INSTRUCTORS
• Name: Samuel N. Y. Simpson (PhD)
William Atuilik (PhD)
• Office Locations: Main Block, G5
• Office Hours: Wednesday, 1:30 pm -3pm
• Friday, 1:30-3pm
• E-mail: [email protected]/[email protected]
Teaching Assistant
• Name: Mohammed AbdulaiCOURSE OVERVIEW & GOAL
• This course exposes students to concepts and principles underlying financial
management in the Public sector-central, local and NGOs:
• Budgeting,
• Accounting and reporting, • Procurement,
• Auditing.
• It focuses on both conventional and contemporary financial management
practices within the public sector environment
• This course seeks to equip both accounting and non-accounting students
Learning Objectives
• Upon successful completion of this course students should be able to:
• Describe the nature of the public sector and public sector accounting
• Describe the legal and regulatory environment of the public sector
• Discuss and evaluate Public sector budgeting and the developments over
the years
• Outline the elements of Public Procurement
• Prepare the financial statements of the central government (Public
Accounts)
Learning Objectives
• Upon successful completion of this course students should be able to: • Outline and discuss the main performance measures and management
tool used in evaluating performance in the public sector.
• Describe the Nature, financing and accountability issues in the local
government administration of Ghana
• Describe the Nature, Types and financial statement of NGOs/NFPOs, etc. • Identify and describe the types of auditing in the public sector
INDICATIVE CONTENT
• Overview and Scope of the Public Sector Environment and Public
Sector Accounting
• Public Sector Budgeting and Case Studies • Introduction to Public Procurement
• Financial Reporting in Public Sector
• Performance Management in the Public Sector • Local Government Finance and Accounting
DELIVERY & GRADING
• The course will be delivered through mainly lectures. • Students will be assessed as follows:
• Individual/group project work and class participation will constitute 15
percent;
• Interim assessment will attract 15 percent; and • Final examination attracts 70 percent.
Reading Resources
• There is no single textbook for this course.
• The course is multi-disciplinary, thus, draws from accounting, public
• Adopted Texts:
• Ives M., Johnson, L., Razek, J.R., & Hosch, G (2009). Introduction to
Governmental and Not-For-Profit Accounting, 6/e. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, a Pearson Education Company
• Freeman, Shoulders, Allison & Smith (2013). Governmental and
• Other Reading Materials • 1992 Constitution of Ghana
• Public Financial Management Act, 2016, Act 921 (Repealed: Financial Administration Act
2003, Act 654
• Financial Administration Regulation 2004, LI 1802 (FAR) • Audit Service Act 2000 Act 584
• Internal Audit Agency Act 2003, Act 658
• Public Procurement Act 2003 Act 663 and Public Procurement (Amendment) Act, 2016 Act,
914
• International Public Sector Accounting Standards
• Local Government Act 2016, Act • National Pension Act 2008, Act 766
• Other fund specific laws such as:
• District Assembly Common Fund Act 1993 (Act 455) • Ghana Education Trust Fund Act 2000 (Act 581)
• Road Fund Act 1997 (Act 536) • Government of Ghana Budgets
• Prescribed journal articles on relevant topics • Relevant journal articles
Other Information
• Class attendance • Plagiarism policy
• Plagiarism in any form is unacceptable and shall be treated as a serious
offence (http://www.ug.edu.gh/aqau/policies-guidelines).
• ALL students are expected to familiarize themselves with the contents of the
Overview and Scope of the
Public Sector Environment and
Public Sector Accounting
Learning objectives
• Upon completion of this session, students should be able to: • Define and describe the public sector environment
• Identify public sector organisations
• Compare and contrast private and public sector organisations • Discuss the changing public sector environment
• Discuss the regulatory environment of the public sector • Discuss the financing arrangements in the public sector
Activity
• Discuss the history of Ghana’s economic system (s) and the
Definitions, Nature and Scope of the Public Sector
•
They encompass both public sector bodies and other
organisations whose primary objective is to provide goods or
services for the general public or social benefit rather than
providing a financial return to equity shareholders.
•
The sector has to do with:
• the whole nation,
• represented by organisations that are established to use the
• The phrase “public sector” is often synonymous with public
administration, public service, and governmental entities.
