A b
st
r a ct
C
op p
e r a nd Z i
n cS
al
t
s a sE
s ch
e ri
ch i
a c ol i A
nt
ag
o ni
st
si
nW
at
e rA b
h
i
n a vS
.R
.K
om
a nd
u rW
at
e rb
or
n ei
l l
n e s si
s o ne o
f
t
h
e
w
o rl d
' sm
o st
p
e rv
a si
v ec a
us
e s of m
o rb
i
d
i
t
y
an
d m
o rt
al i
t
y
,w
i
t
h
s e v e r eh
e al
t
h
, s o ci
al
, e n vi
r o nm
e nt
al
a nd
e c o n om
i
ci
m p
a c
t
.H
um
a nf
a e c e s a r e of
t
e n e x c r et
ed i
n s u ch
af
a sh
i
o n a st
o c o nt
am
i
n at
e c om m
u ni
t
y
w
at
e r s up p
l
i
e s
.F
r eq
u e nt
l
y
,d
i
a r rh
o e al
i
l l
n e s s es a
l
s oi
nd
u c ed
eh
y
d
r at
i
o n , r e s ul
t i
ng
i
n
i
n c r e a s ed
co
n s um p
t i
o n of w
a t
e r a nd
a r e s ul
t
a nt
d
e c r e a s ei
n a c c e s st
o a n al
r e ad
y
-sc
a r ce
r e s o u r c e.S
u st
ai
n ab l
e c om m
u ni
t
y
w
at
e r a c c e s s, e sp
e ci
al l y
i
n c o nt
e xt
sw h
e r ew
a t e r
i
s s c
a rc e
,c a
nt
h
e r ef
o re o
f
t
e n n ot
b
e ac
h
i
e
v ed
, a nd
ad
v
e r s e e nv
i
ro
nm
e nt
al
i
m
p
a ct
s st
em m
i
ng f
r om
f
a e c al
c o nt
am
i
n at
i
o n of w
at
e r c a u se
d b
y i
m
p
ro
p
e rw
a st
ed i
sp
o s al
c a n of
t
e n n ot
b
e ad
eq
u at
el
y
m
i
t
i
g
at e
d
.M
et
al
s ,p
a rt
i
c ul
a rl
y
c op p
e r a nd
zi
n c ,h
a v eb
e e np
r op
o s ed
a s ef
f
e ct
i
v e a nt
i
-m
i
c r ob i
al
ag
e nt
si
n aq
u e o u s s ol
ut
i
o n s.W
e r et
h
i
st
ob
et
h
e c a s e,m
an
y
of
t
h
e r e s ul
t
a nt
ad
v e r s e o ut
c om
e si
nd
u c ed b
y
h
i
g h
p
re
va
l
e
n c e of
w
at
e rb
o
r n ed i
a
r rh
o e al
i
l l
n e ss
co
ul d
b
e
m
i t i
g
at
e
d
o r e nt
i
r e
l y
p
r e v e nt
ed
.T
h
i
s r e s e a r ch
ai
m
ed
t
oq
u a nt
i
fy
t
h
e o v e r al l d
i
si
nf
e ct
i
ng
ef f
e ct
s of
c op p
e r a nd
zi
n c ,i
nt
h
ei
o ni
cf
o rm
, a sw
el l
a st
h
ek
i
n et i
c s of
s u ch d
i
si
nf
e ct i
o n o nE
s ch
e ri
ch
i
a c ol
i
.E
xp
e ri
m
e nt
sw
e r e c o nd
u ct
ed
i
n r o om
-t
em p
e r at
u r ew
at
e r(
v a ry
i
ng
b
et
w
e e n1 8
a nd
2 3
d
eg
r e e sC
e nt
i
g
r ad
e)
b
uff
e r ed
t
o ap
H
of
7
.2
.I
t
w
a sf
o u nd
t
h
at
c op p
e
r a nd
zi
n c s al
t
si
n a c o ns
um
a
b l
ed
o
s ag
e r e su
l
t
i
n a r ed
u ct i
o ni
n c ul
t
i
v ab l
e
£
c ol
i
o nt
h
e o rd
e r of
ap p
r o xi
m
at
el
y 1 0
^ af
t
