ANIMALS AND LANGUAGE LEARNING
ANIMALS AND LANGUAGE LEARNING
Presented by Presented by
Vivi Rizqiyah
Vivi Rizqiyah
Liliani Maulidia
Liliani Maulidia
Ayu Wulandari
Ayu Wulandari
ANIMALS AND LANGUAGE
ANIMALS AND LANGUAGE
LEARNING
LEARNING
•
• D ani!als have lan"ua"e#D ani!als have lan"ua"e#
•
• D they use the lan"ua"e t $!!uni$ate#D they use the lan"ua"e t $!!uni$ate#
•
• %an &e tea$h ani!als s!e srt ' hu!an%an &e tea$h ani!als s!e srt ' hu!an
lan"ua"e# lan"ua"e#
•
• I' they $annt s(ea) I' they $annt s(ea) hu!an lan"ua"e* &uldhu!an lan"ua"e* &uld
this !ean that they
this !ean that they are la$)in" in intelli"en$e*are la$)in" in intelli"en$e* r they la$) a s(e$i+$ innate lan"ua"e ability# r they la$) a s(e$i+$ innate lan"ua"e ability#
,-. /EA%0ING SPEE%0 /1 APES
,-.-.- /he +rst S$ienti+$ Atte!(t2 &ith an
ran"utan 3'urness*.4.56
•
/he resear$her tau"ht an ran"utan t
s(ea)-•
It had nly learned t say* 7(a(a8 and
7$u(8
•
A'ter 'ur !nths* the (r9e$t ended
'ever-,-.-:- Gua2 the $hi!( raised &ith a hu!an 7siblin"8
3 Winthr( ;ell" < Luella )ell"* .45=6
•
/he resear$hers tau"ht the $hi!( in the sa!e &ay that
their &n sn*
Dnald-• The result:
/hey have the sa!e s$re n the (rble!>
slvin" tests and tests ' !ental ability
•
A'ter.5 !nth* /he resear$hers 'und that Gua learned
t res(nd t 4, s()en &rds* (hrases* and
senten$es-E?2 7Lie d&n8* 7dn@t tu$h8*
et$-,-.-- Vi)i2 Anther $hi!( raised in a hu!an husehld 3%athy and ;eith 0ayes* .4,.6
• /he resear$hers treated vi)i as a 'ull !e!ber ' the
'a!ily-• Vi)i &as "iven (rnun$iatin trainin"* but she had nly
learned t utter 'ur &rds2 B!a!a@* B(a(a@* Bu(@ and
Vi)i-,-:- /EA%0ING SIGN LANGUAGE /1 /0E %0IMPANCEE* G1RILA AND 1RANGU/AN
,-:-.- Washe2 /he irst Si"nin" %hi!(
3Allen and beatri$e Gardner
.454*.4,6-• /he resear$hers tau"ht the &ashe a si!(li+ed 'r! ' A!eri$an
Si"n Lan"ua"e 3ASL6
• She learned .F si"ns and dis(layed t&> and three &rd
utteran$es* su$h as B(en 'd drin)@ &hen she &anted s!ethin" ut ' the
re'ri"atr-• Des(ite the !any years ' trainin"* Washe $uld nt advan$e
a$hieve!ent-,-:-:- Luis* Sn ' Washe* and a $!!unity ' si"nin"
%hi!(s-3R"er and Debby uts* .4=46
• /heir '$us is in l)in" at h& lan"ua"e !ay r !ay nt
devel( in s$ial
$nte?t-• /hey e!(hasize n $reatin" the best envirn!ent 'r the
$hi!(anzees t devel( $nversatins and nt n tea$hin" the!
