• No results found

A Peer to Peer Architecture for Collaborative Spam Filtering

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2020

Share "A Peer to Peer Architecture for Collaborative Spam Filtering"

Copied!
100
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

(2)

!

" #

(3)

( )*

! (

# + (

(4)

- .

/

"

( .

0

1 . . +

#

. .

.

2 +

-

(5)

$$ ) $

$& -! 3

$&$ " 4

$&& 5 4

$&6 4

$&3 7 4

$&4 - -! % $6 " % &$ ) 5 8

&$$ 9

&$& ) 9

&$6 ) : $' && : " $$ &&$ 0 ( " $$ &&& " - " $6

&&6 : " $3

&6 . : $4

&3 7.: $;

(6)

6$ < = "= &&

6& >=7? &4

6&$ 7? . &%

6&& 7? . &%

6&6 7? . &;

6&3 Æ &;

66 =: &9

63 @ A &9

3$ " 63

3& : 6%

3&$ " 5 " 6;

3&& 7 " 6;

3&6 7 5 68

3&3 " 68

3&4 5 69

3&% 7 " 3'

3&; B 3'

3&8 0 5 3$

3&9 ?" 3& 3&$' # 36

36 , 33

36$ 7C7 33

36& 5 33

33 : 3%

33$ ?) 5 3;

33& )5 3;

336 ) 3;

(7)

3%$ : 5 39

3%& 4'

3%6 - 5 4'

3%3 - ) " 4$

4$ 5 4& 4& " 46

4&$ + : 46

4&& 5 : 43

4&6 ": 44

4&3 B: 4;

4&4 # : 48

46 2 " 49

46$ . 49

46& . %$ 466 . %& 463 . %6

464 . %6

46% . %3

43 " # %3

43$ "*#$ %3

43& #",$ %3

44 ): %4

4% # ( %% %$ " %8

%$$ B "D %8

%$& " #.", %9

(8)

%&& * ;6

%6 ;6

%3 7 ;4

%3$ : 5 ;4

%3& 7 # ;% %4 " ;% %4$ 5 ;; %4& "7 ;; %46 # ;8

! " !# ;$ -! :+ ;9

;& : B 8'

$ "% #$ ? 8$

#& 5 8& #6 7 8& $ &$ 0$ 5 84

0& # " 84

06 "? ") 8%

(9)

6$ - ": &6

6& :5 &3

66 5 &4

3$ 0" ": 64

3& , #.", 6%

4$ : #",) %4

#$ " ? " 86

0$ # " 8%

(10)

$$ ) ) &

$& # " 5 ("5 3

&$ "# $9

6$ Æ >=7? &8

6& 6$

(11)

" .

( (

2

= " 2

.

? E 9; F

G > H (=

.

( ! .

.

/ @

" ½

H!.=A

#

?

½

(12)

()* + ()* &$ (,*

$'' '$' 9$''

5 ';4 '$' 88''

: ''6 '$' &6''

# ''; '$' 3$''

. $

" '''''$ '$' ''$

$$/ ) )

?

" " + $$

" I

EI'$ F *

("5 =

+ ("5

2

@ A

@ A

' 0 ! @94J

EFA

( +

(13)

/ 01 + 0

2

7 , 5?

@ EB9$FA *

Æ @

A

(

2 (

1 !

.

$ ' =

+

K

" . :.

!

("5 * #- $&

? + EF EF

(14)

2&

$ 6' $&4

3 6'J 8'J

$&/ # "5 ("5

,

! :

+

*

+

Æ

+

-

+

.

.

+

!"

2 !

+

+

(15)

( .

(

:

@

A

" 2

0

! .

.

+ ( .

:

("5 @

A

=

# .

+

: +

@ A

(16)

! . .

" .

+ # .

(

. =

0 + .

?

+

# $$

+

0

(

.+ +

#

"4 !

(17)

. +

"4 !

+

"4 ?

( .

"4

!

"4 .

2 .

(18)

. .

+ 2

+

$ %

)

! (0) ) 2

( "-? @("-A

L3'' 0

("- L3''

.

+ +7

@7: A

( .

.

L3'' "

L3''

("- 0 ! .

(19)

# EB 99F ( .

? /

5 (5.*

#)#

)#

5 (56*

(

5 $ (5* )#

=

5 (5+*

= )#

!

