PATHOLOGIC
ANATOMY
OF
COMPLETE
TRANSPOSITION
OF
THE
ARTERIAL
TRUNKS
Maurice Lev, M.D., Victor M. Alcalde, M.D., and Thomas G. Baffes, M.D.
Cng(’Ilit(Jl heart i)isease Research and Training Center, Hektoen Institute, and the Departments Of
P(:tIiologt/ 011(1 Surgcrsj of tile Children’s Memorial Hospital, and the Departments- of Pathology of Northwestern Unieersity Medical School and the
Unicersity of Chicago School of Medicine
This investigation was supported by Research Grant (H-3351) from the National Heart Institute, Public
Health Service.
ADDRESS: (ML.) Hektoen Institute, 629-637 South Wood Street, Chicago 1.2, Illinois.
PEDIAnucs, August 1961
293
I
PREVIOUS COMMUNICATIONS, thepatho-logic anatomy of transposition
com-plexes, including complete transposition,
were classified and discussed.15 Complete transposition has also been discussed by other authors.613 This report deals with an
analysis of 70 cases of complete
transposi-tion studied from the museum specimens of
the Children’s Memorial Hospital and 77
cases seen at the Congenital Heart Disease
Research and Training Center. This analysis
has resulted in what we believe is a
clanifi-cation of the subject for the pathologist. This study is limited to cases of complete
transposition in pure levocardia. It does not
deal with cases in mixed levocandia
(in-verted transposition-corrected
tnansposi-tion) or in dextrocardia. In pure levocardia, transposition may be defined as an abnon-mality in the position of the aorta on its
remnant with respect to the pulmonary
artery or its remnant, and with respect to the chambers from which they arise. Com-plete transposition may thus be defined as the emergence of the aorta from the right ventricle and the pulmonary artery from the left. Thus it does not include the Taussig-Bing syndrome. The term can include
pul-monary atresia, where the aorta comes out completely from the right and the pul-monary remnant has a position reminiscent
of complete transposition.
The cases of complete transposition were
studied according to position and size of
the arterial trunks, relative sizes and
thick-ness of walls of the atnia and ventricles,
nature of septal defects, architecture of
the muscle bundles of the right ventricle,
and associated abnormalities. The absolute
sizes and muscle mass of the chambers, as
compared to the normal, and the
distribu-tion of the coronary arteries, are not in-cluded in this work and will be reported separately.
CLASSIFICATION
The classification in Table I was adopted for the 147 cases studied morphologically.
The age incidence for the individual types
was studied for 123 cases that came to necropsy and is included in the table. It can be seen that transposition of the arterial trunks is largely a pediatric problem. It is surprising, however, that some patients sun-vive to their teens.
Complete Transposition with Normal Archi-tecture without Ventricular Septal Defect
(51 Cases)
In complete transposition with normal
architecture without ventricular septal de-fect, the architecture of the ventricles was deviated only slightly from the normal. Yet, the aorta emerged from the night ventricle and the pulmonary artery from the left. Usually, the aorta was situated anteriorly and to the right, and the pulmonary artery posteriorly and to the left (Fig. 1).
Occa-sionally the aorta was situated anteriorly
and the pulmonary artery posteriorly (Fig.
pos-tenor and left anterior sinuses of Valsalva (Fig. 4). The tricuspid valve was either
nor-(
Fig. 4). In most cases there was a charac- mally formed, or there was a slight ab-teristic type of crista; the septal band wasnormal; the panietal band was broad and
sharply demarcated from the septal band; the parietal band formed most of the cnista
FIG. 1. Complete transposition with normal
arch-tecture. The anterior surface of heart is shown
with the usual position of arterial trunks; the aorta
(A) is anterior and to the right and the pulmonary artery (P) posterior and to the left.
Fic. 2. Complete transposition with normal
archi-tecture. The anterior surface of heart is shown with
one of the unusual positions of the arterial trunks;
the aorta (A) is anterior and the pulmonary artery
(P) posterior.
