• No results found

ADJUSTMENT OF VENTILATION, INTRAPULMONARY GAS EXCHANGE, AND ACID-BASE BALANCE DURING THE FIRST DAY OF LIFE

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2020

Share "ADJUSTMENT OF VENTILATION, INTRAPULMONARY GAS EXCHANGE, AND ACID-BASE BALANCE DURING THE FIRST DAY OF LIFE"

Copied!
14
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

ADJUSTMENT

OF VENTILATION,

INTRAPULMONARY

GAS

EXCHANGE,

AND

ACID-BASE

BALANCE

DURING

THE

FIRST

DAY

OF

LIFE

Normal

Values

in Well

Infants

of

Diabetic

Mothers

1. Samuel Prod’hom, Henry Levison, Ruth B. Cherry, James E. Drorbaugh,

John P. Hubbell, Jr., and Clement A. Smith

Department of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Children’s Hospital Medical Center,

and Boston Lying-in Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts

(Submitted August 1; accepted for publication November 21, 1963.)

Work supported by grants from the National Institutes of Arthritis and Metabolic Discases and

Neurological Diseases and Blindness, and the Association for the Aid of Crippled Children.

Dr. Prod’hom was a Fellow of the Acad#{233}mieSuisse des Sciences M#{233}dicales.

PRESENT ADDRESSES: (L.S.P.) Clinique infantile, H#{244}pital Cantonal, Lausanne, Switzerland; (H.L. Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto 2, Ontario, Canada. (R.B.C., J.E.D., J.P.l1., and C.A.S.) Boston

Lying-in Hospital, 221 Longwood Avenue, Boston 15, Massachusetts.

PEDIATRICS. May 1964

ARTICLES

682

T

HE etiology and pathogenesis of

hya-line membrane disease are still poorly understood.’ It is well known that the in-fant of the diabetic mother (1DM) is

par-ticularly susceptible, but the connection

be-tween the disease of the mother and the

high pulmonary morbidity of the neonate

is still a complete mystery.

An unselected series of IDM’s was

sys-tematically studied at 1, 4, and 24 hours of age in order to reveal and describe the

early phase of the respiratory distress

syn-drome in physiological terms. Cord blood

was also analyzed for information at age

0. Ventilation, gaseous metabolism, func-tional residual capacity, intrapulmonary gas

exchange (alveolar-arterial Po2 difference in room air and after 100% 0: breathing, arterial-alveolar Pco2 difference), and

acid-base balance were measured by the

tech-niques described by Nelson Ct al.2’ In

all, 30 IDM’s were studied. Three devel-oped respiratory distress and are described

with a series of distressed newborn infants

in a subsequent paper. Two others had

severe malformations. Of the remaining

25, the 20 delivered by section are the

sub-jects of this paper. The five born vaginally

are too small a group to be compared with these 20.

INFANTS

The most important clinical (lata are

given in Table I. These 20 IDM’s constitute

a reasonably uniform population of white infants, delivered by cesarean section

usu-ally with spinal anesthesia (Nos. 23, 25, and 34 after unsuccessful induction), 18 of them at 36-37 weeks, without any sign of fetal distress. Condition at birth was good ex-cept that Nos. 7, 11, 24, 34, and 36 had in-itial Apgar scores of 4 or 5. All recovered rapidly, to scores of & or above at 5

min-utes. No infant had clinical signs of

res-piratory distress, except for occasional iso-lated high rates of respiration (Table I),

not considered significant (see Comment).

METHODS

During the first 20 minutes of life a soft

polyvinyl feeding catheter (size No. 5

French) was placed in one of the umbilical arteries and left for 24 hours. Between studies the catheter was filled with heparin solution, diluted 1:10 with saline.

Umbilical cords were isolated between

two simultaneously applied clamps at birth

and blood was then removed from the

vein and artery with a 10 ml syringe, whose

(2)

Infant Sex vumoer

2 “SE

3 “51

5

7 M

8 M

9 F

11 M

12 “51

14 F

16 M

18 M

‘10 F

23 M

24 F

‘15 M

26 F

Birth

Class of Weight Diabetes3’

(kg)

2.72 F

3.52 F

3.09 1)

2.96 F

3.97 I)

2.48 D

3.29 B

2.84 B

3.66 D

3.42 1)

4.31 C

3.46 C

3.09 1)

3.09 D

2.99 D

2.48 1)

3.35 C

I) F

I)

Apgar Score Respiratory Rate*

Gest.

(nun) (age-hr)

Age _____________________________

_______

_1.

LL_L±J_

36 8 S 8 47 29 31

36 8 8 8 42 49 70

36 8 8 9 72 78 70

36 5 8 9 60 70 57

36 8 10 10 40 42 32

36 8 8 9 35 35 32

36 5 6 8 60 45 50

37 8 8 9 54 69 56

36 8 8 8 42 37 42

37 8 8 i 9 69 72 39

37 8 8 8 56 42 40

37 8 8 9 46 32 37

37 8 10 10 39 39 44

36 4 7 9 70 96

37 I 9 9 9 46 44 44

37 8 8 9 47 38 34

36 4 6 9 61 66 45

36 8 8 9 67 50 47

35 4 5 8 49 48 51

39 6 8 51 58

immediately before study.

X-Ray

negative

negative negative infilt.right lung negative negative hyperinfi. lungs negative negative negative negative negative negative negative negative negative fhyperinfl.

lungs-interst. markings

negative

fat 1hr: diffuse

granu-)larity;at24hr:normal

negative .11

35 ‘SE 3.94

36 M 2.27

48 iSI 2.72

* f counted while infant was in incubator or bassinet

TABLE I

CLINICAL DATA FOR 0 INFANTS OF DIABETIC MOTHERS

until analysis (in the next 30 minutes). All blood was similarly handled, except that 5

ml syringes were used in the collection of

2-3 ml of blood from the umbilical cathe-ter. The dilution of the blood by the

solu-tion filling the dead-space was taken into account for the final calculations of the results.

Expired gas was collected through a one-way ball valve in a spirometer. Alveolar

gas was obtained with a micro-modified

Rahn sampler. The complete open circuit

is described at length by Nelson et al.2

Functional residual capacity (FHC) was

determined with the classical open-circuit N2-washout method of Darling et al.,

modi-fied by Nelson and co-workers.

