(
Received January 7; revision accepted for publication March 2, 1972.)This work was supported by National Institute of Mental Health Research Development Award
Ki-MH-43340 (T.F.A. ) and by the W. T. Grant Foundation, Inc.
ADDRESS FOR REPRINTS: (T.F.A.
)
Children’s Hospital, 219 Bryant Street, Buffalo, New York14222.
PEDIATRICS, Vol. 50, No. 2, August 1972
REVIEW
ARTICLE
SLEEP AND
ITS DISORDERS
IN INFANTS
AND
CHILDREN:
A REVIEW
Thomas F. Anders, M.D., and Pearl Weinstein, MS.
From the Infant Development Laboratory, Department of Psychiatry, Montofiore Hospital and Medical
Center, and The Rose F. Kennedy Center for Research in Mental Retardation and Human Development,
Albert Einstein College of Medicine
ABSTRACT. Recently the polygraphic study of
sleep has provided techniques for the assessment of
central nervous system (CNS ) functioning in new-born infants and the diagnosis of sleep disorders in
children. First, in this review, the normal
develop-mental course of the “active” and the “quiet” sleep
states from birth through childhood is described.
Then, within the context of these recent
electro-physiologic findings, the abnormalities of sleep state
organization during the neonatal period, the
physi-ologic disorders of sleep in older children, and
finally, the psychological disturbances manifested
through sleep are reviewed.
Pediatrics, 50:312, 1972, SLEEP, ENURESIS,
NIGHT-MARES, NARCOLEPSY, INSOMNIA.
I
N 1955 Aserinsky and Kleitman,1observ-ing sleeping infants, described a
“rest-activity” cycle characterized by quiet
pen-ods of no body movements and no eye
movements and active periods of body
movements and rapid eye movements
(
REMs)
under closed lids. Dement andK.leitman2 first confirmed these observations
by electrophysiologic recording from
sleep-ing adults in 1957. More than 15 years later,
after a virtual explosion of investigative
in-terest into the functions and mechanisms of
sleep in man and other animals, it is well
recognized that sleep is not a unitary
physi-ologic state of restitution, but rather two
cycling states of differing physiologic
activ-ity. Several texts indicate the scope of this
work,3 and sleep studies during infancy
Abbreviations
CNS : Central nervous system
EEG: Electroencephalogram
NREM: Nonrapid eye movement
REM: Rapid eye movement
REMs : Rapid eye movements
SWs : Slow wave sleep
have recently been reviewed by Lenard.6
Although the sleep of infants and adults
differs in minor details, the basic alternation
of an “aroused” state with an “inhibited”
one is similar. An initial description of the
adult sleep cycle provides the background
for the understanding of developing sleep
patterns and sleep stage sequencing in the
infant and young child. Demerit and
Kleit-man2 described four stages of
electroence-phalogram
(
EEC)
activity during adultsleep: Stage 1 is typified by low voltage,
fast activity; Stage 2 by the presence of
sleep spindles and K-complexes against a
low voltage background; and Stages 3/4
by varying degrees of slow, high voltage
ac-tivity. Stages 3/4 have been called slow
wave sleep
(
SWS)
. Rapid eye movement(
REM)
sleep is defined by the occurrenceof a Stage 1 EEC, binocularly synchronous
rapid eye movements, the suppression of
muscle tone as recorded from chin muscles,
and accelerated, irregular respiratory and
heart rates. The nonrapid eye movement
(
NREM)
stages(
1 to 4)
of sleep lackREMs and are accompanied by the
pres-ence of muscle tone, and slowed, regular
alternat-REVIEW ARTICLE
ing REM and NREM states, occurring
dur-ing sleep, define two distinct states of
neu-rophysiologic activity. The REM state is
highly activated; the NREM state is basal
and highly regulated. They follow each
other in a periodic fashion and together
they comprise the sleep cycle.
A typical adult sleep cycle starts (as does
sleep onset) with “descending” NREM
sleep stage shifts, moving from Stage 1 to 4,
then “emergent” shifts through Stages 3 and
2 to a REM period after which the cycle is
repeated. The typical night’s sleep involves
4 to 6 REM/NREM cycles. The REM
phase of the cycle is associated with what
typically has been defined as dreaming
though some mental activity does occur
during Stages 1 and 2 of NREM sleep.7’8
The present paper considers sleep and its
disorders in infants and children with
re-spect to recent findings emanating from
po-lygraphic studies of sleep. The
psychologi-cal disturbances of sleep, not associated
with abnormal polygraphic findings, are
differentiated from the physiologic
disor-ders. Three broad areas are reviewed : (1)
the development of normal and abnormal
sleep patterns in infancy, (2) physiologic
disorders of sleep and arousal in children,
and
(
3)
psychological stresses manifestedby disturbances of sleep. Although these
areas differ slightly in their subject matter,
the role of sleep is central and the
poly-graphic recording of sleep parameters is
relevant to both development and
physio-logic studies. For the sake of completeness
they are included in this single review. It is
hoped that continuing investigation will
provide the links, if any, between early
de-velopmental deviations and the later
disor-dens of sleep and arousal. For the present, it
is possible only to review the three areas
in-dependently.
THE DEVELOPMENT
OF SLEEP
PATTERNS IN INFANCY
The changing electrophysiologic and
or-ganizational characteristics of infant sleep,
as maturation progresses, provide new
indi-ces for early developmental assessment.
Several of the differences between infant
and adult sleep patterns and sleep cycles
are worthy of note:
Organization
All of the sleep occurring during the
adult’s night sleep can readily be classified
as either REM or NREM sleep and staged
accordingly. During the newborn period, in
contrast, the physiologic and behavioral
ac-tivities routinely recorded during a sleep
period are not as readily classified into two
distinct sleep states. In a recent attempt at
standardization of terms and techniques, an
infant scoring manual has been published
which defines three sleep states : . . .
active-REM sleep, quiet sleep and indeterminate
sleep.9 Whereas active-REM sleep and
quiet sleep may be precursors of adult
REM and NREM sleep respectively and
seem, even in infancy, to share the
“acti-vated” and “basal” characteristics of the
two adult sleep states, indeterminate sleep
represents an “immature” state of poorly
or-ganized sleep, predominant in premature
infants but also present in young, term
in-fants and some abnormal infants. For more
precise definitions of these sleep states the
reader is referred to the infant scoring
man-ual.#{176}
Proportions
Sleep state proportions change with age.