)# )#(=")5

@")5A)# ")5:

")5

+ E5 8&F")5

- @ A

@ A ")5

7 M M

")5

@ A

(20)

+

?

"

# + .

+ E 8& F

.

+

)#

# .

&$& "

*

7 K

7 -

Æ

+ * .

+

2 .

/

(21)

#

+

= .

(5

2

2 +

:

= @

A "

:

K +

? + *

+ @#

- A

#$ % !

3

2

? +

+.

. * .

@ $&3A B

(22)

1

*

*

+

!

5 .

@ ) ) - A

)#

?

+

@ ("5A #

.

Æ

)# 2 )E)'& F

" ½

+

+

½

!" # $ % &

% ' $ $ % '

$ $

' $ %

$$ $ $'

(23)

+ @ A

5 6

) # @)#A )#

+ -

# + +

!

+

* .

:

. +

+ &6

!! & !

-

("5 =

: ¾

¾

( $

(24)

"

&4

- +

" !

+ (

++.

+ / .

.

2

2/

>= 7 EF

.

+ +

"0@ EFA "" @ EFA

.

@ N??? A

??? " =

(

(25)

) +

0

@ A

. .

2 )#5 "@)#5"A

7 0 @70A EF #

89 "

)#5" 70 # )#5" 70

. . /

"0 -7

@

&&&A

# + .

# O P )

: )#5" 70

*

)#5"70 .

O P )

( + B

# 1

Æ

(26)

A = : ".

0 EF +

(

+

@

+ A

) # @)#A EF

# . +

+

K

+

"

Æ

+ @

-

A

: 2 .

+ +

.

+ :

EF/

¯ #

¯ . +

Æ

¯ . /

(27)

¯ " .

#

+

' (

# $$ ! .

.

&6

,

# +

2 K

@ E 8& FA .

2 *

?

. "

+ 2

# +

+

# 0

EF @

A !

@

A (

* Æ +

+

(28)

@ +

A

Æ + (

Æ

+ +

# +

"# EF (

+

Æ +

+ "#

?

+ +/

8 $

0

69 $

+ &6

+% "" @ 6A "#

+ + B

&$ .

@+A

+

("5 +

+

(29)

(

"

"5#)

"5#)

5>

MO +M

=

-2 2

7

,"0/ +""

,"0/ "

7 70

/CC. CC

"", "

7 I( MM M M

7 MM

Q"

# .Q"

Q"

(30)

+ :

/ + @

A "

@ A

1 !

$&&

* "#

+ @

6A

1 +

) * +

#

+

+ ( ?

2 .+ ?.

.

" .

+ .+

( , 0 +

+ "

(31)

? ( $998 " E"**98 F

, 0 + ?

.

* &''' # E#< ·

'' F .

. +

+

+ K

+

@

(32)

# @.

A

K +

( +

.

.

2 +.

+

. 2

# , -

-" < " " E<"F

+

+

-

+

(33)

+ /

"+)##

@ A

( +

+

+

+ - #

+ +

)#

.+

:6& +

(34)

.+

+ +

(

(

(

+ +

-

? : 66

+

@ )# #A

(35)

0 @

A 2

+ 2

@ A

# .- (/

7? +>> 5

+

E5F

7?

+ " 7? 7.

# : &'. +@ "*#

E,("'& FA 7? "

+@ .

A 7? :#

@ )#A

" # 6$

(36)

K "# &3

.+ 7? = :#

+ >=7?

'($

7? .

7? .7? (

@

A

@ E '$FA )#@E 9;FA

? /

? .

'(!

7? . 7? 7 #

7? "

? .

= :

@ EF ?

) A

? .

(

? . #E? F

? . @

? . A

(37)

/

==..

"

:

",

@ A

+ ? . #

? .

0

7? "

'()

7? . ?

Æ

# Æ @

A 6$ +

Æ 7? (

2

# 7? !

- Æ

"# &3 *

(38)

*&

6$/ Æ >=7?

@

A

# + 7? ? (

?

E? F

#

K

(39)

Q&''& *

E? FK

.

@

A

## -

: 7? / >> 5

Q 7 # , 5. .

5 +.

@ : A . .

+ 7? :

+

# .

:

1 .? .

+

@

7? A Æ

#' 01

EF

2

(

(40)

*

#

2 ( .

")5 !

+

MM

-

*

(

!

