MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project Page 1 April 2020

MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION

HOLLOW LANE CULVERT REPLACEMENT PROJECT (STATE CLEARINGHOUSE NO. 2020039009)

S

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

P

D

The proposed project would consist of a culvert replacement project on Hollow Lane. This roadway serves as the only access for approximately 20 residents on the west side of Dry Creek. Currently, two 60- inch corrugated metal pipes (CMPs) convey Dry Creek under Hollow Lane. The aging CMPs show signs of pitting and corrosion and are in need of replacement. The two existing CMPs will be removed and replaced with one 5-foot tall by 15-foot wide aluminum arch pipe with a concrete bottom. The new culvert will include headwalls, wing walls, concrete aprons, and a 20-foot rock energy dissipation pad at the outlet. Recent high-velocity storm water flows have created two large erosional scour holes at the outlet that form ponds during periods of inundation. These scour holes will be repaired by filling the holes, constructing a 20-foot diameter rock energy dissipation pad, and re-grading the creek channel bottom to direct positive downstream flow. The creek will be accessed on the northwest and southwest sides of the culvert. Existing utilities within the project work zone include: an 8-inch sewer main; a 2-inch gas line; and an 8-inch water main. The sewer main, currently located under the existing culverts, will be replaced and protected with the concrete culvert bottom. The gas line and water main will be replaced within the roadway.

The majority of work will occur within the City’s right of way (ROW); however, temporary permits to enter and construct will be needed to access the north side of the creek, relocate utilities, and install the new culvert. Permanent ROW acquisition or easements may be required for long-term culvert

maintenance. Half-width construction is required in order to maintain access for residents and emergency vehicles. As each half of the arch pipe is completed, Hollow Lane will be reconstructed and an asphalt concrete dike will be installed along the edge of the roadway. Staging will occur with the City’s ROW.

The project is anticipated to be built in 2021 and would require one season of construction.

E

S

Hollow Lane is a two lane residential road that crosses Dry Creek approximately 0.4 miles west of Ridgewood Road in Redding, Shasta County, California. The project area is bounded on the east, west, and north by residential development. The area to the south is City owned undeveloped open space. Dry Creek flows south through the project area, into the open space, and into Churn Creek approximately 800- feet downstream.

City of Redding

Public Works Department, Engineering Division Mitigated Negative Declaration

Page 2 Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

April 2020

F

A

D

The City of Redding conducted an Initial Study (attached) that determined that the proposed project could have significant environmental effects on biological resources. Use of specific mitigation measures identified below will avoid or mitigate the potentially significant environmental effects identified, and the preparation of an environmental impact report will not be required. If there are substantial changes that alter the character or impacts of the proposed project, another environmental impact determination will be necessary.

Prior to approval of the project, the lead agency may conclude, at a public hearing, that certain mitigation measures identified in the Mitigated Negative Declaration are infeasible or undesirable. In accordance with CEQA Section 15074.1, the lead agency may delete those mitigation measures and substitute other measures that it determines are equivalent or more effective. The lead agency would adopt written findings that the new measure(s) is equivalent or more effective in mitigating or avoiding potential significant effects and that it would not cause any potentially significant effect on the environment.

1. Based on the whole record (including the Initial Study and any supporting documentation) and the mitigation measures incorporated into the project, the City of Redding has determined that there is no substantial evidence that the project will have a significant effect on the environment.

2. The Mitigated Negative Declaration, with its supporting documentation, reflects the independent judgment and analysis of the lead agency, which is the City of Redding.

D

The attached Initial Study documents the reasons to support the above determination.

M

M

The following mitigation measures will be incorporated into the project to minimize potential effects on biological resources:

MM-1. Prior to the start of construction, a focused botanical survey will be conducted during the blooming period for potentially occurring plant species. If no special status plant species are found during the botanical survey no other measures will be required. If special status plant species are discovered during the focused botanical surveys, the plants will be marked by a qualified biologist. If the area can be avoided, exclusionary fencing will be placed around the plants and no pedestrian or vehicular entry shall be allowed. If the area cannot be avoided, the City will coordinate with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to avoid, minimize, and mitigate impacts to the species. Potential measures for reducing project impacts on special status plants include limiting ground disturbance until annual plants have gone to seed, then stockpiling the top soil during the initial excavation to be replaced as the top layer during the final site rehabilitation.

MM-2. Construction activities within Dry Creek shall be limited to a work window of June 1 to October 31.

