Physiological Performance of Common Bean Seeds Treated with Bioactivator with and without Moisture Restriction

(1)

http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/ajps.2014.526394

How to cite this paper: da Silva Almeida, A., Villela, F.A., Meneghello, G.E., Deuner, C., de Tunes, L.M., Zimmer, P.D. and Jauer, A. (2014) Physiological Performance of Common Bean Seeds Treated with Bioactivator with and without Moisture Restriction. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 5, 3769-3776. http://dx.doi.org/10.4236/ajps.2014.526394

Physiological Performance of Common Bean

Seeds Treated with Bioactivator with and

without Moisture Restriction

Andréia da Silva Almeida1*_{, Francisco Amaral Villela}1_{, Geri Eduardo Meneghello}1_,

Cristiane Deuner1_{, Lilian Madruga de Tunes}1_{, Paulo Dejalma Zimmer}1_{, Adilson Jauer}2 1_{PPG em Ciência e Tecnologia de Sementes, Universidade Federal de Pelotas, Pelotas, Brasil}

2_{Syngenta Crop Protection, Pelotas, Brasil}

Email: *_{[email protected]}

Received 30October 2014; revised 29November 2014; accepted 6December 2014

This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution International License (CC BY).

http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Abstract

The commonbean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is an important agricultural crop due to its nutritional properties. Insecticides and fungicides employed to control pests and diseases in the common bean may cause as yet unknown effects on the plant’s morphology and metabolism. Bioactivators are complex organic substances, capable of exerting modification upon growth patterns, plant DNA transcription, gene expression, metabolic enzymes and mineral nutrition. Thiamethoxam in-secticide has shown positive action on the enhancement of vigor expression, phytomass accretion and the promotion of deeper root systems. The aim of this work was to evaluate the effect of thia-methoxam on the physiological performance of common bean seeds. Seeds from cultivars Pérola and IAPAR Siriri were treated to thiamethoxam concentrations of 0, 100, 200, 300, 400 and 500 mL·kg−1_{seed. Physiological quality was measured through tests for germination value, first count,} cold test, accelerated aging and seedling shoot and root lengths, all undertaken in the presence and absence of moisture stress. Thiamethoxam stimulated the physiological performance of common bean seeds under moisture stress or in the absence of it, with levels varying according to cultivar and seed lot. The best physiological seed performance was obtained within the range of 200 mL·100kg−1_{seed to 400 mL·100kg}−1_seed.

Keywords

Phaseolus vulgaris L., Bioactivator, Seeds, Vigor

(2)

1. Introduction

The common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) is a plant belonging to the Fabaceae family, whose cropping is im-portant for human consumption due to its high protein content, as well as that of carbohydrates and minerals. Common bean cultivation is widespread throughout Brazilian territory and in many Latin American countries, where it is widely consumed with rice, which is rich in starch, thus providing a balanced diet for vast sectors of the population [1].

Management decisions for successful cropping involve, among other things, the relative uncertainty of pre-dicting weather extremes, which has been a major concern for agribusiness entrepreneurs. These entrepreneurs must have sufficient information to pursue management decisions with the necessary antecedence, which in some cases must be predicted months in advance [2]. Crop management involves, in most cases, the use of pes-ticides, insecticides and fungicides, which are assessed through their efficiency in the control of pests and dis-eases. Some, however, may have unknown effects on plant metabolism as well as cause alterations in plant morphology [3]. Research results indicate that certain insecticides such as carbofuran [4] and thiamethoxam [5]

can cause physiological and morphological changes in plants. Hormone regulators have received increasing at-tention, particularly in high-value crops, as cropping techniques continue to evolve. Bioactivators are complex organic substances which modify plant growth, and are able to act on plant DNA transcription, gene expression, membrane proteins, metabolic enzymes and mineral nutrition [6]. The insecticide thiamethoxam has shown positive effects through increased seed vigor expression, biomass accretion, increased photosynthetic rate and development of deeper roots [7].

