JOURNAL OF VIROLOGY, May1978,p.209-213 Vol. 26, No.2 0022-538X/78/00264209.00/0
Copyright01978 AmericanSocietyforMicrobiology PrintedinU.S.A.
Alkaline
DNase
Activity in Cells
Infected with a
Temperature-Sensitive
Mutant
of Herpes
Simplex
Virus Type 2
B. FRANCKE,1 H. MOSS,2M.C. TIMBURY,2ANDJ. HAY2*
TumorVirologyLaboratory,The Salk InstituteforBiological Studies,SanDiego,California92112,1and The Institute of Virology, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, ScotlandG115JR2
Received forpublication 18 October1977
BHK cells infected with the temperature-sensitive mutant ts13 of herpes
simplex virustype 2atanonpermissivetemperature lackthe alkaline nuclease
activity,which isinducedby themutant at apermissivetemperatureand by
wild-typevirusateither temperature. For ts13, enzyme activity could be induced by
atemperatureshifttopermissveconditions,butnotin thepresenceof
cyclohex-imide. Afterashiftfrompermissivetononpermissive conditions inthepresence
ofcycloheximide,theactivitywasstable inwild-type,butnotinmutant-infected,
cells.Afterextensivepurification, thewild-typenucleasewasfourfoldmoreheat
stableinthe presenceofsubstrate thanwasthemutantenzyme.Mixturesofboth
purified enzymes showed the predicted intermediate stabilities. The results
strongly suggest that theenzymeis virus codedand that themutant possessesa
lesioninthestructuralgeneof theenzyme.
Afterinfectionof cells in culture, herpes sim- gle medium with 10% (vol/vol) calfserum (Colorado
plex virus (HSV) inducesanumber ofenzymatic Serum Co.) and 10% (vol/vol) tryptose phosphate
activities related to DNA metabolism. Among broth (DifcoLaboratories)on5-cmplastic petridishes.
themare a new DNApolymerase andanuclease The virus used was HSV-2, strain HG 52 (wild
(5). Apartial purification of the nucleolytic ac- type), and a plaque-isolated temperature-sensitive
tivity (7) inclicated that itwas aDNA-specific mutant,
tsl3,
obtainedfromabromodeoxyuridine-mu-alkaline exonuclease andthatitsinduction and Virus stocks were prepared by infection of BHK
properties differentiated it from known cellular cellsat a multiplicity of10-2 PFU/cell and titratedon
nucleases. Preliminary experiments (4;H.Moss monolayers of BHK cellsunder an agarose overlay.
and J. Hay, unpublished data) showed that a Forexperimentalpurposes,BHKcellsin 5-cmpetri
DNase with properties very similar to those disheswereinfected with virus at 5PFU/cell,withan
reportedbyMonison and Keir(7)forHSVtype adsorption period of 1 h at
310C
or30min
at390C,1 was induced in cells infected with
wild-type
after whichtime5ml of fresh mediumwasadded. ForHSV type 2 (HSV-2) and
that,
of 13 HSV-2 temperature-shift experiments, the medium wasre-.meauesstvmuatstudied
(9), only
placedwith
5mlofmediumprewarmed
totherespec-temperature-sensitive
mutants
ctyat
anonpemy
tivetemperature.Forexperiments involvinginhibition 1,tsl3,
failed to induce theactivityatanonper- of protein synthesis by cycloheximide, the drug was missive temperature. A largeproportion ofthe present at 50yg/ml.At this concentration, theincor-temperature-sensitivemutantsisolated for HSV poration of[3S]methionineby infectedcells was
re-(1, 8) exhibit a DNA-negative phenotype. The ducedto<2% of that of untreatedcontrol cultures.
ts13mutantof HSV-2 iscapableofsynthesizing Alkaline exonuclease assays from crude
ex-viralDNA at anonpernissive temperature (2); tracts.Extracts were prepared from 107cellsas
de-yet the amounts of DNA made vary consider- scribed by
Morison
and Keir (7) bysonic
treatmentably and aregenerally lowerthan those forwild- inanultrasonic water bath(Bransonic), yielding250
typinfectionsJ. Hyad , ,Francke,
unpub-
1l
ofcrude extract.The assay mixture (150ul)
con-type
infections (J. Hay and B.