• Public sector is said to be that part of the economy where funding
comes largely from government
• Public Services are goods or services provided on a not-for profit basis
to the general public or for social benefit.
• Public service organisation is one or more bodies managed as a
coherent entity with the primary objective of providing public services.
•
The sector is said to encompass the following:
• Government activity and its consequences or State general
decision-making and its outcomes (authority interpretation)
• Governmental consumption, investment and transfers (allocation and
distribution interpretation)
• Government production (provision interpretation)
Features of the public sector environment
• The tasks of public institutions are to be decided by politicians but
executed by administrators in order to satisfy the model of rational decision-making.
• Administration is based on written documents and this tends to make
the office (bureau) the heart of modem government.
• Public tasks are organized on a continuous, rule-governed basis. • The rules according to which work is conducted may be either
• The tasks or functions are divided into functionally distinct spheres,
each furnished with the requisite authority and sanctions.
• Officers as well as tasks are arranged hierarchically, the rights of
control and complaint being specified; preference for centralization, all other things being equal.
• The resources of the organization are quite distinct from those of the
members as private individuals.
• Public employees orientate towards the tasks within the public sector
in terms of vocation or a sense of duty to fulfil the obligations of their roles.
• In the public sector there is one dominating interest, the public
interest, which sets limits to the influence of self-interests in politics and administration.
Difficulties with defining the scope of public sector
• Growing involvement of private sector entities
• Growing involvement of civil society organisations
• Outsourcing of government functions to the private sector • Joint ventures, and
Some Recognised Definitions
•
The OECD defines as:
• General government and
• Public corporations including central banks.
• The United Nations provides a similar definition, and includes not-for-profit
•
IFAC defines “public sector” as:
• national governments,
• regional (e.g., state, provincial, territorial) governments, • local (e.g., city, town) governments and
• related governmental entities (e.g., agencies, boards, commissions
and enterprises)
•
General government:
• consists of all governmental units of the executive, judiciary, and
legislature at the central, state/provincial/regional and local levels
•
Public corporations:
• Include the financial and non-financial corporations concerned
with commercial activities
Governmental Business Enterprises
• Is an entity with the power to contract in its own name;
• Has been assigned the financial and operational authority to • carry on a business;
• Sells goods and services, in the normal course of its business, to other
entities at a profit or full cost recovery;
• Is not reliant on continuing government funding to be a going concern
(other than purchases of outputs at arm‟s length); and
Attributes of Public Sector Organisations
•
Generally, what constitutes public sector is determined by:
• The purpose (or function) of the entity involved, • Ownership (and/or control),
• Source and flow of resource,
Attributes of Public Sector Organisations
• The presence of multiple principals
• The presence of multiple tasks or goals • The nature of output and
The Public Sector of Ghana
• Sources of definition and scope:• Chapters 8, 10, 11, 14 of the 1992 Constitution • The Public Services Commission Act, 1994 (482)
• Includes
• MDAs • MMDAs
• Boards, commissions and authorities
• Public educational and research institution • Public corporations/ SOEs / GBEs
Activity 1
• What characteristics differentiate public sector organizations from
Compare and Contrast Public and Private sectors
•
Areas of Differences:
• Goals & Objectives, Types of orgs., Ownership
• Legal Basis, Funding, Accounting system, Nature of Financial
Statement
• Expenditure , Nature of Output, Product pricing • Nature of Accountability
Point of Difference Public Sector Private Sector
Goals & Objectives Seeking general welfare of all citizens
Provide goods for only those who can afford.
To increase the wealth of capital providers
Types of orgs MDAs, MMDAs, Board & commissions and other parastatal org
Sole trading, partnership, limited liability companies
Ownership Government on behalf of
Point of difference Public sector Private sector
Legal Basis Act of parliament/ L.I., IPSAS Relevant laws such as Companies Code, etc
Funding Tax revenue/non-tax revenue Share capital contributions and other private funding
Point of Difference Public Private Expenditure Little distinction between
revenue exp. & capital exp. Based on cash accounting
Clear distinction between revenue exp. & capital exp.