Thiamethoxam is transported within the plant cell system, enhancing physiological reactions such as protein expression, which is responsible for defense mechanisms against plant stress. These stress-reducing mechanisms allow seedlings to deal better with an assortment of adverse conditions such as drought, low soil pH, high soil salinity, the presence of free radicals, high temperatures, toxic effects due to high levels of soil aluminum, and injuries caused by pests, wind, hail, virus attacks and nutrient deficiency. Thiamethoxam has also shown phyto-tonic effects, providing favorable conditions for faster initial development by enhancing the expression of seed-ling vigor. Increases in seed germination, vigor, productivity, leaf area, root depth and stand uniformity have been observed in soybeans by [8], resulting in faster establishment and growth rate. In turn, these higher growth rates could yield higher competitive ability for the plant against weeds, and favor the absorption of essential nu-trients present in the soil [7].

Plants treated with thiamethoxam show greater tolerance to stress factors and, can consequently develop more vigorously under suboptimal conditions, increasing the likelihood of plants achieving their productivity poten-tial.

Considering the need for further research regarding the effect of thiamethoxam and specifically its potential benefits on the treatment of common bean seeds, the present study aimed to evaluate the influence of thiameth-oxam on the physiological performance of seeds from this species when germinated under different levels of moisture restriction.

2. Material and Methods

The work was conducted at the Seed Testing Laboratory, Faculty of Agronomy Eliseu Maciel from the Federal University of Pelotas (UFPel), Pelotas, RS, Brazil. Seeds from two common bean cultivars, Pérola and IAPAR Siriri, were treated with a commercial product containing 35 g·L of thiamethoxama. Six doses were tested, ranging from zero to 5 mL of product per kg of seed, in increments of 1 mL, equivalent to zero up to a maxi-mum of 0.175 g a.i. per kg of seed.

The mixture of commercial product and moisture was applied to the seeds in plastic bags used as containers with the aid of a pipette, to ensure the application of the correct dosage according to the specific treatment. The volume of the mixture corresponded to that of 0.6 L per 100 kg of seeds. The levels of moisture deficit were zero restriction and −0.4 MPa, comprising a full factorial design with six doses of thiamethoxam combined with two levels of moisture stress.

(3)

Treatment effects were quantified through the following tests.

Germination: four replicates with four subsamples of 50 seeds per treatment were used. The seeds were placed on germitest paper rolls, moistened with distilled moisture at a ratio of 2.5 times the weight of the dry paper and kept in an incubator at a set temperature of 25˚C. The germination value readings were performed ac-cording to the Rules for Seed Testing [10], consisting of two counts conducted at five and eight days, respec-tively. The results were expressed as percentage of normal seedlings.

First germination count: performed on the fifth day after the paper rolls were placed in the germination chamber, it recorded the observed percentage of normal seedlings.

Cold germination: four replicates with four subsamples of 50 seeds per treatment were used. The seeds were placed on germitest paper rolls, moistened with distilled moisture at a ratio of 2.5 times the weight of the dry paper and kept in a refrigerator at a set temperature of 10˚C for seven days. After this, the germitest paper rolls were placed in the germination chamber set at 25˚C. The evaluations were performed according to the Rules for Seed Testing [10]. The count for normal seedlings was performed after five days in the germination chamber and the results expressed as percentage of normal seedlings.

Accelerated aging: this test was performed using plastic boxes, according to [11]. The seeds were distributed in a single layer on the inner screen, and the bottom filled with 40 mL of distilled moisture. All boxes were in-cubated at 42˚C for 72 hours. At the end of the aging period, the seeds were placed on germitest paper and fol-lowed the same procedure described for the germination test.

Seedling length: following the same procedure described previously for the germination test, rolls containing fifteen seeds each provided the seedlings necessary for this test. Ten samples of ten seedlings per treatment were collected after five days in the germination chamber. Shoot and root lengths were recorded, the total seedling length resulting from the addition of both, and the results expressed in centimeters per seedling.