ted
hes
un-tained
thefollowing
components (finalconcentra-lisheddata). Thestudypresentedherewasun- tions): 50 mM
Tris-hydrochloride
(pH 9.0), 2 mMdertakentodeterminewhetherts13 represents MgCl2, 10 mM 2-mercaptoethanol, 125 gAg of
3H-la-the structural gene for the viral alkaline nu- beled BHK DNA (1.6 x 103cpm/yg) per ml, and50
clease,as abasis forfurtherinvestigation of the iLd of crudeextract. Degradationof thelabeled DNA
potentialrole of thisenzyme duringviralrepli- wasmonitored byprecipitating theundigestedDNA
cation. with 5% trichloroacetic acid and counting the
precipi-tateaftercollectionontoglass-fiberfilters(Whatman MATERIALS AND METHODS GF/C) in toluene containing 5 g ofper liter or by counting the soluble nucleotides2,5-diphenyloxazoleas
Cellsand virus. BHK-21(C13)cels (MacPherson described by Morrison and Keir (7). Both methods and Stoker[6])weregrown inDulbecco-modified Ea- gaveidentical results. For each nuclease
determina-209
on November 10, 2019 by guest
http://jvi.asm.org/
210 FRANCKE ET AL. J. VIROL
tion, atime course with atleast three time points, z sampled induplicate, was carried out. The results are L presentedasmicrogramsof DNAdigestedin1minby 3
1 mgofprotein.
Purificationof alkalinenuclease.A total of 10 8 2_ cellswereinfected with wildtypeorts13for18 h at Z
320C. Cytoplasmicextracts werepreparedafterscrap- , _
ing the cellsinto the medium andpelletingthemat
1,200 x g. The pellets were washed in 0.15 M N 4
NaCI-0.02 MTris-hydrochloride(pH 7.5)at4°Cand X 3
suspended in 3 volumes of 10 mMTris-hydrochloride ia
(pH8.0)-i mMMgCl2-1 mMdithiothreitol. Nonidet 2; P-40wasaddedto0.2%(vol/vol), andthe wholewas,
homogenized with 50 strokes in a Dounce homoge- x
nizer. Aftercentrifugation for 30min at30,000rpm
05
6.0 6.5 70 75 no8.s
90and 40C in a Beckman 6OTirotor, the supernatant pH
was used as starfing material for purification. The
extract waschromatographedoncolumns of DEAE- FIG. 1. Effect of pH on the nuclease activity in Sephadex(PharmaciaFineChemicals, Inc.)andphos- extractsfrom tsl3ormock-infectedBHK cells. Ex-phocellulose (Whatman)andcentrifugedon aglycerol tractswerepreparedandassayed fornuclease activ-gradienttogivebetween 1-and>2,000-fold purifica- ityasdescribed in thetext, exceptthatTris-chloride tion with 20% (ts13)to30% (wildtype) recoveryof buffer was replaced with 50 mMN-2-hydroxyethyl
activity.Themethod ofpurificationand theproperties piperazine-N'-2-ethanesulfonic acidadjustedtothe of thepurifiedenzymewillbepublished elsewherein pH indicated with KOH andbroughttoequimolar
detail(Franckeetal.,manuscriptinpreparation). K+withKCI. Symbols: E uninfectedcell extract;0, Heatinactivation of thepurified nuclease. The ts13-infectedcellextract(31°C infectionfor18h);0, preincubation mixture contained thefoliowing:500 ,ug ts13-infectedcellextract(39°Cinfection for9h).
ofbovine serum albumin perml, 10 mM
,B-mercapto-ethanol, 1 mMEDTA, 10 mM Tris (pH 7.5, unless perature sensitive duringthe in vitroassay, at otherwiseindicated), 625 ,ug of BHK DNA (if present) leastup to 1h. Therate atwhichthesubstrate perml, and enough purified enzyme to degrade 6,g of DNA was degradedin vitro at390C wasabout DNA in 1 h at320C.Preincubation wascarried out at twice as fast as at
31°C,
and extracts fromcells450C and was terminated bychillingthe mixtureto infected with tsl3 at
310C
did not differfrom
40C.To assay forresidualactivity, the niixture was
w*ld-type-infected
cell extracts in this respectdilutedfivefold, restoring theconditionsofthestan- (
dard nucleaseassay described above. Since the protein (data notshown). Theapparent lack of mvitro contentof thepurified enzymeswasnotmeasurable, temperature sensitivity ofthe tsl3-induced ac-these results arepresented as the percentage of resid- tivitywill be discussed below.