#+ 7? @

A 2

? #

/

: (

, .

½

) *++ ,% %

(41)

"

(5 ")5

: ")5

: ")5

).( ")5

7 7/

")5

" ")5

.+

0 ")5 .

:?$ + M??M

:?& + M??M

6&/

& )

( @

A 2 #

.

.

MM

??

:

?? "

&'''

( 6& ¾

2

Æ *

.

¾

(42)

5C(5 ," ")5

,"

) : #

, "

2

"!

+

2

=

+

-

!

")5

! (

+

@8A

: 7?

7? "

K

(43)

*

@

A

* Æ

# Æ

Æ

# +

K Æ

@:

A

@ )

(44)

. #

+

!

:2 +

'

+ .

+ 6$6&

:3$

; 2 .

+ ?

; 2 9

#", 0

#

" ;

"

? #",0

(45)

The Internet

ASN User A

ASN User B

A Spammer

The Internet

ASN User A

ASN User B

A Spammer

A

B

C

The Internet

ASN User A

ASN User B

A Spammer

(46)

NODE

A

SIGNATURES.XML

<?xml version="1.0"

encoding="UTF-8" ?>

<!DOCTYPE signature

SYSTEM "signatures.dtd">

<signatures>

<signature

id="iPeldkeoIe/9k"

algo="ASN1" hops="3">

<sender

id="[email protected] />

</signature>

</hosts>

NODE

C

NODE

B

NODE

E

HOSTS.XML

<?xml version="1.0"

encoding="UTF-8" ?>

<!DOCTYPE hosts

SYSTEM "hosts.dtd">

<hosts>

<host id="[email protected]"

lastdate="1030136296"

score="2"

status="ok" />

</hosts>

NODE

D

A

B

A

B

Legende

Node B is among the top nodes on Node A's list. Node A will

accept any signature coming from Node B.

Node A knows Node B, but it is not among its top nodes.

Node A will accept signatures from Node B only on request.

: 3&/ , #.",

'

3&..

? . .

+ =

+ = +

# +

@ 3&6A

(47)

@

A 2

& ) + &&

0 ?

( +

! .

+

" . .

! @ $&&A .

: .

! !

# .

#

: .

K

.. .

22

?

B

>=7? 6& (

#

? @

(48)

: 34

$

:

(

?

#

#+

2

, &

.

#

(

+

( . .

R R

=

@ 3&6A

(49)

#

0

(

(

#

+

(

@

A

,

# ? . .

0 ?

(

" . @

3&6A +

-

"

(50)

# 7? 6&

+

0

+ .

(

* /

@

A

K

?

R

7? E?F R

. /

- +

+ ! $&3

&6

. :

(51)

-

#

*

?

?

: /

*

:

?

+ Æ

"

*

(

?

0 ! . . $&6

:

. +

+ :

. . ?

0 #

0 .

(52)

2 2

K+

+ @

= A *

+

1 *& ' &

-.

:

)

: ? .

? "

+

+

(53)

=

+ : . .

*

, .

# +

5 .

.

5<(@5<(A

+

"

?

B

+

+ +

+

!

(54)

+

'# 2

4&5!

. C

@

= +A =

+ @ A

.

+

. .

(

= +

+

@ 3&6A #

!

.

K *5 ")5- @ 5A .

(55)

+@ A

*5")5

K

+

*5

:

*

*5G R+

"

. . *5

:

")5 +

=

")5 *5 +

( = (

")5

:

! .

")5

. !

.

5# ( ! .

(56)

.

+ 0

. -

==

.

! . .

:

+

==

- .

:

'' $

# + +

.

+

2 +

B .

K

! (

?

(57)

+ )#

)# " #

@ E '$FA

0

= + +

6 ,

#

G

+ G

@5-5A @()#5A

, *

:

+

:

+

* ! /

2

!

(58)

: ?

= !

- (

2 * ?

+ (

?? 6

0 2

?

(

#I)

75 !

*) * 4&J ?

2

@

A

#

7? ?

..

* ??2 ? .

)

?? *

½

? I

@

A ??

½

/

(59)

0

? .

*

?? - ??

. 2

'3 $

(

2 + .

/

- "

- +

/ +

+

*

@ A

+ :

K

! +

2

* : 2

(60)

. +

@

+A

- *&! +

"

( @3&%A

+

* .

K

#

E,("'& F . .