e r ap
e ri
od
of
ap
p
r o xi
m
at
el
y
6 h
o u r s,w
i
t
h
si
g
ni
f
i
c a nt
d
i
si
nf
e ct
i
o nb
ei
ng
ob
s
e r v ed
af
t
e r a sl
i t
t
l
et
i
m
e a s2
0 m
i
n ut
e s.A
ck
n
ow
l
ed
g
em
e nt
sT
h
ew
o rk
of
t
h
i
st
h
e si
sw
o ul d h
a v eb
e
e n ut t
e rl
y i
m
p
o s si
b l
et
of
i
ni
sh w
i
t
h
o ut t
h
e v a st q
u a nt
i
t
i
e s of
p
at i
e n c e a nd f
o rb
e a r a n c e sh
ow
nt
om
eb y m
y
l
o ng
-s uf f
e ri
ng
p
a re
nt
s,w
i
t
h
o ut
w h
o s el
o v e a nd
c a r e(
i
t
g
o e sw
i
t
h
o ut
s ay i
ng
]
I
w
o ul d
c u r r e nt
l
y
b
e a st
r e et
u r ch i
n .I
nk
i
nd
,I
m
u st
g
r at
ef
ul l
y
t
h
a nk
D
rM
a
rk
D
.S
ob
s
ey
,D
rP h
i
l l
i p C
.S i
ng
e r,D
rL
o u
i
s
eM
.B
a
l l
,D
r
J
i l l R
.S
t
e
w
a rt
, a nd p
a rt i
c
ul
a rl y D
rL
a n ak i l
a
"K
u "M
c
M
ah
a nf
o rt
h
ei
r
d
i
sp l
a
y
o
f
e nd
u ra n
ce
a nd f
o
rt i t
ud
ei
n
g
ui
d
i
ng
t
h
i
sp
ai
n
f
ul l y
i
m m
at
u r ew
o
rk
t
o c om
p l
et
i
o n .F
u rt
h
e rp
r o st
r at
i
o n s a r e ow
ed
t
ot
h
eg
o rg
e o u sl
ad
i
e s a nd h
a nd
so
m
eg
e nt
l
em
e nt
h
at
m
ad
e up t
h
el
ab
t
e a
m
t
h
at
p
e rf
o rm
ed
, am
o ng m
a ny
ot
h
e r a ct i
vi t i
e s,t
h
e
w
o rk
d
e sc
ri
b
ed h
e r ei
n .M
y
h
u
g
s a nd k
i
s s e st
o(
i
n a n o rd
e
rp
u re
l y
al p h
ab
et
i
c al
)
:A l y
s o nM
.M
al
o n e ,A
nd
r ew
M
.A
rm
st
r o ng
,C
r ai
g
S
h
a v e r,E
m
i
l
y
S
.B
ai
l
e
y
,J
o si
ah
I
r vi
n,K
at
h l
e e nG
.R
ot
h w
el l
,K
el l
y
M
.M i
t
ch
el l
,L
uk
eW
.W
o od
c o ck
,M
a ry
C
o op
e r,M
eh
ri
nI
sl
am
,M
i
ch
a el
C
l
e a r,N i
k
i
t
aJ
at
h
a n,P
r a s a nt
L
ok
i
ne
nd
i
,S
a r aC
.S
t
ep
h
a n o, a nd
T
u ck
e rW
i t
s
i l
.S
o r ry f
o
ry
o u r al w
ay
sb
e
i
ng l
a st
T
u ck
e r,b
ut
r e st
a s s
u r ed y
o u a r ec
e rt
ai
nl y
N
OT l
a st
i
nm
y
h
e a rt
.T
a
b l
e o
f C
o
n
t
e
n
t
s
I
.I N T R O D U C T I O N
2
I I
.E
X P E R I
M
E
N T A
L D
E S
I
GN
3
I I I
.L
I T E R A T U R E R E V I E
W
. . .6
I V
.M
A T E R IA L
S A
N D P
R O C
E D
U
R E
9
V
.R E SU L T S
1 4
V
L
I
N
T
E R P R E T A
T I
O
N
2 6
V I L
D I
S CU SS
I
O
N
2 8
V I I I
.S U
M M
A R Y O F F I N D I N G S
3
2
I X
.F U T
U
R E R E
S
E A R
C
H
. . . . .. . .3
2
X
.R E F E R E N C E S
. . .3 4
X L
A P P
E
N D I CE S
. .. . . . . .!
