Fresh
Whole
Blood
Transfusions:
Efficacy,
Limitations,
and
the
Future
By
Marc
Difronzo
ACapstonePapersubmittedtothefacultyof theUniversityofNorthCarolinaatChapelHill
inpartialfulfillmentoftherequirements forthedegreeofMasterofHealthSciences
inthePhysicianAssistantProgram
ChapelHill December2017
________________________________
ToddWilliamsPA-C
11/15/2017
________________________________
KimFaurotPA,MPH,PhD(epidemiology)
11/15/2017
Background
Lossofbloodfromtraumassufferedonthebattlefieldisthemostcommoncauseofdeath amongpotentiallytreatableinjuriesinfrontlinemilitary operations(Keenanand Riesberg2017). Cessationofbloodlossandfluidrepletionhave beenmajordrivingfactorsthatcanreduce battlefieldcasualties.Oncethehemorrhagehasbeenstopped, thenextstepistoreplacelost volumetodecreasecardiacfailureorshock(Eastridge etal.2012;Butler2017).Uncontrolled hemorrhagecanleadtothe"traumatriadof death",whichconsistsofhypothermia,acidosis,and impairedcoagulation(Howardetal.2017).Hemostaticresuscitationinvolvestheblood
componentsresemblingwholeblood.Thegoalsaretoavoidmetabolicacidosis,hypothermia, treatingcoagulopathyandstabilizing thepatientassoonaspossible(Nicksonn.d.).The resuscitationfluidsofchoiceforcasualtiesinhemorrhagicshock,listedfrom mosttoleast preferredare:wholeblood;plasma,RBCsandplateletsin1:1:1ratio;plasmaandRBCsin1:1 ratio;plasmaorRBCsalone,and crystalloidfluids(Nicksonn.d.).
BetweenOctober2001andJune2011, 4,596battlefieldfatalitieswereanalyzed. Non-compressiblehemorrhageisthecauseofover 2/3ofbattlefield deaths,whichmakes hemorrhagestheleadingcauseofpotentiallysurvivable deathsincombat (KeenanandRiesberg 2017).Themajorbodyregionbleedingfocusaccountingformortality weretorso48%,
extremities31%,andneck/groin/ axillaregion21%(Eastridgeetal.2012).Casualtieswith severehemorrhagicinjury,theoddsofKIAmortality were83%lowerforcasualtieswhoneeded andreceivedpre-hospitalbloodtransfusion(Shackelfordet al.2017).Evaluatingtheinfluences onmortalityishelpfulforplanningeffortsthatoptimizeplacement,proximity, andprovisionof timelyandeffectivetransportandtreatmentcapabilitiestominimizecasualtyrisk (Malsbyetal.
2013).Combatwoundedontoday’sbattlefieldexperiencethehighestsurvival rateinhistory. Advancesinbattlefieldmedicineduringtheconflicts inIraqand Afghanistanhaveincluded theeffectiveuseof tourniquets,damagecontrolresuscitation,traumasystemdevelopment,en routecare,useof tranexamicacid,andadvancedtopicalhemostaticdressings (Malsbyetal. 2013).In2008,therewasamandatethatalltheinjuredpersonnelevacuationtosurgeonmust occurinlessthan60minutes,“TheGolden Hour”,thatcontributedtothelowestmortality rateofanyconflictinhistory (KeenanandRiesberg2017).
Componenttherapyremainsthemainstayintraumaresuscitation.Inprolongedfieldcare, accesstopackedredbloodcells,platelets,andfreshfrozenplasmaisoftenlimited(Keenanand Riesberg2017).TransfusionoffreshwholebloodhasbeenusedwhenaccesstoCTinthese settingsarelimitedorhavebeenfullyutilized .Theprocessofseparatingandreconstituting bloodcanlessenitseffectiveness.CurrentProlongedFieldCarestandardsidentified thatthebest practicefortransfusionswouldbetomaintainastockofpRBCandFFPandhavetype-specific donorsidentifiedforimmediateFWBdraw (KeenanandRiesberg2017).
PICOTQuestion:WhatarethelimitationsofFreshWholeBloodtransfusionsor
administrationofbloodproductsinprolongedpoint ofinjurycare onthebattlefield?