Indeterminate sleep, predominant in the
premature infant of 34 weeks, diminishes
and most often disappears by 3 months of
age. At term, active-REM sleep occupies
45 to 50% of total sleep lime, indeterminate
sleep occupies 10 to 15%, and quiet sleep
occupies 35 to 45%. With increasing age,
the proportion of quiet sleep increases and
active-REM sleep decreases until late
childhood when young adult normative
amounts are achieved
(
20% REM sleep;80% NREM sleep).b012 Furthermore, by 3
months of age, quiet sleep EEC patterns
can begin to be subclassified into NREM
sleep stages.13
The predominance of an activated state
led Roffwarg, et al.1 to put forward the
on-togenetic hypothesis which restated,
sug-gests, “the REM sleep mechanisms of the
brainstem constitute a CNS
auto-stimulat-lug system particularly important during
uterine development and early post-natal
life when the young organism is relatively
cut off from external stimulation. Since
growth and maintenance of neural tissue
are enhanced by stimulation, according to
this view, the cyclic excitatory activation
provided to much of the brain by REM
sleep serves to augment differentiation of
neunonal structures and lay down the
mdi-ments of neurophysiological discharge
pat-terns in the developing organism.”15
Periodicity and Sequencing
The length of the sleep cycle
(active-REM/quiet sleep) changes with age. The
cycle of normal infants at term has a
pen-odicity of 45 to 50 minutes. More immature
infants have shorter cycles and premature
infants of less than 34 weeks’ conceptual
age do not demonstrate sleep cycling.16 The
sleep cycle of adolescents and adults
ap-proximates 90 to 100 minutes.
The temporal patterning of individual
sleep states within a sleep period also
changes with age. Whereas adults enter
sleep with an initial sustained NREM
pe-nod and have most of their REM sleep
dun-ing the last third of the night, newborn
in-fants enter sleep initially through
active-REM sleep and cycle, at regular intervals,
with quiet sleep. Thus there is as much
ac-live-REM sleep in the first half of the
new-born’s sleep period as in the second half.
Day-Night Shifts
Diurnal patterning of sleep and
wakeful-ness develops with maturation. In adults,
wakefulness and sleep are associated most
commonly with light and dark respectively.
In newborn infants, daytime wakefulness
and night time sleep is evident by 3 months
of age, though indications of the diurnal
rhythm have been reported as early as the
first 10 days of life.17,18 These day-night
shifts occur while the overall 24-hour
amounts of sleep and wakefulness change
only minimally. Initial brief, individual
sleep and wake periods coalesce into longer
periods as the diurnal pattern develops. By
8 months of age a sustained period of
day-time wakefulness, interrupted by two brief
naps, and an uninterrupted period of night
time sleep are characteristic.19 This process
of “settling” or sleeping through the night is
discussed further in the section on
psycho-logical disturbances of sleep. It is unclear
what, if any, environmental influences retard
on enhance the progression of these
devel-opmental changes. On the one hand, early
adequate mother-infant regulation
includ-ing appropriate feeding procedures, diet,
absence of excessive anxiety, sufficient
han-dling, and so forth have been implicated;
on the other hand, maturation of the CNS
alone has been felt to be sufficient. Most
likely, the combination of a sensitive,
re-sponsive environment and normal
matuna-lion is optimal.
Miscellaneous
Several minor differences between adult
sleep and infant sleep have also been noted.
It is possible to deprive adult sleepers of a
single sleep state, such as REM sleep, for a
period of time and demonstrate a selective
“rebound” of that state during subsequent
uninterrupted recovery 2#{176}Neither
deprivation nor recovery of sleep states are
as clear cut in the newborn period. Rather,
the infant demonstrates a “tenacity” for his
ongoing sleep state, returning to it
immedi-ately following disturbance.15 Finally,
hon-mones such as human growth hormone and
cortisol have been associated with particulan
sleep stages in adults.Sl,22 These
relation-ships do not seem to exist during the first 3
months of life for the human infant.23’24
The assessment of sleep state
onganiza-tion, proportions and nhythmicity by the
polygraph has resulted in a new tool-the
sleep polygram-useful in the diagnosis of a
wide variety of developmental
abnormali-ties. The areas of clinical applicability can
Dreyfus-Brisac and Monod25 have
ne-ported a complete lack of cycling in the
sleep of severely brain damaged newborn
infants and unusually frequent and
irregu-Ian sleep state shifts in infants with lesser
degrees of neurological impairment. Infants
with mild degrees of birth trauma,2#{176} infants
born to diabetic mothers2 and to toxemic
mothers,25 and infants born to
heroin-ad-dicted mothers have all demonstrated
ab-normalities in their quiet sleep state
organi-zation and/or in the maturation of various
EEC wave forms. Abnormalities of
active-REM sleep have been reported in a variety
of pathological conditions including
chro-mosomal abnormalities,30 infantile autism,31
and nonspecific mental retardation.32 The
reversal of sleep EEC abnormalities
associ-ated with thyroid deficiency closely
paral-lels clinical improvement.33
More experience with the sleep polygram
during early development will provide the
basis for a much needed sensitive early
in-dicator of neurological integrity, especially
in the early detection and prognostic
deter-mination of children with minimal brain
damage. The efficacy of various therapeutic
regimens may prove to be another area in
which sleep studies will provide clinically
useful information.
DISORDERS OF SLEEP AND AROUSAL IN CHILDREN
In children older than 2 years, although
sleep stage proportions have not achieved
adult ratios, the characteristics of the
physi-ologic measures recorded during sleep have
by and large assumed adult forms.
There-fore, as in the adult, it is possible to define a
state of REM sleep alternating with a state
of NREM sleep which can be subdivided
further into Stages 1 to 4 according to
pre-viously described EEC criteria.2
Nocturnal enuresis, somnambulism,
somniloquy, pavor nocturnus
(
nightten-rors
)
and narcolepsy are generallyconsid-cred to be the most common physiologic
childhood disorders of sleep. In the past
they have been classified in a variety of
ways depending on their motor,
auto-nomic, or psychophysiologic components.34
Through the use of the sleep polygraph, the
widely held belief that these disorders wene
associated with seizure activity has not
been confirmed.3#{176} Rarely, teniporal lobe
seizures may mimic these disorders, but
ad-equate study in the sleep laboratory readily
differentiates epileptic disorders from sleep
disorders. Currently a helpful classification
has been with respect to their relationship
to the REM/NREM sleep cycle. After a
prolonged initial period of Stage 3/4
NREM sleep, the ascending or “emergent”
shifts to Stages 2, 1, and REM sleep
nepre-sent the “lightening” of sleep in the
dinec-lion of arousal. Accordingly bed wetting,
sleep walking, sleep talking, and night
ten-nors are all associated with emergence from
Stage 3/4 NREM sleep and consequently
are defined as disorders of arousal.
