• No results found

Knowledge Acquisition Module for Conversation Agent

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2020

Share "Knowledge Acquisition Module for Conversation Agent"

Copied!
9
0
0

Loading.... (view fulltext now)

Full text

(1)

' )( *%+,-.,/0 1

2436587:9<;>=&?@36A8B$C8DFEG="HI;>J6KMLH)N&36;>JOBPCRQ7S3658T>=&U>36VVW5OXZY6C>[\367<="=PT!N&3ITOHG5^]_Y

`FaIbdcPegfihMbkjmlnpoqRrphMsrpaIbdrGtuqvrphMsr"aubdrGtuwxIhyjMfzrp{|bdrGt

}~6"€I$‚ZƒG„†…ˆ‡6‰ŠŒ‹$$„Žƒ6‘…ˆ’$"ƒ66“P”€6•66–R…m„p—P€…m"€

˜

`FaIb|cegfihMbkjmlWnpov™Fegšœ›GnpxIjiWžŸrp{|eZhZtO›6lI IaIegl$t6w¡xuhyjMfzrp{|bdrGt

}¢PP"€6—„vŠŒ£6$p„„P—6“P”$¢–p„†…¤€Pƒu–£…m„p—p€…mp€¥P¦‰I"ƒ6$”€G•$6–R…y„P—"€…mp€

§W¨v©ZªZ«¬®­pªP¯ q+Ie&oSn$°ZxIh±npo4jMfzrp Ibkjib|nPaurp{+°Znpa6cegfihir"jib|npa®rp{+rp²Pega6jih³b|hµ´I{drp°Ze ¶npa

aur"jixIfzr"{·{:r"au²px®rp²pe´Ifin$°geZhMhMb|au²Ÿr"a® @xua® Gegfihyjzrpau Ib|au² jiIe)auege Ih-n"oFjiIe)xuhMe_f¸

q+IeZhMeWrp²Pega6jihµr"fie&jŒlI´Ib|°rp{|{kl¶b|s&´u{|eZs&ega6jieZ ¹o<npfµhM´OeZ°Zbkº®°W Inpsrpb|auhhMxI°_jiur"j

 GnPsrpb|a&»6aunš·{|e G²Perpa® -°gnPa6cegfihirjibdnpauh.r"fie¡¼uxub|{kjsrpa6x®r"{d{kl$¸p½*nPsr"b|a&»GaInš·{|¾

e G²Pe*n"ovjiueghMe*rp²peZa$jih·r"fieeZaI°Zn6 IeZ 1r"h4°ZnPa6cegfihirjib|nPa®r"{^°gnPa$jieZa$j+š·ub|°z)°r"xuhMeZh

r¶´On$n"fhMeZ´ur"fzr"jib|npa¿¼Oegjmš.eZeZa\jiuejŒš+n@ Gbdhyjib|aI°gj1jŒlG´OeZhnpo»6aunš·{|e I²peP¸·q+Ibdh

´GfinP¼u{|eZsÀb|hsrp²PaIbkº®e ±¼$l³jiue4{drp°z»±n"o8»GaInš·{deZ I²Pe¡r"°Á$xub|hMbkjibdnpa-jin$nP{|h+r"a® >t$rphr

fieZhMxI{kjtr"²PeZa$jih†º®au µbkj IbkÂ&°ZxI{kjjinFrP Irp´Ij‘jinF IbkÃ>egfieZa$j Inpsrpb|auh‘r"a® µjinxu´> Ir"jie

egÄGb|hyjib|au²-»6aInš·{|e G²Pe¼®r"hMeZhZ¸

q+Ie-o<fzrps&e_š+npfi»¹´GfinP´OnPhMeZ b|a!jiub|h´urp´Oegf³r"bds&h*jinWfieZ°gjibko<lÅjiub|h´GfinP¼u{|eZs¼$l

¼Ixub|{d Ib|au²rs&n6 Ixu{|e.jinF®rpau I{|e+»6aunš·{|e G²Pe¡rp°Á$xIbdhMbkjib|nPa8¸q+Ie4s&n6 IxI{de+rp°Á$xubkfieZh

»6aunš·{|e G²PeFjiGfinPxu²pWr³°r"hMeg¾ˆ¼®r"hMe 1s&egjiIn6 Inp{dnp²pl°r"{|{deZ WÆ¡b|´u´u{|e½*nš·a1Æ¡xu{|eZh

Ç

Æ¡½*ÆFÈ_É$r*jieZ°zuaubdÁ$xue+jiur"j.®rph¼OeZeZa&eZs&´I{|nle ±hMxu°g°ZeZhMhyoSxI{|{|lWr"°gfinPhMh+rInPhyj.npo

egÄG´OegfMj·hylGhyjieZs¸

Ê Ë\Ì4Í>Î*Ï·Ð8ѡҳӵÔ

ÕM;IXg="7<7:9<JG=p;uXÅÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G736JI=";uXg]Ù^3×G=¶Ú^=p=";œX_Ù8=@5>7:X_9<V36X_=ŸJIHI367*9<;ÛX_Ù>=ŸØg=p3G7:VÜH6Ý

Ùu58V3G;ÞÖ"HGVß>5OXg="Ø-9<;IXg="ØZ3GÖX_9<HG;8]pàRá*Ù89<]-Ù83I]±V)HGX_9<×$3$X_=PTâ3!7S36ØgJG=W;®5>V1Ú^=pØ&H6Ý*36JG=p;uXg]µH6Ý

׏3GØ_E®9<;>JµÖ"HGVß>7<=ãO9:XiE-X_H-]z5>Ø_݈3GÖ"=9<;)Ø_=PÖ=";uX+EG=P36ØZ]·ä|åPæyà6çµ;8=FHGÝ>X_Ù8=F=P36Øg7:9<=p]zXpC36;^TWßR="ØgÙ836ß^]

V)Hu]iXFè=p7:7RA®;>H$è;‘Cu=ã>36Vß>7<=³HGÝ]z5^ÖZÙÅ36JI=";uXg]¡9<]Fé·7<9:êP3¹ä<ëPìPæyà®é·7<9:êP3=";8JI36JI=p]3WÖHI;®×G="ØZ]g3$K

X_9<HG;)X_Ù>ØgHG58JGÙ]z9<Vß>7:=]gÖØg9<ßOXg].XgÙ83$X·ß>ØgHGVßOX4XgÙ>=]_ß^=P36AG=pØ+è9dXgÙíu5>=P]iXg9:HI;8]4TO=pØ_9<×G=PTݤØgHGV

X_Ù>=-7S3$X_=P]iX5OX_X_=pØg3G;8Ö=Iàu[îÙ89:7<=-X_Ù>9S]36ß8ß>Ø_Hu3GÖZÙÅ3G7:7<H$è]HG;>=±X_H Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]_=è9:X_Ù¶é·7<9:êP3>C®X_Ù8=

Ø_=P]z5>7:X_9<;>JÅT>9<3G7:HIJG5>=&ÚR=pÖ"HGV=p]µ3¹]z=pØ_9<=p]H6Ý·Øg="ßR=X_9:X_9<HG5^]³íu5>=p]zX_9<HG;^]"àRï>HGر36;@3GJG=";uXXgHÅÚR=

H6Ý·36;®E58]z=IC89:Xµ]_Ù>HG5>7ST¶ÚR=136Ú87:=&XgH¹ß>ØgH$×®9<TO=]_HGV=A®9<;8T¶H6Ý·]_="Øg×®9<Ö"=GC8]_58ÖZÙ@3G]³JG9<×®9:;>J¹3G;

=ãOß^=pØzX¡3ITO×®9<Ö"=*9:;3±ð8="7ST1H6݆]zßR=pÖ"9<3G7:9S]_36X_9<HG;‘à6á*Ù89<]+9S]+X_Ù8=*XiEußR=*H6݆36JI=";uX+X_Ù836X4X_Ù>9S]+ß836ßR="Ø

è9:7<7†Ý¤HOÖ58]*HI;Ÿ36;8T!9:;¶ß83GØzXg9<Ö"5>7S36ØPCIXgÙ>=Ö5^]iXgHGV9<]g3$Xg9:HI;!HGÝ.]_58ÖZÙ¶36JG=p;uXg]pà

QHG;uX_=pV)ßRHGØZ36ØgE³Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;836763GJG=";uXZ]‘7<HuHIA³XgHXgÙ>=·ð8=p7<T8]HGÝ>7:9<;>JG589<]zX_9SÖ"]36;8T&V=pV1K

HGØgE@ݤHGØWV)HIØ_= Øg=p3G7:9S]zX_9SÖV)HOTO=p7<]H6Ý36JI=";uXg] äñ$æyàï8Ø_HIVòX_Ù89<]pCV 36;®E\TO9:óR=pØ_=p;IX&XiE®ßR=p]WH6Ý

ß836ØZ]z=pس36;^TŸ]zßR="=PÖZٟJG=";8="ØZ3$X_9<HG;¶]_E®]zX_=pV ]³36Øg=&Ú>5>9<7:Xpàvï>HGص9:;^]iXZ36;8Ö"=GC>XgÙ>=2·Ù89:7<7:9<ß8]³X_ØZ369<;

]zEO]zX_="Vôä<ëæ†9S]31Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;8367^36JG=p;uXXgÙ83$X9S]FÖ"HG;>;8=pÖXg=pT¹X_H 3Wß85>Ú>7<9<ÖµX_=p7:=pß>Ù>HI;>=µ;8=XzK

èHIØ_AèÙ89<ÖZÙÖp36;&ß>ØgH$×®9<TO=.XgØg3G9:;-Xg9:V=XZ36Ú>7<9<;>J9<;OݤHGØgV 3$X_9<HG;±XgÙ>Ø_HI5>JGÙ&Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;‘àá*Ù>9<]

36JG=p;uX-=P]_]_=";uXg9<3G7:7<E¶X_Øg=p36Xg]±X_Ù8= 58]z=pØ&9:;8ß>5OX13I]&3íu5>=pØ_Eõ9:;uX_HXgÙ>=X_9<V=Xg3GÚ>7<=¹T>3$XZ36Ú83I]z=Ià

(2)

H6ݱX_Ù>=P]z=Ÿ]_E®]zX_=pVÜÙ83×I=3Þß>Øg=pT>=ð8;>=PTÛT>3$XZ36Ú83I]z=!X_Ù836XÅ]iXgHGØg=p])XgÙ>=ŸA®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=H6ݱX_Ù8=

36JG=p;uXpà†[îÙ>9<7:=XgÙ>9S]&9<]-JIH®H®TõݤHGØ1]zEO]zX_="V ]-èÙ>=pØ_=VHI]zX-݈3GÖXg]3GØ_=3$XgHGV9<ÖGC†X_Ù89<]-9S]&;>HGX

]z5>9:Xg3GÚ>7<=-ݤHGس]zX_HIØ_9<;>J)=ãOß^=pØzXA®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=Gà>á*Ù89<]ß8Ø_HIÚ>7:=pVü]_HG7<×®9:;>JA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=-9<]Ú^3G]_=pT

HG;Ù>="5>Øg9S]iXg9<Öp]*èÙ>9<ÖZٟÖp36;>;>HGXÚ^=]_5>9:Xg36Ú87:E¹="ãOß>Ø_=P]_]_=pT!9<;3)ý^36XT>3$XZ36Ú83I]z=Ià

á*Ù>="Øg=36Øg=="×I=";ŸVHGØg=36V1Ú>9:X_9<HG58]µ36JG=p;uXg]*XgÙ83$X-TOH¹;>HGXµHG;87:E9:;^ÖHGØgßRHGØZ3$X_=&]_ß^=p=pÖZّC

Ú>5OX³367S]_H1ÚRHOTOEÅ7S36;>JI5836JI=GCO]_58ÖZÙ3I]*="VH6Xg9:HI;8]*36;8T¶]_ß83$Xg9<3G7†3èF3GØ_=p;>=p]g]"C®3G]*="ãO="Vß>7<9dð8=PT