CrystalloidFluids
IsotonicIVfluidsbecamepopularintheVietnam Warduetoreducedcostandprolonged shelflifebecauseaccesstosupplieswasvery limitedduringthecampaign.Isotonicfluidsalso requirelessequipmentandlesstrainingfortheprovider aswell.Thestorage lifeof0.9%Normal Salinewhichis15monthsto3yearsdependingonthevolumeofthebag(Beckettetal.2015).
Thereisnoevidencethatsupportsisotonicfluid beingalife-savingmeasuretotraumaticinjuries (Beckettetal.2015)(Beckett etal.2015).Infact,itleadstofollowingcomplications:(1)
exacerbationofbleedingduetopossibleclot disruption,(2)exacerbation ofanemia,(3) thrombocytopenia,and(4)coagulopathy duetohemodilution(Nicksonn.d.).Ley etal.found thatreceivingintravenouscrystalloid>1.5litersin theemergencydepartment (ED)isan independentriskfactorformortality.
OtherAdjunctMethods
Manyothermethodshavebeenutilizedin conjunctionwithblood transfusionsinremote environmentstodecreasemortalitysuchasutilizing FactorVIIand TXA(tranexamicacid) (Anonn.d.).Theseareusedforshorttermresuscitation andcan“buytime”.TXAisanFDA approvedanti-fibrinolyticthatpreventsclotbreakdownbutcanleadtothromboembolicevents suchasdeepvenousthrombosisorpulmonaryembolism(Anonn.d.).FactorVIIisacrucial initialcomponentofthecoagulationcascade.Adouble-blindrandomizedcontroltrialconducted byAnantharajuetal.demonstratedastatisticallysignificantreductioninbloodtransfusion requirementsinpatientswithblunt,but notpenetrating,trauma.Tourniquetsareuser-friendly, cheap,andtransportableandtheirroleistostopthehemorrhage.Thephysiologicaleffectofan appropriatelyplacedtourniquetwillstoparterialflowtotheextremity,butatalowerpressure,it willstopthevenousflowtotheextremityandtrapthebloodinthe extremity.Asaresult,
clottingoccurs,andthebloodlactateconcentrationwillriseintheretainedbloodandwillbe releasedintothesystemiccirculationwhenthetourniquetis released(Tangetal. 2013).Thiscan leadtohypercoagulabilityandlactateacidosis.Thetourniquet hasarolewhenitcomesto
stoppingthehemorrhageandisbestused inconjunctionwith FWB.Autotransfusiontourniquets
arebeingutilizedintheciviliansettingaswell. Dr.NoamGavriely,a professorofmedicineand formerlyanemergencyphysicianandmemberoftheIsraeliDefenseForce, inventedtheFDA approveddevicewhichiscurrentlyusedintheOperating Roomsetting(Tanget al.2013).The devicecouldbeusedonahemorrhagingextremityoreven onanopenfractureifitcanberolled overtheinjury.Theremovalofthedevicehad tobedonegradually aftercorrectionofbleeding, andrestorationofthebloodvolume(Tangetal.2013) .Ifitwasremovedtoorapidly,wouldbe thesameastheimmediatelossofoneliterofwholeblood.Anotheradvantageoverthe
traditionaltourniquetistheshortertimeittakes toapplythedevice.Apre-hospitalstudy applicationinaCaliforniaEmergencyMedicalSystemisintheprocess ofarandomized prospectivestudy(Tanget al.2013).