City of Redding

Mitigated Negative Declaration Public Works Department, Engineering Division

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project Page 3

April 2020

MM-3. Within 7 days prior to the onset of construction activities, a qualified biologist shall conduct pre- construction surveys for western pond turtle, turtle nests, and Foothill yellow-legged frog. If these species or turtle nests are observed during the pre-construction survey or during construction, CDFW will be contacted and work within that area will be avoided until an appropriate course of action is established. If western pond turtle, turtle nests, or Foothill yellow-legged frog are not observed during the pre-

construction survey, then construction activities may begin. If construction is delayed or halted for more than 7 days, another pre-construction survey will be conducted.

MM-4. To the extent practicable, removal of large trees with cavities, crevices, or snags shall occur before bat maternity colonies form (i.e., prior to March 1) or after young are volant (i.e., after August 31).

If construction (including the removal of large trees) occurs during the bat non-volant season (March 1 through August 31), a qualified professional shall conduct a pre-construction survey of the study area to locate maternity colonies and identify measures to protect colonies from disturbance. The preconstruction survey will be performed no more than 7 days prior to the implementation of construction activities. If a maternity colony is located within or adjacent to the study area, a disturbance free buffer shall be established by a qualified professional, in consultation with CDFW, to ensure the colony is protected from project activities.

MM-5. To the extent practicable, removal of vegetation shall occur outside of the ring-tailed cat maternal denning period (May 1–June 30). If vegetation removal is to occur during the ring-tailed cat maternal denning period (May 1–June 30), a qualified biologist shall conduct a preconstruction survey of the BSA to locate maternity dens. The preconstruction survey will be performed no more than 7 days prior to the vegetation removal. If a ring-tailed cat maternity den is found, a qualified biologist (in consultation with CDFW) will develop measures to protect the maternity den from disturbance.

MM-6. If vegetation removal or construction activities will occur during the nesting season for migratory birds or raptors (February 1 through August 31), a qualified biologist shall conduct a

preconstruction survey 7 days before construction activities begin. If nesting birds or raptors are found, CDFW will be notified and consulted. An appropriate buffer, as determined by CDFW and the qualified biologist, will be placed around the nest until the young have fledged. If construction activities cease for a period greater than 7 days, additional preconstruction surveys will be required.

P

R

D

Draft copies or notice of this Mitigated Negative Declaration were distributed to:

 State Clearinghouse

 Shasta County Clerk

 California Department of Transportation District 2

 California Department of Fish and Wildlife District 1

 Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board

 California Native Plant Society

 California Highway Patrol

 Native American Heritage Commission

 State Office of Historic Preservation

 All property owners within 300 feet of the property boundary

City of Redding

Public Works Department, Engineering Division Mitigated Negative Declaration

Page 4 Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

April 2020

PUBLIC REVIEW

(X) Draft document referred for comments 03/05/2020–04/06/2020 Date

( ) No comments were received during the public review period.

( ) Comments were received but did not address the draft Mitigated Negative Declaration findings or the accuracy/completeness of the Initial Study. No response is necessary. The letters are attached.

(X) Comments addressing the findings of the draft Mitigated Negative Declaration and/or accuracy or completeness of the Initial Study were received during the public review period. The letters and responses follow (see Attachment D, Response to Comments).

Copies of the Mitigated Negative Declaration, the Initial Study, documentation materials, and the Mitigation Monitoring Program may be obtained at the Planning Division Public Works

Department, City of Redding, 777 Cypress Avenue, Redding, CA 96001. Contact: Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager, (530) 225-4046 or [email protected].

Date of

Draft Report: March 2, 2020 By:

Name/ Title: Amber Kelley

Environmental Compliance Manager Date of

Final Report April 20, 2020

Attachments:

A. Project Location Map B. Initial Study

C. Mitigation Monitoring and Environmental Commitment Program D. Comments and Response to Comments (if any)

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

Response to Public Comments Received on CEQA Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration, State Clearinghouse #2020039009

In accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), an Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (IS/MND) for the Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project was made available to the public and interested agencies for a minimum 30-day review period. The agency review period was managed by the State Clearinghouse (SCH) and closed on April 2, 2020. The public review period was managed by staff and closed on April 6, 2020. All written comments received during the public and agency review period are attached, along with written responses to environmental issues raised by commenters on the IS/MND. Comments received on the public draft IS/MND do not identify new significant impacts or significant new information that would require recirculation of the draft IS/MND pursuant to CEQA Guidelines Section 15073.5. This technical memorandum is being used to summarize comments and support adoption of the public draft IS/MND.