ÚuE þ=P3 äù$æ†36;8T¹?õ3$ã¶äÿ6æmà®á*Ù>=p]_=µ3GJG=p;IXZ]·36Øg=³3GÚ>7:=³X_H)ÖHG;®×I="E1]_5>ÚOXg7:="X_9<=p]*]_58ÖZÙ¹3G]¡Ýˆ3GÖ"9<3G7

=ãOß>Øg=p]g]z9<HG;8]±èÙ>9SÖZÙ¿36Øg= 9:VßRHGØ_Xg3G;IX&;>HI;OKy×G="ØgÚ83G7+Ö"5>=p]&ݤHGØ="ã®ß8Ø_=P]_]_9:;8J!XgÙ>=¹ÖHI;uX_=ã®X9<;

èÙ>9<ÖZٟ]_ß^HIAG=p;Å9<;OݤHGØgV 3$X_9<HG;9S]JG9<×G=p;‘à

þ=pÖ"=";uX³TO="×I="7<HGß>V=p;IXZ]*9:;XgÙ>=)QEOÖ-ß>ØgHi=pÖX367<7:H$è]*="ã®ßR="Ø_XX_H 58ßRT>36X_=&XgÙ>=&A®;>H$è7:K

=pTOJI=!Ú83I]z=ÅX_Ù>ØgHG58JGÙ 3âè=pÚOKyÚ83G]_=pT/3Gß>ß>7<9<Öp3$Xg9:HI;Àäì$æmà4á*Ù>=¶]_E®]zX_=pV Ù83G]WX_H®HI7<]]_58ÖZÙú3I]

TO9<ÖX_9<HG;83GØ_9<=p]³36;8T@3G;8367<HGJI9:=P]FX_H¹9<;uX_ØgHOTO58Ö=W;>="è ݈3IÖXg]³9:;uXgH X_Ù>=1A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=&Ú^3G]_=Gà^á*Ù8=

]zEO]zX_="Vü9<]3G7<]_H ]z5 Ö"9:=p;uX_7<EÅ9<;IXg="7<7:9<JG=p;uXX_HJG=p;>="ØZ3$Xg=±Øg="7S3$Xg=pTÅ݈3GÖXg]èÙ>9SÖZٟ36Øg=µ9<Vß>7<9:=PT

ÚuEX_Ù>=58]_="Ø49<;>ß>5>Xpà6[îÙ>9<7<=*X_Ù>9S]4]zEO]zX_=pV ß>ØgH$×u9STO=P]HI;>=*H6Ý^X_Ù>=VHI]zX49:;8;>H$×$3$X_9<×G=*V=XgÙ>HOT

H6ÝWA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=â3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;‘CF9:X¶HI;>7<EÀ36ß>ß>7<9<=p]!X_HÛ3GT>T>9:;>J ݈3GÖXg]9:; 3œÖHGVVHG;>Ky]_=";8]_=

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=±Ú83G]_=GàO[îÙ89:7<=-X_Ù>9S]Ö"3G;!ß8Ø_H$×®9STO=±3]_HG7<9<T!Ú83IÖZAIKy=";^T¹Ý¤HIØFJI=";>=pØg3G7vAu;8H$è7:=PTOJG=IC

X_Ù>=3GØgÖZÙ>9:X_=PÖXg5>Ø_=±9S];>H6X]_5>9:Xg36Ú87:=-ݤHIØØ_="Xg369<;>9<;>J]zßR=pÖ"9dð^Ö&T>HGV 369<;!A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=Gà

ÕM;/]z5>VV 36ØgEGC.ÖHI;IXg="VßRHGØZ36ØgEõÖHI;u×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7436JG=p;uXg]3GØ_= ݤHOÖ"58]z=PT\HG;\XgÙ>=Åß>ØgHGÚ>K

7:=pV H6Ýß>ØgH$×®9<TO9<;>J 3 ;83$Xg5>ØZ367-36;8TÀ3IT>36ß>X_9<×G=@è*3E XgHú9<;uX_=pØg3IÖXÅè9:X_Ù X_Ù>=Þ=";8T 58]_="ØPà

‘9:XzX_7<=ÅÙ^3G]ÚR="=p; TOHI;>=¹HG;/]_9<V)ß87:9:ݤE®9:;>J@X_Ù>=!ß>Ø_HOÖ"=p]g]&H6Ý5>ßvT>36X_9<;>JŸX_Ù8=ÅA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI= H6Ý

X_Ù>=&36JI=";uXg]pàOá*Ù>9S]*ß836ßR="Ø*ß>ØgHGßRHI]_=p]*31Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=-3GÖpíI589<]_9dXg9:HI;ÅVHOTO5>7<=±X_Ù836X*è9<7<7‘367<7:H$è

ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7v3GJG=p;IXZ]XgH¹7:=P36Øg;ŸTOHGV 369<;@]_ß^=PÖ9:ð^ÖA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=GCOXgÙ®58]"CRÖØg=p36X_9<;>J¹3ý8="ãuK

9:Ú>7<=&ݤØZ36V="èFHGØgA ݤHIصÖ5^]iXgHGV9<]_9<;>J¹]zßR=pÖ"9<3G7:9S]_=pTŸ36JI=";uXg]pà8á*Ù>=1]z5>Ú^]z=PíI58=";uX³]z=PÖXg9:HI;8]è9<7:7

TO="VHG;^]iXgØg36X_=-Ù>H$èÀXgÙ>9S]]iXgØ_58ÖX_5>Øg=-èHIØ_AO]pà

Ð8Ì \Ñ·Ð>Î

á*Ù>=·VHOTO5>7<=¡Ú>5>9<7ST>]‘HI;36;&=ãO9S]iXg9:;8J³ÖHI;u×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7$36JG=p;uX36;8T-A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=·3GÖpíu5>9<]_9:X_9<HG;

V)="X_Ù>HOTOHI7:HIJGEIà ö ]zßR=pÖ"9<3G7FT83$Xg3â]iXgØ_5^ÖX_58Ø_=!Au;8H$è; 3G]1ݤØZ36V=Å9S]ݤ58;8T>36V=p;IXZ367FX_HâX_Ù8=

TO="×I="7<HGß>V=";uX.H6ÝOX_Ù8=VHOTO5>7<=Gà$á*Ù>=¡Ý¤HG7<7:H$è9<;>J³]_=pÖX_9<HG;8].]zÙ^367<7I9<;uX_ØgH®T>58Ö=¡X_Ù>=P]z=="7<="V=";uXg]

Ú>Ø_9<=ý^EGà

! "#$%'&)(*

á*Ù>=1VHOTO5>7<=ݤHIصA®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=13IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;Ÿ9S]±Ú>5>9<7dX-HG;õ=ãO9<]zX_9<;>JÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G736JI=";uX

X_=pÖZÙ8;>HG7<HGJI9:=P]"à·ï.9<Øg]zX!36;^TœÝ¤HGØg="VHI]zXpC4XgÙ>=õÖ"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;836736JI=";uX X_Ù^3$XÅ9S]Å3G5>JGV=";uXg=pT

è9dXgÙîX_Ù>=õV)HOTO587:=â9<]Å2·Ø_HIÚ^HGXpàÕyXÅ9<]36;Û="ãuXg=";8]_9<HG;ÛX_H/X_Ù>=âß>Ø_HIJGØZ36VV9:;8JÞ7S36;8JG583GJG=

9:2·ØgHG7<HGJ^CO36;¶=";>Ù^36;8Ö"=pT!×G="ØZ]_9:HI;ÅH6Ý+]iXZ36;8T836ØZTÅ2·ØgHG7<HGJä<ë,+æyà

2·Ø_HIÚ^HGX&9<]3Xg5>Øg;OKmÚ^3G]_=pTÞÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7.3GJG=";uXPC†èÙ>="Øg=X_Ù>= 5^]z=pØW36;8TâXgÙ>=¹36JI=";uX

367:X_="Øg;836X_=1]_ßR=p36A®9<;>J8àvá*Ù>=pØ_=19<]±;>H!;83$Xg5>Øg3G77S36;8JG583GJG=ß>ØgHOÖ=P]_]_9:;8JÅ9<;õ2·ØgHGÚRH6XPC^9<;8]zX_=p3IT

58]z=pØ¡9<;>ß>5OXF9<]¡V 3$XgÖZÙ8=pT 36Ju369<;8]zX·ß83$X_X_="Øg;8]TO=ð8;8=pT 9<;ð87<=p]·A®;>H$è;¹3I]¡]gÖØg9:ß>Xg]pàuQHG;uX_="ã®X

H6Ý·XgÙ>=p]_=1ß^3$XzXg="Øg;8]±36Øg=1]_="ß83GØg36X_=pTŸX_Ù>ØgHG5>JIٟX_Ù8=158]_=)H6Ý·XgHGß>9SÖ"],-RX_Ù>9S]-367<7:H$è]X_Ù>= ]g36V=

ß83$X_X_="Øg;8]µè9dXgÙõ×$36ØgE®9:;8JÅV=p3G;>9:;8JI]XgHÖ"H®=ãO9<]zXµè9:X_Ù89:;õX_Ù>=36JI=";uXµè9:X_Ù>HI5OX&36VWÚ89:JI5>9dXiE

(3)

ï>ØZ36V=p]F36Øg=µ]zX_Øg58ÖXg5>Øg=p]54ð8ØZ]iX*ß>ØgHGßRHI]_=pT Ú®E ?@3GØ_×®9<;Å?Ÿ9<;8]zA®EŸä6æ87¡5^]z=PT ݤHGØ*TO=P]_Ö"Ø_9<Ú>9<;>J

3\XiE®ß>9<Öp367±]z9:X_5836X_9<HG;‘CF]z5^ÖZÙÀ3G] =p;IXg="Øg9:;8J 3¿ØgHuHIV¶à·é¡3GÖZÙÀ3I]zßR=pÖXÅH6Ý-XgÙ>=â]_9dXg583$Xg9:HI;î9<]

Ø_=pß>Ø_=P]z=p;uX_=pTÞÚ®Eâ3õ]z7<H6XPà?Ÿ9<;8]zA®EÞÚ^=p7:9<="×I=p]-XgÙ83$X1HG;>=¹58;8TO="ØZ]zXg36;^T>]TO9S367<HGJI5>=X_Ù>ØgHG58JGÙ

ð8;8TO9<;>JÞݤØg3GV=p]1X_Ù836X¹TO=p]gÖØg9:ÚR=X_Ù>=ŸÖ"HG;uX_=p;IX VHI]zX 36ß>ß>ØgHGß8Ø_9S3$Xg="7<EGà4L=Ÿ367S]_HõÚR="7<9:=p×G=p]

X_Ù836X)XgÙ>="Øg=¶9<]3âÙ>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙuE\HGݳݤØZ36V=p]pC+èÙ>="Øg=!=P3GÖZٜ]z5>Ú^]z=PíI58=";uX)7<="×I="7*9<; XgÙ>=@ÖZÙ8369<;

H6Ý+9:;>Ù8="Øg9dXZ36;8Ö"=ÖHG;uXZ369<;8]9<;8ÖØg=p3I]z9<;>J36VHG5>;uXHGÝ4T>=Xg3G9:7S]3GÚ^HI5OXX_Ù>=X_HGß89<Ö-HGÝ.9<;uX_="Øg=p]zXpC

VW58ÖZÙ¿7<9:AI=!]_5>ÚvÖ7S3G]g]z=P]&9:;/X_Ù>=!HGÚ!i=PÖXWHIØ_9<=";uX_=PT\ß836ØZ3GT>9:JIVà ö ݤØZ36V=¹9S]W367S]_Hõ36Ú>7<= XgH