A completely randomized 2 × 6 factorial design (levels of moisture stress × levels of thiamethoxam commer-cial product) with four replicates was established, the data collected as percentage values transformed ( x100) and treatment effects analyzed through polynomial regression.

3. Results and Discussion

Each common bean cultivar was tested through three seed lots. Due to the absence of differences between the two common bean cultivars (Pérola and IAPAR Siriri), data is presented only for cultivar Pérola. The germina-tion values fitted a regression equagermina-tion (Figure 1), with positive association to dose of thiamethoxam for the three lots, irrespective of the moisture stress level. The quadratic fit increased germination, peaking at the dose of 250 mL of product per 100 kg·seed−1, with slight variations between lots, after which germination decreased with increasing doses of the commercial product.

Across the three replicates (seed lots), the range for the increase in the germination values when seeds were not subjected to moisture stress was 16% to 27%, compared to the check treatment. When the common seed beans were exposed to moisture deficit, the range for the increase was 10% to 16% in the germination value. In-creases in the germination values due to treatment with thiamethoxam were also observed in soybean seeds [7], carrot seeds [12] and cottonseed [13].

Germination values for the first count fitted a quadratic response curve, regardless of the moisture stress level (Figure2(a); Figure2(b)). The positive association between thiamethoxam and germination values peaked at doses close to 260 mL·kg−1 seed of commercial product. According to [6], soybean seeds treated to thiameth-oxam accelerated germination by stimulating enzyme action, which in turn yielded faster emergence rates and higher establishment percentages. Similar results were described for carrot seeds [12] and rice [8].

When the thiamethoxam effect was measured under the cold test, increases in the percentage of normal seed-lings were observed for seeds across both moisture level treatments (Figure 3). This behavior was similar for the three lots and for Seed Lot 1, with the least vigor, a 27% germination value increase was recorded between the check treatment and those with thiamethoxam in the absence of moisture stress. For seeds germinated under moisture stress the difference was of 28 percentage points.

(4)

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1340x + 72.9}

R² = 81

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1124x + 84.9}

R² = 93

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0845x + 87}

R² =65.3 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

G er m in at io n ( %)

Doses of thiametoxan (mL.100 kg de seeds) Lote 1

Lote 2

Lote 3

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1344x + 69.66}

R² = 63.3

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1023x + 76.3}

R² = 68.4

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1110x + 76.6}

R² = 73.6 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

G er m in at io n( %)

Doses of thiametoxan (mL.100kg de seeds) Lote 1

Lote 2

Lote 3

[image:4.595.87.538.79.249.2]

(a) (b)

Figure 1. Germination (%) of seeds from three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to different doses of

thiameth-oxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1546x + 68.7}

R² = 78

y = -0.0003x2_{+ 0.1246x + 81.9}

R² = 89.6

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0976x + 85}

R² = 64 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Fi rs t g er m in at io n ( % )

Lote 2

Lote 3

y =- 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1243x + 70.7}

R² = 70.6

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1310x + 65.8}

R² = 67.7

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1099x + 74}

R² =73.5 50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Fi rs t g er m in at io n ( % )

Lote 2

Lote 3

[image:4.595.88.539.290.455.2]

(a) (b)

Figure 2. First germination count (%) of seeds from three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to different doses of

thiamethoxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1623x + 68.4} R² = 79.1

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1256x + 80.5} R² = 86.6

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0951x + 83.7} R² = 62.7

50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Co ld te st (% )

Lote 2

Lote 3 y = - 0.0002x_{R² = 71.2}2+ 0.1231x + 68

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1219x + 73.6} R² = 78.3

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1294x + 62.9} R² = 78.6

50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Co ld te st ( % )

Lote 2 Lote 3

(a) (b)

Figure 3.Cold test germination (%) of seeds from three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to different doses of

thiamethoxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

[image:4.595.89.539.489.659.2]

(5)

soybean seeds.