During each study the infant was

wrapped in a swaddling blanket, and at

the end of each study, the environmental

and rectal temperatures were measured by

thermocouple.

Protocol of Studies Subsequent to

Cord Blood Collection at 0 Time

1. 20 minutes: Sampling of arterial blood

(determinatien of blood gases, pH, CO2

content of plasma).

2. 1 hour (actual time: 1.46 ± .26 hours): (a) Simultaneous collection of expired and

alveolar gas and arterial blood during room-air breathing (measurement of ventilation, gaseous metabolism, alveolar-arterial Po2

and Pco2 differences, acid-base balance); (h) collection of expired gas during 100%

02 breathing (determination of FRC); (c)

hyperoxia-test (breathing of 100% 02 given

by funnel at a flow of over 8 L/min for

30 minutes), after which blood (1 ml) was again taken for determination of arterial

Po2 (measurement of true right to left

shunt).

3. 4 hours (actual time: 4.41 ± .25 hours):

as in (2) above.

(3)

lkr 4/jr 24k,

n mean SD range n mean SD range n mean SD range

f-breatha/min Vx-mi/min BTPS YE/Kg-mi/mm/Kg VT-mi BTPS VAtml/min BTPS VAanat/Kgml/mifl/Kg VDanatml BTPS VD,,/VT VAphysInl/mifl BTPS VAphy,/KgInh/min/Kg Vophy,ml BTPS VDphy,/VT Vo,-ml/min STPD Yo,/Kg-mi/min/Kg Vco,-mI/min STPD 02/Kg.m’,’mmn/7g both VO1L VAphy,/VO,11h1/mifl STPD FRC-ml BTPS FRC/Kg-ml/Kg VT/FRC 17 17 17 17 15 15 15 15 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 14 14 13 53 670 212 13.0 407 127 3.7 28 345 109 5.0 .37 21. 8.8 ‘19.51 0.92 13.8t 71 22.5 .20 12 171 40 2.9 110 27 1.4 .07 89 20 1.5 .10 6.1 1.5 5.0 1.3 0.13 3.4 4.0 .04 34-72 391-949 124-256 6. 6-18. 9

248-598 75-165 1.0-6.4 .15-44 206-465 67-146 1.9-7.6 .14-52 10.3-31.6 4.5-9. 1

10. 9-29. 1

3. 8-8.5 0. 74-1. 21

8.3-21.1 49-92 15.0-29.4 12-. 26 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 17 16 16 16 16 17 17 17 17 17 16 13 13 13 49 616 I 99 13.2 373 120 3.8 320 100 5.0 .39’ 17.7t 5.61 15.91 5.1’ 0.89 14.7 76 24.0 .20 17 160 44 3.0 76 24 1.3 .07 88 24 1.2 .09 3.8 1.0 3.6 1.0 0.09 2.6 30 9.5 .06 29-96 329-893 121-289 9. 1-17.8 235-490 82-164 1.9-6.5 .17-38 188-523 74-149 3.0-8.0 .27-52

9. 9-24 .3

4.0-8.0 8.4-22.7 3.7-6.7

0.79-1.10

10. 9-2 1. 0

39-140 14.3-46.8 .11-28 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 14 14 14 14 15 15 15 15 14 11 Ii 9 45 599 192 13.7 397 128 3.1 .221 372 118 3.71 .27’ 18.7 6.0 15.1’ 4.

0.821

16.31 77 24.4 .19 12 178 48 3.5 99 28 1.4 .08 106 30 1.7 .10 4.4 1.0 3.9 1.0 0.13 2.7 16 5.7 .06 29-70 327-1017 114-289 8. 9-19.8 241-606 86-181 1. 1-5.6 .11-59 23 -555 74-185 1.8-6.0 .16-41

10. 4-25. 0 4.2-8. 1

10.3-21.8

3.3-6.5 0. 61-1. 00

I I .3-20.0

52-110

13.2-32.3

.10-.28

TABLE II

VENTILATION, GASEOUS METABOLISM, AND FUNCrIONAL RESIDUAL CAPACITY

‘and t. P<.O1; , .05>P>.O1.

hours): as in (2) and (3) above.

From the nature of these investigations, it can be understood that in occasional in-fants one or more determinations were for

various reasons omitted. The number of

satisfactory studies of each parameter at

each age period is included in Tables II

and III.

Determinations

02 and CO2 concentrations in expired

and alveolar air were measured with the

0.5 ml Scholander gas analyzer. In some

cases CO2 concentration in the expired gas

was determined with a Beckman infrared

rapid CO2 analyzer (Spinco Model LB-i

Medical Gas Analyzer).

Po2 and Pco2 in blood were directly meas-ured in micro-cuvettes at a temperature

of 37#{176}C with Clark-type and Severinghaus-type electrodes (Instrumentation Labora-tory, Inc., Boston, Model 113 system). In

duplicate measurements the maximum

dif-ference for Po2 at low level was 3 mm and

at more than 200 mm, 20 mm; maximum

difference for Pco2, 2 mm. In some cases

Po2 and Pco2 were determined by

micro-modification6 of Riley’s bubble technique. The agreement between these two methods is good. CO2 content in plasma and oxygen capacity of whole blood were determined with the Kopp-Natelson Microgasometer (Model 600, Scientific Industries, Inc.).

Duplicate analysis within 0.2 mM/L was

required for CO2 content and within 0.3

volume % for 02 content.

The pH was determined directly at 37#{176}

C, at first with a glass-electrode (0.5 ml

whole blood) of the Model 113 system,

later with the Astrup-micro pH-electrode (Radiometer Type E5020 micro-electrode) connected to the Instrumentation Labora-tory’s Model 113 pH meter. Duplicate

anal-yses within .01 pH unit were required.

pH was also calculated from CO2 content and Pco2 by the Henderson-Hasselbalch

equation, assuming a pK’ factor of 6.093

(4)

co-NP =

* Standard symbols for respiratory variables used.’#{176}

efficient of CO2 in plasma at 37#{176}C of .5i34. The average difference between

cal-culated and actually determined pH in 150

different blood samples was .01 with a

maximum difference of .06. The pH values

presented are the calculated ones; the

actual determinations were used only as

checks.

Calculations

All gas volumes are given in BTPS with

the exception of oxygen consumption, CO2

production, and ventilation equivalent which are in STPD.