V3G9:;uXZ369<;3)7<9<]zXH6Ý4íu5>=p]zX_9<HG;8]FXgÙ83$XÖp36;¶Ú^=3I]zAI=pTÅèÙ>=";ŸÖ=pØzXZ369<;!×$3G7:5>=P]36Øg=µ;8="=pT>=pT†à

á*Ù>="Øg=3GØ_=!XièFHõXiE®ßR=p])H6ݱAu;8H$è7:=PTOJG=!X_Ù836X HGßR="ØZ3$X_=9<;œ3ÞÖHI;u×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G73GJG=";uXPà

çµ;>=9<]&Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;@A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=36;^T@XgÙ>= H6XgÙ>="ØPC‘TOHGV 3G9:;ÞA®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=Ià†á*Ù>=p]_=)XiEußR=p]

H6Ý*Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG= 36Øg=VH®T>5>7<3GØpC36;8TÞ58]_=¹3¶]z9<;>JG7<=¹T>36Xg3Ÿ]zX_Øg58ÖXg5>Ø_=A®;>H$è;¿3G]&3ݤØZ36V=P]

X_Ù>HI5>JGÙ!X_Ù>=P]z=3GØ_=±V 369<;uXg369<;>=PTÅXgÙ>ØgHG5>JIÙ!]_="ß83GØg36X_=±ß>Ø_HOÖ"=pTO5>Øg=p]pà

ï>ØZ36V=p]Ö"36;1367S]zHØg=p3IÖXX_H³=p×G=p;IXZ]‘XgÙ>ØgHG5>JIÙ-X_Ù>=F58]_=¡H6ÝRT>36=pV)HI;8]pàpá*Ù>=P]z=F36Øg=]_9:V9<7<3GØ

X_Hõ=p×G=p;IX1Ù836;8T>7:=pØg]&9<;/7S36;>JI5836JI=p]]_58ÖZÙ/3I]:9u3×38à‘9<2·Ø_HI7:HIJ@Ù83I]WTO="ð8;>=pT 3Ÿ;®5>VWÚR="Ø1H6Ý

T>36=pV)HI;8]FX_Ù^3$X³36Øg=&Ö"3G7:7<=pT!èÙ>=";Ÿ3)×$36Øg9:="XiE¹H6Ý.="×I=";uXg]pC>]z5^ÖZÙ¶3I]FX_Ù>=&9<;8]zXg3G;IXg9<36X_9<HG;H6Ý+3

ݤØg3GV)=ICOHOÖ"Ö58Øg]pà

ï>ØZ36V=p]3GØ_=&9STO=P367T83$Xg3 ]zX_Øg58ÖX_5>Øg=p]*ݤHIØXgÙ>=A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=3GÖ"íu5>9S]_9dXg9:HI;VHOTO5>7<=W3I]9:X

]z5>ß8ß^HIØzXZ]ý8="ã®9<Ú>7<=1T>36Xg3!]iXgHGØZ36JG=3I]èF="7<7.3I]³Ö"HG;uXg3G9:;>9<;>J¹=p7:=pV=";uXg]µH6Ý·ÖHI;®×G="ØZ]g3$X_9<HG;¶9<;

31VHOTO5>7S36ØV 3G;>;>="ØPà

<; =>?*@A%*B$(>&ACEDF?"#"8 ,"

á*Ù>=Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=3GÖpíI589<]_9dXg9:HI;õV=XgÙ>HOTOHG7<HGJIE@3GTOHIßOX_=PT@ݤHIرX_Ù>9S]&ß>ØgHi=PÖX-9<]±XgÙ>=¹þ9<ß>ß>7<=

G³H$è;Àþ587:=34ŒþHG±þI7¹3Gß>ß>ØgHI3GÖZÙà4ÕyXÅèF3I]ð8ØZ]iXTO="×®9S]z=PTúÚ®Eœ24365>7&QHGVßOX_HI; äJæ±3G]Å3

ÖHG;^]z9S]iXg=";uX36ß>ß8Ø_Hu3GÖZÙ¹XgH5>ßRT83$X_9<;>J 7S36ØgJG=±A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=±Ú83I]z=P]-äKæyà

á*Ù>=³ÖHIØ_=3I]_]_5>VßOXg9:HI;)HGÝvX_Ù>9S]¡V="X_Ù>HOTOHI7:HIJGEW9S]4XgÙ83$X=ãOß^=pØzXZ]·V 36AI=i58TOJIV)=p;uXg]·HI;

3 Ö"3G]_=&Ú®E!]_HGV=&9<V)ß87:9SÖ9:X³Øg=p3G]_HG;89:;>J^àG³9:óv="Øg=";uXµÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;8]36Øg=&JG9<×G=p;Ÿ3G]3Øg=p]_5>7:XH6Ý

׏3GØ_9S3$Xg9:HI;8]+9<;1XgÙ>=p]_=³Öp3G]_=p]pà$é4ãOß^=pØzXZ]·36Øg=*Ú^="XzX_=pØ36X·9<TO=p;uX_9:ݤEu9<;>J-XgÙ>=×$36Øg9<36X_9<HG;8]+9<; Ö"3I]z=P]

X_Ù836X³TO9<]zX_9<;>JI5>9<]_Ù>=P]*HG;>=±Ý¤ØgHGV÷3G;>H6XgÙ>="ØPà

N-;>H$è7:=PTOJG=19<]W]iXgHGØg=pT@è9:X_Ù89:;¿3Ø_587:=XgØ_=p=GC†èÙ>=pØ_==p3IÖZÙõ;>HOTO= 9S]&3¶ÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;Þ3I]

è=p7:7*3G]13@]z="X1HGݳÖHG;^TO9dXg9:HI;8]&XgÙ83$X)9dX)VW58]zX)]g3$Xg9<]zݤEGà

ö

])3@;>=pèÖ"3G]_=¹9S]WJI9:×I=";\XgH@X_Ù8=

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=Ú83G]_=GC49:X¹è9<7:7ÚR=X_=P]iXg=pTÛ36Ju369<;8]iXØg5>7:=P]è9dXgÙ>9<;úXgÙ>=¶X_Øg="=IàFQHG;^Ö7<58]z9<HG;ú9<]

JG9<×G=";!Ú®E X_Ù>=&7S3G]zX;>HOTO=±X_Ù836XX_Ù>=Öp3G]_=±Ö"HGVß>7<=Xg="7<EÅ]_36X_9S]ið^=p]pàuÕyÝ.X_Ù8=&=ãOß^=pØzXTO9S]g36JGØg="=P]

è9dXgÙ/X_Ù8=Ö"HG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;‘C.;>="è÷Ø_5>7<=p])Ö"3G;/ÚR=!èØg9dX_X_=p;/X_HÞÖHIØ_Øg=pÖXX_Ù>=A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=ÅÚ83I]z=Ià

L="è Øg5>7:=P]-Ú>ØZ36;8ÖZÙ>=P]µÝ¤Ø_HIVôX_Ù>= 7S3G]zXÖHIØ_Øg=pÖX±;>HOTO=ICvX_Ù836X9<]pCvX_Ù8= ;>HOTO=X_Ù836X&Ù83GTâX_Ù8=

9:;8Ö"HGØgØ_=PÖX&ÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;‘à ö ]-XgÙ>=Ø_=P]iX&H6ÝX_Ù>=XgØ_=p=19S]-;>HGXW3$óv=pÖX&Ú®EŸXgÙ>9<]&ÖZÙ^36;>JI=GC†þHG±þ

JG9<×G=p]*3 Ö"HG;8]_9<]zX_=p;uX3Gß>ß>ØgHI3IÖZÙ X_H 9<;8ÖØg="V=p;IXZ367v7<=p36Øg;>9<;>J8à

ûßvT>3$Xg=p]¡3GØ_=³HG;>7<EWØg=píu5>9<Ø_=PTèÙ>=";XgÙ>=³="ãOß^=pØzXT>9<]g36JIØ_=p=p]4è9:X_Ù XgÙ>=³Ö"HG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;X_Ù8=

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG= Ú83I]z= Ù^3G]WT>Øg3è;‘àÕM;/ß>ØZ3GÖXg9<Ö"=GC‘=P3GÖZÙ\5>ßvT>3$Xg=ÅØg=píu5>9<Ø_=P]-X_Ù8=Å]zßR=pÖ"9dðRÖ"3$Xg9:HI;

H6ݵ3ÞÖ"3I]z=IC+3Þ]_=XH6ݵØg5>7<=p]1X_Ù^3$X9<TO=p;uX_9:ð8=p])XgÙ>=ŸÖ"3G]_=!3G;8T 3â;>=pèüÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;¿X_Ù^3$X 9<]

TO9dóv="Øg=";uXݤØgHGVüX_Ù8=1ÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;¶JG=";8="ØZ3$X_=PTÚuE!X_Ù8=A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=&Ú^3G]_=Gà8á*Ù>=P]z=W="7<="V=";uXg]

(4)

á*Ù>=&VH®T>5>7:=-9S]ÖHI;8]_9<]zX_=PTÅHGÝXièFH)A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=-3GÖ"íu5>9S]_9dXg9:HI;Ö"HGVß^HI;>=";uXZ]Q->TOHIV 369<;3G;8T

ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G74Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=IàDFH6XgÙ¿58]z=P]XgÙ>=¹Ý¤ØZ36V=!Ù>9:=pØg3GØgÖZÙ®EõX_Hâ]zX_HIØ_=Å9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;

Ø_=PíI589:Øg=pTõÚuE¶XgÙ>=A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=)3GÖpíI589<]_9dXg9:HI;õß>ØgHOÖ=P]_]±36;8TõX_Ù8=T>=Xg3G9:7S]±H6Ý¡èÙ89<ÖZÙÞè9:7<74ÚR=

=ã>36V9<;>=pT!9:;ŸTO="Xg3G9:7<=pT9<;ÅXgÙ>=-ݤHG7<7:H$è9<;>J ]_=pÖXg9:HI;8]pà

;0 =>?*@A%*B$(>&ACEDF?"#"8 ,"R/ST2U>V>"#1!1CWX

á*Ù>=ŸA®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=Ÿ3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;œÝ¤ØZ36V=U4ˆN

ö

ݤØZ36V=7)9S]¹5^]z=PT ݤHIØÅ]zX_HGØg9<;>J\9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;

Ø_=PíI589:Øg=pT@ݤHGØ3¶]z9<;>JI7:=5>ßvT>3$Xg=Gàá*Ù8="Øg=)3GØ_= 3;®5>VWÚR="Ø&HGÝ¡ð>ãO=pTâ="7<="V=p;IXZ]-X_Ù^3$X3¶N ö

ݤØg3GV)=-3G]*TO9SÖXZ3$Xg=pT!ÚuE!þHGµþ 36;^T¹9S]TO9<]gÖ5^]_]_=pTÅß>Ø_=p×®9:HI58]z7<E9:;ŸU®=PÖX_9<HG;ŸìOàù>àON ö ݤØg3GV=

]zÙ>HI5>7STÞÖ"HG;uXg3G9:;âX_Ù8Ø_=p=¹]z7<H6XZ]"C†èÙ>=pØ_==P3GÖZÙ\9dXg="V9<]&Øg="ß8Ø_=P]z=p;IXg=pTâÚ®Eõ3ݤØg3GV=3G;8T\36Øg=

=p]g]z=p;IXg9<3G7:7<EW]_5>ÚOݤØZ36V=p]pà ö ]·3±Øg=p]_5>7:XpC63&N ö ݤØg3GV=Fè9<7<7>Ù83×G=X_Ù8=*ݤHG7<7:H$è9<;>J&]z58ÚOݤØg3GV=p],Y

Ö"3G]_=ݤØg3GV=GC·ÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI; ݤØZ36V=Ÿ36;^TúÖ"HG;8TO9:X_9<HG;œÝ¤ØZ36V=GC·3I]9:7<7<58]iXgØg36X_=PT 9<;îï9<JG58Ø_=\ëGà