ualactivity after preincubation for the times indicated, In contrast, when tsl3-infected cells were
with theactivity ofasamplenotexposed to 450C as shiftedto anonpermissivetemperatureinvivo,
100%. Ifkept at 40C, the preincubation mixture had the alkaline nuclease activity behaved in a tem-no effect on theenzymaticactivity, a control that was perature-sensitive fashion (Fig. 2). Both wild performed with each of the inactivation experiments type and
tsM3
inducedsimilaramounts ofactiv-describedbelow. ity at
310C.
A shift to390C
hadlittleor noeffectonwildtype,but resulted inareduction of the
RESULTS activity in
ts13-infected
cells(Fig. 2a and c).TheOne of thedistinguishingfeatures ofthe HSV- kinetics of theturnoff of the nucleasewas
vari-induced nuclease is its high pH optimum (7). able,dependingmostmarkedlyonthetiming of
When either uninfected or tsl3-infected cells theshiftto390C(see alsoFig. 3). Forareduction
wereassayedfornuclease activitybetweenpH to 50% of thepreshift level, between 30and 90
5.5 and 9.0, the results shown in Fig. 1 were min at390Cwasrequired, whereas after 3 h the obtained. The crude extracts used in this exper- activityreached backgroundlevels in allcases. iment showactivity at acidpHand atalkaline Inthereverseexperiment,shifting to a
permis-pH,yetlittleactivityatpH7.The acidnuclease sive temperature after 9 h at310C, tsl3-infected
appearstobeof cellularorigin,since it isfound cells were capable of expressing the nuclease.
inuninfectedcells,whereas thealkaline nuclease Thekineticsof the turn-onexhibited no
notice-appears to be virus induced. The absence of the ablelag period. Again, ashiftfrom 39 to 310C
latter from cells infected with Msl3 at anonper- had little effect on the activity present in
wild-missive temperature (390C) is unique for this type-infected cells (Fig. 2b and d). To test mutant.All other mutants of HSV-2expressed whethertheappearance ofalkalinenuclease in
somealkaline nuclease after infection at
390C
ts13-infected cellsafter a shift to a permissive(Moss and Hay, unpublished data). Figure 1 temperature wasduetode novosynthesis or to
showsthat theenzymaticactivitywasnot tem- theactivation of an inactive enzyme, the
on November 10, 2019 by guest
http://jvi.asm.org/
[image:2.509.270.458.77.223.2]VOL 26,1978 DNase ACTlVITY IN CELLS INFECTED WITH HSV-2 211
imentshown in Fig. 3 was performed. ts13-in- ifcycloheximidewaspresent,indicatngthatits
fected cells,lackingtheactivitydue to a shift to appearancerequired the
synthesis
of newpro-39°C for 3 h, were capable ofproducing the tein and that the preexisting activity became
nuclease againat31°C at anytimeduringthe irreversibly inactivated during the period at
replicative cycle. At later times,induction was 39°C.The accelerated appearance of nuclease in
pooreranddelayed,probablyreflectingthestate celLs
kept
at39°C
from the time of infection andof the infected cellsatthis time.However,atno shiftedto31°Cat3h suggests that the mutation
time didtheactivityreturnafterashift to31°C does not involve any steps in
early
tanscrip-tional control but rather affects the enzyme
it-self. To compare the heatlabilityof the
mutant-a)
1s+, 31@C
C)tiI3,
31iC
induced nuclease with the wild-type enzymeafter shifting infected cells to a nonpermissive
temperate,theexperimentshown in .4 was
E t 1 t E I .ts13 NUCLEASE ACTIVITY
X- 311,C
I -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1.5-*+39"C
o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~ 0-431*,C
S-+31' C+cycloheximide
°-E 0 EvL 2
-(b)ts+, 39)c d) ts)3, 39(c(
El~~~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~~~1.0
zS
CP~~~~~~~~~~~
0.5-0 612 1624 6 1218S24C
(3) (6) (9) (12) (3) (6) (9) (12) HOURS AFTERINFECTION
HOURS AT 31-C, (39"C) FIG. 3. Behavior of the
nuclea
activity
in tsl3-FIG. 2. Effect of tenperatureon theinductionof infectedcells.tsl3-infectedceUswereshiftedto 39°C alkalinenuckaseactivity.Four seriesofdishes were at 0 h or at6f 12,and 18 h after infectionat 31°C infectedwithwild-tpeHSV-2orwith tsl3 and incu- (indicatedbyt) At 3 haftertheshift-up,eachsetwas batedat31°C(0)or39°C(@).At the timesindicated, shiftedback to 31 C(indicated byl),andthe recovery samples were taken for extract preparation and ofthenuckaseactivitywasfollowedin theabsence DNase assayat31°C,asdescribed in the text, atpH orpresenceof50pgof cycloheximideperml, added9.0. At tines indicated by arrows, samples were atthetimeof shift-down. Experimentaldetailswere
shiftedupto390C (t)orshifteddownto31°C(1). asdescribedinthekgendtoFig.2.
