Hamline University
DigitalCommons@Hamline
School of Education Student Capstone Projects School of Education
Fall 2017
How Mainstream Teacher Attitudes Affect English
Language Learner Student Learning In The
Mainstream Classroom
Lauren Barbara Lippert
Hamline University
Follow this and additional works at:https://digitalcommons.hamline.edu/hse_cp Part of theEducation Commons
This Capstone Project is brought to you for free and open access by the School of Education at DigitalCommons@Hamline. It has been accepted for inclusion in School of Education Student Capstone Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@Hamline. For more information, please [email protected], [email protected].
Recommended Citation
Lippert, Lauren Barbara, "How Mainstream Teacher Attitudes Affect English Language Learner Student Learning In The Mainstream Classroom" (2017).School of Education Student Capstone Projects. 119.
HowMainstreamTeacherAttitudesAffectEnglishLanguageLearnerStudentLearninginthe MainstreamClassroom
by
LaurenBarbaraLippert
AcapstonesubmittedinpartialfulfilmentoftherequirementsforthedegreeoftheMasterof ArtsinEnglishas aSecondLanguage
HamlineUniversity SaintPaul,Minnesota
December2017
PrimaryAdvisor:PattyBornSelly PeerReader:SarahHuseby
Thisworkisdedicatedwithlovetomyhusband,Ryan.Thankyouforyourunwaveringsupport andencouragement.
Andalso,dedicatedwithlovetomyparents,DanandKimLippertforteaching methevalueof educationandlifelonglearning.
Copyrightby
LAURENBARBARALIPPERT,2017 AllRightsReserved
TABLEOFCONTENTS
CHAPTERONE:Introduction 6
EducationalEquality 7
BackgroundandRoleofResearcher 8
GuidingQuestions 10
Summary 10
CHAPTERTWO:LiteratureReview 12
CorrelationbetweenMainstreamTeacherAttitudesandStudentLearning13
VariablesthatAffectMainstreamTeacherAttitudes 16
AttitudesTowardsELLInclusionintheMainstreamClassroom 16 AttitudesTowardsELLTrainingforMainstreamTeachers 18 AttitudesTowardsModificationsforELLStudentsinthe
MainstreamClassroom 20
AttitudesTowardsLanguageBackgrounds 22
WhatMainstreamTeachersNeedtoKnowaboutTeachingELLs 23 UnderstandingSecondLanguageLearning intheMainstream
Classroom 24
SecondLanguageLearningStrategies intheMainstream
Classroom 26
ConsiderationsforMainstreamTeachers 30
SummaryandPreviewofChapterThree 34
CHAPTERTHREE:ProjectDescription 36
CHAPTERFOUR:ReflectionandConclusion 41
REFERENCES 47
BIBLIOGRAPHY 51
FURTHERRESOURCES 53
APPENDIXA 54
CHAPTERONE Introduction
EnglishLanguageLearnersareagrowing, heterogenouspopulationthatrepresented9.4 percent,oranestimated4.6millionstudents,inournation’spublic-school system,duringthe 2014-2015schoolyear(NationalCenterforEducationStatistics,2017).Inrural areasofthe U.S.,EnglishLanguageLearnersaccountedforanaverageof3.5percent ofthepublic-school studentenrollment.InMinnesota,thatpopulationaccountsfor7.2percentofpublic-school studentenrollment.Locally,ourschooldistricthas40classroomteachersin aK-12setting. EnglishLanguageLearnersmakeupabout11percent, or58students,ofourentirestudent populationofabout550students.Ofthe40licensed teachers,threeteachershold anEnglishasa SecondLanguage(ESL)license.
SometeachersperceiveEnglishLanguageLearners (ELLs)orminoritystudentsas inferiortothemajority,andthereforeneedingcorrection(Sullivan,2016).Oftenteachers
misinterpretthepotentialadvantageswhenastudentisabletousetheirfirstlanguagetonavigate theirsecondlanguage(Kibler,2010).Mainstreamclassroomteachersneedprofessional
developmentregardingbestpractices,usefulclassroomstrategies,andinformationabout languagebackgroundstoavoidmisinterpretinglinguisticor academicneedsso thattheycan provideallstudentsanequitableeducation.These toolscouldfacilitate learningandimprove teacherattitudestowardsEnglishLanguageLearners.