U®Ù83GT>=pTÚ^HãO=P]9<;8TO9SÖ"36X_=P]*X_Ù836X*X_Ù>=-ݤØZ36V=-9<]³TOHGV 369<;¶TO="ßR=";8T>=";uXpà

KA Frame

Conditions

New Conclusion

Case

Operator

Slotname

Value

Conclusion n

Domain KB

Slotname 2

Slotname 1

1..n

Z\[^] ¯1_®¯` wbaIfzr"s&e

á*Ù>=¹Ö"3I]z=ݤØZ36V=¹TO=P]_Ö"Ø_9<Ú^=P]±Ý¤=p36X_5>Øg=p]&HGÝ*3Ÿ]_9:X_5836X_9<HG;\ݤØgHGV èÙ89<ÖZÙ¿36;\="ã®ßR="Ø_XWÖ"3G;

TOØg3èÀ3)ÖHI;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;‘CO]z5^ÖZÙ!3G]*]_E®V)ß>X_HGV ]FH6Ý.3Wß836X_9<=";uXpàOá*Ù>9S]FݤØZ36V=µ9S]*TOHGV 3G9:;TO="ßR=";OK

TO=";uXpCv36;^T¶VW58]zXµÚR=WØg="VHOTO="7<=pTݤHIØ="×I="ØgE!A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=&Ú83I]z=&XgÙ>=W3GJG=";uX³9S]9<;uX_ØgHOTO58Ö=PT

X_H8à>á*Ù89<]FXZ3G]_A¹9<]FXgÙ>=-Ø_=P]zßRHG;^]z9<Ú>9<7:9:XiE¹H6ÝX_Ù>=&TO=p×G=p7:HIß^=pØXgÙ83$X9S]3GT836ßOXg9:;>J1X_Ù8=36JG=p;uXXgH

X_Ù>=&;>=pè T>HGV 369<;‘COH6Ý+ÖHI5>Øg]_=GCOè9:X_ٟ]_5!¹Ö9<=";uXÖHI;8]z587dXZ3$X_9<HG;è9:X_ÙX_Ù>=&="ãOß^=pØzXZ]"à

á*Ù>=@Ö"3I]z=ݤØZ36V=@367S]zH\Ù>HI58]_=p])X_Ù8=õTOHGV 3G9:;ÛA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=Ú^3G]_=Gà·á*Ù>9S] 9S]Å3Þ7:HIJG9SÖ"3G7

ÖZÙ>HG9SÖ=±3G]X_Ù>=-A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=Ú83I]z=±VW58]zX*Ù83×G=±3GÖ"Ö"=p]g]·XgHWXgÙ>=±Ý¤=p36X_5>Øg=p]FH6Ý.31Öp3G]_=³9<;ÅHGØZTO=pØ

X_HTOØZ3èúÖ"HG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;8]ݤØgHGV 9:XpàcG³5>=*XgHT>36=pVHG;)9:;>Ù8="Øg9dXZ36;8Ö"=GC$XgÙ>=A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=*Ú83I]z=*è9<7:7

HG;>7<Eõ;>=p=pTâX_HõÚ^=¹TO="ð8;>=PT\9:;\XgÙ>= JG=p;>="Øg9<Ö Öp3G]_=)ݤØg3GV)=¹3G;8T\367<7·9<;8]iXZ36;8Ö"=ݤØg3GV=p]&è9<7:7

(5)

Ú83G]_=-è9dXgÙ>HG5OXXgÙ>=&;>=p=pT!X_HØg=p]zX_Øg58ÖXg5>Ø_=Ià

QHG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;8]136Øg=¹ß^Hu]_]_9<Ú>7:=Ö7S3G]g]z9:ð^Öp3$X_9<HG;^]&X_Ù^3$X)3G;/=ãOßR="Ø_X)V 3EÞJG9<×G=ÅX_Hâ3âÖ"3I]z=Ià

á*Ù>9<]1]z="XWH6Ý×$367<5>=P]WÖ"3G;\Ú^=]iXgHGØg=pT\3G]-ýR3$XW×$367<5>=P]"CÙ>H$è=p×G=pØ&9:;/]_HGV=¹Ö"3I]z=P]"C9dX)V3E

Ú^=!Ø_=pß>Ø_=P]z=p;uX_=pTâVHGØg=Å3GT>=píu583$Xg="7<EõÚ®EâݤØg3GV)=P]"àï>HGØ1=ã>36Vß>7<=GCX_Ù>=!36JG=p;uXV3EÞ7<=p36Øg;

Ù>H$èœX_HW]_="7<=pÖXÖ"3GØg].ݤHIØ3&JI9:×I="; Ö58]zX_HIV="ØPàuQHG;8Ö"7:5^]z9<HG;8]·9:; XgÙ>9S]¡Ö"3I]z=èFHG587<TÚR=³ÚR=X_X_="Ø

Ø_=pß>Ø_=P]z=p;uX_=pT!Ú®E!3 Öp36Ø*ݤØZ36V=&Øg36X_Ù>=pØ*X_Ù83G;ei58]iX³X_Ù>=VHOTO=p7‘H6Ý.X_Ù>=1Ö"36ØPà>á*Ù>9S]*ݤØZ36V=&9<]

TOHGV 369<;â3G;8Tâ9:Vß>7<="V=";uXZ3$X_9<HG;Þ9<;8TO="ßR=";^TO=";uXpC36;8TõVW58]zX&Ú^=Øg=pÖØg=p36X_=PTŸÝ¤HGØ-=P3GÖZÙõ;8="è

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=±Ú83G]_=Gà

QHG;8TO9:X_9<HG;^]36Øg=&Ø_=P]zßRHG;^]z9<Ú>7<=-ݤHGØÙ>HI7<T>9:;>JÅØ_5>7<=p]Ø_=p7<36X_=pT9<;OݤHGØgV 3$Xg9:HI;èÙ8="Øg=Ø_587:=P]

]zßR=pÖ"9dݤE¶TO9S]iXg9:;>JI5>9S]zÙ>9<;>J ß>ØgHGßR="Ø_X_9<=p]*HGÝ·3 Ö"3G]_=Gà>á*Ù8=p]_=&ß>Ø_HIß^=pØzXg9:=P]36Øg=-ß>Øg=pTO9SÖ"36X_=p]X_Ù836X

è9:7<7^=p9dXgÙ>="ØF="×$3G7:5836X_=³X_HXgØ_58=³HGء݈367S]z=IàGµ5>=³X_HXgÙ>=µÝ¤Øg3GV)=µ]iXgØ_58ÖX_5>Øg=GCIX_Ù8=p]_=³ß>Øg=pTO9SÖ"36X_=P]

36Øg=WØg=píu5>9<Ø_=PT¶X_HA®;>H$è èÙ>9SÖZÙõ]z7<H6X-9<;@X_Ù8=)Öp3G]_=ݤØZ36V=19S]µX_H!Ú^=)X_=P]iXg=pT†à†á*Ù>=pØ_="ݤHGØg=GCR3

ÖHG;^TO9dXg9:HI;ŸÝ¤ØZ36V=W;>=p=pT>]³X_HÙ83×I=&X_Ù>Øg="=)]z7<H6XZ]QYv]_7:HGXµ;83GV)=IC^HIß^=pØg36X_HIص36;^T@ÖHIV)ß^36Øg9<]_HG;

׏3G7:58=GàuÕM; X_Ù>=-]_9:Vß>7<=p]zXFÖp3G]_=GCI31]z7<H6Xè9:7<7vÚ^=µ×G="Øg9:ݤE1èÙ>="X_Ù>=pØ9:X*Ù>HG7ST>]¡31]zßR=pÖ"9dðRÖ×$367<5>=Gà

LH$èF="×G=pØpCuXgÙ>="Øg=&36Øg=µHGX_Ù>=pØT>3$XZ3WXiE®ßR=p]FXgÙ83$XØg=píu5>9<Ø_=P]FV)HIØ_=±XgÙ836;i58]zX=píu58367<9:XiEGC>]_58ÖZÙ

3G]!;u58V)=pØ_9SÖõ3G;8TÀT>36X_=ÞÖHGVß83GØ_9S]_HG;8]pà·ÕyX¶9<]!ß^Hu]_]_9<Ú>7:=õX_HœÖØg=p3$Xg=@;>=pè TO=ð^;>9dXg9:HI;8]!H6Ý

ÖHGVß83GØ_9S]_HG;±Ý¤Øg3GV=p]‘9:ÝOX_Ù8=p]_=¡;>=pè\ݤØg3GV)=P]Ö"HG;uXg3G9:;-XgÙ>=·XgÙ>Ø_=p=¡]_7:HGXf4ˆ]_7<H6X;83GV=GCPHGßR="ØZ3$X_HIØ

36;8TÖHIV)ß^36Øg9<]_HG;!׏3G7:58=Gàg7

ÕyX-9S]&ßRHI]g]z9<Ú>7<=)ݤHGØ&36;Þ=ãOßR="Ø_X&X_HŸTO=ð^;>= VW5>7:X_9<ß>7<=Ø_5>7<=p]±Ý¤HIØ-X_Ù>=¹]g36V= Ö"3I]z=Ià†á*Ù>9<]

9<]WV3ITO= ßRHI]g]z9<Ú>7<= ÚuE\367<7<H$è9:;>JXgÙ>=ÅN

ö

ݤØZ36V=X_HŸXZ36AI=¹3¶7:9S]iX1H6ÝÖHG;^TO9dXg9:HI;\ݤØg3GV=p]pà

[îÙ>=";@3IT>TO=pTXgH X_Ù8=A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=&Ú^3G]_=GCOXgÙ>=7<9<]zX³è9<7:7Ú^=)ÖHI3G7:=P]_Ö"=pT!è9dXgÙ¶X_Ù>=1Ú^H®HI7:=P36;

ݤ5>;8ÖXg9:HI;

ö

LIG1à

çµ;8Ö=)367<7+X_Ù>=T>3$XZ3Å9S]-ÖHI7:7<=pÖX_=pT‘CRA®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=1Öp36;âÚ^=5>ßvT>3$Xg=pTâ9:;âX_Ù8=1A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=

Ú83G]_=³Ú®E Ö"3G7:7<9:;8JW3ß>Øg=pT>=ð8;>=PT ݤ5>;^ÖX_9<HG;ihEjcjQklmj1làOá*Ù>9S]è9:7<7†3GT>TXgÙ>=±;>="èîØg5>7<=µ3$XFX_Ù8=

36ß>ß>ØgHGß8Ø_9S3$Xg=µ7<HOÖ"3$Xg9:HI;!9<;!X_Ù>=þHG±þ X_Øg="=Ià

á*Ù>9<]Ù>9:=pØg3GØgÖZÙ®EÅÖ"H$×G=pØg]X_Ù8=Ú83G]_9SÖ"]*ݤHIØA®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=&3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;‘C8Ù>H$è=p×G=pØpC>Ö"HG;8]_9<TOK

="ØZ3$X_9<HG;)]zÙ8HG5>7STWÚR=JG9<×G=p;XgH±58;8TO="ØZ]zXg36;^TO9:;8J±="ãOß^=pØzX+X_=pØ_V9<;>HG7<HGJIE±Ý¤HGØ·]_ß^=PÖ9:ݤEu9<;>J±X_Ù8=p]_=

Ø_5>7<=p]F36;^TÅÖ"3I]z=P]"à®á*Ù>=±;>=ã®X]z=PÖXg9:HI;Å]zÙ^367<7R="ãOß>7<3G9:;Å9:;¶TO=XZ369<7^Ù8H$èîX_Ù>=P]z=µX_=pØ_V9<;>HG7<HGJI9:=P]

Ö"36;ÚR=&HGÚOXZ369<;>=pT!Ú®E¹X_Ù8=36JG=p;uX*3G;8TÙ>H$èÀXgÙ>=p]_=±XièHÙ>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙ>9<=p]*ÖH®HGßR="ØZ3$Xg=Gà