The raw data of respiratory rate (f),

minute volume (7)* and 02 and CO2

con-centration in inspired, expired, and alveolar air were used for the calculation of anatomic dead space (VDanat) , anatomic alveolar venti-lation (VAanat) , oxygen consumption (Vo2), and CO2 production (jTco2). Physiologic dead-space (VD0hy,) and physiologic alveolar ventilation (VAph,) were calculated by re-placing the fractional CO2 concentration of alveolar (end-tidal) gas (FAC02) by arterial Fao2, or Pao2/(PB-47).

These different volumes have been inter-related below as follows:

VD/VT = dead space-tidalvolume ratio

co2/Vo2 = respiratory quotient (RQ) or

respiratory exchange ratio (R)

VA/V02 = ventilation equivalent (in this

case, physiologic alveolar ven-tilation, VAPLYS, was used as

VA).

FRC was calculated in the usual way.

Tidal volume and alveolar tidal volume were

related to FRC (VT/FRC and VT-VD/FRC).

The (A-a)Po2 gradient in room air was ex-pressed as venous admixture (VA), by use of the classical shunt formula:

Sc’-Sa

___--Sc’-S

and by the 02 hemoglobin dissociation curve for fetal blood.” In all cases alveolar

Po2 (PA02) was calculated from the alveolar gas formula:

/ 1-Fi02

PAeffo2 = Pi0. - Pao2

(

Fi02+

-R

The true right to left shunt (s/T) was

calculated, according to Berggren,’2 from data obtained during the hyperoxia-test:

Qs/QT =

(PA02 - Pa02) X .00302

(PA02-Pa02) X .00302+CapO2Xav Sat.diff. in which .00302 is the solubility factor for 02 in plasma at 370 C. The oxygen-binding

capacity for whole blood (CapO2) was

ac-tually determined after equilibrating the

blood with room air during 20 minutes.

An arterial-venous saturation difference

(a Sat.diff.) of 0.15 is assumed from the

work of Rudolph and his associates.’3

Julian’s formula’4 was used to express per-centage of alveoli which are ventilated but not perfused (NP):

Paco2 - PACO2

Paco2 - PACO2+PECO2

This fraction, like those for VA and true

shunt above, was converted to a #{231}ercentage by appropriate multiplication.

Finally, in an attempt to quantitate the degree of metabolic acidosis, the amounts of nonvolatile acid

(

= fixed acid) were deter-mined by plotting CO2 content and Paco2 On

a modified Davenport-diagram (see below).”

RESULTS

The results in Tables II and III are best presented under separate headings.t

t Original data used for these tables have been de-posited as Document number 7881 with the ADI Auxili-ary Publications Project, Photoduplication Service, Library of Congress, Washington ‘15, D.C. A copy may be secured by citing the Document number and by re-mitting $1.25 for photoprints, or $1.25 for 35 mm microfilm. Advance payment is required. Make checks

(5)

TABLE

Po2 AND Pco GRADIENTS

Umbilical Vein Umbilical Arlay 20 mm

n mean SD range n mean SD range vi mean SD ranye

Body temprature-’C -

-5-24 - --16 16 I 6 16 .59 97 38 33 17 11 13 16 29-94 78-113 13-37 7-72 Pao,in room air-mmHg

PAeo,_mm Hg (A#{176}.a)Po,-mm Hg VA-% 18 -25 -. -4 -17-31 -17 . -15 -6

-Pao, in 100% 0,-mm JIg

(A#{176}-a)Po,-mm Hg ,/T-%

--

- - -

-Faco, at 37’C-mm hg

Paco, at body temp-mm Hg

PAco,atbodytemp.-mmllg

(a-A) Pco, at body temp. -mmHg NP-% 15 -46 -6 -36-60 -15 -58

-9 -44-81 -16 -47 -8 -35-66 -C0,plasma-mM/L pH-ealculated-atS7#{176}C pH-ealculated-atbodytemp. FixedAcid-wM/L 20 15 -20 24.1 7.31 1.2 3.0 0.09 5. 17.8-28.7 7.08-7.46 -7.5--’I2.7 19 15 19 26.4 7.24 1.! ‘2.5 0.09 4.7 21.2-29.1 6.99-7.26

--4.3-*13.6

16 21.9 , 3.2

16 , 7.26 1 0.09

- -

-16 1.5 5.0

17.4-16.7

7.11-7.39

-2.5--’12.3

‘andt,P<.Ol; I..05>P>.01.

Ventilation (Table II)

No change was found in minute volume

(YE and YE/Kg), in tidal volume (VT),

anatomic dead-space (VDanat), and anatomic

alveolar ventilation (VAanat and VAan,t/Kg),

during the first day of life. Physiologic

alveo-lar ventilation (TA9h, and TA,,/Kg)

showed a slight, but statistically not signifi-cant, increase during the same time, whereas

VDPbYS/VT ratio decreased significantly

be-tween 4 and 24 hours (t=3.4, P<0.01). At 24 hours of life anatomic and physiologic

dead-space, and therefore also anatomic and physiologic alveolar ventilation, were in the same range.

Gaseous Metabolism (Table II)

Oxygen consumption (o2/Kg) fell from

6.8 ml/min/Kg at 1 hour to 5.6 ml/min/Kg

(t = 2.5, P = .02) at 4 hours and 6.0

mi/mm/Kg at 24 hours. These values agree well with the 6.7 ml/min/Kg of Nelson’s

nonIDM’s2 and with the 6.2 ml/min/Kg

oh-tamed in Karlberg’s’6 very careful investi-gation with rigorous control of the body

temperature. The observed decrease in 02

consumption could be related to a change in environmental or body temperature.

[low-ever, there are no significant changes in

eu-vironmental temperatures at 1, 4, and 24

hours (21.6±2.3#{176}C, 22.0± 1.9#{176}C and 22.3

± 2.0#{176}C, respectively) and, although the

body temperature of these IDM’s was low

(35.2±0.6#{176}C) at 1 hour, it (lid not change between 1 and 4 hours (35.5 ± 0.9#{176}C)as the

02 consumption decreased. Thus, the

(Ic-crease in \02 does not appear to be related to these tenhl)eratures. CO2 l)rodUetiOI1

(

\‘co2/Kg) decreased significantly froiui 6.2

nil/nun/Kg at 1 hour to 5.1 iiil/miii/Kg at

4 hours (t=2.8, P<.01) and 4.9 mi/mm/Kg

at 24 hours (t=3.2, P<.005).

