CRITICAL REFLECTION ON RESEARCH PROCESS
7.3 Reflections on the Nature of Work Based Research Project
My teaching and research experiences started when I was a research assistant in the
Department of Educational Sciences. As I am now a senior instructor and researcher in
both the Faculty of Education and Distance Education Institute at EMU, I have gained
a depth of knowledge and understanding by continuing my education and experiences.
After I successfully completed a broad-based Masters degree, covering education,
technology and communication in line with distance education practice, this project
provided a chance for me to specialize in a particular area. In this respect, these
experiences provided me with insights into my own learning management by
developing and broadening my understanding in terms of both the theoretical and
practical knowledge of distance education practice.
Being a senior instructor and a researcher provided me with many opportunities for
learning, and my academic background and position gave me great enthusiasm to
conduct the research project. On the other hand, my enthusiasm was tempered by the
situation of the country which is biased against new ways of learning and has a
centralized based education system. This restricts open minded people from conducting
innovative practices. Although there are restrictions in conducting research in this
small country, the EUA report about EMU practice became a milestone for me as a
researcher worker and the basis for my research project. As I was becoming aware of
report emphasized the importance of conducting wide ranging research and giving
importance to distance education practices. Therefore, I applied for a research project
that was funded by Ministry of Education in order to support the Distance Education
Institute’s as a worker researcher. This contributed to developing my management
skills and ability to allocate resources.
EMU set its vision and mission for continuous quality improvement according to the
report of the EUA. In this respect, the issue of online education gained importance as a
way of supporting continuous quality improvement in the university and in the
Distance Education Institute. Conducting research became important for university
policy and work based learning and projects provided an opportunity to pursue this
policy.
In line with this rationale, the Distance Education Institute at EMU provided access to
conduct research for change and development of the institute based on EUA norms.
Therefore, my project aimed to support an action plan for the Distance Education
Institute in EMU regarding online education practice and focusing on the role of tutors
in facilitating communication in constructing knowledge and developing professional
and organizational knowledge.
The intense need for the implementation of an action plan for the development of
Distance Education Institute, and the focus of my project validated my practical work
and the work I was conducting in the Doctorate in Professional Studies Programme.
In these respects, my project accomplished the following objectives:
To develop awareness of the relevance of communication and organizational climate in the Distance Education Institute and online
To provide training on the roles of tutors and create awareness of their roles in the online learning and teaching process
To enhance the online socialization of students by overcoming social barriers
To create an organizational culture in the Distance Education Institute by focusing on communication practices between tutors and among students.
In my project, inductive reasoning was used to focus on the experiences of online
tutors, and the meanings of the actions that they constructed through social interactions.
Therefore, a qualitative research design suited my research and the online tutors played
a great role in my project with their efforts, reflections and perceptions regarding the
research.
The action research approach adopted facilitated my practical work with the online
tutors and provided them with insights on how to teach their courses, considering their
roles in the Distance Education Institute. Choosing the research approach was a
challenging process for me, particularly in terms of interpreting the essences of action
research for implementation.
On the other hand, I felt excited and motivated by my experiences of the new approach
and the ways in which it provided new ways of learning to participants. Therefore, I put
a lot of effort into managing the series of actions in my research project in a planned
way. My project included a series of actions, including focus groups, in-depth
interviews, self-reports and training which were used as data collection techniques and
actions in order to reach the research objectives.
The training and the changes that resulted during the action research were the main
achievement, particularly in the enhancement of the knowledge of novice tutors about
preplanning and careful consideration in order to prevent dilemmas in the research
process.
As the online tutors were the key characters in the project, gaining access to research
participants was conducted strategically so that the online tutors became voluntarily
part of the project. Consent forms were prepared and signed by research participants in
order to reach a common understanding of the research project and its actions.
I established self-disclosure through having good communication, ensuring punctuality,
setting the right time and places for meetings and considering all details in every event.
I prepared research packages for each research participant that gave detailed
information about the research project’s aim, objectives, data collection techniques,
training information, project report, the roles of worker researcher as insider researcher
and the impact of my research project. This demonstrates how I paid attention to the
research participants within the action research process. As my project was funded by
the Ministry of Education, I was able to use resources in an efficient way. Expenditure
included buying incentives such as a webcam, pen, headphones and folder bags for
online tutors, preparing handbooks on how to teach online courses to online tutors and
other higher education institutions, and organizing focus groups and training sessions.
“Challenge” can be seen in every aspect of research. It is good to have challenges if
these challenges can be managed by researchers for success. As a worker researcher,
every challenge motivated me to produce better work. Persuading online tutors to the
part of the research project was the first challenge. Explaining to them the importance
of the research project convinced them to be research participants. This involved face
to face meetings, giving detailed information through the research package, and
tutors were well-informed that they had the chance to gain knowledge about online
pedagogy through the action learning process.
Conducting the focus group was another challenge. Getting participants to respond to
questions in front of group was difficult due to cultural factors. My communication
skills were very important in overcoming this cultural barrier and getting the
participants to open up.
Subsequent focus group actions were easier for me, and the in-depth interviews were
very fruitful as the online tutors expressed their thoughts on their changing roles and
became aware of not having enough knowledge about online pedagogy. Thus, they
realized how training was crucial to enhance their knowledge of their roles.
Finding the right time to meet online tutors was another challenge. My intellectual
flexibility and patience however enabled me to create mutual understanding among
participants. The words “Management”, “Pre-planned”, “Empathy”, “Enthusiasm”,
“Efficient”, “Critical Reflection”, “Negotiation”, “Mutuality” became keys to my
success. The project management required high responsibility, intellectual flexibility
and networking skills. These key skills enabled me to make positive contributions to
the outcome of the research project.