ComponentTherapy
Componenttherapy(CT)ispartofthecurrentstandardofcare aswell.Component therapydoesconveybenefitsinfinancial,logisticalandinventorymanagementincontrolled environments(RamakrishnanandCattamanchi 2014).CTneedstobethawedandwarmed beforeusetoavoidcausinghypothermia.Bloodproducts thathavebeenusedlongerthan24 hoursresultinincreasedmortality.FWBhasmore clottingfactorsandnoneofthestorage problemsthatCThas (RamakrishnanandCattamanchi2014).Whencompared withfreshwhole bloodcells,thetransfusionoflargeamountsofpRBCcontributesto adilutionalcoagulopathy whichisprimarilythe resultofthrombocytopeniaandpoorplateletfunction.Storedplatelets demonstratedecreasedthromboticfunction.Thisisprimarily becauseofa decreaseinexpression ofhigh-affinitythrombinreceptors duringplateletstorage(Kauvaretal.2006).Clinically,FWB hasdemonstratedtoreversedilutionalcoagulopathy,withevidence thatasingleunitofFWBhas
ahemostaticeffectsimilartotenunitsofplatelets(Kauvar etal.2006).A1:1:1ratioofplasma, PRBCsandplateletscomponenttherapydoesnot containequivalentamounts ofclottingfactors, plateletsorfibrinogenasWFWB(Ramakrishnanand Cattamanchi2014).Necessityisthe motherofinventioninextendingtime toapatient'sdefinitivecare.
FreshWholeBlood
BattlefieldbloodtransfusionshavebeenusedsinceWWII.Thereisdata thatsupportsthe useofFWBinhypovolemic shock(Spinella2008).Itcontainsredbloodcells thatcarryO2to thetissues;plateletsthatpromoteclotting;andotherproteins,suchas albumin,thatmaintain bloodpressure.Criteriaindicatingneedforbloodtransfusionwasdefinedbased onthefollowing criteria:(1)systolicbloodpressure(SBP)≤90,(2) heartrate(HR)≥ 120,or(3)multiple
traumaticamputationsatorabovethekneeor elbow(Spinella2008).FWBresuscitationcan reducethe23%mortalityamonghypotensivetraumapatients (Smithetal.2016).Wholeblood hasa24hrlifespanandneedstobedestroyedafterthistimehaspassed.Theyshouldnotbeleft outofcontrolledtemperaturestorageformorethanthirtyminutesand transfusionshouldbe completewithinfourhoursfromcontrolledtemperature storage(Mclennanet al.2017).
TransfusionReactions
Transfusionreactionscanhappenbetweenthe donorandpotentialpatient.Compatibility isbasedonantigensAandBfoundintheredbloodcells.Apersoncanhave A,B,AB,orO (noneoftheantigens).Aperson'sbloodwillmakeantibodiesfortheotherbloodtypes.For example,typeBwillhaveanti-Aintheirplasma (Spinellaetal.2009) .Ifanincompatible transfusionoccurssuchasanacutehemolytictransfusionreaction(Spinellaetal.2009).Ifthis
happens,thehostbodieshaveantibodiesIgGandIgMthatwouldattachanddestroythedonor's redbloodcells.Asystemicimmunereactionwould occurandthecomplementsystemwouldbe activated.The"enemy"cellswouldbelysedand macrophageswouldcleanupthemessby phagocytosisandbyreleasingcytokinesandinterleukins. Thecytokinestrigger thereleaseof tissuefactorwhichwouldactivatetheintrinsicandextrinsiccoagulationpathways (Mitraetal. 2012).Previousresearchandpublicationsdemonstratethatwholebloodwith lowanti-Aand anti-BIgMtiterspresentalow/negligiblerisk ofacatastrophic acutehemolytictransfusion reactionwhengiventoindividuals thatarenotofthesamebloodgroup(Bassettetal.2016).
Limitations
Duringcombatsituationsbloodbankcapacityof forwardsurgicalunits andcombatfield hospitalsisfrequentlyoverwhelmed.The75thRanger Regiment's'RangerO LowTiter(ROLO) WholeBloodProgramwasthewinnerofthe annualArmy'sGreatestInnovationAwardatthe AssociationoftheUnitedStatesArmyGlobal WarfareSymposium.The programidentifiedall bloodgroupOmembersoftheunitandthenteststhemtodeterminepossible donorstobeused atthepointofinjury.Afterlaboratoryconfirmationofbloodtype,theteammedicwillmaintain arosterofbloodtypesforeachTypeOindividualonhisteam.The bloodproductshavea 35-dayshelflifewhenstoredat1to6 degreesCelsius.Typically,2-4 unitsarecollected24hrs priortoamission.