synta?-• /hey believe that the $hi!(anzee $an advan$e* n$e "iven a
hu!ans-,-:-- /ea$hin" Si"n Lan"ua"e t ;)* the Grila 3ran$ine Pattersn* .4=a* .4=b* .4=F6
• ;) has been trained in A!eri$an Si"n
Lan"ua"e-• She has re$eived s(ee$h in(ut 'r! her trainers as &ell as si"n-• A'ter -, years she had learned .: si"n &rds* a'ter .F !re
years that ttal $a!e t ,FF r !re- Hut*It is l&er than year> ld hu!an $hild &hse v$abulary
thusands-,-:-,- /ea$hin" Lan"ua"e t %hante)* the ran"utan 3Miles* .4=*.44F6
• 0e $hse ran"utan be$ause they "enerally s$re hi"her n
$"nitive tests than Grillas r
$hi!(anzees-• 0e did nt 9ust train %hante) t use si"ns but als i!!ersed her
in a hu!an $ultural envirn!ent t learn a((r(riate &ays 'r behaviur and
intera$tin-• A'ter seven years* $hante) learned t use a v$abulary ' .F
si"ns &hi$h si"ni'y b9e$ts* a$tins* (r(er na!es* attributives* l$atives and
(rnuns-,- /EA%0ING AR/II%IAL LANGUAGES /1 %0IMPANCEES
,--.- Lana* the %!(uter %hi!( 3/he Ru!bau"hs* .46
• /hey tau"ht Lana a si!(le arti+$ial lan"ua"e $alled er)ish-• /he lan"ua"e $nsisted ' seven $lurs and nine "e!etri$al
sha(es &hi$h re(resented !ainly b9e$ts and
a$tins-• Lana learned hundreds ' senten$es in this
'ashin-• Sue Sava"e>ru!bau"hs believes that a(es have but a li!ited
a$quisitin-,--:- sarah2 /he Ma"neti$ Plasti$ t)en %hi!( 3David Pre!a$)*.4F*.4.* .456
• 0e "ave sarah .F (lasti$ t)ens &ith !a"nets s that they
$uld be !ani(ulated easily by her and thers- /he t)ens 'r na!es ' $lurs* a$tins* 'ruites and s!e 'un$tin su$h as
$reatures-,--- ;anzi a (y"!y %hi!( (rdu$es synthesized s(ee$h 3ru!bau"h* M$Dnald* sev$i)** 0()ins < Rubert* .4=56
• /he resear$her believe that a (y"!y $hi!( !re si!ilar t
hu!ans than t ther
a(es-• In their trainin" the resear$hes &uld (int t a )eybard and
s(ea) in en"lish t b9e$ts* a$tins* l$atins that &ere ' interest t the
$hi!(s-,-- /ea$hin" lan"ua"e t Dl(hins
,--.- Elvar2 /he &histlin" Dl(hin 3Lilly*.45:*.45,6
• /he resear$her tried t tea$h a dl(hin t 'r$e air thru"h its
bl&>hle in su$h a &ay that it &uld all& the dl(hin t i!itate hu!an s(ee$h
sund-• Lilly $lai!ed that elvar inter$han"ed hu!an sunds &ith dl(hin
,--:- A)ea)a!ai and (heni?- Learnin" arti+$ial Lan"ua"es thru"h Si"ht and Sund
30er!an < Wlz*.4=6
• /hey trained a bttlense dl(hin t !i!i$ $!(uter>"enerated
sunds-• /he dl(hin $uld learn ne& &histle and a((ly this &histle t the
na!in" ' b9e$ts su$h as Bball@* Bh(@* and
B'risbee@-• /he resear$hers $ndu$ted e?(eri!ents usin" t& diJerent
ty(es ' arti+al lan"ua"es* ne invlvin" sunds* the ther invlvin" visual "estures** i-e-
Si"ns-• 0er!an@s resear$h is ne ' the !st s$ienti+$ and
!ethdl"i$ally reliable n the learnin" ' lan"ua"e by
ani!als- /EA%0ING SP1;EN ENGLIS0 /1 AN
ARI%AN GRE PARR1/
%an (arrt learn lan"ua"e # /he ans&er is nt but based n the Pe((erber"@s 'as$inatin"
resear$h3 .4=* .44KPe((errber" and ;za) *.4=56 has (rven that ur assu!(tin is &rn"- 0e did a resear$h t a !ale A'ri$an Grey (arrt na!ed Ale?-Ale? $an sh& an e?$ellent $!(eten$e by identi'y $lr and sha(e and !aterial !re than .FF b9e$ts-Even Ale? !ade !ista)e but it al!st li)e the hu!an Bs !ista)e 'r instan$e he (rdu$e the &rd b? by
b$)-Ale? has !re talent then A(es and Dl(hin she has l& level ' synta? then
the!-ANIMAL %1MMUNI%A/I1N IN
/0E WILD
Ani!al $!!uni$ate thru"h a &ide variety ' !eans li)e sund* s!ell and visual
si"nal-,-5-:-/URN>/A;ING IN
S1UND>MA;ING
In !a)in" $!!uni$atin* ani!al (ra$ti$e natural ne li)e dne by hu!an bein" - r instan$e a !n)ey "et the $han"e t
$!!uni$ate a'ter his 'riend +nish- /his situatin als 'und in the birds@
li'e-,-5-- HIRD %ALLS
/he $alls ' bird has !any (ur(ses * they are2 .- Givin" in'r!atin ' it@s readiness t !ate :- Givin" alar! t (revent it@s territry
Based on the researcher that the calls of bird is innate, moreover a bird can imitate the human sound even it can not used it appropriately based on the context.