Output Public goods & services Highly excludable goods
&services
Point of diff Public Private
Accountability Delivered to citizens
through parliament Delivered to private contributors of capital through their Boards.
Financial Statement Fund-Based Finance
Appropriation a/c, Rev & Exp a/c and others similar to private
Prepares no appropriation alc, prepares T,P& L a/c instead
Case study
• A large private bus company in Empire City went bankrupt. At Empire
City's request, the state legislature established a legally separate public benefit corporation named Metro City Bus. In the law
establishing Metro City Bus, Empire City was authorized to appoint
Metro's entire governing body, and Metro was authorized to issue tax-exempt debt to assume the assets of the private bus company. When Metro City Bus went to prepare its financial statements, a question was raised. Was Metro City Bus a government?
Case study
• Discuss whether Metro City Bus is or is not a governmental entity. • What are the specific factors in this situation that cause Metro to be
Activity 2
•
Indicate whether the following is part of the public sector or
not.
• Services which are publicly financed and publicly provided • Services which are privately financed and privately provided • Services which are privately financed and publicly provided • Services which are publicly financed and privately provided
Suggested answer
• These are clearly part of the public sector.
• These are clearly not part of the public sector since they involve a
contractual arrangement between a private individual and a private company.
• These could be considered as being part of the public sector since
they involve activity by a PSO.
• Since these involve public expenditure they can be regarded as part of
Areas of Similarities
• Operate in the same economy and compete for same resources:
financial, capital, and human
• Acquire and convert scarce resources into goods and services •
Use of accounting and other information systems
• Need to operate economically, effectively, and efficiently • Provide goods and services, many of which may be similar
Developments in the public sector environment
• Size of the public sector and its relation to the overall size of the
economy
• Configuration:
• the dichotomy of service policy and purchasing, and service provision • the mix of public sector and private sector service provision
• organizational simplification.
• Changes in functions
• Organization and culture • Financing trends
FINANCING ARRANGEMENTS
Government activities are financed through tax revenues, non- tax revenue and borrowings
Tax revenue sources:
Direct taxes: Personal income tax (PAYE), Company/corporate tax, capital gain tax, gift tax
Indirect taxes: Import duties, export duties, petroleum levy, excise duties, VAT, mobile telecom tax.
Non tax revenue:
Proceeds from the sale of state assets including divestiture proceeds.
Dividends from state owned enterprises. Petroleum/oil revenue
fines and penalties
Interest on loans and other investments
Royalties from mineral and other natural resources Fees and user-charges
Borrowings and grants:
Locally contracted borrowings and Loans.
Externally/foreign contracted loans include; bilateral loans from other
countries and multilateral loans from International Monetary Funds, World Bank etc..
Grants and Aid (Grant-in-Aid)
• Grant:
• A financial award given by the federal, state or local government to an
eligible grantee.
• Government grants are not expected to be repaid by the recipient. • Grants do not include technical assistance or other forms of financial
assistance such as a loan or loan guarantee, an interest rate subsidy, direct appropriation or revenue sharing.
• Aid:
• Is a voluntary transfer of resources from one country to another.
• The type of aid given may be classified according to various factors,
such as
• its intended purpose,
• the terms or conditions (if any) under which it is given, • its source,
• its intended use, and • its level of urgency:
• Grant-in-Aid
• A transfer of money from government(s) to a state government, local
government or individual person for the purposes of funding a specific project or program
Contemporary Financing Arrangements
• Public-Private Partnership (PPP):
• Is a long-term arrangement where private sector organization take on risk and
responsibility for the delivery of a public project, usually involves the creation or enhancement of a fixed asset.
• Is an approach to delivering public services that involves the private sector, but
one that provides for a more direct control relationship between the public and private sector than would be achieved by a simple (legally-protected) market-based and arms-length purchase.
Rationale of PPP
• access to private finance for expanding services, • clearer objectives,
• new ideas, flexibility, better planning,
• improved incentives for competitive tendering and greater value for money for public projects • efficiency savings
• the desire to improve the performance of the public sector by employing innovative operation and
• reducing and stabilizing costs of providing services;
• improving environmental protection by ensuring compliance with
environmental requirements;
• reinforcing competition;
• reducing government budgetary constraints by accessing private
Types of PPP Arrangement
Service contract
Management contract Design &Build
Service concession
Design-build-operate- Maintain (DBOM) Design-build-finance-operate (DBFO) Build-own-operate (BOO)
Euro and other bonds
• First in 2007, Ghana’s first bond secured $750million at an interest rate
of 8.5 per cent.