InthisCapstone,Iamstudyingteacher attitudestowardsEnglish LanguageLearnersin themainstreamclassroomandtheeffectsonstudentlearning.Asaresultofthe study,Iwantto
createprofessionaldevelopmenteducatingteacherson bestpracticesforteachingEnglish LanguageLearnersinthemainstreamclassroom.Ultimately,thegoalofthis trainingisto improvestudentlearningbygivingteachersconfidence inteachingELLs anddemonstratingthe valueofpositiverelationshipswithELLs.
Thischapterintroducestheissuesassociated withmainstreamteacherattitudestowards theinclusionofELLsinthemainstreamclassroom,trainingformainstreamteachers,
accommodationsforELLs,andlanguagebackgrounds.Inaddition,thischapterdiscussesseveral theories,strategiesandconceptsthatmainstreamteachersneed toknowasitwilllikelyaffect theirattitudetowardsteachingELLstudents.
EducationalEquality
WehaveagrowingEnglishLanguageLearner populationforwhom educatorsneedan advancedunderstandingoflinguisticandacademicneeds. Inadditionto ourmoralobligation, therearelawsinplacethatrequireEnglish LanguageLearnerstohaveaccesstoequitable educationalexperiences.Severalcaseshavefoughttodefinewhatconstitutesanequitable education.InreferencetotheSupremeCourtcase,Lau v.Nichols(1974),it canbearguedthat wemaybepreventingourEnglishLanguage Learnersfrommeaningful learningexperiencesby merelyprovidingourELLswiththeexactsame materials,teachers,andfacilitiesaseveryother student.Equalityoftreatmentdoesnotequalmeaningfuleducation.Similarly,theEqual
EducationOpportunitiesActof1974(EEOE)mandatesthatschoolsmustovercomethe
languagebarriersthatmayimpedestudentlearning(Wright,2010).Inaddition tothematerials weprovidetoourstudents,wemustalsogivethemthemeanstoaccess learning.Thisaccessto learningmayrequireadditionaltrainingforclassroomteachersinorderto understandwhatan
equitableeducationlookslikeforEnglishLanguageLearners.Significantresearchexiststhat showstheconnectionsbetweenstudentlearningandteacherattitudesaswell astheidentification ofteacherattitudestowardsELLs.TheliteraturereviewprovidedinChapter Twowillhighlight researchthatdemonstratesaneedforclassroomteacherstoundergohigh-quality,on-going professionaldevelopmenttoensureallstudentshave equalandequitable accesstolearning.
Thefollowingarecommonacronymsusedinthisresearchstudy:
ELL:EnglishLanguageLearner;theacronymusedin thispaperregardinganystudentwhois learningEnglishinthemainstreamclassroom
L1:achild’snativetongue;thefirstlanguagetheyacquire
LEP:LimitedEnglishProficiency;astudent’s Englishisnotyetnative-like
ESL:EnglishasaSecondLanguage;referredto asthespecificlanguageclassforELLs MainstreamClassroom:AnyK-12classroominclusiveofallstudents,includingELLand SpecialEducationstudents
BackgroundandRoleoftheResearcher
Ibeganmyteachingcareerin2012asa preschoolteacherina small,rural,anddiverse schooldistrictinsouthernMinnesota.Amajority ofmyclass camefromSpanish-speaking homes.TheHispanicculturewasnotanewconcepttomeasIgrewupinasimilarsetting.In thatdistrict,wedidnotservicesecondlanguagelearnersuntilkindergarten. Therefore,noneof mystudentswereconsideredELLs.Regardless,Iquicklybegantosee howtheeducational needsofmysecondlanguagelearnerswerequite differentthanthoseofmynativeEnglish speakers.Oneyearlater,IbeganworkingasanELLteacherinarural Minnesotadistrictthathad
ahighELLpopulation.At first,IworkedunderavariancewhileobtainingmyESLlicense.This particulardistrictwasproactiveinprofessionaldevelopment forallstaff regardingourELL population;i.e.,differencesinculture,educationalbackgrounds,andbestpracticesinteaching ELLs.Administration,specialists,andclassroomteacherswereallwell-trainedinworkingwith adiversepopulation.Inaddition,duetothe district’slargesize,thereweremanyresources availabletoteachers.TheELLdepartmentchairregularlyledprofessionaldevelopmenttrainings forthedistrict.Overall,therewererequirementsformodificationsinthe classroom,andteachers weretrainedinfacilitatingthosemodifications.Thedistrict heldteacherstoahighstandardin regardstomeetingtheneedsofallstudents.In turn,teachersheldall students,ELLsincluded,to ahighstandardoflearning.Whileworkinginthis district,Iwasunder theimpressionthatall schoolsheldteachersandstudentstothosesamehighstandards.