Seeds subjected to accelerated aging showed increases in germination levels to increasing levels of thiameth-oxam, regardless of the moisture stress treatments (Figure 4). The quadratic response curve for Seed Lot 3 was somewhat steeper than for the other two seed lots, with greater variations in the germination values. Repeating the trend observed in previous results of this work, the positive response between germination levels and thia-methoxam peaked at 200 - 300 mL commercial product per 100 kg−1 seed, decreasing thereafter for higher con-centrations of the commercial product.

The highest germination values for accelerated-aging treated seeds were obtained with doses equal to 200, 300 and 400 mL of commercial product per 100 kg·seed−1, for Seed Lots 1, 2 and 3, respectively, regardless of the moisture stress level applied.

Increases in the germination percentage values were observed for seeds from Lot 1 under both levels of moisture stress, with 27% increase for seeds on the check moisture stress treatment and of 28% when germi-nated under moisture stress conditions.

It was observed that germination of common bean seeds treated to thiamethoxam responded in a quadratic fashion (Figure 5), the best-fit model for all three seed lots. Total seedling length peaked at doses of 200 to 300 mL of commercial product per 100 kg·seed−1, according to the lot, after which a decrease occurred for higher doses of the commercial product.

For Seed Lot 3, the dose of 3 mL commercial product increased seedling length by up to 22 cm under no moisture stress and up to 18 cm for seedlings originated from seeds germinated under low moisture level,

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.1333x + 78.04} R² = 63

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1223x + 69} R² = 70.8

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1239x + 78.3} R² = 74.3

50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Ac ce le ra te d a gi ng (% )

Lote 2 Lote 3

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1615x + 68.7} R² = 78.6

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1267x + 81.4} R² = 86

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0951x + 84.7} R² = 62.7

50 60 70 80 90 100

0 100 200 300 400 500

Ac ce le ra te d a gi ng (% )

Lote 2

Lote 3

[image:5.595.90.537.326.491.2]

(a) (b)

Figure 4.Accelerated aging germination (%) of seeds from three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to different

doses of thiamethoxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

y = - 0.0004x2_{+ 0.1754x + 20.3} R² = 89

y = - 0.0001x2_{+ 0.0586x + 20.2} R² = 95.1

y = - 0.0004x2_{+ 0.1724x + 20.6} R² = 84.9

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40

0 100 200 300 400 500

Le ng gt h o f s ee dl in gs (c m )

Lote 2

Lote 3

y = - 0.0001x2_{+ 0.0661x + 18.2} R² = 98.7

y = -0.0004x2_{+ 0.1541x + 18} R² = 90.5

y = - 0.0004x2_{+ 0.1385x + 17.3} R² = 82.6

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35

0 100 200 300 400 500

Le ng th o f s ee dl in gs (c m )

Lote 2 Lote 3

(a) (b)

Figure 5.Total length (cm) of seedlings originating from the seeds of three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to

[image:5.595.90.537.526.695.2]

(6)

compared to the check treatment. The higher seedling length for treatments with thiamethoxam commercial product can be explained by assuming that it enhanced moisture absorption and stomatal resistance, thus im-proving the plant’s moisture balance and making the moisture deficit less severe [3]. Data by [14] in thiameth-oxam-treated soybean seeds showed enhanced root development that led to increased nutrient absorption, yield-ing a larger leaf area with positive effects on the expression of plant vigor.

The favorable effect of thiamethoxam on the increase of root length (Figure 6and Figure 7) in common bean seedlings has been observed previously by [6] in sugarcane and potatoes, in soybean by [15], in cotton by [13], in carrots by [12], and for rice by [16].

It is noteworthy that the increase in root length due to the thiamethoxam commercial product was higher for Seed Lots 1 and 2, of lower physiological quality than Seed Lot 3.