• The Second in 2013, fetched $1billion from the International Capital
Market, after securing $1.2billion. It attracted an interest rate of 7. 877 per cent.
• The third in 2014, attracted an order of $3billion, but secured $1billion
at an interest rate of 8.25 per cent
Assignment
• Analysis the financing sources and expenditure pattern over the last
10 years, and discuss the implications on the medium to long-term development agenda of Ghana
WHAT IS PUBLIC SECTOR ACCOUNTING
?
• Is the system developed for and/or in public sector organisations to
enable them account for, or trace the finances they generate or use and the services or developments that they undertake.
• Is the system of accountability through which the established
institutions of the public report on the available revenues of the nation and how these revenues are used.
• It refers to all the financial documents and records of public
institutions relating to the collection of government revenue and
their analysis, the control of expenditure, the administration of trust funds, the management of government stores and all the financial responsibilities and duties of the relevant government departments.
• Is the process of recording, analysing, classifying, summarising,
communicating and interpreting financial information about government in AGGREGATE and IN DETAILS, reflecting all
transactions involving the receipt, transfer and disposition of government funds and assets in general
Objectives of Public Sector Accounting
• To fulfil legal requirement:
• The law requires that government accounts are prepared
annually
• To satisfy the stewardship function:
• The ruling government is the steward of the resources and
finances of the nation and so has to give account of how these finances are used
• To enable the government to plan well the future developments and
programmes of the nation;
Users of information from the Public Sector
• Unlike business organizations where the users of their financial
reports are obviously and readily recognizable, it is not always clear who the intended readers of public related financial
statements are.
• Why?
• Some principal users are:
• Legislative and other governing bodies • public as tax payers and/or voters
• Investors and creditors • Rating Agencies
• Donors and sponsors • Management
• Others are
• The media,
• economic and financial analysts, • customers and clients,
• suppliers, • employees, • competitors, • academia
Overview of Financial Management in the Public
Sector
• Financial management is one of the factors that ensures successful
public sector management.
• It sits alongside other contextual aspects, such as
• leadership, transparency and accountability, levels of resources and staff
capacity,
• is influenced by many aspects of the social, political and economic environment.
• It generates vital information for better decision making, better services,
• It impacts on a broad range of areas including:
• aggregate financial management – fiscal sustainability, resource mobilisation
and allocation
• operational management – performance, value-for-money and budget
management
• governance – transparency and accountability
• fiduciary risk management – controls, compliance and oversight
• Public Financial Management (PFM) is multidimensional – and liable
to differ between countries.
• PFM is no longer viewed as a purely technical finance and accounting
topic (as it once was); rather, it has become a subject where institutions and political factors play an important role.
What is public sector financial management?
• Definition may PFM differ from donor to donor and from one partnercountry to another.
• It encompasses the mobilisation of revenue; the allocation of these
funds to various activities; expenditure; and accounting for spent funds.
• It includes all components of a country’s budget process –
• upstream (including strategic planning, medium term expenditure
framework, annual budgeting), and
• Public Financial Management (PFM) is the system by which the
financial aspects of the public services’ business are directed,
controlled and influenced, to support the delivery of the sector goals (CIPFA-1)
• PFM is the system by which financial resources are planned, directed
and controlled to enable and influence the efficient and effective delivery of public service goals (CIPFA-2).
• Is any activity in order to analyse, structure, set objectives and
implement measures in the field of finance, if the entity is government of any level
• a corporation controlled by the government or
• For countries, financial management refers to the budgeting,
accounting, internal control, funds flow, financial reporting, and auditing arrangements by which they receive funds, allocate them and record their use (World Bank).
• PFM is concerned with the laws, organizations, systems and
procedures available to governments wanting to secure and use resources effectively, efficiently and transparently.
• It encompasses taxes and other government revenue, borrowing and
debt management, but its main focus is expenditure management, especially in the context of public budgeting.