3. With pulmonary stenosis 7 5 11 days-74 yr yr 9 mo
B. With common ventricle (cor biatriatum triloculare) 4 Sf yr-1 yr 1 yr mo
C. With single ventricle and small outlet chamber’4 7 6 8 days-b yr 3 yr 44 mo
II. YSITH AIINORMALA-V ORIFICE
A. With tricuspid stenosis or atresia 11 13 Stillborn-44 yr 1yr 8 mo
B. With mitral stellOsis or atresia 5 5 3 days-4 yr 9 mo wk
C. With common A-V orifice 8 5 3 days-8 yr I yr 8f mo
h ,
v’
Fic. :3. Complete transposition with normal
archi-tecture. The anterior surface of heart is shown, \vitll another ullusual position of the arterial trunks;
the aorta (A) is to the right and the pulmonary artery (P) to the left.
In complete transposition with normal
architecture with ventricular septal defect, the architecture of the right ventricle was
somewhat more disturbed than in the previ-ously discussed complex. However, it still
FIG. 4. Complete transposition with normal archi-tecture, right ventricular view, showing coronary
ostia (C), panietal band (Pa), septal band (S), and
usual architecture of the cnista.
Fic. 5. Complete transposition with normal
archi-tecture, left ventricular view, showing defect (D)
of the ventricular septum situated below the
pul-monary artery (P), between the anterior and
p05-tetior septa.
normality in the connections of the medial leaflet. This was connected by small papillary muscles to the septum.
In almost all cases there was either a probe-patent or widely patent foramen
ovale, and in most cases there was a patent
ductus arteniosus. The pulmonary artery was larger than, equal to, or smaller than
the aorta. Usually, the right and left ventri-des were of equal size and thickness, on the right ventricle was larger and thicker than the left. Less frequently, the left ventricle was larger and thicker than the night. The same applied to the atria. There were fre-quent abnormalities of the eustachian and thebesian valves. In a few cases, there was a bicuspid or otherwise abnormal pulmonic valve, a fetal coarctation, or a left superior
vena cava draining into the coronary sinus.
Complete Transposition with Normal
FIG. 6. Complete traIlSl)OsitiOfl vith normal
archi-tecture, left ventricular view, showing defect (D)
of the ventricular septum, situated some distance l)elOW the lt1lmo11tr> artery (P) between the
an-terior and posterior septa.
FL,. ,.. .,)1ete transposition with normal
archi-tecture, right ventricular view, showing defect (D)
of the ventricular septum excavating the septal band (S), and the panietal band (Pa).
bore a strong resemblance to the normal. The position of the arterial trunks was the
Fic. 7. Complete trans]position with normal
archi-tecture, left ventricular view, showing defect (D)
of the ventricular septum, situated in the posterior
septum at the base, and the pulmonary artery (P)
same as in the previous type, as were the
coronary ostia. The ventricular septal de-fect was either in the anterior septum at the base (Fig. 5), at the junction of tile anterior and posterior septa at the base (Fig. 6), in
the pars membranacea, or in the posterior
septum at the base (Fig. 7). Uncommonly
the defect was in a more apical portion of the septum. In a few cases there were two defects, one at the base and one near the
apex, or both were at the base, one in the anterior and the other in the posterior sep-tum. Accordingly, the defect entered the right ventricle, either without disturbing the cnista or altering the cnista in various ways.
Where the defect was in the anterior sep-tum, it usually opened into the right
ventri-dc beneath the cnista, or the cnista was
excavated mildly or to the point of complete
separation of the septal and parietal bands.
\Vhere the defect was between the anterior
and posterior septa, or in the posterior
septum, it usually altered the septal band
(Fig. 8). Commonly, tile defect was unre-lated to the orifices of the aorta and
Fic. 9. Complete transposition with pulmonic ste-nosis, left ventricular view, showing the subpul-monic stenosis (ST) and the ventricular septal
defect (D), and pulmonary artery (P).
FIG. 10. Complete transposition with pulmonic stenosis, right ventricular view, showing defect (D)
adjacent to aorta (A).
Fic. 1 1. Complete transposition with pulmonary
atresia, left ventricular view, showing aorta (A),
closing ventricular septal defect (D), and
atresia (At).
to tile pulmonary artery than the aorta, but
in some cases it was related to both. The
relative sizes of the aorta and pulmonary
artery varied. The tricuspid valve was more
often abnormally formed than in the
previ-Otis type; the medial leaflet was connected
to papillary muscles or to the rim of the defect.