With these changes in 02 consumption and

CO2 production, the respiratory exchange

ratio (RE), based on expired gas sample, fell

from 92 ± .13 at 1 hour to .82 ± .13 at 24

hours (t=2.3, P=.02), in agreement with

observations of others. 7

The ventilation equivalent (VA9b,/ \“02,

(6)

1hr 4 hr

n mean SD

24 hr

range n mean SD ranga

‘5 20 17 17 17 20 20 20 18 13 13 ‘3 13 18 18 18 20 mean 35.2 61’ 9.5. 36 368 299 22 461 42’ 4 11 23.2 7.27’ 7.311 f2.3’ SD 0.6 12 14 90 90 6 9 8 7 10 3. 1 0.08 0.08 4.5 37.1 71 107* 36 20 0.5 10 7 9 7 range

34. 0-36. 0

36-86 6(1-115 18-67 12-60 222-523 140-452 11-29 34-69 37-63 3 1-58

- 4-.9 0-28

17. 6-30.6 7.02 7.39 7. 08-7. 41 -3.5--.14.9 1.5 ‘9 16 16 16 17 ‘7 16 12 12 12 12 16 16 14 18 35.5 72’ l01 29 386 285 21 140’ 37 3 24.7 7.35* 17.37’ -1. Ot 0.9 10 7 13 10 97 92 3 6 14 2.1 0.05 0.01 2. 9

33. 3-37. 0

46-93 84-118 12-55 8-46 157-5 13 160-478 13 30 37-56 35-48 26-46 -5--’ll 0-35 20.4-27.8 7.27-7.42 7.31-7.45 -5. 9-4.5 5 ‘4 ‘4 14 ‘4 13 13 13 ‘5 14 14 ‘4 14 15 14 15 35.6-37.8 55-88 9,-I’S I7-51 9-34 304-483 197-374 I 7-32 49-Il 29-11 25-39 -4--’13 0-42

20. 5-26. 8 7.34-7.49

7. 33-7.49

-5 .0-’3. 6

388 56 289 56 24 4 36’ 3 36’ 3 133’ 3 3 5 II 12 23.8 1.7 7.43’ 0.04 7.43* 0.04 -2.0’ 2.2

AND ACID-BASE BALANCE

equivalent at 1 hour of age was 13.8 ± 3.4

and rose to 14.7±2.6 at 4 hours and 16.5

± 2.7 at 24 hours (t, between 1 and 24 hours,

=2.4, P= .02).

Functional Residual Capacity (Table II)

The average FRC/Kg varied between

22.5 ± 4.0 inl/Kg and 24.4 ± 5.7 ml/Kg,

values which are in agreement with the first

24-hour data in tWo j)apers on nonIDM’s: Klaus et al.,’8 means between 21.3 and 26.3

obtained by plethysmography, and Geubelle

et a!.,” iiiean of 27.7 by helium (lilUtiOll. Nelson et al.’ obtained a mean of 40.6 ± 13.1

by plethysmography in nonll)M’s of 10-day average age. The absence of statistically

sig-nificant change in FRC and FRC/Kg be

tween 1, 4, and 24 hours of life is also in agreement with Geubelle et al.’9 and Klaus et al.2#{176}

To evaluate FRC in its physiologic

con-text, this volume may be usefully correlated

with VT or with alveolar-tidal volume

(VT-VD0h38). The V’r/FRC ratio in adults is 0.21, and-as reported by Karlberg21-in

nonIDM’s, 0.18; the VT-VDh,/FRC is 0.13

in adults and in the nonIDM. These ratios are in the same range for the IDI’l : VT/FRC

being 0.20 and VT-VD/FRC 0.14 without

changes from 1 to 24 hours.

Alveolar-arterial P02 Difference (Table Ill)

Arterial Po2 in room air increased from

59± 17mm Hg at 20 minutes to 61 ± 15 at I

hour, and to 72±10 at 4 hours (t=2.6,

.02>P>.OI), and remained at 71 ± 10 at

24 hours. At 20 minutes and 1 hour, the

values were in the same range as those of Oliver’s22 cesarean-section i ufan ts.

The niean Pao2 values in the 1DM

throughout the first 24 hours were not

systematically (hiferent from nonIDM re-suits4’ 23, 24 The alveolar-arterial Po2

dif-ference varied from 38 mm Hg at 20

minutes to 29 at 4 hours and 36 at 24 hours, but the calculated venous admixture (virtual plus true right to left shunt) fell from 33%

at 20 minutes and 31% at 1 hour, to 20 at

both 4 and 24 hours (t, between 1 and 4

hours, =2.6, .02>P>.01).

The mean Pao2 after 30 minutes of 100%

(7)

at 4, and 388 at 24 hours. The calculated true right to left shunt of 22% at 1 hour remained

essentially unchanged at 4 and 24 hours. Nelson et al.4 have demonstrated that the larger (A-a)Po2 gradient of the newborn as compared to the adult is mainly due to an over-all true right to left shunt whose exact localization cannot be defined by the

deter-minations used. Although certain assump-tions were necessarily involved, calculations

from the current study suggest a similar con-elusion. At 4 and 24 hours, at least, the venous admixture in room air had essentially the same value as that in 100% 02. In the latter environment the (A-a)Po2 difference

due to diffusion impairment and uneven

ventilation/perfusion ratio disappears so that the remaining (A-a)Po2 gradient will be due entirely to a true right to left shunt. The significant difference between venous

admixture and true right to left shunt

(t=2.5, .02>P>.01) at 1 hour indicates some degree of virtual shunting in the lungs, probably from uneven ventilation/perfusion ratio. Between I and 4 hours the fine adjust-ment between alveolar ventilation (A) and

pulmonary blood flow (Qc) appears to have been completed.

Arterial-alveolar Pco2 Difference (Table Ill)

Mean arterial Pco2 remained between 47

and 49 mm Hg at 20 minutes and 1 hour of

life. It fell to 44 at 4 hours (t=2.0, P=.05),

and between 4 and 24 hours to 36 (t = 5.4, P<.001). Except for that at 24 hours, these values are higher than the age-equivalent values reported by Weisbrot et al.,2’ Reardon

et aL,24 or Oliver et al.2’ All the foregoing

figures are adjusted for a body temperature

of 37#{176}C. If mean Pco2 is converted for the actual body temperature at sampling, by the

factors of Severinghaus,’6 the actual Pco,

becomes reduced (significantly) to 46 mm

Hg at 1 hour, 40 at 4 hours, and is unchanged

at 24 hours when body temperatures were

37#{176}C. Even with this correction the 1 and 4 hour values are significantly higher than those reported by Reardon.