Nanco-lepsy, on the other hand, is associated with
the abnormal occurrence of REM sleep and
is thus regarded as a disorder of sleep.413
It is becoming increasingly evident that the
disorders of arousal are most often
associ-ated with signs of neurological immaturity
especially upon their initial occurrence in
younger children.
The various disorders of arousal often
ap-pear in the same penson at different times
and often with a family history of the
disor-ders.4446 They are further linked by
com-mon aspects of their symptomatology: They
are paroxysmal in nature and are
character-ized by nonresponsiveness to the
environ-ment, automatic appearance to actions, and
retrograde amnesia for the episode. Prior to
their study by sleep polygraphy, these
dis-orders were commonly regarded as dream
equivalents or “acting out” of dreams.7’8
Dissociating these disorders from REM or
“dreaming” sleep, however, are:
(
1)
epi-sodes occur during REM periods in less
than 10% of polygraphic recordings; (2)
REM sleep is most abundant during the
last third of the night, whereas these
disor-dens occur mainly during the first 3 hours of
sleep;
(
3)
dream recall is present afterawakening from REM sleep while there is
episodes, and (4) children suffering from
these disorders have normal REM sleep
patterns and proportions.36’4#{176}
Still poorly understood is the reason that
specific disorders occur in particular
mdi-viduals and in those individuals only at
cer-tam times. There is evidence that the
sus-ceptibility to particular sleep disorders is
related to individual physiologic differences
and possible genetic factors.40’49
Psycholog-ical anxiety and environmental stress are
also frequently recognized, particularly
where symptoms persist into late childhood
and early adulthood, suggesting multiple
interacting etiologies.
Nocturnal Enuresis
Bed wetting past the age of 3 is the most
prevalent childhood sleep disorder. Rarely
an organic etiology such as genitouninany
pathology, epilepsy, or diabetes may be
as-sociated with enuresis but more often it is
considered to be functional or idiopathic.
In the pediatric literature childhood
enune-sis has been classified in various ways :
Pni-mary enunesis refers to the enunesis of
chil-dren who have never developed bladder
control, whereas secondary enunesis refers
to children who have developed bladder
control and then lost it. This secondary loss
of control is often attributed to
psychologi-cal stresses on intervening organic
pathol-ogv. Nighttime enunesis has also been
differentiated from daytime enuresis. In
studies relating enunesis to sleep stage
pat-terns, these distinctions have not been
main-tamed and the results suggest that all
categories of enuresis share varying
propon-lions of a common physiological imbalance,
at least when the symptoms first occur.
Ritvo, et al.#{176}have suggested that the initial
psychophysiologic substrate for enuresis
may provide a basis for perpetuation of the
condition through later neurotic conflicts
especially where enunesis occurs during
Stages 1 and 2 NREM sleep in olden
chil-dren and adolescents.
Depending on the definition of enuresis
and the methods of sampling, 5 to 17% of
children between 3 and 15 years of age
cx-hibit the disorder. The condition, more
common in males, usually diminishes with
maturation, rarely persisting into adult-hood.445152
Bnoughton and Castaut,53 by polygraphic
monitoring, have defined an “enunetic
epi-sode” which generally occurs 1 to 3 hours
after falling asleep, as the child is arousing
from NREM Stage 3 or 4 sleep prior to
en-tening his first REM period. The sleep stage
change is often associated with body
move-ments and increased muscle tone followed
by tachycardia, tachypnea, erection in
males, and decreased skin resistance.
Mic-turition occurs ii to 4 minutes after the start
of the episode in a moment of relative
quiet. Immediately following micturition,
children are difficult to awaken and when
aroused indicate that they have not
dreamed. There is total amnesia for the
event. Adolescents and young adults ane
more likely to be enuretic when arousing
from NREM Stages 1 or
Bnoughton#{176} has suggested that the
arousal from slow wave sleep provides the
appropriate dissociative state in which
enu-resis may occur. Evidence has been
ob-tained that enureics have higher
intra-vesi-cal pressure, especially in Stage 4 NREM
sleep than controls, have more frequent and
intense spontaneous bladder contractions,
and have more secondary contractions in
response to naturally and artificially
occur-ring increases in pressure.55’56
Treatment has taken many forms
includ-ing drugs, conditioning techniques, and
psychotherapy. Presently the drug of choice
for severe enunesis is imipnamine which
ne-portedly increases Stage 2 NREM sleep and
decreases Stage 4 NREM sleep and REM
sleep. It is unclean whether the effects of
imipramine are due primarily to its
anticho-linengic properties effecting bladder control
on to its stimulant effect. A flexible dosage
and slow withdrawal schedule are
recom-mended.57’58 Ritvo, et al.#{176}noted that
imi-pramine was most effective for enuretic
epi-sodes that occurred during Stages 3 and 4
NREM sleep transitions.
con-ditioning techniques or psychotherapy have
met with mixed results.52,5963 Bakwin63
noted the lack of evidence for clear cut
be-havioral differences between enuretic and
normal subjects, but stressed the
psycholog-ical value of the physician’s supportive role.
When viewed as disorders of
developmen-tal immaturity, most cases
(
Stage 3/4en-uresis
)
subside spontaneously; intractablecases
(
Stage 1/2 enuresis)
require morevigorous intervention.
Somnambulism and Somniloquy
Perhaps 15% of all children between the
ages of 5 and 12 have walked in their sleep
at least once. Occurring in 1 to 6% of the
population, somnambulism or persistent
walking is a fairly common disorder
afflicting more males than females, more
children than adults, and often associated
with nocturnal enuresis.36’46’4#{176} Of enunetic
naval recruits, 34% reported a positive past
history, and 25% a family history of
sleep-walking.45 Monozygotic twins are
concon-dant for the disorder six limes as often as
dizygotic twins.’9 A typical somnambulistic
episode consists of the following behavioral
sequence: A body movement is followed by
the subject abruptly sitting upright in bed.