Response to Comments

In addition to confirmation from the State Clearinghouse that the 30-day posting requirement was met, a total of two comment letters were received regarding the IS/MND. The confirmation notice and comment letters are attached to this technical memorandum in the order indicated:

State Clearinghouse Compliance Notification (Letter A)

Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board (Letter B) California Department of Fish and Wildlife (Letter C)

1. Letter A confirms project compliance with the State Clearinghouse review requirements for draft environmental documents pursuant to CEQA. No response is needed for this letter.

2. Letter B was submitted by the Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board (CVRWCQB) and includes one comment related to the Clean Water Act Section 401.

Comment B1. Clean Water Act Section 401, Water Quality Certification

Response: Replacement of the Hollow Lane culvert will result in a discharge of fill material in jurisdictional waters (culvert and energy dissipation pad); therefore, the City of Redding will apply for a 401 Water Quality Certification and will file a report of waste discharge as required.

3. Letter C was submitted by the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) and

includes seven comments related to botanical surveys, vegetation communities, Western

pond turtle, bat surveys, Section 1602 permitting, and mitigation measures.

2

Comment C1 & C2. Botanical Surveys and Mitigation Measure-1:

Response: As reflected on page 13 of the Initial Study, the project study timing did not align with the limited blooming period for special status plant species (typically April through June); however, it is common practice to reduce project delays by assuming a potentially significant impact and incorporating mitigation to reduce the impact to a less than significant level. The potential need for an Incidental Take Permit is acknowledged on page 13 of the document. The City has reviewed Mitigation Measure-1 and determined that it will satisfactorily protect the species and does not require change.

Comment C3 & C4. Vegetation Communities and Compensatory Mitigation Measure:

While the vegetation community “type” is Freemont Cottonwood forest, there are very few trees within the project study area. Vegetation communities are determined by the type of vegetation species that are predominant, but the community type is not indicative of the quantity or quality of vegetation in the area. Page 15 (Migratory Birds and Raptors) indicates that the project will result in the removal of one large willow tree that is approximately 12-inches in diameter. The tree is located in a riparian/fresh emergent wetland area. No other large trees are anticipated to be impacted.

The project will have a very minor permanent impact on wetlands and waters. The project would not have “a substantial adverse effect on state or federally protected wetlands”, as indicated in on checklist section IV. Biological Resources (c); therefore, the impact is less than significant and does not require mitigation under CEQA. Opportunities to offset the loss of wetlands or waters will be addressed during the regulatory permitting process.

Comment C5. Western Pond Turtle and Mitigation Measure-3:

The high fidelity of the turtle is reflected in Mitigation Measure-3 where it is stated that if the species is observed, the California Department of Fish and Wildlife will be contacted and work within that area will be avoided until an appropriate course of action is established. The City has reviewed Mitigation Measure-3 and determined that it will satisfactorily protect the species and does not require change.

Comment C6. Bat Surveys and Mitigation Measure-4:

Mitigation Measure-4 will be changed to: incorporate trees with crevices and snags; extend

the non-volant preconstruction survey period to August 31

; and perform preconstruction

surveys 7 days prior to construction activities. The City requests information (published

scientific data and pilot studies) that demonstrates the benefit and effectiveness of

conducting hibernacula season pre-construction surveys, as well as information on how

this protocol is being applied consistently across the State by CDFW.

3

Comment C7. Lake and Streambed Alteration Agreement:

Response: Staff will coordinate with the CDFW and will submit a 1602 Lake and

Streambed Alteration Agreement Notification (LSAA).

From: Mikayla Vaba

To: Kelley, Amber

Subject: SCH#2020039009

Date: Friday, April 3, 2020 3:10:07 PM

CAUTION: This email originated from outside the City of Redding; please be careful with links or attachments.

The State Clearinghouse would like to inform you that our office will be transitioning from providing a hard copy of acknowledging the close of review period on your project to electronic mail system.

Please visit:

full details about your project and if any state agencies submitted comments by close of review period (note: any state agencies in bold, submitted comments and are available).

This email acknowledges that you have complied with the State Clearinghouse review requirements for draft environmental documents, pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act.

Please email the State Clearinghouse at [email protected] if you have any questions regarding the environmental review process. If you have a question about the above-named project, please refer to the ten-digit State Clearinghouse number when contacting this office.