R R

.

: : 3&

=

1

- )

"

. .

.

#

1 .

+

(61)

@ A

? @ A

*

. / .

0

$'

- )

# ")5

(

.

. .

*

.

. .

.

.

2

3%6

2 ,

(62)

L) + ( + * ?

32

*

3

) &

( + ! .

$&&

.

")5

@

EB -'' FA ! @ EI)9%FA 0

!

.

(63)

# 3&$ +

. :

L) .

3& + +

. / +.

*7& "

+ + C

/

!"

#$%& & "

& %& & #'("

& ) %& & #'("

+ + B .

/

*+) ,-./0- ,-( 1- *"

2% 3$ 3 -/-"

"

"

,-- ),-455-6"

,-)7-),-455)5)7/+)- 6"

,-87)-),-455587)/+)- 6"

,-9- ),-45559/+)- 6"

,--),-4555/+)- 6"

,-- ),-./0- 6"

,-))- ),-&.- 6"

,-9- ),-:- 6"

,-)- ),-);</- 6"

,-9- ),-)///- 6"

,-977)- ),-=- 6"

,-79)- ),-:- 6"

(64)

6"

"

2 .

: 9

2 46

"

+

+ /

9 9 !"

9 #$%& & "

& 9 ) %& & #'("

& 9 %& & #'("

& 9 %& & #'("

& 9 %& & #'("

.

) .

K

# 3&6

?

#

B

(65)

G

B

; 8 B

8 ; #

8

# @ 3&8A

+/

*+) ,-./0- ,-( 1- *"

2% 3$ 9 3 -9/-"

"

9"

9

,-)/<@/-),-.0:0.:>=A>- ,-=- ,-;-6"

9

,-);</-),-.0:0.00.0=- ,-0- ,-8-6"

9

,-)<//-),-.0:0.00.0=- ,-0- ,-;-6"

69"

"

+

(

+@ 3&8A

& "

+ + ( .

"

!

(

+/

!"

(66)

& %& & #'("

& ) %& & #'("

& 79 %& & #'("

& %& & #'("

& %& & #'("

#

"*#.$

+ L) K

@BA @-A

) .

" .

+

79 . .

B 79.

#79 '

* 79

+ +.

+

.

(

(67)

*+) ,-./0- ,-( 1- *"

2% 3$ 3 -/-"

"

"

,-$$C(DE6A9%F%(8-),-G&.- 79,-:-"

,-);</- ,-.0:0?H?0??- 6"

6"

,->HD.E;1();1H6-),-G&.- 79,-=-"

,-)<//- ,-.0:0?H?=:.- 6"

6"

6"

"

.

+ .

-

@)+ + +A

+2

-

+

/ "

+ .

.

: +/

87) 9 !"

9 #$%& & "

& 9 %& & #'("

& 9 9@ %& & #'("

.

(68)

9@ *

9@

( 2

977) + + ?

2 .

=

#

'

(

'

: +/

*+) ,-./0- ,-( 1- *"

2% 3$ 87) 3 -87)/-"

"

87)"

9 ,-/77<//- 9@,-0- 6"

9 ,-@/7))<//- 9@,-0- 6"

687)"

"

3 "

+

+

+ +/

)7 )7 !"

(69)

& )7 ) %& & #'("

.+

4&6

) +

B

/

*+) ,-./0- ,-( 1- *"

2% 3$ )7 3 -)7/-"

"

)7"

)7 ,-G&.- ),-455)57./9)-6"

)7 ,-&.- ),-455)5./9)-6"

6)7"

"

+ #

+

)# $ 4

.

2

(

#",.+

(70)

+/

<": I%

G ( ( G

( @

A

+ ' ( @ A

:

<":+

( 8

+ =

-=: &J (

- @

&JA + 2

(

(

*

4&4

-=:+ #

+

+

(71)

+ + +

# 3 1

($

@ A

(

+ (

+ (

2

977) + +

I&2K I&F&J

( .

@ E '$ FA + /

G,667

LM2,

&,NOG2P6)

M2I,NOG2P6+

2J,NO&P6)

40

! QI&4

R 9) 676);66/9)

048

(72)

! QI&F&J

676);6)69

+ #", (

. (

.

?

(

+

(,

B

@

) + 4&4A

+ + ?

2 ( $'

+

@

) A

( 3&3

-

3&6

. @

. A

; 8

.