;0. ! "#n&ACEDF?"#"8 ,"R/ST2U>V>"#1!1CWX

á*Ù>=ÖHI;u×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;3GÖ"íu5>9S]_9dXg9:HI;ÅݤØZ36V=&Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙ®E¹367<7:H$è]3G;¶3GJG=p;IX*XgHX_ØZ36;8]_7<36X_=-èÙ836X

36;õ="ãOß^=pØzX&Ù83I]±]g369ST@9<;uX_H¶36;â9:;uX_=pØ_;^367+Ø_=pß>Øg=p]_=";uXg36X_9<HG;‘àR2·Øg="×®9:HI58]_7:EŸ9<;â2¡Ø_HIÚ^HGXpCv58]_="ØZ]

Ù83GTõX_H¶ÖØg=p36X_=]_Ö"Ø_9<ßOXg]µÝ¤HIØ&Ø_=PÖHGJI;>9S]z9<;>J¹ß836XzXg="Øg;8]-9:;\]_ß^=p=pÖZّà†á*Ù>9S]-èF3I]-3!]_9:Vß>7<=EG="X

ݤ5>;8ÖXg9:HI;836736ß>ß>ØgHI3IÖZّà‘û;>ݤHGØ_X_5>;836X_=p7:EIC‘=p3IÖZÙÞ]_7:HGX9<]9:;uX_=pØ_ß8Ø_="X_=pT\TO9:óv="Øg=";uX_7<Eâ3G;8TÞØ_="K

íI589:Øg=p]&3!;>="è ]_=X&H6ÝFß83$X_X_="Øg;8]pà ö ]±Ý¤ØZ36V=p]&3GØ_=)ßRHGß>5>7S3$Xg=pTÞè9:X_ÙÞV)HIØ_= ]_7:HGXg]pC‘]_Ö"Ø_9<ßOXZ]

Ù83×G=±X_HÅÚ^=èØg9:XzX_=p;¶Ý¤HGØ=P3GÖZÙ¶;>=pè ]_7<H6X,-8Ø_=P]z5>7:X_9<;>J 9<;@3ß>ØgHG7<9dݤ=pØg36X_9<HG;H6Ý·]_Ö"Ø_9<ßOXZ]"à8á*Ù8=

Ù>9:=pØg3GØgÖZÙ®Eß8Ø_HIß^Hu]z=PTÙ>="Øg=9S]¡3]_9:Vß>7<=µ]_HG7<5OXg9:HI;ݤHGØ]_HG7<×®9:;8J-X_Ù>9S]¡ß8Ø_HIÚ>7:=pV Ú®E)V="ØgJG9<;>J

]_Ö"Ø_9<ßOXg]3G;8T!9:;uX_=pØ_;^367‘T>36Xg3)Ø_=pß>Øg=p]_=";uXg36X_9<HG;8]F9<;IXgH)X_Ù>=-ݤØZ36V=&]iXgØ_5^ÖX_58Ø_=Ià

N-;>H$è7:=PTOJG=3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;Å9:;ÅX_Ù>9S]FV)HOTO587:=µ58]z=P]þIGµþÀݤHGØ*]iXgHGØg9:;>J1ß83$X_X_=pØ_;8]¡X_Ù^3$XF3G;

36JG=p;uXµV 3E!;8="=pT@X_H!Ø_=PÖHGJI;>9S]z=W3G;8TŸ9:X±9S]-]z9<V9:7S36سX_H!X_Ù>=1Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙuE¶TO=P]_Ö"Ø_9<Ú^=PTŸ9<;@X_Ù8=

ß>Ø_=p×®9:HI58]³]_=pÖX_9<HG;‘àvLH$èF="×I="ØPCOX_Ù>9S]±9<]µØg=p]zX_Øg9<ÖX_=pTXgH!Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;8367†A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=èÙ>9SÖZÙ

JG9<×G=p]*JIØ_=P3$Xg="ØÖHI;uX_ØgHG7‘H$×I="Ø*Ù>H$è X_Ù>=A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=&9S]]iXgHGØg=pT¶36;^T¶V3G;>9<ß>5>7S3$X_=PT¶36;8TŸ3I]

(6)

36;8TîÖ"HG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;‘à ö ;®EÛ5OXzXg="ØZ36;8Ö"=ŸÝ¤Ø_HIVÜXgÙ>=õ5^]z=pØÅ9S] X_Øg=p36X_=PTÀ3G]!3/Ö"3I]z=Ià¡þ5>7<=p]36Øg=

ß83$X_X_="Øg;8]³X_Ù836X-Öp36;âÚ^=)V 3$XgÖZÙ8=pTŸH$×I="ØXgÙ>=Ö"3G]_=Gàvï.9:;^367<7:E@Ö"HG;8Ö"7:58]_9<HG;8]µ36Øg=X_ØZ36;^]z7S3$Xg=pT

׏3G7:58=p]FݤHGØ]_7<H6Xg]*9<;X_Ù>=-ݤØZ36V=Ià

ö

;®E ]_7:HGX X_Ù836XØg=píu5>9<Øg=p]58]_="ع]_ß^=p=pÖZٜ9:;8ß>5OXÅ;>=p=pT>])XgH¿Ù83×G=!X_Ù8=Ÿ9:;OݤØZ3G]zX_Øg58ÖX_5>Øg=

ݤHGØ3GÖpÖ=P]_]_9:;8J!5OX_X_=pØg3G;8Ö=P]±Ý¤Ø_HIVôX_Ù>= 5^]z=pØ-3I]-è=p7:7·3I]&37:HOÖ"36X_9<HG;âX_HŸ]zX_HGØg=Ø_587:=P]±X_Ù836X

36Øg=3Gß>ß>7<9:=PT/XgHâXgÙ>=¶9:;8ß>5OXpà

ö

;Û3GT>TO9:X_9<HG;^367]_7:HGX)9S] 3GT>T>=pT X_HÞX_Ù>=ݤØZ36V=Ÿ]iXgØ_5^ÖX_58Ø_=IC

o!pprq lsh1tu q CèÙ>9SÖZÙ]iXgHGØg=p]†5^]z=pؑ9:;8ß>5OX.3G;8T±9<]5>ßvT>3$Xg=pT&è9:X_Ù&=p×G="ØgE³5>XzX_=pØg3G;8Ö=Ià2·Øg=p]_=";uX_7<EGC X_Ù>= o!pvpwq lmhtu q ]z7<H6XZ]FݤHGØ*="×I="ØgEݤØg3GV=µXgÙ>ØgHG5>JIÙ>HG5OXFX_Ù8=&Ù>9:=pØg3GØgÖZÙ®Eè9<7:7†Ù83×I=³XgÙ>=]g36V=

]z=p;IXg=";8Ö"=±X_H 9<;IXg="Øgß>Øg=XpàOL³H$è=p×G="ØPC®9dX9S]*ßRHI]g]z9<Ú>7<=µXgH 9:;^Ö7<58TO=]_HGV=±X_=ã®XV 36;>9<ß>5>7S3$Xg9:HI;

3G] XgÙ>=õ9<;>ß>5>X!9S]¹9<;IXg="Øgß>Øg=X_=PTÛÚ®E XgÙ>=@ݤØZ36V="èFHGØgA 3G;8TÛè9:7<7±Ú^=Þ36;À36Øg=p3ÞݤHIعݤ5OXg5>Øg=

=ãOß>7<HGØZ3$X_9<HG;à¡á*Ù>=õA®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=ŸÚ83I]z=â9<]!]iXgHGØg=pTÛ9<; 36;>HGX_Ù>=pعð>ãO=PTÀ]z7<H6XPCIx.t pwq lvyl qQp 9<; èÙ>9<ÖZÙCOX_Ù>=&Øg5>7<=p]ݤHGس9:;uX_=pØ_ß8Ø_="Xg3$Xg9:HI;!3GØ_=&]zX_HGØg=pTÅÙ>="Øg=Gà á*Ù>=*9:;OݤØZ3G]zX_Øg58ÖX_5>Øg=F3G7:HI;>=*9<]+;8H6X·=";8HG5>JIÙWݤHIØ·]zßR=pÖ"9dݤE®9<;>J±X_Ù>=Øg5>7<=p],-X_Ù>=pØ_=*;>=p=pT>].XgH

Ú^=³3èF3EWX_HWíu583G7:9:ݤEXgÙ>=³ß836XzXg="Øg;8]"à ö ;>=pèúݤ58;8ÖXg9:HI;‘C

o

kz{h

p

us|OCG9S]¡TO="ð8;>=pT9<; 9<2·Ø_HI7:HIJ

X_Ù836Xµè9<7:7+367<7:H$è XgÙ>=ݤHI7:7<H$è9:;8J XiE®ß^=1H6Ý·ß836XzX_=pØ_;^]XgH¹Ú^=)V 3$XZÖZÙ>=pT†C^Ú83G]_=pT@HG;@3¹7<9S]iX±H6Ý

JG9<×G=";èFHGØZT>]"C0h6COX_H V 3$XZÖZÙ3GJI3G9:;8]zX,Y

} h1~.~rY8X_Ù>=&5OX_X_=pØg3G;8Ö=-VW5^]iXÙ83×I=±=p×G=pØ_E èFHGØZT¹9<;X_Ù>=&7<9<]zXh$à } h1tTY>XgÙ>=&5OX_X_="ØZ36;^Ö=-VW58]zXÖHI;IXZ369<;36X7:=P3G]zXHG;>=-èFHGØZT X_Ù^3$X9S]9:;!X_Ù8=&7:9S]iXh6à } |h1€PkHyT|*lmh1€ q Y^X_Ù>=&5>XzX_=pØg3G;8Ö=-V158]iXÖ"HG;uXg3G9:;!X_Ù>=&ß8Ù>Øg3I]z=h6à á*Ù>9<]W9<]W;>H6X19:;uX_=p;8TO=PTÞX_H@ÚR=Å3@Ö"HGVß>Øg="Ù>=p;8]z9<×G=7<9<]zX1HGÝFHIß^=pØg36X_9<HG;ÞX_Ù^3$X)Öp36;\ÚR=¹ß^=pØzK

ݤHGØgV)=PT¹HI;Å]zßR="=PÖZÙ¹Xg=ã®XpC®XgÙ>HG5>JIÙ X_Ù8="EÅ3GØ_=±3GÖ"Ö"="ßOXZ36Ú>7<=ݤHIØVHu]iXÖ9<ØgÖ"5>V ]iXZ36;8Ö"=p]pCIß^36Ø_K

X_9SÖ5>7S36Øg7:E)9<;¹AG=pEuèFHGØZT1V36XgÖZÙ>9<;>J^àIï>58ØzXgÙ>="ØFHGßR="ØZ3$Xg9:HI;8]·Ö"3G; Ú^=±3GT>T>=pT)X_HWX_Ù>9S]¡Ý¤5>;8ÖXg9:HI; ÚuE!3GT>TO9<;>J;>=pè TO="ð8;>9:X_9<HG;8]X_H o kzAh p u‚|9<;9<2·ØgHG7<HGJ^à

á*Ù>= 3GÖ"íu5>9S]_9dXg9:HI;âHGÝXgÙ>=p]_=ß83$X_X_="Øg;8]&9S]&TOHI;>= V 36;®58367<7<EGC†Ú®E@èÙ>9SÖZّC†XgÙ>= 58]_="Ø&Ù83I]

X_H="ã®ß87:9SÖ9:X_7<E19<;>9:X_9S3$Xg=X_Ù8=³ß>ØgHOÖ=p]g]pàGLH$èF="×I="ØPC$7:HIJG9SÖ"367<7<E9dX*]zÙ8HG5>7ST 367S]zH&ÚR=³ßRHI]g]_9:Ú>7<=ݤHIØ

X_Ù>=µß>Ø_HOÖ"=p]g]4X_H1Ú^=µ9:;^]iXZ36;uX_9S3$Xg=pT èÙ>=p; X_Ù8=µ]_E®]zX_=pV ð8;8T>]¡X_Ù836X;>HI;>=³HGݑ9dXZ]·Ý¤ØZ36V=P]¡Ö"3G;