The foramen ovale was usually open, but the cluctus arteniosus was often closed. A few cases showed closure of both. In most
cases the pulmonary artery was larger than
tile aorta. Uncommonly, the vessels were of
equal size, or the aorta was larger than the pulmonary artery. In the majority of cases, the left ventricle was larger than the right
ventricle; but in many cases, the right
yen-tricle was larger than the left, and in a few
cases they were equal in size. In general,
tile ventricles were of equal thickness; but, in some cases, the night was thicker than
the left. However, it was uncommon for the left ventricle to be thicker than the night. In most cases, tile right atrium was larger than the left; in a minority, both atnia were of equal size or tile left was larger than the
right. In general, both atria were of equal tilickness, or the right was thicker than the
left. Uncommonly, the left atrium was
FIG. 14. Complete transposition with single ventricle
and small outlet chamber, showing aorta (A),
ptl-monary artery (P) and small outlet chamber (0).
In cases of complete transposition with
I . #{149}-‘
FIG. 13. Complete transposition with common
yen-trick, showing tricuspid orifice (T), mitral on-fice (M), pulmonic orifice (P) and aortic orifice (A).
FIG. 12. Complete transposition with common ventricle and aortic hvpoplasia, anterior view,
showing aorta (A) and pulmonary artery (P).
tilebesian valves were common. Other as-sociated abnormalities were bicuspid
pul-monic valve, bicuspid aortic valve, fetal
co-arctation, displaced right atrial appendage,
cleft aortic leaflet of the mitral valve,
con-genital aneurysm of the pars membranacea with the defect, and double aortic arch.
Complete Transposition with Normal Archi-tecture with Pulmonary Stenosis (7 cases)
normal architecture with pulmonary
ste-nosis, the architecture of both the right and left ventricles deviated more from the
nor-mai than in the two types just discussed (Figs. 9 and 10). Yet, the basic architecture of the ventricles was retained. The
pul-monary artery and aorta were situated
an-teniorly-posteniorly, respectively, or the aorta was anterior and to the right, and the
pulmonary artery posterior and to the left.
The coronary ostia were situated either in the posterior sinuses of Valsalva, in the pos-tenor and right anterior, or in the posterior and left anterior. The ventricular septal de-fect was in the anterior septum, or at the junction of the anterior and posterior septa. The defect was not confluent with the mouth of the pulmonary artery (Fig. 9), but in some cases it was confluent with the mouth of the aorta (Fig. 10). The defect opened into the right ventricle, excavating the cnista (Fig. 10), in the cases presented here. One case in this series presented no defect. Another case showed pulmonary atresia,
with the remainder of the heart being identical in type with tile others (Fig. 11).
The left ventricle, in this series, presented a separate narrow outflow tract, which gave rise to the pulmonary artery (Fig. 9). The
lining of the tract showed marked
fibro-elastosis. Tile pulmonary orifice was
nan-rowed or normal. The pulmonary artery was
smaller than the aorta, or they were the
FIG. 15. Complete transposition with single ventricle
and small outlet chamber, with view of the right FIG. 18. Complete transposition with mild tricuspid
atrium anti single ventricle. stenosis (tricuspid valve, at T).
of the former. The pulmonary valve in some cases was bicuspid, or abnormally formed,
with marked hemodynamic changes. In the cases presented here, the left ventricle was
larger than the night (Fig. 9). The walls
were either of equal thickness, or the right or left dominated in thickness. An atrial
FIG. 16. Complete transposition with single ventricle
and small outlet chamber, with view of the left atrium and single ventricle.
FIG. 17. Complete transposition with single ventricle
and small outlet chamber, showing ridge (R) that
bears I)tllldle of His and bundle branches, and Fic. 19. Complete transposition with severe
FIG. 20. Complete transposition with tricuspid ste-nosis, right ventricular view, showing right
ventni-cle (RV) and aorta (A).
F.. . omplete transpo tnic
atresia, left ventricular view, showing pulmonary artery (P), defect (D) of ventricular septum,
due-tus anteniosis (Du) and aorta (A).
Complete Transposition with Common Ven-tricle (4 Cases)
;.4w,’__’ -
-#{149}b#{149} ,
septal defect was found, but the ductus was usually closed. Associated abnormalities in
this series were displaced right atrial
ap-pendage and night aortic arch.