Letter A

4/6/2020 Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

https://ceqanet.opr.ca.gov/2020039009/2 1/2

SCH Number Lead Agency Document Title Document Type Received Project Applicant Document Description

Contact Information

Cities Counties Cross Streets Zip Total Acres Parcel # State Highways Schools Waterways Township Range Section Base

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

Summary

2020039009

Redding, City of (City of Redding)

Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project MND - Mitigated Negative Declaration 3/4/2020

Residential and Open Space

The project would replace the existing Dry Creek culvert crossing beneath Hollow Lane,

approximately 0.4 miles west of Ridgewood Road in Redding, California, Shasta County. The two existing 60" corrugated metal pipes will be removed and replaced with one 5-foot tall by 15-foot wide aluminum arch pipe with a concrete bottom. The new culvert will include headwalls, wing walls, concrete aprons, scour repair, and a 20-foot rock energy dissipation pad at the outlet. The project also includes underground utility relocation and scour repair at the culvert location. Most work would occur within the City right of way; however, acquisitions and easements may be required. Tra ic control would be necessary to construct the project. It is anticipated that construction would take one season and is planned for 2021.

Amber Kelley City of Redding

777 Cypress Avenue Redding, CA 96001 Phone : (530) 225-4046

Location

Redding

Shasta

Hollow Lane and Ridgewood Road 96003

0.26

073180062 I-5, 273, 299

Shasta College & Simpson University Dry Creek, Churn Creek

32N 4W 17 7.5 min

Notice of Completion

4/6/2020 Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project

https://ceqanet.opr.ca.gov/2020039009/2 2/2

Review Period Start Review Period End Development Type Project Issues Reviewing Agencies

Environmental Document NOC State Comments

3/4/2020 4/2/2020

Other (Storm Drain Culvert)

Biological Resources Drainage/Absorption Vegetation Water Quality Wetland/Riparian Cumulative E ects California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection California Department of Parks and Recreation

California Department of Transportation, District 2 California Department of Water Resources

California Highway Patrol California Native American Heritage Commission California Natural Resources Agency California Regional Water Quality Control Board, Central Valley Redding Region 5 Central Valley Flood Protection Board O ice of Historic Preservation State Water Resources Control Board, Division of Drinking Water

California Department of Fish and Wildlife, Eureka Region 1

Attachments

NoticeofIntentNegativeDecl   NOC  

2020039009_CDFW Comment  

Disclaimer: The Governor’s O ice of Planning and Research (OPR) accepts no responsibility for the content or accessibility of these documents. To obtain an attachment in a di erent format, please contact the lead agency at the contact information listed above.

You may also contact the OPR via email at [email protected] or via phone at (916) 445-0613. For more information, please visit OPR’s Accessibility Site.

PDF 5130 K PDF 1375 K

PDF 424 K

Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board

19 March 2020 Amber Kelley

City of Redding Public Works Department 777 Cypress Avenue

Redding, CA 96001

COMMENTS ON THE INITIAL STUDY AND MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION FOR THE HOLLOW LANE CULVERT REPLACEMENT PROJECT, STATE

CLEARINGHOUSE NUMBER 2020039009, REDDING, SHASTA COUNTY

The Central Valley Regional Water Quality Control Board (Central Valley Water Board) is a responsible agency for this project, as defined by the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). On 6 March 2020, we received your request for comments on the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration for the Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project (Project).

The applicant proposes a culvert replacement project on Hollow Lane. The two existing corrugated metal pipes will be removed and replaced with one 5-foot tall by 15-foot wide aluminum arch pipe with a concrete bottom. The new culvert will include headwalls, wing walls, concrete aprons, and a 20-foot rock energy dissipation pad at the outlet.

Recent high-velocity storm water flows have created two large erosional scour holes at the outlet that form ponds during periods of inundation. These scour holes will be

repaired by filling the holes, constructing a 20-foot diameter rock energy dissipation pad, and regrading the creek channel bottom to direct positive downstream flow. The creek will be accessed on the northwest and southwest sides of the culvert. The sewer main, currently located under the existing culverts, will be replaced and protected with the concrete culvert bottom. The gas line and water main will be replaced within the roadway. The Project site is located on Hollow Lane at the Dry Creek crossing, approximately 0.4 mile west of Ridgewood Road.

Based on our review of the information submitted for the proposed project, we have the following comments:

Clean Water Act (CWA) Section 401, Water Quality Certification

The Central Valley Water Board has regulatory authority over wetlands and waterways under the Federal Clean Water Act (CWA) and the California Water Code, Division 7 (CWC). Discharge of dredged or fill material to waters of the United States requires a CWA Section 401 Water Quality Certification from the Central Valley Water Board.

