Defeasible reasoning and argumentation theory 47
An argumentation system for defeasible reasoning
... and argumentation ones. The theory over which an argumentation system is built is a logic program, that is, only one type of rules is ...well-known argumentation system is ABA ...rule-based ...
40
Modeling Mortgage Assessment with Computational Argumentation Theory and Defeasible Reasoning
... In this particular case, the calculation summary result, as the outcome of the argumentation is: 1.71, for both applicable semantics. This result is a representation of the forecasting arguments which support ...
128
Combining quantitative and qualitative reasoning in defeasible argumentation
... Let us briefly discuss the role of the these properties. Restricted inclusion ensures that non-defeasible facts can be ontologically understood as empty arguments. Cummulativity allows to keep any argument ...
12
Agent programming using defeasible argumentation for knowledgerepresentation and reasoning
... BDI theory are ...uses Defeasible argumentation for the knowl- edge representation and reasoning of the ...a defeasible argumentation ...
12
Extended defeasible reasoning for common goals in n-person argumentation games
... of reasoning against q must be considered: (1) q is already definitely provable; or (2) the defeasible part of D is ...or defeasible rule with head q which can be applied is in the theory ...
23
A Qualitative Investigation of the Degree of Explainability of Defeasible Argumentation and Non-monotonic Fuzzy Reasoning
... two reasoning approaches suggests that defeasible argumenta- tion might lead to explanations that are more suitable to understand for humans, both for a domain expert and a lay ...fuzzy reasoning and ...
13
Inferential Models of Mental Workload with Defeasible Argumentation and Non-monotonic Fuzzy Reasoning: a Comparative Study
... approaches argumentation theory has recently shown appealing proper- ties for inference under uncertainty and conflicting ...of reasoning under uncertainty with real- world ...between ...
17
Comparing Defeasible Argumentation and Non-Monotonic Fuzzy Reasoning Methods for a Computational Trust Problem with Wikipedia
... the reasoning methods would rank these individuals relative to the regular ones, and this will be done by assessing what the lowest ranked Barnstar user’s ‘trust score’ is (their associated inference) in terms of ...
103
An Empirical Evaluation of the Inferential Capacity of Defeasible Argumentation, Non-monotonic Fuzzy Reasoning and Expert Systems
... Another MWL assessment technique is the Workload Profile (WP) which is based on the Multiple Resource Theory (MRT) (Wickens, 1991). Contrarily to the NASA-TLX, it is built upon 8 dimensions: solving and deciding, ...
88
Rationality postulates: applying argumentation theory for non-monotonic reasoning
... of argumentation theory, we observe that the current state of affairs (at the time of writing) is somewhat ...the defeasible rules is either empty or total (hence ruling out a proper partial ...
24
Reasoning about intentions: a defeasible argumentation approach
... model, reasoning about beliefs, desires and intentions must be performed; we will use Defeasible Logic Programming (DeLP) [4] as the reasoning ...a defeasible logic ...
12
Introducing probabilistic reasoning in defeasible argumentation using labeled deductive systems
... (i:e:, defeasible proofs which are non-contradictory wrt the strict knowledge Strict(¡) for a given knowledge base ...and defeasible information, ...
5
Evaluating the Impact of Defeasible Argumentation as a Modelling Technique for Reasoning under Uncertainty
... Nonetheless, not all collected information was consistent. In some cases, descriptions contained contradictory information and could not be used without further clarification. In other cases, the author did not have the ...
301
Dialectical explanations in defeasible argumentation
... within argumentation systems through a graphical representation of dialectical ...in argumentation has been addressed in ...animated argumentation space: ar- guments are introduced one by one in the ...
13
Argumentation semantics for defeasible logics
... abstract argumentation framework of [24] addresses both strict and defeasible rules, but not ...in defeasible arguments is different from that of defeasible logic, and there is no concept of ...
11
Introducing dialectical bases in defeasible argumentation
... If we find that (A, qi) is not consistent with respect to its argumentative line, then we must eliminate th~ sub-tree rooted with (A, qi) from 1(A,q)' Note that, as we [r] ...
10
A defeasible reasoning web service
... Keywords: web services, defeasible reasoning, dialectical argumentation, semantic web. 1 INTRODUCTION The World Wide Web Consortium defines Web Services as “software systems designed to sup- port ...
5
Defeasible reasoning in dynamic domains
... In particular, we have redefined specificity ( definition 2. 7) to compare argu - ments independently from the set of observations. Note that the meaningful activat.ion [r] ...
12
Mercier and Sperber’s Argumentative Theory of Reasoning: From Psychology of Reasoning to Argumentation Studies
... In short, in natural settings, when people reason they do not try to produce the best answer to a given rebuttal, but rather try to find confirmatory arguments that maintain their beliefs. Because confirmation bias is ...
28
An Asymmetric Protocol for Argumentation Games in Defeasible Logic
... heavy then it might not fly. This rule can prevent the derivation of a “fly” conclusion. On the other hand it cannot be used to support a “not fly” conclusion. DL is a “skeptical” non-monotonic logic, meaning that it ...
12