; : .

(73)

B

.

(

@ 3&6A

+ + .

+

# . + .

@ A+

.

(

?

+

(

+ +

. :

@ 9) S66/9)

(74)

+

- ($

( +

+ "

+ (

+

.

.

464

)'

2

83

"*#.$ @ G&.A

"*#.$ %3 ,.

( " &; .

: E,("'&F

39

+ #", @ &. ½

A "*#.$

%3 0 .

I ) ? . @

0A

½

& 0 ' $&

(75)

From [email protected] Fri Sep 6 19:52:14 2002

Return-Path: <[email protected]>

Delivered-To: [email protected]

Received: from mail.cs.tcd.ie (relay.cs.tcd.ie [134.226.32.56])

by jessica.minet.net (Postfix) with ESMTP id 8A73241E4

for <[email protected]>; Fri, 6 Sep 2002 19:52:14 +0200 (CEST)

Received: from mail.cs.tcd.ie (localhost [127.0.0.1])

by relay.cs.tcd.ie (Postfix) with ESMTP id 66EA8F5EA

for <[email protected]>; Fri, 6 Sep 2002 18:52:13 +0100 (IST)

Received: from localhost.localdomain (unknown [134.226.36.150])

by mail.cs.tcd.ie (Postfix) with ESMTP id BEDB3F58D1

for <[email protected]>; Fri, 6 Sep 2002 18:52:12 +0100 (IST)

X-ASN: EXC-I

Subject: [ASN-Message] Please read the notice at the end of the message

From: Cottereau Laurent <[email protected]>

To: [email protected]

X-Mailer: Ximian Evolution 1.0.5

Date: 06 Sep 2002 19:42:04 +0100

Message-Id: <1031337724.628.3.camel@clark>

Mime-Version: 1.0

hosts:

_host_one@domain_one

_host_two@domain_two

...

_host_x@domain_x

signatures:

_signature_one

_signature_two

...

_signature_x

---The Anti-Spam Network is a collaborative spam filtering system.

There are two main reasons why you might have received this

message. You might already be using the system, and this means

that it is not set correctly. Please refer to the manual.

If you have never heard of ASN before, then somebody -intentionaly

or not - is trying to have you participate in the network. If you

wish to have more information about the ASN, please refer to

http://asn.tuxfamily.org. If you don't want to receive these spam

messages anymore, you can set a filter on you incoming mails: these

ASN messages will have "[ASN-Message]" in the Subject field.

1

5

4

3

2

: 4$/ : #",)

))

:4$ #",) +

/

$ L.#",/ 46$

& !

!

(76)

3

!

/

@A . .

B

. .

+ + +

@A

.

+

@A

: #",/

= G&. >HD.E;1();1H6

4 # 2 .

#

+

#",

)3 +

" 4$ 44 .

3

. .

- ! !

(77)

- .

. .

2 #

1

( ?

+

)# )# @

A #

+ .

(

( .

. .

. @ )

- A +

(

. K

!

- .

(78)

( .

3 4

+ .

! . . .

$&

*

! !

$& .

#

3 5

- / :

)*

+ + .

.

E*98F

* +

: I

# 2

(79)

B

"# (

. #

. +

+

- 3 (! 9;$

( .

( +

Æ

3

! /

2& .

2& "

2& "

2& "

2& "

(80)

ÆG G .

0

" .

6 ( .

6 > ? .

( .

.

6 +

(

! .

#

+

+

Æ

.

(

@ A

" ?

@ 3%6 3%3A

(81)

"

# +

.

@ A

(

Æ .

(

-

+

@ 46A

33 * +

2 @

336A

!

.

*

*

B

+ *

+ (

(82)

.

. .

B

@ 3%$A

@ 977)A

+

.

Æ *

+ ?

# +

?

3 5

! .

$&& (

. /

- !

I + /

.

@A -

+

(83)

B

#

!

:

#

I,I5@I5 E: 9$FA

- 8

. .

I .+ ")5

.

. .

. .

# 5

+

*

4%

4

. .

3# %

+ !

$& #

@ A

(84)

. .

.

@ A

½

:

:

. +

.

+ +.L)#

L) +

.

+

= .

? B 2

977)

+ ++ 2 0

. ?

(

* .

(

. (

("5 : .

½

(85)

.