3 6
I
nt
rod
uct i
o nT h
ed
i
s e a s eb
u rd
e n a nd m
o rt
al
i
t
y
of
v ul
n e r ab l
ei
nd
i
vi
d
u al
s,p
a rt
i
c ul
a rl
y
t
h
ep
o o r,w
o
m
e n, ch i l
d
r e n, a nd
r u r al
r e si
d
e nt
sw h
o s uf f
e r a nd p
e ri
sh
e v e ry y
ea
r a sa
r e s ul
t
of
d
ri
nk
i
ng
c o nt
am
i
n at
ed w
at
e r,i
s of
ag
r e at
m
ag
ni
t
ud
eA
c c o rd
i
ng
t
ot
h
eW
o rl d
H
e al
t
h
O
rg
a ni
z at
i
o n,w
at
e rb
o r n ed i
s e a s e, e sp
e ci
al l
y
d
i
a r rh
e al
i l
l
n e s s, a c c o u nt
sf
o rf
o u rp
e r c e nt
of
al l d
e at
h
s a nd f
i
v ep
e r c e nt
of
al l h
e al
t
h l
o s st
od
i
s ab
i
l
i
ty
w
o rl d w
i
d
e;
ad d
i
t
i
o n al l y
, a n e st
i
m
at
ed
9 0 0
m
i
l l
i
o n a nd
2
.6
b
i
l l
i
o ni
nd
i
vi
d
u al
s a r e v /i
t
h
o ut
a c c e s st
oi
m
p
r o v ed
d
ri
nk
i
ng
w
at
e r s up p
l
i
e s a nd
i
m p
r o v ed
s a ni
t
at
i
o n, r e sp
e ct
i
v el
y
[ W
H O
.,2 0 1 0
)
T
h
e r e a r em
a ny
ob
st
a cl
e st
o o v e r c om
e v /h
e n c o n si
d
e ri
ng
m
e a n s of
t
r e at
i
ng
i xp
e n si
v e am
et
h
o
d
o
f
t
r
e at
m
e nt
,t
h
eb
et t
e r(
D
h
o ng
r e,2
0
1
U
J
A
n ot
h
e ri
m
p
o
rt
a nt
rTiTi c tn o i'o t-3 r ;n tc THrO n n i "!? ?"^ r*f r'^*^ e^H'"^ ^ ^'LWi^^ sf \f^iU-ir A tf i ( f\n t ^n n" ? It' '-/If -V^ T;i_J:tI
f-iyrT;|; T r? ( J OA '! nr 70
1 ^ sr r ^r p n ' ^ n t :iH^ Ta
d d
i
t
i
v e sh
a v eb
e e np
re
vi
o
u sl
y i
n v e st
i
g
at
ed
(
S
ud h
a et
al
2
0 0 9
,L i
n1 9 9
6
,C
e r va
nt
e s1 9 9 4
,T
h
u rm
a n1 9 8 9
)
.H
ow
e v e r,t
h
ei
r eff
i
c a cy
a nd d
i
si
nf
e ct
i
o nk
i
n et
i
c s r em
ai
n u n cl
e a r.W
i
t
h
t
h
eg
o al
of
e v e nt
u al l y
d
e v el
op i
ng
ad
i
si
nf
e ct
a nt
c om
p
ri
s ed
of
co
p p
e r a nd
zi
n c a nd m
e et
i
ng
al
l
of
t
h
e ab
o v eq
u al
i
t
i
e s)
, a ni
n v e st
i g
at
i
o n r eg
a rd
i
ng
t
h
e ef f
e ct
of
c op p
e r a nd
zi
n ci
o n s o np
r e v e nt
i
ng g
r ow
t
h
a nd p
r ol
i
f
e r at
i
o n a nd
r ed
u ci
ng
t
h
e vi
ab
i
l
i
t
y
of
£
c ol
i i
n a st
a nd
a rd
i
s ed
aq
u e o u s s ol
ut
i
o nw
a sp
u r s u ed
E
xp
e ri
m
e nt
al
D
e si g
nT
h
e o v e r al l
ob
j
e ct
i
ve
f
o rt
h
e e xp
e ri
m
e nt
v / a st
o e v al
u at
et
h
e u s e of
c op
p
e r a nd
zi
n ci
o n st
og
et
h
e r a sd
i
si
nf
e ct
a nt
si
n e xp
e ri
m
e nt
al l
y
c o nt
am
d
n at
ed
w
at
e rT
o a c c om p l
i
sh
t
h
i
s,t
h
e s ei
o n sw
e r ei
nt
r od
u c ed
i
nt
o ch
em
i
c al l y
d
efi
n ed
,b
uf
f
e r ed
t
e st
iv a 'p ri
n ih
s lO rm
of
ch l
o
ri
d
es
al
t
s.T
h
ew
at
e rw
a *'H
r)c a r?
a r 10
%
3 0
'^'^
' a nd
1
0
0
" '^ of
t
h
em
a xi
m
um
c o n s um
a
b l
ed
o s e a sd
ef
i
n ed
b
v hf itn A H r^ ' ^^ : o n s um
ip
t
i
o nl
e v el
Lil i ^ ii i ect^ U i ctD ie C Uil C C U u id L lOll OI ^ Ui tUl ctUie l i. C'Ji i \V C fC U Ucti tLi l ie Cl, £1 :5 vvc i c ^^^ p n f 5p p V ^/: Jr r\j ' i]
»r : :3n r\
>^ u rtfu n iri ^ " ! C in rt»f t ^" /n CiK P:^ n t ' " n rs^ o n ^ p r i st
i n"o
r Di s rf jr ii »;:j c M CsQn n !^<i r r \r^f}n r} n t ^^fr )\r * -^ \fT i n n A €5? r -^ c-om
IA n r i\? T \^\ 5r o v i a ef ^^d
d
i
t i
v f ^ s i is ed
vjQT p 3 c om
b
i
n at
i
o no