f
e ctio n u s u a
lly i
n v olv e
the a
li
me nt
a ry t
r a ct,
othe r
mu c o s al
s u rf
a c e slin e
d
with
epit h
elia
l
c ells a r e a
ls o
p
e rmis s
iv e
t
oin
fe c
tio n
(
Ca s e
mo r e,1988
)
.Ex c
y
sta
tio n
is
tho u
g ht t
o r e s ult fr o
m e xp
o s u r eto a c o
mbin a
tio n o
f bo
dy t
emp
e r at
u r e,CO
j,p
r ote o
lyt i
c e n zy
me s a nd
bile s a
lts
(
C
u r r e nt
,1987
)
.Up
o n at ta ch
me nt
of th
e sp
o r o z oite
t
o a c ell,
af
e ed
e r o rg
a n ell
ede v e
l
op
sbe
t
w e e nthe s
p
o r o z oit
e s a nd
c ell
cy t
op
l
a sm.T he
p
a r a sit
e u nde r
g
o e sdiffe r e n
ti
ati
o n withi
nt he
ho s
t
sp
a r a sit
op h
o r o u s v a c u ole m e
mbr a n e
t
ofo r
m a nin
tr a c e
llu
la r
t
r op h
o z oite
.As e x u a
l di
vis
io n
, me r ogo
my
, r e s ults
in
th
ef
o rmatio n o
f ty p
eI
me r o nts.T he s e
me r o n
t
s c o nta
in s
ix
t
o eig ht
me r o z oit
e s a nd
c a nin
fe c
t
aho s
t
c el l to
de v e
lo
p i
nt
o a n e wT yp
eI
me r o n
t
o rT yp
eII
me r o nt
s.T yp
eII
me r o nt
s u nd
e rg
o a s e x u al
div
i
sio n s
t
op
r odu c e
f
o u r me r o z oite s
th
at g
o o nto
de v e
lo
p i
nto
g
amo nts
,t he s e x u a
l
sta
g
e.A
maj
o rity
of t he
me r oite s
fr o
mT yp
eII
me r o n
t
sg
o o nt
ofo r
m ma c r og
amets
(
80%
)
,the r e
mai
ni
ng
fo r
m mic r o
g
amo nt
s(
20%
)
,t he
f
emale
a n
d
male
co u nte r
p
a rts r e s
p
e ctiv ely
(
Cu r r e n
t
,1987
)
.F
e rtil iz atio n r e s u
lts
in
the
p
r odu c
tio n o
f
a zy g
ote
th
at de v e
lo
p
si
nto eithe r
thin o r
th ic
k
w alle
d
o o cy
ste wh ic
h
sp
o r ula
te s
in v
iv o
.Bo
th typ
e s of
o o cy
st c o nt
ain
f
o u r sp
o r o z oit
e s.M
o st of th
e o o cy
sts
p
r od
u c ed
a r et hic
k
w al le
d
a nd
a r e sh
ed i
nthe
f
e c e s.T he s e a r e
t he e n v
ir o n
me nta
lly
r e sist
a nt fo r
msth
at c a ntr a n s
mit the
in
fe cti
o nto o
the r
ho s
t
s.
T he
thi
nwalle
d
o o cy
st is s u r r o u n
de
d
o nly b y
a u nit
membr a n e a n
d
e x cy
st with i
nthe
g
a st
r oin
te s
tin a
l tr a c
t
of the
ho st
s o o n afte r r e
l
e a s efi
'om a
h
o st
c ell
a nd
a r e c ap
able o
f
r ein
iti
ati
ng
the e n
do
g
e n o u s cy
cle
.T he
p
ote n
tia
l fo r r e c
y
clin
g
sp
o r o z oit
e sthr o u
gh th
eg
e n e r atio n o
f th i
n w all
ed
o o c
y
st
si
s u ni
q
u eto
t his
g
r o up
of
Co c c
idia
's
p
a r a site s
(
Cu r r e n
t
a nd
Lo n
g
,1
983
)
.T his
fe a
tu r
eis
p
r oba
bly
r e sp
o n sib le
f
o rthe
l
o wi
nf
e cti
v edo s e r e
q
ui
r ed to
i
nitia
t
ein
fe c
tio n a n
d the
p
e r sis
te n
t l ife
t hr e a
t
e nin
g
i
nf
e ctio n
in a
bs e n c e o
f
r ep
e at
o r al
e xp
o s u r e ofte n s e e n
i
nA ID
S
p
atie n
ts
.T he
ti
me r eq
ui
r ed to c o
mp
le
t
ethe e n
tir e
lif
e cy
cle o
f this
p
a r a sit
e v a rie s w
ithi
nho s
ts
,bu
t is
r e
p
o rted to
be
be
tw e e n
18
-24 ho u r s w
ithi
nhu
ma n s.
T he
p
e rio
d be
tw e e n
in
f
e cti
o n a nd
o o cy
st
she
dd
in
g
in
h
uma n s v a ri
e sfi
s
he
d i
nf
e c e s app
e a r sto
be a s s o c
ia
te
d
with
s e v e rity
of
sy
mpt
oms,b
ut
a sy
mpt
omat ic c a r r
ie r s a r e
als o c a
p
ab le o
f
sh
ed di
ng
o o cy
st
s.Fi g
u r e2
.2
L if
eC
y
cle o
f
Cr
y p t
o sp
ori d i
um
4 Ho st^p iihali iiV
m rs Gt kH i Inge stio n
I I
Twe ime ran t
Matu r e
o o cyst T Mi elme r aM
Ma c r ogamo nl
C
ry pt
o sp
o ri dio sis
T he e
ffe c
t
of in
g
e sting
C
.p
a r v um o o cy
st
c a n r a ng
ef
r om a sy
mpt
omatic
i
nf
e ctio n
, afe w
d
ay
s of
mi ld to s e v e r e
dia r r
h
e a, cho
le r a
-
lik
e
di
a r rhe a r e
q
uir
in
g
med ic a
l
atte n
tio n
,ho s
pit
aliz a
tio n
a nd
p
ote n
ti
all
y
de a
t h
.T he
mo st p
r omin e n
t
a nd fr e
q
u e ntly id
e ntifie
d
ma nife s
ta
tio n o
f
c r
y pt
o sp
o rd io sis
is
p
r of
u s e,w ate r
y d i
a r rhe a
, a s s o cia
te
d
with
v omitin
g
, abd
omin a
l p
ain
, a n o r e xia
, w eig ht l
o s s,de
hy d
r atio n a n
d lo w
g
r ade
f
e v e r(
C
u r r e nt
a nd Ga r c
i
a,1991
)
.Ge n e r a
lly
a s elf
-