9:;uX_=pØ_ß8Ø_="XFXgÙ>=&58]_="Ø9<;>ß>5OXPà 2+3GØzX.H6Ý^X_Ù>=F×®9<]_9:HI;WHGÝ^ÖØg=p36X_9<;>JXgÙ>9<]+VHOTO5>7<=F9<]X_H-367<7<H$è\ݤØg3GV)=P]X_H±Ú^=*Øg="58]g36Ú>7<=Gà ö ] =p3GÖZÙWݤØg3GV=F9S].Ø_=P]zßRHG;^]z9<Ú>7<=¡Ý¤HIØ49:;uX_=pØ_ß8Ø_="X_9<;>J±T83$Xg3³Ý¤HGØ49:Xg]_="7:ÝiC$9:X+9S]+ßRHI]g]z9<Ú>7<=XgHµØg="5^]z=FX_Ù8= ]_3GV)=!ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7.A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=Ú83G]_=Gà.ï>HIØ=ã>36Vß>7<=GCJG=p;8TO="ØWV3EâÚ^=3@]_5>ÚOݤØZ36V= H6Ý436;>HGX_Ù>=pØ*ݤØg3GV)=IC>]z5^ÖZÙ¶3I]*ß^=pØg]_HG;à8á*Ù>=36JI=";uX*X_Ù>=p;¶7:=P36Øg;8]]zHIV=±Øg5>7<=p]*ݤHIØTO=ð^;>9:;8J

X_Ù>=&JI=";8TO=pØ*H6Ý431ßR="ØZ]_HG;‘à>á*Ù>=&3GJG=";uXV 3E ;>="=PT!X_HÚ^=3IT>36ß>X_=pTÅX_H HGX_Ù>=pØTOHGV 369<;8]36X

]zHIV)=µß^HI9:;uX*7<36X_=pØpCuèÙ>9SÖZÙ¹Ø_=Píu5>9:Øg=p]¡9:;>ݤHGØgV36X_9<HG;¹HI;Å9<;uX_="Øgß>Øg=Xg9:;>JX_Ù>=±JG=p;8TO="ØPC®]_3EICGݤHIØ

36;>9<V 367S]"à$á*Ù>=pØ_=F36Øg=FÖ"HGVVHG;83G7:9:X_9<=p]9:;WX_Ù>=*7S36;>JI5836JI=¡58]_=pTWÚ^="Xiè=p=";WX_Ù>=TOHIV3G9:;^]3G;8T

9dX-9<]±Ù>=pØ_=WX_Ù836XµVHOTO5>7S36Øg9dXiE¶HGÝ·X_Ù>=)ß>ØgHGßRHI]_=pT¶Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙ®E!9S]µAG="EIàRþ5>7:=P]±7:=P36Øg;>=pTݤØgHGV

X_Ù>=!ß>Ø_=p×®9:HI58]TOHIV3G9:;/Öp36;¿ÚR=Å36ß8ß>7:9<=pT¿X_HŸXgÙ>=Å;>=pèTOHGV 369<;‘à4ç³ÝÖ"HG5>ØZ]_=GC‘;>=pèØ_587:=P]

Ù83×G=ÅX_H\Ú^=ŸÖ"Ø_=P3$X_=PT¿Ý¤HIØT>HGV 369<;ú]_ß^=PÖ9:ð^Ö!X_=pØ_V9<;>HG7<HGJI9:=P]"C.9:;œ3GT>T>9dXg9:HI; XgHâ9<;8ÖHIØ_Øg=pÖX

ÖHG;^Ö7<58]z9<HG;^]3G]FݤØZ36V=p]3GØ_=-58]_=pT9<;ŸTO9dóv="Øg=";uXµÖ"HG;uX_="ã®Xg]pà>þHGµþ ="ã>Ö="7S]*9<;Ÿ9:;8Ö"Ø_=pV=";uXg3G7

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=-3GÖpíI589<]_9dXg9:HI;‘COèÙ>9SÖZÙ¶Ø_=p9:;OݤHIØgÖ"=p]F9:Xg]*;>=PÖ=p]g]_9dXiE¹9<;X_Ù>9S]VHOTO5>7<=Gà

ƒ „n…z̆OiÑ·Ï¡ÒI ˆ‡Þѡӊ‰®Ð8ыO

(7)

TOØ_9<×G=p;T>9<3G7:HIJG5>=±Øg36X_Ù>=pØ*X_Ù83G;3 Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;‘à

ÕyXÅ9<]!9<V)ßRHGØ_Xg3G;uX¹X_H¿ð^Øg]zXÅ=ã>3GV)9<;>=@èÙ^3$X!A®9<;8TîHGÝ-9<;uX_=pØg3IÖX_9<HG;ÛXgÙ>=õ3GJG=";uXÅV158]zX

=";>Ju36JG= 9<;\ݤHGØ1A®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=¹3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;à‘ÕyX19S]=P]_]_=";uX_9S367<7<Eâ3¶XZ3G]_AõݤHIØð87<7:9<;>J@9<;/T>36Xg3>C

èÙ>9<ÖZÙC‘èÙ>=";¿Ö"HGVß>7<=X_=PT†C†XgÙ>=Å36JI=";uX&9<]W36Ú>7<=X_HŸ5>ßvT>36X_=X_Ù8= Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=Ú83I]z=è9:X_ّà

ö ]-TO=p]gÖØg9<Ú^=PTŸ9:;âß>Øg="×®9:HI58]±]z=PÖX_9<HG;^]"C^X_Ù>=36JI=";uXµ;8="=pT8]µ3¹ð>ãO=pT@;®5>V1Ú^=pØ-H6Ý·="7<="V=p;IXZ]"à

LH$èF="×G=pØpC+9:X¹9<];8H6X¹;>=PÖ=p]g]g36ØgE\ݤHGØX_Ù8=Ÿ58]z=pØg])XgH\JG9<×G=Ÿ367<7H6ݱX_Ù>=Ÿ9<;OݤHIØ_V 3$Xg9:HI;ú9<;Û3

ð>ãO=pTúHGØZTO="ØPà2¡Ø_HIÚ^HGX)58]_=p]]gÖØg9:ß>Xg]1X_H\ÖHI;IXgØ_HI7¡XgÙ>=ŸTO9<Ø_=PÖX_9<HG;œ36;8T/X_Ù>=ŸÖ"HG;uX_=p;IXH6ݱ3

ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;‘àGá*Ù89<]9<];>HGXF×I="ØgE1ß>ØZ3GÖX_9SÖ"3G789:ݑý8=ãO9<Ú>9<7:9:XiE9<]F3Øg=píu5>9<Ø_=pV=";uXpCu3G]9dX*9<];>HGX

ß^Hu]_]_9:Ú87:=4XgHµ3G;IXg9<Ö"9:ß^3$X_=367<7uÖ"HGVWÚ89:;836X_9<HG;8]H6ÝOèÙ>9SÖZÙHGØZTO=pØ358]_="ØV 3E±]_ß^=PÖ9:ݤE±Ýˆ3GÖXZ]"à

ö

]

3Ø_=P]z5>7:XpC8ß>Ø_=p×®9:HI58]9<V)ß87:=pV)=p;uXg3$Xg9:HI;8]HGÝ.XgÙ>=&A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=3GÖ"íu5>9S]_9dXg9:HI;!VHOTO5>7<=&ݤHG7<7<H$è]

X_Ù>=&V=";®5ŸTOØg9:×I=";TO9<3G7:HIJG5>=-VHOTO="7mà

ö VHIØ_=-3GT>3GßOX_9<×G=-36ß8ß>Ø_Hu3GÖZÙ¹9S]FX_H 3G7:7<H$èÀ58]_="ØZ]X_H ]zßR=pÖ"9dݤE!]z7<H6X*×$367<5>=p]*9<;!;8H1ð8ã®=PT

HGØZTO="ØPà>ÕyXµ9S]µ9:VßR="ØZ3$X_9<×G=ݤHGØXgÙ>=HI7<T@]gÖØg9<ßOXµ]_E®]zX_=pV÷XgH!ÖZÙ83G;>JG=Ià

ö

]³X_Ù8=1ÖHI;®×G="ØZ]g3$X_9<HG;

9<]!Ö=";uXg="Øg=pTÛ36ØgHG5>;^Tú="ã®X_ØZ3GÖXg9:;8J¿9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;ÛݤØgHGV XgÙ>=õ5^]z=pØ X_H¿ð^7:7±9:;ÛXgÙ>=ŸÝ¤ØZ36V=GC

3@ݤØZ36V=¶9<]);>H$è÷Ú^HI5>;8TO=PT/XgH\3Þ]gÖØg9:ßOXPà·á*Ù>=ß>5>Øgß^Hu]z=¶H6ݱ3Þ]gÖØg9<ßOX)9S])X_H\TO9<Ø_=PÖXX_Ù8=

H$×G="ØZ367<7†ÖHI;u×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;‘C®]_58ÖZٟ3G]pCOÙ>H$è XgÙ>=36JI=";uX]zÙ8HG5>7STØ_=P3GÖXHI;8Ö=3G7:7vXgÙ>=;>=PÖ=p]g]g36ØgE

9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;@9S]³JI9:×I=";‘C^èÙ>="Øg=p3I]ݤØZ36V=p]µ;>H$è Ù83G;8TO7<=X_Ù8=WXgØg3G;8]z7S3$Xg9:HI;ŸH6Ý¡TO9S367<HGJI5>=&XgH

]zHIV)=!9:;uXg="Øg;8367FA®;>H$è7:=PTOJG=ÅØ_=pß>Ø_=P]z=p;uXg3$Xg9:HI;‘àá*Ù8=ÅXgHGßOKyVHI]zXWݤØZ36V=ÅHGÝX_Ù>=Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙ®E

è9:7<7vÚ^=&3G]g]_H®Ö"9<36X_=PT è9dXgÙ¹XgÙ>=&]_Ö"Ø_9<ßOXpà>U®9<;8Ö"=±]_HGV=±9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;¹V 3E ÚR=±]zX_HIØ_=PT è9dXgÙ>9<;

]z5>Ú>ݤØg3GV)=P]"CF9:X9S];>=pÖ"=p]g]_3GØ_EúX_Húß83G]g]Å9<;OݤHIØ_V 3$Xg9:HI; TOH$è;îXgÙ>=\]iXgØ_58ÖX_5>Øg=â]_58ÖZÙ X_Ù836X

]z5>Ú>ݤØg3GV)=P]1Öp36; 3G7<]_Hõ9<;uX_=pØ_ß>Øg=X1X_Ù>=58]_="Ø)9:;8ß>5OX)ݤHGØ)׏3G7:58=p]pà.ÕM; HGØZTO="Ø1X_HÞTOHÞ]_H8CX_Ù8=

ݤØg3GV)= V158]zXWA®;>H$è èÙ>9SÖZÙ¿]z7<H6XZ]36Øg=¹]_5>ÚOݤØZ36V=p]pà‘á*Ù>9S]7<=p3GT8]-X_H¶XgÙ>=¹9<;8Ö7<58]_9:HI;ÞHGÝ*3G;

3GT>TO9:X_9<HG;^367³]_7:HGX!Ö"3G7:7<=pTŒ€

oTŽ lmh1z

q

€âèÙ>="Øg=¶X_Ù>=â]z7<H6XÅ;^36V=@36;8TœXgÙ>=õ]_5>ÚOݤØZ36V=ŸXiE®ßR=

9<] ß^369<Ø_=PT†à4ÕM;œX_Ù>=ŸÝ¤5>X_5>Øg=GC¡]_7<H6Xg])XgÙ83$X¹5^]z=P]ݤØg3GV=è9<7<7µ365>X_HGV 36X_9SÖ"367<7<E\Xg36JIJG=PTú3I] 3