FIG. 21. Complete transposition with tricuspid atresia, night atrial view, showing limbus (L) and
atresia (A).
In the complex of complete transposition with common ventricle (con biatniatum
tniloculare) (Figs. 12 and 13), there was an absence of the ventricular septum (Fig. 13), the only remnant being a low ridge on the
posterior wall, representing the posterior
septum. The latter carries the atrioventricu-lar bundle and both bundle branches. Both the mitral and tricuspid orifices entered, and both the aorta and pulmonary artery emerged from, the common ventricle. The
entrance into the aorta was in some cases
surrounded by a circular rim of
muscula-tune. In this series the aorta was situated an-tenionly and to the left and the pulmonary
artery posteriorly and to the right. The
aorta and pulmonary artery were equal in
size, or either vessel was larger. Pulmonary stenosis was present in one case.
Complete Transposition with Single Ven-tricle and Small Outlet Chamber (7 Cases)
301
FIG. 24. Complete transposition with tricuspid
atresia, showing displaced right atnial append-age (RA), left atnial appendage (LA) and arota (A).
Complete Transposition with Tricuspid Atresia or Stenosis (1 1 Cases)
FIG. 23. Complete transposition with tricuspid atresia. right ventricular view, showing right
ventri-dc (RI’) and aorta (A).
FIG. 25. Complete transposition with mitral and
pulmonic stenosis and common ventricle, anterior view, showing the aorta (A).
outlet chamber 14 (Figs. 14-16) resembled
the preious type. Internally, however, the muscle bun(lleS of tile flgllt ventricle were
represented by a circular ring of muscle,
pro-ducing a pseudoseptum that separated a
main cllalTflber from a small chamber usually
situated anteriorly and superiorly. There
vas a small defect in this pseudoseptum. A
remnant of posterior septum was always
present on the posterior wall carrying the
conduction system (Fig. 17). The aorta was
situated anteriorly and to the left, and the
pulmonary artery posteriorly and to the right (Fig. 14), or tile vessels were
anterior-posterior. The main chamber received the
mitral and tricuspid orifices (Figs. 15 and
16) and gave rise to the pulmonary artery.
The small chamber gave rise to the aorta
(Fig. 14). The pulmonary artery was larger
than tile aorta. The coronary ostia were in
the posterior sinuses of Valsalva, or the
pos-tenor and right anterior sinuses of Valsalva.
The mitral and tricuspid valves were often
altered and in several cases difficult to
iden-tify, as were the inflow tracts into the single
ventricle.
FIG. 26. Complete transposition with mitral and pulmonic stenosis and common ventricle, internal view,
showing aorta (A), pulmonary artery (P) and tricuspid valve (T). The pointer is in the mitral orifice.
diminutive night ventricle with a lange left
ventricle, or a single ventricle with small
outlet chamber. Under these circumstances
FIG. 27. Complete transposition with mitral and
pulmonic atresia, left atnial view. The arrow points
to the region of mitral atresia.
the ventricular septal defect was relatively small, and the aorta was smaller than the
pulmonary artery. In a variant (not seen in
this series, but previously seen by one of us {M.L.}) tile right ventricle or conus was divided from the main chamber by an ab-normal cnista with a large defect, and the aorta was large with pulmonary atnesia.
In this series, the aorta and pulmonary artery were situated anteroposteniorly, or the aorta was anterior and to the left and the pulmonary artery posterior and to the right, or the aorta was anterior and to the right and the pulmonary artery posterior and to the left. The coronary ostia lay in the
posterior, on posterior and right sinuses of Valsalva. In most cases the ventricular
sep-tal defect was small, and situated either in the posterior septum, on at the junction of the anterior and posterior septa, or in the anterior septum. It was usually not
ri
FIG. 28. Complete transposition with mitral and
pulmonic atresia, ventricular view (may be
in-terpreted as single ventricle with separate conus,
or common ventricle), showing aorta (A), muscle ridge (Al) dividing off “conus” from ventricle, left inflow tract of ventricle (L), right inflow tract of ventricle (R) and ridge (Ri) probably carrying
atnioventnicular bundle and bundle branches.
FIG. 29. Complete transposition with common
atrioventricular orifice and pulmonary stenosis, right
atrial and right ventricular view. The arrows point
to the proximal and distal margins of the combined
septal defect.