The eyes are open, glassy, and appear
“un-seeing.” The subject may or may not
actu-ally get up and leave the bed. Doors and
drawers may be opened, furniture skirted.
The movements are clumsy but collisions
and actual physical injury are generally
avoided. Efforts to communicate with the
sleepwalker may elicit mumbled and
slurred speech with monosyllabic answers
that are poorly related to the question.
Occa-sionally spontaneous somniloquy is
ob-served. The total duration of the episode
may range from 15 to 30 seconds when
sit-ting in bed, to 5 to 30 minutes, or more,
when actual walking occurs. Walking
gen-erally ends with the child returning to his
bed to sleep. There is amnesia for the event
upon awakening. Severe sleepwalkens may
have episodes 1 to 4 times weekly.
The majority of the somnambulistic
epi-sodes occur in the 1 to 3 hours immediately
317
following sleep onset. They appear, as do
enuretic episodes, to be associated with
transitions from Stages 3/4 NREM sleep
to lighter stages, prior to the first REM
pe-nod. Kales, et al.,64 recording
polygraphi-cally during somnambulistic episodes,
never found sleepwalking to arise during
REM sleep. In this same report,
sleepwalk-ing could be induced in 7 of 38
sleepwalk-ens by standing them up during Stage 3 or
4 NREM sleep but not in REM sleep.
Nor-mal controls could not be induced to walk
during any stage of sleep. When restricted
from walking, somnambulists, compared to
controls, tend to make many niovements of
a complex nature during slow wave sleep.34
They also exhibit longer than normal
confu-sional episodes following forced
awaken-ings from these stages.4#{176}
The sleep EEC of somnambulists reveal
the presence of rhythmic, paroxysmal, high
voltage, slow frequency delta bursts
(
1-3Hz) preceding each event.65 These
paroxys-mal bursts also occur in somnambulists at
times unassociated with the event. Gibbs
and Gibbs66 have described these bursts as
present in 85% of normal 6- to 11-month-old
infants, decreasing to 3% in 7- to
9-year-olds. Their continued presence in
somnam-bulists has suggested to Kales, et al.65 an
organic index of CNS immaturity in such
patients.
Administration of a wide variety of
psy-chological and personality tests has shown
no single constellation of traits
chanacteris-tic of somnambulists. A wide range of
per-sonality traits, emotional responsiveness
and heterogeneous psychopathology marks
these patients.#{176}7 Somnambulists in the
mili-tary, on the other hand, exhibit greater
psy-chopathology than controls.46 Sleep-walking
incidents, despite their distinctive
physio-logical signs and lack of specific
psycho-logical symptoms, are not divorced from
psychological and environmental factors.
In-vestigators report less sleep-walking in the
laboratory than in the home.40’65
Individu-als who have had long periods without
sleer-walking may revert under stress.#{176}7
somnambulistic episodes. When it occurs
alone it is most often associated with
emen-gent stage transitions during NREM sleep.
In these instances, speech content is related
to immediately preceding experience.68
As with enunesis, the therapy of
somnam-bulism has included drugs, situational
ma-nipulalion, and psychotherapy. The drug of
choice for intractable, frequent occurrences
is diazepam (Valium) which significantly
reduces Stage 4 NREM sleep and also may
reduce the number and intensity of
emer-gent sleep stage shifts.69 As CNS maturation
progresses, somnambulistic episodes usually
diminish and disappear spontaneously.
Pavor Nocturnus
Attacks of childhood night terror must be
differentiated from the more common
nightmare on anxiety dream. In pavor
noc-turnus, the child suddenly sits upright in
bed and screams. He appears to be staring
at an imaginary object, breathes heavily,
of-ten perspires, and is in obvious distress. He
is usually inconsolable for 10 minutes or
more, then finally relaxes and returns to
sleep. Immediate dream recall is
fragmen-tary,
if
present at all, and in the morningthere is amnesia for the attack. Though seen
in older children and adults, night terrors are
most common in the preschool age group.
Gastaut and Broughton34 polygraphically
recorded seven episodes of night terror in
seven children. In all cases, the attack
oc-curned during intense and sudden arousal
from slow wave sleep. It was further noted
that these children had relative tachycardia
during slow wave sleep and hyperactive
heart rates during arousal episodes. Fisher
et al.69 have confirmed these
electnophysio-logic findings in young adults.
For severe cases, the drug of choice, as in
somnambulism, is diazepam. Most episodes
in children occur so infrequently, however,
that no medication is indicated.
Nightmares and anxiety dreams, which
will be discussed more fully in the next
see-tion, are not considered disorders of
arousal. Rather, they occur during REM
sleep, are associated with vivid
recollec-lions, and often make the child fearful of
going to bed.
Narcolepsy
Narcolepsy, in contrast to disorders of
arousal, has been defined as a disorder of
sleep. The characteristic symptom is
recur-rent daytime episodes of irresistable
drow-siness and sleep. These sleep attacks may or
may not be associated with the three
auxillary symptoms of cataplexy, sleep
paralysis, and hypnagogic hallucinations to
form the “narcoleptic tetrad.”39’7#{176} Cataplexy
is the sudden loss of muscle tone resulting in
falling to the ground while consciousness is
maintained. Sleep paralysis is the sudden
awareness, while falling asleep or during
sleep, that one can not move or cry out.
Hypnagogic hallucinations consist of vivid
visual or auditory imagery occurring at
sleep onset. Sleep attacks are associated
with cataplexy about 75% of the time and
with sleep paralysis and hypnagogic
hallu-cinations 20 to 30% of the time. The full
blown narcoleptic tetrad occurs about 10%
of the time.7#{176}A genetic factor is suggested
by the higher familial incidence of the
dis-order.70’”
While most sufferers are brought to a
physician in their teens on early adult years,
it is probable that childhood symptoms of
recurrent drowsiness are present but not
considered remarkable. The interval
be-tween the first sleep attack and the
occur-rence of the other symptoms may vary
from hours to years.39 The symptoms,
them-selves, also may vary between attacks and
do not always occur together. Partial
nemis-sions have been reported, but complete
remission is doubtful.
