Linux Collaboration Solution to
Replace Microsoft Office
John D.: Sally R.: John D.: Sally R.: John D. Sally R.
Instant
Messaging
E-Mail/
Calendar
E-Meeting
Teamroom
Document
Management
E-Learning
Client
Client
Client
Client
Server
Client
Server
Server
Server
Client
Server
Server
Standalone, poor integration, expensive to deploy and maintain
Standalone, some integration, expensive to deploy and maintain
John D.: Sally R.: John D.: Sally R.: John D. Sally R.Instant
Messaging
E-Mail/
Calendar
E-Meeting
Teamroom
Document
Management
E-Learning
Windows
Messenger
Office
Live
Comm.
Server
Outlook
Windows
Messenger
Exchange
Office
Live
Meeting
Nothing
to offer
Microsoft Collaboration Solutions
Office
2003
Office
2003
Windows
SharePoint
Services
SharePoint
Services/
Portal
What should a Collaboration Solution Provide?
Server runs on any platform to provide choice and flexibility
Client runs on Windows or Linux
Microsoft Office does NOT run on Linux
Richer user experience with disconnected support to increase user
productivity
Integration across all functions
Messaging, Personal Productivity, Document Management
Low TCO
Common programming environment between client and server so
that developers are more productive
Built-in data management and security features
Lotus Workplace: An Integrated Collaboration
Platform
John D.: Sally R.: John D.: Sally R.: John D. Sally R.Instant
Messaging
E-Mail/
Calendar
E-Meeting
Teamroom
Document
Management
E-Learning
Runs on Linux
All collaborative functions written as J2EE-based services!
Linux Server
IBM Workplace Family
Rich Client Browser Client
WebSphere Portal Server
Family of personal productivity and collaboration functions implemented in J2EE on
the server and delivered via a portal to the browser or a rich client
Linux Server
John D.: Sally R.: John D.: Sally R.: John D. Sally R.WebSphere Application Server (J2EE)
Windows/ Linux
Windows/ Linux
IBM Workplace Client Technology Benefits
Multi-platform support increases flexibility and choice
Richer user experience with disconnected support
increases user productivity
No-touch deployment helps lower TCO
Common programming environment (J2EE) between
client and server makes developers more productive
Built-in data management and security features
Local and server-managed encrypted data stores with
synchronization
Specific Capabilities include
Personal Productivity
Email and Calendar
Lotus
Workplace
Server
Server Datastore
How the Lotus Workplace Client Works
Browser
Request rich
client code
Data
synchronization
and application
updates
Lotus Workplace
Rich Client
One-time
client code
download
(Windows or Linux)IBM Workplace Client Technology
Managed Client UtilitiesPortal
Server
Server Desktop Laptop Cell Phone PDAServer OS
Device OS
Replication Local Application Server (J2EE) LocalDatabase Provisioning Agent
• User Experience framework • Windowing
• Component Interaction mechanism
Eclipse 3.0 Foundation
Client-Side
User
Experiences
Replication/ Synchronization Dynamic client provisioningCompact,
Lightweight
Middleware
Stack for the
Client
Windows, Linux, MacOS (future)
Multi-platform
• Messaging • Documents • OthersLotus
Workplace
Custom/
ISV
Industry/
Cross-Industry
…
Server
Managed
Deployment
Windows 2000 Pro
Desktops with Internet
Explorer Browser
Exchange
5.5
Outlook
Existing Windows NT
Servers
Office 2000
John D.: Sally R.: John D.: Sally R.: John D. Sally R.IBM Workplace Platform
?
New Microsoft Collaboration
Platform
Existing ODI Collaboration Environment
John D.:
Sally R.:
John D.:
Sally R.:
12
Internet Explorer Browser (5.5, 6.0)
Exchange
2003
Outlook
$699/server $67/user
Server Upgrade Costs:
Client Upgrade Costs:
E-Mail, Calendaring and Scheduling
(Exchange Std) (Exchange CAL)
Active
Directory
Existing Windows 2000 Server
The “New” Microsoft Collaboration Platform is
Expensive!
13
Windows
ShareP
oint
Services
SQL
Server
Active
Directory
Office
ShareP
oint
Portal
Exchange
2003
Outlook
Office 2003
Windows Server 2003
$699/server $0/server $3,999/server $754/server $799/server $67/user $329/user $72/user $147/user $40/userServer Upgrade Costs:
Client Upgrade Costs:
Add Teamroom & Portal
(Exchange Std) (WSS) (SP Portal) (SQL Server Std) (W2K3 Server) (Exchange CAL) (Office 2003 Pro) (SP Portal) (SQL Svr CAL) (W2K3 CAL)
“Microsoft
recommended”
Required
for WSS,
SP
Internet Explorer Browser (5.5, 6.0)
The “New” Microsoft Collaboration Platform is
Expensive!
14
Office Live
Meeting
(hosted)
Windows
Messenger
Windows
ShareP
oint
Services
SQL
Server
Active
Directory
Office
ShareP
oint
Portal
Office Live
Communications
Windows XP
Exchange
2003
Outlook
Office 2003
Windows Server 2003
$699/server $0/server $3,999/server $754/server $799/server $733/server $67/user $329/user $72/user $147/user $40/user $25/user $199/userServer Upgrade Costs:
Client Upgrade Costs:
Add Instant Messaging, e-Meetings
Needs WinXP for A/V support (Exchange Std) (WSS) (SP Portal) (SQL Server Std) (W2K3 Server) (Live Comm Svr) (Exchange CAL) (Office 2003 Pro) (SP Portal) (SQL Svr CAL) (W2K3 CAL) (Live Comm CAL) (Win XP Pro)
$732/user
(up to 4-way only)
$6,984/server
$75/user
per
month
The “New” Microsoft Collaboration Platform is
Expensive!
15
Lotus
Workplace
Messaging
2.0
DB2
(included)Workplace
Rich Client
Server License Costs:
Per User License Costs:
included included included $29/user $89/user
WebSphere Portal Server
(limited use license included)
AD or
LDAP
Directory
Team Collaboration
Lotus Workplace
2.0
$118/user
$0/server
E-Mail, C&S, Teamrooms, Portal, IM, e-Meetings
(LW Messaging) (LW Team Collab) (DB2 included) (LW Messaging) (LW Team Collab)
IBM Workplace is a Bargain By Comparison!
WebSphere Application Server
(limited use license included)
Browser UI
(Internet Explorer, Mozilla browsers)
and/
or
$1,196,226*
$236,000
2000 users
$611,226*
$118,000
1000 users
$318,726*
$59,000
500 users
$172,476*
$29,500
250 users
$84,726*
$11,800
100 users
Microsoft
“Piece Parts”
Lotus Workplace
(Messaging + Team
Collaboration)
Per user pricing of SQL Server gives way to per CPU pricing, unlimited users ($4,999/CPU) above 25 users * - assumes that all Microsoft components can run on a single 4-way server and handle user volume as stated;