a)ts+ b) ts 13
X 331C
0.* 391C
,, N 391C + Cycloheximide
If,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I
1.0 /
X£
E /O6 6 121x21
0
HOURS AFTER INFECTION
FIG. 4. Effect of temperature shift-up on preexisting nucleaseactivity. Two series of dishes were infected withwild type ortsl3at31°C.At 12 and 18h,thecultures were shifted to39"C(indicated byt). and half of them receivedcycloheximide at the time of the shift-up. Experimental details were as described in the legend to Fig. 2.
on November 10, 2019 by guest
http://jvi.asm.org/
[image:3.509.78.225.169.369.2] [image:3.509.262.453.215.362.2] [image:3.509.137.378.458.630.2]212 FRANCKE ET AL. J. VIROL.
performed. When protein synthesis was in- TABLE1. Inactivationofwild-type(ts+) andtsl3
hibitedatthe time of shiftto390C in wild-type- nucleaseactivitiesat450Ca
infected cells, the level of nuclease activity in- Inactivation conditions
t1/2
(min)
dicatedaheat-stableenzyme(Fig.4a). The
ts13-induced activitywasheatlabile,asnoted earlier, pH DNA ts+ tsM3
whichwasslightlyexaggerated by thepresence 9.0 - 8(6.5)b 9(16.6)c
of cycloheximnide (Fig. 4b). This experiment also + 16(61.7) 16(78.7)
arguesagainstapotentialinhibitor of preexisting
nuclease induced byashiftto390C, which could 7.5 - 9(77) 8(112)
havegoneunnoticed inthe typeofexperiment + 136(79) 36 (108)
shown in Fig.2 duetocontinued de novo syn- a The preparation of purified enzymes and
preim-thesis in wild-type-infected cells. cubation conditions were as described in the text.
The results reported so far are compatible Preincubation was for 15, 30, 60, 90, and120minat
with the notion that the tsl3 mutation corre- 450C, andt1/2wasdetermined graphically after
plot-spondstothestructuralgenefor theviral alka-
ting
logio of residual activity againsttime.line nuclease. Since crude extracts from tsM3- bNumbers in parentheses are initial enzyme
activi-infected cells failed to showtemperature sensi-
ties
(at zerotime)
expressed as counts per minute xtivity whenassayed in vitroat390C(seeFig. 1), e Even at0°C,the enzymeactivities were unstable
theheat lability of purifiedenzymepreparations in theabsence of DNA at pH 9.0.
fromwild-type- and tsl3-infected cellswas
com-pared. During the purification (as outlined 10
above) the acid exonuclease activity was
re-moved during the first chromatography step
(only the alkaline activity bound to DEAE- X
Sephadex). Both enzyme preparations were 70 o A (
morethan2,000-foldpurifiedover asoluble cy- (a)
toplasmic extract, and the final preparations
contained too little protein to measure. The 50- (b)
nuclease activities for both preparations were 0
I- +A
linearly
proportional
to the volume of enzyme , ts ts3usedper assay(datanotshown).Table1shows 4 x 3 0 (c)
thatpreincubationoftheenzymesby themselves w A 2
at450Cresulted inarapid loss of activity, with 4 30 03 2 0
nomeasurable difference between wildtypeand d 0 0 3
tsl3, but in the presence of substrate (DNA), z
the wild-type activity was 3.5 to 4 times more ae (d)
stable than the tsl3 enzyme. Interestingly, the
stabilizing effect of the substrate was onlyob- 0
served at close to neutralpH (7.5) and not at
the pH optimum for enzymatic activity (9.0).