+

@ A

- "

. +

( @ A

(

"*#.$@

E,("'& FA

@ A (

@ A

( 3&%

+ @ E? FA

: .

(

.

B @ 3&;A

(86)

: +

+

=

( + .

. .

/

*

- 3$

(

.

* @3%A #

3)

B+$&

/

(87)

?

-

(

:

(

"(N !@ E<B# ·

'$ FA

" .

+ )

+ @ 6$A

0

. ? @

+ &6 &3 A +

+

+ #

$&4 ! !

: .

@

A

- &

.

2

I)= * +

(88)

?

??

.

- !) 3

?

* 5<( +

.? .

5<(,5<(@EFA

#

B

.

(89)

. . +

( +

.

6 !" *

# .

! % .

3 !

$&

*

4 . . $&6

, .

4%

.

(90)

# .

.

!/

¯ L) .

"

: L)

@? A

" 2

L)

( L)

.

¯ # +

+

¯ 2 +.

"

%6 2

+ 2

¯ +

+

.

. .

(91)

I).

&''$ * ?.

@

A 2

+ ?.

? ?

$5 /

) ? ?

#

$K

2

% : 2

?

2&

+

.+- 7 !

(92)

@ A

/

@ !

! 7

865- *)

/ 0 #

$

# + ,.

7 5 B " Q *) .

@ A +

*

# 9'&

@ A

2

# (

?#$

+ #$

? !

=

(93)

! "#$ %&' (! )*+$ ,

-.

/

*0&! 12 3.

*04 10.

/10.

#$/ " ? "

(94)
(95)

( .

I

) # (

483% 2 &''$

&''&

8 $

2

? . @ #$ 2

? A ?

2? @

A

8

+.

0$

.

(96)

8# /

? B

??

( + 0&

+ ?

? ? .

( + &4% (

+ @6JA

4$&

(97)

Maximum Value

:0&/ "?

(98)

E#< ·

''F ( # Q < < > .

I 5 " #

.+ (

& '

$$ 9R$; &'''

E 9;F 5 " $99;

#-/CC C C!C9

EF 0 /CC C

EF /CC C

E <'$F I Q < (

)* ( # .B

&''$

EF /CC C

EF /CC C *C

E 9;F 0 -=7 $99;

E 8&F * "

7 8&&(

: # $98&

EF

(99)

E: 9$F : " : , , & Q

$99$ &

EI'$F I " # &''$ (8

EI)9%F Q I *)I + -# & #

* . " ) $99%

E*98F )* ( .

)= .

$998

E<"F "< ""

+ /CCC C 4&; !

E<B# ·

'$F < B# Q2

) "N / )

6@$A/;8R86 &''$

EF ) /CC. C

E)'&F 2 ) " .

. / Q&''&

EF , /CC

E,("'&F ,(" " / '

$8'.& #&''&

E5 8&F Q 0 5 " 7

8&$(: # $98&

E5F >> 5 7? /CC? C

E '$F /0# &''$ $648

E?F # ? ./CC .

(100)

! /CCC C

E"**98F ) " " * * ? #

+! Q$998

E" '$F " "/ # + 7

6'&8(: Q&''$

EF " /CC

EF " /CC C

EF " /CC CC

EF /CC

E'$F B - &''$

EB9$F B ,

+ 1 , %6 - $99$

EB -''F B Q -

-=7 &'''

References

Related documents

Composing a TOSCA Service Template for a “SugarCRM” Application using Vnomic’s Service Designer, www.vnomic.com. The SugarCRM application include

focus on groups with symmetric access to genre expectations. Future research could explore how genre expectations develop and are shared among people with asymmetric access to

Interviews were conducted before and after intervention using a physical restraint questionnaire to examine any change in staff knowledge, attitudes, and behaviours on physical

In the field study, there were two different planting regimes: the control treatments were made up of seeds that were planted at the normal and usual time of

Based on the purpose, this study include the type of causal research for this study was conducted to test the effect of independent variables (profitability,

– Member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund, TD Waterhouse Private Investment Counsel Inc., TD Waterhouse Private Banking (offered by The Toronto-Dominion Bank) and

In order to attempt to solve the inverse problem of damage identification using vibration measurements to detect these changes, the direct problem of calculating

 For a first minor infraction, the student must meet with the Program Coordinator, plus any other individuals the Program Coordinator deems necessary, to discuss the incident.. 