Electrophysiologic studies of the
narco-leptic tetrad confirm its relationship to
REM sleep.4143’72 In patients with a history
of cataplexy on other auxillany narcoleptic
symptoms, sleep attacks during the daytime
are episodes of REM sleep intruding upon
wakefulness. Cataplectic attacks during the
day and sleep paralysis at sleep onset
repre-sent the loss of peripheral muscle tone, a
refers to extreme confusion and drowsiness,
lasting for 1 to 2 hours, upon awakening.76
The nocturnal sleep of hypersomniacs
cx-hibits normal REM/NREM sleep cycles
and patterns. The hypersomniac episodes
generally represent periods of Stages 1 and
2 NREM sleep. The incidence, etiology,
and management of this disturbance
ne-mains unclear, but it is generally felt to be
largely associated with psychological
con-flicts.
PSYCHOLOGICAL DISTURBANCES OF SLEEP
“A sleepless baby is a reproach to his
guardians” wrote Sundell in 1922
suggest-ing that the full responsibility for sleep
dis-turhance belonged to parents. Anna Freud,3
on the other hand, suggesting cultural
sources of sleep disturbances, has pointed
otit that the human infant is perhaps the
only creature among mammals who sleeps
without the direct contact and warmth of
another’s skin. Regardless of their source,
virtually all parents anticipate some sleep
disturbances in their children.
Prior to sleep polygnaphy, many of the
previously described disorders were
con-sidered psychological in etiology. Indeed,
many of them are associated with or
in-duced by psychological conflicts or
situa-tions of heightened anxiety. All are a source
of psychological suffering. The disorders to
be described in this section, however, are
those characterized by normal sleep
poly-grams. They are more common, often are
reflections of normal phases of development,
and have been loosely labeled by parents
and pediatricians as “insomnia” and
“night-manes.” By far the majority are transient
and, though a source of irritation, are
in-consequential. Sometimes when bizarre or
fixed, however, they may be indicators of
more serious psychopathology. Medication,
by and large, is not indicated though the
short-term use of chloral hydrate has been
advocated to promote peace and quiet in
the family and prevent the sleep
distur-bance from becoming ingrained by
“posi-live” reinforcement. Understanding the
REVIEW ARTICLE
The vivid imagery of the hypnagogic
hallu-cinations resembles dreams recounted after
REM sleep awakenings. In contrast to
nor-mat adults who enter sleep through a
prolonged NREM period, sufferers of
cata-plexy, sleep paralysis and hypnagogic
hal-lucinations exhibit a prolonged initial REM
period, both in daytime attacks and in
noc-turnal sleep, reminiscent of newborn sleep.
Individuals who have only sleep attacks
without a history of any auxillary symptoms
may not demonstrate this unusual transition
to REM sleep, but rather the normal
de-scending pattern from wakefulness to
NREM sleep in both daytime attacks and,
nocturnal 47 That is, all daytime
sleep attacks are not episodes of REM
sleep. This has led Dement, et to
pro-ROSe a compelling argument to limit the
definition of narcolepsy to those disorders
characterized by attacks of REM sleep and
relegate other episodes of involuntary sleep
to another diagnostic category.
The etiology of the disorder remains
oh-scure but emotional experience and
in-creases in tension and anxiety are known to
precipitate attacks. Treatment with
analep-tic drugs has proved effective. The
amphet-amines, which reduce REM sleep while
minimally interfering with other sleep
stages are most commonly used.39’2
Me-thylphenidate hydrochloride
(
Ritalin)
hasalso been tried.” Although numerous
inves-tigators have confirmed the nonepileptic
form of narcolepsy, the anticonvulsant
phe-nacemide
(
Phenurone)
has achieved somesuccess.74 Most recently the use of the REM
suppressing MAO inhibitors have had
marked
Hypersomnia refers to an excessive
amount of sleep. It generally starts during
adolescence. Though often confused with
narcolepsy, it is not a disorder of REM
sleep. Hypersomniacs fall into three
catego-lies : Daytime hypersomnia refers to
exces-sive sleepiness during daylight hours when
wakefulness is desired; nocturnal
hypen-somnia is characterized by excessively long
nocturnal sleep periods with difficulty in
source of the child’s anxiety, the parental
concerns, and the current family situation
are most often sufficient to enable the
pedi-atnician to provide supportive guidance
un-til the disturbance subsides.
Sleep disturbances may occur from the
imminent approach of bedtime to the time
of awakening. Nagera79 has extensively
re-viewed these disturbances and classified
them according to the most common age of
appearance. This system of classification
af-fords optimal understanding of the
distur-bance within the context of the child’s
de-velopmental stage.
The First Year of Life
Two major concerns of the infant’s family
during the first year of life are sleeping
through the night (“settling”) and night
awakenings. Settling, most comprehensively
studied by Moore and Ucko,8#{176} refers to
sleeping from around midnight to early
morning. These authors report that 70% of
babies settle by 3 months, and another 13%
have settled by 6 months. Ten percent
never sleep uninterruptedly during the first
year. The factors which promote settling
are unknown though it is generally felt that
it is related to the process of CNS
matura-tion. Infants who have suffered some
peri-natal insult, such as anoxia, settle later.81
Sex, birth weight, and weight at 6 months
do not seem related. Environmental
condi-lions such as feeding schedule, sleeping
ar-rangement, minor illness, and so forth, also
do not seem related though high levels of
maternal anxiety, reflected by inconsistent
handling or insufficient nonfeeding play
does seem to delay settling. Interestingly, 3
months of age
(
the age at which mostin-fants are settling) is the time when infants’
sleep polygrams assume more adult
charac-tenistics. At that time infants enter sleep via
a sustained NREM period and the NREM
EEC begins to be differentiated into
NREM sleep stages.’3 A study of the
nela-tionship between the age of settling and the
maturity of the sleep polygram would be of
interest.
Once the process of settling has occurred,
waking normally recurs in 50% of infants
between 5 and 9 months. During the
see-ond half of the first year environmental
fac-tons such as changed sleeping
arrange-ments, separations, minor trauma, and new
family members have been reported to be
associated with wakenings. These
disrup-lions are usually transient, though severe
trauma may result in more prolonged
dis-turbances. After 6 months of age parental
concern and anger over poor sleeping
hab-its may frequently compound the existing
difficulty.82 Thus during the first year, if the
babies’ physiological needs are met
ade-quately, empathetic understanding and
guidance from the pediatrician to allay
cx-cessive parental anxiety should lead to a
rapid resolution of the sleep disturbance.