]z5>Ú>ݤØg3GV)=¶36;^T¿è9:7<7="7<9<V)9<;836X_=!X_Ù>=;>="=PT¿Ý¤HIØ1XgÙ>==ã®X_ØZ3õ]_7:HGXpà·UOÖ"Ø_9<ßOXg]Öp36;/XgÙ>=";ú58]_=

X_Ù>9S]9<;OݤHGØgV 3$X_9<HG;ÅX_H¹Ö"Ø_=P3$X_=-]_5>ÚOX_HIß>9SÖ"]pà8U®5>ÚOXgHGß>9SÖ"]7<9<;>A!3]_5>ÚOݤØZ36V=±X_H)X_Ù>=-XgHGßOKyVHI]zX

ݤØg3GV)=IC·36;8T X_Ù®58]pC·ß>ØgH$×®9<T>=3\ÖZÙ83G;>;>="7HGݱÖ"HGVVW5>;89<Öp3$X_9<HG; ݤHGØ ß83I]_]_9<;>Jâ5^]z=pØ 9:;>ß85OXpà

é·×G=pØ_E¿9<;>ß>5OX 9S]1ð87dXg="Øg=pT/X_Ù>ØgHG5>JIÙ/XgÙ>=ÅݤØZ36V=Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙuEIà ö ]=p3GÖZÙ/ݤØg3GV)=9S])3GÚ>7<=ÅXgH

ß>Ø_HOÖ"=p]g]5^]z=pØ9:;>ß85OXpCR]z7<H6XZ]Ö"36;ÚR=-ð87:7<=pT9<;Ÿ36;®E HGØZTO="ØPà

UOÖØg9:ß>Xg]VW58]zX.ÚR=36Ú>7<=·XgHµ×I="Øg9dݤE±XgÙ83$X436;1=";uX_9<Ø_=¡Ý¤Øg3GV=Ù83I]ÚR="=p;ð87<7<=pTW]_58ÖpÖ=p]g]zݤ5>7:7<EGà

á*Ù>="Øg=µV 3E ÚR=-="7<="V=";uXg]*9<;!ݤØg3GV)=P]X_Ù836X3GØ_=±HGß>X_9<HG;83G7v3G;8T¹9:X9<]FXgÙ>="Øg=ݤHIØ_=±;>=PÖ=p]g]g36ØgE

X_H1]_ßR=pÖ9:ݤEèÙ>9SÖZÙ!]_7:HGX¡9<]F3Øg=píu5>9S]_9dXg=Gà ö ;>=pèÀT>36=pV)HI;‘Cl

q‚o x.l

q

j6CI9S]¡9<;uX_ØgHOTO58Ö=PT èÙ>9SÖZÙ

58]z=P]36;®E¿9:2¡Ø_HI7:HIJõß>Øg=pTO9SÖ"36X_=!X_H\ÖZÙ>=pÖZA¿èÙ8=X_Ù8="Ø 3õ×$3G7:5>=Ù83I]Wݤ587dð87<7<=pTúX_Ù>=Øg=píu5>9<Ø_="K

V)=p;uXg]pà‘á*Ù>9<]±èFHGØgAO]³9<;ÞÖ"HG;1i58;8ÖXg9:HI;âè9:X_Ù\3Å;8="è ݤ58;8ÖXg9:HI;‘C$|h1€Pkl

q‚

C†èÙ>9SÖZÙâ36ß8ß>7:9<=p]

X_Ù>=ß>Ø_=PTO9SÖ"3$Xg=·TO=ð^;>=pT&9<;{l

q‚Qo x.l

q

jµX_H³TO="X_=pØ_V9<;>=·èÙ>="X_Ù>=pØ3*ݤØZ36V=49S]ÖHIVß>7:="X_=Iàp[îÙ>=p;

36ß>ß>7<9<=pT)X_H1]z5>Ú>ݤØg3GV)=P]"CGX_Ù>9S]·è9<7<7^367<7<H$è XgÙ>=³=p;IXg9:Øg=Ù>9<="ØZ36ØZÖZÙ®EX_HWÚ^=³ÖZÙ8=pÖZAG=PT†à6ÕM;Xg="ØgV]

H6Ý+Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=-3GÖpíI589<]_9dXg9:HI;‘CuX_Ù>9S]è9<7:7JG583GØg3G;IXg="=µX_Ù836X*X_Ù>=&58]_="ØÙ^3G]*ß>ØgH$×®9<TO=PTÅ=p;>HG58JGÙ

9:;OݤHIØ_V 36X_9<HG;ݤHGسX_Ù>=A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=-Ú83G]_=&XgH Ú^=15>ßRT83$X_=PT†à^á*Ù89<]ݤHGØgV]X_Ù>=7S3G]zX³=p7:=pV)=p;uX

;>="=PTO=pT!ݤHGØ*ý^=ãO9:Ú87:=&ÖHI;®×G="ØZ]g3$X_9<HG;à

‘ ‡âÑÓ³ÍOzғ’*…iÑ¡Ó

(8)

Ù83G]±TO="VHI;8]iXgØg36X_=PTŸ3 ݤØZ36V="èFHGØgA¹XgÙ83$X-9<]±3Å]zX_Øg58ÖX_5>Øg=pTŸV="X_Ù>HOTŸÝ¤HIر3GJG=p;IXZ]XgHÅ7<=p36Øg;

TOHGV 369<;¶36;8T¶ÖHI;®×G="ØZ]g3$X_9<HG;^3678A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=Gà

ÕyX!9S]ÅV 3GT>=õßRHI]g]z9<Ú>7<=@X_Ù8Ø_HI5>JGÙÛXgÙ>=Þ]_="ß^36ØZ3$X_9<HG;ÛHGÝWÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G736;8TÀT>HGV 369<;

Au;8H$è7:=PTOJG=&XgHÅß>ØgH$×®9<T>=W3¹ÖHI;8]_9<]zX_=p;IX-36ß>ß8Ø_Hu3GÖZÙݤHGرÖ58]zX_HIV)9S]_9:;>J36;@3GJG=";uXPà†QHIV)ß87:="K

V)=p;uX_9<;>J¹XgÙ>9<]-3GØgÖZÙ>9:X_=PÖXg5>Ø_=W9<]µX_Ù8=158]_=WHGÝþHG±þ&à†á*Ù>=WV="X_Ù>HOTOHI7:HIJGEŸ]z58ß>ß^HIØzXZ]³9<;8Ö"Ø_="K

V)=p;uXg367O7<=p3GØ_;89:;>Jµ9:; 3±ÖHI;8]z9S]zX_=";uX+V 36;>;>=pØpà6á*Ù89<]+9S]+]z9<JG;>9:ð^Öp36;uX+3I].X_Ù>=]_EO]iXg="V 9S]4369<V)=PT

X_HÚ^=3IT>36ß>X_9<×G=&36;8TÖ"3G;¶JI369<;ÅA®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=-èÙ>9<7:=-9<;5^]z=Ià

ö

ÖØg58Ö9S367Oß83GØzX4HGÝ^XgÙ>=VH®T>5>7:=9S]+XgÙ>=58]_=FHGÝ^ݤØZ36V=P]"à6á*Ù>9S]·]zX_Øg58ÖXg5>Øg=F=p;8Ö"3Gß8]_5>7<36X_=P]

T>3$XZ3!9<;¿3V3G;>;>=pØ&X_Ù836XW367<7:H$è]±A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=WXgHŸÚ^= Øg="5^]_3GÚ>7:=Ià†á*Ù>=¹ÖHu]iX-X_H@3IT>36ß>X&3G;

36JG=p;uX1XgHÞ3Þ]z9<V9:7S36Ø TOHIV 369<; è9<7:7*ÚR=Øg=pT>58Ö=PT†à·ï>ØZ36V=p])367S]_HÞÖ"HG;uX_Øg9:Ú85OX_=!X_Hâý8=ãO9<Ú>7<=

ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG; ý8H$è&COèÙ89<ÖZÙèHI5>7ST!HGX_Ù>=pØ_è9S]_=µÚR=pÖ"HGV=3)V)=p;®5TOØg9<×G=";¶TO9S367<HGJI5>=Gà

ÕM;õ]z58V)V 3GØ_EIC8XgÙ>=1VHOTO5>7<=TO=XZ369<7:=PTŸ9:;õX_Ù>9S]±ß836ßR="ر9S]±3Å;>H$×G=p73Gß>ß>ØgHI3GÖZÙ¶XgH!]_HG7<×uK

9:;>JXgÙ>=ß>Ø_HIÚ>7<="VòHGÝFÖ5^]iXgHGV9<]_9<;>JÖ"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;8367.36JI=";uXg]pàvÕyX9<]&Öp36ß83GÚ>7:=)H6ÝF7:=P36Øg;>9<;>J

ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G7R3G;8T!T>HGV 369<;!A®;>H$è7<=pT>JG=±9:;Ÿ31ý8=ãO9<Ú>7<=36;8T!Ø_=p58]g36Ú>7<=-V3G;>;>=pØpà

” ÒH‰>ÒÐ –• Ñ¡Ð>Î

á*Ù>9<]¡Ý¤ØZ36V="èFHGØgAWÙ83I]¡3G7:7^X_Ù>=µ="7<="V=";uXZ]¡Øg=píu5>9<Ø_=PT)ݤHGØAu;8H$è7:=PTOJG=³3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;ݤHIØÚRH6XgÙ

TOHGV 369<;¶36;8T!ÖHG;®×I="ØZ]_36X_9<HG;83G78A®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=GCuX_Ù>HI5>JGÙC®X_Ù>=-èFHGØgAX_Ù®58]F݈36Ø*9S]*H6Ý+3Wß>Øg="7<9<V1K

9:;83GØ_EÅ;83$Xg5>Ø_=Ià

— 365>JI9:;>J1X_Ù8=W]z5^Ö"Ö=P]_]FHGÝ+3 Ö"HG;®×G=pØg]g3$Xg9:HI;8367R36JG=p;uX*9S]3TO9˜¹Ö5>7:X³V 36;>;8="ØPC>3G]FX_Ù8="Øg=

36Øg= ;>Hâ]zXg3G;8T>36ØZTÞV=X_Øg9SÖ"]&ݤHIØWV=p3I]z58Ø_9<;>J¶X_Ù8=ÅßR="Ø_ݤHGØgV3G;8Ö=Ià ö ])þHG±þÙ83I]W367<Øg=p3GT>E

ß>Ø_H$×I="; X_H\Ú^=Ÿ3\]_58Ö"Ö"=p]g]iݤ5>7V="X_Ù>HOTOHI7:HIJGE\ݤHGØA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=3IÖ"íu5>9S]z9:X_9<HG;CXgÙ>="Øg=¶9<];8H

;>="=PTŸX_HÅX_=P]iX-èÙ>=XgÙ>="رXgÙ>=1VHOTO5>7<=Ö"36;â3GÖ"íu5>9<Øg=WA®;>H$è7<=pTOJI=Gà8ÕM;^]iXg=p3GT‘C^ݤ58ØzXgÙ>="رèHIØ_A

;>="=PT>]+X_HWÚ^=³T>HG;>=HI;1Xg=p]zX_9<;>JÙ>H$èúX_Ù8==";uX_9<Ø_=ݤØg3GV)=pèHIØ_AÖ"H®HGßR="ØZ3$X_=P]+èÙ>=";¹3IT>36ß>X_9<;>J

X_HÅ3¹]_ßR=pÖ9:ð^ÖT>HGV 369<;‘à ö ]z9STO=ݤØgHGV÷X_=P]iXg9:;>JÅHG;ŸHG;8=WTOHGV 3G9:;‘C8X_Ù>=pØ_=&9S]³3G7<]_H¹3 ;>=p=pTXgH