The mean alveolar (end-tidal) Pco, simi-larly decreased from 42 mm Hg at 1 hour to 33 at 24 hours. Since the assumption that

end-tidal gas is representative of mixed al-veolar gas in adults has been found also valid in newborn infants,3 an (a-A)Pco, difference will reflect the presence of alveolar dead-space. Iii this series of IDM’s the locals (a-A)Pco, gradient, at body temperature,

was 4±4 mm hg at 1 hour, 3±5 ‘ii” hg

at 4 hours, and 3±5 inni Hg at 24 hours. Statistically there is no difference at any tiiiic between Paco2 and PAco2. The calculated dif-ferences are of the same order of magnitude

as the (a-A)Pco, difference of 1 .8 ± 3.8 inns

Hg obtained by Nelson et al.’ in a series of well nonIDM’s and IDI%I’s. From these data

it can reasonably be concluded that no sig-n ificasig-nt (a-A)Pco, difference is detectable during the first day of extrauterine life. Ad-justment of perfusion of the capillaries to alveolar ventilation is adequate.

Acid-base Balance (Table Ill)

Despite the many reported

detern1ina-tions, exact measurement of acid-base

bal-ance during the newborn period is not en-tirely satisfactory. The biology of fetal and neonatal blood is still not well known. Weisbrot et al.” and Reardon et al.’4 assuiiied

that the Singer-Hastings diagram can be

used without introducing too many errors.

For several reasons we cannot agree, and

prefer, with Oliver,” a modified Davenport”

diagram with two assumptions. Until the

buffer line of neonatal blood is knowii, it must be assumed that the slope of the line for adult blood can be used.” At 24 hours of age

the blood has a pH of 7.40, a Pco, of 35, and

a plasma CO, content of 22.5 inM/L. For

this reason, it is assumed that the line niay be drawn through this point, and the acid-base balance estimated from a diagram thus modified.

Table III indicates, in umbilical veiti

blood, an average pH (at 37#{176}C)of 7.31, Pco, of 46, CO2 content in plasnsa of 24.1

mM/L, and fixed acid of 1.2 mM/L.

Cor-responding averages for umbilical artery

blood were: pH, 7.24; Pco,, 58 iiiiii Hg; CO,

content in plasma, 26.4 muM 1; and fixed

acid, 1.1 mM/L. Both umbilical vein and

artery blood thus reflect acidosis, mainly

(8)

Hg

40

35

30

rM/L 70 65 60 55 50

700 7.10 720 730

pH at 37CC

74#{212} 750

FIG. 1. Adjustment of acid-base balance in new-born infants without respiratory distress during

the first 24 hours after birth.

Time:

O Birth (umbilical artery)

#{149}5-10 minutes

El 20 minutes

z 1 hour

x 4 hours

+ 24 hours

KEY

Infants: Of diabetic

moth-ers; cesarean. (Pres-ent study)

Of

nondiabeticmoth-ers; vaginal.22’ .

-

-

Ofnondiabeticmoth-ers; ccsarean.22

The values are in agreement with those of

nonIDM’s,2427’28 although not with the other published data on IDM’s.28 29 Unlike those

figures, only 3 of the 20 IDM’s here reported had an important metabolic acidosis

(non-volatile acid: 13.6, 7.9, 6.4 mM/L). The

reason for the more “normal” values in this

series is not known. The mean pH reported

for a temperature of 37#{176}Cwas relatively low at 1 hour (7.27) and at 4 hours (7.35), but adjusted to the body temperature of the in-fant became 7.31 and 7.37 respectively. These values are well within the range of

those reported in normal infants by Weis-brot,2’ Oliver,” and Reardon.’4

The Paco2 at 1 and 4 hours indicates per-sistence of some respiratory acidosis, but less netabolic acidosis than in infants of

lion-diabetic mothers (Fig. 1). At 24 hours, there

is a stage of respiratory alkalosis. No data

from other laboratories could be found for

comparison except those for capillary blood of 7 IDM’s without respiratory distress re-ported by Lowry.’#{176} For those 7 infants our calculations indicate average pH and Pco2 at 4 hours of 7.36 and 40, and at 24 hours, 7.38 and 35, lying entirely within the range ob-served here.

COMMENT

The high incidence of respiratory distress

syndrome and hyaline membrane disease in

IDM’s is well known.3’ For this reason the

adjustment of ventilation, gaseous

metabo-lism, FRC, intrapulmonary gas exchange, or

acid-base balance during the first day of

extrauterine life might have been expected

to behave differently in such an infant as

compared to the infant of a nondiabetic

mother. No fundamental difference has been found to characterize the adaptation of these functions in the 1DM’s. This statement needs brief discussion under several headings.

1. VOLUMES: Compared on a body-weight basis there is no significant difference

be-tween the VT, VD, YE, and VA of these

IDM’s and the 24-hour data of Nelson et at.’

from infants of nondiabetic mothers. 2. CHANGES IN R: Oxygen consumptioii

related to body weight is in the same range as in the nonlDM’s. The decrease in

respira-(S)

(L) ‘#{176}

tory gas exchange ratio (R) is also that ex-pected. A widespread of values in R can be due to change in ventilation or to changes in metabolism. Only in the steady state is R

equal to RQ. From theventilation equivalent

(

\TAh/VO,) and R, one can easily evaluate

R as a function of VA/Vo, (Fig. 2). As cx-pected, there is a good relationship between

these two ratios. Thus, for a ventilation

equivalent of 16, there is a highly significant

decrease in R from 1.0 at 1 hour to 0.8 at

24 hours (t = 8.5 ;P < .001). This change must represent altered metabolism, and it is in-teresting to see that abnormally low and

ah-normally high values of R are related to

hypoventilation and hyperventilation, re-spectively.