The shoot length of seedlings with and without moisture stress (Figure 8(a) and Figure 8(b), respectively) increased with increasing doses of the commercial product. In all three seed lots, shoot length showed an in-crease of at least 5 cm for untreated seeds in Lot 1 without stress, and of 3 cm for untreated seeds under moisture stress. The maximum shoot length increase for Seed Lot 2 was 3 cm and 10 cm, for seeds germinated with and without moisture stress, respectively. The highest responses were obtained for doses of 200 to 300 mL commer-cial product per 100 kg of seed, dependent on the seed lot and level of moisture stress during germination, the highest responses being for seeds under no moisture stress. The increase in shoot length due to different levels of thiamethoxam could eventually enhance stomatal resistance to moisture loss, according to [3], maintaining an active metabolism and increasing resistance to stress. Moreover, according to the same authors, efficiency under

y = - 7.9452-005_x2_{+ 0.0369x + 13.58} R² = 93.4

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0796x + 14.4} R² =75.2

y = -0.0002x2_{+ 0.0791x + 14.4} R² = 76.8

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

0 100 200 300 400 500

Ro

ot

le

ng

th

cm

)

Lote 2 Lote 3

y = - 6.6597-005_x2_{+ 0.0378x + 12.9} R² = 93.9

y = - 0.0003x2_{+ 0.1213x + 10} R² = 98.4

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0937x + 11.5} R² = 78.8

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

0 100 200 300 400 500

Ro

ot

le

ng

th

(c

m

)

Lote 2 Lote 3

[image:6.595.92.536.326.491.2]

(a) (b)

Figure 6.Root length (cm) of seedlings originated from seeds of three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to

dif-ferent doses of thiamethoxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

(a) (b)

Figure 7. Root length (cm) of seedlings originated from seeds of three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to

[image:6.595.88.535.527.692.2]

(7)

y = - 5.5250-005_x2_{+ 0.0340x + 5.03} R² = 94.6

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0963x + 5.9} R² = 96.1

y = - 0.0002x2_{+ 0.0856x + 5.9} R² = 92.3

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

0 100 200 300 400 500

Sh

oo

t l

en

gt

h (

cm

)

Doses de tiametoxam (mL/100 kg de sementes) Lote 1

Lote 2 Lote 3

y = - 6.5867-005_x2_{+ 0.0280x + 5.34}

R² = 0.9198 y = - 0.0001x2_{+ 0.0327x + 7.94}

R² = 57.3

y = - 0.0001x2_{+ 0.0430x + 6.1}

R² = 86.4 0

2 4 6 8 10 12 14

0 100 200 300 400 500

Sh

oo

t l

en

gt

h (

cm

)

Doses of thiametoxan (mL.100kg de sementes) Lote 1

Lote 2 Lote 3

[image:7.595.84.538.80.251.2]

(a) (b)

Figure 8.Shoot length (cm) of seedlings originating from seeds of three lots of common bean, cultivar Pérola, treated to

dif-ferent doses of thiamethoxam, under normal moisture conditions (a) and subjected to moisture stress (b).

field conditions could be improved for crops that show low germination, slow nutrient absorption and transpor-tation, and low assimilation rates.

The different parameters evaluated in seeds subjected or not to moisture stress showed the same trend, with maximum trait values for levels of thiamethoxam commercial product ranging between 200 to 300 mL·100kg−1 seed. This suggests that under stressful field conditions, the treatment of common bean seeds could ensure the expression of normal seedling development.

In short, thiamethoxam exerted a positive effect on seed germination potential, accelerating the growth of roots and increasing the plant nutrient uptake. When combined with the use of high quality seed, thiamethoxam can enhance a crop’s potential yield. The results for the different vigor tests assessed in this work, based on dif-ferent principles, yielded similar maximum values for the same trend across both moisture level treatments, with differences in the magnitude of the values dependent on the seed lots.

4. Conclusions

Thiamethoxam enhances the physiological performance of common bean seeds regardless of the moisture status at germination, to vary magnitudes depending on the seed lot and cultivar.

The recommended dosage ranges from 200 mL to 400 mL of commercial product per 100 kilogram of seed, corresponding to 0.07 g to 0.14 g a.i. thiamethoxam kg−1 seed of the common bean.