The
Second Year of LifeDuring the second year of life, sleep
dis-turbances often reflect infantile anxiety
stemming from either developmental
im-maturity or neurotic conflict. At this age,
psychological and cognitive components are
added to the physiological requirements of
sleep. With the strengthening of the child’s
ties to significant people and to the
happen-ings of the external world, he clings all the
more tenaciously to 78 A
preva-lent disturbance of this age, therefore, is
re-luctance to go to sleep.83 During the first
half of the second year, the child’s ego is
still immature and can offer little comfort
during times of separation. Since the child
lacks the capacity to differentiate between
absence and total disappearance of an
ob-ject, he attempts to hold onto his important
ties to avoid the fear of loss. Substitute
ob-jects, such as teddy bear or blankets, often
tide him oven these difficult times. By the
end of the second year, with the acquisition
of language and the development of a sense
of object permanence, these difficulties
of-ten disappear.
Children in this age group are also easily
overexcited by parents or upset by
frighten-ing daytime experiences. The resulting
in-creased tension may lead to a second
night-REVIEW ARTICLE
mares. Polygraphic studies have confirmed
the presence of dream reports following
REM sleep awakenings in 2-yean-olds.84
. . Latency
Most often these elicited dream reports are
re-enactments of daytime experiences,
though the characters are frequently
ani-mals or monsters. Since the child, at this
age, cannot distinguish between dreams
and reality, fear of going to sleep because
of bad dreams may develop. With an
in-crease in ego development and the
estab-lishment of a clear-cut distinction between
dreams and reality, this type of disturbance disappears.
To allay the anxiety associated with
go-ing to sleep, presleep habits or rituals
de-velop during the second year. These
in-elude repetitive bedtime stories, last
good-nights, and so forth. In a minority of cases,
the rituals seem to stem from additional
conflicts and become excessive,
represent-ing early precursors of more serious
psycho-pathology. These instances are most often
associated with overzealous attempts at
early discipline (e.g. toilet training, limit
setting, and so forth) . It has been
hypothe-sized that the anger generated by these
par-ent-child power struggles is reduced by the
child’s presleep rituals. The youngster who
repeatedly needs to kiss his parents
good-night, and so forth, indicates his love for
them and in turn verifies their love for him.
The Third to Fifth Year of Life
It is rare to find a child in the 3- to 5-year
age group who is not experiencing some
difficulty over sleep, whether it be tardiness
in falling asleep, night wakening,
night-mares, projective fears of ghosts and wild
animals, inability to sleep alone or in the
dark, or ritualistic presleep behavior. Most
of these disturbances are transient and
re-sponsive to minimal environmental
manip-ulation. If refractive, the sleep disturbance
most often represents only one symptom of
a more profound conflict. Such conflicts in
this age group most commonly are
attnibut-able to parental disturbances or reflect the
child’s inability to enter into the wider
world of social relationships. Enlightened
family counselling or psychotherapy for the
child and family may be indicated.
During latency there usually is
ameliona-lion of most sleep disturbances. Reading
before going to sleep often replaces other
presleep rituals. This avoids engaging in
fantasies, mostly erotic, and the resulting
secondary conflicts over masturbation. On
occasion, however, the previous sleep
dis-turbance may carry oven, on even arise de
novo. It may then persist through
adoles-cence into adulthood.
SUMMARY
Recent electrophysiologic techniques
have added considerably to the
understand-ing of sleep and its disorders. Persistent
nocturnal enuresis, somnambulism,
somni-loquy, and night terrors have been
associ-ated with emergent sleep stage transitions
from Stage 4 to Stage 1 NREM sleep and
have thus been classified as disorders of
arousal. Narcolepsy, on the other hand, has
been associated with the abnormal
transi-tion from wakefulness directly into REM
sleep and has been termed a disorder of
sleep. Though these disorders may be
asso-ciated with psychological factors,
psycho-physiological factors have been
demon-strated and specific pharmacologic agents
have proven most effective in treatment.
The stresses and conflicts of growth and
normal development may be expressed,
from time to time, in various manifestations
of disturbed sleep. Many complaints of
“in-somnia” and nightmares fall into this
cate-gory and are misunderstood in terms of the
developmental problem that the child and
family face. Most often patience, support,
and guidance are sufficient to alleviate the
symptoms. Rarer, pathological disturbances
must be differentiated from the more
com-mon developmental manifestations.
REFERENCES
1. Aserinsky, E., and Kleitman, N. : A motility
cy-cle in sleeping infants as manifested by
2. Dement, W., and Kleitman, N. : Cyclic
varia-tion in EEG during sleep and their relation-ship to eye movements, body motility and
dreaming. Electroenceph. Clin.
Neurophy-siol., 9:673, 1957.
3. Luce, C., and Segal, J.: Sleep. New York:
Coward McCann, 1966.
4. Kales, A. ed.: Sleep-Physiology and Pathol-ogy, A Symposium. Philadelphia: J. B.
Lip-pincott, 1969.
5. Hartmann, E. ed. : Sleep and Dreaming.
Bos-ton: Little, Brown, Intl. Psychiat. din., 7:
1970.
6. Lenard, H. : Sleep studies in infancy-facts,
concepts and significance. Acta Paediat.
Scand., 59:572, 1970.
7. Dement, W. : An essay on dreams. The role of
physiology in understanding their nature. In
Barron, F., ed : New Directions in
Psychol-ogy, vol. 2. F. Barron, New York: Holt,
Rinehart and Winston, p. 135, 1965.
8. Foulkes, D. : Nonrapid eye movement
menta-lion. Exp. Neurol. ( Suppl. ), 4:28, 1967.
9. Anders, T., Emde, R., and Parmelee, Jr., A.
ed. : A manual of standardized terminology,
techniques and criteria for scoring states of
sleep and wakefulness in newborn infants.
Los Angeles, UCLA Brain Information
Ser-vice, NINDS, Neurological Information
Net-work, 1971.
10. Dreyfus-Brisac, C., and Monod, N.: Sleep of
premature and fuilterm neonates-a
poiy-graphic study. Proc. Roy. Soc. Med., 58:6,
1965.