,-5-- 01NE HEES /0E
IN1RMA/I1N DAN%E
/here are !any interestin" thin"s 'r! the &ay ' bees@ $!!uni$atin bet&een the!* they are2
.- /hey use visin and tu$h t in'r! and understand the !essa"e 'r! ther by tu$hin" their 'riends by their &n
antennae-:- /hey instru$t t their 'riend t " ba$) t their hive by usin" s(e$i+$ !ve!ent* dan$e- E?$e(t 'r the bees that have a tas) t +nd 'd
- Givin" in'r!atin abut a s(e$ial ne$tar sur$e r even they $an tell t their 'riend the distant ' the ne$tar 'r!
the!-,-5-,- REAS1NING AND
%1NS%I1USNESS IN HEES AND ANIMAL
Hased n the Prin$etn University ethl"ist a!es
Guld3.4=5*.4==K "uld < "uld* .4== 6 that$ertain bees nt nly have an ability t in'r! that there is a ne$tar
near the! but they als $an anti$i(ate the ne& area ' 'd and y t )ee( it until their 'riends $!e t "et- It !eans that the bees have an ability t !a)e a !a( in their
!ind- In ther &rds &e $an said that the bees and ther ani!al *Hat* d thin" $ns$iusly and d thin) t a$t s!ethin"- 3Grin* .44:6-0e said that t )n& ani!al@s behaviur &e !ust learn the! s that &e $an understand the devel(!ent ' ur evlutin ' ur $ns$iusness and
thin)in"-,- %1N%LUSI1N
,--. $an Ani!al %!!uni$atin be re"arded as lan"ua"e
We $an say n* &hy#It $an be aans&ered thru"ht their $!!uni$atins B$hara$ters-0u!an $!!uni$ate &ith ea$h ther $reatively- /hey $an $reate any
variatin ' lan"ua"es -1n the ther hand ani!al $an $!!uni$ate quite s(esi+$ and sterety(e- /hey $an $!!uni$ate 9ust 'r the b9e$t trained t the!-/he study ' Washe*Sarah*Lana* ;)* ;anzi * the dl(hin and Ale? de!nstrate nly a !ini!al de"ree '
a$hieve!ent-,--:- /0E PUCCLE 2SEEMINGL
0IG0L IN/ELLIGEN/ ANIMALS
LEARN LI//LE LANGUAGE
/he resear$h dne n the ani!al sh&s that ani!al nly have rudi!entary lan"ua"e ability* &hether in the &ild r thru"h trainin"- Even the A(es is $reative and inventive t slve the (rble! than ther ani!als but they $an nt learn !re abut &hat is tau"ht t the!- 1n the ther $hildren $an learn !re &ith all its@ $!(le?ity 3Wl'"an"
%hler6- /here are t& ty(es ' e?(lanatin abut the a$quisitin ' lan"ua"e bet&een ani!al and hu!an2
.- Pr intelli"ent theries that ani!al la$) ' $ertain intelli"ent t learn lan"ua"e-3Pie"et6
:- Innatists 3 %h!s)y6 2ani!al brn &ithut a s(e$ial lan"ua"e ability- Ani!al dn@t have the $a(a$ity ' understandin" the "ra!!ar ' the