For a reproducible difference in
t42-
at 450Cbetween the two preparations, it was further _
necessarytokeepthe salt concentrationatless lC 0 o 60 90
than 30 mM KCI. Bovine serum albumin, al- MINUTES AT 450C
thoughused in theexperiments shown,wasnot
requiired
for the stability of theenzyme,nor did FIG. 5. Heatstabilityofwild-tbpe. andtsl3-puri-itqaffec
thethe
stati45
or
theenzymatic
activit
fiedalkalinenucleases.Preincubation
at 45°Cwasit
affec(
tde
ta
at45 ortheenzymatiC
activity in thei presenceofDNAatpH7.5asdescribed in theat 310C (data not shown). Because potential text. Each preincubation mixture(200(1)contained contaminants in theenzymepreparations,caus- 15idof
enzyme.
Both enzymes had beenadjustedtoing the different heat labilities, could not be equalactivityper volume before mixing. The 100%
excluded, the mixing experiment shown in Fig. values(i.e.,notexposedto45°C) were asfollows(in
5 was performed. Both preparations were ad- IHcountsperminuteX103 acidsolubleafter 60 min
justed to equal activitiespervolume and then of incubation at32°Cunder nuclease assay
condi-preincubated at450C in the presence of DNA tions):13.5 (a), 13.7 (b), 13.2
(c),
and 13.4 (d). (a) andby themselves and as 2:1 enzyme mixtures of (d) weredrawn to best fit theexperimentalpointsx
wildtypeto mutantor mutant to wildtype.The and0,respectively. (b) and(c)representtheoretical
wldx
typetomutant or mutanttowildtype.The curves derivedfrom (a) and (d) by adding thetwoexperimentalpoints for the mixtures fell closely inputactivitiesat 1/3 or 2/3, respectively, corrected on the theoretical lines constricted from the for thesurvivingactivity for eachtime pointduring
best-fitlines for thetwoenzymesalone.It,there- theinactivation.
on November 10, 2019 by guest
http://jvi.asm.org/
[image:4.509.267.458.273.518.2]VOL. 26, 1978 DNase ACTIVITY IN CELLS INFECTED WITH HSV-2 213
fore, appears that the increased heat lability of the infectivity of virus preparations made at a
the ts13 nuclease in the presence of DNA atpH permissive temperature was sensitive to heat
7.5 is a property of the enzyme itself and not underconditions of wild-type stability. Thus, in
caused bya contaminant. The failure ofcrude this mutant, we can define two
temperature-extractsfrom ts13-infected cellstoshow temper- sensitivefunctions, one related to the virus
par-aturesensitivity duringanin vitro assay is pos- ticle and likely to be a structural polypeptide
siblyaconsequence of thehigh pH required for and the other the virus nuclease activity. It is
the assay. conceivablethatthesetwochangesinphenotype
are the result of a single genetic change. If,
DISCUSSION however,we aredealingwithadouble
temper-The data given hereshow that atemperature- ature-sensitivemutant,thenwecannotat
pres-sensitive mutantof HSV-2 induces an alkaline ent say which of these is lethal. We haverecently
nuclease activity that is temperature sensitive isolated revertants oftsM3,and their examination
both invitro and in vivo. Shifting infectedcells shouldhelpto resolvesomeof these issues.
in vivo from a permissive to a nonpermissive
temperature results in irreversible inactivation ACKNOWLEDMENTS
ofthe enzyme'sactivity,asdocumented by the We thankJohn Subak-Sharpe for his interest in thiswork,
requirement forprotein synthesisfor thereap- MajorieStrobel-Fidlerfortechnicalassistance,andthe Inter-pearanceofactivity after shifting backto aper- national Union Against Cancer (UICC) fora
Yamagiwa-Yosh-mlssvetemperature. Inaddition,thewild-type idaMemorialInternationalCancerstudygranttoJ.H.