11. Petre-Quadens, 0. : Ontogenesis of paradoxical
sleep in the human newborn. J. Neurol. Sci.,
4:153, 1967.
12. Feinberg, I., and Carlson, V.: Sleep variables
as a function of age in man. Arch. Gen.
Psy-chiat., 18:239, 1968.
13. Metcalf, D.: EEC sleep spindle ontogenesis.
Neuropaediatrie, 1:428, 1970.
14. Roffwarg, H., Muzio, J., and Dement, W.:
On-togenetic development of the human
sleep-dream cycle. Science, 152:604, 1966.
15. Anders, T., and Roffwarg, H.: The effects of
selective interruption and total sleep
depri-vation in the human newborn. Develop.
Psy-chobiol., in press, 1972.
16. Dreyfus-Brisac, C. : Ontogenesis of sleep in
human prematures after 32 weeks of
con-ceptional age. Develop. Psychobiol., 3:91, 1970.
17. Parmelee, Jr., A., Schultz, M., and Disbrow,
M. : Sleep patterns of the newborn. J. Pediat., 58:241, 1961.
18. Sander, L., Julia, H., Stechier, C., and Burns,
P.: Continuous 24-hour interactional
moni-toting in infants reared in two different
care-taking environments. Psychosom. Med., in
press.
19. Parmelee, Jr., A.: Sleep patterns in infancy: A
study of one infant from birth to eight
months of age. Acta Paediat. Scand., 50:160, 1961.
20. Dement, W. : The effect of dream deprivation.
Science, 131:1705, 1960.
21. Sassin, J., Parker, D., Mace, J., Gotlin, R.,
J ohnson, L., and Rossman, L.: Human
growth hormone release-relation to slow
wave sleep and sleep-waking cycles.
Sci-ence, 165:513, 1969.
22. Weitzman, E., Schaumburg, H., and Fishbein,
W.: Plasma 17-hydroxy-corticosteroid levels
during sleep in man. J. Clin. Endocr., 26:
121, 1966.
23. Anders, T., Sachar, E., Kream, J., Roffwarg,
H., and Heilman, L. : Behavioral state and
plasma cortisol response in the human
new-born. PEnwniucs, 46:532, 1970.
24. Finkelstein, J., Anders, T., Sachar, E.,
Roff-warg, H., and Heilman, L. : Secretion of
growth hormone and behavioral state in the
human infant. J. Clin. Endocr., 32:368,
1971.
25. Dreyfus-Brisac, C., and Monod, N. : Sleeping
behavior in abnormal newborn infants.
Neii-ropaediatnie, 3:354, 1970.
26. Prechtl, H., Weinmann, H., and Akiyama, Y.:
Organization of physiological parameters in
normal and abnormal infants. Neuropaedia-tnie, 1:101, 1969.
27. Schulte, F., Lasson, U., Par1, U., Nolte, R., and Jurgens, U. : Brain and behavioral
matura-tion in newborn infants of diabetic mothers,
II. Sleep cycles. Neuropaediatrie, 1:36,
1969.
28. Schulte, F., Hinze, C., and Schrempf, G. :
Ma-ternal toxemia, fetal malnutrition and
bioe-lectnic brain activity of the newborn.
Neuro-paediatrie, 2:439, 1971.
29. Schulman, C. : Alterations of the sleep cycle in
heroin addicted and “suspect” newborns.
Neuropaediatrie, 1:89, 1969.
30. Petre-Quadens, 0., and Jouvet, M. : Sleep in
the mentally retarded. J. Neurol. Sci., 4:354,
1967.
31. Ornitz, E., Ritvo, E., Brown, M., LaFranchi, S., Parmelee, Jr., A., and Walter, R. : The
EEC and rapid eye movements during REM
sleep in normal and autistic children.
Elec-troenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 26:167,
1969.
32. Feinberg, I.: Eye movement activity during Sleep and intellectual function in mental tardation. Science, 159: 1256, 1968.
33. Schultz, M., Schulte, F., Akiyama, Y., and
Par-melee, Jr., A. : Development of
electroen-cephalographic sleep phenomena in
hypo-thyroid infants. Electroenceph. Clin. Neuro-physiol., 25:351, 1968.
REVIEW ARTICLE
polygraphic study of episodic phenomena during sleep. In Wortis, J., ed.: Recent Ad-vances in Biological Psychiatry. New York: Plenum, 7: 197, 1965.
35. Gastaut, H., Broughton, R., Tassinari, C., and
Rudkowska, A. : Polygraphic tests of parox-vsmal phenomena occurring in night sieep. Electroenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 18:713,
1965.
36. Kales, J., Jacobson, A., and Kales, A. : Sleep disorders in children. Prog. Clin. Pathol., 8: 63, 1968.
37. Poussaint, A., Koegler, R., and Riehl, J.: Enu-resis, epilepsy and the EEC. Amer. J. Psy-chiat., 123:1294, 1967.
38. St. Laurent, J., Batini, C., Broughton, R., and Gastaut, H. : A polygraphic study of
noctur-nal enuresis in the epileptic child. Electroen-ceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 15:904, 1963.
39. You, R., and Daly, D. : Narcolepsy in children. PEDIATRICS, 25: 1025, 1960.
40. Broughton, R. : Sleep disorders: Disorders of arousal? Science, 159: 1070, 1968.
41. Hishikawa, Y., and Kaneko, Z. :
Electroenceph-alographic study on narcolepsy. Electroen-ceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 18:249, 1965. 42. Dement, W., Rechtschaffen, A., and Culevitch,
C.: A polygraphic study of the narcoleptic sleep attack. Neurology, 16: 18, 1966.
43. Roth, B., Bruchova, S., and Lehovsky, M.:
REM sleep and NREM sleep in narcolepsy
and hypersomnia. Electroenceph. Clin.
Neu-rophysiol., 26: 176, 1969.
44. Martin, C. : A New Approach to Nocturnal En-uresis. London: H. K. Lewis & Co. Ltd., 1966.
45. Pierce, C., Lipcon, H., McClary, J., and Noble, H. : Enuresis: Clinical, laboratory and
elec-troencephalographic studies. U.S. Armed
Forces Med. J., 7:208, 1956
46. Pierce, C., and Lipcon, H. : Somnambulism: Electroencephalographic studies and related
findings. U.S. Armed Forces Med. J., 7:
1419, 1956.