References

[1] Silva, J.C., Heldwein, A.B, Radons, S.Z., Maldaner, I.C., Trentin, G. and Grimm, E.L. (2011) Necessidade de irrigação para o feijoeiro na região central do Rio Grande do Sul. Revista Brasileira de Agrícola e Ambiental, 15,1030-1036. [2] lima, J.S.S., Martins-Filho, S., Lopes, J.C., Garcia, G.O. and Neto, R.S. (2002) Qualidade fisiológica de sementes de

feijão produzidas em solo compactado. Revista Brasileira de Sementes, 24, 111-117.

[3] Castro, P.R.C., Pitelli, A.M.C.M., Peres, L.E.P. and Aramaki, P.H. (2007) Análise da atividade reguladora de cresci- mento vegetal de tiametoxam através de biotestes. Publicatio UEPG (Ponta Grossa), 13, 25-29.

[4] Freitas, D.B., Bezerra, E.C. and Teixeira, N.T. (2001) Aldicarb e Carbofuran e teores de nutrientes na parte aérea de feijoeiro (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) cv. Carioca 80. Ecossistema, 26, 68-70.

[5] Calafiori, M.H. and Barbieri, A.A. (2001) Effects of Seed Treatment with Inseticide on the Germination, Nutrients, Nodulation, Yield and Pest Control in Bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) Culture. Ecossistema, Espírito Santo do Pinhal, 26, 97-104.

[6] Castro, P.R.C. and Pereira, M.A. (2008) Bioativadores na agricultura. In: Gazzoni, D.L., Ed., Tiametoxam: Uma

revolução na agricultura brasileira,Bogotá, Colômbia, 118-126.

(8)

Colômbia, 123-192.

[8] Clavijo, J. (2008) Tiametoxam: Um nuevo concepto em vigor y productividad. Bogotá, Colômbia, 196 p.

[9] Villela, F.A., Doni-Filho, L. and Sequeira, E.L. (1991) Tabela de potencial osmótico em função da concentração de polietileno glicol 6000 e da temperatura. Pesquisa Agropecuária Brasileira, Brasília, 26, 1957-1968.

[10] Brasil (2009) Ministério da Agricultura e da Reforma Agrária. In: Regras para análise de sementes, SNDA/DNDV/ CLAV, Brasília, 398 p.

[11] McDonald, J.R. and Phaneendranath, B.R. (1978) A Modified Accelerated Aging Vigor Test Procedure. Journal of

Seed Technology, Lansing, 3, 27-37.

[12] Almeida, A.S., Tillmann, M.A.A., Villela, F.A. and Pinho, M.S. (2009) Bioativador no desempenho fisiológico de sementes de cenoura. Revista Brasileira de Sementes, 31, 87-95. http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/S0101-31222009000300010 [13] Lauxen, L.R., Villela, F.A. and Soares, R.C. (2010) Desempenho fisiológico de sementes de algodão tratadas com

tiametoxam. Revista Brasileira de Sementes, Brasília, 32, 61-68.

[14] Tavares, S., Castro, P.R.C., Ribeiro, R.V. and Aramaki, P.H. (2008) Avaliação dos efeitos fisiológicos de tiametoxam no tratamento de sementes de soja. In: Gazzoni, D.L., Ed., Tiametoxam: Uma revolução na agricultura brasileira, Bogotá, Colômbia, 193-204.

[15] Tavares, S., Castro, P.R.C., Ribeiro, R.V. and Aramaki, P.H. (2007) Avaliação dos efeitos fisiológicos de tiametoxam no tratamento de sementes de soja. Revista de Agricultura (Piracicaba), 82, 47-54.

[16] Almeida, A.S., Carvalho, I., Deuner, C., Villela, F.A. and Tillmann, M.A.A. (2011) Bioativador no desempenho fisio- lógico de sementes de arroz (Oryza sativa L.). Revista Brasileira de Sementes, 33, 501-510.

(9)