3GT>3GßOX+X_Ù>=36JI=";uX.X_H-VW5>7:X_9<ß>7<=TOHGV 3G9:;8]K†XgÙ>9<]+è*3EGCPXgÙ>=Ø_="Km5^]_3GÚ>9:7<9:XiE&H6Ý8XgÙ>=FݤØg3GV="èFHGØgA

Ö"36;ÚR=&Ø_=p×G=p3G7:=PT†à

™ Í>ÎÓ³ÑSšO› Ôϊœ Ӌ‰’

á*Ù>9<]Ø_=P]z=P36ØZÖZÙÅÙ83I]Ú^=p=";¶Ý¤5>;^TO=pT¶Ú®E¹XgÙ>=WU®V 36Ø_XÕM;uX_=pØ_;>="X³á=PÖZÙ>;>HI7:HIJGEQFþQ 36;8T!X_Ù8=

365OXgÙ>HGØZ]èFHG5>7ST\7<9:AI=¹X_Hâ=ãOß>Øg=p]g]&XgÙ836;>AO]ݤHGØ1X_Ù>=]z5>ß8ß^HIØzX)Ø_=PÖ="9<×G=PTÞX_Ù>ØgHG58JGÙ>HI5OXX_Ù8=

ß>Ø_HOTO5^ÖX_9<HG;œH6ݵX_Ù>9S]ß83Gß^=pØpà ö 7<]_H8C+XgÙ836;>AO])XgH ö T836VÜDF="ØgØgE\ݤHGØß>ØgHuHGݵØg=p3ITO9:;8JõXgÙ>9<]

ß836ßR="ØPà



Sžs Ð Ó³Í $’

Ÿ

¸¡ ³¸·wxIhyjtŠ¢!¸Š£Fegfz Ie_ft‹a.¸›GeZbd Iept¡rpa® U¤µ¸·›6jieZb|a6¼ub|hMhZ¸ q+ue!´uIbd{|b|´uhrpxIjinpsr"jib|°!jMfzr"b|a

jib|s&egjzr"¼u{|e³bdaGoSn"fisr"jib|nPaÅhylGhyjieZs¸¡¥ma>¦,§c¨›¨r©›ª¬«S­,®“®5¯°±8©P²,³.±.­,°ut>cnp{|xus&e Ÿ´ t8´urp²PeghHµQ¶·¸

µQ¹µ$¸

Ÿ

·,·º$¸

µ6¸½*rc6bd i»+rÄ6jiegft‹¼PnPaš½.xGfMjibdhZt+½rce!›G°zuauegb: Gegft+Æ¡nP¼Oe_fMj

`

r"u{|egfMjt\¾‘b|egfi{|xub|²PbI¢)bkfzrp²p{|b:r6t

¾ve_jiegf4žŸr"²Paue_ft ` rji6l:¾†r"a$jinPa^t*¿*rc6bdaA¢r"jMjiIegš·hZt®r"a® 1wsrpau urH¤FbÁÀZe GnPs¸‘w¡a1b|a$jiegfM¾

(9)

Õ

r"a® d µ¸1Ú.rpa8¸Û‘s±¼On6 Gb|s&eZa$jb|aW°ZnPa6ce_fihir"jib|nPaurp{>b|a6jie_fMorp°geZh‚ÜuÆ¡er6¸¥ŒaݫދÂsßßpt6´urp²Pegh\ºµQא¸

º,µ ´ t Ÿ ·,··6¸

¶I¸H¼G¸\½+rphMhMeg{d{r"a® U¢!¸4›6jinPaIeP¸nØ8bdc6b|au²Ÿurpau âjinŸs&nPxGjiÜ?¾hylG°zunP{|np²Pb|°rp{*jiIeZnpfib|eZh)rp¼OnpxIj

hM´OegeZ°_¶rpa® !²PeZhyjixGfieWb|aŸb|a$jiegfzrp°_jibdcPe1 Gbdrp{|nP²pxuehylGhyjieZs&hZ¸A¥ŒaÝàÊw­á©›¨›¨rÐ,±^°Ó,Ì­wâd³^ª¨ãċĊċÂ

ä ßßßIå²Ò<Ò!¦cÔ,®Š§E­,ÌP±<¯®æ­,°eàÌPÔ©›ªc­ÒÁ­PÓ,±8©P²Ò!Í)­áÐ1¨sÒÌ'­wâã«S­,®5®“¯E°c±8©P²,³.±8­,°{±^°ç«S­Ò<ÒÁ²èP­,Êw²,³.±<Ñ,¨

¦cÔ,ÌP³¨m®“Ìztu´®r"²PeZh Õ ¶¸1¶1µ$t Ÿ ···6¸

º6¸H¾v¸½.nPs&´GjinPa-r"a® ³Æ³¸¼rpaIhMeZa^¸®wâ´Iub|{|nPhMnP´Iub|°r"{®¼®r"hMbdh†o<npf»GaInš·{deZ I²Pe¡r"°Á$xub|hMbkjibdnpa^¸¥maeÇ,ÊrÐ

é?¯Êr­m§c¨r²,°ëêH°!­Qì\ÒϨPЂÓ1¨dċ©Pís¯±<ÌP±<³.±8­,°e₭,Ê5ê¡°!­,ì\ÒϨrÐáÓ1¨sÅ<,Ìs¨rÐï¦ÔQÌP³¨m®5Ìëȓ­,ÊPËQÌwªc­›§®t‘´®r"²PeZh

´ ºá¸1· Ö t Ÿ · Ö ·G¸

¹G¸³›O¸ ` np´u´8t»¸E¼PxIau²It6™³¸Ø^eghMhMsrpaua8tGrpau ð¥z¸žŸr"°_IhMs±xGji^¸¢r"Ä&¾†rsµxu{kjib|s&n6 ur"{OrphMhMb|hyjzrpa$j

b|a1cGbkfMjixurp{>fierp{|bkjml1°ZnPaIhyjMfixu°gjib|npa^¸ê'ÂmÅ<êH¯°*Ò°ÌP³8Ò±8©›ªc¨'›°³¨sÒ^Ò±ÏÓ1¨m°ñgtc¶cܟŸ¸ Ÿ´ tTµ,×,× Õ ¸

´ ¸I¢!¸¢)°ZqRer"f¸±›6´OnP»eZaÅ Gb:r"{|nP²PxIe±jieZ°zuaInP{|nP²"lTÜۑa®r"¼u{|b|au²jiue³°ZnPa6cegfihirjib|nPa®r"{xIhMegf*b|a$jiegfM¾

oSrp°Zep¸†ÄI«Íò«S­,®Š§*¯³.±<°Ód¦¯Ê›Ñ,¨mÔ,Ìit Õ ¶

Ç

Ÿ ÈmÜ·,א¸ Ÿ ¹·6t¢r"fi°zµ,×,×µ6¸

Ö ¸I¢!¸¢)b|aIhM»6l$¸Aóª¨HàÌPÔ©›ªc­ÒÁ­PÓ,ԁ­vâ«S­,®f§¯E³¨mÊïô±<ÌP±8­Q°ut>°z®rp´GjiegfwnaIfzr"s&egš+n"fi»)oSn"fÆeg´I¾

fieghMeZa$jibdaI² ` aunš·{|e G²PeP¸?¢e¥yqU¾†fieZhMhZt Ÿ · ֟ ¸

·G¸H¾v¸T¾†fieZhyjinPa8t¿µ¸Û Gš+r"fz IhZt^r"a® É¾†¸½.nps&´IjinPa8¸µwõµ,×,××1fixI{|e±egÄG´OegfMjhylGhyjieZs š·b|jiInPxGj³r

»6aInš·{|e G²PeWeZau²pb|aueZegf¸)¥ma¬à?Êr­á©›¨P¨rÐ,±<°1Ó,ÌA­wâd³^ª¨eö³^ªïĊċĊÂmÅ8¦§E­Q°Ìm­,ÊP¨rÐÉv÷–ê¡°!­,ì\ÒϨrÐáÓ1¨

Ä\©Pís¯E±^̛±^³.±8­,°“â‚­,ʊꡰ!­,ì\ÒϨrÐáÓ1¨sÅ<1¨rЦcÔ,ÌP³¨m®5Ì{ȓ­,ÊrËQÌwªc­m§®t Ÿ ·,·,¶I¸

Ÿ ×G¸I½¸ ›Irps&sµxIj¸ bd´GfinP{|nP² ´Ifinp²pfzr"s&s&egfáøh sr"a6x®rp{¸

$jMji´TÜù,ùš4š4š¸°ZhMeP¸xIauhyš¸e Ix8¸rpx!ù-°Z{dr"x® Ieáùjier"°_IbdaI²1ù"wŠ¥rùaun"jieZh›ù"´GfinP{|nP²ù"b|a® GegÄ>¸$jis&{¸

Ÿ,Ÿ ¸I½¸>›Irps&sµxIj¸féÒϨr©s³.Êr­,°c±8©AóÊr²Q°Ìm²©s³.±8­,°cÌd­,°Ä‹Êm³.±ú?©s±8²Ò›°³¨sÒ<Ò±ÏÓ1¨m°*©›¨_t>°_urp´Ijie_f¡¢r"a®rp²pb|au²

½.npa$jiegÄ6j·bdard½.nPa6cegfihirjib|nPa®r"{vw¡²PeZa$j¸SØ^b|aI»nP´IbdaI²±`aub|cegfihMbkjml:ۑ{|eZ°gjMfinpaub|°I¾‘fieZhMhZt!µ,×,× Ÿ ¸

Ÿ µ6¸H¼G¸†ž¶eZbÁÀZeZa6¼urpxus¸)ۑ{|bÏÀZržr °Znps&´uxIjie_f-´Ifinp²pfzr"süoSn"f-jiueWhyjix® 6l¶n"oFaur"jixIfzr"{4{drpau²px®r"²Pe

°gnPs&s±xIaub|°rjibdnpa!¼Oe_jmš+egeZa¶srparpau srp°zub|auep¸Ý«S­Q®5®5¯°c±8©P²,³.±8­,°cÌð­wâã³^ª¨ãÄI«Í t·

Ç

Õ ¹"¾

¶ºPÈ_t Ÿ ·,¹¹G¸

Ÿ‚Õ ¸H¼G¸!¢!¸*û>eg{d{|er"a® 1Ƹc¼I¸¢)n$npauegl$¸SØ8er"fiaIb|au²±jin-´ur"fihMe Ir"jzr"¼®rphMe³Á$xue_fibdegh4xuhMb|au²-b|au Ixu°_jibdcPe

{|np²Pb|°&´Ifinp²pfzrps&s&b|aI²I¸“¥maçàÊw­á©m¨P¨rÐ,±<°1Ó,Ì:­wâ5³^ª¨ äsü ³^ªÉýH²Q³.±8­,°!²,Ò\«S­Q°áâá¨mÊr¨m°!©›¨­,°ïċʛ³.±ú$©s±8²Ò

References

Related documents

Keywords: Middlemarch , Dorothea Brooke, Will Ladislaw, Victorian marriage,

Ainda em relação ao fortalecimento de campos de pesquisas, eventos importantes ocorridos no Brasil, como nas Reuniões Anuais da Associação Nacional de Pós-Graduação e

Indeed, the algorithm allocating funding to active labour market policies (ALMPs) across regions favours more troubled local labour market, giving a premium to higher than

(Install in accordance with manufacturers instructions) Min Ø 19mm Internal pipe Boiler with 75mm sealed condensate trap 75 Min Ø 19mm Internal pipe Min Ø 30mm Internal pipe

Courses described by sustainable engineering (SE) champions were grouped into four categories: Sustainable Engineering (dedicated sustainable engineering courses),

Bidders are required to provide a critical path diagram and schedule for the project that specifies the critical path for each of the elements of the project development

It also examines key policy issues, including the cyclicality of spending, public investment, public employment and social spending, finding that primary

The headquarters of the trans-Caribbean corporations are mainly in Trinidad and Tobago and, to a lesser extent, Barbados (shipping) and Jamaica (predominantly hotels and