47. Pierce, C., Whitman, R., Maas, J., and Gay,
M. : Enuresis and dreaming. Arch. Gen. Psy-chiat., 4:166, 1961.
48. Sours, J., Fmumkin, P., and Indermill, R. : Som-nambulism. Arch. Cen. Psychiat., 9:400, 196:3.
49. Bakwin, H. : Sleep walking in hvins. Lancet, 2: 446, 1970.
50. Ritvo, E., Ornitz, E., Gottlieb, F., Poussaint, A., Maron, B., Dithian, K., and Blinn, K.:
Arousal and nonarousal enuretic events.
Amer. J. Psychiat., 126:77, 1969.
51. Tapia, F., Jekel, J., and Domke, H. : Enuresis: An emotional symptom? J. Nerv. Ment. Dis.,
130:61, 1960.
52. Lovibond, S. : Conditioning and Enuresis. New York: Macmillan Co., 1964.
53. Broughton, R., and Gastaut, H. : Polygraphic
sleep studies of enuresis nocturna.
Elec-troenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 16:625,
1964.
54. Ditman, K., and Blinn, K. : Sleep levels in
enu-resis. Amer. J. Psychiat., 111 :913, 1955.
55. Broughton, R., and Gastaut, H. : Further
poly-graphic sleep studies of enuresis noctumna
(
Intravesicular pressures. ) Electroenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol., 16:626, 1964. 56. Gastaut, H., and Broughton, R. : Conclusionsconcerning the mechanisms of enuresis
noc-tuma. Electroenceph. Clin. Neurophysiol.,
16:625, 1964.
57. Poussaint, A., and Ditman, K. : A controlled
study of Imipramine (Tofranil) in the
treat-ment of childhood enuresis. J. Pediat., 67: 283, 1965.
58. Miller, P., Champelli, J., and Dinello, F. : Imi-pramine in the treatment of enuretic school
children. Amer. J. Dis. Child., 115: 17, 1968.
59. De Ataide, S.: Contributions to the study of
enuresis in children. Psychol. Abstr. 23:
#4499, 1949.
60. Hamill, R.: Enuresis. J.A.M.A., 93:254, 1929.
61. Kriegman, E., and Wright, H. : Brief psycho-therapy with enuretics in the army. Amer. J. Psychiat., 104:254, 1947.
62. Zufall, R. : Adult male enuresis: A study of 200 cases. J. Urol., 70:894, 1953.
63. Bakwin, H. : Enuresis in childhood. J. Pediat.,
58:806, 1961.
64. Kales, A., Jacobson, A., Kun, T., Klein, J.,
Heuser, C., and Paulson, M. : Somnambu-lism: Further all-night EEC studies.
Elec-troenceph. Clin. Neurophsiol., 21:410,
1966.
65. Kales, A., Jacobson, A., Paulson, M., Kales, J.,
and Walter, R. : Somnambulism:
Psychophy-siological correlates, I. Arch. Gen. Psychiat.,
14:586, 1966.
66. Gibbs, F., and Gibbs, E. : Atlas of
Electroen-cephalography, Vol. 1. Cambridge,
Massa-chusetts: Addison Wesley Press Inc., 1950. 67. Kales, A., Paulson, M., Jacobson, A., and
Ka-les, J.: Somnambulism: Psychophysiological correlates, II. Arch. Gen. Psychiat., 14:595,
1966.
68. Rechtschaffen, A., Goodenough, D., and
Sha-piro, A. : Patterns of sleep talking. Arch.
Gen. Psychiat., 7:418, 1962.
69. Fisher, C., Kahn, E., Edwards, A., and Davis,
D.: Effects of Valium on NREM night
ter-ross. Psychophysiology, Abstr. Assoc.
Psy-chophysiol. Study of Sleep. In Press. 70. Yoss, R., and Daly, D. : Criteria for the
diag-nosis of the narcoleptic syndrome. Proc.
Staff Mtgs. of the Mayo Clinic, 32:320, 1957.
71. Daly, D., and Yoss, R. : A family with
narco-lepsy. Proc. Staff Mtgs. of the Mayo Clinic,
324
72. Hishikawa, Y., Nan’no, H., Tachibana, M., Fu-ruya, E., Koida, H., and Kaneko, Z. : The
na-tare of sieep attack and other symptoms of
narcolepsy. Electroenceph. Clin.
Neurophy-siol., 24:1, 1968.
73. Yoss, R., and Daly, D. : Treatment of
narco-lepsy with Ritalin. Neurology, 9: 17, 1957.
74. Aird, R., Gordon, N., and Gregg, H. : Use of
Phenacemide ( Phenurone ) in treatment of
narcolepsy and cataplexy. Arch. Neurol.
Psy-chiat., 70:510, 1953.
75. Wyatt, R., Fram, D., Buchbinder, R., and
Sny-der, F.: Treatment of intractable narcolepsy
with a monoamine oxidase inhibitor. New Eng. J. Med., 285:987, 1971.
76. Rechtschaffen, A., and Roth, B.: Nocturnal
sleep of hypersomniacs. Activitas nervosa
Superior, 1 1 :229, 1969.
77. Sundell, C.: Sleeplessness in infants. Practi-tioner, 109:89, 1922.
78. Freud, A. : Normality and Pathology in
Child-hood. New York : International University
Press, 1965.
79. Nagera, H. : Sleep and its disturbances
ap-proached developmentally. The
Psychoana-lytic Study of the Child. New York:
Interna-tional Universities Press, 21 :393, 1966.
80. Moore, T., and Ucko, L. : Night waking in early infancy: Part I. Arch. Dis. Child., 32:333,
1957.
81. Preston, M. : Late behavioral aspects found in cases of prenatal, natal and post-natal anoxia.
J. Pediat., 26:353, 1945.
82. Hirschberg, J.: Parental anxieties
accompany-ing sleep disturbance in young children. Bull.
Menninger Clinic, 21 :129, 1957.
83. Ragins, N., and Schacter, J.: A study of sleep
behavior in two-year old children. J. Amer.
Acad. Child Psychiat., 10:464, 1971.
84. Kohler, W., Coddington, R., and Agnew, H.:
Sleep patterns in 2-year old children. J.
Pediat., 72:228, 1968.
Acknowledgment
Doctors M. Cohen, L. Finberg, M. Gersch, and
H. Cordon graciously reviewed earlier versions of