Collectionofthebloodproductsareconducted byBloodSupport Detachmentlocatedin overseasmilitarytheaterswhentheSoldierfirstarrives.Thedonorsfor thisbloodhave
completedtheunit’spreparation,screeningandvaccination programandhave beenincludedin
anestablished“walkingbloodbank”(Bassettetal. 2016).Thewalkingbloodbanksidentify specificbloodtypesofalltheSoldierspriortomilitaryoperations,sotheywilltheirspecific bloodtypetransfusedifneeded(Bassettetal.2016) .BloodtypeforeverySoldierisusually displayedonavelcropatch.Earlyactivationof thewalkingbloodbankbasedonprehospital mechanismofinjuryreducethetimetoFWBtransfusion(Bassettetal.2016).Thepreferred methodusedwhenperformingatransfusionisto givetheexacttypebetweendonorand recipient,butintimeswhentheenvironmentisnot controlled,typeOmay beusedasthe universaldonor(Hoand Leonard2011).
SOFmedicspreventtransfusionreactionswiththe useofblood cardsthatconsistently providebloodtypeinlessthan10minutes withtheFDAapprovedtheABORhcard(Bowling andPennardt2010).ViralinfectionssuchashepatitisBandCcanbescreenedwithrapid immunoassays,butthesetestsarenotFDAapprovedfordonorsettings (BowlingandPennardt 2010).Achallengewithbloodtransfusionsisequippingdesignatedpersonnel withtheproper equipmentandtraining,butSOFpersonnelutilized theirtraininglearned attheSpecial OperationsCombatMedicSkillsSustainmentCourse (BowlingandPennardt2010).
Theoperationalsituationischanging.Withthereductionoftroopsand decreaseintrue combatmissions,theSOFare beingreliedonmorenowthaneverbefore.Theareasaremore remoteandausterethaneverbefore(KeenanandRiesberg 2017).Theydonotenjoythesupport ofalargemedicalinfrastructurethatregulararmyunitshave.Medical evacuationtodefinitive careismeasuredindays,nothours.There aren'tenoughsurgicalandcriticalcareresources. CASEVAC’sareconstrainedbylandingstrips, weather,andunreliablepoliticalpermissions (KeenanandRiesberg2017).Withthepastrobustmedicalsupportavailableduringthewar,the
SpecialOperationsMedicshadade-emphasisontheirprolongedfieldcareforthesakeofpoint ofinjurytraumacare.Withthe,limitations inequipmentand transportation,Operationalcontext wasdefinedby“Ruck, Truck,House,Plane”(KeenanandRiesberg2017).Medicalsupport planswouldbedevelopedbasedonthisaspect.ProlongedFieldcare includessurgicalskills, freshwholebloodtransfusions,ventilatormanagement,advancedpainmanagement,and anesthesiaskills.TeleconsultationandrealtimeUltrasoundarebeingconsidered(Keenanand Riesberg2017).
NewTechnology
AstudywasconductedbyBoscarinoet almeasuredthe biochemicalandbiomechanical markersaffectedbychangessuchasheat,agitation,andpressurechanges onpRBC.Even thoughFWBwasnotusedinthisstudy,thesamechangeswouldhappento theRBCwithinthe FWB(Boscarinoetal.2014).Hemeasuredphysicalandchemicalchanges duringasimulated HALO(HighAltitudeLowOpening)airborneoperation followedbya 12-hourfootpatrol (Boscarinoetal.2014) .HALOairborneoperationsareconductedby SpecialOperationForces (SOF)whojumpfromthe aircraft,free-fallforaperiodoftimeatterminalvelocity,andopen theirparachuteatalowaltitude.Thishelps defeatidentificationviaradarandreducesthe amountoftimeaparachutemightbevisibletogroundobservers,enablingastealthyinsertion.
ThebloodsampleswerestoredintheSeries4-EMTGoldenHour coolingcontainersfor thedurationoftheexperiment.Thecontainers remainedbetween2.3-3.8 degreesCelsiuswhich isinaccordancewiththeAmericanAssociation BloodBankstandards fortransport(Boscarino etal.2014).DuringtheHALOdrop,thepHdidnotsignificantlychange.LactateandPotassium