As found by Nelson,2 the drop in R is ac-cornplished by a highly significant fall in CO2 production with a steady 02 consumption

between 1 and 24 hours. On the other hand,

Cross’7 observed a rise in 02 consumption with steady CO2 production in the first day of life. This difference may well be related to

(9)

oh-Li

1.10

.80

.60 .70

.60

4 hr

24 hr

Ihr-o

r..79

a 4hr.x

r 81

24 hr - a

r.79

fo, (both 60tumes STPD)

Fic. 2. Relation of respiratory gas exchange ratio (R) to ventilation equivalent (V.sPh}$/V2) at 1, 4.

and 24 hours.

Regression lines: 1 hr, R = .487 .032

“yr .06; 4 hr, R = .452 + .029 V/V9, ay =

.07; 24 hr, R = .125 + .042 V./V9, ayx .06. Significance: At V.%I)hyS/Vo 16 nornial ventilation, R changes significantly: between 1 and 4 hr, P < .01; between 4 and 24 hr, P <

.001; between 1 and 24 hr, P < .001.

The widespread of R during the first day of life is due not only to changes in ventilation but also to metabolic changes.

served in this study was almost completed at 4 hours of age, when Cross was just

be-ginning his determinations. Fromii his

regres-sion line, R at 24 hours should be 0.77 which is not too far from the 0.82 of Table II. Further studies of ventilation and gaseous metabolism in very early life are needed.

3. HYPERVENTILATION

(?)

AT 24 Houns:

At 24 hours, the low arterial Pco2 usually

found is commonly thought24” to result from

hyperventilation. This should be reflected in a high ventilation equivalent. In these

in-fants at 24 hours, the ventilation equivalent

was 16.5 (normal for young adults) when

arterial Pco2 was 36 mm Hg. As postulated by Nelson et al.,2 this result rules out hyper-ventilation, though no other reason for the low Paco2 is immediately apparent. Possibly the threshold of excitability of the respira-tory center is “set” for an in utero biological

“milieu int#{233}rieur” different from that of

I hr adult life.

4. RAPIDITY OF ADJUSTMENT OF

INTRAPUL-MONARY GAS EXCHANGE: With Karlberg’s

first-breath analysis’4’ it becamiie evident that

the inflation of the lung is rapidly achieved.

The determinations of FRC by Geubelle

et at.,’9 Klaus et al.,’8 and in this series have

confirmed this finding. Analyses of the (us-tribution of ventilation4” have also demon-strated how complete is the adjustment of ventilation during the first and second day

of life. As an indication of intrapulmonary

2c2 2zc gas exchange, Graham 23 found a relatively

low value of 74 mm Jig for arterial Po, on

the first day comnj)ared to 95 in adults. He

postulated pulmonary shun ting through

ateleetatic lung areas. Nelson et al.4”7 have more directly evaluated the gas exchange in the lungs of normal newborn infants by

con-sidering diffusion, distribution, and shunt as the three components leading to reduced Pa02. The conclusion was reached that, after

the age of 12-24 hours, the observed

(A-a) Po2 difference was entirely due to a

true right to left shunt. The exact

localiza-tion of this shunt is still a matter of

specu-lation.

With this same method of analysis at 1

hour after birth the results from these infants of diabetic mothers indicate a larger venous

admixture in room air than could he

ac-counted for by true right to left shunt. The difference (virtual shunt) is (Ille to imbalance between alveolar i-en tilation and pulmonar’

capillary blood flow (A,/’Qc less than

normal).

The larger part of the (A-a) Po, difference, however, is due to true right to left shunt

(approximately 20-25% of total cardiac

output) which does not change during the

first day of life. It is unlikely that this shunt

is larger in IDM’s thami in infants of normal

mothers; the arterial Po, (in room air) and

(A-a) Po2 difference are essentially the sante

in 1)0th groups.4”3”4 In no,ihi)M’s, venti-lation is ideally tlistr,buted.4 In nonhl)M’s and IDM’s, the diffusion capacity of the lung

(10)

Infants Whose

f= .() or

VE/Kg 240±34(4)* 186±40(13)* 0.05

VT/Kg

o/Kg

\Ai3,/\o3

3,3±0.5(4)

95,0±16.0(4)

5.6±0.6(4) 14.1 ± 1. (4)

4.5±0.6(18)

10-2±27(1)

5.7±1.(13) 14.9±3.0 (li)

.93 0.45

0.13 0.54

0.01 <0.70

0.90 0.60

0.48±0.04(1) 0.36±0.O9(1) .50 0.0

l’aco. (temp. 370C) 46±4 6) 4±5 (10) 1.40 0.O

1)11 calc 7.34±0.04(6) 7.34±0.05(10) 0.5 0.80

* Figure in( ) indicates number of infants so studied at 4 hours.

5. HYPOVENTILATION AT 1 AND 4 Houns:

The arterial Pco2 of these infants of diabetic

mothers is high at 1 and 4 hours; both

Reardon’4 and Oliver” reported lower values

from full-term babies, whereas those reported here are prematures of 36-37 weeks

gesta-tion. Identical studies with premature babies of 36-37 weeks gestational age horn also by

cesarean section are necessary to evaluate the effect of prematurity or of cesarean see-tion in the genesis of this slight CO2 reten-tion. At 24 hours the arterial Pco, is in the

range of the nonIDM.

6. SIGNIFICANCE OF RESPIRATORY RATE

OVER 60: Rates can be measured without

complicated instruments. sIiller’8 in

non-IDM’s and Haddad’9 in I1)M’s have

con-eluded that rate indicates presemiceor absence of respiratory distress, an(l Gellis and IIsia3’

reported a respiratory rate exceeding 60 per

minute in 55% of 172 infants of diabetic

mothers. Nevertheless, the assillliption that disturbance of respiratory rate necessarily means lung disease is not always right. Since

YE VTf an increase in minute volume is

often associated ith an increase in f alone, but a normal minute volume may occur with

a high f providing VT is correspondingly de-creased. For a given alveolar ventilation the optimum respiratory frequency is usually

that at which work4#{176}or average force of the respiratory muscles4’ will be minimal. Cook4’

has found this rule to explain the relatively

high respiratory rate associated with the

particular mechanical properties of the lung

ill the newborn period.

Six of the 17 IDM’s studied at 4 hours had

a respiratory frequency higher than 60.