FIG. 30. Complete transposition with common
atnioventricular orifice and pulmonary stenosis, right ventricular view, showing aorta (A) and accessory
ventricular septal defect (D).
of the fossa ovalis, a displaced right atnial
appendage (Fig. 24) and right aortic arch.
Complete Transposition with Mitral
Steno-sis or Atresia (5 Cases)
The complex of complete transposition
with mitral stenosis (Figs. 2 and 26) or atresia (Figs. 27 and 28) presented either a common ventricle or a single ventricle and small outlet chamber. The aorta and pul-monary artery were situated
antenopos-teriorly, or the aorta was to the right and
anterior and the pulmonay artery to the left
and posterior, or the aorta was to the left and anterior and the pulmonary artery to
the right and posterior. Pulmonary stenosis or atresia was present in all our cases. The left atrium was smaller than the right, and
there was an atrial septal defect of the
secundum type in all cases. An associated
abnormality was right aortic arch.
Complete Transposition with Common Atrioventricular Orifice (8 Cases)
In complete transposition with common
atrioventnicular orifice (Figs. 29-33), the
position of tile aorta and pulmonary artery
was anterior-posterior, or the aorta was
an-tenor and to the night, and the pulmonary artery posterior and to the left. The
l LA
,
L.
i
FIr.. 31. Complete transposition with common
atnio-ventricular orifice and pulmonary stenosis, left “entnicular view, showing pulmonary artery at P.
FIG. 32. Complete transposition with common
atrio-ventricular orifice and pulmonary atresia, showing
aorta (A) and combined septal defect (arrows).
component. There was either a night and
left ventricle, slightly subdivided, with the right larger than the left, on there was either a single ventricle with small outlet chamber
or a common ventricle. The night atrium
was larger than the left. In all cases in this
FIG. 33. Complete transposition with common
atrio-ventricular orifice and pulmonary atresia, showing
aorta (A), pulmonary artery (P) and left atnial
appendage (LA).
series there was pulmonary stenosis or
atresia.
COMMENT
It is self-evident that complete transpo-sition as discussed above includes various entities that differ markedly physiologically and clinically. However we believe that from a pathologic standpoint this concept of complete transportation is helpful at the
necropsy table and may also prove advan-tageous from the angiocardiographic, cine-angiocandiographic and noentgenologic standpoints. Certainly from the
stand-point of embryology this grouping has a
unity, which has been discussed
else-where.1’2’ 7,11,15
It may be noted, as originally pointed
out by Spitzen,7 that this group (Groups 3 and 4 of Spitzer) presents the simplest
to the most complicated complexes. Thus in complete transposition with normal
archi-tectu.re, aside from the shunts, there are
only minimal variations from the normal architecture of the heart. On the other hand complete transposition with common
chamber, show marked departure from the normal arcilitecture. Thus severe types of
transposition may be associated with
nor-mal or almost completely absent ventricular
septation.
It may be further noted that complete
transposition is often associated with
pul-monary stenosis or atresia. This is seen in a
few cases Witil normal architecture, is more
common in common ventricle, and becomes
very common in complete transposition
with mitral stenosis or atresia, or with common atrioventricular orifice. Complete transposition with common ventricle, with single ventricle and small outlet chamber,
and with tricuspid atresia are more often as-sociated with increased pulmonary flow.
The complex complete transposition \vitil
pulmonary stenosis deserves further
com-ment. Tile stenosis is almost if not always
some distance from the pulmonary orifice
and may be called “subpulmonary” or “left infundibular.” This stenosis may
pen-ilaps be acquired hemodynamically, due to
tile distance of the ventricular septal defect
from tile pulmonary artery. This is further
indicated by a case of pulmonary atresia
and what appeared to be a closing defect.
It may be postulated that this was originally a stenosis that went on to atnesia due to the diversion of flow through the defect and the fibroelastic reaction to the turbulent
flow.