• Other definitions tend to cluster around the budget as the central theme. • PFM has sub-systems such as:
• Public sector accounting
• Government financial statistics (GFS) • Budgeting
• Treasury
• PFM is said to comprise:
• the institutional framework, systems, and procedures that govern the
preparation, execution, and reporting of the budget
• all phases of the budget cycle, including the preparation of the budget, internal
control and audit, procurement, monitoring and reporting arrangements, and external audit
Objectives of PFM
•
PFM has wide public policy and economic significance.
•
PFM is highly relevant to:
• resolving problems of financial crisis • resolving process of fiscal adjustment
• correcting fiscal imbalances and then stabilize fiscal positions • Developing appropriate economic and financial policies.
Objectives of PFM
•
It promotes accountability within developing countries and
provides donors with assurance on the use of their funds.
•
The objectives of PFM include:
• maintaining fiscal discipline;
• allocating resources strategically; and • operational efficiency.
Comprehensive fiscal risk oversight :
Comprehensive fiscal risk oversight :
Is oversight of fiscal risk Information:Information:
Comprehensive, Policy-based, budget:
Does the budget capture all relevant fiscal transactions, and
is the process, giving regard to government
policy?
Comprehensive, Policy-based, budget:
Does the budget capture all relevant fiscal transactions, and
is the process, giving regard to government
policy?
Budget Realism:
Is the budget realistic, and implemented as
intended in a predictable manner?
Budget Realism:
Is the budget realistic, and implemented as
intended in a predictable manner?
Control :
Is effective control and stewardship exercised
in the use of public funds?
Control :
Is effective control and stewardship exercised
in the use of public funds?
Accountability and Transparency :
Are effective external financial accountability
and transparency arrangements in place?
Accountability and Transparency :
Are effective external financial accountability
and transparency arrangements in place? Six core
objectives of PFM system
Elements of PFM
• The elements PFM have been variously categorised. • For example:
• budget,
• procurement,
• accountability and transparency, • audit and control,
• revenue and resources mobilisation, • debt management
• Other notable (World Bank) elements include: • Legislation
• Standards
• Execution – Strategy & Planning, Operations, Monitoring & Control • Assurance
• Scrutiny •
• Legislation: the regulatory framework for PFM, determining the
powers and mandatory requirements within which public sector bodies raise and spend money and receive income.
• Standards: the established principles or rules common to a group
that is intended to govern their actions and behaviour to achieve
compliance with a common set of non-statutory requirements (e.g., IFAC, ICA).
• Execution – Strategy & Planning:
• the processes that set the direction for the activities which require financial
management, in the short, medium and longer term, and the frameworks within which overall financial performance is managed.
• Execution – Operations, Monitoring and Internal Control
• the principal financial operations needed to maintain financial
discipline and resilience, deliver services and enable desired outcomes.
• In practice, while central governments may set the framework for
spending, it will often be departmental ministries and local administrations who carry it out.
• Monitoring and Internal Control includes a cluster of processes,
complementary to operations, designed to measure progress and
achievement of milestones and to keep organisations on track to realise their objectives.
• Assurance:
• formal processes to give assurance to stakeholders about the organisation’s
standards and effectiveness, carried out at arm’s length from the operations they examine.
• The rigour, professionalism and independence of these processes, and of the
bodies that carry them out, contribute to public trust and the resilience of the taxpayer relationship.
• Scrutiny:
• scrutiny of PFM processes, outside executive responsibility, can oversee,
influence and challenge the allocation of resources and the administration of public sector finances.
• Scrutiny processes create a demand for transparency and improve accountability;
• Learning and Growing:
• processes that enable public service organisations, individually and
collectively, to reflect and learn from best practice, from partners, mentors and peers and from their own experiences, in order to develop their
knowledge and capabilities.
• Growing in this context refers to internal growth and not to organisational
Regulatory Environment
of the Public sector
Regulatory Environment of the Public sector
• The Regulatory environment includes the standards or guidelines, the
legal frameworks and the institutions associated with public sector accounting and finance.