Several parameters were analyzed separately in these 6 infants and compared with those of the others with respiratory rates of 60 or

less. The results are summarized in Table IV. It appears quite clearly that the most

im-j)Ortaflt difference is the size of the tidal

volume per unit of body weight (P= .01). To keep alveolar ventilation normal,

respira-tory frequency is increased. As the frequency of breathing rises, there is an increase in

physiologic dead-space, so that the

organ-ismn must still further increase minute volume to obtain adequate alveolar ventilation. In fact, there are no significant differences in

VA/Kg, VA/VO,, and Paco,. The observed

change in VDh8/VT ratio is that expected. I1)I1’s who breathed at a rate over 60 (with-out other clinical signs of respiratory distress) miiay rej)reseflt only the upper extreme of a

population with average f= 49 with 2 S.I).

± 17=34. A “normal” limit of f=60 may he

not only statistically but clinically erroneous. The reason for change in VT is not yet

known. 1)isturbance of some physical

prop-erty of the lungs may be shown by further

studies of compliance and resistance. Fromii

the reported data, a high respiratory

fre-uency alone is not believed to establish the clinical diagnosis of respiratory distress

syndrome.

TABLE IV

EFFECT OF RESPIRATORY FREQVENCY

Signfieance of Difference

between Means

(11)

SUMMARY

Determinations of blood gases and of

acid-base balance were done in umbilical vein and artery blood at birth and in arterial blood at the age of 0 minutes in 0 infants of diabetic

mothers. All were born by cesarean section,

18 of them between 36 and 37 weeks

gesta-tion. None showed respiratory distress at any time.

Ventilation, gaseous metabolism ,

func-tional residual capacity, intrapulmonary gas exchange, and acid-base balance were deter-mined at the age of 1, 4, and 24 hours in these

o

infants.

The results indicate the following conclu-sions with regard to infants of diabetic

mothers.

1. Adjustment of ventilation to

per-fusion in the lung appears to be complete at

4 hours of life.

2. Throughout the first 24 hours there is

a persistence of an over-all true right to left shunt of approximately 0-25% of the total cardiac output. The exact localization of this shunt is unknown.

3. Acid-base balance in cord blood and in

arterial blood during the first day of life in

infants of diabetic mothers differs only slightly from that of infants of nondiabetic

mothers. At 1 and 4 hours of age there is some persistence of a slight respiratory acidosis.

4. At 24 hours infants of diabetic mothers have the usual low arterial Pco2 of other

new-born infants, but a ventilation equivalent of 16.5, which is normal for adults.

5. Although 6 of the 17 infants studied at

4 hours have shown a respiratory rate above

60 without other signs of respiratory distress, these infants with high rates had small tidal

volumes, high physiologic dead-space/tidal

volume ratios, and relatively little increase

in minute volume. It is suggested that such

rates in some otherwise well infants of dia-betic mothers are probably at or near the

extreme upper values in a population whose

average rate is slightly higher than that of a normal population.

6. It seems reasonable to assume that the

infant of a diabetic mother has much the

same adjustment of ventilation, gaseous metabolism, functional residual capacity,

intrapulmonary gas exchange, and acid-base balance as does the infant of a nondiabetic

mother.

REFERENCES

1. Driscoll, S. C., and Smith, C. A. : Neonatal

pulmonary disorders. Pediat. Clin. N. Amer.,

9:325, 1962.

2. Nelson, N. M., et al.: Pulmonary function in

the newborn infant. I. Methods : ventilation

and gaseous metabolism. PFrnAmIcs, 30:

963, 1962.

3. Nelson, N. M., et al.: Pulmonary function in

the newborn infant. II. Perfusion-estima-tion by analysis of the arterial-alveolar

car-hon dioxide difference. PEDIATRICS, 30:975, 1962.

4. Nelson, N. M., et al.: Pulmonary function in

the newborn infant: the alveolar-arterial oxygen gradient. J. Appl. Physiol., 18:534,

1963.

5. Nelson, N. M., et al.: Pulmonary function

in the newborn infant. V. Trapped gas in

the normal infant’s lung. J. Clin. Invest., 42:

1850, 1963.

6. Bates, G. D., and Oliver, T. K., Jr. : A micro-modification of the bubble method for the direct determination of blood gas tensions.

J. Appi. Physiol., 17:743, 1962.

7. Riley, R. L., Campbell, E. J. M., and Shepard, R. H. : A bubble method for estimation of

PC02 and P02 in whole blood. J. AppI. Physiol., 11 :245, 1957.

8. Severinghaus, J. W., Stupfel, M., and Bradley,

A. F. : Variations of serum carbonic acid

pK’ with pH and temperature. J. AppI.

Physiol., 9: 197, 1956.

9. Bartels, H., and Wrbitzky, R.: Bestimmung

des C02-Absorptionskoeffizienten zwischen

15 und 38#{176}C in Wasser und Plasma.

Pflugers Arch. ges. Physiol., 271 : 162, 1960.

10. Pappenheimer, J. R., et al.: Standardization of definitions and symbols in respiratory phys-lology. Fed. Proc., 9:602, 1950.

11. Nelson, N. M., et al.: A further extension of the “in vivo” oxygen-dissociation curve for

the blood of the neonate. J. Clin. Invest. (in press).

12. Berggren, S. M.: O deficit of arterial blood caused by non-ventilating parts of the lung.

Acta Physiol. Scand., 4:Suppl. 11, 1942.

13. Rudolph, A. M., et at.: Studies on the

circula-tion in the neonatal period. The circulation

in the respiratory distress syndrome.

PEru-ATRICS, 27:551, 1961.

(12)

ARTICLES

occlusion upon end-tidal CO2 tension. J.

App!. Physiol., 15:87, 1960.

15. Davenport, H. W. : The ABC of Acid-Base

Chemistry. Chicago: University of Chicago

Press, 1958.

16. Karlberg, P., Moore, R. E., and Oliver, T. K.,

Jr.: The thermogenic response of the

new-born infant to noradrenaline. Acta Paed.,

51:284, 1962.

17. Cross, K. W., Tizard, J. P. M., and Trythall,

D. A. H. : The gaseous metabolism of the

newborn infant. Acta Paed., 46:265, 1957. 18. Klaus, M., et a!.: Lung volume in the newborn

infant. Pinmmics, 30:111, 1962.

19. Ceubelle, F., et at.: L’a#{233}ration du poumon chez le nouveau-ne. Biol. Neonat., 1:169,

1959.