There is a group of cases that may be
called partial or complete transposition with
pulmonary atresia. In these cases, the aorta
comes from the right ventricle, and the position of the aorta and pulmonary rem-nant, the coronary ostia, and the architec-tune of the muscle bundles of the right
ventricle are reminiscence of complete or partial transposition. There is always a ventricular septal defect in the anterior
sep-tum, and right ventricular hypentrophy. These cases are best considered under the concept of pseudotruncus, which also in-cludes over-riding aorta with pulmonary
atnesia, and they are therefore not con-sidered in this paper. We believe the term pseudotruncus should apply only to those
cases of over-riding aorta, partial or
com-plete transposition with pulmonary atresia, without other basic abnormalities such as absence of the ventricular septum, and ab-normalities in the atnioventnicular orifices, which are described above. Likewise
pul-monary atresia without a transposition
coni-plex should not be included in this category. It is also clean that complete transposition with common ventricle and with single vei’-tide and small outlet chamber are akin. If the muscle bundles of the crista are so
arranged as to produce a separate small outlet chamber, then the latter is obtained.
If on the other hand they are so situated as to produce a demarcation between the aorta and pulmonary artery, without
actually setting off a small outlet chamber, then the former is obtained. Sometimes the musculature is so arranged that the heart can be classified in either way.
It might be useful to look upon complete transposition complexes as having multiple variables producing many combinations. The variables are 1) pulmonary stenosis or
atnesia, or hypoplasia of the aorta with or without coarctation, 2) complete, partial or no ventricular septation, and 3) normal
atrioventricular orifices or mitral or
tricus-pid stenosis or atresia, or common
atnio-ventricular orifice.
From the surgical point of view, the
above classification of complete tnanspo-sition has its place in deciding whether a lesion is amenable to surgery, and the type of surgery to be employed. In complete transposition with normal architecture, with or without ventricular septal defect or with
mild pulmonary stenosis, partial correction by transplantation of the inferior vena cava and night pulmonary veins may be under-taken. In complete transposition with non-mal architecture with marked pulmonary stenosis, and other types of complete trans-position with pulmonary stenosis or atnesia, an aortico-pulmonany,
subclavian-pulmo-nary, or superior vena cava-pulmonany
artery anastomosis may be performed. Complete transposition with abnormal
atnesia or with common atnioventnicular
on-fice are characteristically associated with pulmonic stenosis and atresia, while com-plete transposition with tricuspid stenosis on atresia, on with common ventricle, or single ventricle and small outlet chamber are more
commonly associated with increased pul-monary flow. The two complexes, complete transposition with common ventricle and that with single ventricle and small outlet chamber, are very closely related
pathologi-cally.
REFERENCES
1. Lev, M., and Saphir, 0. : Transposition of the
large vessels. J. Tech. Methods, 17:126, 1937.
2. Lev, M., and Saphir, 0. : A theory of
trans-position of the arterial trunks based on the
phylogenetic and ontogenetic development
of the heart. Arch. Path., 39: 172, 1945.
3. Lev, M. : The pathologic anatomy of cardiac
complexes associated with transposition of
arterial trunks. Lab. Invest., 2:296, 1953.
4. Lev, M. : Congenital heart disease, in A Text
on Systemic Pathology, Vol. 1, edited by 0.
position den Herzostien-ein Versuch der
Erkl#{228}rung dieser Erscheinung: Die
Phorono-mie den Herzentwicklung als morphogene-tische Grundlage den Erkl#{228}rung; die
Pho-ronomie den Herzentwicklung. Z. Anat.
Ent-wicklungsgesch., 100:563, 1933.
10. Taussig, H. B.: Complete transposition of the
great vessels : clinical and pathologic fea.
tures. Amen. Heart J., 16:728, 1938.
11. Harris, J. S., and Farber, S.: Transposition of
the great cardiac vessels, with special
refer-ence to the phylogenetic theory of Spitzer.
Arch. Path., 28:427, 1939.
12. Becker, M. C., and Bnill, R. M. : Complete
transposition of great vessels : report of three
cases and review of the literature. Arch.
Pediat., 6,5:249, 1948.
13. Edwards, J. E. : Congenital malformations of
the heart and great vessels, in Pathology of
the Heart, Ed. 2, edited by S. E. Gould.
Springfield, Illinois, Thomas, 1960, p. 260.
14. Taussing, H. B.: Congenital Malformations of
the Heart. New York, The Commonwealth
Fund, 1947.
15. Lev, M., and Kaveggia, E. : The etiology and
pathogenesis of congenital heart disease, in
Cardiology, edited by A. Luisada. New York,