• Traditional regulatory frameworks
• Country based • Sector based • Function based
Overview of the legal framework
• The 1992 Constitution
• The Financial Administration Act 2003 (Act 654)
• The Financial Administration Regulatory 2004 (L.I. 1802) • Procurement Agency Act 2003 (Act 663)
• Internal Audit Agency Act 2003 (Act 658) • Audit Service Act 2000 (Act 584)
Regulatory Authorities
• Executive• Parliamentary Control
• Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning (MOFEP) • Controller and Accountant-General
• Auditor-General
• Internal Audit Agency • Bank of Ghana
Executive (Office of the President/cabinet)
• Determines the overall strategy of government and reviews and
approves sector ceiling of MDAs
• Takes decisions on government polices with regard to financial outlay • In taking decisions, the Executive takes careful consideration so as not
to overburden taxpayers
• Also, exercises careful control so that commitments made are
Parliamentary control
• No revenue shall be levied or expenditure incurred except as
authorized by Parliament (1992 Constitution)
• Parliamentary Control is exercised in different phases:
• Appropriation • Audit Control
• Review by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) • Other parliamentary select committees
Ministry of finance and economic planning
• Overall responsibility as an overseer ministry for financial
management in the country
• Oversight responsibilities include:
• Development and implementation of the country’s macro-economic and fiscal
policy framework
• Advising government on the total resources to be allocated to the public
sector and the appropriate level to be allocated to individual programmes and activities within the sector
• Ensuring the presentation to Parliament periodic statements of
current and projected state of the economy
• Signing of warrant for approval of withdrawal from the Consolidated
Fund of moneys allocated by Parliament
• Giving direction to PAC on accounting practices with regard to
collection and accounting of public and trust moneys by any government department.
Controller and accountant-general (CAG)
• The CAG performs the following financial control duties:
• Responsible to the Minister for the custody, safety and integrity of the
Consolidated Fund and other public funds designed under the care of the CAG
• Responsible for the compilation and management of the accounts
prepared in relation to the Consolidated Fund and other public funds
• Chief adviser to the Minister and the government on accountancy
matters
• Responsible for keeping, rendering and publishing of statements of
Auditor-General
• Appointed by government in consultation with the Council of State in
accordance with Article 70(1b) of the Constitution
• Responsibilities include:
• Examining and certifying government accounts
• Auditing, and reporting on, the public accounts of Ghana and of all public
offices such as the courts, the central and local government administrations, Universities and other public institutions
• Auditing of the foreign transactions through Bank of Ghana
• Examination of the CAG’s report on public accounts
Internal audit agency
• Ensuring that risks in MDAs and MMDAs are managed adequately. • Ensuring the resources of the nation are safeguarded and used
economically, efficiently and effectively.
• Ensuring that systems are put in place to enable fraud and errors n the
MDAs and MMDAs to be detected quickly
• Ensuring that efficient internal audit is developed and maintained in all
MDAs and MMDAs through a plan approved by the board of Internal Audit Agency
• Ensuring an effective reporting system which informs MDAs and MMDAs
about detected problems and deficiencies in the administration of their programmes and operations.
Bank of Ghana
• The general functions of BOG includes:
• formulate and implement monetary policy aimed at achieving the objects of
the Bank;
• promote by monetary measure the stablisation of the value of the currency
within and outside Ghana;
• institute measures which are likely to have a favourable effect on the balance
of payments, the state of public finances and the general development of the national economy;
• promote, regulate and supervise payment and settlement systems; • issue and redeem the currency notes and coins;
• ensure effective maintenance and management of Ghana's external
financial services;
• license, regulate, promote and supervise non-banking financial institutions; • act as banker and financial adviser to the Government;
• promote and maintain relations with international banking and financial
institutions and subject to the Constitution or any other relevant
enactment, implement international monetary agreements to which Ghana is party; and
• do all other things that are incidental or conducive to the efficient
Functions Relating to FM
• Chapter 13 (183)
• BOG shall be central bank of Ghana and the only authority to issue currency
of Ghana. It also provides for the responsibilities of Ghana.
• Promote and maintain the stability of the currency and direct and regulate
the currency system in public interest
• Sole custodian of state funds of Ghana
• Ensure effective and efficient operation of a banking and credit system to
encourage and promote economic development and efficient utilization of the resources of Ghana