Comment B1

Letter B

State of California – Natural Resources Agency GAVIN NEWSOM,Governor

DEPARTMENT OF FISH AND WILDLIFE CHARLTON H. BONHAM, Director Northern Region

601 Locust Street Redding, CA 96001 www.wildlife.ca.gov

Conserving California’s Wildlife Since 1870

March 30, 2020

Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager City of Redding

Public Works Department 777 Cypress Avenue Redding, CA 96001

Subject: Review of the Mitigated Negative Declaration for the Hollow Lane Culvert Replacement Project, State Clearinghouse Number 2020039009, City of Redding, Shasta County

Dear Amber:

The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (Department) has reviewed the Initial Study/Mitigated Negative Declaration (MND) dated March 2020, for the above-referenced project (Project). As a trustee for the State’s fish and wildlife resources, the Department has jurisdiction over the conservation, protection, and management of fish, wildlife, native plants, and their habitat. As a responsible agency, the Department administers the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) and other provisions of the Fish and Game Code that conserve the State’s fish and wildlife public trust resources. The Department offers the following comments and recommendations on this Project in our role as a trustee and responsible agency pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), California Public Resources Code section 21000 et seq.

Project Description

The Project as proposed “would consist of a culvert replacement project on Hollow Lane.”

Two existing 60-inch corrugated metal pipes will be removed and replaced with one 5-foot tall by 15-foot wide aluminum arch pipe with a concrete bottom. The replacement culvert will include “headwalls, wing walls, concrete aprons, and a 20-foot rock energy dissipation pad at the outlet.” The Project will occur primarily in the City’s right of way on Hollow Lane.

The Project proposes to commence work in 2021 and will require one season of construction.

Comments and Recommendations

The Department has the following comments and recommendations:

Botanical Surveys

Botanical surveys, as well as wildlife surveys, should have been conducted during the appropriate blooming time prior to the approval of this Project and not included as a mitigation measure. One of the special status plant species having the potential to occur onsite is Boggs Lake hedge-hyssop (Gratiola hetersepala), a CESA listed Endangered species. If this species is found during pre-construction, and cannot be avoided, an




 

Comment C1

Letter C

Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager March 30, 2020

Page 2

Incidental Take Permit would need to be obtained. This process could potentially take up to four months or longer to procure.

Mitigation Measure MM-1 should be changed to the following (in bold):

Prior to the start of construction, a focused botanical survey will be conducted by a qualified biologist, preferably a botanist, during the blooming period for potentially occurring plant species. Botanical surveys should follow California Department of Fish and Wildlife’s (CDFW) March 20, 2018, Protocols for Surveying and Evaluating Impacts to Special Status Native Plant Populations and Sensitive Natural Communities. Reference sites of all potentially occurring special status species shall be surveyed at the same time as the Project site to determine if the species is identifiable at the time surveys are conducted. If no special status plant species are found during the botanical survey no other measures will be required. If special status plant species are found during the botanical surveys, the plants will be marked by a qualified biologist familiar with the species. If the area can be avoided, exclusionary fencing will be placed around the plants and no

pedestrian or vehicular entry shall be allowed. If the area cannot be avoided, the City will coordinate with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to avoid, minimize, and mitigate impacts to the species. Potential measures for reducing project impacts on special status plants include limiting ground disturbance until annual plants have gone to seed, then stockpiling the topsoil during the initial excavation to be replaced as the tip layer during the final site rehabilitation. If State Listed species are found, an Incidental Take Permit may be needed if the species cannot be avoided. Botanical survey results shall be emailed to the CDFW at

[email protected] or mailed to CDFW, ATTN: CEQA, 601 Locust Street, Redding, California 96001.

Vegetation Communities

There is some indication within the MND that large trees, other than the large willow tree in Dry Creek, will be removed in order to replace the culverts. However, there is no

information provided on the number of large trees or the species. The MND explains that approximately 0.028 acre of riparian/fresh emergent wetland and 0.010 acre of perennial stream would be permanently impacted and approximately 0.008 acre of riparian/fresh emergent wetland would be temporarily impacted from the Project. No compensatory

mitigation was proposed to offset the permanent and temporary impacts of these vegetation communities, some of which are considered sensitive. The Department considers all

wetlands sensitive and the State has a “No Net Loss” wetland Policy. ¹

According to the Department’s Wetland Technical Memorandum³, numerous studies have shown that wetland mitigation projects often do not meet their required U.S. Army Corps of Engineers permit conditions. Along with the risk of mitigation

underperformance or failure, the temporal loss of wetland function from the time of impact to the time a mitigation site is fully functional is also a factor in potentially

diminishing the value of compensatory restored wetlands. Such temporal loss may vary depending on habitat type and other factors. For the above reasons, the Department

1 Fish and Game Commission Wetlands Resources Policy (Amended 8/18/05)

3 https://wildlife.ca.gov/Search-Results.aspx?q=Wetland%20Technical%20Memorandum




 

Comment C2

Comment C3

Comment C4

Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager March 30, 2020

Page 3

recommends that mitigation for the loss of wetlands and riparian habitat begin at 3:1 or greater.