In2016,Ileftthedistrictforamuch smaller,lessdiversedistrict inruralMinnesota,also myalmamater,toteachinthemainstreamclassroom. Atmynewdistrict, Isoonrealizedthat therewasasignificantneedformoreprofessionaldevelopmentforallstaffinordertobetter understandourELLpopulation.Inthenewdistrict, thereisalong-termELLissuewhere studentsenterELLinkindergartenandfailtoexitbeforegraduation, whichsuggestswe
educatorsneedtodevelopadeeperunderstandingoftheeducationaland culturalbackgroundsof ourELLstudents.Inthedistrict,thereare severalconcernssurroundingtheELLprogram.One oftheprimaryconcernsisthattheELLclasses arecurrentlyregardedas studyhallsforELL studentsinsteadoflanguagefocusedclassrooms,where teacherssendworksheets withtheirELL studentstocomplete.Inaddition,therearenoexpectationsfromthe administrativeteamthat outlinewhatteachersshouldadoptasappropriateELLstrategiesinthe mainstreamclassroom.In
addition,walkingthedistrict'shallsasastudentand nowasateacher, Ihavewitnessedour graduatingclassesdiminishtolessthanhalfthesizetheyusedtobe.However,theELL
populationcontinuestogrow.Asaresult,toretainthesmallpopulationwehave leftaswellas providethemostequitableservicespossible,itisessential thatwelearnhow toprovidethebest learningexperiencesforallstudents.Mybackgroundhasledtomy researchquestionabout studyingteacherattitudestowardsEnglishLanguageLearnersinthemainstreamclassroomand theeffectsonstudentlearning.
GuidingQuestions
DomainstreamteacherattitudestowardsEnglishLanguageLearnersaffectstudent learningandhow?Theprojectfollowingthisresearchwilladdressthe needsofmainstream teacherstomoreeffectivelyteachEnglishLanguage Learnersinthe mainstreamclassroomand improvestudentlearningexperiences.Theprimarytopicbeinginvestigatedinthis chapteristhe attitudesofmainstreamteacherstowardsELLs.Theultimategoalisto createaprofessional developmentopportunitythatwillhelpmainstream teachersprovidemoretargetedinstruction. Thefollowingaretheguidingquestionsthatwillhelp frametheproject1. Whatisthecorrelation betweenmainstreamteacherattitudesandstudentlearning?2.Whatvariablesaffectmainstream teacherattitudes?3.Whatdomainstreamteachers needtoknow aboutteachingELLs?