20. Klaus, M., et a!.: Functional residual capacity in newborn infants measured by a rapid physical method. Amer. J. Dis. Child., 100: 482, 1960.

21. Karlberg, P. : The lung function. In Die

Physio-logische Entwicldung des Kindes.

Vorlesun-gen #{252}berFunktionelle Padologie, edited by Friedrich Linneweh. Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 1959, pp. 85-96.

22. Oliver, T. K., Jr., Demis, J. A., and Bates, G. D.: Serial blood-gas tensions and

acid-base balance during the first hour of life in human infants. Acta Paed., 50:346, 1961. 23. Graham, B. D. : Polarographic Studies of 02

Tension in Newborn Infants. Adaptation to

Extrauterine Life. 31st Ross Conference on Pediatric Research, Ross Laboratories, Co-lumbus, Ohio, 1959, pp. 57-59.

24. Reardon, H. S., Baumann, M. L., and Haddad, E. J.: Chemical stimuli of respiration in

the early neonatal period. J. Pediat., 57:151,

1960.

25. Weisbrot, I. M., et a!.: Acid-base horneostasis

of the newborn infant during the first 24 hours of life. J. Pediat., 52:395, 1958. 26. Severinghaus, J. W., and Stupfel, M.:

Alveo-lar dead space as an index of distribution of blood flow in pulmonary capillaries. J. App!. Physiol., 10:335, 1957.

27. James, L. S., et a!.: The acid-base status of human infants in relation to birth asphyxia and the onset of respiration. J. Pediat., 52: 379, 1958.

28. Kaiser, I. H., and Goodlin, R. C.: Alterations

of pH, gases and hemoglobin in blood and

electrolytes in plasma of fetuses of diabetic

mothers. Pznwrmcs, 22: 1097, 1958.

29. Segal, S., et a!.: Determination of pH, CO2 content, 02 saturation, and lactate in the blood of the newborn infants of diabetic

mothers. Amer. J. Dis. Child., 94:562, 1957

(Abstract).

30. Lowrey, C. H., Graham, B. D., and Tsao,

M. U. : Chemical homeostasis in the new-born infants of diabetic mothers. Prnmics,

13:527, 1954.

31. Gellis, S. S., and Hsia, D. Y. : The infant of

the diabetic mother. Amer. J. Dis. Child..

97:1, 1959.

32. Cook, C. D., et at.: Studies of respiratory

phys-iology in the newborn infant. I.

Observa-tions on normal premature and full-term infants. J. Clin. Invest., 34:975, 1955. 33. Tooley, W. H., et al.: The distribution of

yen-tilation in normal newborn infants. Amer. J. Dis. Child., 100:731, 1960 (Abstract). 34. Smith, C. A.: Physiology of the Newborn

In-fant. Springfield, Illinois : Charles C Thomas,

1959, p. 210.

35. Stahlman, M. : Ventilation control in the

new-born: carbon dioxide tension and output. Amer. J. Dis. Child., 101:216, 1961. 36. Karlberg, P. : Breathing and its control in

pre-mature infants. Physiology of Prematurity.

Macy Foundation Conference, 1957, edited

by J. T. Lanman, New York City.

37. Nelson, N. M., et a!.: Pulmonary function in

the newborn infant. Diffusion: Estimation

of direct Di2 by the Bohr-integration

tech-mque (in preparation).

38. Miller, H. C., and Conklin, E. V. : Clinical evaluation of respiratory insufficiency in newborn infants. PEDIATRICS, 16:427, 1955.

39. Haddad, H. M., Hsia, D. Y., and Gellis, S. S.:

Studies on respiratory rate in the newborn. Its use in the evaluation of respiratory

dis-tress in infants of diabetic mothers. Pmu-ATRICS, 17:204, 1956.

40. Otis, A. B., Fenn, W. 0., and Rahn, H.: Me-chanics of breathing in man. J. Appl.

Physiol., 2:592, 1950.

41. Mead, J.: Control of respiratory frequency. J.

Appi. Physiol., 15:325, 1960.

42. Cook, C. 1)., et a!.: Studies of respiratory

physiology in the newborn infant. III. Measurements of mechanics of respiration.

(13)

1964;33;682

Pediatrics

Hubbell, Jr. and Clement A. Smith

L. Samuel Prod'hom, Henry Levison, Ruth B. Cherry, James E. Drorbaugh, John P.

in Well Infants of Diabetic Mothers

AND ACID-BASE BALANCE DURING THE FIRST DAY OF LIFE: Normal Values

ADJUSTMENT OF VENTILATION, INTRAPULMONARY GAS EXCHANGE,

Services

Updated Information &

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/33/5/682

including high resolution figures, can be found at:

Permissions & Licensing

http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xhtml

entirety can be found online at:

Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or in its

Reprints

http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml

(14)

1964;33;682

Pediatrics

Hubbell, Jr. and Clement A. Smith

L. Samuel Prod'hom, Henry Levison, Ruth B. Cherry, James E. Drorbaugh, John P.

in Well Infants of Diabetic Mothers

AND ACID-BASE BALANCE DURING THE FIRST DAY OF LIFE: Normal Values

ADJUSTMENT OF VENTILATION, INTRAPULMONARY GAS EXCHANGE,

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/33/5/682

the World Wide Web at:

The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on

American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 1073-0397.

References

Related documents

For each non- decimated as well as decimated realization discrete-time Fourier series coeff cient values, located at Nyquist frequency are calculated, using speedy recursive

of the Web graph and new algorithmic techniques to achieve a very high compression ratio, while still retaining a good access speed (but it could be better). ◮ Our software is

In this section, I will describe my methods for moving from a homogenous group of incident reports (e.g. patient safety incidents involving vulnerable children) to a plan (a

Develop modern transport with reasonable cost, safety, minimize environmental impact and save energy; Application of advanced transportation technology,

Given shock formation(s) within a jet, cosmic particles are accelerated by stochastically crossing the shock discontinu- ity as they diffuse in the turbulent magnetic field, which

The subject of this article is the role of freehold land and property in the developing commercial economy of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. As we will

As preterm infants are at risk of extra uterine growth restriction, early and optimal parenteral nutrition is essential in neonatal intensive care units.. Careful and

Ac- cording the Invitrogen brochure SYBR ® Safe is “specifically developed for reduced mutagenic- ity, making it safer than ethidium bromide.” 15 SYBR ® Safe