The Department recommends compensatory mitigation at a 3:1 ratio for the 0.038 acre (total of 0.114 acre) of permanent riparian/fresh emergent wetland and perennial stream impacts and 2:1 ratio for the 0.008 acre (total of 0.016 acre) of temporary impacts to riparian/fresh emergent wetland. One large willow tree is proposed to be removed to accommodate placement of the energy dissipation pad. It is not clear if this one large willow is included in the 0.038 acre of permanent riparian/fresh emergent wetland. If not, additional mitigation will be necessary.

Western pond turtle (Emys marmorata)

The western pond turtle exhibits high site fidelity. If found, and then relocated, the likelihood of the pond turtle coming back into the construction zone is high. Therefore, the Department recommends that a qualified biological monitor be present in the construction areas if pond turtles are observed and then relocated. The construction area should be surveyed each morning prior to the start of construction.

Mitigation Measure MM-3 should be changed to the following:

A qualified biologist should conduct pre-construction surveys immediately prior to the start of any vegetation removal or in-water work. Surveys will occur each day that in-water work will occur unless exclusion measures are implemented to prevent occupation of the site by special-status species.

Any adult western pond turtles that are found during surveys shall be relocated to a safe location, by the qualified biologist, outside the work area and away from direct and indirect impacts. Surveys for foothill yellow- legged frog shall occur at the same time. If present, the frog shall be moved out of harm’s way as permitted by CDFW.

Bat Surveys

Mitigation Measure MM-4 should be changed to (in bold):

Removal of large trees with cavities, crevices, or snags shall occur before bat maternity colonies form (i.e., prior to March 1) or after young are volant (i.e., after August 31). If construction (including the removal of large trees) occurs during the bat non-volant season (March 1 through August 31) or during the hibernacula season (October 16 – February 28), a qualified bat biologist shall conduct a pre-construction survey of the study area to locate maternity colonies or hibernacula and identify measures to protect roosts from disturbance. The preconstruction survey will be performed no more than 7 days prior to the implementation of construction activities. If a maternity colony or hibernacula is located within or adjacent to the study area, a disturbance free buffer shall be established by a qualified bat biologist, in consultation with CDFW, to ensure the colony/roost is protected from project activities. No trees shall be removed or trimmed until the bat biologist has determined that a roost site is no longer active and no bats are present. Additional mitigation measures for bat species may be




 

Comment C6 Comment C5

Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager March 30, 2020

Page 4

recommended if special status species are found to be roosting within the study area.

Lake or Streambed Alteration Agreement

For any activity that will divert or obstruct the natural flow, or change the bed, channel, or bank (which includes associated riparian resources) of a river or stream, or use material from a streambed, the Department will require a Lake and Streambed Alteration (LSA) Notification, pursuant to section 1600 et seq. of the Fish and Game Code, from the applicant. Project activities, which would be subject to LSA Notification requirements, include construction of stormwater features that discharge on or over the streambank and modification of associated riparian resources growing on the bank. Issuance of an LSA Agreement is subject to CEQA. The Department, as a responsible agency under CEQA, will consider the CEQA document for the Project. The CEQA document should fully identify the potential impacts to the stream or riparian resources and provide adequate avoidance, mitigation, monitoring and reporting commitments for completion of the agreement. To obtain information about the LSA notification process, please access our website at https://www.wildlife.ca.gov/Conservation/LSA or to request a notification package, contact the Lake and Streambed Alteration Program at

(530) 225-2367.

If you have any questions, please contact Amy Henderson, Senior Environmental Scientist (Specialist), at (530) 225-2779, or by e-mail at [email protected].

Sincerely,

Curt Babcock

Habitat Conservation Program Manager

ec: Amber Kelley, Environmental Compliance Manager City of Redding

[email protected] State Clearinghouse

[email protected] Amy Henderson

California Department of Fish and Wildlife [email protected]




 

Comment C7