Summary
Inthisproject,Iwillprovideinformation regardingteacherattitudes inthemainstream classroomtowardsELLstudents.ChapterOne providedbackgroundinformationconcerningthe needforthisresearch,definedvocabulary,explainedofthebackgroundand roleofthe
Twowillexploretheresearchregardingthe importanceofclassroom teacherattitudestoward ELLsandhowtheycanpositivelyornegatively affectstudentlearning.Iwilldiscussthe correlationbetweenmainstreamteacherattitudesandstudentlearning.Secondly,Iwillidentify fourvariablesthataffectmainstreamteachers:attitudestowardsELLinclusion,attitudestowards ELLtrainingformainstreamteachers,attitudestowards modificationforELL studentsinthe mainstreamclassroom,andattitudestowardslanguagebackgrounds.Lastly,Iwillidentifywhat mainstreamteachersneedtoknowaboutsecond languagelearningin theclassroomincluding theoriesregardingSLAandlearning.Inaddition, Iwilladdress manyresearch-provenstrategies formainstreamteacherswithELLsintheir classroomthatreinforce thosetheories.Chapter Threeisadescriptionofthemethodologyusedinthisresearchandprojectdesign.ChapterFour isareflectionandconclusionofthecapstone project.Thisresearchpertainstoallclassroom teacherswhoteachELLsandwillhelpprovidehighqualityprofessional developmentthatwill enhancelearningexperiencesforourELLs.
CHAPTERTWO
LiteratureReview
Introduction
Thegoalofthisresearchwillbetoexaminethecorrelation betweenmainstreamteacher attitudesandstudentlearning,discussvariablesthat mayaffectteacher attitudes,andidentify whatmainstreamteachersneedtoknowaboutteachingELLsintheclassroom. Basedonthis information,alistofbestpracticeswillbeputtogetherthatcanbeusedforprofessional
development.Inthischapter,asummaryofrelevant researchispresented,andwillidentifythe gapinresearch,alongwiththeneedforfurtherresearchregarding professionaldevelopmentfor mainstreamteachersteachingELLs.
GuidingQuestions
Theresearchquestionintendedforthiscapstoneprojectis:domainstreamteacher attitudestowardsEnglishLanguageLearnersaffectstudentlearningandhow?Theproject followingthisresearchwilladdresstheneedsofmainstreamteachersto moreeffectivelyteach EnglishLanguageLearnersinthemainstream classroomandimprovestudentlearning
experiences.Theliteraturereviewpresentedbelowis inconjunctionwith theguidingresearch questionsthatoutlinemyresearch:1.What isthecorrelation betweenmainstreamteacher
attitudesandstudentlearning?2.Whatvariablesaffectmainstreamteacherattitudes? 3.Whatdo mainstreamteachersneedtoknowaboutteachingELLs?
CorrelationBetweenMainstreamTeacherAttitudesandStudentLearning
Studentlearningisaffectedbyanumberof variables.Teacherattitudesareoneofthose variablesthatcaninfluencestudentacademic performance.AccordingtoGriffin(2008), motivationforacademicandsocialsuccessis stronglyinfluencedby theteacher’sexpectations andconducttowardsthestudent.However,teacherattitudesorperceivedattitudestowards studentsaredifficulttomeasureasteachersmaynotbeawareoftheirbiasesorbehaviors towardsstudentsorstudent groups.Thatsaid,researchmayshowquantitativelyacorrelation betweenstudentperformanceandteacherattitude. Teachers’attitudesandperceptionscan largelyaffectanELL’seducationalopportunities(Griffin,2008).
Thetoneoftheclassroomisinherentlysetbythedemeanorandmodeledbehaviorsofthe classroomteacher.Regardlessofteacherpreferences,teacherscanapproachequalitybybeing self-awareofjudgementsandbiastowardsstudents (Mitchell,1976).As theELLpopulation continuestogrow,itisimportanttoaddresstherelationshipbetweentheteacherandtheELL studentandhowthataffectsstudentacademicperformanceinthemainstreamclassroom.
ELLstudentsposeanewchallengefor classroomteachers,especially thosewhouse traditionalstrategiesnotgearedtowardsavarietyof learningstyles.Inturn,ELLstudentsmay remainisolatedandbeunintentionallydeniedtheir richestsourcefor intellectualandsecond languagedevelopment—socialinteractionwiththeirnative-speakingpeerswhichcangive accesstolinguisticinput(Penfield,1987).
Marlin(1991)studiedthecorrelationbetween teacherattitudestowardseconomicsand studentperformance.TheresultsofMarlin’sstudycanbeappliedtoour nation’scurrentsituation asourELLpopulationisgrowingandtherearesuchfewrequirementsforclassroomteachersto