missivetemperature.In addition, the wild-type ThisworkwassupportedbyPublicHealth Servicegrants
activity isstable intheabsence ofproteinsyn- CA-15088 and CA-14195 awarded by the National Cancer
thesisat anonpermissive temperature, whereas Institute.
themutantactivity is not. Incubation of purified
enzymes invitroat45°C showsafourfold-faster LITERATURE CITED
inactivation rate for the ts13-induced enzyme 1. Benyesh-Melnick,M., P. A.Schaffer,R. J.Courtney,
overthewild-type enzyme. These findings pro- J.Esparza and S.Kimura.1974.Viralgenefunctions
vide the firststrongevidence that thenuclease expressed and detected by temperature-sensitive
mu-activity
activityis coded directly bythe virus genome,~~~~~~~~~~~~~Symp.
tants of herpesQuant.Biol. 39:731-746.simplex virus. Cold Spring Harboralthough they donotruleoutthe
possibility
that 2. Halliburton,I.W., and M.C.Timbury.1973.Charac-partoftheenzymeprotein iscontributedby the teristics oftemperature-sensitive mutants ofherpes cell. The accelerated appearance ofactivityata simplexvirus type 2. Growth and DNA synthesis.
Vi-permissive
temperatureafteraperiod
of3hat rlg 46-83.
Hafliburton,
l.W.,and M. C.Timbury.1976.Temper-a nonpermissive temperature indicates that ature-sensitive mutants of herpessimplexvirus type2:
early steps in the infectious cyclearenotaffected descriptionof threenewcomplementationgroupsand
by the mutation, as would be expected for a studiesontheinhibitionof hostcellDNA synthesis.J.
lesion in the structural gene ofa late function. 4
Gen.
Virol. 30:207-221.4.Hay,J.,H.Moss,and L. W. Halliburton. 1971.
Induc-Halliburton and Timbury (2) have reported tion ofdeoxyribonucleic acid polymerase and deoxyri-that tsl3 makes significantly less virus DNA bonuclease activities incellsinfected withherpes
sim-thandoes wild typeat anonpermissivetemper- plex type II. Biochem. J. 124:64P.
ature,but isnotDNAnegative.Ourownstudies 5. Keir,H.M.,andE. Gold. 1963. Deoxyribonucleicacid
onDNA synthesis agree with this assessmet . nucleotidyltransferaseanddeoxyribonucleasefrom
cul-on DN>A synthlesis agree with this assessment tured cellsinfectedwithherpessimplexvirus.Biochim.
andwouldsuggestthat HSV-2 canreplicateits Biophys.Acta 72:263-276.
DNA,atleasttosomeextent,inthe absence of 6- MacPherson,L.A., and M.G. P. Stoker. 1962.Polyoma thegreatmajorityof thisnucleaseactivity.Sev- transformationof hamstercellclones-aninvestigation
eraleralpossibilitiespssibiitiesarise from this iresut.rise rom tis reslt. PrhapsPerhaps of16:147-151.geneticfactorsaffecting cell competence.Virology
the virus needsonlytrace amountsofexonucle- 7.Morrison,J.M.,and H. M. Keir.1968. Anew
DNA-aseactivityfor its replication,or, alternatively, exonuclease incellsinfectedwith herpes virus:partial
suchDNAasissynthesizedints13-infectedcells purificationand properties of theenzyme. J.Gen.Virol.
atanopermissvetemprature sdefecive in 3:337-347.
at a nonpermssive temperature IS defective in 8. Subak-Sharpe, J.H.,S. M.Brown, D. A.Ritchie,M.
some way. The DNase activity could alsorep- C.Timbury,J. C. M.Macnab, H.S.Marsden,and
resent a dispensable viral function, atleast in J. Hay. 1974. Genetic and biochemical studies with the system used to isolate and test the virus herpesvirus. Cold SpringHarbor Symp. Quant. Biol.
39:717-730.
mutant. 9. Timbury,M. C. 1971. Temperature-sensitive mutants of
Earlierobservations on tsM3 (3) revealed that herpessimplex virus type 2. J. Gen. Virol.13:373-375.
on November 10, 2019 by guest
http://jvi.asm.org/